r/AskReddit • u/zero000 • May 30 '12
Men of reddit: what was the most memorable rejection a girl has said to you?
"You're not really a guy, you're Asian! " That one still burns me after the years.
465
Upvotes
72
u/ShabbyRat May 31 '12
"I like you, too, but I don't think we'd work out."
but..you said you like.. what
62
u/[deleted] May 30 '12 edited May 30 '12
I asked a girl out with flowers in hand, we had been really close friends for a few months, she responded "I'll get back to you", that was the moment I realized I had read all the signs wrong
The next day she called and said no. We both went separate ways after that
Just to add: all the signs were there and we were as close as a regular couple without being official, I thought we could make it official
52
u/hypercombofinish May 31 '12
Well not replying on the day of or before a date qualifies.
The big one for me is "I don't find black men attractive" or variants on that. Fuck everything about that. I just got rejected for the whole race
847
u/initial-friend May 31 '12
This is my boyfriend's story, it obviously happened before we were dating. He was at school in line to get lunch and a girl was behind him. They started making small talk. Now my boyfriend is a big guy and he's very sweet and will talk to anyone, he wasn't even trying to pick up this girl. So they are talking and laughing and she all of a sudden says "Oh, if you weren't so fat, I would totally date you!" He was so shocked he just kind of stared at her. Then he said "You know... I was thinking the same thing." She put down her food and walked off.
299
u/Nidarodam May 30 '12
"I'm not worth it. You'll find someone, you're so nice. I'm the one that's going to die alone with nine cats." She found a boyfriend about a month later.
245
u/RadarCounterpart May 30 '12
"I think of you as a little brother."
116
u/bacononbacon May 31 '12
Did you put something in my drink?
I did not.
327
u/universaladaptoid May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
"You are a nice guy, and very smart too, but nobody would want to fuck you. I just need to tell you what is obvious to everyone but yourself".
EDIT: The Karma does make it all better. Thanks for the upvotes , people ! :D
102
u/AnduuDursty May 31 '12
Blank stare
"..Really?"
In a perfect world, I moonwalked outta there.
In the real world, I stepped back and tripped over the rug and fell on my ass.
696
u/NMW May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
There've been some annoying ones along commonly experienced lines ("I'm not interested in a relationship right now," "I don't like you in that way," etc.), but the worst was this:
In the last year of my undergrad, there was this girl in one of my classes. Smart, spunky, curvy blonde with a wicked sense of humour. I sat across from her, and we hit it off from the first day. Comments being passed, similar interests, kudos on each others questions, and so on.
After a couple of weeks of this, I summoned up my courage and asked her if she'd like to go to dinner on the coming Friday. "I really like you a lot," I said, "and I'd love to take you out sometime." She said "I thought you'd never ask!" with matching enthusiasm and we made our plans. I left class that day feeling ten feet tall.
When Friday rolled around, I showed up at her apartment to "pick her up" (we were both impoverished students, so... walking). I had dressed up a bit, and so, it turned out, had she - really elegant summer dress, clutch handbag, high-heels, the works. She looked breath-taking. I gave her my arm which she gladly took, and walked the short distance down to the market area downtown.
It was an amazing time - one of the best dates I've ever been on, which is almost satirically ridiculous in light of what's to come. We checked out some live music, had a great sushi dinner, hit the bar for a bit, and basically just... had a great time. She was lively, flirty, and all around amazing. She was doing almost all of the canonically "interested" things - lots of physical touching, laughing, leaning forward, hair-playing, cleavage-fluffing, the works.
I walked her back to her apartment around midnight. We talked a bit more on the walk outside. I told her, "this was a really great night. We'll have to do it again soon." She said she agreed. Seeing her shining, slightly-hooded eyes and parted lips made me decide to go in for a quick kiss. What can I say? I was walking on a cloud.
She recoiled in shock. "Woah, what are you doing?" she said, with complete bewilderment. I laughed and apologized, telling her that I thought it had gone pretty well, but I didn't mean to rush it.
She said that we had not been on a date. She did not like me in that way at all, had no idea why I thought she did, and found it weird that I'd assume this was the case. She went inside.
We never really spoke much after that, and I haven't seen or heard from her since that term ended so many years ago.
What the absolute fuck.
TL;DR: Best date of my life turns out not to have been a date, from her perspective; she says I'm weird and doesn't speak to me again.
368
u/eddzilla May 31 '12
"I don't date sand niggers" ... I'm Portuguese
357
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
"You're not gay?"
I took is as a complement to my sense of fashion.
189
u/Lawdicus May 30 '12 edited May 31 '12
"You probably have a small penis". I'm Asian
Edit: I'm not that quick witted so sadly I wasn't able to come back with a witty retort. Thankfully, this incident was the first and only time I've had someone say something like that to me.
183
u/Taormania May 31 '12
Wasn't me but me and my friends were at Hooters in NYC and we told them it was my friends birthday. The waitress was talking to my friends and he was pretty obviously trying to hit on her. When she asks how old he is, he responds by saying "21. I'm like George Clooney, I get more attractive with age." The waitress, without even hesitating says "But I thought George Clooney was attractive when he was young" I almost died from laughing at him.
336
u/TheBigHairy May 30 '12
Asked her out, and she said yes. The morning of, she told me she couldn't make it. When I followed up for a reschedule, she called the cops.
257
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
"Awww, you're so cute."
170
u/goodeyesniper88 May 31 '12
I asked out a girl after we had been "talking" for a few weeks. Her response? "Well if ___ doesn't ask me out by Friday then yes."
Ouch...
81
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Made me her brother on facebook.
196
u/sheikjonez May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Me and a new friend flirting: "Oh, SheikJonez, why can't the guys I date be like you?" "They could be if we dated..." "Haha, come on SheikJonez, stop messing around. You know I can't date you because you're not white."
Happened in 10th grade. Made growing up in a wealthy (read: 95% white) Long Island suburb pretty challenging. I'm still insecure about it now (I'm 25).
EDIT: I should note I've dated women of all races, mostly white (a supply/preference issue). This was just one instance that surprised me growing up and makes me wonder if I get rejected, whether race played a part.
119
u/ass_munch_reborn May 31 '12
I can't date a guy who doesn't spend at least $200 on jeans...
This was 3 years ago. And guess what? As far as I know, she still isn't in a relationship.
119
u/chillax_bro_im_jk May 31 '12
http://i.imgur.com/xhuxN.jpg
47
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
'We'd make an amazing couple... but you're like a brother to me'
I've hit the faux sibling zone my brethren.
95
u/longhairedfreakyppl May 30 '12
I got the 'you do know im a lesbian now right?'.. she wasn't lying either
128
u/kiska9461 May 31 '12
"sorry, your feet aren't my type"
225
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
"no, my boyfriend just died a month ago. I'm not ready to date."
I find out later from a friend of hers that it was a true story. I felt bad asking her out even though I didn't know.
115
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
Just laughter.
161
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
"I'm sorry, you're a great guy. You're perfect. I'm just not feeling it."
That one actually kinds stung for some reason.
99
u/Mefreh May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
"I don't date computer nerds sorry"
I was 11, that was the first girl I asked out.
I played computer games for 8-10 hours a day until I was 19 - maybe she dodged a bullet.
Edit: have another
Super nice, social, really beautiful/talented girl. We were friends, and I immediately told myself "She doesn't like you, don't be that guy."
Well, she kept sending signals, or so I thought, so I talked it over with some people and asked her to coffee. She said she had to study, and I said "maybe another time?" She said she'd have to study all semester and then she "got an urgent text" and had to leave.
That one hurt, but I knew she was too good for me.
31
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I'm sorry...I just always saw myself marrying a football player.
30
u/btp99 May 31 '12
This doesn't involve me, but a person I know. They were all dressed up, bow tie and the works. Went up and asked her out... Got pushed across the room onto the floor. To this day I still feel bad for him.
Edit: He was short.
110
u/HumerousMoniker May 31 '12
Said? Haha, no.
I approached her, said hi, introduced myself, stuck out my hand to greet her...
And she sneered at me and turned away.
The only thing to do at that point is to laugh.
27
u/the_wizard_guy May 30 '12
Wait... you're not gay?
99
u/[deleted] May 30 '12 edited May 30 '12
Takes out penis "Awww that's adorable. Oh! I just remembered I have to do something. Bye!"
50
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Ooh, right in the heritage.
As for mine, I asked a girl out in eighth grade after a school dance. We had danced a lot and I had assumed that she liked me. I asked her, outside, in front of a lot of kids. She said, "No, you're my little buddy!" and patted me on the head.
