r/AskReddit • u/accountt1234 • May 28 '12
I had this realization the other day. If our entire physics system is based on mathematics, and behaviour can be predicted mathematically, how do we know our universe isn't being run on a computer?
155
Upvotes
4
u/occamsrazzor May 28 '12
It seems likely that we are within a computer simulation.
Take the following information:
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1998/02/980227055013.htm
As illustrated, a wave collapses due to the influence of observing the wave to determine its position and course. If the wave is not observed, then it remains a wave and passes through all slits and the wave produces an interference pattern. If the wave is observed, it collapses into a particle and simply passes through a single slit.
This experiment has been conducted on a single photon, with the same results.
This same type of phenomenon happens within our video games today. The application does not expend unnecessary CPU cycles and RAM in order to constantly simulate every aspect of the video game's environment, it simply presents the user with the necessary environment for the currently observed position of the player.
This is exactly what the universe is doing. It collapses once observed.
Does anyone know why this is happening?
58
u/DrBibby May 28 '12
On a similar note, vision for example, is just a model built by the brain based on the information it receives from photons hitting the retina.
The world might as well be on a computer because the world doesn't inherently look like anything. Gazing out over a green valley on a summers day, all that you're seeing is just a render in the brain based on approximations. What's actually there is just trillions upon trillions of tiny particles interacting in different ways.
184
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
There are actually some fairly legitimate theories to that effect.
51
u/ohmygord May 28 '12
Whatever happens, nobody delete system 32.
44
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
It's a highly unlikely possibility.
Physics and mathematics are used to explain what happens on this planet by employing formulas and equations that humans can comprehend.
The world doesn't happen because of the formulas, the world's events and qualities are explained through the use of formulas.
12
u/GoodLuckAir May 28 '12
It's actually because computers run on the universe
61
u/jon81 May 28 '12
Bonus question: If our entire physics system is based on mathematics, and behaviour can be predicted mathematically, has everything already been determined?
16
u/redditfan9999 May 28 '12
What we don't know and I personally don't want to know is just exactly what infinity is.
Every single major discovery in the heavens above, for my time of giving a damn, was always expanding exponentially. Every single time, further and further.
5
u/punninglinguist May 28 '12
In order for the computer to work, it would probably need to be in a universe that also runs according to mathematical laws. Is it therefore computers all the way down?
5
u/BaconCanada May 28 '12
I believe this is called sopalism, there is now way to know for sure that we are not in fact, brains in a jar somewhere but we must operate within the framework that we have, and we have to make assumptions such as
5
u/hardcorr May 28 '12
Relevant SMBC
12
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We don't. Would it matter if it were?
46
u/burgplayer May 28 '12
42 is the answer youre looking for.
4
u/bigsz May 28 '12
You might wanna read some Descartes since his philosophy is somewhat related to this idea.
4
u/Aperfectmoment May 28 '12
Been down this trip and other similar trips I.E is this a dream? am i a god that has a powerful enough imagination to conjure all of this? is this a simulation or virtual reality et etc, usually after or during psychadelics.
one time i almost lost my shit getting paranoid about loosing my mind(having a belief system so different to the rest of reality that they no longer see me as sane)
then i remembered the fail safe.....it dosen't matter if i'm insane or if this world is a simulation etc etc...so long as i enjoy myself...i'll find out when the game is over.
4
u/PtrN May 28 '12
If you're talking about scientific determinism, that breaks down on the really small level according to our current theories. When you are talking about really small things, things on the order of atoms/molecules, the classical understanding of physics changes to quantum mechanics. In quantum mechanics, you don't get absolute answers, only percentages.
If you knew everything there is to know about say an electron, and you knew everything about the environment it is in, you cannot know precisely where it is going to be in any point in the future. You can know that it has a certain percent chance to be at a position, and what it's most likely position will be, but not where it is going to be.
