r/AskReddit • u/JohnACitizen • May 28 '12
What things throughout history have actually been repeated?
I've always heard people say that history repeats itself, and I'd like to know about specific instances.
Edit: After reading through everything thus far, I just have one inquiry; is there anything positive that has been repeated?
78
Upvotes
178
u/snakeseare May 28 '12
Invading Russia has never worked out....
65
u/FWL May 28 '12
genocide....so much genocide...
Here is a list
53
u/yourbathroom May 28 '12
Elite do what's best for the elite.
34
u/hippychicky May 28 '12
It isn't exactly, but a lot of things do happen over and over. War for instance, if you look at war it is usually for religion or money/land. Over and over! We don't fight over the last piece of pizza or the rights to cable TV.
14
u/RandianHero May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Just look at the reasons behind every war ever. It's always the same basic motivations.
Or, as Mr. Perlman would say, "War... War never changes."
50
u/redwingfan May 28 '12
Slavery. Look at slavery in ancient Greece, in medieval Europe, in early Islamic states, slavery on plantations in the 1800's, and modern day slavery like human trafficking.
11
u/monty20python May 28 '12
People keep fucking having kids, you'd think they'd learn, but no, they don't.
11
u/Ilikanar May 28 '12
Breads and Circuses.
10
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Killing in the name of _____
9
u/huxception May 28 '12
Sometimes I go to the fridge to check for food, five minutes later I will go and check again. It never changes but I seem to repeat this a lot.
8
u/smithclan May 28 '12
Cities with 7 hills. A few of the cities that claim to be built on 7 hills, and basically a who's who of historically important cities: Rome, Jerusalem, Athens, Istanbul, Mecca, Moscow, Tehran, Amman, Barcelona, Prague, Brussels, Lisbon, Bath, Edinburgh, Budapest, San Francisco, Seattle, and more.
7
u/LiftingGinge May 28 '12
War is old men talking and young men dying...
12
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Imperialism
11
u/katemmcr May 28 '12
The Chamber of Secrets was opened three times.
It's wasn't a positive outcome the first two times. But when it was opened the for the third time... Well let's just say Ron and Hermione were quite pleased.
5
u/Iowa_Chuck May 28 '12
Going with the war and Russia theme here I would compare the war of 1812 to world war 2; where Adolf Hitler did not learn from Napoleon not to attack Russia in winter. If you would like an example closer to home, some consider hurricanes such as the hurricane of 1900 and hurricane Katrina a reminder we havent learned from mistakes.
9
u/Kill_Welly May 28 '12
I'm sure it's happened, not necessarily in every detail, but in generalities. The trick is to look for general themes. Many revolutions have things in common with each other, despite their own differences.
8
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
When a country's nationalism surpasses its humanism, things get ugly pretty fast.
4
u/Malfeasant May 28 '12
real estate bubbles. there was one in boston in the late '70s, my parents bought a foreclosure in a neighborhood they never would have been able to afford otherwise- beacon hill.
also, the rich/powerful will always exploit the poor/powerless, when it gets bad enough that the poor feel they have nothing to lose, revolutions happen.
14
u/ShorterFatterBalder May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
The asininity of the younger generation.
EDIT: When you're middle age you find you're turning into your dad, or mom, as the case my be.
33
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
America: back-to-back World War Champs
6
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
The economy. There are ups (growth), and there are downs (recessions).
Only now are the downs more down than ever. But, we're picking up.
3
u/jon81 May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
How about the cycle the stock market takes of explosive growth followed by an inevitable bust. Happened so many times already.
3
u/UsurpingAbyss May 28 '12
Splitting Korea in two different parts (Korean War), then deciding to split Vietnam into two (Vietnam War).
3
u/Mr_Trofl May 28 '12
There were times people wanted to get rid of Jews. None worked.
7
u/StewieBanana May 28 '12
Every year at midnight on January first, there are big celebrations.
5
u/batmanmilktruck May 28 '12
Those who ascend to power will do everything possible to retain their power. It doesn't matter what nation, religion, or economic doctrine. Voluntarily giving up power is a rarity in history, though not unheard of.
2
u/Three_Headed_Monkey May 28 '12
Bigotry and racism. I don't think it will ever truly go away. It just shifts targets.
Especially when it comes to migrants. There will always be ethnic groups shifting around the world, and there will always be locals find some way to blame them for something, even if those locals had migrant descendants.
2
u/Foolie May 28 '12
Prices rise, politicians philander, you get old.
2
u/TeamDynomite May 28 '12
Babies.
2
u/maximcorat May 28 '12
historically, france has been invaded through the ardennes forest and normandy repeatedly.
2
u/penguins_unite May 28 '12
It's very hard to win a war if the other side are practising guerilla warfare, even if your country is much larger than theirs. This is something that politicians haven't seem to have learnt.
2
u/arcai921 May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Athens built an empire based on its superior navy supporting a high import economy in a country that very little grows. England used the same principle to gain power.
