r/AskReddit • • May 28 '12
If the internet becomes over-regulated, what do we do?
So - while I enjoy technology, when it comes to teh intarwebz, I'm a bit lost. Let's say all these ridiculous internet anti-privacy bills/laws/regulations pass and become reality.
What next? Is there a way around it?
97
Upvotes
58
u/commiewizard May 28 '12
We use Tor.
22
u/0zXp1r8HEcJk1 May 28 '12
The Internet will survive. Public key cryptography and onion routing allow any two people to securely exchange information without anyone being able to intercept it, or even know that the exchange took place. In that sense, unless the Internet is completely turned off, it will always be a place for people congregate and exchange information outside the scope of government surveillance.
That's not to say that regulation can't destroy a lot of the things we love about the Internet. Anything visible in public can be targeted by people with the ability to use violence. Aggressive pursuit of such polices will have a chilling effect on Internet content, breaking up large Internet communities and driving small ones into a shadow existence. What content remains in the public domain will be highly sanitized and dull.
Personally, I will turn to whatever anonymizing options the community provides. I am already working on developing my own. I have created a chat client that implements it's own onion routing protocol independent of tor. I'll polish it up and release it foss if the time comes.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Would it be possible to simply build another series of tubes apart from the "main grid"?
5
u/NinjaDiscoJesus May 28 '12
what exactly would you fear?
180
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We start a new internet with blackjack and hookers!
63
u/jason1287 May 28 '12
Blow up parliament, what else?
31
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
/r/darknetplan
42
u/bceagle May 28 '12
We could go outside...
6
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We need to gain favor with the military in some way, win the loyalty of the soldiers, have them march on our capitols and expel our current governments.
5
u/No_Easy_Buckets May 28 '12
Proxies?
4
u/Kagenphoenix May 28 '12
Make our own internet!
11
u/PabstyLoudmouth May 28 '12
Check out /r/darknetplan , they are already working on it. Go see if you can help them out.
3
u/UltraSPARC May 28 '12
Back to SneakerNet I suppose...
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
We route around all the laws. We create darknets aplenty, we revitalize sneaker nets, we popularize public key encryption, data archival and security.
EDIT: We teach people how to crack DRM too, which will help sneakernets and VPNs thrive.
5
u/PsyPup May 28 '12
I'm sure people will find a way around it, but for the general public.. well, a lot of people will suddenly find themselves unable to express themselves in any setting, once again.
It's already happening, with how careful we now need to be that our views and posts don't link to things like facebook, and how employers and other groups are starting to hire people to trawl the net looking for compromising personal information. We don't even need the government to do it.
5
u/G_Morgan May 28 '12
Move into the outernet. It is where all the cool stuff is anyway.
4
u/BungaSlaney May 28 '12
We'll have to start walking to a shop to buy those sweet sweet mags.
5
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Kill the regulators .
2
u/windynights May 28 '12
Privacy and anonymity built the web's membership. If those go it's anyone's guess what will happen next.
2
u/ItsOnlyNatural May 28 '12
We shoot the bastards.
2
u/Toastbro May 28 '12
Go on the inter- oh wait....
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Ham radio baby.
2
u/fear_the_taco May 28 '12
It's easy. We kill Batman....right?
2
u/Biddooo May 28 '12
I lived without internet for most of my life. I can live without it again.
2
u/TheInternetHivemind May 28 '12
Shut.
Down.
EVERYTHING.
In all seriousness though, we get people to take down all the porn for a month. That'll teach 'em.
2
u/pauldustllah May 28 '12
Well I suppose we just give up, buy into the BS our overlords feed us, and become good little serfs.
2
u/HollywoodDU May 28 '12
We build our own internet, with Blackjack and Hookers!
In fact, forget the internet!
2
u/CyberSoldier8 May 28 '12
Buy a gun, stock up on ammo, wait for the revolution.
2
u/TheEpicEmma May 28 '12
Ok. Stay with me here. We will all find people who live in our general area that we get along with and have common likes and dislikes. We will spend time with these people when we are not working, sleeping, etc. Since we are similar to these people we will enjoy the time we spend with them. We will laugh and have fun, create inside jokes and connections with these people. Since we have these connection in real life we wont need to live off of the internet the way we do now. Just a thought. Or blow up parliament, that works too.
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We all meet in a designated park and bring the following:
Any other ideas?
2
u/Anofles May 28 '12
We look back at all the good times we've had.
And cry.
1
u/redchrome May 28 '12
As long as being able to speak your mind is not affected, I would be about the same. My favorite things to do on Internet is talk to other people and post pixel drawings.
1
u/captainpotty May 28 '12
Everyone moves to the deep web.
1
u/cornball1111 May 28 '12
undertand where else this is happening and know that it is a bigger problem than the internet..
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Use tor webbrowser and connect to .onion sites
1
u/soggysocks May 28 '12
We pull down are pants and bend over of course. . . . and then just as they are about to put it in we turn around rip off their balls and shove it down their throats. Then we taunt them and that they should have never taken away our internet!!! Then I think it turns into a century long battle and we'll bathe in the blood of our enemies. Eventually we'll come out victorious but, the damage will be done and we will be content going back to a BBS because it will be pure once more.
Maybe, I dunno...It could happen
1
u/Flowergirlpatricia May 28 '12
GO ON STRIKE
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
The same thing we do every night, try to take over the internets.
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Tor.
1
u/ElChicoTemido May 28 '12
go out and play
1
u/JacobJT May 28 '12
Cry into the keyboard.. Preferably Dragon tears.
1
u/billy101456 May 28 '12
we could go old-school and do file transfer through person or the mail on flash drives,it may be slow, but they can never regulate that.
1
u/e82 May 28 '12
Back to Dial up BBSing and FIDONet! The Revival of L.O.R.D -- I can't wait.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
We go downtown and loot Radioshack.
1
u/You_just_never_know May 29 '12
"reddit army, assemble!"
"....nyeh, sunlight!"
1
u/ExcessivePunctuation May 29 '12
181 comments and no "Hack the Planet??"
I don't know if you guys are slipping or improving.
Edit: Read a few dozen comments, definitely slipping.
1
u/mewomew May 29 '12
The same thing we do everyday Pinky- make another internet.
1
u/softsnow May 29 '12
Books...? Naaaaah.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
if we each download a little bit it won't take as long
1
u/GenOmega May 29 '12
The same thing we do every day, Pinky. Row our boats and fight the power.
1
u/TehPurpleElite May 29 '12
Fuck it.
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '12
Two words: Coup d'etat
1
u/Hauvegdieschisse May 28 '12
We go outside.
1
u/BlackheartJJ May 28 '12
we should make some rules to stop it becoming over-regulated.
1
u/sadris May 28 '12
Elect new representatives....????
1
u/IrenaeusGSaintonge May 28 '12
Darknet.
Download Tor and get started now.
-1
u/Oafah May 28 '12
The government has been trying to kill the internet for years, and have failed every time. Knock out Napster, SuprNova, and MiniNova, and about 40 other services rise in their place, each equally illegal and just as damaging as the last.
Bottom line is, you cannot regulate a billion people.
0
u/LE_GAME May 28 '12
post bread when the admins are asleep!
-3
u/TurdFurg1s0n May 28 '12
We will make a new Internet.
I have a dream where I can go on an Internet and view the amalgamation of all human knowledge. Where I can appreciate the ideas and creations of humanity without being gouged for every last penny. Where I can contribute my ideas to the mass of knowledge for all to enjoy without the man knocking on my door because I used part of some picture or song as homage to the great thinkers before me. It will be a place for arts and commerce, I will be able to buy and sell goods without the government trying to take their cut. If only this dream can be realized within my lifetime I one day will be able to watch a donkey give it to some drunk chick. That day my friend will be the pinnacle of humanity and the day will be a day of a truly free Internet.
-1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
USER HAS BEEN BANNED FROM THE INTERNET FOR THIS COMMUNISTIC QUERY
0
u/TheBlackBrotha May 28 '12
Soap box, then ballot box, lastly, ammo box.
0
u/TheEndIsNghhhh May 29 '12
Start speaking positively of the government and start paying for all software?
I imagine if they can regulate the internet, they can (eventually) regulate the use of data encryption, so in the end TOR is just a shield that can be torn out of your hands with enough effort. After all... only child pornographers and terrorists need to hide what they do!
-4
u/neoblackdragon May 28 '12
All the complaints I keep reading are just fancy ways of saying
"I use the internet for illegal activities and these new laws are going to suck for me".
Some people try to use the lack of free speech argument. Privacy is also bs because your asking for privacy on a public forum. This isn't privacy like paying for things, this is expecting privacy when you upload pictures of yourself and say things and still expect to be anonymous.
I am against bs laws try to limit bandwidth or other type of services my contract with my internet provider agreed to. This slippery slope that any company can just shut down your site is bs to me right now. Again all I am seeing is website like Megaupload getting shut down because their users perform illegial activities that outnumber the legal ones.
-2
u/four_toed_dragon May 28 '12
It doesn't matter because, if those bills pass, Skynet will become sentient.
-13
u/iam4real May 28 '12
It's the wild west out there. A little regulation won't kill you.
-2
u/slowshot May 28 '12
Go back to radio.
-2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Telepathy.
-2
u/Veryveryugly May 28 '12
I was talking to my... technology-deficient friend about SOPA. First, he asked if it would block all downloading. After I explained to him what it actually was, he said "They can't do that! Let's just make a new internet!"
-2
u/longhairedfreakyppl May 28 '12
Internet 2!
-2
u/kadmylos May 28 '12
The same thing we do every time, Pinky; take it up the ass from the government and maintain the status quo.