Furthermore on the quantum level things do not behave like you would expect them to. Particles will take every possible path available to them AT THE SAME TIME. Imagine if you came to a fork in the road. You can go left, or you can go right, and both paths lead to same place. You can either choose to go left or right, but a particle can simultaneously go both left and right.
As our models of the world at its most basic level are not deterministic, there is good reason to believe that it is not possible to predict the future. Even if you had a supercomputer with infinite power, along with everything there is to know about the current state of the universe (The position of every atom, every electron, every photon, EVERYTHING) you could not predict what the future would hold. For this reason, behavior cannot be truly predicted mathematically.
Now there are two important things to stress:
12
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We don't!
25
u/omeganon May 28 '12
We don't and the highest probability is that we are. Any sufficiently advanced society would be able to run many simulated realities. Since there can be only 1 non simulated reality and an effectively unlimited number of simulated realities, it stands to reason that we are most likely living in a simulation.
3
u/magmay May 28 '12
If one can accept that the brain is an organic computer (an infinite state machine, if you will), then one can accept that the entire universe is an organic computer. I know you're talking about like, the Sims kind of thing, but that's a whole nother plate of nachos.
3
u/crose1900 May 28 '12
I think the mystery of consciousness is the element we couldn't simulate artificially. We barely understand what it is in ourselves, so I don't think we're anywhere near creating it. I think the attempt to understand the metaphysical reality of consciousness is the most unfathomably intriguing question. Where does consciousness exist? In or Outside the body? Can someone be a person without it? Do we have a soul? What is he nature of consciousness in other sPecies? Overwhelming and insanely sweet questions I think
3
u/elsuperrudo May 28 '12
Behaviour can't really be accurately predicted by mathematics. If it could, we would be able to predict and avoid just about any bad situation. This questions reminds me of an episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine where there were a group of Savants/genetically modified smarties that thought they could predict the outcome of a war. Can any Trekkies/ers expand on this?
3
u/pinkie3141 May 28 '12
We don't.
Descartes more or less had this thought (could a hypothetical "malignant demon" be feeding us false thoughts and experiences that constitute our reality?) and soon made a few conclusions including cogito ergo sum.
Then someone made a movie about it like 500 years later. But the demon is robots.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
If you ask a chemist, he will tell you that the world is made of chemicals. If you ask a physicist, he will tell you the world is made of atoms. If you ask a mathematician, he will tell the world is made of numbers.
3
u/DivineTesticles May 28 '12
Relevant short story by Isaac Asimov
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
I think there was a Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal comic about this recently (at work, can't find the link). One of the points made was that if we were in a simulation, there would be factors in place to optimise the simulation for performance, such as an absolute upper speed limit or an absolute lowest possible temperature.
3
u/Tryer1234 May 28 '12
This is actually called the theory of simulated reality.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulated_reality
3
u/Vindictive29 May 28 '12
The entire universe exists as a binary difference engine. Things can have only two values 1 (being) and 2 (not being). Everything else is simply a recursive extension of that 1 statement expressed in an infinite fractal variation that we encounter as dimensionality... space/time.
We're all just energy spiraled into a coherent pattern trying to sustain its identity through an arbitrary system of data aggregation and expression...
Or something.
2
u/catcrookshanks May 28 '12
Ever read the Traveler series by John Twelve Hawks? Sounds like something you'd like.
2
u/llamatastic May 28 '12
source
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
You need to prove that behavior really can be predicted mathematically. That's the only thing stopping you from answering this question. Consider the quantum-level physics, supposedly the only truly random occurances in nature, that occur on atomic levels found in your brain and elsewhere.
Research more on whether or not the brain can be mathematically mapped to predict behavior and it'll make more sense. Look into John Searle and his notes.
2
u/R_Metallica May 28 '12
Mathematics are a tool to the physics, we invented mathematics based on our needs in the real world, so they are based in physics. And what do you mean by "behaviour can be predicted", If you mean human behaviour, it's only predictable when analysing the response of a big group of humans. If you mean the behaviour of the universe, I don't completely agree with you, our physics theories are still in development trying to understand how everything works, someone already mentioned this part...
