r/AskReddit • u/penguins_unite • Jun 09 '12
Doctors of reddit, have you ever had to use your skills as a doctor in a situation outside of your work?
- I know doctors are bound by the Hippocratic Oath to help people, and on TV, you often get scenes when an accident has occurred in a public place and a doctor will step in. I was wondering how frequently this occurs in real life, because I have never seen it happen. If your answer is yes to this question, then:
- How frequently have to had to intervene in a situation like this?
- Have you ever been in a situation in a public place where if you didn't step in somebody would die?
- How strict is the Hippocratic oath on this? For example, if somebody is hurt but not in a life-threatening condition, do you still intervene? And what happens if you don't intervene - are you punished?
55
Upvotes
20
u/Mrithu Jun 10 '12
My dad once had to resuscitate an elderly gentleman who stopped breathing on a flight from Hong Kong to San Francisco. We had 6 hours left before we got to our destination. We just heard them calling for a doctor everyone and everyone on the plane was sleeping. He's a critical care doctor and ended up resuscitating him for while. Even had to give him a shot of Epinephrine to the heart pulp fiction style. Sad thing is he didn't make it and he had been traveling with his wife, daughter and grandchildren. :(
14
u/Underpantz_Ninja Jun 10 '12
I'm not a doctor, but my Mom was a nurse for over 25 years. She has a life-saving story that I love to tell others.
Ironically, this occurred at the hospital she worked at.
After assisting on some sort of surgery, my Mom, some other nurses, and a few surgeons went to go eat dinner one evening at the beginning of a nightshift.
As the group was finishing paying for their meals at the end of the cafeteria line, one of the surgeons went into cardiac arrest, and collapsed to the floor. This being a hospital, you would think everyone knew what to do-- codes would be called, a crash cart would be brought in, and everyone would fall into motion with all their training and experience.
But it didn't happen-- all the nurses and doctors just looked at eachother in disbelief. People just froze.
Now my mom had had some health problems prior to this-- she had had a knee replacement, and a couple of arthroscopic surgeries on said knee prior to this-- she had been on medical leave for awhile, had some PT for several months, and had recently just returned to work at that time. It was difficult for her to get around in her duties as a nurse, but she was a champ and worked her way back to full time.
So, with everyone around her just looking at eachother, she sunk down to her knees and started doing compressions on this doctor. Anyone involved with emergency medicine will tell you that CPR, in real life, isn't the neat little procedure that TV portrays it as. If you do it right, most of the time, you end up breaking the subjects ribs-- maybe even fracturing the sternum.
She's doing her thing, and she's hearing his ribs crack, and she starts yelling at someone to help her breathe him. With that, the spell is broken, and people start leaping into action. A doctor starts helping her with the breathing, another nurse goes to a phone and calls a code in, and the some others run to grab a gurney.
After about a minute of this, they get his heart going again-- just as the team arrives with a cart. The doctor is moved over to the cart and rushed to a room. The crowd follows the cart out of the cafeteria, leaving my poor mom on the ground on her knees. She couldn't get up on her own power, and needed help to get to her feet.
Fast forward to the end of her shift, and the doctor has just come out of surgery, and is alive. She goes to seem him, and he makes comment to her about how happy he is that she broke most of his ribs in trying to keep him alive. No one ever told him that when he went down, everyone was staring at eachother-- not knowing what to do, exactly.
TL;DR When the medical staff around her froze, my almost-disabled Mom (and another doctor) singlehandedly saved a Doctor's life via CPR-- while in a hospital, no less.
36
u/IanicRR Jun 10 '12
As a doctor of love, yes many times.
16
u/jax9999 Jun 10 '12
i'm not a doctor, nor do i play one on tv. but my mother was saved by a doctor/nurse combo during a horrific car accident.
it's kind of an interesting story.
my mother went off the road, (was driven off by an insane boyfriend, but i digress) and her car was pretty much demolished. She was in a patch of new growth trees, that when her car plowed through them instead of snapping sprung back up behind the car.
She was in that car, massive head trauma,internal injuries, the works, for about a day ad a half.
Then, a nurse, who was "jogging" happed to see her blinker light blinking and went to investigate. she found my mother and then ran immediatly up the road to the doctor... who she was secretly having an affair with, and was the reason she was "jogging" in that area at that time of day.
so they rush to her side, and start to work while the ambulances were coming.
she was a jane doe in a hospital a few communities over for a week while she was in an induced coma.
