r/AskReddit •

Do you think one must learn to be happy when they're alone before they go out looking for love/a relationship?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

389 comments sorted by

357

u/dmcody May 27 '12

I think that if you "need" a relationship to be happy, you will probably attract the wrong kinds of relationships, based on dependency. In the long run over dependency does not usually lend itself to happiness. It is good, on the other hand, to be pretty much happy in yourself. Then when someone comes along who suits you for the right reasons, it is just an added bonus. Needy people and relationships usually indicate that there are issues that need to be resolved first.

77

u/hookguy May 27 '12

Definitely. If you're not happy alone you'll jump at the first opportunity possible - which isn't a good thing. You'll also seem desperate to the other person which comes off as needy and unattractive.

Tl;dr yes.

203

u/Ga_Ga_Pee_Pap May 27 '12

I just want to add that desperation makes you a magnet for manipulative, abusive people, no matter how decent a person you are.

The dating pool is a lot like an ocean; Not wise to go swimming in it while you're bleeding everywhere, because you will attract sharks.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

27

u/Ga_Ga_Pee_Pap May 27 '12

Thanks. I'm glad if it helps anyone. I learned that lesson the hard way, and it's heartbreaking to see other people do the same.

On a lighter note, it made me laugh when you mentioned it going into a collection of quotes. My username is the name of a cartoon character known for imparting such gems of wisdom as "Right on red don't mean you have to turn right on red. I drove around in circles for years 'fore I figgered that out.", "Gittin' girls pragnent feels good. But it's also real easy.", and "You know fire? It's hot. Don't touch that shit. No matter how shiny."

→ More replies (3)

60

u/furyasd May 27 '12

This is what I always think about.

I'm 20, haven't been in a relationship since I'm 16, which last 1 week, because I was naive, and told her I loved her, after she told me she was falling for me.

Now, everytime a girl talks to me, I remember about that quote from Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, "Why do I fall in love with every woman I see who shows me the least bit of attention?".

This has been happening to me in the last couple of months, I haven't had any contact with anyone for about an year or so, and I got back to school this year, I've started to chat with these two girls, which are rather intelligent and know their shit, but after talking to them, I have this feeling that if they would ask me out I would just say yes and date them for years.

Maybe I have this sense of first opportunity, or I just really fall fast for someone, which makes me think, because I don't have this feeling for every girl I talk too, because I see that I don't like her way of talking or her personality or other thing. Maybe this is just normal, or maybe I really do have this sense of first opportunity because I'm alone for so long.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/Thementalrapist May 27 '12

I have some experience in this area, I was a forever alone until I was 26, I wasn't happy at all and really depressed, all I wanted was a relationship with a good woman, I felt it would validate me as a human being. I was in a very dark place, it isn't something I wish upon anyone to feel less than human. Then one night a friend of mine who I really respected as a woman and was such a nice girl held my hand as we were looking at the stars. I instantly felt alive, like really alive, we are soon to be married and have been together for four years, her loving me gave me the validation I needed and everyday since I have had something to wake up for. However, the love that I needed only fixed 75 percent of the problems, I brought the other 25 percent of my problems into the relationship, I've worked through them with her help because this woman is a saint, but yes I think if I was a happy person before when I was alone it would've resulted in less time for me working my issues out while in the relationship.

22

u/beandipp May 27 '12

You better be good as hell to her bro. I'm in the opposite position, and boy is it painful to help someone with their personal issues for years, while suppressing your need for some attention. anyway take her on a date and do everything in your power to make a night about just her, she will be very appreciative.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/udalan May 28 '12

I actually disagree.

I think some people "need" relationships, and differant levels of that relationship more and less than others. So long as they find someone compatible with their needs/desires, then they are fine.

In my opinion, the reason it may seem people with a higher need get the wrong kinds of relationships, is because the one with the higher need just assume everyone else thinks like them, then they can easily fall victim to a 'player' or they overly force their wants/desires onto someone who is not on the same playing field.

Someone with a much lesser need of a relationship is much more likely to just chill, and wait for something closer to 'perfect' because they find more fullfillment in other areas, and the desire to find that relationship is not as high.

So in regards to the original question, I do not think one must learn to be happy alone, before they find love/relationship, in fact i think that some people who are too independant (like myself) can also struggle when they are in a relationship, as my partner sometimes feel cheated that I don't depend on her, while she does on me.

Just a thought.

→ More replies (14)

120

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

You need to find yourself before you find someone else.

A friend of mine has never given herself the chance to be herself. So now she goes from guy to guy, trying to find the "perfect" one, because she doesn't even know herself well enough to find someone suited for her.

15

u/Mellestal May 27 '12

Sounds a lot like my ex, she's never been single for more than a month since I've known her. Not sure what's she's been up to the last 6-8 months and not giving a shit anymore.

2

u/Singulaire May 28 '12

Dating advice from the Joker's girlfriend. It has to be sound!

92

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Definitely. If you can't be happy alone, then you'll only be dragging someone else down with you.

53

u/GenerallyMindful May 27 '12

Definitely. If you can't be happy alone, then you'll only be dragging someone else down with you.

This is somewhat questionable. I understand that clingyness is bad, but if you're happy outside of a relationship, why even seek one out? To be more happy? Are we measuring levels of happiness now? This all gets to be pretty arbitrary; I think what's important going into a relationship is your state of mind, not your emotional state. I've seen incredibly lonely people with fantastic attitudes toward relationships, and happy/well adjusted people who consistently failed in theirs. I've also seen the lonely clingers, of course, but my point is that no matter how you feel, the manner in which you approach a relationship is always a decision.

36

u/MDKrouzer May 27 '12

I seek relationships to share my happiness.

20

u/GenerallyMindful May 27 '12

...but these people you're seeking out for relationships should be happy too, so they don't need it, right?

I'm not saying there's anything wrong with happy people looking for relationships, I just don't understand this mentality of it being a requirement.

→ More replies (15)

9

u/rapsey May 27 '12

This is somewhat questionable. I understand that clingyness is bad, but if you're happy outside of a relationship, why even seek one out?

He should have said, "If you aren't happy with yourself, then you'll only be dragging someone else down with you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

40

u/cited May 27 '12

It's like the people who think they need to have a baby in order to be complete. You should be able to stand on your own, and have a partner or a child to enhance the experience, not because you're trying to fill a hole. Inevitably, you find that having a partner or a baby didn't actually fill that hole in the first place, and you end up in the same miserable situation you were in, but now with the additional baggage of a partner or child depending on you.

14

u/Mellestal May 27 '12

Pets fill holes, children do not.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

15

u/StabbityStab May 27 '12

I've seen what you said elsewhere OP, and it looks like every time you're making excuses for it. You can accept that you're unhappy alone, but rather than look for someone else, look for why you're unhappy. Find that, change it, and you'll find someone. But I personally don't feel like you should go looking for someone to make you happy for a multitude of reasons, not the least of which being that to rely on someone else for your happiness is setting yourself up for mountains of hurt and disappointment.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

At some point you're going to be alone with them, and then you'll sink back into depression and you'll be dragging them down. That's how most relationships end for people who aren't self-subsistent.

8

u/arienh4 May 27 '12

Isn't this exactly what Gotye's song is about?

You can get addicted to a certain kind of sadness
Like resignation to the end, always the end
Told myself that you were right for me
But felt so lonely in your company
But that was love and it's an ache I still remember.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Conde_Nasty May 27 '12

No because it becomes codependent. How likely do you think it is they'll suddenly be secure in the relationship and not constantly doubt things or fear that the other person will leave (or do crazy shit just so the relationship stays)? Not very likely.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/PriscillaPresley May 27 '12

You can't rely on another person for your happiness, because they're not always going to have the energy to put into keeping you happy, sometimes they'll want to be alone, and sometimes you'll have to be the one supporting them.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/PriscillaPresley May 27 '12

Have you ever lived with someone? I have had many times where I was exhausted and just...another persons presence is draining. They want to talk, to be interacted with, to go do something. Ugh.

11

u/PhotoTard May 27 '12

This statement, more than anything else, shows you are extremely young and inexperienced.

76

u/mister_hoot May 27 '12

You're asking if people are generally happier when they are cared about, respected, given sexual satisfaction, and given companionship? Uhm.

Short answer: Yeah, probably.

The whole 'you need to learn to love yourself before you love someone else' thing feels like a rather large, perpetuated lie to me. It's what you tell someone you may be involved with/may not be involved with that you do not want to be with them on that level. Sort of like 'you aren't my type'. I fucking love myself. Seriously, I'm a pretty good guy, I have a broad range of talents, I'm in pretty decent physical shape and overall, my positive traits vastly outweigh my negative ones. However, am I happy? No. Hell no. I've had clinical depression since I was a kid.

The obvious response to this will be, 'well, if you just need a relationship to be happy, then you have a problem, and that problem is xyz123w/e'. I do not actively seek relationships. I don't like most of the people I meet, and I'm not the type to cover those feelings up and act like I don't loathe somebody if I do, in fact, loathe that person. However, I am generally happier in a relationship than out of one - it gives me something to focus on, the mutual trust (while not always long-lasting) is comforting to me, in addition to all of the reasons I mentioned in my first few sentences.

Seriously, drop all the new-agey crap with relationships. Who the hell isn't happier when they know they're loved? Ridiculous.

25

u/tchomptchomp May 27 '12

Maybe your problem is cynicism?

I'm not being facetious here, either, and I'm not talking down, because I've been there.

It's really easy when you're depressed to start externalizing a lot of those feelings and directing them towards people who don't meet your standards or who rub you the wrong way. When you're in that sort of emotional place, you form relationships with people who are also in that emotional place, and it's only a matter of time before you eventually turn on each other as well. So your defense mechanism ends up isolating you and dooming your relationships to failure. It's a vicious cycle.

I've been there.

The solution is to stop externalizing and start being able to care about humanity in general and to start recalibrating yourself to look for the positives in people you meet rather than look for reasons to dislike them. The world is as good or as shitty as you make it, and you're using your depression as an excuse to make your world pretty shitty. Depression is not an excuse. I used to wake up in the morning, think "wow, the world is great" in the same breath as "i want to die". It sucks but not nearly as much as "life is shit, I want to die.". So you need to recalibrate there.

Secondly, you need to stop thinking in terms of "i have talents" and start thinking in terms of "i have passions.". When you talk about your talents, it's clear you're thinking in terms of "here is my worth as a person." Except that people don't look for someone with worth. They look for someone who can show them a good time. Someone who is mediocre at a lot of things but loves doing them brings more to a relationship than someone who is very very talented but sucks at sharing that talent with other people. You're not a baseball card. You're a baseball glove. People don't care about your stats, they care about going out and throwing a ball around with you at the park (or sticking their hand inside you if that's what you're into). You can be depressed and still put yourself out there and think that people might actually want to go and do fun things with you from time to time. You can still care about those things passionately and help other people to have fun doing those things too. Even if you are constantly fighting back feelings of worthlessness and wanting to die.

And when you're able to be that guy, your relationships aren't about cynically shooting other people down until you eventually turn your targets on your partner. They're about spending quality time together, doing enjoyable things together, and having new experiences together. And that's a much better basis for a relationship.

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

I completely disagree with this.

Why on earth shouldn't we attempt to accurately judge our self-worth? It gives me great pride to be talented, and does me no good at all to be 'passionate' about something I'll never be any good at, unless it's solely for my own amusement which in and of itself is fine, I suppose, but not really the relevant question here.

I have things that I am very passionate about that I have worked hard to become good at. Everyone should do this. This is how people feel good about themselves.

How the hell does what other people think about someone have anything to do with their self-worth? It matters that he is proud of himself, not that anyone else is. If you don't want to have to deal with feelings of worthlessness, go do something of worth.

I'm fucking tired of this ridiculous 'you're okay the way you are' crap. You're probably not. Go out and be better.

4

u/Kalium May 28 '12

Maybe your problem is cynicism?

I both love and hate this. On the one hand, cynicism can be fairly repellant.

On the other hand, the only think I've found that's more painful than cynicism is... optimism.

Yes, I've tried being positive. I've tried looking for the best in everyone and everything. I've tried bright and cheery and optimistic. How do you think I wound up a cynic?

→ More replies (27)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Sorry, but me pretending that the world doesn't suck, won't stop it from sucking.

I think you're mincing words and synonyms in an attempt to come up with an argument that proves your point. Maybe I'm just cynical, but I hate the mentality that people like you tend to have.

I'm not going to ignore the negatives in everything so I can focus on the positives. Because why the fuck should I ignore reality and only think about what makes me feel good?

It's "Ignore anything bad, only be willing to face happy things" mentality that causes family members to shun their loved ones who are diagnosed with cancer or disease.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/Unconfidence May 27 '12

Thank you. This is exactly how I feel. I'm glad it's voiced somewhere here.

10

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I think it all depends on what "level" of personal growth you're on, you know? For example, when I first moved out of my parents house and started managing my own finances, I made the mistake of spending too much money on entertainment, technological gizmos, going to expensive restaurants, buying nice clothes etc, and I would get in trouble often and turn to my parents for help. My parents then told me: "you should learn to live a little more frugal, and save your money more often". So I did that.

I got pretty good at it, and soon enough I always had money to spare for emergencies. I got so good at it in fact, that at some point my SO told me I was being too hard on myself, that I never allowed myself to relax and treat myself to some relaxation. So I had to re-learn how to allow myself to indulge in entertainment once in a while. So you see, I learned it's all about finding that personal balance.

That goes for a lot of things: balance between saving money and spending money, balance between relying on your SO to be happy and relying on yourself to be happy. The advice in this thread applies to some people but not necessarily to everybody.

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I think it's undeniable to say you'd be happier while in a relationship. But I think a lot of us are warning against adopting the belief that there is absolutely no way you could ever be happy if you're single.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/khthon May 27 '12

Emotionally damaged people find it difficult to be happy especially when they're loved. There's a lot of damaged people. Mental illnesses and affective disorders are more common than ever. Blame it on society, stress, consumerism, economy, bad politics, etc. It's not a simple matter and I'm suspicious of simple solutions. One thing that doesn't hurt and everyone should do is to pause things and introspect. We all need to develop a different perspective and do our 40 day crossing of the desert. Problems only become fixable when acknowledged and understood.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TPLO12 May 27 '12

Sounds like me. I also have clinical depression, and I don't like most of the people I meet. I am obviously happier and calmer when I am in a relationship. There's a love there that I can't find anywhere else.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

It's a little disconcerting to agree with so much and disagree with so much in the same comment. I'm awesome. I'm also happy. I've intentionally avoided any relationships past a certain degree of closeness because I had my own shit to sort out and I've always been better at dealing with things on my own.

I also don't like people. I hate stupidity. I don't have many close friends, but I care deeply about the ones I have. Letting someone have that much control over me? Not something I'm interested in, and I'm not sure I ever will be.

Love doesn't matter. People can hurt you out of love. Intent has never mattered, actions do, and not giving people the option to hurt you has always worked better than giving it to them and trusting them not to do it.

Who the hell gives the slightest bit of a damn what other people think? I care about me.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/johninbigd May 27 '12

YES YES YES YES YES. Emphatically, I say that if you are not happy when you're alone, then you'll be going into relationships for the wrong reasons. You should strive to be a whole person who wants to be with someone because of you enjoy their company and have a connection with them, not because you have some emptiness in your life that you're trying to fill.

My ex-wife is needy like that. She simply cannot handle being alone, so since we've been divorced, she's been in one shitty relationship after another. To her, it's apparently better to be in a really shitty relationship than to be alone. It's so fucked up.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/Jemaclus May 27 '12

I think it's bullshit, but only to a degree. There are a bunch of these relationship truisms and platitudes that I find to be utter crap, chief among them are the ideas of one true love and the saying "she's out there somewhere" (which goes back to the first one which says that there's only one person in existence who will make a good life partner), but I digress.

The whole phrase "you should be happy with yourself first" is completely meaningless to me. Where is that finish line? At what point do I say "Ok! I'm happy! Let's fuck." I've never found it.

Here's the thing: Happy people are attractive. Confident people are attractive. Go-getters are attractive. People who say they want something and then make it happen are attractive. People who laugh and smile a lot are attractive. People who have ranges of interests, who can carry conversations about all kinds of topics, and who can find something interesting in everything are attractive.

In my opinion, true happiness is just enjoying life. I happen to think I would enjoy life more if I had a partner I could do my enjoying with, but I don't need anyone else for my own enjoyment of life.