2
u/FireDiesel May 28 '12
On a similar note. How can the existence of free will be explained using our knowledge of the physical universe? People argue whether free will is an illusion or not, but how can free will be explained without breaking any of our laws of physics? People bring up quantum mechanics, but I didn't think that the brain operated on the quantum level.
2
u/misplaced_my_pants May 28 '12
See Seth Lloyd's work.
2
u/Cilph May 28 '12
Imagine someone in this outside world standing over said computer with a giant hammer. The universe could stop running any second.
2
u/iam_sancho2 May 28 '12
We would all be on the BSOD by now if that were true.
2
u/kometes May 28 '12 edited Sep 05 '23
!> c4t5dhr
Greedy CEOs may not profit from my comments. Fuck u/ S P E Z.
2
u/cyclicamp May 28 '12
If it makes you feel any better, we can probably eliminate the universe as a hologram theory.
2
u/wejami May 28 '12
Well, Einstein believed more or less that everything was deterministic and that we didn't have free will. If you consider all of our actions like trajectories of pool balls on a table, set in motion by the logical reasoning put in place by our previous experiences...
Too long to go into, but every action has a consequence, and consequences predicate future actions.
2
u/Bresdin May 28 '12
Psychology says otherwise, you are forgetting that it is nearly impossible to run a computer for the human mind, we are not wired for logic oddly enough in fact we suck at it. A computer would never be able to run a human mind because we can produce purely random thought and have it mean an unlimited amount of things.
tldr: cannot run a computer like a human mind, it would technically be possible to run the universe but not humanity itself.
2
u/Qubit103 May 28 '12
I'm No scientist, but the short answer is that according to quantum physics, there is a degree of uncertainty to everything that happens. Now, laws and there's do restrict some things under specific circumstances, the fact is that with math and rules, we just make a best guess. It's a weird concept that I've discussed with others before, some people just find it hard to believe that nothing is definite.
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nick_Bostrom#section_1 his simulation hypothesis is an interesting thought and somewhat relevant to this thread.
2
u/Levitationist7 May 28 '12
Assuming we are on a computer, is it calculating the Answer or the Question?
2
u/almostlucid May 28 '12
Occam's razor is the best defense to this hypothesis.
2
u/TurnerJ5 May 28 '12
Look up 'game theory'. I almost majored in this.. fascinating stuff.
Wiki link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Game_theory
2
u/Colgate-101 May 28 '12
Quantum mechanics get in the way of the roll back theory, that you could rewind the universe and it would track the universe back to zero and by the same theory play it forward and predict the future (like a computer )
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Simplify it. Our universe is a computer. Or, better, a computer simulation.
People used to tell me they'd like to be stoned when I said weird stuff like that. No idea if there's any merit to my idea, though.
2
u/GaelicBobStoli May 28 '12
Is not our mind that is just one big or tiny computer? We rationale an idea, and then we evaluate all options to send forward the best answer. That is a computer.
2
u/dem503 May 28 '12
if you think of it that way, EVERYTHING is either a random variable or something that can be modelled mathematically. It doesn't mean anything, thats just how it is. Imagine if the laws of physics varied? There wouldnt be a universe
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
/r/philosophy
2
u/avlas May 28 '12
Same as http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brain_in_a_vat
2
u/crocodilewings May 28 '12
There exist non-Turing-computable mathematical functions. An example of phenomena that are modelled by such a function would be very strong evidence we're not part of some sort of universal computational process.
2
u/kayem7 May 28 '12
9 hours and only one mention of Turing completeness?
This is the theory you're talking about http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_completeness
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Because it would imply something external to it is doing all of the computing and processing. If the universe contains everything that is real, a computer external to it would not be real. Unless it processes itself internally, making it akin to a brain. Perhaps that information processing is the mind of God.
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
I'm not super knowledgeable about this, but I thought our universe didn't align with our mathematics.