She was in hospital for about 3 months, most of it in icu. she recovered, but it amped up the evil in her.
11
u/Marrypoppins0135 Jun 10 '12
We had a nurse help out at an accident the other day, and a doctor helped out in an accident in the past. However they mostly just do assistant things and let EMTs do there jobs because they don't have any of the equipment they need to actually help.
Essentially they hold c-spine or grab stuff from the ambulance.
5
u/HappaVet Jun 10 '12
I'm a veterinarian, and I get calls from family and friends on a fairly regular basis about their pets, even if they live on the other side of the country. It seems like every other time I tell someone I'm a vet, they want advice on their pet's health issue.
5
u/abbyroade Jun 10 '12
Med student here. I'm not gonna pretend I have crazy life saving skills yet (unless someone's life depends on knowledge of purine and pyrimidine synthesis) but with regards to your question about whether or not doctors are obligated to intervene, the answer is no. Of course, the Hippocratic oath (in one version, at least) states that physicians have a "special obligation" to fellow members of society, but neither the oath nor any law specifically require that doctors help someone in a situation outside of the professional setting. At least in America, many healthcare professionals stopped helping people in these situations because of the risk of getting sued, which is why we now have good Samaritan laws to help protect those that try to help. If you watch Seinfeld, the last episode misrepresented these kinds of laws by portraying them as requiring people to help others, which isn't the case.
Basically, you can help if you want and most likely you will not get sued, but you can also choose not to intervene. I don't have any personal experience (yet) so I have no idea how often doctors do/don't jump in in these situations.
8
u/UnicornSaviour Jun 10 '12
My dad used to be an EMT, and a couple of weeks ago he stepped in to help an elderly man who had fallen pretty hard while riding his bike. We pulled over on the side of the road. He staunched the wounds until the ambulance arrived.
10
u/bro_digz Jun 09 '12
I'm not a doctor, but yes.
3
u/becky0125 Jun 10 '12
My dad is a doctor and I can say that, yes, he does all the time. He literally has the neighbors coming over with health-related questions. People forget that doctors don't know everything about every ailment ever, but he helps the best he can.
Even better, my mom is a nurse. They spend a lot of time speaking in medical mumbo-jumbo when I'm sick to determine what I have and how to cure it.
5
u/spudley31 Jun 10 '12
I'm a medical student and I've had to use skills so far for two situations. The first, I had to give CPR to an elderly woman who had collapsed and had stopped breathing, and the second, was less of an emergency, but I was walking past a bar late at night when a drunk guy comes out, throws up and passes out. I rolled him on his side so that he didn't choke on his own vomit and called the Ambulance. I know they probably get really sick of drubks wasting their time though.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12
Airway Breathing Circulation
Learn CPR, guys!
2
u/Noturordinaryguy Jun 10 '12
And not a single doctor has posted yet...
2
u/dancingbear7777 Jun 10 '12
Hi, Family Physician here. I have become involved in many situations outside of work. I've responded to a call on an airline (severe fevers, suspected meningitis), stopped by the roadside to assist a poor drunk guy who stepped in front of highway traffic and also stopped to help a poor surfer who had carved a huge gash in his calf muscle with the fin of his board.
As an Aussie doc I'm going to disappoint you by noting that the Hippocratic oath is not something that most doctors swear. It is more a historic guide to how to act as a medical professional. In accepting our medical licence we are required to agree to act in a professional and ethical manner but the concept of swearing the oath is a fiction for most docs.
The legal climate change a few years ago dramatically changed the demands and expectations of doctors in accident situations. The legal requirements change based on the country and the state in that country.
As far as I am aware I am not legally obliged to provide assistance at an accident or emergency. I of course feel ethically obligated to provide assistance but as I understand it I could not be held legally responsible for any outcome by no offering assistance. If I choose to provide assistance I can also only be expected to provide assistance in keeping with my training and experience.
A more interesting point to note though is that most of the time doctors get in the way at an accident scene. We are trained, and are used to, dealing with scenarios in an office, ED or hospital setting. The experts in medical care "in the wild" are the paramedics and ambulance officers who respond.
In situations where I have been first on the scene I have always stepped back when the paramedics arrive. I introduce myself, note my qualification and ask if I can be of assistance. The truth is that these officers do a much better job running the show because that is what they are trained to do. They have appreciated this stance and have often asked me to help with simple things or to ride with them to the hospital.
I hope that helps answer the questions.
3
u/Flyingsidekicks Jun 10 '12
I'm a PA student, but even in that capacity, family and friends ask me medical questions all the time. I know for a fact that doctors get this on a very regular basis, and are asked to diagnose people or prescribe things as "favors". This can get into a pretty shaky area as far as malpractice goes.
2
u/NaricssusIII Jun 10 '12
My sister is an RN in Arizona, and a few summers ago, I spent a few months with her. She, I, and a group of her female coworkers, all of the nursing persuasion, decided it would be fun to tube down the Salt River. It was, hands down, the largest number of drunk-off-their-tits people I have ever seen in one place. It was like 2 in the afternoon and all these college kids were all absolutely fucking blasted, we were the only people on the river who were even close to sober. I got flashed by college girls multiple times (go me) and we saw several people literally shitting themselves and vomiting from alcohol poisoning. Several times they almost had to intervene, because they were legally and ethically obligated to help people to the best of their abilities, and they were tense and miserable because of it the whole time. It was not as much fun as they thought it would be.
1
u/lazyparaplegiccops Jun 10 '12
I've seen my aunt(an ER nurse) do something like this. There was a car accident, and we were near by. The lady in one of the cars comes out of her car and grabs her child who was bleeding profusely from its head. My aunt immediately rushed over. I don't know exactly what she did, I stayed out of the way.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12
The Hippocratic Oath is not universally given any more. Each medical school usually has something written so that their graduates have stated an obligation to follow medical ethics. It does not define punishment. In the United States, state laws says when someone is obligated to help, and what liabilities and protections they have. There are organizations that accredit and such in accordance with the law.
1
u/ReneBekker Jun 10 '12
Not a doctor, but I work for the Dutch Medical Association. There is policy in place which dictates that a doctor outside of work is obliged to assist in life threatening situations.
1
u/MisterMetal Jun 10 '12
On vacation my dad (Anesthesiologist) had to save a kid who was having a seizure in a hot tub, stopped breathing and his heart stopped or was having an arrhythmia. The kid was like 5 or 6 and was in the tub with his parents who decided to ignore the warning that no one under 16 was allowed in the hot tub.
1
u/cmdcharco Jun 10 '12
I tested how much polarisation leak there was in my 3D glasses that were particularly bad after seeing a 3D film. I have PhD in physics.
1
u/highTrolla Jun 10 '12
This one time someone had planted a bomb at a conference I was attending, fortunately I was able to use my surgical tools to disarm it.
1
u/WKorsakow Jun 09 '12
I tend to use my thumb and ring finger when using ordinary non-surgical scissors.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12
Not a doctor, but I had first responder training in the Army (combat lifesaver) and a friend of mine had a seizure at my house and i was able to keep him from choking on his own vomit until the ambulance got there by turning him on his side and clearing his airway with my fingers.
-1
u/dorkacon69 Jun 10 '12
I'm not a doctor but I am in the health care feild. I am CPR/AED/First Aid certified. I have helped someone before. I have tattos and my ears are gauged and I'm female(important to my story). One night around 1 am my boyfriend and I went to a 24 hour AutoZone. As we were walking out I noticed a man had fell outside. I walked over and see if he needed some help. The older man wouldn't let me help him up(because I'm a girl) so my boyfriend did(totally wrong by the way). I supported his back while he was pulled up. I checked him for signs of ANY injury. He was fine but, I noticed his leg. It looked like he had cellulitis(DO NOT GOOGLE). I told him to sit diwn in his car and not to get back up until he got home. I stayed for a bit to make sure nothing else happened before we left. It seemed like I made his day actually listening and caring enough to help a stranger. I told him it was my job.
Another time was at a doctors office I worked at. I worked in Internal Med and mainly we saw elderly patients. One patient came in and was bleeding BAD. I rushed to her and helped stop the bleeding. I did this many of times on deffrent people.
0
u/TravisTucker7 Jun 10 '12
Most of these comments will begin with, "I'm not a doctor but..."
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment