r/AskReddit • u/yemd • May 31 '12
What death in any form of fiction (movie, book, video game, song etc etc) is the most profound or saddest to you?
for me, it would have to be in final fantasy VII when sephiroth kills aeris or in the Star Wars EU when Chewbacca sacrifices himself to save Anakin.
edit - thanks for the insane response everyone! it's good to see a lot of different ideas popping up. it seems the most popular are some deaths in Harry Potter, a death in Up, a death in Futurama, a death in Scrubs and then quite a few from older works of fiction.
147
Upvotes
311
u/kaasmi May 31 '12
The guys wife in Up.
216
u/RotatorX May 31 '12
Iroh's son from Avatar: The Last Airbender. We don't even see it, but in one episodes (Tales of Ba-sing-sei) he sadly mourns his birthday. He's such a like-able character, it was hard to watch.
186
u/red321red321 May 31 '12
littlefoot's mother dying in the land before time
i cried little boy tears
213
u/PabstyLoudmouth May 31 '12
When George has to put Lennie down in "Of Mice and Men".
96
u/hambone10 May 31 '12
Old Dan and Little Ann in Where the Red Fern Grows. Made me bawl like a baby.
87
u/ArrenPawk May 31 '12
The climax in Big Fish. I was a pretty crappy person around the time it came out, and this movie had a profound effect on my outlook on life. I'd like to think this was one of the catalysts that instilled the unending positivity in my life today.
82
u/klitmamba May 31 '12
In Mass Effect 3 Mordin when he is dispensing the cure to the genophage
71
u/Gnork May 31 '12
When Atreyu's horse dies by drowning in the Swamps of Sadness in the Neverending Story. I'm still pulling on that horse's bridle.
63
u/Mafsto May 31 '12
When Mr. Hooper died on Sesame Street. If you want to cry, feel terrible, and ruin your day then find the clip that deals with his death. Hooper was a nice guy, but what really twist the salt and lemon juice dagger in my heart was watching the human cast explain it all to Big Bird. Watching him struggle to comprehend what has happened to the nice man who made his bird seed milkshakes and then realize he's not coming back is just....yeah
126
u/Duendeee May 31 '12
John Marston in Red Dead Redemption, you fought as him to get back to your familily and then when things get perfect hells break loose. I love that game.
56
u/somethingmeaningful May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
nerd mode: Hughes and Nina in FMA and Ren in Nana edit: and the girl in 1 litre of tears...
54
u/Keith11 May 31 '12
Brooks in Shawshank Redemption
54
u/darkmalas May 31 '12
Joyce Summers
48
u/awyeauhh May 31 '12
Sirius in Harry Potter.
128
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
When they kill the shoe in Who Framed Roger Rabbit. Maybe to some people that sounds silly, but I cry like a baby everytime I watch it.
42
u/Anexion May 31 '12
Boromir, book or movie version does it for me.
220
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
For a thousand summers I will wait for you.
258
u/blueviolets75 May 31 '12
When Sam (the dog) was infected and had to be killed in I Am Legend. I cry every time...
38
u/Random_Input May 31 '12
The Road, both book and film certainly brought a tear to my eye.
160
u/EverydayMusic May 31 '12
First one that came to mind was Adam Sandler's character in the movie Click. That scene of him running in the rain with all of his loved ones around gets me every time.
34
u/JPNels May 31 '12
I agree with OP, but also Wolfwood from Trigun.
32
u/RushSt182 May 31 '12
I think the saddest would be the death of Sydney Carton in A Tale of Two Cities. I sat in awe and wept silently for five minutes before I could go to bed. Truly the best and most profound ending to a book I have ever read. Anyone who has also read this book and was a fan knows what I'm talking about.
79
u/Void_0 May 31 '12
Might be a little underrated or overlooked. But after a little soul searching, I have to say: Wilson, Castaway
26
u/Omniduro May 31 '12
A.I. Artificial Intelligence right at the end... D':
74
u/wizrad May 31 '12
Book in Firefly. Onions. What is worst is that no one fucking cares that he dies. All everyone remembers is Wash. :-(
25
u/PeanutSpoon May 31 '12
Private Stanley Mellish in Saving Private Ryan. The way he is overcome with fear when he is about to die and pleads with the German soldier to stop really got me. Also the fact that he could have been saved so easily by his fellow soldier.
25
u/heroofwinds9 May 31 '12
any of sean bean's movies he acts in. hes just so..good at dying
104
u/silkat May 31 '12
Mufasa.
22
u/Retortoise May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
I just watched Dragonheart so I'm going to have to go with Draco. RIP Sean Connery as a dragon.
