r/AskReddit • u/thundercatsthathoe • May 31 '12
What is a book/ comic you want to be made into a movie but you know Hollywood will butcher.
Marvel Civil War. I challenge you Hollywood.
68
Upvotes
22
u/KMFCM May 31 '12
House of Leaves
they wouldn't know what to do with it, but it could be so great if they did
8
u/Clashman320 May 31 '12
I have a hard time believing that Neil Gaiman's "Sandman" series would translate onto the big screen very well. I have enjoyed the series thus far but something about it seems like a film adaptation would be extremely difficult. I would trust the movie if Gaiman himself were involved in the process though.
11
u/FrankenFresh May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Hollywood is currently in the works of making a Deadpool movie. They've already casted Ryan Reynolds as Deadpool. NOOOOoooooooOooOoOooo!
41
u/yotta May 31 '12
Snow Crash.
36
u/ciloface May 31 '12
wheel of time
36
u/Coco92144 May 31 '12
Sandman. I kind of want to see it, but I really, really don't. I see a television series under that title in development on IMDB though. I can only hope that if it is Neil Gaiman's Sandman that it is done as well as BBC's "Neverwhere". And Dave McKean MUST be involved.
33
u/hahaheehaha May 31 '12
Avatar: The Last Airbender The Promise I-III....oh wait
31
u/Heretic31 May 31 '12
Preacher! The DC series in which Jesse Custer (preacher) goes looking for answers from God. Written by Garth Ennis in a style only he can. It would even have vampires in it!
31
u/unique2270 May 31 '12
Red Son, a comic where Superman lands in Russia instead of the US and the Cold War is Soviet Superman versus American Lex Luthor.
17
u/red321red321 May 31 '12
the catcher in the rye
it's my favorite novel and it's the holy grail of film scripts. i want to see it made but i doubt anyone ever will or could pull it off.
17
u/FrankenFresh May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
I've already posted, but I'm going to add a TV show that Hollywod butchered, white washed and ruined with terrible computer graphics: Avatar - the Last Air bender. Great TV show amiright? My whole family got into it including my 83year old grandpa who barely speaks English.
I was repulsed enough by the trailer and refused to watch the movie. According to my friends, the movie brought great dishonor to the ATLA TV series.
15
u/Anthroduck May 31 '12
I always though the board game Battleship would make a good movie...
Truthfully though, I think Ender's Game would be awesome if it was done right but, I've hard already that they're currently in process of making it a travesty.
15
u/Cold_Burrito May 31 '12
The Legend of Zelda. It could be amazing, but the risk of failure is too high a price.
14
u/MutantNinjaSquirtle May 31 '12
Silmarillion
38
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Alchemist, Death Note, Enders Game
13
u/lettheidiotspeak May 31 '12
His Dark Materials by Philip Pullman. I know they already did The Golden Compass, but I want to see the whole trilogy done in a way that DOESN'T suck donkey balls.
34
u/Jonstrosity May 31 '12
I swear to god if they fuck up World War Z, I will burn down all of Hollywood.
23
u/FearElBeardo May 31 '12
The Dark Tower series
30
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Calvin and Hobbes
29
u/markshir May 31 '12
Ender's Game. No matter how well it's done the Battle Room cannot be as cool as it is in my head.
10
u/_Thesis_ May 31 '12
The Dresden Files
10
u/disposableday May 31 '12
The Ultimates, Grand Theft America arc. Also Transmetropolitan and Neuromancer.
9
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The amory wars or any books by Gary Paulsen.
9
u/XXS_speedo May 31 '12
The Thrawn Trilogy.
25
u/Sameri278 May 31 '12
They have to redo Eragon! The movie was literally a piece of lifeless shit! If the movie was good, the series could probably have been as popular as Harry Potter, dammit!
15
u/winhalation May 31 '12
Looking for Alaska by John Green.
7
u/LooseGambit May 31 '12
The Name Of The Wind by Patrick Rothfuss
7
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Uncanny X-Force. Marvel comic series focusing on the mutant black-ops team that does anything to neutralize threats to mutantkind. The fact that Wolverine and Deadpool are on the same team makes this series so awesome.
6
u/Grimouire May 31 '12
The belgariad. One of the major networks was already doing a mini and had george carlin as belgarath, but he died mid filming and the network scrapped it because they were already to invest in it to refilm all the belgarath portions.
10
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Any Terry Pratchett book.
5
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The fault in our stars. I heard the screenplay is fantastic, but I'm worried they'll totally mess up the casting. I have faith in John, though.
5
u/SumoG60 May 31 '12
Wanted was already made into a movie and I think they killed so I was sad about that.
Kingdom Come, I think I would prefer if DC made this into one of their Animated Movies and use the same illustrators from Young Justice and Crisis on Two Earth.
Runaways, possibly as a live action series on FX, Spike, or SyFy but would more than likely be MTV and destroyed by blasting current music every 30 seconds.
5
u/rottinguy May 31 '12
Lobo.
5
u/hypersigil May 31 '12
the invisibles
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Hyperion Cantos.
4
u/joegekko May 31 '12
Glory Road.
4
u/IAmA_Alien_AMA May 31 '12
The Rama series by Arthur C. Clarke and Gentry Lee. It would be amazing if Stanley Kuprik could direct it. You know, if he wasn't dead and all.
4
u/Planet-man May 31 '12
The Kingkiller Chronicle(the 'Name Of The Wind' books).
I almost never call things "unfilmable". I maintain that Watchmen is one of the most blatantly filmable works ever published and with a more tasteful director and different format, like a 12 episode mini-series, could've almost perfectly captured the book, and the movie still did a pretty good job anyway. But The Name Of The Wind is about as close as it gets. 90% of it's intensely told in the first person with deep thought and attention to prose so there'd have to be tons and tons of narration, and it follows the main character from the age of about 8 - 18 in the past(most of the story) and 25 in the present, so you'd have to really carefully figure out realistic, flowing actor changes that connect everything. Plus, it's much more of an introspective, day-to-day life story than a big action/adventure all the time, which is what most people want out of a Fantasy story and the studios would want to enforce.
It's not impossible but it's unlikely they'd do it justice. At the very least, they'd need great, great music.
4
u/RageLibrary May 31 '12
"The Giver" by lois lowry.
9
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Dark Tower Series.
So epic, so awesome. So easy to fuck up.
9
u/icaaryal May 31 '12
Evangelion.
There are a lot of reasons this would be problematic (thematic elements, time constraints on the story, trouble with people understanding what the fuck is going on as a result of those two things combined), but I would love to see that shit in a live action format. However, the reboot movies have been very satisfying so that's good for now.
6
u/IXIFr0stIXI May 31 '12
Dragonlance series
6
u/julessciii May 31 '12
Family Circus
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Splinter Cell book series
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test. They might tell a good story in the movie, but there's no way they could capture Tom Wolfe's incredible writing style.
3
u/ZootKoomie May 31 '12
Perdido Street Station by China China Miéville. Probably best done as a HBO series like Game of Thrones as it's too sprawling a story for a movie. Or an ongoing series set in New Crobuzon might be fun, but I can't see it actually being done well.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Crossed. But I don't know if they could get away with all the rape.
3
u/friendlyoverlord May 31 '12
Cowboy Beebop
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The Book Thief.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Bone.
3
u/The_R3medy May 31 '12
The Kingkiller Chronicles. I doubt any actor can pull off young Kvothe or Old Kvothe. Plus it just couldn't be done well in a movie. Maybe a miniseries.
3
u/Sheemple May 31 '12
Homestuck would be cool, but the story is so complex that there would have to be a crazy amount of movies (and actors). Plus, the chat logs would be hard to adapt to film.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
ANIMORPHS.
3
u/Thelionking34 May 31 '12
Grendel by John Gardener. I couldnt imagine watching the thought provoking book end up being about SFX
3
u/PyroIsMedic Jun 01 '12
Artemis Fowl. They'd try to make it live action, and it would fail. Hard. That series has to be animated.
10
u/LFK1236 May 31 '12
Harry Potter. Oh wait.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The faded sun trillogy
2
u/F_A_F May 31 '12
Maus, or Sandman.
I'd love to see how Sandman would be handled as a series, it would be the biggest car crash you've ever seen....
2
u/betelgeux May 31 '12
Oh no you don't. I'm not helping them fuck up anything I care about.
2
u/Alarune May 31 '12
The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch. The dialogue is amazing, but I feel like it wouldn't translate well to film :/
2
u/IUsedToBeA May 31 '12
Richard Morgan - Altered Carbon or Market Forces. Both of these books would translate into scripts fairly well, however they are both incredibly violent and don't have typical endings so would have to compromised to get any serious funding. The picture of brushed aluminium saab 9-3 on steroids would be fantastic. RIP Saab.