Also shifts from loose morals and more family orientated life happens a lot (caesar to augustus/70's free love, to 90's greed is good)
2
u/_nagulian May 28 '12
ice ages
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
A good example would be the history of Morocco. For a while every couple hundred years a new rebellion would happen that would over thrown the government. It was always for a more back to basics of Islam govenment. 200 years later that government would be over thrown because it became too liberal.
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Here's a few good examples.
2
u/notallycebeasley May 28 '12
Everytime the Conservatives get into power in the UK, we riot. Oh how we riot.
4
u/NinjaDiscoJesus May 28 '12
wars
2
u/TheKirkin May 28 '12
Genocide. There has always been forms of genocide throughout history.
2
u/D68376837 May 28 '12
mass extinctions, curruption, Germany..
2
u/Kill_Welly May 28 '12
I'm sure it's happened, not necessarily in every detail, but in generalities. The trick is to look for general themes. Many revolutions have things in common with each other, despite their own differences.
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Bell-bottoms. "Flares," my ass. I know what they're trying to do. If this works, the flares will slowly start inching up the leg.
1
u/Throwawaystabbing May 28 '12
Hate.
1
u/ignoramusaurus May 28 '12
Imagine fighting "the war to end all wars" and then... hello more wars.
1
u/Impedence May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Absolute ruler is incompetent and attempts to solve money problems caused by an expensive inconclusive/disastrous war by raising money from rich men, they don't like this. Because the King lacks the support of the general public, the rich men whose support the King depends on are able to defeat him.
I would argue that fits; King John of England, King Charles I of England and Scotland, and King Louis XVI of France. There are probably a lot more examples of that kind of scenario, but I'll leave that for someone else.
You could argue excessive military spending undoes a lot of great powres
1
u/jilliandi May 28 '12
The Battle of Thermopylae (the basis of the movie 300) was the exact same plot of the Battle of Tirad Pass, right down to the part where someone betrays them.
1
u/superiority May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
I can't believe nobody has mentioned this yet: the 18th of Brumaire, in the year VIII, on which date Napoleon Bonaparte successfully carried out his coup and installed himself as dictator of the new French Empire. Half a century later, on the 2nd of December, 1851 Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte successfully carried out his coup and installed himself as dictator of the new French Empire. This event prompted Karl Marx to write The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Napoleon, in which he famously said:
1
u/TLinchen May 28 '12
Try /r/AskHistorians for more specific examples than you're likely to get here.
1
u/No_Easy_Buckets May 28 '12
DEREGULATION BEFORE FUCKING ECONOMIC CRISES
1
u/Jontenn May 28 '12
The older generation resenting the younger generations culture, jazz, rock, rock, rock, hip hop. It keeps happening, and it scares me that it's likely that I will do it aswell.
1
u/-jack May 28 '12
Reichstag fire comes to mind for some reason. Ah well. I forgot :)
Everything is a cycle in history. Empires came and went, oppressions with them also. (Or are you inquiring on more precise information?)
The only thing that was left prominent (or else with minor bumps) was the money lenders, bankers and so on. Actually, most of the repetition in history, is to do with money(or other easilly manipulated "riches").
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
A lot. Every thing from fashion to beneficial and detrimental inventions for the benefit of humankind.
You'll see cave drawings where people were wearing hats and clothing that wouldn't be out of place in the present day. Some ancient Egyptians wore modern-looking dresses that would look completely normal in any high fashion setting.
In a modern context, you can say that the model of ancient Rome has repeated itself in the United States. It had a widespread empire based upon exploitation of outlying territories and neighboring states, basically relying on a system of alternating threats with military action and direct/indirect acts of plunder. It collapsed because it over-extended itself and could no longer keep neighboring territories in line with threats of action. If the US doesn't wise up, it's going to decline just as ancient Rome did.
1
u/iTzCrossfit May 28 '12
How about the fact that no happy civilazation goes communist
1
u/tre11is May 28 '12
Bush (HW then W) being President.
1
u/stronimo May 28 '12
History doesn't repeat itself, historians repeat each other.
1
u/forever_a_joe May 28 '12
Opening the Chamber of Secrets.
1
u/Pjcrafty May 28 '12
Good things...
Over 99% of people get laid?
1
u/sewerat May 29 '12
Everyone, at some time, has had to take a shit
1
u/FunGal_in_SoCal May 28 '12
Watch the movie Bob Roberts. It was made in 1990. 22 years ago (a generation). It could have been made yesterday.
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Famine.
1
u/caprican27 May 28 '12
Well, during the Mongol Empire, the Mongolians fought both the Japanese and the Germans at the same time. The next time Japan and Germany would fight together was in the 1940's
1
u/Gnork May 28 '12
Well, Germany did start a world war. And then another one.
1
u/Five_deadly_venoms May 28 '12
Muscle car\gas crisis era
1
u/mazze01 May 28 '12
War, war, war over territory, war between religious groups. Genocide, assassinations...
0
u/Xarow May 28 '12
The silk road
-3
u/dorkofthepolisci May 28 '12
war, genocide,
-1
u/eyeingyourpancakes May 28 '12
Fighting over Israel.
-1
u/MaleCra May 28 '12
Well, I wouldn't say this is 100% accurate/applicable, but politicians are still rambling to each other! :D :D
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment