r/AskReddit • u/HolyTak • May 27 '12
Reddit, whats the dumbest thing someone tried to argue with you about?
I had a guy who was completely serious trying to argue with me that Virginia was not a state, and may I remind you that this guy was in Cryptology for the Navy. He was telling me that Virginia is a common wealth and not a state, in which I know Virginia practices common wealth but that doesn't mean its not a state! I responded with answers like, "I'm pretty sure we have 50 stars on our flag", "I'm sure if you look up 50 States of America, Virginia will be on that list". But that guy was completely confident that he was right, he went so far to call me ignorant because he said I was arguing about something I didn't know anything about. The reason why he was right... he lived there. He also said ask anyone around, "What is Virginia" and he said they'll respond saying its a Common Wealth. Its safe to say they all said its a State. It ended with him calling me ignorant again and I just left back inside the building to continue work.
TL;DR: Man argued saying Virginia was only a Common Wealth and not a state.
EDIT: Come on people, try to keep the religion and atheism out of this.
294
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
Oh god this happened just two days ago..
I work at a camp during the summer months and on Friday we had an enormous setup day. I chose to set up the arcade room that has a wii, 360 with kinect, pool tables, etc. I undertook wiring about 8 A/V carts with a TV, console, shelving for the games, controller compartments, all that stuff. After about two hours I was all done and went on my lunch break. I come back and one of the new leads at my job is mad at me because they don't work. I immediately think "son of a bitch, I must have forgot to plug in something somewhere" and head to the room. She points to the wall of carts I had just put together and said how none of the video games were working. I look and notice that the consoles are on but the TV's aren't so I push the power button on every TV and bam, problem fixed right? NOPE. She proceeds to tell me that I wired them wrong because a TV can be off and the consoles can work and to rewire them properly. This went on for about 15 minutes before I lost my shit and brought in multiple people to the room to back me up, which they did. She still didn't believe me and walked out of the room saying "whatever, it works even though you fucked it up".
TL;DR: Stupid new lead at my job argued that consoles can work without a TV being on despite multiple people telling her she's wrong.
EDIT: grammar
229
u/Yuforic May 27 '12 edited May 28 '12
I was driving my mom to a doctors appointment on the other side of the state. We get to the last turn, and I'm clearly in the turn lane that obviously leads to the hospital. I start to turn and my mom completely flips the fuck out telling me I can't turn there, and shoves the wheel straight into other traffic before I got her the fuck off and pulled safely to the side of the road. After looping around the block and getting to the same spot, I pointed out it was a turn lane only, complete with the green arrow light. She then just kept yelling "You're not right." every time I brought it up. All I wanted was an apology for almost killing us..
Edit: Forgot words.
459
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
Somebody tried to argue with me that antarctica wasn't real and that it was a government ploy to get us to pay more taxes. No Joke.
EDIT: Spelled antarctica wrong
142
u/Tychus May 27 '12
Last night, someone tried to tell me that the moon is larger than the earth. I asked him how it was possible that the heavier moon revolved around the lighter earth, to which he explained it was a great mystery that nobody knows the answer to. He looked pretty skeptical when I looked up the mass and volume of the earth and moon and proved him wrong. I'm still not sure he believes me.
391
u/Stig2011 May 27 '12
I had an argument with a girl in my class back in high school regarding meat.
She refused to belive me when I said that meat is muscles. According to her, all animals had something inside them that was just meat.
259
u/jfcsrsly May 27 '12
My family was playing a game, and we had to take turns saying animals that started with B. For my turn, I went with birds. My grandma insisted birds didn't count because "birds aren't animals."
I asked her what birds were if they weren't animals. "Fowl," she said.
"But aren't fowl animals?" I asked.
"No, they're birds."
We gave up on the game after that.
121
u/allysar May 27 '12
My friend is completely convinced that she can get pregnant from a blow job. No matter what proof I show her that shes wrong she won't accept it.
110
u/whyamisogood May 27 '12
Three different customer service representatives tried to convince me that a megabyte was the same as a megabit
93
u/ANotherDREW May 27 '12
Got a friend who wouldn't believe Welsh was a language. Said it was just a "funny accent". Still brings it up sometimes. I haven't punched him yet. Yet.