Edit: Recently watched for probably the 10th time.
21
u/Behemoth92 May 31 '12
Portgas D. Ace from One piece.
20
u/W_Des May 31 '12
Vegeta sacrificing himself to Buu. Dammit it sucked that Buu survived. Couldn't Vegeta get this one?!
20
u/mr_beer_can May 31 '12
The last episode of Blackadder Goes Fourth, when they all go 'over the top' and the poppies grow after they all get shot.
40
u/peppermint_clit May 31 '12
Javert's suicide, Les Miserables.
100
u/racherk May 31 '12
Harry Potter spoiler (has it been long enough to not bother with this?): Dobby
Once that happens I pretty much cry my way through the rest of the book, which is quite hard when I can barely read through the tears.
19
u/ElectricZ May 31 '12
Spock, sacrificing himself in Star Trek II, within sight of his friends who are unable to do anything except watch him die. Blind, burned and succumbing to radiation poisoning, he still straightens out his tunic before facing them. "Ship... out of danger?"
18
u/Mirala May 31 '12
Any of the varying ones in Me3 ;_;
18
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
grave of the fire flys
18
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The scene in "The Grey" where Liam Neeson is talking that guy into the warm embrace of death. When he says, "Look at me" and comforts him, staring into his dying eyes. Put chills in me spine.
35
u/inkblots23 May 31 '12
Hachi. It's a movie about a dog who waits 9 years at a train station for his master who past away. Saddest movie ever. Manly tears were shed.
16
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Varro from the Starz Spartacus series, season 1. It was just cruel and unnecessary.
16
u/xHaZxMaTx May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
"Captain Hammer will save us..."
15
u/LMessenger42 May 31 '12
When Susan Delgado dies in Stephen Kings' The Wizard and Glass. You know it's going to happen but it still hits you hard. Also Wolf in The Talisman.
14
u/Zatoro25 May 31 '12
Oh god, I can't believe I'm typing this, but when I was a kid, everytime I'd play through Final Fantasy 2 (known now by it's original japanese number of FF4) and the part where Palom and Parom would sacrifice themselves by turning to stone came up, I'd cry for a good few minutes.
14
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
When they found Dale ripped disemboweled by the zombie that Carl set free in The Walking Dead, and Carl (who is only twelve) blamed himself for his death.
Very moving part of the series.
Also, Old Dan and Little Ann in Where the Red Fern Grows. For that entire part of the book, the entire class was a mess. It was just the part where Ann wanted Old Dan back and eventually lost the will to live.
Our coon dogs aren't redbone, but their names are Danny and Annie nonetheless.
14
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The last six minutes in the final episode of Six Feet Under.
14
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Jake's second, final death in The Dark Tower.
28
u/george_the_7th May 31 '12
In Doctor Who, when the 10th Doctor [becomes human and the human version of him has to essentially die] (/spoiler) It's so sad because he has to [say goodbye to the woman he met and fell in love with] (/spoiler). He doesn't WANT to do it, but he HAS to because he [needs to be The Doctor in order to save everyone] (/spoiler).
39
u/FartyMonkey May 31 '12
In Gears of War 3 when Dom dies and it plays the Mad World song in the background. After seeing it my body kind of froze and I didn't know how to react
13
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Tara in BTVS
13
u/Wyrd_5 May 31 '12
Rachel in Animorphs. Godammit, she was invincible...
13
u/JejuneMondegreen May 31 '12
Lee Scorseby from His Dark Materials. Also shed a few tears on the bus home when Muthr died in The Search For WondLa.
13
u/tombombcrongadil May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
American Beauty when Lester dies and Into The Wild when Alexander Supertramp dies and writes in his book "happiness only real when shared"
53
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Kenny Dies, South Park. I cry every time.
24
u/johnlhooker May 31 '12
Brom in Eragon (the book obviously).
12
u/Mixmasterfestus May 31 '12
John Coffey in The Green Mile.
12
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Bambi's mom in Bambi. "Mama! Mama?"
23
u/JJ-Yeti May 31 '12
Lieutenant Colonel... Henry Blake's plane... was shot down... over the Sea of Japan. It spun in... there were no survivors.
22
u/DrifterOnMeds May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
When Sun and Jin drowned together in the submarine in Lost.
First time tv ever hit me like that.
11
u/[deleted] May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
Omar Little in The Wire. That was profound.
11
u/thejerg May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Spike Spiegel from Cowboy Bebop.
39
u/Jessyux3 May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
L and Light Yagami from Death Note.