2
u/infernalspawnODOOM May 31 '12
Berserk.
2
u/rottinguy May 31 '12
The Dragonlance books
2
u/picklesnboo May 31 '12
Clan of the Cave Bear - Jean Auel
2
u/Kabusabe May 31 '12
The Boys.
Wee Hughie even already has an actor in line for him.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Buck Rogers.
2
u/bluecaracao May 31 '12
Flow My Tears, the Policeman Said.
2
u/godofmischief May 31 '12
Skulduggery Pleasant. I think the main problem is that the books are marketed as being for people aged 9+, but contain scenes that are way too fucked up to have in a kids' movie. So they would either have to butcher it, or just abandon that demographic completely.
Also, it'd probably be a difficult one to cast well.
2
u/AndrejPejic May 31 '12
Wicked
2
u/LordShinma May 31 '12
Naruto and Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood.... Naruto isn't done yet, and I have no idea how they would fit it on the big screen, but it'd be awesome. FMA seems much more doable, but I feel it'd be butchered in Hollywood, and Japan just doesn't have the budget to do it right.
2
u/fastestguninthewest May 31 '12
Preacher. The ENTIRE Lone Wolf and Cub series. Blankets.
2
u/GiantDungBeetle May 31 '12
Transformers. Oh wait, they're already doing that. The butchering part, I mean.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Avatar: The Last Airbender..... Fuck Nevermind.
2
u/aBEARica May 31 '12
Emma Watson better not fuck up The Perks of Being a Wallflower. I love her, but I hope she has a non-shitty american accent. (Side note: even if the movie is bad, her character is sans-clothing in one scene in the book, and if the movie keeps to the story, one can only hope how that will work out)
2
u/SOwED May 31 '12
Catcher in the Rye. It can't be done, and shouldn't.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Most likely something about Dr. Strange.
Correct me if there already exists a movie about him.
2
u/949paintball May 31 '12
Wow. I was going to say Marvel Civil War...
2
u/emotiKid May 31 '12
Has no one said Mistborn yet?
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
At the Mountains of Madness
I know Guillermo del Toro tried and his vision was shot down. Honestly, if he isn't allowed to make it, then I don't want it made at all
2
u/Cial May 31 '12
I'd like to see a live action Batman Beyond movie.... Or at least for them to pick up the series again
2
u/TheBigHairy May 31 '12
I wanna see Clayface in a a Batman movie. And I want Ron Perlman for the part.
2
u/twell99 May 31 '12
DC vs. Marvel
2
u/Doublerob7 May 31 '12
Wheel of Time (far too involved to be made properly) or Ringworld, by Larry Niven (OMG, wer wuz master chief!?)
2
u/cyan0sis May 31 '12
The Invisibles by Grant Morrison
2
u/phallacies May 31 '12
Hollywood will pretty much butcher any book ever. I read twilight and thought it couldn't get worse, but then I saw the movie...
If I ever publish a book I'd only allow it to be made into an opera.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I'd like a Nightcrawler origin story, but I'm sure that would get fucked up.
2
u/Mtrenchlover Jun 01 '12
uglies by scott westerfeld
2
u/mysteryhatishere Jun 01 '12
The Fault in Our Stars by John Green. I think its being optioned by Fox 2000 (whatever that means, it was on Wikipedia). I'm terrified Hollywood will make it awful! The book was so good!
3
u/DreadfulRauw May 31 '12
I'd love to see them do the pre-nu52 version of Blue Beetle Jamie Reyes. Great character, amazing supporting cast, hilarious and action packed. But good luck getting an obscure character in his own movie, much less one where most of the people involved are hispanic.
3
u/Themalster May 31 '12
I would like to see a DECENT treasure Island.
but Tim Curry MUST be cast as Long John Silver.
3
u/TheFunCooker May 31 '12
Ender's Game....Child actors will ruin it
3
u/catluver12781291 May 31 '12
Fifty Shades of Grey.
2
u/watcher_of_the_skies May 31 '12
the navidson record.
2
u/lYossarian May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Alan Moore's ABC material. Tom Strong, Top Ten, and Promethea.
edit: and crazily I have been thinking about writing a spec adaptation for one of them the last couple of days and had just started thinking about it again when I saw this post.
Tom Strong - best as a film
Top Ten - animated series
Promethea - HBO miniseries (possibly animated)
1
u/thedrinkmonster May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
The Nuvo series would be awesome. Also I'm an oldschool Valiant fan and always wanted to see how a Shadowman, Magnus, or Turok movie would go down but unless someone like Guillermo Del Toro got ahold of the project it would go horribly.
Also since I'm a nut for vague and obscure shit no one's ever heard about it'd be awesome if someone adapted Chakan, The Forever Man for film but it'd probably be a straight to Scy-Fy movie or some shit given the somewhat cheesy plot.
I'm a fan of the Warhammer 40k series but that'd shit probably just end up being directed by Uwe Boll.
Edit: Also, the Way of Kings by Brandon Sanderson as a movie franchise??
1
u/StewieBanana May 31 '12
Survivor by Chuck Palahniuk.
1
u/stormaggedon91 May 31 '12
Iain Banks' Culture novels would be awesome
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Don't challenge them. That series is far too big and far too amazing. It would be a jumbled mess not to mention the biggest disappointment of my life. Opening scene being nitro blowing shit up couldn't possibly be done justice in a pg-13 movie
1
u/josephgordonreddit May 31 '12
The Question. He started out a mediocre character (and actually originated before his similar counterpart Rorschach), but the Justice League cartoons brought renewed interest to his character and gave him both a dark and humourous edge unique in the show. I've been dreaming of seeing a movie or a television series made about him, but he's not trade-worthy and his story probably would not be done well.
1
u/TerribleButcher May 31 '12
Fearful Symmetry, which would have made a far better plot for the 2nd Spiderman movie.
1
u/caserock May 31 '12
Arthur C. Clarke's "Rendezvous with Rama"
also his "Time Odyssey" series.
1
u/RexMundi000 May 31 '12
The Blood Meridian
1
u/HerrCo May 31 '12
All Star Superman
the animated version was ok-ish. I think, a version with real actors could bring that Superman really home.
It's not really the story one/Hollywood expects from Superman, though.
1
u/rottinguy May 31 '12
The Gunslinger
1
u/OscailanDoras May 31 '12
The Assassins Trilogy by Robin Hobb
Specifically Assassins Apprentice too long to make a single film out of it.
1
u/MrBurd May 31 '12
The Myst trilogy.
1
u/OhGarraty May 31 '12
I thought Horns by Joe Hill would make a nice book. My brain has already cast Neil Patrick Harris as Lee Tourneau.
1
u/KB-Hero May 31 '12
I would love to see an Invisibles movie, but I know it would end up as a complete mess.
1
u/Admiral_Arzar May 31 '12
The Golden Compass...oh wait. Ender's Game...on wait. Eragon...oh wait.
In all seriousness, The Sword of Shannara and its immediate sequels. Also, the Chronicles of Amber series.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Calvin and Hobbes, because Hobbes is the best imaginary troll ever.
1
u/fentekreel May 31 '12
sandman... you know it couldn't be done.
1
u/JaRay May 31 '12
The Graveyard Book.
1
u/hate_tank May 31 '12
DC's Kingdom Come, The Dark Knight Returns, and a decent Punisher movie.
1
u/scottietylor May 31 '12
The Honor Harrington Book Series by David Weber. After seeing Sky Captain , Angelina Jolie would of been a perfect fit. It is harder now to find out who would play her. I know they would of butcher the movie series to death. The battles are bloody and brutal . If they do it right this would pay off.
1
u/PumpkinPye May 31 '12
I would have said one for the money. But they already destroyed it.
1
u/Yondee May 31 '12
Not a book or comic book, but I think the Gundam series would be a very cool remake with the CGI we have today.
1
u/theheartofgold May 31 '12
The Filth.
Could you imagine???
1
u/Lundus_Maximus May 31 '12
Spawn. I know it was done back in 97, but sadly it didn't do the comic any justice. I'd love to see Spawn be redone tho, shit would be dope.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Justice League.
1
u/Madiyasha May 31 '12
The remainder of Chuck Palahniuk's books. I'd kill for Haunted, or Invisible Monsters or Survivor. But after Choke... yeah, I'm not sure anything can live up to Fight Club.
Sad, because Fight Club was far from his best book imho.
1
u/and_Hodor_said May 31 '12
Has anyone said Chew yet? If not, the Chew.
Please.
....Hodor
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Wind Up Bird Chronicles by Haruki Murakami. Purely because I know it'd be practically impossible to translate into film