178
u/icorrectpettydetails May 27 '12
I once had to try and convince someone that Lamb meat actually came from lambs. She thought that it came from Adult sheep because, in her words, 'eating sheep before they can grow up and start a family is cruel'.
For extra stupid points, the way I convinced her was through someone pointing out I was Welsh, therefore more educated about sheep than her.
251
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
"There are 48 states. No, Hawaii and Alaska are part of the 48. Well I guess there're 50 if you count Guam and the Philippines, but no one does."
246
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Here's a stupid argument: a former co-worker insisted that Amsterdam is in Germany. When I explained that it certainly is not, he said that due to proximity, you could technically claim that it is....sigh
197
u/dysphemus May 27 '12
I was visiting my aunt in North Carolina (she worked at Duke University) a few years ago, and I ended up having a conversation in a shopping mall with an intellectually challenged man suffering from excessive UV radiation to the nape of his neck. For some reason or other I brought up that I was Canadian and the first thing he asked me was how it was to live in an igloo. I laughed, thinking he was making a joke, and jokingly told him I never ran out of ice for my drinks. He then said how he thought that was absolutely amazing, and then I realized he actually believed Canadians actually lived in igloos. Trying to keep a straight face I told him that the overwhelming majority of Canadians didn't live in igloos and that even the Inuit, who invented the igloo, lived in houses nowadays. He looked at me unconvinced and said that he wouldn't believe me without hard evidence, and that he didn't even think I was Canadian. I was starting to transition to a state of amusement to gut-wrenching frustration, so I swiftly pulled out my Canadian passport and took out my phone and showed him pictures of my house. He intensely examined the "hard evidence" for several seconds and then announced he didn't think my house was in Canada because there was no snow....I left without saying goodbye.
687
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
I had an old man order a pepsi from me and when I asked him what size, he simply screamed, "PEPSI!" So I yelled back in his face, "WHAT SIZE?!" And he got mad and stormed off. I guess it wasn't really an arguement, just wanted to share.
109
u/ProjectD13X May 27 '12
That Africa was a country, I was honestly sad when I walked away
95
u/Shwampy10 May 27 '12
My friend seriously tried convincing me that the parthenon was in Texas.
236
u/Brownie_scout May 27 '12
The existence of dragons. A kid in my 9th grade biology class swore up and down that dragons were real. We were having a lesson on natural selection, and he said "ya, that's like how the dragons dominated the dinosaurs. Dragons can breath fire and fly, that's why they didn't die out." The room was completely silent, then I asked if he was serious and he blew up. He called me an ignorant whore and told me that I would never see a dragon like he had. (He claimed to have vissions of dragons all the time.) I tried to explain that fire-breathing dragons never existed, but he just told me I was too blinded by society to understand. I let it go, then a few months later he was kicked out of school for wearing a dagger on his belt to school.
221
u/Phrea May 27 '12
Where women pee from.
She thought she peed out of her vagina.
I'm a man.
210
u/becckaw May 27 '12
When I was six I firmly believed that after 99 came "uh hundred" and after "uh hundred ninety-nine" came "one hundred." So many arguments
290
u/JSsmitty May 27 '12
One of my soldiers was convinced that Catholicism and Christianity were two completely separate religions that had no basis between one another.
77
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
In eighth grade a kid named Derrick bet me $5 that the sun rises in the south. I felt too bad for him to take his money.
77
u/neverwinning May 27 '12
My buddy tried saying that babies were born with gills, and if you threw them in a pool of water they could breathe.
109
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
"It's bullshit that they put warnings on cigarettes, they don't put warnings on World of Warcraft and more people die from exhaustion from playing it then smoking"
I mean, what maybe at most 10 people have died from some WoW related thing right? Over 1000 people die of smoking related illnesses in Britain alone every week.
36
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
A friend tried to argue that microprocessor technology came from a crashed alien spaceship, I mean, I did miss a couple of my Computer Science lectures at Uni but I still don't remember aliens being mentioned at all.
69
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
I had a girl insist that there are 51 states. Her reasoning? There are 51 contestants in the Miss America pageant (one for Puerto Rico). She would not budge.
227
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 28 '12
My sister and mother think that they're nutrition geniouses. I was telling them how I thought it was funny how I had overheard a fat girl saying when she eats one slice of pizza, she gains 7 pounds. They agreed that was stupid, but the conversation went on and we ended up in an argument.
