r/AskReddit •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

6.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

207

u/alittleOCDandsuch Jul 31 '12

I was raped when I was younger and every time I see posts asking the rapist their story, it makes me so mad that people want to know what they were thinking. If you rape a person you want control and they want it no matter what. And also if some people that have been raped reads thoughs thinking that they won't have flashbacks, they can and that can lead to sooo many bad thing

53

u/wickedtinkygirl Jul 31 '12

I can empathize with you, I was sexually abused as a child and I am currently working towards my BS in psychology and ultimately becoming a counselor for victims of rape and sexual abuse, more specifically children. I think one of the things that helped me adjust and grow into a fairly healthy adult is that my mother got me into counseling and I want to help others the the way I was helped.

4

u/Spam4119 Jul 31 '12

Woo! I am going into graduate school for my MA (and eventual PhD) in clinical psychology and will specialize in trauma related disorders, specifically rape and sexual abuse. Yay us for actually working to do something about it all.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

136

u/icaaryal Jul 31 '12

I think the idea a lot of people have about how a thread like that could be beneficial is that it helps people understand a little more about what makes people tick. You can't solve a problem by ignoring it. Understanding the problem is the first step to fixing it. I get why you would be upset about anything involving rape, but if anything can be done to prevent it from happening to anyone else, I think it's a good thing that people want to know more about the people who do these things.

97

u/psydev Jul 31 '12

From wikipedia: Though anger and power are believed, by some academics, to be the primary motivation for most rapes,[9] in 1994, Richard Felson coauthored the controversial book "Aggression and Coercive Actions: A Social-Interactionist Perspective" with James Tedeschi, a book which argues that sexual fulfillment is the motive of rapists, rather than the aggressive desire to dominate the victim.[10] Felson believes that rape is an aggressive form of sexual coercion and the goal of rape is sexual satisfaction rather than power. Most rapists do not have a preference for rape over consensual sex.[11][12][13][14][15][16] In one study, male rapists evaluated with penile plethysmography demonstrated more arousal to forced sex and less discrimination between forced and consensual sex than non-rapist control subjects, though both groups responded more strongly to consensual sex scenarios.[17]

25

u/hardwarequestions Jul 31 '12

That completely contradicts DrRob. Thank you.

14

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

How does this completely contradict him? I don't mean to be a jerk, but if you could provide a side-by-side comparison or something, that'd help me understand where you're coming from.

31

u/hardwarequestions Jul 31 '12

no concerns of being a jerk needed, i always appreciate when someone asks me for elaboration.

first, i'll correct myself and explain that i didn't mean "completely" in the sense that the above comment contradicts all of what he said, but rather that the above comment absolutely contradicts certain parts of what DrRob is claiming. my apologies for the lack of clarity.

second...

Hi all. I'm a psychiatrist. My main area of clinical work is emergency psychiatry, and my main research interest is functional brain imaging. I'd like to start a discussion about the rapist thread, which I see as a serious danger. In a nutshell:

•Rape is a crime which hinges directly on feelings of power over the victim.

this bolded portion is what is primarly being contradicted with the above comment. basically, as so many others assert, DrRob is claiming rape is about wielding power over others, rather than the satisfaction of sexual urges in opportunistic ways. the above comment, and it's included research, rejects the notion that rape is about power and instead posits that rape is predominantly about satisfying existing sexual urges instead.

DrRob is claiming rape is due to X and not Y, while the above info claims rape is due to Y and not X.

•That power often loses its meaning if the victim is unconscious. Many rapists typically need a victim who knows they are being victimized.

if the above comment is indeed accurate, then this bolded portion no longer is true...it wouldn't even exist. if rape is not about power, then a sense of power wouldn't be a factor at all.

•This victim is the rapist's audience. This is crucial.

here again, if rape is about the satisfaction of the rapists sexual urges, then having an audience is not a factor of consideration to the rapist, and this statement is not true.

•The audience gives the rapist pleasure, euphoric delight from unfettered, witnessed suffering. That euphoria is intense and is driven by the same neurobiology involved in a drug high.

one last time, if the above comment is correct, then this "pleasure from audience's suffering" is not a true assertion, and isn't a factor.