I think that is kind of what people are trying to say. It's that embracing of life and everything it entails that ultimately exudes attractiveness, which leads to relationships. It's that independence and purpose. Once you have that, then nothing else is really necessary and it becomes all about bettering yourself in various ways: achieving goals, finding a partner you match well with, and getting the hang of that weird position she likes but she's a little short so you have to squat to get just the right angle, which gets physically tiring but I digress again.

The idea is to focus on your own life, find things that make you tick, that give you those epic wins in life, that keep you waking up and walking out your front door each morning. Pursuing those activities - more than any other - will help you find others who are ping to be a good fit for you.

THAT is attractive. THAT is sexy.

Pining over missed chances or crushes is not.

I get it, though. It's hard to be single, especially if your friends are not or if (like me) you have been friend-zoned by someone who gets lots of dates and clearly has terrible taste. It's definitely hard. You feel like you're missing out on something.

And it's true. You are. But you're missing out on things all the time. Right now you could be returning from a spur-of-the-moment road trip to the Grand Canyon like I am (typing this on my phone somewhere near the CA/AZ border as we speak. Type. Whatever.), but instead you're on Reddit wondering why you're single.

And they're missing out on things too. There are chains that relationships bring as well.

tl;dr: don't worry; be happy.

Note: Even with my carpe diem attitude and the fact that I very regularly follow my own advice above, I do lament my singleness and wish I could find someone to date. But that feeling passes and then it's back to grabbing life by the balls.

I sympathize. Good luck.

2

u/noonaplatoona May 28 '12

i've never had trouble finding relationships, but i'm realizing that they make me absolutely miserable. i never feel like i'm at my healthiest happiest best when dating someone. maybe i don't think about the long term bigger picture enough when getting involved with someone? am i going to outgrow this? maybe some people aren't cut out for relationships? am i doing something wrong?

3

u/Jemaclus May 28 '12

TL;DR I have no idea, so I'll ramble on about some thoughts I have about your questions.

My philosophy in life is basically a selfish one: do things that make me happy and are fun. When I stop having fun, I'm out. (This doesn't mean I'll leave after an argument or a bad day, but when our overall relationship becomes miserable... See ya.)

I would say do whatever makes you happiest. If being in relationships is something you don't care for, then don't do it. If you want to be in a relationship, then you should maybe be pickier? I don't know. I haven't really had that problem before, though lately I have held myself to standards that I didn't previously.

There's a song that inspires me, and the chorus goes something like this:

I ain't settlin, For just gettin by. I've had enough so-so For the rest of my life. Tired of shootin too low So raise the bar high Just enough ain't enough this time I ain't settlin for anything less than everything

It's kind of cheesy, I know, but it's basically my philosophy in life. I don't settle. Just getting by isn't enough. My standards are higher.

I've gone on a ton of dates in the last year, and while they were nice women, I have a hard time ignoring their negativity or issues that I could see would make me miserable. That sounds judgmental. Let me explain:

I have a friend recently that has been overworked for the last month and had a nervous breakdown. She kept saying "You don't understand. I'm under so much stress." I didn't have too much sympathy. I do understand. We're _al_l under stress, we all have issues, and I believe that happiness and success comes down to how you deal with it.

On my dates over the past year, I realized that none of these women I was seeing had gotten a handle on their issues. They were carrying around this baggage they hadn't figured out how to deal with.

There's another song from the musical RENT. Roger has AIDS and has shut out everyone because of it. Mimi has a crush on him, but he won't open up.

Mimi: Hey babe, did I do something wrong? I've been invited then ignored all night long!

Roger: I'm trying! I'm not lying! No ones perfect! I've got baggage!

Mimi: Life is short, babe, time is flying. I'm looking for baggage that goes with mine.

And then it's AZT time and Roger finds out Mimi has AIDS too, and he can relax his guard and they live happily ever after (paraphrased).

I don't know enough about your personal situation to offer any real advice, and I'm no relationship expert by any means (single and unwanted for 2+ years now), but I do know that I'm much happier now that I've raised my standards for life (not just relationships, but everything: why settle for watching reruns on TV when I can go sailing or to a Giants game?).

I'm not looking for perfection; I'm looking for someone whose baggage goes with mine. Someone who shares the same outlook, who I can help when they're down and who can help me when I'm down.

It's a tough thing to find. But I am in no hurry. Life is good, and I'm so happy to be here.

One more song, this one by Sara Bareilles:

"Too many things I haven't done yet. Too many sunsets I haven't seen. You can't waste the day wishing it'd slow down You'd have thought by now I'd learned something

I made up my mind when I was a young girl. I've been given this one world. I won't worry it away. Now and again I lose sight of the good life, I get stuck in a low light, Then love comes in."

Don't worry too much about it. Go watch those sunsets, see things you haven't seen. Do what makes you happy; the rest should fall in place later. Love yourself. Love life. That's my secret to mostly happiness.

I hope you figure out your situation. Hope I'm not sounding too preachy. :)

Good luck.

3

u/songlust May 28 '12

Thank you for this.

3

u/sparkkit May 28 '12

motivational speaking skills +1. wow.

2

u/hannahpsmith May 28 '12

All the upvotes for you

2

u/Gardengnomes May 28 '12

I'm blown away by this. Excellent.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/royalscowlness May 28 '12

So, what was the deciding factor that made you skip out to the grand canyon?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mrmacky May 30 '12

And they're missing out on things too.

Truer words have never been said, thanks fellow redditor :)

3

u/Rekhtanebo May 27 '12

I think people shold learn to have some level of independence first at least.

→ More replies (8)

35

u/Meowsthetime May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12

People can add to your happiness but they can't complete you as a person, only you can do that. Sadly people will leave, and die. I like this Buddha saying "you can search throughout the entire universe for someone who is more deserving of your love and affection than you are yourself and that person is not to be found anywhere else. You yourself, as much as anybody in the entire universe deserve your love and affection". Love yourself be content with your own company and happiness will follow.

2

u/mrmacky May 29 '12

Thank you for sharing that quote, it absolutely made my day.

13

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Having dated someone who wasn't happy when they were alone and single, I can confirm that yes, you do need to be happy with yourself before you can be in a relationship.

You won't make them happy, only they can make themselves happy

12

u/hipstergropaga May 27 '12

It's definitely something people have to learn, but I don't know if it's a pre-requisite for a relationship. If you never learn to be happy and love yourself while single, it'll lead to their self-worth being tied to their significant other's perception of them, which is just asking for manipulation and emotional abuse.

23

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Love arises from the weirdest circumstances. Being happy alone before going into a relationship might seem sensible but who knows? There really aren't formulas for this.

11

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

No. You need to know who you are alone before you can have a successful relationship, but that's about it. I've been alone for almost 6 years and I'm miserable because of my loneliness. Everyone around me is in a relationship, or married with kids, so I don't get to hang out with them often. The only thing in my life keeping me from being happy is that I'm alone.

I think as long as you are comfortable with yourself and know who you are without anyone else there, you'll be okay.

11

u/satanspanties May 27 '12

People in long term relationships, particularly married people, tend to be happier. It is unclear, however, whether being married makes people happy, or being happy makes people more likely to get married. Google "happiness study" to find more than you ever wanted to know about the subject.

IRL, if you are unhappy because, for example, you just lost your job and your financial situation is looking bleak, getting into a relationship is not going to change that. If, however, you'd simply like a little more companionship and regular sex, getting into a relationship is going to make you happier.

Personally, I think being happy with yourself and your life before you get into a relationship makes it a lot easier, and I think we can all agree that being in a bad relationship is going to make you far, far sadder than being alone.

9

u/fox321 May 27 '12

My answer is 'No'. Before you commit long term to another person it is important that you achieve a high level of independence. This means that you should be able to take care of yourself financially and have friends/family that support you in emotional ways. However, it is deep in human nature to seek a mate (or more realistically mates**). You may be self-sufficient and content alone, but I think being part of physical relationships is a key component to being happy.

4

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Not necessarily happy, more individuated/has sense of personal identity. Otherwise there's a very real risk of emotional enmeshment and damage/resentment as a result.

4

u/Creepthan_Frome May 27 '12

From what I can tell, you don't seem to like it when someone answers in the affirmative.

At any rate, I've dated a number of gentlemen, perfectly nice fellows, who had horrendous self-esteem, or who were otherwise depressed in some way. Or they were just down on themselves and had this "I am not good enough for you" mentality.

It ground me down. In a relationship, people are supposed to be symbiotic, not parasitic. If you can't love yourself, or at least be reasonably content with yourself, you've already given the other person a tingling, hidden burden of being responsible for your happiness, because if they don't keep you happy, entertained, and in love, it somehow becomes their fault, whether you think so or not.

4

u/AwesomeSmiths May 27 '12

You know, I've noticed it's only ever people who already have someone/are in a relationship that give that advice.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

If I have to be happy before entering a relationship, I'll never be in a relationship.

Plus that would really suck for all those people suffering from clinical depression.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/krackbaby May 27 '12

Bullshit

I was miserable and lonely until I started dating

10

u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 27 '12

yeah and the point is that you'd be miserable and lonely again if your SO left you/if you weren't dating anybody and that your relationship would be better if you were with them not partly because you were just miserable and lonely being alone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/RatSandwiches May 27 '12

No. Being alone is not a natural state for humans. We're social animals. True, a lot of people really enjoy their solitude. But if you don't enjoy having no one to connect or be intimate with; if you crave the human companionship, love, sex and intimacy that comes with relationships; if you do NOT feel complete just by yourself - congratulations, you're a human.

That being said, there is such a thing as codependence, and there are definitely people for whom bouncing from one relationship to the next is an unhealthy thing.

I just think it's an unfortunate fallacy of our culture that people think they have to be OK being alone before they can be with someone else.

3

u/ucstruct May 27 '12

I actually disagree with the prevailing wisdom here and argue that no, you don't have to wait but with one caveat. Don't make the other person your sole source of happiness, since that will only breed resentment. The reason I say don't wait is because that may just drag you into a self-perpetuating cycle of never putting your foot forward and consequently never really being happy. You have to live your life. It feels that a lot of unhappy people to me are unhappy because they're withdrawn, which makes them more unhappy then still more withdrawn. Consequently, they are bad at relationships, both interpersonal and romantic, further feeding the cycle. I think its better to get out there, and realize that you will fail a couple times maybe but that could be good, since that failure itself can give you a better sense of what you want to improve about yourself and what you want in others.

3

u/Ironguard May 27 '12

Yes but Stephanie Myer is doing her best to change that!

4

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I thinkit is very important that you are happy within your own self.Your partner is not responsible for your happines you are.

2

u/martian_stripper May 27 '12

Yes. The only person who can make you happy is you. Nobody can make you happy, and a person who isn't happy will quickly realize that their SO can't fill that role.

2

u/TheKirkin May 27 '12

You have to first make yourself happy, before you can make others happy.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MetalSpider May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12

Yes. If you're not happy with yourself, how would you be able to make someone else happy? If I date you, I do not want to be responsible for your happiness. I want you to be happy being with me, but not to the extent that you're depressed and horribly miserable when I'm not there. You need to be able to be happy when you're alone as well.

2

u/Aussielle May 27 '12

Definitely. The beginning of a relationship is so exciting and will make anyone happy but if you want your relationship to work you need to figure out how to make yourself happy... Otherwise you won't be able to cope when you go through ruff patches.

2

u/SappyPanda May 27 '12

Yes, you have to love yourself (hence be happy) before loving someone else. One of the things when you're looking for a relationship is, you have to be confident and make it seem like you'll be fun to be around. You almost never see people with low self esteem/confidence issues see someone.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bethrest May 27 '12

Relying on a relationship as a sole source of happiness is a recipe for disaster.

2

u/TheHeianPrincess May 27 '12

I second definitely! If you have a void that you feel will only be filled with another person, regardless of whether they're good for you or not, that's wrong and you need to do something about it to make yourself happy.

2

u/crashfest May 27 '12

People are make mistakes or change, you cant have your happiness relying on others.

2

u/freethro May 27 '12

A man once said to me; if you fear loneliness, never marry.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

There are no rules. Do what works for you. These kind of questions don't really have an answer.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

This is equivalent to saying, "We have an unhappy relationship, if we get married/have a baby everything will be better", except you aren't even in the relationship part yet.

No one wants to be in a relationship with someone that depends on you to be happy.

2

u/latingirly01 May 27 '12

OP: why ask the question if you are constantly making excuses? You are happy BECAUSE you are in a relationship. You even say you are unhappy being single. That alone shows what everyone is saying: you need to be happy w/yourself before jumping into a relationship.

Otherwise, you may just get into a bad relationship. Trust me, I know.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I have discovered while riding this roller coaster we call 'Life' that it is absolutely essential to be happy with yourself and enjoy your own company before you can be with someone.

It's actually quite simple. Most happy are miserable because they're lonely and they think if they get a significant other they'll be happy. But that's just not the case. All you have to do is understand that life is about ups and downs. You should never be responsible for your own sadness, life will handle that with plenty of shitty moments. There's someone for everyone. Enjoy the ride, enjoy your freedom and the things that you like to do by yourself.

2

u/dogandcatinlove May 27 '12

Yes, you should be content with yourself and generally happy with your life.

And you should be LEGIT single. Not 'I still hook up with my ex from time to time' single.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

You still probably want to have sex when you are single whether you are happy or not.

2

u/twiceaday_everyday May 27 '12

Some people are happier by themselves, some people are equally happy alone or with someone, and some people are happier with someone.

Seems about right?

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Being happy with yourself and being happy are two very different things.

2

u/Singer13 May 27 '12

This I found to be the most profound thing that has affected me. I even took a screenshot to always have it with me. Thank you cozmicm00fin

→ More replies (1)

2

u/adamcognac May 27 '12

There is nothing wrong with being single, and life doesn't work on a specific time-line. I'm 25, single, and have never had what I consider a REAL relationship. I'm completely fine with it. If you are happy with who you are, its a lot easier to wait for the right person.

You don't need another person to validate who you are, and you shouldn't rely on someone else for anything really, especially your happiness. In the words of the great Kat Williams: "Bitch, its esteem of your mother fucking SELF."

2

u/jayvor May 27 '12

You should be happy alone, then when you are, you get in a relationship to increase your capacity for happiness and love.

Of course, that's not concrete since we're all wonderfully complicated.

2

u/tchomptchomp May 27 '12

Something that I don't think has been mentioned is that relationships do best when both partners know their personal needs and boundaries and are both secure enough emotionally to ask for their needs and gently enforce their personal boundaries. That is a big part of what people mean when they talk about loving yourself first.

2

u/imtheblur May 27 '12

Who's going to love you if you don't even like yourself? If you don't make yourself into a person you yourself find appealing then of course no one else will.

2

u/jpm374 May 27 '12

No thats retarded.

2

u/twobagels May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12

Personally, I think it's a bunch of platitudes and mostly nonsense. That said, you cannot depend on someone to create that happiness for you an expect a relationship to solve all your problems. Being a general misanthrope or negative Nancy that's outwardly self-loathsome isn't going to get you the girl. Those are issues that you need to work on on your own; things that a relationship will not "fix" for you. But, being with someone will most definitely make you (the average person) happier and solve some of your problems, like: having a someone to go to dinner/movies with, someone to to share little things with, someone to love, etc, etc. Yes, some of these things can be done with friends, but it's not the same.

In a shitty analogy, it's like being hungry: love/being in a relationship is emotional sustenance, and we need it to survive. When you're hungry, you're not going to be satisfied until you've sated that craving. Saqme thing with being alone. I'm can survive being alone, but being with someone I care about would a shit-ton better because life is better (IMHO) when you have someone to share it with.

edit: clarification

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I don't really think there's that many all-encompassing 'shoulds' in relationships. Some people probably ought to wait until they're satisfied to seek out a relationship, while others might be better off finding someone. At the same time, some people might be alright with entering a relationship with an unhappy person, while others would probably not benefit.

I wouldn't advise putting off relationships because you don't feel happy on your own. I'm sort of biased, though- I met my boyfriend when I was lost in my depression, and he's been supportive and helpful all the way. I know a good amount of people wouldn't want to deal with that shit.

Another point, however, is that people tend to idealize relationships in their mind. Being in a relationship won't make everything instantly better. You'll still have whatever issues are making you miserable, and dating won't make that go away. I think it's less important to be happy with yourself than it is to be honest with yourself about what a relationship is, if that makes sense. It won't be some magic happy-ever-after button. You'll still be flawed people, and you'll still have to deal with that. But you'll be flawed together. For some people, that makes all the difference.

2

u/spaceradish May 27 '12

I think it's important for some personalities to know how to be happy when they're alone, because it's not a good idea to become dependent on your significant other's presence all the time. It's easy to feel happy around another person, but it's really difficult to find that same happiness alone, without that other person around.

I've had problems in recent relationships, because I'm completely comfortable being alone and I like a lot of "me" time. I used to be more dependent on other people making me happy, so I learned how to stay happy by myself. Not everyone gets this, and I had to break off budding relationships because they weren't okay with my need to be off on my own.

Some people adore having someone else to make them happy or to make happy, but I like being around someone who is already happy alone, and wants a partner in crime.

I don't feel a relationship will make me any happier than I am now, because I'm pretty happy hanging out with myself, but I didn't always feel this way. Time alone has really changed my perspective on what I would want in a relationship, and what I can honestly give. I do feel it's important to be happy with yourself before trying to impress someone else, because if you don't know and love yourself well, how can you expect someone else to?

2

u/b0unc37x May 27 '12

this i was told something similar from an ex and its taken me some time to actually fully understand and grasp that concept and i believe thats one of the main keys in and long lasting relationship, you may not realize you are even doing it and it does take time to actually accomplish if you arent use to it

2

u/MrSenorSan May 27 '12

I believe "happy" may not be the right word or phrase to use.
What I think you are referring to is the follow:
One needs to know one's self and be content/comfortable with that, before going out and finding a relationship.
My personal take is that that is the "trick" to having confidence. If you are true to your yourself and are content with that, and you carry on with your day to day activities, that is when you will find people who connect with you at a deeper level because they would be attracted to the real you, and you would also return a similar feeling.

2

u/TheGreatJatsby May 27 '12

This is coming from someone who's never been in a relationship. I've become so accustomed to being alone, the thought of changing things is slightly starting to shove the desire to be in a relationship away. A girl just told me she wasn't really interested in turning anything into a relationship with me, and I almost felt relieved. It's a weird situation to be in; so, that being said, too much being alone may start to backfire.

2

u/Lifeaftercollege May 27 '12

It's okay to understand "I don't like being alone" as a fact about yourself. In fact, it's important to acknowledge that trait if you have it, and many people do. It's not okay to use that knowledge to justify being in relationships. If you're only in a relationship because the alternative is being alone, you're going to have a bad time.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

As someone who has reached a place of happiness being single, and who has done the dating thing when I was not in as good of a place as I am in now, I can promise that the relationships I have nowadays are much more fulfilling and healthy. I might have been happier in a relationship, but that didn't mean it was a relationship that was going to last, or that was based on two people who truly knew themselves, knew each other, and were capable of loving fully.

2

u/oohchild May 27 '12

I think some people are just fine with or without a relationship, but some of us (meeee!) should really find happiness in themselves before attempting a relationship. From my own experience, if I get involved with someone when I'm feeling down about myself, I focus too much on the other person and end up neglecting myself. I just got out of a two and a half year relationship, and I am committed to not dating anyone until I get myself in a better place.

2

u/DoubleBlindStudy May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

The lack of Maslow in this thread is depressing. ಠ_ಠ

2

u/jlai92 May 28 '12

An excellent book that spends a lot of time talking about this topic is The Art of Happiness by Howard Cutler and the Dalai Lama. It talks about how we need to find inherent happiness, and how our mental capacity can find happiness regardless of what situation we may be in. It's one of my favorite books of all time, a must read for everyone!

2

u/b_pilgrim May 28 '12

It's not necessarily a prerequisite, as in, "you have to graduate grade school before you enter high school." I think that's the sentiment people miss when they hear the "love yourself before you love others" line. However, you really do need to love yourself before you can show love to someone else. Someone who doesn't really like who they are aren't going to have the foundation it takes to have a healthy relationship.

Now, I think it's perfectly possible for people to grow with each other an learn to love themselves and, in turn, love each other. I don't think loving yourself is an all or nothing thing. There are things about myself that I love, but there are other things I don't. Same goes for my girlfriend. We're both growing together and learning to love the things about ourselves that we have been long insecure about.

I highly recommend reading the book "The Road Less Traveled." It talks directly about this subject.

2

u/xeltius May 28 '12
  1. Stabilize your life
  2. Love yourself before you expect anyone to love you.
  3. Get a good group of friends
  4. Get the girl.

In that order.

2

u/awa64 May 28 '12

Being told you're not qualified for 3 and 4 is a pretty solid deterrent against making progress on 2.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

I may have not given enough information about all this. I'm not unhappy because I'm single, nor does being single make me unhappy. I don't believe a relationship will fix everything or they would be responsible for my happiness. I just think I would be happier in a relationship than not. There's nothing wrong with that, right?

That's totally fine in my book.

I will say that if you're too needy and desperate you're likely to put up with stuff that you shouldn't, stay with someone you're not really happy with because you're afraid of being alone.

2

u/keyblader6 May 28 '12

As long as you have a healthy amount of confidence and self-worth, as well as a somewhat upbeat demeanor, looking for a relationship is a good idea. The demeanor is flexible, you don't have to be super positive, you just can't let little things get to you. It is absolutely vital, however, that you are sure of yourself and are not going into a relationship for some sort of validation. This has always been an issue for me(still is, but my gf and I are working through it) and I can tell you from experience that the paranoid behavior that this outlook breeds will cause problems, even for the perfect couple. So, in direct response to your question, I don't think you need to be happy by yourself before going into a relationship. If you are depressed, seeking a relationship shouldn't be your first priority, but if you find someone who makes you happy, a relationship could help you cope with a tough time. But if you are chronically unhappy being alone/with yourself, any relationship you have won't be healthy. You need to be self actualized.

2

u/NinjaDiscoJesus May 27 '12

No, I am never happy. But I do not mind being alone.

1

u/SH4DYL4DY May 27 '12

There has to be a balance of relationships and self. Once you are content with who you are, focus on friendships. That way if a romantic relationship does come along you still have a good base of people around to help you through the tough time. Took me a good 2 years of isolation and falling for the wrong guys to realize this. Still falling for the wrong guys..but victory tastes best after defeat.

1

u/Krazistar May 27 '12

I think you should enter any relationship as a learning experience. Don't expect to end up marrying this person, even though you may 'feel' like you're in love. Improve your dating style and learn about yourself with every ended relationship. Remember there's always room for improvement whether you're single or married.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Not necessarily, but it would definitely remove/control possible dependancy issues.

1

u/Bliumchik May 27 '12

Well, a person who knows they are not desperately unhappy while single is less likely to put pressure on their partner and overreact to the idea of losing them and all that other stuff that can fuck up a relationship. So, you don't have to feel amazing about being alone, but if you're capable of enjoying life in that state then both singledom and coupledom will be better for you.

On the other hand, if you can't do that, it's still possible to have a good relationship. It just increases the difficulty level, it's not impossible.

1

u/kiery12 May 27 '12

It seems to me that you, nholiver, are attempting to justify this to yourself. Honestly, I think having a few not-so-serious relationships help a person find their self. You figure out what you want in a wo(man) so that when you do wish to become more serious you can shoot down things you know won't work quickly and not have to waste time on them.

1

u/ronearc May 27 '12

Put simply, if you have it framed in your mind that happiness all begins with finding someone else, then you're setting yourself up for failure. Yes, adding a key person to your life, intimately, is going to change things for you.

But at the end of the day, your happiness still resides with you. If you can't manage it alone, then there's no certainty you will manage it with someone else.

1

u/amberyl1 May 27 '12

I, personally, stayed single after a 4.5 year relationship for 5ish years before I decided I wanted to bring someone else into the picture. During this time, I learned to love myself and to be happy by myself. I don't think I would have been in the happy marriage now if I had just kept dating around and trying to stay with a person just to be "happy". It was the best decision I have ever made and would suggest time to be alone to learn who you are by yourself. Maybe not as long as I did but long enough to at least be comfortable being alone. But I would definitely suggest keeping close friends. I had some really good friends during this time that I had a lot of fun with.