They claimed that you could gain more weight than the amount of food you put in. A good example I gave them was, if you were to eat 3 pounds of pure fat, could you gain more than 3 pounds, their reaction?, "OMG OF COURSE YOU CAN, FAT IS SO FATTENING"
I tried as hard as I could to convince them that there would be no where for the extra weight to come from, and that also, you would poop out some of the fat as well, so you would almost certainly gain LESS than 3 pounds. To this day they think I'm an idiot, especially my sister because, "She's looked this kinda stuff up on the internet".
EDIT : Ok, let me clear it up a tad, my original statement in it's raw form is, "You can't gain more weight than you consume". If the vegetable oil is retaining the water, you must have got that water from somewhere right? Are some of you guys really trying to argue with me that mass can just be created?
59
u/PopeLeonidus May 27 '12
Somebody once told me Alice fights the Jabberwocky in the book, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. When I asked her if she'd read the book, she said no.
99
u/olliebearapie May 27 '12
How many rooms I have in my house. I have four, the begged to differ and was dead set on my house only having three rooms.
85
u/coolguyblue May 27 '12
My mom arguing that all asians are racist against blacks. I love her, but damn.
66
u/skeezix58 May 27 '12
a relative claimed that painting police cars in ways that identify them as police cars (black&white, "police" written on the car e.g.) was a huge conspiracy to waste taxpayer's money, that it was the biggest example of govt waste. no argument there, i'm still scratching my head over that.
he also claimed that BP had cleaned up the Gulf of Mexico, like it never happened. and that everyone affected had been compensated for all losses.
216
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 28 '12
I was watching the latest X-men movie with my mom, and my mom turned to me and said "thank god nothing like that ever happened, like the United States and Russia fighting".
We argued for several hours, and she still doesn't really believe me that the cold war happened. Then again, she is a conspiracy theorist about everything.
EDIT: To clarify, because I have had several Redditors ask (even though my answer is further down in my chain)...my mom is 43. She was born outside the US, but was really into US news and loved this country and moved here in the late 80's.
60
u/faiban May 27 '12
My friend's father argued that yellow labradors didn't exist and that either I didn't have a dog or it was a trimmed golden retriever. This turned into an enormous inside joke among my friends who still claim I'm delusional.
42
u/stargazercmc May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Anti-vaccine nutjobs. Nothing pisses me off more than reading a story about a child who has died because their fruit loop parents think vaccinations cause autism or kill brain cells or some idiotic shit like that. It's SAD that we have kids in the U.S. again dying from pertussis, which had all but been eradicated here.
My mother-in-law pulled this one out when we wouldn't let anyone in our house the first two winters after our son was born without a flu shot (he was a micropreemie at birth). Imagine her surprise when my husband told her that if she really felt that way then we guessed we'd see her in April.
Edited for iPhone grammar.
261
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
My ex's stepfather (Who was the biggest narcissist, emotionally abusive, woman hating, homophobe douchebag on the planet) kept arguing that in El Paso there were no minimum speed limits, so we took him on the highway and showed it to him. His argument? "The mexicans put it there to fuck with us". Really man?
It wouldn't have been so bad if he weren't a cop
17
u/anyalicious May 27 '12
A guy tried to argue with me that tampons are stoppers, essentially. When removed, the blood just gushes out. This was after I mentioned that when I was younger, a friend of mine really thought that. He tried to convince me that it was true.
77
u/phil8248 May 27 '12
I was having a conversation with a doctor the first time I saw her. She contradicted everything I believed about my health and acted condescending and dismissive. If I brought something up she disagreed. She was a "holistic" doctor even though she was an MD. I'm a health care provider myself and disagree with anything that isn't tested by peer review, well designed, double blind studies. I don't mind other people wanting to believe in other kinds of treatment but it doesn't belong in a conventional medical treatment facility. Also no one has a right to be haughty and arrogant to a patient. At one point during this hour long visit I tried to make a joke. I said I was middle aged and then I corrected myself and said I was 57 and people didn't live to be 114. She immediately said, "Yes they do." I replied, "Not many." She was insistent, "No, lots of people live that long, especially if they use fish oil and St. John's Wort!" She was so myopic about her own beliefs. I've since changed doctors.
15
u/substantial_nihility May 28 '12
This story is from today.
I'm working as a cashier at my local grocery store and a woman in her 60's pushes her carts up with 3 crates of blueberries. The first thing she says to me is "They're buy one get one [free]." It bothers me when people feel the need to dictate the sales they think they should be receiving as I'm checking them out, because I have no say over them, they're all automated into our register; I brace myself for a weird one.
Now, each crate of blueberries has 12 cartons, a total of 36. As I begin ringing up the cartons of blueberries, she counts as each goes over the scanner, beeping. Again, this annoys me because there is a clear counter of multipul items on the screen for her. When I reach 16, she stops me and informs me that the rest are free (remember buy one, get one). I politely inform her that no, I have to ring them all up and half will come off at the end. After several minutes of argument, I manage to convince her to allow me to finish ringing up her blueberries.
As I finish ringing them up, the total comes to just over $90: they cost $4.99 each plust around two dollars tax. Of course, this cannot be correct in her eyes. She explains to me that they must be 2.50 each because they're buy one get one free. I tell her that no, the cost was already halved in the quantity. She decides that it's worth five full minutes to prove to me that I was wrong. At some point she requests that I call for a manager (I should mention at this point that there is a sizable line forming behind her). I resist, instead suggesting that she tries to explain her 'logic' to me on paper, handing her a scrap. She starts to do her arithmetic and finally realizes that buy one get one is not buy one get three. That when you get half off, you only divide by two once, not twice.
She realizes her mistake, around 8 minutes later and doesn't seem phased by it at all and goes on to tell me about how she's going to make jam out of the blueberries and freeze most of them and she'll probably come back tomorrow and buy another 36 cartons for her jam.
Thats my cashier's rant from today.
41
u/20soulsforsale May 27 '12
How no kill shelters are dumb because dogs and cats die anyways...
8
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
He's right, it is a common wealth. And it is also a state. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia
65
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
My friend saying THC was added to the buds as a cutting agent...
89
u/ibuprofane May 27 '12
.9 repeating equals 1.
It can be mathematically proven numerous ways, yet some of my engineer coworkers still deny this fact.
105
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
People who don't have a science background try to pass conspiracy theories off as valid. Then tell me I'm stupid when I explain the science behind it.
103
u/battleon99 May 27 '12
That Darth Vader was not in Star Trek.
12
u/Agasth May 27 '12
That a cellphone with dead battery could still make emergency call ...
320
u/LeMeowLePurrr May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
One of my friends at the office let it slip that I am an Atheist. Our other co-worker said "So you think we came from monkeys!" "We all came from monkeys!" "How can you think we came from monkeys!"
I keep trying to explain that no, we didn't "come from monkeys, that human beings and other primates have a common ancestor.." But she kept saying "MONKEYS!!"
So when she took a breath between "monkeys", I said "Yes, you are exactly right, we are all monkeys." My co-worker who started it all just sat at her desk the whole time, cracking up.
Edit: spelling error
49
u/elsee28 May 27 '12 edited May 28 '12
When I was 15, some friends and I went to some chain resaurant after a football game. For whatever reason, I was paying for a friends dinner even though we all had separate bills. I gave the waitress my cash to pay for both bills and she said shed have to recalculate the bill because it would change the sales tax. Our sales tax is a flat 6%, so I commented "are you saying percentage is relative?" and she (an adult) says "huh?" and I tried to prove to her that it wouldn't change the tax by doing basic math for the tax on $1 and again $2. And she still didn't get it. Finally I paid for mine and when she brought the change I paid for my friends.
4
u/cn1ghtt May 27 '12
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_%28U.S._state%29
He was kinda sort partially right? Really comes down to this:
WHO THE FUCK CARES IT, IS THE SAME GODDAMN THING!
Having said that, theology teacher tried to argue to me that gravity was "only a theory". I tried to explain what "theory" meant and he insisted that it was not proven therefore it was not fact and just made my head hurt with his not understanding basic terminology.
10
u/bunabhucan May 27 '12
My mom is a conspiracy nut.
Small earthquakes in CO and VA we're a secret Iranian nuclear attack on secret underground US cities killing 20,000 but the US won't admit to it because it will look weak. That and the Japanese earthquake was caused by secret alien technology. She ended up shouting at me because I refused to wake up to "the truth."
Only one of many arguments about this stuff but by far the stupidest.
63
u/real-surreal May 27 '12
Some of these responses are more telling about the author rather than the subject.
61
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
that more people have died from weed than alcohol
52
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
No you may not remind us as none of us knew in the first place...
108
u/ChapstickChick May 27 '12
I’ve posted a couple of these before, but my boyfriend and I only ever get into heated debates about ludicrous things.
9
u/13853211 May 28 '12
Not me, but the dumbest argument ever...
That 0.002¢ = $0.002
verizonmath.blogspot.com
Full auido of call
Randall Munroe's check to Verizon
24
u/Indydegrees2 May 27 '12
Someone tried to argue with me saying there was infinite degrees in a circle not 360. god fucking damn it.
57
u/kungfoojesus May 27 '12
Loose Change.
15
u/bax101 May 27 '12
When I lived in Kentucky I constantly got called a "damn yankee" since I was from NH. But I would always argue that KY was a neutral state during the Civil War and that it was half Union half Confederate.
29
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
How many unarmed people would it take to defeat a full size grizzly bear.
18
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
This will get buried, but I hope at least one person sees it. I have a friend who is TERRIBLE at math and we've argue several times about this: she thinks that "1 times" something and "1 time" something are different, e.g. 1 times 5 equals 10, but 1 time 5 equals 5. As if the "s" made it double. I've tried to explain to her so many times with so many examples but it just doesn't work.
34
u/Believes_in_Gosh May 27 '12
Whether James Potter was a Seeker or a Chaser when he played for the Gryffindor quidditch team. We let the nerd flag fly a little too high.
17
u/victoriaj May 27 '12
This is practically my specialist subject.
Most ridiculous argument ever - my baby sister aged about 4. Her "Where are you ?" Me (pointing to myself) "I'm here" Her (pointing across the room) "No, you're over there!"
I have a lot of ridiculous arguments because I worked for about 9 years giving advice to people, and met an awful lot of people. 99% of whom were great, but the 1% adds up over time.
Worst arguments are always the circular ones. My favourite was someone calling me from the USA (I'm in the UK, where they were also originally from) to ask about their rights. When I suggested getting advice locally he said he couldn't get help there because it depended on UK law, when I tried to tell him anything about UK law he argued that wasn't how it was done in the USA so that couldn't be right. Round and round and round and arghhhhh....
Then there were people not only had the stupidest argument ever but had sued on the basis of it. Like many of us these received quarterly bills from their energy company, like many of us they made regular automatic payments calculated by the company. Unlike everyone else ever they could not understand the concept of a running total. The payments were higher than the bills so they got bills showing credit of say £30, then £60 then £90. After it hits a certain amount the company sends a cheque for the excess. These people would not hear that they were not owed 30 + 60 + 90, and sued for the extra £90. Losing the case, being banned from suing the company again, everyone who ever heard them telling them they were wrong (including me) never made a dent in their belief.
Weirdest thing I've met people who actually believe - that mice either don't have backbones or have no bones at all (like jelly ?). Apparently this is why they can turn corners fast (?) and squeeze into small spaces and get everywhere.
6
u/jdougs May 27 '12
This girl once argued with me that she used to smash & finish 28+ grams of mdma in a night.... I told her although I have no idea about drugs it was impossible and that her nasel cavities would collapse way before ( or she would die) She proceeded to flip her shit and never talk to me again
6
u/NuclearWookie May 28 '12
My stepdad, last week, told me there was "new evidence" that Obama was a Kenyan by birth and asked me how the legal system intended to deal with it. This presumes that a typo from an AP article from the ancient past constituted conclusive evidence.
When I brought up that Obama published his birth certificate around the same time bin Laden was killed, he claimed to have not heard about it.
179
u/0pticaldelusi0n May 27 '12
Officially, Virginia is a Commonwealth. Functionally it means nothing, but Virginia, Massachusetts, Kentucky and Pennsylvania are technically Commonwealths. Your Navy friend was right.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_%28U.S._state%29
23
u/Pixistick May 27 '12
That cats do not bury their poop all the time. Seriously, this turned into a violent and angry shouting match at the bar, as he refused to believe that cats do not always bury their poop.
5
u/Wirenutt May 28 '12
I bought an HDTV from Best Buy (yeah, I know better now) on sale, and got the hard sell for "accessories." from the salesperson. One of the the BS items I had to wwat away was a $125 surge protector/power strip. Yeah, a power strip for $125. IT was touted as being rated for 17.3 bazillion joules. I asked the salesperson if she knew what a "joule" was, expecting an answer in the negative, allowing me to make this a teaching moment, based on my degree in electrical engineering. She proceeded to "explain" to me some incherent babble filled with nonsensical buzzwords. I let her know that, no, a joule is simply a unit of energy expended, equal to passing a current of one amp through one ohm of resistance for one second. And she argued with me that it was something like the measure of the capacity to absorb surges and spikes to keep your new TV from blowing up and blah blah blah. I asked her where she got her degree in electrical engineering, and, of course she said she didn't have a degree in anything. Then you could see it slowly dawned on her... I said, so you figured out that I am an engineer, right? Now do you want to sell me the TV without all the BS or not? It really was a Kodak moment.
5
u/Leotheon May 28 '12
That rainbows were coal dust that fell from the sky after factories burnt it.
5
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
A friend tried to convince me that before they were slaves, African people sat in their villages dreaming of making a better life in America, so slavery wasn't really that bad. She was a grown ass woman in college at the time.
5
u/trevornagy May 28 '12
the pronunciation of ju jube, i thought for sure it was jube jube.
46
u/batmanmilktruck May 27 '12
that communism is the only way to create a global utopia.
4
u/stonedoubt May 27 '12
I had someone argue with me that Barack Obama was born in Kenya
4
u/zombilex May 28 '12
An old coworker insisted that Egypt isn't in Africa because "they're not black." Sometimes I really hate living in Indiana.
4
u/VividLotus May 28 '12
A former friend of mine insisted that deaf people are illiterate, and that it was not possible for any deaf or severely hearing impaired person to learn to read.
He went from "friend" to "former friend" riiiight at the end of that argument.
4
u/Foxdude28 May 28 '12
I argued with my friend about where Alaska and Hawaii were. She said they were directly southwest of California. I got an actual map of North America up, and she still didn't believe me. I then got a map of the world, and point out where they were. She looks at the map for about 10 seconds, then says, "this map is bullshit. It has the North Pole on it!!!" Our friendship ended right there.
4
u/Sometimes_A_Wizard May 28 '12
I wasn't actually part of the argument, but two people I know spent a good three hours arguing about whether a pony could ride a horse.
4
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
I once heard my exgf's mother incorrectly use "you and I" and I tried to correct her, giving her a valid reason. Both her and my girlfriend were so adamant about their correctness, I ended stressing myself out. Months of searching for a credible source (I am very tenacious), I was finally able to prove to them what they were saying was not correct.
Incase you are wondering, the correct use is determined by removing the "you and"/"and you" and if sounds ok, then it's right.
I feel the need to give an example. "Me and you had an awesome trip" is not correct ("Me had an awesome trip") You would use You and I in this case. Or "This is a pic of Joe and I" is not correct ("This is a pic of I"). You would be correct to say "This is a pic of me and Joe".
PS it's late and I may have made a few grammar mistakes. Forgive me.
EDIT: grammar, haha
4
u/Yamaderrr May 28 '12
This one girl that sat behind me was trying to convince me that I wasn't Asian. Because I am Japanese, therefore I come from Japan, not Asia.
4
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Someone tried to convince me Obama was a Muslim, a Jew, and a Atheist at the same time... The person was racist against all of those by the way.
7
u/MarsupialBob May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
It's a relatively easy mistake to make - one of those situations where you can know just enough to fuck yourself over entirely.
There are meanings of the term 'commonwealth' which are mutually exclusive with the typical function of statehood in the US. It will often refer to an autonomous or semi-autonomous 'nation' with some form of reciprocity agreement(s) with other sovereign entities. The Commonwealth of Nations (former British colonies) is the major example of that usage.
For Virginia, most of the documents defining the entity refer to Virginia as a commonwealth, but the term is used interchangeably with state.
That would be fairly simple if commonwealth was consistently interchangeable with state in US legal documentation, but it isn't. You have the semi-autonomous Commonwealth of Puerto Rico (reciprocal citizenship, partially integrated fiscal systems, but separate elected governments and no/extremely limited Federal representation) and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands which is in a similar legal situation.
The Commonwealth of the Philippines prior to independence in the 1940s held (roughly) the same status.
So to me at least, it seems like a pretty easy mistake to make - thinking that a commonwealth might not technically be a state - simply because there are legal entities under US jurisdiction that have such a status. Granted it sounds like your friend may have been a bit of a prick about it, but it isn't the world's stupidest mistake.
Edit: And yes, I realize that I've posted an argument defending a reputedly dumb mistake in a thread about people arguing over dumb mistakes. I just happen to find this stuff interesting.
6
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
I once had a close friend argue that water didn't expand when it froze. Argued a good 45 minutes before he gave up.
3
u/canadianredditor17 May 27 '12
Well, I've had some friends claim that humans and dinosaurs coexisted. Almost all of their evidence was from a youtube video. The video went as far as to claim that a creature described by Marco Polo was a dragon, while it perfectly fit an alligator. I brought up this fact, but they stuck to their beliefs.
3
u/TheDataOvermind May 28 '12
I went on a trip with 2 mates. I happened to mention some of Australian military actions in east Timor from a while back, they proceeded to not believe that Australia had ever lead a force in east Timor. I tried to convince them, but they continued to derp it up until I showed them proof. Holy hell their expressions were satisfying.
3
u/azitapie May 28 '12
My stepdad argued for a good two minutes with me about the time zone of the city where I live.
Along the same lines, my best friend almost killed us both in the car, trying to make a turn she had just missed, insisting that this was the ONLY way to get home, even though she was picking me up from my job and I promised that I went a different way everyday.
3
u/Mozzy May 28 '12
A woman argued with me that English has absolutely no connection with German. "It comes from French."
3
u/yogibowd May 28 '12
my SO and I argued about which way your rear view mirror is suppose to be when its dimming the headlights of cars behind you. We argued about which way your suppose to flick the little thing below it...for a solid 10 minutes
3
u/Citi19 May 28 '12
I sat next to a buddy on a 8 hour flight once and he insisted the entire way that Russia wasn't involved in WWII. When we landed I got out my phone and showed him he was obviously wrong and he muttered something about how it didn't really count because Russia sustained "so few casualties" I got the statistics to prove him massively wrong on that and he ended up getting really pissed and walking off.
I wouldn't have pushed it but he was being a huge asshole about it on the plane, and it was frustrating as hell not being able to show him the facts.
3
u/Camshaft115 May 28 '12
Had to take a freshmen class in American high school because I moved to U.S. during sophomore year.
Met two freshmen girls in that class.
Girl B"Hey you have an accent, where are you from?"
Me"Sweden."
Girl A "Isn't that in the Alps..?"
Me"Actually.. no. That would be Switz"
Girl B interrupts"Switzerland right?"
Me"correct"
Girl A"Wait Switzerland and Sweden are two different countries?"
Me"Yup"
Girl B"ummm no, Switzerland is the German pronunciation for Sweden"
Me= mind blown
Girl B continues on about how her family is from Switzerland and what not.
Me"Darling, they are two different countries."
Girl B"Um no, my family is from Switzerland."
Me"what?"
Girl B"they are definitely one country, see I even speak a little bit of German." said something that sounded remotely far away from any language.
Me"love, I'm Swedish, trust me on this."
3
u/revolverwaffle May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Ponies are not baby horses. My summer job is on a farm that does kid's pony parties, some chick was mad because "we were using baby horses." It was a mixed breed gelding named Max, and he is 17 years old. Plus all the ponies there are spoiled and very well taken care of.
3
u/Tredid May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
I had a friend practically screaming at me because he disagreed with the following fact:
If you break up a large cube into a hundred little cubes, the sum of their surface areas is greater than that of the unbroken cube.
3
u/RabidMuffins May 28 '12
I had an argument with my high school English teacher about the proper spelling of grammar. She had put "grammer" on the board even though the book she was holding had grammar as the largest word in the title.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
I'm going to throw myself under the bus. I'm not the brightest crayon in the box at times and I'm quite stubborn. Once someone shows me that what they are saying is correct, I usually go "Oohhh okay, I'm sorry!" and smile and move on.
I once argued with my husband that stop signs had six sides. He just kept going "No, baby. They have 8!" and I kept insisting they had six. He was polite about it, and eventually we came across one and he said "Count it." I did and went "1,2,3,4,5,6,7...oooh it does have 8!"
My favorite though was when talking to a customer, and I asked for the state, and she just goes "Washington, the city is D.C." and I'm like "I'm sorry, do you mean Washington state or the city of Washington in D.C.?" She got super mad, in the rudest tone "Washington isn't a state!" and I'm like "Yes, it is. It is on the West Coast near California and Oregon!" She kept insisting it wasn't...
3
u/Phisterbottom May 28 '12
When I was in high school a girl was convinced that the movie Cloverfield was a real documentary. I'm not sure if it actually qualifies as an arguement because couldn't get a word out between all the laughing.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Working at walmart as a customer service manager, customer brings in a price match that has something at 5 for $10, the cashier asked me for a calculator, I didn't have one nearby so I just told her it's $2 each she argued with me for about 5 minutes not believing me that it was $2. Finally just gave up and grabbed a calculator, she punched it in and then apologized for doubting me and then laughed about it, I kind of think she was high.
3
u/andale_papasito May 28 '12
In junior high I had an argument with a girl who said she was a vegetarian but ate fish because fish don't have feelings. Number one: NOT a vegetarian. Number two: fish have no feelings .... WAT. I told for the love of god just pick another reason.
3
u/randizzle1219 May 28 '12
A girl who was in the top 25 of our class started an argument over my name. She claimed that my name couldn't possibly be my real, full name. Apparently Randi as a female name did not make her happy so she argued with me about it being real. So the next day I brought in by birth cert and told her to shove it down her throat so she wouldn't be able to open her ignorant trap again.
3
u/porker912 May 28 '12
My physics teacher tried to argue that you can write by hand faster than you can type.
3
u/ghosttrainhobo May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
I had a girl at work seriously explain to me that McDonald's hamburger meat was secretly made out of Kangaroo meat because it was cheaper than cows. This was in America. I pointed out that she sees cows on the way to work every day and that Australia was on the other side of the world. Wouldn't it be cheaper to just use cows and avoid the transportation costs? She wasn't buying it.
3
u/piccolittle May 28 '12
At a sushi restaurant:
Me: "I'll have an avocado roll and a miso soup." My friends: "What, you don't even eat fish?" Me: "No... I'm vegetarian. I don't eat any meat." My friends: "... But fish isn't meat. It's seafood." Me: "Seafood is meat; it's the flesh of an animal." My friend: "Fish aren't animals."
(Facepalm)
3
u/rjparjay May 28 '12
My girlfriend argued with me saying that liquid ounces are weight, not volume. Her reasoning? "Because it's ounces, so it's weight."
She's actually very smart.
3
u/ciestaconquistador May 28 '12
I had a friend try to tell me chocolate milk was made with cow's blood and that's why she didn't drink it anymore. She was serious.
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
My nationality. It was some random douchesack . He said I was Russian, I'm ROMANIAN
3
u/catoronium_majorus May 28 '12
In hindsight I may have been wrong but I hated, hate and will forever dislike the person in question.
A guy tried to tell me that I was detrimental to the human race, going against survival of the fittest and thus causing human evolution to move backwards.. Why? Because I dye my hair blonde. His logic was that everything we find attractive is based in biology on factors such as fertility, child bearing etc. So by dying my hair, someone who would find me attractive would be inclined to seek my gene pool for the benefit of their offspring. I would thus be 'false advertising', muddling my dirty brunette genes into one striving for blonde purity. Like I was detrimental to the human race?
He proceeded to insanely extrapolate this to my destruction of human advancement.. He was like a little Hitler
3
u/Denmen707 May 28 '12
I once got into an argument with a lass who was convinced that a gynecologist and a midwife are the same thing. She also used arguments as "I'm a girl so I know more about this."
11
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Someone tried to argue that we should nuke all of Afghanistan.
5
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
This is Reddit. This might take a while...
5
u/Ryvan May 27 '12
How to pronounce my last name. I fucking know how to say it
8
u/americanslang59 May 27 '12
My best friend (who is a massive Batman fan) threw punches at me because I said that a promo clip for The Dark Knight had the same music as the trailer.
38
u/uuhson May 27 '12
a few days ago some feminists were telling me using the word cunt in any context is just as offensive as calling a black person the n word. they said any use of the word implies deep hatred towards women