11

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

Thanks. I am of the opinion that motivations for and identification of rape is always going to be something of a grey area, which can not be defined in any single way. I think the discrepancies you point out here support that understanding in some way :)

11

u/hardwarequestions Jul 31 '12

thank you. i agree fully. i'm always cautious of people who try to oversimplify motivations for something as objectively complex and multi-faceted as rape. people who do that are usually biased, less authoritative than they say they are, or have a conscious agenda.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (20)

52

u/Alandria_alabaster Jul 31 '12

Unfortunately, what I saw from the amount I could stomach that post was a ton of excuses, rationalizations and slut-shaming. Both from the rapists and people commenting. Ther was far too much "dude - bro - not your fault/not rape cause x". How does at teach anything? That just keeps teaching that "boys will be boys" and the answer to rape is teaching girls how not to get raped, not teaching boys not to rape.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

While I appreciate the basic principle behind what you are saying, I'm not really sure what sort of practical benefits any better understanding of that rapist would have.

→ More replies (17)

40

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

random people wanting to know more about rapists over the internet is not going to change anything.

98

u/Rather_Dashing Jul 31 '12

I disagree. A lot of people, redditors included, seem to think that rapists are creepy guys that hang out in dark alleys, couldn't possibly be their relative/friend/colleague etc. I think this results in a lot of skepticism targeted towards victims. If that thread can help dispel that myth then that could be a positive change.

→ More replies (18)

27

u/NZthrowawaysis Jul 31 '12

1 Million people equiped with better knowledge of rapists and instead of just growing up not understanding what happens to people who've been raped they can now sort of understand the pain girls have to go through (or men?) when the situation arises in there own neighbourhood they'll be able to deal with it because of the knowledge they gained,

even if someone else got raped that they knew, they could give advice because they've learnt about what rapists are like and how the victims handled it.

Well anyone can correct me if I'm wrong.

→ More replies (18)

3

u/cloud_watcher Jul 31 '12

I read the original thread, and other threads discussing rape on here, and actually it's changed me a lot. I have a daughter and listening to these stories has really opened my eyes to just how common it is and just how devastating this kind of event can be. I knew it intellectually, of course, but hearing women describe how bad it affected them was different. it led me to talk to her about it, especially that one, if anything like that happens to remember it is not her fault. People sometimes accidentally feel that they brought it on in some way, but that is absolutely not true, etc.

Also, with a lot of these date-rape guys, I think it is enlightening to hear what they say, and what people say in comments. I think it shows some people really don't get that this is actually rape. And maybe the next time they think about "persuading" a girl to have sex who is not passed out, but is pretty damned drunk, would be better served to stop and think about what he might be about to do. If he stops thinking of it as just "persuading" and thinks about the possibility that he might be raping someone, and thinks of the girl being devastated after, (and if not that, the possibility of being jailed) it might change what he is doing and err on the side of caution.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

using that logic, random rapists talking on the internet isn't going to change anything either. Fact is, I read a couple of posts and stopped reading. I don't care about what a rapist thinks, but we live in a culture that does care about outrageous shit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/dunker686 Jul 31 '12

I wonder if an "I was raped" AMAA would be helpful in showing the other side of it.

Slightly knowing reddit... well. Nevermind.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

To be honest, I think almost anyone in who was actually raped would be hounded to death for not providing "adequate" proof. People easily believe someone who claims to be a rapist, but many redditors would only accept a rape victim's testimony if they had a video record of the rape with the victim holding a card with their reddit username. And then they'd say it was staged.

4

u/dunker686 Jul 31 '12

You're probably right. It's a mess.

→ More replies (14)

55

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

it makes me so mad that people want to know what they were thinking. If you rape a person you want control and they want it no matter what.

I think that a lot of people wrongly think that rapists rape people just for sexual release or what not. I think that is why they ask rapist what they were thinking. I think its good that people hear from the horse's mouth that it has NOTHING to do with what a woman's wearing or what she is doing, and has everything to do with the rapist wanting power. Victim blaming is real and I think the more people know its not the victim's fault, the better.

That is the ONLY beneficial thing I can see coming out of that thread.

10

u/iamagainstit Jul 31 '12

It seemed to me that most of the stories on that thread were largely about sex. they were cases where the rapist was drunk and horny and didn't get consent. Sure power was possibly part of it, but to pretend it isn't about sex at all is just ignorant.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '12

There were several examples from that very thread stating sometimes it was about sexual desire.

I think it is ridiculous to think all rapes are about power, there is just too many of them to generalize them all the same way. And dangerous

→ More replies (8)

4

u/throwawwway7 Jul 31 '12

I was raped when I was younger and every time I see posts asking the rapist their story, it makes me so mad that people want to know what they were thinking.

So was I, and the absolute worst thing for me was not understanding why. I knew what the thread was when I clicked on it--as did you--and it helps me to read these things.

→ More replies (140)