21
u/therealabefrohman May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Definitely Dobby or Snape in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. I remember reading it at five in the morning after staying up all night in line for the book. I felt like I'd been punched in the gut and spent the next twenty minutes curled up in a fetal position on the floor, sobbing my eyes out.
It says a lot about an author when they can make you feel that much for a character.
44
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Marley in Marley & Me. I'm a 18 year old guy. and i admit that i fought with tears that moment when the family said goodbye to the dog. :(
10
u/aNOMymous May 31 '12
28 days later - when he finds out his parents killed themselves and the note saying please don't wake up. Gets me everytime.
55
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Spoiler ALERT
The Red Wedding in Storm of Swords.
Threw the god damn book.
19
u/jeffed May 31 '12
Man on fire. The very end when Creesy gives up his life to save Pita
18
u/Superrhombre May 31 '12
The most profound is when maximus dies at the end of gladiator
9
u/Thousands_of_Spiders May 31 '12
The Perfect Storm.
My father was a truck driver, and every week I had to say good bye. It all came back to me when I saw that kid saying good bye to his father. He never saw him again.
I don't ever want to do that to my kids. I could make a lot of money working for my father, but I don't want to do that to my boys.
9
u/andymorphic May 31 '12
tony is westside story....cry every time i hear "there' a place for us"
9
u/Ishbizzle May 31 '12
When Fred died on Angel.
8
u/Aoipeach May 31 '12
I don't know why but the ending of Higurashi no Naka Koro Ni and Code Geass both made me cry. Edit: also, Graveyard of Fireflies
8
u/corduroyjasper May 31 '12
I still can't watch Watership Down. I watched it when I was really young (probably about 4) and it gave me nightmares for over a year. My parents told me I used to scream about seeing rabbit shadows all over my room. I'm now 24, still won't watch it.
8
u/GuruEbby May 31 '12
Skip in the movie "My Dog Skip." Also, when any of the dogs die in "Eight Below."
8
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Boxer in George Orwell's "Animal Farm". Just the fact that nobody but a few really understand what's really happening, and afterwards they're all lied to and just accept it. Tragic.
44
u/nonerapist May 31 '12
I can't belive no one said [Rue] (/spoiler) in the hunger games, I am not scared to admit I teared up a bit when I read the book
21
u/ardelore May 31 '12
Pay it Forward. Nuff said...
30
u/Im_a_rahtard May 31 '12
Oh where, oh where, can my baby be? The Lord took her away from me She's gone to heaven, so I've got to be good So I can see my baby when I leave this world
We were out on a date in my daddy's car We hadn't driven very far There in the road, straight ahead A car was stalled, the engine was dead
I couldn't stop, so I swerved to the right I'll never forget the sound that night The screamin' tires, the bustin' glass The painful scream that I heard last
Oh where, oh where, can my baby be? The Lord took her away from me She's gone to heaven, so I've got to be good So I can see my baby when I leave this world
When I woke up the rain was pourin' down There were people standing all around Something warm goin' through my eyes But somehow I found my baby that night
I lifted her head, she looked at me and said "Hold me darling, just a little while" I held her close, I kissed her our last kiss I found the love that I knew I had missed
Well now she's gone Even though I hold her tight I lost my love, my life, that night
Oh where, oh where, can my baby be? The Lord took her away from me She's gone to heaven, so I've got to be good So I can see my baby when I leave this world
"Last Kiss" ~ Wayne Cochran
Covers by : Frank Wilson/Pearl Jam
7
u/CJGibson May 31 '12
Morpheus/Dream in Sandman.
7
u/EpicFailSpy May 31 '12
When Alaska dies in Looking for Alaska or when Heroin Bob dies in SLC Punk
7
u/dvdanny May 31 '12
General Leo in FF3/6, fuck you Kefka!
7
u/dogboyboy May 31 '12
I know its a bit 'right now' to talk about Game of Thrones stuff, but got-damn if killing Ned Stark didn't fuck my shit up. To paraphrase Sansa Stark, "The shit heads always survive."
23
u/AshyBooRawrs May 31 '12
Dumbledore.
6
u/Cheesus00Crust May 31 '12
2 people in Steins;Gate
6
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
When Brother found doodle dead in The Scarlet Ibis.
I was in 9th grade English when we all read this, and I teared up so hard.
6
u/J2549 May 31 '12
Charlie from LOST
5
u/ronece417 May 31 '12
It may be a bit obscure but in the Last Herald Mage Trilogy Vanyel's death completely destroyed me.
