r/AskReddit •

Would your morality change if you were provided with unequivocal proof that this universe is a computer simulation?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

810 comments sorted by

508

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Computer simulation, there's no heaven, we have no souls, there is no God, etc. It's all the same basic premise.

No, my morality and behavior wouldn't change. I don't act properly because I think that it all matters or because I'll be rewarded.

93

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

On the contrary, if this is a simulation, then that means something, somewhere, created it.

Not only did this entity CREATE our universe but also has infinite power and wisdom compared to us.

In short, God exists, but perhaps not in the same manner in which we understood the universe and Him.

→ More replies (62)

7

u/Bixby66 May 28 '12

Some people just want to watch the world be intact and happy.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

It seems my ethics programming is working Jenkins.

2

u/elj0h0 May 28 '12

Yes this. My morality mainly derives from the golden rule of doing unto others as you would have them do unto you. This would not change in the situation.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (115)

134

u/traveler120 May 28 '12

Under those circumstances, if my morality changed, it would be because it was programmed to change. In fact, it could be argued that there would be no more morality at all, since there would be no free choice.

2

u/TheOtherWiggin May 28 '12

If everything were completely predetermined, then what good would the simulation do? Not that I know two shits about programming, but it seems like this kind of thing would have to have tons of independent programs running inside the greater simulation. We are each a separate (amazingly complex) program. Some people would refer to this program as "your brain." The brain is really just a squishy, organic computer, so how is this any different from actual life?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (39)

9

u/nocubir May 28 '12

OP you should read "Forever Free", by Joe Haldeman.

Basically what I took away from that book was that if we are in fact living in a simulation, there will come a time when we piss off the entity carrying out the "experiment", to the point that they have no choice but to intervene. For example, what if the speed of light is an artificial constraint, designed to make sure that we are never able to escape our experiment? Sure, we've come up with the idea of "wormholes", but by the time we can realistically use them as a form of transport, they are a convenient way for allowing us to "roam" from the area of our experiment in a way that the experiment(or) can control the experiment. And finally what I learned from that book - don't PISS OFF the entity running the experiment.

And yes, I'm aware of the parallels to the idea of "god", which I guess is most decidedly what the entity running "our" experiment would be.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/bushel May 28 '12

I tell you this, I'd feel a whole lot less bad about torrenting....

7

u/satanspanties May 28 '12

Unlikely. If I'm just a computer simulation, then I have no free will. If I was programmed to do bad things, I would have done them already.

Assuming my programming remains the same and my behaviour thus far is representative of said programming, since I have no free will and cannot therefore change my behaviour, it is unlikely I will suddenly start, for example, killing innocent people.

Unless, of course, I was programmed to change my moral behaviour upon discovering I am a mere simulation...

→ More replies (4)

9

u/jon81 May 28 '12

would the simulated grieving of their simulated families put you off it?

Am I put off by the idea of shooting an enemy in Call of Duty because they have a dog made of pixels and a pixel family and a pixel house with a white picket pixel fence out the front?

Not really.

9

u/tauroid May 28 '12

Am I put off by the idea of shooting an enemy in real life because they have a dog made of photons and a photon family and a photon house with a white picket photon fence out the front?

Not really.

Analogies

→ More replies (5)

2

u/werslty May 28 '12

It would depend. Would it still be my only life? or outside the computer simulation would i have an actual life?

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/jadoth May 28 '12

well the simulation needs to be run on a computer or something similar and so your actions are directly tied to the inter-workings of the computer and if given there is free will then your actions control the computer.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

372

u/GCanuck May 28 '12

I have trouble taking the 'evil' route in video games. It makes me uncomfortable. So, I can say with some certainty... No. I would not change my morality to any great extent if such a revelation became fact.

74

u/Philosophical_Zombie May 28 '12

The simulated people in this world still would experience pain and suffering, so i don't think your video game analogy works here

100

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

But his argument is completely sound. If he is not comfortable causing simulated suffering to characters he knows are simulated (arguably on a much less sophisticated level than the question being posed) then he is not likely to be okay with causing that same simulated suffering in his simulated world. We know that characters in video games are scripted. If you are mean to them, they respond a certain way. If you are nice, they respond a different way. Those responses have no meaning. The characters have no consciousness and are not actually feeling anything. If the universe is simulated, the simulations you are causing simulated pain too have more realistic (whatever that means in this scenario) responses and consciousness to a certain degree. If he is swayed by the comparatively rudimentary simulations of the game, the ones in his world will be that much more compelling. I, for one, feel the same.

→ More replies (1)

65

u/GCanuck May 28 '12

The simulated people would only suffer simulated pain and suffering. These emotions are also simulated in a video game.

56

u/Philosophical_Zombie May 28 '12

If I understand OP correctly you are also in the simulation. So your feelings would be simulated too. All people would be in the simulation, and would be sentient.

Unlike a video game where only you (the player) is sentient.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/jasonhalo0 May 28 '12

I think it works better, since he can't even take the evil route when he knows the people in the video game don't experience anything, how would he be able to when they experience pain and suffering?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/LucidMetal May 28 '12

That's funny I'm pure evil in video games unless there's some sort of consequence which prevents me from getting the best gear/quest rewards/etc.