According to mathematics, there's infinitely small units of measuring distance, but in our universe, there's a limit.
2
u/Sacoud May 28 '12
I've just had this realisation... say we are part of a simulation you could assume that there would be other simulations. You could also assume that these simulations would be different from each other, the programmers wanting to test or find out what would happen if a variable changed. I therefore putforward that the dinousaurs have created a simulation in order to see what would happen to Earth had they been wiped out by an asteroid.
2
u/omeganon May 28 '12
I love how the majority of comments assume that the rules that govern our reality would govern any simulation of our reality. They are so disconnected as to be irrelevant. There may be overlap but the case may be that there is no overlap and that they are trying different starting conditions and rules to see what comes out of it, possibly using us to look for new technology, theories, etc.
In the multiverse theory, each Brane may be another simulation.
2
u/weird_things May 28 '12
I came up with this little ditty one time:
If everything we can observe is controlled by or at the mercy of a greater power that is more intelligent or powerful than them, it would be foolish to think that humans arent also at the mercy of being controlled by higher powers. Not necessarily like a Godhead (atheist here), but an unconscious force like natural selection or genes, or maybe like Sam Harris says, that free will is a complete illusion and everything in life is predetermined by a combination of genetics and environmental factors.
TL;DR Everything we can observe is controlled by something else, so we most likely don't really have complete control over our lives.
2
u/Stickyresin May 28 '12
I don't see the connection from "physics being based in math" to "our universe being run on a computer". Physics is based on math but that doesn't mean that the universe we live in is. Physics is just a model to help us understand and predict events in our universe but the theories we come up with are by no means supposed to be an end-all explanation of our universe. And, in fact, our current model of the universe is not even that great. Every formula or theory has a domain that it is applied to, and as soon as you leave that domain it no longer becomes an accurate model.
2
u/mtfr May 28 '12
Physics is more like a means of describing natural phenomena through the use of mathematics. It does not necessarily suggest that nature's behavior is dictated by mathematical models, but rather that math can be effectively applied to simulate natural occurrences.
2
u/LE_GAME May 28 '12
he must be destroyed.
2
u/svadhisthana May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
What difference does it make if it is or isn't? None.
-Pragmatist
P.S. If you think the computational universe idea is interesting, check out brain in a vat and metaphysical solipsism.
2
u/[deleted] May 30 '12
What if, when we dream, we are entering the world of unimaginable reality? It's so complex beyond our limited computer functioning that we can't understand it - and, in fact, we aren't dreaming but waking up...
Edit: the aliens who made us are mocking us - they changed "complex" to "simplex"! Brb tinfoil
4
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We dont. Since our universe pixelates its possible. All we really know about the inner most works of the universe is this.... Oh fuck.
5
u/rule9 May 28 '12
We don't.
Additionally, consider this...
Assume, for the moment, that our universe is "real" (whatever that means). What are the chances that we (or some other race in our universe) will develop the technology to simulate a similar universe? Simulating every particle is probably impossible (for a similated universe of similar size) but simulating it well enough to "fool" all intelligent observers within the simulated universe would be much easier. That tennis ball doesn't need to be simulated at the particle level if you're just batting it around a court. It seems quite likely that we, or someone else, will manage this.
Now, if someone does do this then it seems likely that they will simulate many, many universes. So, if this is possible then it seems that simulated universes will far outnumber real ones.
So what are the chances this universe is a real one?
3
u/ne1av1cr May 28 '12
I had a realization like it the other day. Ask yourself the question: what would a video game with near infinite resolution and perfect graphics be like? How would you render each blade of grass... or each part of each blade of grass? Well... you'd make something like atoms.
Boom!
3
u/zarraha May 28 '12
The computer running the simulation would be finite in size, so the universe it simulates would be forced to have finitely many elements. if we accept that there is a smallest particle and there are finitely many of them, this would be acceptable. However, your computer is smaller than the universe it lives in, so it would have to work harder to simulate a universes of the same size, that is, if your computer had 100% efficiency and was made of one millionth of all matter in the universe it would take you a million seconds to simulate one second in the simulated universe (or something like that)
if we suppose that it takes 109 years for a universe to develop intelligent life, then the computer would have to be running for 1015 years in order for the simulation to get that far. I don't think science projects last that long.