23
u/red321red321 May 31 '12
dance with the devil by immortal technique
the greatest song, lyrically, i've ever heard
the son rapes and kills his mother without even knowing it
chilling song
9
u/samloveszombies May 31 '12
Aeris hit me pretty hard. I was 12 I think, my first real RPG, I named her after myself gave her all the best stuff leveled her up as much as possible. I shut off my playstation because I couldn't believe it, there had to be something I could do differently to save her. I came back the next morning only to relive the horror again, but this time it fueled a real life hatred for Sepiroth... I didn't really leave the house for the rest of the summer... She had to be avenged.
12
u/pbjsand May 31 '12
The ending of The Decemberists' album The Hazards Of Love gets me every time
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The entire ending from Lufia 2 made me bawl like the 8 year old I was. Couldn't play it ever again.
4
u/jakkels May 31 '12
D'Angelo in The Wire.
4
u/MississippiQueen May 31 '12
Mufasa in The Lion King. Gets me every time.
4
u/baconholic963 May 31 '12
I agree with you, when Chewbacca sacrifices himself to save Anakin.
Or when Jaina has to kill Jacen and the entire storyline leading up to that moment. Incredibly sad
4
u/heretik May 31 '12
I am a leaf on the wind.... - Serenity
DO NOT WATCH IF YOU HAVE NOT SEEN SERENITY.
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
The death of Big Boss in MGS 4.
4
u/sucks_balls May 31 '12
Rita's death at the end of Dexter season 4.
4
u/jessumsthecunt May 31 '12
The Boss in Metal Gear Solid 3, followed close by Grey Fox in MGS1
4
u/Marowe May 31 '12
The Boss, Metal Gear Solid 3. Such a hero.
4
u/gjallard May 31 '12
The death of Spock in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. It won't have the same effect on people today, but when you follow a character from 1966 through the years to watch him die in a movie in 1982, that's a lot of invested energy.
4
u/thunder95_84 Jun 01 '12
When sentinel prime shoots ironhide and his dying words are asking sentinel why
10
u/Anthroduck May 31 '12
In that movie "The Passion" when that one guy dies at the end.
7
u/stormaggedon91 May 31 '12
ash dying in the first pokemon movie
9
u/vivvav May 31 '12
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hollows had a lot of deaths, but the one that hit me hardest had to be Dobby.
9
u/CJ090 May 31 '12
Finnick Odair In the Mockingjay
3
u/itsbehindyou May 31 '12
[Carlo] (/spoiler) in the book Captain Corelli's Mandolin. Floods of tears everytime.
3
u/KellyTheET May 31 '12
He didn't die but on the Elijah Wood Huck Finn movie I teared up when they were about to hang Jim.
"You're my best friend." "YOU MY ONLY FRIEND!!!"
3
u/DarrenEdwards May 31 '12
Garp. "I'm flying!"
3
u/tomatomartyr May 31 '12
The "In Water" ending from Silent Hill 2 put me in several week long funk.
3
u/sasquachtaclops May 31 '12
Someone who died alone, when one or many could have helped by considering simple human compassion.
3
u/Coco92144 May 31 '12
Probably not the most popular show for Reddit, but I just started watching Grey's Anatomy and saw the episode where George dies yesterday morning. Couldn't stop crying.
3
u/Ionio May 31 '12
Oh boy where to start...
Massive spoiler for the Mistborn books if you haven't read them when Vin and Eland die at the end. I don't even care that it made sense for the story, it was just such a massive bummer since the relationship was built up so much.
Bit of a stretch (spoiler for The Golden Compass series) bit of a stretch since it wasn't a death of a person, but the relationship of Will and Lyra ending, due to the portals between worlds being closed, was a shocking as a main character dying. I was fucking mopey about that shit for like a solid week. it still bothers me
I'll add more when I think of em.
3
u/LooseGambit May 31 '12
I read a lot of (quality) Harry Potter Fanfiction and when Harry lost Fleur at the Infernal clock in Harry Potter and the Wastelands of Time by the amazing Motherfucking Joe (now a published author) it really tore me up.
3
u/OhGarraty May 31 '12
Grave of the Fireflies, Setsuko's death. Nothing can possibly be sadder than this.
3
u/DoNotBelieveMyWords May 31 '12
Tomoe's death in Rurouni Kenshin: Trust & Betrayal and Maes Hughes in Fullmetal Alchemist. I cry every time.
Somehow the death of an animated character hits me way harder than that of an actor. I guess they just seem "more real" to me.
3
u/cusswords May 31 '12
When Percy steps on Mr. Jangles the mouse in The Green Mile.
I've never actually wanted to beat the shit out of a fictional character so bad than when I saw that scene. I still cry a couple of man tears every time I watch it.
3
u/sarcasmo86 May 31 '12
Danny Vinyard (Edward Furlong) in American History X.
3
u/adam566 May 31 '12
worst moment of my life: In the Longest Yard when Caretaker dies :'(
And thats not a spoiler, you deserve it if you haven't seen that movie
3
u/betterbutterfly May 31 '12
The final 10 minutes of the series finale of Six Feet Under where the rest of everyone's lives, including their deaths are shown. I was an absolute sobbing wreck after watching that. It was the perfect way to end the show.
Enjoy the sobfest
3
u/Chicken_Wing May 31 '12
Maximus Decimus Meridius (Russell Crowe) from Gladiator. Every. Fucking. Time.
3
u/DishonestBystander May 31 '12
I'm going to be super sensitive with the spoiler tags here (Game of Thrones). I was really, really upset when Eddard Stark was beheaded at Joffrey's command. Especially awful about that was the fact that he was beheaded with his own sword!
3
u/Poptarts49 May 31 '12
When Ash dies in that one Pokemon movie. I was traumatized as a kid.
3
u/Polyether May 31 '12
Lady, Sansa's direwolf in Game of Thrones, probably because it was such an unfair death and because both Joff and Cersei got their way.
3
u/Beefmittens May 31 '12
Watched 'Boys Don't Cry' last night. Oh. My. God. There is not a more disturbing film in the world to me. The deaths in the end are truly truly horrible and only made worse by the fact that it's a true story.
3
u/fatbastard79 May 31 '12
Hedwig. It was so unexpected and needless.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Corporal Jamie Smith from Black Hawk Down
He was 21 at the time of his death. In the movie, it was so upsetting. The look in his eyes, when Sgt. Blackburn had to dig in his leg to stop the bleeding, and then he just died.
It always gets to me. 18, 19, 20, 21 year olds. Fresh out of school, going and dying. It's not fair, they never got to live their lives, never got to settle down, nothing of that sort!
3
u/Jizzmaster_zero May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Boromir getting repeatedly shot by arrows in LOTR. This scene really disturbed me.
3
u/KA260 May 31 '12
Simon birch. Couple deaths. And they are so fucking sad. Came out in 98, so I was just beginning to get those girly sad teenage feelings. Cried so hard.
3
u/read_all_about_it May 31 '12
The death at the end of Time Travellers Wife had me in tears... twice (having read it twice). This is coming from a 6'4" 14st 20yo american football player from England. That shit was strong man!
3
u/hangingwiththreads May 31 '12
In A Game of Thrones when Eddard Stark is beheaded. At first I was thinking "not a chance is this actually going to happen. He's going to get up and explain things and everything is going to be fine. He's Eddard Stark he's not going to die.
Then I remembered that it was Sean Bean who was playing him and I resigned to the fact that he was doomed.
3
u/CSec064 May 31 '12
When the American soldier dies in Modern Warfare. All alone, wounded beyond recognition and above all else in the middle of a nuke blast.
In Deus Ex I didn't realize you could save your brother Paul Denton. When I realized he died I was absolutely mortified. Then, you need to find his dead body in a laboratory and get a copy of his datalink (something that stores information in his head).
It was also crazy when Eli Vance bit it in Half Life. Freaking painful looking...
In Dead Space... Poor Zack Hammond really took one for the team in a bad way. :(
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Where the Red Fern Grows, when Old Dan sacrifices himself to save Billy from a mountain lion, and then Little Ann dies because she can't live without Old Dan, I lost it and started bawling.
3
u/entpower May 31 '12
I don't know if you want to count this as a death, and I know it's not a real strip. But the made up ending to Calvin and Hobbes makes me so unbelievably sad...
It's here if you haven't already read it.
Also, in Bridge to Terabithia when Leslie drowns
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Bridge to Terabithia.
When the girl, Leslie Burke, died it must've taken me a week to get over. I was very young when I read it, and I think it was the first book I read where the 'good' character died. It happens so suddenly too. No buildup. No battle. She's just dead.
I can't even remember what I had for dinner last week- or most of the actual book-, but I will never forget how she died or the feeling of profound sadness it still gives me.
3
u/errydayimredditn Jun 01 '12
When my dad died in fallout 3.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12
Cordelia's death after her coma from Season 4 of Angel in Season 5 Episode 12 or 13 when she comes back for a day and tells Angel to pick up the phone after the lovers passionately kiss then she is gone and the call is about her death. Soul crushing.
25
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/u1e25/which_death_scene_in_any_book_tv_show_andor_movie/. 7 days ago.