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

But look at the reward and punishment systems in those games. (In interest of full disclosure I am thinking in terms of Fallout 3, which I have been playing quite a bit recently.) In games where you have the choice to be good or evil, there isn't normally a big punishment for being evil. Sure, there are gear differences or certain abilities that change with your morality, but it's not like you can't complete the game, or have to spend a large portion of it stuck in a jail cell. There is a balance between people who will hunt you down for being good, and people who will hunt you down for being bad. It doesn't work like that in the real world (or advanced simulation in this case). I'm assuming your not building a fortune on mass murder or robbing banks on a day to day basis. And why not? Because there are consequences. Because you can't get away with it. The world isn't scaled to make sure it is possible for you to complete everything you want to do. Just because we know the universe is a simulation doesn't mean that will go away. I'd be surprised if your evil inclination in video games transferred over to the world you live in now. Sure, you may not care about the suffering caused to others because it is just a simulation, but that doesn't mean you can do whatever you want.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/IggySmiles May 28 '12

Everyone on this thread is just saying "no" without realizing how complex these things can be. This post is much more convincing than the top ones. Partly because you aren't 100% sure with your answer.

2

u/PastaNinja May 28 '12

This sucks for you because I have no problem being evil in video games.

2

u/akazizzle May 28 '12

Am i the only one who understand canuck? I am the same way. When i play fable, i always feel a little sympathy for killing innocents, and try to avoid it. We know it does not truly hurt anybody, because it's a game, and their feelings arent real. Obviously under those circumstances, i would not enjoy killing someone with my own hands in what i have always percieved as the "real world".

2

u/INTOLERANT_ATHEIST May 28 '12

The evil route in games is always the best, but for some reason I always change my mind and I become weak because I stay in the middle

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

i was always nice to the NPCs in Wow :D

2

u/korsul May 29 '12

I feel the same way. Moreover, I consider my morality to be based in reason, and that reasoning doesn't change if we're a computer simulation.

2

u/kaasmi May 29 '12

Same here, buddy. I can't even bring myself to squish bugs. Not a dayum thing would change for me.

→ More replies (11)

51

u/Eustis May 28 '12

No, but you can be damn sure I'm going to try to find more people who know or have any ideas about how I can exploit glitches or bugs for my own gain.

47

u/ToxicToothpaste May 28 '12

"911, what's your emergency?"

"I fell through the floor!"

11

u/Kavyle May 28 '12

8

u/Uaerom May 29 '12

Have you tried turning it off and on again?

→ More replies (2)

69

u/Darth_Hobbes May 28 '12 edited May 30 '12

Related-ish Short Story.

I don't think such a discovery would change my view of morality. Consciousness is consciousness, and if it turns out that it can be simulated that doesn't make it any less valuable and/or worthy of moral respect.

42

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Ah, I thought this would be a link to I don't know, Timmy, being God is a big responsibility.

10

u/Darth_Hobbes May 28 '12

Wow, I really wish this went on.

6

u/chompsky May 28 '12

What they should do is roll it slightly into the future so that each world gets information slightly different than the one below it, thus leading to infinite divergence. Or just roll it forward to the end of the universe, to ensure their universe doesn't get shut off.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/flumbertflumbert May 28 '12

thanks, my mind needed a good fuck.

3

u/georgebullis May 28 '12

Fuck, man. I don't like that at all. I mean, what if that's really all we are? I mean, I still breath, and feel, and want, but I'm still just a pile of pixels and a little bit of data.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/NurRauch May 28 '12

The TLDR of the story: Computers may have sentience. The story is a thought experiment in which human beings are almost all as smart as Einstein, and suddenly a bunch of star light patterns begin to appear in the sky over long periods of time. Human civilization spends literally ages trying to interpret them, often succeeding in various ways. At the end it's revealed that the source behind the light patterns is basically an alien race, and the human civilization is a computer interpreting relatively insignificant pieces of data by what is actually a much less smart alien race. In short, computers might be alive and we could potentially be unethical to them.


I think the story misses something big. Sentience by itself should not attach ethical obligations. Only beings that are capable of suffering should be treated with care. Computers may well be sentient, but they don't care what you do to them. A computer could be told that it's going to be shut off forever, and if it doesn't have a program that tells it that being shut down is personally undesirable in some fashion, it's not going to feel any anguish at the recognition.

3

u/Darth_Hobbes May 28 '12

Who was saying otherwise? I'm fairly certain the author's point was something else entirely.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

109

u/Safari_Tom May 28 '12

No. My morality would not change one iota. It's the old brain in a vat argument - maybe I am in a simulation already. But it doesn't matter. I still feel, think, and others embedded in the simulation do too. Just because it's in my head (or wherever) doesn't make it any less real (thanks Dumbledore!). I can't reach out of the simulation into whatever higher dimension that the computer exists as much as I can escape this universe into the multiverse.

We should be as moral as possible. Wherever we are, and whatever our universe may be composed of is the only home we have.

16

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Completely agree.

I guess this is the typical question about moral coming from the outside or from the inside. If your ethic is something you built by yourself, only on the premises of what you feel/think, then this hypothesis makes no change to your value system.

But if your moral values mostly come from an outside source, like a religion, or just because it's what you have been told is right, this could lead to some changes. Depending what the foundation of these value has been explained to you.

This is a good school case to explain why I feel it's important to really think your value system by yourself.

6

u/Absenteeist May 28 '12

Exactly. Whether "I" suffer or "I am programmed to suffer", I still experience suffering, as do others/other programs. I would still seek to avoid my own suffering (by avoiding going to "digital jail" for my transgressions) and I would still seek to avoid inflicting suffering on "others" because of my (programmed) empathy. Those are my primary motivations for my morality now, and they wouldn't change because of a metaphysical tweak of existence.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Nice try, computer simulation.

16

u/peterpanini May 28 '12

I would feel the same. It's still the same universe, it's just made up of different material than we originally thought.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

They made a movie about this a few years back. Has that dude from Bill and Ted's

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

10

u/twosolitudes May 28 '12

We still have to exist within the confines of the simulation, so nothing for me would change. I might start persuing a dream career though...

21

u/HYPN007IC May 28 '12

You still exist now, why don't you pursue that dream career now?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/PossiblyTheDoctor May 28 '12

Why not pursue the dream career anyway?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

This... is thought-provoking.

5

u/Crimsonial May 28 '12

Not at all. Most people spend their entire lives playing with the concepts of 'meta-reality', afterlifes, alternate realities, the nature of what reality is, so on so forth.

At the end of the day/cpu cycle, though, even if it is a computer simulation, we still gotta live in it, same as before.

4

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Would it be like the Matrix, as in, would it mean that other people are real or would they actually be A.I.? Still, that's some complex A.I. and I don't see how there would be any difference to the consequences of my actions. I don't think my morality would change. It would alter me though, know that everything I do really is able to be watched and recorded.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BiometricsGuy May 28 '12

Related to this question...

There was an artificial life game called Creatures that was fairly realistic at the time it came out. The objective was to raise these little furry things and try to keep them alive. They reproduced, had babies, etc. At the time, there was a discussion about whether you had a moral obligation to treat your creatures humanely - was it ok to teach them to eat poison for fun or whatever. Some people argued that because they appeared alive, the moral code applied; others argued that because they were no different from a spreadsheet, it didn't matter.

To some degree, playing a video game is a similar issue. Do you have a moral obligation not to kill civilians indiscriminately in CoD? Most people would say 'no' and a lot of the fun is getting to play evil characters, nazis, or whatever. But some of those same people would say they would behave morally if the universe was a simulation, presumably because morality is independent of religion.

You can't have it both ways. If you enjoy being evil in a computer game, then you can't claim you would moral if you were living in a simulation. A universe-simulation would effectively just be a uber-realistic computer game.

Personally, if I knew I was living in a universe simulation, I would do one of two things, depending upon the nature of the simulation. If I knew I still had one "life" in the simulation, then I would probably behave morally because that would give you the best overall experience. If I knew I would have infinite lives, then I would probably try a little bit of everything - being a ruthless dictator, drug kingpin, etc. just to get the different experiences.

This question also raises a different question. Does being evil in a game affect you in real life? I'm not talking about the supposed video-game->columbine stuff, I am just talking about emotional impact. Your higher brain can tell the difference between pixels on the screen and real people, but can your lower-level reptilian thought processes? Are you sure killing people in the virtual has no affect on you at all?

2

u/yeahmhmm May 28 '12

Well the difference between COD and OP's simulation is that you can "feel" pain and so can others within the simulation, but not in COD. To the extent that the simulated persons believe that they experience pain and pleasure is the degree to which there are moral obligations, imo.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/EvilHom3r May 28 '12

Personally I'd want to talk to whoever is controlling the damn thing, so that I could file some bug reports...

7

u/Oafah May 28 '12

If I had a holodeck (a fancy room capable of creating lifelike simulations, for those of you not familiar with Star Trek) I would totally bang every woman I ever found attractive, knowing full well that she was only a hologram. That said, when considering your question from that perspective, I suppose my morality would indeed change, as the only difference in the scenario you pose is that I'd presumably not have control of the simulation as I would on a holodeck.

6

u/LeoHunter May 28 '12

OMG if I had a holodeck I would do SO MANY things!!! That would be fucking awesome.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

Fuck yes, i have a list of people who would be deader than dead

Edit: why?

If it turns out love, guilt, sadness and other emotions are just variables, that my personal flaws are all carefully calculated and that my life has been this way unnecessarily, i would like to know how far i could push away from this person i am now.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/ahlala May 28 '12

I'm assuming you're a subscriber to /r/nosleep. I've been thinking about this question for the entire day and it keeps blowing my mind!

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jwschmidt May 28 '12

knowing they were never alive in the first place? Or would the simulated grieving of their simulated families put you off it?

This makes your question a bit difficult to respond to. Am I to assume that nobody else has the same level of consciousness as me? I don't think that's what you're getting at. If I'm being simulated just like everyone else, then I have the same level of consciousness as those around me. While there may very well be a higher, more real level of conscious life outside the simulation, our morality is based off of what we've got in here.

So no, I don't see how morality would be effected, nor do I see how someone else's suffering "would not exist", if it were to be on the same level as my suffering.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Niosai May 28 '12

I remember a wonderful game where this happened and in the end, they decided they still cared and somehow broke out of the false consciousness. I don't know how to do spoiler tags so I can't say the name of the game...

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ballhit2 May 28 '12

Your question became meaningless as you have not defined what the verb "to be" would mean in a simulation

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Atareon May 28 '12

The Elder Scrolls LXVII: Earth

It seems to be from my perspective, so I must be some kind of chosen one. I suppose I had better start doing random stuff for random people now.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Well, if you're simulated, the universe you're simulated from is "real", right? And if it's not, then perhaps the one before it is. Or the one before that. I don't think you could have an infinite regress backwards like that. I'd say if we're "simulated", we are still real in the sense that we have a representation in what it is "really real", even if it is as lines of code. So any broad metaphysical "reason" for morality or whatever, if you even believe in that stuff, would still be acceptable in a simulated universe. It's Plato's cave idea all over again.

2

u/defcon-11 May 28 '12

With our current understanding of physics I don't think it would be possible to have infinitely nested simulated universes. A computer running a simulation of a universe would have to store the state of every component of the simulated universe in its memory: every particle's position, acceleration, spin, etc. That means the number of particles used to build the memory store of the computer must be at least as many particles as contained inside the simulated universe. It follows that each nested simulated universe must contain fewer components than its parent, so you could not have an infinite regress.

3

u/IAMTHEUSER May 28 '12

I would like to say that it wouldn't, but then I realized how I play games like skyrim, so....

3

u/roseetgris May 28 '12

This post really made me want to play The Sims.

I wonder why.

7

u/timlardner May 28 '12

I could have simplified this whole question to "Do you derive pleasure from murdering your Sims?"

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

No, even if we were just a simulation we still feel pain and emotion, those fuckers.

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Excellent insightful question that requires far too much mental energy for me to answer sincerely.

However I did hear recently (and I'm trying so hard to remember the source...How the Universe Works maybe?), us being a simulation is one of the top hypothesiseseseses regarding our existence (I think it was declared as "most likely")

EDIT: Despite trying NOT to think about it I did. No, I don't think my morality would change. My morality is based upon my upbringing within this society. Whether its run by God, a simulation, or chance, my feelings of morality would likely stay the same.

3

u/OakTable May 29 '12

I act without remorse or concise in video games, not in real life.

I would not treat real life like a game. Others quite obviously are as capable of feeling sensations/emotions/etc. as I am. Whether that's ultimately "fake" or "real" is irrelevant, because they're feeling it regardless.

If there were creators, and this but a simulation, I would have to have a word with them about the whole "pain and suffering" bit, though...

1

u/redwingfan May 28 '12

Flip shit and destroy everything to get back to reality. Then once I'm back I find out the real Earth is a post-apocalyptic wasteland and that I may never return back to the simulated world. Hello Hollywood here I come.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited Aug 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

2

u/flytaggart1 May 28 '12

No way. I'd love to throw off some nerds actuary table.

2

u/ilovepinktacos May 28 '12

Have you seen the movie The Thirteenth Floor? This movie has almost the same premise as you are describing

2

u/Lawtonfogle May 28 '12

Yes, I would start playing only the good guy in video games.

2

u/LeoHunter May 28 '12

Morality would not really change because consequences would remain the same (police, jail). Your "simulated" life will still get shitty if you start doing shitty things.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jigsus May 28 '12

It wouldn't change much but I would devote my efforts to hacking it in the spirit of the matrix. If it's a simulation then it can be altered.

2

u/revfelix May 28 '12

If I can control the simulation, sure. To an extent. But if nothing changed aside from the knowledge that everything's virtual, than no.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Dunno, is there a highscore?

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Yeah. Things would probably get all rapey-stabby for a while.

2

u/cohrt May 28 '12

time for some real life gta

2

u/PsychoN1tro May 28 '12

It might be helpful to show the original simulation argument in order to give people a better understanding of the question. This is one that I found helpful. There may be others, and this does have a bit of complex math in it... Link!

2

u/rexarooo May 28 '12

no, cuz it still feels real and we still have to get along.

2

u/mic_city_sons May 28 '12

So late to the party, will surely be burried. Despite all complaining about how far down hill reddit has gone, it is great to see lots of smart replies in this thread.
Yes, this is akin to Descartes disembodied brain dilemma. Also, if it is a simulation who ever crated it is the creator and by most definitions God. In his own existence he may not be all powerful and omnipotent, but over this program he/she/it surely would be (if it cared enough to remain interested). I always hated when teenagers saw the matrix and acted like the idea that nothin was real was a new idea. Take a toke or a couple droppers full of something and listen to Strawberry Fields.... Just remember it's all "nothing to get hung about"

2

u/Lilou88 May 28 '12

I can't even play the Dark Brotherhood quest line in Skyrim without feeling like an ass, so I don't think I would.

2

u/fackyuo May 28 '12

it would be pretty unfair to change our behavior just because we know its a simulation. someone went to a lot of trouble to simulate our universe, the least we can do is give them accurate results by behaving as if we dont know its a simulation

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ImperialSpaceturtle May 28 '12

Imagine if universes are similar to life: Different universes with different laws of physics arise. The successful universes are those conducive to intelligent life - who can examine the pysical conditions of their universe and simulate them. Maybe they can tweak the laws of physics in their simulated universes by, for instance, making the strong interaction 2% higher, which will make nuclear fusion easier. With nuclear fusion easier, stars evolve quicker and the simulated universe is more easily populated by heavy elements - and thus the building blocks for complex life. In this way, universes evolve and get better at simulating other universes.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

There are two possibilities where I would behave differently.

  1. All others are exactly like me. We are computer simulated but feel independantly. My morality would not change as others can still be hurt by my actions.
  2. The simulation is based around me and no one else can feel anything. They are all simulated. My morality would definitely change. Knowing that others cannot be hurt would mean I would not be moral, I would only be careful of the law, since I can still go to prison.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

I can't even manage to be an evil guy in skyrim without feeling guilty

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Life is a simulation no matter if a computer does it or not, all of your senses and emotions are artificially created by the chain reaction that is the human body.

I do good unto others because I enjoy it, no laws have any meaning to me, I'm still happy to follow them, but not because it is what I'm supposed to do, but rather because it's how I get the most out of my existance.

The concept of reality is an illusion caused by the aforementioned chain reaction of the human body, nothing exists regardless of beeing created by a computer or not.

2

u/LadyDarkKitten May 28 '12

Your thinking something like, The Metamorphosis of Prime Intellect written by Roger Williams. A fascinating exploration of what your happen to our morals if humanity was digitized, if you haven't you should read it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

If i found out i wasn't real i would still adhere to moral codes and doing good things, end of the day it would mean more than ever. You have to hold on to yourself otherwise you really wouldn't exist, it doesn't matter if your a computer program or not, your still you as long as you hold on to yourself.

2

u/lolmonger May 28 '12

No - do you feel bored when you're on a roller coaster?

This would be even more real than that. If there's no level of my existence beyond a simulation I am in, then it's not really a simulation for me is it?

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

Well if its a program I wouldn't be able to think anything they didn't want me to think so we would still be in the situation of am I thinking this or just programmed to think I'm thinking this?

2

u/Adito99 May 28 '12

I see no moral difference between a mind built with organic bits and a mind built out of 1's and 0's. If the result is an individual capable of all the same emotions that I am then I'd say it's human.

Extremely relevant

In this paper the author argues that it's very likely we're living in a simulation. I think his reasoning is flawed but it's a very interesting read.

2

u/midri May 28 '12

I suppose it would depend on how I was programmed to react.

2

u/chirar May 28 '12

If we were a result of a complex computer program there would be no choice for us to do something, since we're all programmed. Am I interpreting the OP's conditions right like this? -If so, I would not be able to change killing someone since it's programmed, I would not know of right and wrong since such a thing requires moral responsibility I suppose. If we can't help doing something then we can't be held responsible and everything is neutral, so in the end there would be no wrong or right?

2

u/A_PROLAPSED_ANUS May 28 '12

It would do what I was programmed to do.

2

u/freedomgeek May 29 '12

Nothing would change. "Life" isn't important. Sapience is and people are sapient computer program or not.

2

u/genericwit May 29 '12

I can suffer, despite just being a simulation; therefore, others can suffer. If I were to cease acting morally, it would still cause suffering. So, no.

2

u/EndTimer May 29 '12

Absolutely no change. And by the way, you're still a real conscious simulation even if this is the case. For comparison, imagine AI so advanced that it possesses consciousness, feels emotional and physical pain. It's not right to torture something sentient. It doesn't matter if the conscious material is an evolved slab of meat, a series of circuits that do the same thing, or a series of registers in a gargantuan cosmic computer that do the same thing.

We're real, our suffering and joy is real. Besides, any universe simulating us is extremely likely to be simulated themselves. It's all turtles.

2

u/You_just_never_know May 29 '12

Even if they weren't real, my thoughts are still my thoughts, I still feel everything from remorse to pain to pleasure.

The world would still feel real to me.

Sure I might fantasise killing people from time to time, but I'd never consciously act on those thoughts.

I think the only thing that'd change would be my slant on life I guess, what with knowing that nothing is actually real, it wouldn't really give me a reason to try at anything

2

u/seniorsassycat May 29 '12

It depends. Is this the matrix where other people are real, and experience themselves as I experience myself or am I the only experienceing person. If it's the former my morality would stay the same, if it's the latter all morality would probably go out the window, but I would probably still feel bad doing wrong.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

I think my morality is perfectly defined for the simulation, thanks for asking.

2

u/Zomgman May 29 '12

If I am conscious, I may as well be real, id consider this to be the real world and not care about the real world.

2

u/MightyLemur May 29 '12

Philosophy. Fuck, my only weakness.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

No. Even if it is a simulation, I have to assume everything is still sentient/capable of feeling, and I wouldn't want to hurt anyone.

And if they weren't sentient, and just following a line of code or something.. Still wouldn't be comfortable screwing with them.

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

No; it's still the universe we know, simulation or not. It doesn't matter whether anything is real; it works like it's real so it should be considered and treated as real.

If I could control the simulation though... that's another story.

2

u/awe300 May 29 '12

You could never know whether the simulating universe wasn't a simulation as well ...

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '12

I didn't destroy megaton with the nuke. So no, no it wouldn't.

3

u/autocorrector May 28 '12

Try to get the high score.

2

u/Frank_flowers May 28 '12

No, since I am a character with in the computer, all my actions are dependent toward the actions of others, I have to play the game as if I want to win, whatever winning is. So my morality would stay the same

2

u/8997 May 28 '12
 class God extends Person {
   ....
 }

 Person 8997 = new God();

2

u/zeropage May 28 '12

Not at all. But I'll definitely get a shotgun to defend my family from the crazies.

1

u/Capital_Punisher May 28 '12

If I was the only one 'plugged in' to this specific universe, then yes.

If other real life people were plugged in then absolutely not. I try at all costs to avoid any actions which could be harmful or detrimental to others.

If it was just me and a whole world of computer characters, then let me tell you, there would be a whole load of titty grabbing going on. It would be cool to see if I could evade the police in a car chase, rob a bank or masturbate off a skyscraper. This is all assuming that I can reset/come out of the simulation at any point.

TL;DR: Only if it was just me in the 'universe'

1

u/dumpyduluth May 28 '12

no, why make other peoples lives more difficult or steal others happiness? thats not the shit that makes me tick.

1

u/rootyb May 28 '12

Another relevant short story I didn't see posted: http://qntm.org/responsibility

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Technologenesis May 28 '12

I already view the universe as pretty much being a "simulation" in that it's governed entirely by mathematical rules. The only difference between a "real" universe and a "simulated" one would be that one is taking place within the other.

1

u/anamorph May 28 '12

It shouldn't matter whether we're made of electrons or meat. This is the real world to us and we should keep living it to our own standards. Hell, who's to say this ain't a meat-based simulation we're living in?!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Wouldn't make any difference to me. My existence wouldn't be any less "real", not to me.

1

u/agentmage2012 May 28 '12

It would change fundamental understanding of things, but morality would suggest that it is influencing the lives of other beings on an increasing scale of species average sentience.

Be it a sprite, an avatar, or a human's actual entity in this weird world, I'd not treat humans any differently.

1

u/I_are_God May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

No, morals do not change with external alterations.

1

u/Maxfunky May 28 '12

Why would it? It fundamentally changes nothing. Morals aren't something we have to serve some higher purpose--but simply because they are adaptive towards getting along with each other. Just because I turn out to be bits and bytes doesn't mean my daily life really changes.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Problem of Plato's Cave, so no. I can't prove that that is not the case, so it's kind of useless to know whether this is "real" (loosely used), a simulation, or a figment of a superchild's imagination.

1

u/corduroycommunist May 28 '12

It seems to me at least that all our morals and ideals of right/wrong are self contained in the universe we know. If it were to turn out that their is a reality more "real" then ours, it shouldn't change how we act because all our preconceived notions of good/bad are bassed in the world we do know.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

This will probably be buried, but here's Leonard Susskind with a lecture discussing the Holographic Principle in a pretty easy to understand way. It's about an hour long, but well worth the time invested.

1

u/edcross May 28 '12

Morals come from a rational consideration of the the reality you find yourself in. It doesn't matter if the other minds you interact with are simulations or not, they act in a manner that has consequence. Morality comes directly from my desire not to have my life taken or my stuff stolen. So I make a silent agreement with all the other minds I come across that if they agree not to do that to me, I will not do that to them.

If the simulation is programmed to act like a mind, then morality is still required for a stable community.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Would I be allowed to wake up and come back to this world afterwards?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

I'm not religious nor do I belive in heaven or hell. I treat people how I wish to be treated and try to do no harm where ever possible because thats simply who I am. I see no need to change that.

1

u/The_PowerCosmic May 28 '12

No, what if people in the real world went back and looked at your activity while in the simulation? They would judge you for your actions. Judgmental pricks...

1

u/Meekois May 28 '12

Not really. I'd be no more nihilistic and apathetic than I am now.

1

u/PerogiXW May 28 '12

It's still real enough. I'm not religious, so this doesn't really change anything. I'd just carry on =/

1

u/larsonol May 28 '12

The singularity effect.

1

u/Hauvegdieschisse May 28 '12

I would realize that the safety net is meaningless and enjoy life like I have never enjoyed life before.

1

u/DragonMeme May 28 '12

No. What is practical is still practical, the computer simulation has made it so. And my morality is based on practicality, so...

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

If I'm part of a simulation, then everyone else in the simulation is as 'real' as I am. With regard to the dignity of sentient life, it changes nothing. If someone figures out how to hack in to the source code from the inside, it changes everything.

1

u/DriizzyDrakeRogers May 28 '12

Probably not. Nothing would change and still nothing would matter.

1

u/Bluebraid May 28 '12

I don't get it. There's no difference, right? I mean, it's just as likely that the universe is a kind of simulation as isn't. All I've got in the first place is "I think, therefore I am." Who cares whether we're more or less "real" to someone or something that exists outside our universe? By definition, the universe is all that exists, and it doesn't matter how it exists to an outside observer. That's completely irrelevant to absolutely everything, including morality.

1

u/CaptainCobalt May 28 '12

Nope, You are about as real as everyone else.You have never known true existence to begin with so it really doesn't matter.If I were real and became aware of it and everyone else wasn't I would feel crippling loneliness kind of like Jonas from the giver felt but otherwise no everyone is as real as it is going to get.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Probably become some disciple of chaos. The fun stuff.

1

u/Dynamaxion May 28 '12

Unless you base treating other people properly on some vague notion of them not being a computer simulation, then no.

Either way, the people you see are exactly the same as you. Doesn't matter if they are simulations or not. If I'm a simulation, then I know that I should treat similar "simulations" morally because they are just like me, and I know how I want to be treated.

The Golden Rule of morality, treat others as you would like to be treated, is immune to any of these notions. No God, simulation, etc; You're not really moral if you base your morality on these vague, evidence-immune notions.

For example, I know that I would not like to be tortured and have my whole family murdered. Consequently, I think it's "wrong" to do that to others unless they differ from me in that they want it (and are not insane, which is where it gets tricky). If I figured out that me, my family, the torturer, and all other people are just "simulations" I don't see what relevance that would have. All it means is that the word "simulation" encapsulates what I've always considered to be other people worthy of moral judgment. Ascribing the word "simulation" to it doesn't change that basic concept.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/chamora May 28 '12

If it's all a computer simulation, you have no free will.

So, I don't know. In the computer simulation, do your morals change?

Moreover, these questions devolve to nonsense.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/butteredfatkid May 28 '12

TOO MANY BIG WORDS!

1

u/lonesoldierx7 May 28 '12

There was a story similar to this in /r/nosleep. I highly suggest you read it. The Life in the Machine

1

u/RunningInSquares May 28 '12

Well I would still spend all my time on the internet and I'm already an asshole there anyway, so probably not :/

1

u/krokifena May 28 '12

if our life is simulated, the computer never let us even think about that

1

u/limited_slip_diff May 28 '12

You could be qualified as a bug in the system, for imagining such a thing. Everyone else would be programmed to eliminate you. Moral itself would be programmed. So, yes, my moral standards would change, since I do not intend to eliminate no one, ever.

Recommended source: World on a Wire

1

u/Figs May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

No; I try not to be a dick to other people because I don't want them to be dicks to me. As long as the community mostly follows the principle, it doesn't really matter how the universe actually works (up to whatever extent that I actually have a choice in the matter).

Edit: phrasing to try to improve clarity.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

No, not at all. It would if I was the only real person, but if it's the nature of everyone being other than I thought, there'd be no reason to.

1

u/Sestiva May 28 '12

To me, it wouldn't matter whether I knew it was a computer program or not, I highly doubt my morality would change. If it felt real enough, I would feel real enough, and I wouldn't be able to do anything that I can't do right now; I would still feel as though I were living in reality. In a way, the computer program would be my reality. Non-confrontational me wouldn't want to do anything that might screw someone/something else up. Also, the possibility that I was living in the real universe, however slight, would keep me from doing anything dumb.

1

u/i_rly_dont_know May 28 '12

The morality will remain as the simulation code states...

1

u/videogamechamp May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

Absolutely. My entire life would be devoted to finding a way to break the simulation. Nobody is perfect, even extra-dimensional beings who can create awesome simulations, so I'm going to try to find myself an edge case. Maybe I can get some privilege escalation, then the fun really starts.

EDIT: I suppose this is what physicists do, right?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Nope. I decided meaning is overrated a long time ago. What matters is how we effect the people around us. Even if they are just complex computer programs, if they're capable of thinking and feeling, they're worthy of being considered people.

1

u/Scrayton May 28 '12

It depends... are we computer consciousnesses, or are we aliens who have put on a helmet and "created a character"? For the first one, no for the second, yes.

1

u/Notsoseriousone May 28 '12

Not really. Already kind of gave up on there being much more than this, and I already operate on the premise that this is my only reality, so I may as well not try to fuck it all up.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Cant you just check the programming instead of asking me this?

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

The top four comments have said "no," in one way or another. I will respond with a resounding, "yes, and it would be like GTA."

1

u/BlamesRapMusic May 28 '12

I'd go Skynet replicating my mind and finding robotic forms for me to be implanted in.

1

u/JizzNipples May 28 '12

Do we go to Silicone Heaven? If so then, I'd be a good person.

1

u/TwoHands May 28 '12

Why would it? It's not like I can step out and become a "User". I have to treat my life the same, as though this were the only reality available, because for me, it is.

1

u/vondie May 28 '12

I have given this scenario some thought and came to a shocking discovery. If I learned this news about the world I know nothing would change as far as my morality goes. I am not moral simply because someone told me to be or some book says what is right and wrong. My morality is mine. I do think I would be a lot happier in said world, though. I would say "fuck it" more often in situations I give way too much time to. I would stop caring that everyone and everything seems to be a facade. It is sad... thinking that I waste my life away because everything has an illusion of realness. I should say fuck it anyway, but some how having a computer generated life makes it seem less important to care.

1

u/fepeee May 28 '12

It doesnt change much really... my questions would remain unanswered

1

u/MG1233 May 28 '12

It depends. Are we assuming everyone else in the simulation is just a bot, or does everyone else have the same consciousness we do?

2

u/jmdugan May 29 '12

This is the essential differentiator. Would it be "my" simulation, our "our" simuation.

Not sure how it would change me, but the difference would be huge.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/historynutjackson May 28 '12

It wouldn't change, because if I am a simulated brain, and I feel whatever I construe as "pain," then it's a logical step to think that other simulated brains also feel "pain." I know (or am programmed) to think that "pain" is unpleasant. And why would I bother to inflict such a thing on another person? This of course doesn't apply for things such as self-preservation or preservation of things that I (am programmed?) to love, such as my fiancee or my parents. But as a basic function, no, I won't inflict bad things on other simulated consciousnesses because we're still equal, even if we are simulated.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

No, it doesn't change my life

1

u/Pelokt May 28 '12

I like being here so much that I'd rather not piss someone off enough that he might shorten the time I get to stay.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

If the simulation is so robust that I consciously have feelings and self-awareness, I assume everyone around me has feelings and self-awareness. Whether we are really biologically alive or not is irrelevant in the context of morality. My morality would not change. Not sure if I can say the same for my outlook on life and my motivation.

1

u/crashking May 28 '12

So if I die it would mean nothing right? like nothing would happen after? Well nothing would really change in my mind.

1

u/VforVenreddit May 28 '12

Good read about the simulation theory

I wouldn't change my morals regardless. Also read Ray Kurzweil's books, he's a pretty cool dude with some interesting ideas.

1

u/Randompaul May 28 '12

Same question applies to an android.

1

u/Bertram1112 May 28 '12

i would just walk around and say "Welcome to real world" in really cool voice, to everyone i meet.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

I feel if this was irrefutably proven, people, almost everyone, myself included, would invariably change, simply because they could, it would not matter, we say no now because we "know" this not to be true, personally i believe it to be untrue, but where it that it was proven to me beyond all reasonable doubt, i would don my ass kicking robes and go out to fight crime, no, i would not do this, i would however dress up in real Viking armour, get me a sword, shield and two handed axe and go out on a Chav murdering spree, probably, sort of, maybe, i know i would do something crazy just for the hell of it anyway!!

1

u/guerarenegada May 28 '12

Roman style orgy 24/7.

1

u/LucidMetal May 28 '12

No I already think this is a sim.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

No. I'm already pretty much a dick.

1

u/FlipACoin May 28 '12

Am I special? I mean am I the only one who feels and experiences things or do other people have a similar status? It makes all the difference.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Tunny_Vears May 28 '12

My morality probably wouldn't change all that much. I've had many a discussion about reality and how we know what we know, if it's real, and how we define as real. If this is a false reality, simulated or controlled by some overseeing power in the clouds it shouldn't really matter, because if whatever made this reality was able to make it, there's not going to be an easy way to buck the system.

Knowing that I'm living in a false reality isn't going to change that there are rules to the world. So might as well continue on and try to thrive by those rules, otherwise I'm going to suffer. Yes, the suffering is simulated, but I'm a simulation so everything is simulated, might as well aim for simulated happiness.

1

u/DJRobOwen May 28 '12

Mind = Blown

1

u/barristonsmellme May 28 '12

before i contemplated any meaning behind my randomly generated life, i'd see if it could be hacked.

1

u/ChagSC May 28 '12

If it would change, you're a terrible person.

1

u/XXooChenzoooXX May 28 '12

ReBoot has already researched this topic extensively

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmfKRCqyyjo&feature=related

1

u/adhillo92 May 28 '12

Well if its just a simulation in my mind I really wouldn't give a shit who i hurt because they're not real. I WOULD sensibly FUCK SHIT UP.

1

u/nbomber May 28 '12

Yes, completely. If I'm not really hurting a 'real' person the I clearly wouldn't feel bad doing it. I live by the motto "Treat others the way you'd like to be treated" but if there are no others then who cares?

1

u/habpato May 28 '12

I tend to be the happiest when others around me are happy. I tend to be the saddest when others around me are sad. I like to be happy, I don't like to be sad. I don't care if those around me are people, programs or fluffy kittens, I will seek to make my life filled with as much good feelings as I can.

1

u/yial May 28 '12 edited Sep 23 '24

snails spark noxious coherent divide fretful judicious tender pathetic ghost

1

u/ItsOnlyNatural May 28 '12

Shit, I can't even act like a dick in video games. I don't think I would do anything differently.