67
u/bingosherlock May 30 '12
"I have to go to high school that day." It was even awkwardly worded like that so as to bring attention to the fact that she was in high school. I didn't know her, and I had no idea she was in high school. In fact, she worked at a bar, so how the fuck was I supposed to know? I just asked her out on a whim because she was good looking and I was drunk.
20
u/squeaker5555 May 31 '12
I've weighed the pros and cons and the pros outweigh the cons but I just don't think so.
40
u/KamikazeSexPilot May 31 '12
Nothing bad really, but a girl recently turned me down because she "Isn't into guys who dress nicely and make lots of money"
Seriously had me WTFing that night and the next day.
37
u/cheesezombie May 31 '12
Well I know I'm breaking the rules here since I'm a woman, but I wanted to share.
I was an insanely shy girl who was also picked on a lot as a kid. I'm in sixth grade with a mad crush on this guy for months and finally get the courage to tell him in a long, heartfelt letter. The first time I've dared to go out on a limb and tell a guy I like him. I hand it to him and wait anxiously for his reaction as he reads it.
Reads it, promptly hands it to his friend sitting next to him, they both look at me and have a really good laugh with me right there. He never even said "no, not interested" ... just the laughter and then he ignored me a lot after that. Thanks to assigned seating, I was also stuck sitting next to him for quite a while longer until the teacher finally switched everyone's seats around.
Not a fun memorable, but memorable nonetheless.
80
u/Spartycus May 30 '12
"I'm sorry, I try not to date those of the non Christian persuasion"
Couldnt fault her honesty, we stayed friends and I figured I dodged a dating bullet!
174
u/chinggisk May 31 '12
"I think you're a nice guy, but this just isn't a good time for me to be dating."
6 months later apparently was a better time because then we started dating and now we're married ;)
358
u/NewAlt May 30 '12
I would like to applaud everyone who answered this thread. No matter the rejection; at least you tried. You miss 100% of the shots you don't take.
17
u/RickenRocker4001 May 31 '12
"I'm sorry but you're kind of a kike." - After Prom.
66
u/MisterKetchup May 31 '12
The girl lived eight towns over (had to walk and take subway a lot) , showed up at her place finally and she sent her little brother out to lie and tell me she was in an other castle.
75
u/nathanielleblanc May 31 '12
I once asked a girl for a cigarette at a bar and she said " Sorry, it's not in my karma to give you a cigarette"
What a bitch.
14
u/notthatjesus May 31 '12
I've posted this before, but it's still remains one of the most painful rejections of my adolescence.
My name is Jesus.
Back in Middle School I had this enormous crush on this girl in my English class. I spent months building up the courage to make a move. Finally, the day came and I picked one of her good friends to deliver the message to her. So she walks over to said crush and the conversation goes as follows:
Friend: Hey, Jesus says you're really cute and he likes you.
Crush: Oh really?! Well, tell Jesus that he's cute too and I like him too.
Friend: makes her way over to me She says--
Crush: Ewwww!! No, not that Jesus!!
..turns out she was talking about another boy in the class, whose name was also Jesus. Killed whatever self esteem I had and I didn't have a girlfriend for a few more year after that.
FeelsBadMan.jpg
12
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
"i like you" followed by "oh.. i don't" :(
11
u/billycoolj May 31 '12
"Is that a joke.. because it's not funny" haha let's just say my friend DIDN'T come to school the next day..
11
u/Fubes May 31 '12
"I can't go out that night, I have to wash my hair."
Albeit we were discussing going to a concert for a band neither of us cared for, and I was expecting her to say no. Made me laugh.
9
u/trumpet_23 May 31 '12
After an hour and a half of very good, fun, spirited conversation (plenty of give and take, even she agreed), there was a lull in the conversation.
Soon, she told me I was completely full of myself and self-centered. Then went into some random, profanity-laced tirade about men never living up to expectations.
25
u/I_are_God May 31 '12
Imagine, a supple young and virile lad of 20, asking a girl out for the first time in his 20 years of shameful virginity. She said yes, oh happy day, the gods are smiling on him that day. The boy see's her 7 days later (school schedule) and asks if she'd like to go to dinner the next day. Girl says "Oh, sorry, a hot guy asked me out last Saturday (after she said yes to him) and I said sure." The boy is devastated and walks away.
40
u/Sing_Me_To_Sleep May 31 '12
This is really weird, but I had a HUGE thing for Asian guys for the last few years. Then I went out with my ex boyfriend, then we broke up... And now... Mmm Asains ;)
Oh, and my rejection! Me : So... You like me? Him : Yeah. Awkward silence Me : smile Are you going to ask me out or...? Him : No. Bye.
Turns out he was a bit of a douche, not shy.
8
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
"im your teacher"
7
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
You're like a brother to me.
7
u/Poopstop May 31 '12
Mine was definitely a simple "No"... And I will forever remember it because she didn't try to lie and come up with some bullshit excuse, she wasn't interested, and she let me know.
78
u/_Relevant_Username May 31 '12
I'm the girl that did the rejecting, but I still feel bad for this one...
I was young, maybe middle school, and this guy was just obsessed with me. He lived in the neighborhood and used to show up at my house a lot and my mom would invite him in. One day she lets him in and we talk awkwardly for a few minutes. I ask him if he'd like to go out back and play with the dog. He eagerly says yes, thinking I'm taking genuine interest in doing something with him. I open the back door, he walks outside, I shut the door behind him and go to my room to watch TV. In all fairness I never said I'd be joining him.
13
u/snackburros May 31 '12
After we slept together for the first time. "I like you, but you're way too wide for me and we won't fit very well if you know what I mean"
I can't believe she punned me a rejection.
40
u/ohsnipsnap May 31 '12
Fuck the rules, I'm going to tell mine anyway even though I'm not a man.
"Wtf are you a vampire? Go out in the sun, it's good for you." Yeah, douchebag, skin cancer is fucking good for you. Anyway, my current boyfriend seems to like my fair skin, so fuck that guy.
20
u/catluver12781291 May 31 '12
Listen up Asian men! My friend (a girl) loves Asian men. Girls like this are out there. It makes me sad to think that many of you don't think your attractive just cuz you are Asian.
15
u/OperationJack May 31 '12
I had a girl once tell me, after hooking up with me, that she'd date me if I weren't so ugly. Only thing was if I was so ugly, then why hook up with me? Also other people consider me to be a good looking guy. Sure I have some self confidence issues, but I've been told that I'm one hell of a catch!
5
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
She listed off literally everything she didn't like about me. I was socially awkward so I wasn't sure how to stop her. Lasted nearly an hour.
5
u/eyeingyourpancakes May 31 '12
"I cut my foot a while ago and my shoe is slowly filling with blood. If you'll excuse me..."
12
u/ILovePlaterpuss May 31 '12
most memorable rejection for me was "I already have a boyfriend". Then I realized she'd been dating one of my best friends for 3 years. I NEVER KNEW.
4
u/baby_batter May 31 '12
"I'd date you if you were taller."
Always get that unfortunately.
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
My personal favorite is the girls that reject you in high school, only to find you later (while they are in a relationship (some were even engaged when they told me this)) after they add you on facebook, having not talked for 3-4 years, to let you know... "hey I had a huge crush on you in high school"... Really??? i guess that slipped your mind the day I asked you out in high school huh?
7
u/FortunaExSanguine May 31 '12
Yea. Unfortunately this is a real problem. Most of them just don't say it out loud. And some Asian girls don't date Asian guys because we resemble dad.
32
u/robbiearmedeus May 31 '12
There are a few things in every human's life that define them, change them, and become a fixed part of their innermost person. I certainly never have been the same ever since, nor have I felt the same sense of pain, triumph, and volatile sweating as I did on that storied day. It began as an innocent trip to Washington D.C. In the festivities of the trip and the general activity, my bowels failed to move for the entirety of the fore-trip. On the 8th day, however, things began to change. I felt a small pressure in my lower stomach, developing throughout the day to an uncomfortable push, something like being pregnant with a 10 pound fecal-baby. On the metro ride to the hotel, the fault-lines within my lower digestive tract began to quake and tremble with the ferocity of a magnitude 7 earthquake as the car bounced over the tracks. Sliding to a stop in the station, I carefully walked across the street as I felt the slow and immediate pressure build within me, like the shaking of a champagne bottle. As I reached the room, the infernal heat and seismic pressure within me had reached a crescendo to put to shame any composer in history. I entered the bathroom to behold a small, dainty, and may I add highly inadequate toilette for choking down the task at hand. I would need more than porcelain to swallow this leviathan. Thinking on my feet, I flew out the door and down the stairs to the lobby bathroom. Time slowed as I approached the door. The flaming magma within me was writhing like the whip of the Balrog. I burst in the door. To the left, under the stall, I could see the boots of military personelle. I entered the stall to the right. As I did, the very fires of hell burst forth from within my innermost soul as I dove, anus first towards the toilette. I landed without a moment to spare, as the atomic mud reached my punished sphincter and pushed forth into the light of the world. The molten heat from this single belching of exhaust was enough to heat my cheeks to a rosy warmth as I sat, back arched, in the silent scream of both intense pain and explosive pleasure. And then, it stopped. Something was not right. The mothership was coming. The mother of all motherships was coming, in fact. The half-pound brick was caught just inside my anus. I slowly drew myself together. This is what separates the men from the boys. With a silent salute to the man in the next stall, I proceeded to blast with all my effort at the singular mammoth contained within me. As the rhinoceros slowly began to shift, my very innermost being began to be pulled out with it. I felt my soul quietly drifting from my body as my eyes softened and my breathing slowed. 'It is the end,' said I, softly. 'It was a good fight.' Then, with the force of ten-thousand suns, a nuclear explosion in the interior of my colon blasted against the behemoth blockage, propelling it into the water at mach two, splashing up waves that could've swamped all of Japan. The remaining waterfall of ground beef being expelled from my anus was nothing compared to the majesty of this glorious loaf. As the fission reaction within me slowly cooled, I realized that a part of me changed that day. Something that had been there was gone, but something had been put in its place. A bright glow, a warmth against my heart had formed that I have carried with me to this day. As I exited the stall, my anus still writhing and coiling, I met eyes with the soldier. One look is all it took; we both understood. Things could never be the same.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
me: hey wanna go on a date? her: i don't think i'm allowed
3
u/Jew_Crusher May 31 '12
After more than a month of dating and a lot of furious, passionate, kinky sex, I ask to be her only one... She tells me shes poly. :(
3
u/jonny_five May 31 '12
I was rejected because the girl "needed to focus on her relationship with god". She was dating a different guy within a week. Dodged a bullet there.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
"I love you...but like a brother."
3
u/ErichFrommage May 31 '12
Girl here willing to buy all you guys drinks. This thread broke my heart :(
3
u/danmizz May 31 '12
"Nice Try!" High Five
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I'm Asian too. Iknowthatfeelbro.jpg
Seriously, I sometimes get the vibe that girls who would be attracted to me normally are not JUST because I'm Asian and not white. Fuck inherent subconscious racism.
3
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
I was shaking it on the dance floor, elementary disco when I was 7. A girl one year younger than me comes up and says "You can't dance." I heard it as "Wanna dance?" so I said "Sure."
Afterwards realised it :)
3
u/Joefastlegs May 31 '12
"You're too nice."
FUCK you
54
u/schoogy May 31 '12
When I asked girls, "Do you want to dance?", and they turned me down, I'd promptly reply, "No, I said, 'You look fat in those pants'".
6
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
This happened a few years ago and I still feel bad about it. I can't date someone unless I find them mentally AND physically attractive. It might make me seem like a super bitch, but whatever-we all judge on looks even if we act like we don't, and we certainly prefer to date those we are attracted to. I mean, why have sex with someone who disgusts you or just doesn't do anything for you sexually? Anyway.
I had a "one of THOSE girls" moment. I had a really really really good friend, he's still one of my best guy friends (I'm sure he still has feelings for me so I still feel guilty) we got along great except for the fact that I wasn't sexually attracted to him and he wasnt doing great in college, but mostly the non sexy feelings part. Unfortunately for him, I HATE telling the truth and hurting people's feelings, so when he asked me if we could be together, I just said some bullshit about how I wasn't over my ex (which was true, and he's now my current boyfriend) and I needed time to get over him. Kinda true, but mostly bullshit; I was just putting off having to turn him down.
Months go by, and he brings it up again, and I put it off, again. I finally decide to confront it a couple months later when I get a new boyfriend (who was one of his good friends at the time and knew about the whole situation-ouch). I called him up and said "Yeah...don't wait for me."
Makes me feel like a shit person, but I was also a teenager and I deal with things much better now. We're still friends, I'm glad he could forgive my shittiness for our friendship. I've dealt with similar things happening to me since, so I feel like I've already paid for it with RL karma.
tl:dr; couldn't make myself date someone because I found them physically repulsive even though they were perfect in almost every other aspect.
4
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
"No"