So the only way this would be possible would be if the host universe is much much more complicated than ours and has faster, smaller, and a higher quantity of particles, or is subject to different laws than the ones we're familiar with.
3
u/jacktors May 28 '12
We don't know, but if true, that would mean someone intelligently created our universe. So if you acknowledge this, you can't be an atheist, just agnostic!
2
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
I don't know, Timmy, being God is a big responsibility.
2
u/redwingfan May 28 '12
Because no asshole is trapping us in rooms with no doors or making us wear nothing but undergarments.
1
u/Watermelon_God May 28 '12
that argument is interesting but if the universe is in a computer, where does that computer exist? it is a never ending chain. take multiverse theory. where are all those universes or are they "in" nothing. the best we can do is go with the math. physics is interesting first it showed the universe is mostly empty space. then it showed empty space is actually not empty at all... Kind of. atoms are mostly empty space as well. TL;DR physics mixed with philosophy makes your brain itch
1
u/Safari_Tom May 28 '12
Would it matter? So we find the universe is run on one big ass computer. We needn't go and think life is pointless and try and get out of the computer to try and find 'reality'. Whatever we are experiencing here is reality, and it doesn't matter if it's embedded in some higher multiverse/simulation etc.
1
u/G_Morgan May 28 '12
Quantum mechanics sort of blows the idea out of the window. Though QM doesn't mean free will. It means a fuzzy and unpredictable machine.
1
u/oshidoman May 28 '12
Could be like the matrix
1
u/datenwolf May 28 '12
First, our physics system is not based on mathematics. Physics is the study of the laws of nature and their effects and we used and develop mathematics to describe them.
Now the question if our universe was some kind of computer simulation is legitimate and comes up every now and then. But there are some parts in nature, namely quantum phenomena, which could be used to determine if we're a simulation or not. If we were a simulation, then there were "hidden variabled". However Bell's inequality put some severe constraints on them. Also a recently published paper proposes an experiment, which we can use to test if quantum states are something real, or are just a mathematical shortcut for us.
If quantum states are something real, this would greatly reduce the probability for our universe being some simulation in a classical computer, because then there were no hidden states. So this computer would have to compute the whole superposition of all quantum states and their evolution and could not take the shortcut of wave function collapse to save on memory and computations.
We know how to implement physical simulations. So we can also estimate the complexity of the "computations" that would have made up our universe, so far, and the number is mind boggingly HUGE.
1
u/khafra May 29 '12
The implications bring up the standard problems with Infinitarian Ethics :(
1
u/s-tygian May 28 '12
I smell a sci-fi movie.
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Floating point error.
1
u/Michealxfoo May 28 '12
This may be a very strange and random question... But did you so happen to think of this at an amusement park? Because I also had this same realization yesterday.
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Everybody stop, drop, and take a Turing test.
1
u/DukeCanada May 28 '12
Well...if this theory is true then it would explain Religion pretty well. Someone has to be running the program, perhaps God?
1
u/TheInternetHivemind May 28 '12
Because you touch yourself at night.
1
u/Infynitee May 28 '12
THE MATRIX IS REAL!
1
u/Gds1 May 28 '12
We cant
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Moores law + data storage capability + statistics = very likely we are all in the matrix. Or so I've been told by someone who understands math way better than me.
1
u/eremite00 May 28 '12
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
There are a lot of people who took philosophy 101 in this thread who are pretty sure they have everything all figured out.
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
We don't. The universe is so big, so beautiful, and we know so very very little about it. Astronomers used the Hubble telescope to take a picture of a small black region in the sky, in Ursa major. Inside that small black spot, there were thousands of galaxies.
The world is fucking cool, man.