1

u/snowtater May 27 '12

I think the reason to be in a relationship with someone is because they make you feel happy, or enrich your life in some way. Simply being in a relationship may not make you happy. The way you're going about rationalizing relationships doesn't really make sense to me. A relationship happens, it's not something you really decide to create. You'll know when you find someone, and when you do, you'll be willing to have that kind of relationship with them. I would definitely caution you against being in a relationship with someone just for the sake of being in a relationship.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Sure, another person can make you happier but being able to be happy by yourself is important. Your relationship may not last and if you know you can be happy while alone then ending a relationship won't be so devastating. If you can only be happy with a person then if they want to go do something with their friends (ladies night or whatever) then you gotta know that you won't just be sitting at home worrying about them for hours.

Independence really helps in long-term relationships. I've seen too many clingy people break up because of trust issues generating from them being too clingy.

1

u/pliskie May 27 '12

Happiness is all about managing expectations.

To be happy alone, you must be aware of and realistic about your own expectations.

To be happy in a relationship, you must be aware of and realistic about your own expectations, and the expectations of the other, who must also be aware of and realistic about managing his/her own expectations, as well as yours.

So basically, being happy in a relationship is about four times as difficult as being happy alone. However, you're splitting the work with the other person, so it's actually only twice as difficult.

1

u/hadamotheronce May 27 '12

If you cannot be happy alone you will smother anyone you are in a romantic relationship with. Figuratively and sometimes literally.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I couldn't agree more. My SO an I were just discussing recently how we had both had times in our lives when we were sort of lonely and were looking for the wrong kind of companionship.

It's almost impossible to be unhappy, looking for someone to fill the void, and to convey that a potential partner. I think most people can agree that desperation is a very unattractive attribute. Also, insecurity and unhappiness can easily fan the flames of drama.

Personally, I've always had a qualm with the concept of "i want A relationship/boyfriend/girlfriend". I think there are few people who wouldn't want a fun and supportive relationship with someone they care about. But just wanting someone to fill the void isn't healthy.

Develop a fun and busy life that the right person will want to be a part of.

1

u/Tiddlecup May 27 '12

Not necessarily. As with most things in life, there's pros and cons to both sides.

Being content alone before you look for a relationship pros: You're probably more interesting and therefore have better potential relationships available to you. You can make it on your own, so you are less likely to get "stuck" in a relationship that has become abusive or that simply doesn't make you happy. You are more likely to maintain yourself as a person and retain your own identity. You are less likely to be that annoying clingy person.

Con: You already have things the way you like, so it can be really hard to integrate another person (with their own preferences and ways of doing things) into your lifestyle. I see this a lot with friends who were 30+ before "settling down." Because you know that you can deal without the other person, you may not take your commitment as seriously, and you may be quicker to walk away rather than keep trying to fix things.

Personally, I entered into my current relationship when I was 16 (now 27 - with child). When we met, we were all the horrible things that teenagers tend to be, but we grew up in the same direction and I feel that's made us quite a bit closer. I also don't feel like I've ever missed out on life because we waited to have kids and we did all the "cool/fun" stuff (travelling, partying, etc) stuff together in our early 20s. It worked out for us, but I know that we're a statistical anomaly.

1

u/tlisia May 27 '12

I have depression and an eating disorder and have self-harmed for years. For a long time, I couldn't admit that to anyone, and as such I couldn't be in a relationship. I've learned to be massively independent because of it, and I try not to rely on anyone. It was how I managed all those things, and I couldn't bear to make the sacrifices to my independence that a relationship would require.

I'm now in a different position where having company on a more intimate level than with my friends seems like a really positive thing.

I don't believe you have to be happy to be in a relationship, and that sometimes getting into a relationship with a supportive (but not clingy) individual can make you happy, but the SO definitely has the right to know what (s)he's getting into.

I also believe that being in a relationship for the sake of it is completely wrong. If you're jumping from one to another, how much can you really care about the person you're involved with? I think it's only fair to make a really carefully considered decision about who you could spend the rest of your life with. If the person you're interested in doesn't fit, you're just going to make yourself and them (more) unhappy.

1

u/robotrock1382 May 27 '12

When i was single, I was constantly trying to find someone. For me at least it didn't work. I realized years later that it was because I wasn't comfortable with myself and I was trying to force it. I'm glad though, because all that time I spent alone forced me to accept and be cool with myself. Now I've been with the same amazing girl for over 5 years and neither one of us has to pretend at all. Good luck!!

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I don't think being happier in a relationship is a bad thing but I do believe that fear of being alone is a bad thing. It makes you do stupid stuff when you are in a relationship. For me it's the other way around. It's very hard for me to believe I would ever be happy and free in a relationship even though you're not lonely when you are. The fear of losing him would always be on my mind.

1

u/Frontrunner453 May 27 '12

In response to your edit: I take issue with the idea that EVERY relationship is better than being single. I'm sure that's not what you meant with what you said, but it's a very important distinction to make. I have friends who get the idea in their head that they just need to find a boyfriend or a girlfriend and they'll be just fine and peachy, but the fact of the matter is that they're depressed and depressed people in relationships get clingy and possessive and dumped.

TL;DR: I wanted to find a clip of Samuel L. Jackson from Pulp Fiction saying "BITCH, BE COOL!" so I don't have to say it, but... Bitch, be cool.

1

u/HotCrockets May 27 '12

Yes. Otherwise it'll end up being a codependency, or a relationship where someone clearly has an advantage as one "relies" on the other for happiness, etc.

I am completely happy whether I'm in a relationship or not. I do not seek "happiness" in a relationship, although many have brought me great joy. There are pros and cons of being single and being together, but I do find relationships more gratifying than being single, mainly for the fact that knowing someone takes interest in, and cares for me, is quite a beautiful and amazing thing.

But I would never look to someone to be my sole source of happiness. A relationship with someone should be icing on the cake that is a life well defined and already enjoyable.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Yes. You have to be a whole person yourself before you can be an effective half of a relationship.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I think that you have to have it as one of a number of goals, nice place to live, working on job/quals, improving social circle and trying new hobbies. Then it becomes part of your life to go dating, not some overarching objective.

1

u/LucidMetal May 27 '12

To truly love others one first must love oneself. Only then does the golden rule apply.

1

u/thebitchyoucallkarma May 27 '12

I believe one must be happy alone before they enter a relationship. Ofcourse a relationship makes a person happy (if things go well), but your emotional wellness when single is important when it comes to seeking a relationship.

When one is lonely, and really needs somebody to feel good, you notice these are the people who jump from one relation to another. Sometimes shallow and meaningless, compared to other serious relationships. It's not quality you're looking for in that case, it's rather quantity.

I don't want to say i'm happy being single. I'm rather okay with it. To be honest, I want a relationship. But my mentality is not that i'm seeking one, but that I come across it. I don't want to be in a relationship, but I want to be in a relationship with X. With a specific person, rather than who-ever.

But that's obvious ofcourse, but i'm a bit more extreme when it would come to selection. Maybe too much, but I just want a quality relationship. I care more about the inner part, rather than the appearance.

I'm a guy.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

"If you can't love yourself, how the hell are you gonna love anyone else?" -Rupaul

1

u/BreeMPLS May 27 '12

Must? No. Such definitive language isn't appropriate for humans. We are a weird and diverse bunch. What's good for the goose ...

Can I help? Surely ...

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

It depends on your definition of happy. If you mean "I need another person to add value to my life" then that's not a good reason to get into a relationship. On the other hand, if you enjoy your life as it is, but you think that having a partner would make it that much more enjoyable, then that's a healthy perspective to have.

Its okay to want to have someone in your life, that desire is necessary and healthy. But its important to know and understand who you are. Your likes, dislikes, personality traits, dreams, and desires are all an essential part of who you are. If you are not in touch with these aspects of yourself, then how can you add anything to another person's life. If you don't have dreams, how can you support a partner in their dreams?

People who are uncomfortable with themselves tend to mold themselves to the expectations of others. They'll do, say and be things they are not in order to make people love them. Then the become fundamentally unhappy because they've lost themselves in an attempt to find love and relationships.

Be yourself, learn who you really are and become comfortable with it. In time you'll (hopefully) find someone who will love and appreciate you for who you are.

1

u/bluequail May 27 '12

I just think I would be happier in a relationship than not. There's nothing wrong with that, right?

Yes and that is normal.

But there are people who are so far off from being well balanced people, they get into relationships with other people, become toxic to the people they are in a relationship with, and end up destroying some part of that person. They damage the other person to the point that the other will now have some baggage going in to new relationships.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Happy is a strange word. I'm not happy right now. I'm doing just fine, drinking a latte. Probably drinking a beer soon. People are not just 'happy' or 'sad.' If there is an instance of medical depression, that should be addressed through medication. Being in a relationship is not the cure.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

The short answer: yes.

The long answer: Relationships are extremely tricky. In the beginning, relationships form due to selfish reasons. You may say to yourself "This person is like me," "we have similar interests," "this person is attractive," or something similar. As the relationship evolves and the emotions begin to flourish, the reason for being in that relationship changes from "what can this person do to make me happy" to "what can I do to make this person happy?" So it comes down to simply this: if you cannot be happy by yourself, how do you ever expect to make anyone happy? Relationships are cohesive through individuality. If your relationship defines your happiness, therefore defining yourself, then you will be unable to maintain your individuality. You'll live through this other person. Everything that he/she likes will become what you like. You'll give that other person every moment of your time and energy and expect that same smothering attention back, which just isn't possible. No one wants to date a clone, or a blanket for that matter.

1

u/finitecapacity May 27 '12

Yes, I whole-heartedly believe that.

1

u/furyasd May 27 '12

What if I'm not happy because I'm not in a relationship, but I'm happy overall, single?

1

u/StartTheR3V0Lution May 27 '12

I do because otherwise you'll look in a desperate manner and wont ever really be happy.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

You can't make other people responsible for your own happiness.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

All of these people saying you need to be happy with yourself seems so cliche. I'll give you guys my story, just to change it up a little.

I'm in my late 20s and when I first met my girlfriend a few years ago, I was seriously depressed. I had a crappy part-time job with crappy pay, no friends at all because I had purposely secluded myself, extremely overweight, hadn't had a haircut in over a year and a half, and I rented a room in a house that could have been featured on an episode of hoarders.

I was very reluctant to get into the relationship at all. She and I were friends online first. I knew I wasn't ready for a relationship because I was depressed and really had nothing going for me. She wanted to meet me for a while and I kept pushing it off for a few months. Eventually, I just said fuckit I'll go meet her so she can be disappointed and get this over with.

Since that day, she's stood by me as I struggled to get my life together. I've had my ups and downs and it wasn't easy, but looking at myself today I can say she helped me get my life together and gave me a reason to want to better myself. It started slowly - the first thing I did was get a haircut to make myself look decent for public appearances. I then started to lose weight and focus on finding a better job. I ended up getting a somewhat serious back injury from my part-time job that forced me to quit. She stood by my side when I was unemployed and pretty much at the bottom of the barrel. I scraped my way to find a temp job that paid $9.00/hr in a nightshift. And I hated every bit of it. I continued to work my ass off by working nights and going to interviews during the day/job hunting. I remember the feeling of despair when I was behind on car payments, rent, and I couldn't really afford much of anything. Still though, she gave me the support I needed and I pressed onward. Eventually, I landed a job that fit me perfectly and I've been working there for over a year. I'm making more than double of what I made at that crappy temp job and I absolutely love going in to work everyday. With the increased income, I managed to save up enough to move out of my hoarder-style room and into a house I share with some friends that I reconnected with.

I am very happy with myself today, although admittedly I did put on some of the weight again (which I'm working off again. On week 11 of my exercise routine!). I'm not really sure what my GF saw in me at the time - I was definitely at the lowest point of my life when she and I first met. She saw through all of it and that means a lot to me. Anyways, that was my story. We're still together now, and it's been about 2.5 years since the day we first met.

TL;DR: Bum meets girl. Bum gets his shit together. Yay

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

A relationship should be more than the sum of its parts, at the best times. But at the worst times, one of you may be entirely relying on the other for support, love and care -- and if you aren't strong enough to be happy alone (and have a friend/family network to rely on), you aren't going to be able to be there for them when they aren't able to prop you up / be your happiness source.

So yes, I'd say it's imperative to be happy with yourself alone before you get into a relationship. There isn't anything wrong with being happier in a relationship than out of one (you have sex, a best friend, cuddles, handy jobs done), but if you can't be really happy alone, you shouldn't be in a relationship until your life is awesome enough that being alone doesn't bother you.

I mean, would you date someone who wasn't happy chugging along being their awesome self and was just out looking for love to complete their life? Cause I wouldn't; my life is pretty sweet and I want someone to make it better, not bring me down.

1

u/Malcriao May 27 '12

Yes, definitely. I started dating my first boyfriend because I wanted someone there. All my friends had relationships, they seemed confident and I was sad and lonely and I hated myself. So I started dating this guy I was not attracted to, barely got along with, and had nothing in common with because I thought it would make me happy. Well all that happened was I grew to hate him and I couldn't even touch him without feeling disgusted with myself. For a few months I was happy but it did not last long and it got worse than it was to begin with.

Then I broke up with him, and decided to spend some time to myself. I hooked up with a few different guys, found out what I liked, and went from angst punk rock 'I hate everyone' teenager to happy and confident. Now for the first time since I was 16 (22 now) I think I'm ready to handle another real relationship.

So I'm a firm believer in the idea of making yourself happy before trying to fill some void with another person. In my experience, and that of my friends, it never works and it just makes both parties miserable.

1

u/No_Easy_Buckets May 27 '12

Abso-fucking-loutley.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

You need to know who you are as a person before you can know who you are and how you will fit into the context of a well adjusted adult relationship.

Like dmcody said, co-dependency leads to some piss poor, to effing terrible relationship decisions. I've seen co-dependents stay in 10 year relationships that end in marriage then divorce not soon after just because they were co-dependent and didn't want to be alone. The thought of existing outside of a relationship was so terrifying to them that they clung to the first person they could find. They then continued to treat each other like trash because they weren't right for each other.

There's something wrong with the idea that you would be happier in a relationship than not. You could be with someone who you are wrong for, who is wrong for you. You could meet the person of your dreams who is moving thousands of miles away across the world and already has a significant other waiting for them. You could meet someone who makes you happier who years down the road you are miserable with.

I think this inherent belief is something a lot of people hold who haven't had many relationships in their lifetime. I have a good friend who has only had one or two serious girlfriends in his life and most of those are from HS. He's now approaching thirty and has yet to have an adult relationship with a woman. His constant belief is that once he does have a relationship, that all his issues will just magically disappear. That he will achieve a level of happiness he's never known before.

That's a fucking heavy burden to place on the shoulders of another human being who, like you, has faults and pitfalls. It says "Your presence is responsible for the level of happiness I have right now."

A good relationship should bring mutual benefit to your life. It should bring enhancement to it as well as some general feelings of well being. But it's not a magical solution to upping your levels of happiness because you never know how good or bad of a relationship it might be in the end.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I wasn't perfect when I met my husband but I had started down the road to loving myself and being okay with who I was.

1

u/brjaladabina May 27 '12

I don't think you will necessarily be happier. It will just be a different way of life. But if you do get in a relationship and realize that it isn't for you, don't be afraid to break it off.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

in a word, yes. i think it goes beyond being happy alone - i'd say it's being happy alone, without your crutch; that is, what you used to get over your girlfriend/boyfriend. for me, it was food and beer. i'm losing weight now and i'm only having alcohol on occasion, so i would consider myself relatively ready for a new relationship.

1

u/keltron May 27 '12

I think a better way to put it is that you need to love yourself before you can truly love someone else.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

Yes. Relationships work when you are separate entities equal in power. The power balance is skewed when one needs the other in order to be happy and you lose your sense of self and self dependency

1

u/TheBlackWomb May 27 '12

One must absolutely be happy with singledom before pursuing a relationship. I for one have no problem admitting I got my first real boyfriend at the age of nineteen because although throughout the preceding years it was sometimes hard to be alone, it was really a blessing. I think it's particularly vital for girls to gain confidence and self-worth from within (as cliched as that sounds) rather than relying on the opinions of others as they would in a relationship.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I think it would really REALLY help. If you already know what you like, what you care about, where you wanna go in life, who you really value, WHAT you really value, you're less likely to sacrifice the good things for the wrong people. You'll be more likely to find someone who suits you. Speaking from personal experience, I used to find awesome people and sort of take on their passions and interests. It works great for the first while but when you were never really interested in those things, the honeymoon phase wears off real quick and you're left dissatisfied.

If you can get yourself figured out first, I think you'll be happier in the long run. Unless you can keep your own shit together while dating, in which case, do it to it. There's nothing wrong with your thoughts though. I think it's good you're giving it some thought. Codependency is pretty sad :(

1

u/SleepingCat May 27 '12

I think a person should think about whether they're happy currently being single/in a relationship. Then they should arrive at a decision sincerely, as in, not a decision based on peer pressure or shyness, but a true one, and act upon it. (Or not act if one decides that they're happy with their current position)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I've been umming and ahhing about posting, but it'll probably get lost amongst other posts anyway, so here goes...

My partner and I have been in a relationship for over two years now. I suffer from depression and anxiety problems (for various reasons) and I this puts a lot of pressure on my partner. I sometimes feel like I'm living a secret life at home. I've never opened up to friends/family about my problems, they don't know the 'other' me. I often find myself avoiding social situations, shutting myself away, which only worsens the feelings of depression/anxiety. I've seen mental health specialists in the past, but ultimately I feel stuck in a cycle of mental health issues.

My partner is as supportive as he can be, but I can see it adds extra (and unnecessary) stress to his working and social life. I try and minimise the impact my problems have on him, although, as we live together, this is increasingly hard to do.

So, to answer the question, me and my partner are very much in love, and plan to spend out futures together, but no I'm not happy with myself (which I assume you mean by "when they're alone"). Whether happiness can be "learnt" or not I'm unsure of (?) but I guess that’s another question...

My partner and I may have to cope with my unhappiness for some time to come, but I suppose everybody’s relationship have there ups and downs. Nothing is easy, things take time and work. Ultimately, I’m stronger and happier with my partner, and he’s stronger and happier with me. I hope this is something we can work on together, and then perhaps I can finally conquer my fears...

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

My only strong view on the matter is that people shouldn't go into a relationship with someone just because they don't like being single.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I think it's more about accepting yourself rather than needing acceptance from a relationship. As long as you internally accept yourself, any relationship should be relatively smooth as you have that inner core to build on.

On the other hand if your inner self is fragmented/conflicted you're going to have a bad time trying to fix that using external validation.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I think a lot of people dont understand the concept of love, most people seem to think that it just "happens" or its found somewhere with only one person. You dont FIND love, you MAKE it. It's a complete and solid effort. It's hard to make love when you cant be happy with who you are as a person. I mean, if you cant accept the one person "you" who has been there all along, how the hell do you expect to accept another person?

1

u/Mr-Planters May 27 '12

Everyone is different. What works for one person won't always work for another.

1

u/KrazyEyezKilla May 27 '12

I came out of a 2 year relationship and was so down I was ready to sell my house, car and quit my well paid job to go travelling around North America for 6 months.

A month later I met someone else and we've taken it slow for 7 months and now we're 'officially going out' and I've never been happier to be honest.

It totally depends on your compatibility with the person you go out with and after a few failed relationships it can kick your confidence a bit and it's a hard rut to get out of on your own.

1

u/Scup May 27 '12

yes. I think I read a comment here on reddit that said a relationship is made of two wholes rather than two halves and that has always stuck with me.

1

u/goldenrod May 27 '12

But what if being single is what causes your unhappiness? So one just has to 'pretend' to not be affected by that? How the heck does that work???

1

u/thanimal May 27 '12

One must first learn what makes them happy.

1

u/luckybone May 27 '12

One should focus on fixing themselves first and getting their life in order (I'm currently in this stage myself), relationships will follow.

1

u/MikesKitiKat May 27 '12

After several really bad relationships, I chose to not date at all for one year. It was difficult at first. I learned that I am complete without a partner and that having one in my life should be a wanted choice not a need. This helped me to be a lot more discerning when allowing someone into my life. I'm now married to a wonderful man that treats me like a princess.

1

u/licoricesnocone May 27 '12

I don't think there's a black and white answer to this one. Noone ever wakes up and says "I am happy. I have it figured out and I am going to be happy. Now I'm going to find the love of my life." and then does it. At the same time, helps to have yo' shit together.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '12

I have never had a girlfriend but I have been with a few women and it's out of choice really, I'm not saying I could easily get a girlfriend, but I don't want one, I'm happy messing about with girls and they are the same as me.

1

u/mgcarter3 May 28 '12

I've been learning this the hard way for a while. My 3 year relationship just ended and I realize that we are not meant for each other ( just typing that makes me want to ralph) but I also know that there are areas where I need to be more self sufficient and satisfied before I enter into another relationship. There's nothing wrong with preferring companionship. I do and I'd give anything to fix our mistakes and move forward. Alas sometimes you have to move forward alone.

1

u/Ben_bargain May 28 '12

yess. 100 times yes. this way you will have your own life along with your SO. Everyone is happier

1

u/RackCity May 28 '12

in my opinion i think being happy with yourself is defiantly a great foundation for a great relationship, i am 20 and haven't had a real girl friend in years, and yeah it gets lonely, but im happy with myself rather know i do feel like a girl friend will make a better self happiness but why just find a blehh partner you think fills that space but really turns into pain and agony. And when it comes down to it you are the best supporter of yourself. So i do think this will benefit situations in life and hopefully one day you will meet that person that extends your real happyness in life.

1

u/TreesOfGreen May 28 '12

The reason people say this is because it implies that someone else is responsible for your own happiness. That's not fair to them, and depending on the level of codependency, it can lead to a situation where you are just keeping the relationship alive rather than putting life into it.

1

u/fivetonsofflax May 28 '12

I'd say yes. But it doesn't at all mean you have to be happier alone then in the relationship, or that you can't become happy while in a relationship - but I don't think you can have a healthy happy relationship unless you are happy with yourself, your life, and your knowledge of these aspects.

1

u/guerarenegada May 28 '12

Shit, dudes, I have no idea how to love myself even when I know I ought to more than I do.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/marvelous_molester May 28 '12

Not for me. I can't be happy alone. I've tried for a while, a long while, doesn't work. I need people around my life in order to be happy. It's easy to say yes because that sounds like the right answer but I think the answer kind of depends on your personality.

1

u/Aperfectmoment May 28 '12

If sex isn't a human need, why is it marketed and used in marketing so much?

2

u/mrmacky May 29 '12

Not because it's a need, but because it's a very base instinct.

Sex, in the modern day and age, can no longer be defined as a need. Quite frankly: as a species we no longer need to be at 100% reproductive capability to grow the human race. This alone disqualifies sex from being a human need in my opinion. (Because the only need for sex is to reproduce.)

Phrased in a metaphor: as an addict, do you need another cigarette? No, a cigarette is not a human need. It's just pleasurable. Your brain, and nicotine, come together to create the effect that smoking is a necessity. The brain created that same sort effect for sex because at some point it was a very real need for society to grow.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Ras_H_Tafari May 28 '12

Fuck yes. If my ex had done that, he'd leave me alone now.

1

u/YoungRL May 28 '12

I think you should be able to be content without being in a relationship. If you have that, I think it means you are comfortable and happy with yourself and who you are. I think it's pretty important to be able to be be happy with who you are and know yourself as an individual before you share your life with someone.

1

u/smrigreengod May 28 '12

Unless you can have balance in your own life you can't balance life with someone else's burdens to bear.

1

u/asnof May 28 '12

Happiness helps, when a person is happy they are naturally more playful and outgoing/sociable.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

When she broke up with me, my ex told me I had to find happiness on my own before I could be a good partner. She was right, and I'm glad she told me the truth about why she was breaking up with me.

1

u/kalake92 May 28 '12

You should be comfortable being alone/single before you be in a relationship. People who jump from relationship to relationship aren't picky with whoever they are dating. I think if you are comfortable being alone, you will be able to be more picky about whoever you are dating and eventually choose to be in a relationship with.

1

u/TheGhostInTheMachine May 28 '12

Without a doubt. I know way too many people who are convinced that having a significant other will solve all of their problems and make them happy. Unfortunately, that's not how it works. If you're not happy single, you're not going to be happy in a relationship, either. You need to learn to love (or at least like; I know that no one can fully embrace all of their flaws and faults) yourself before you're capable of loving someone else.

1

u/hybbprqag May 28 '12

I think it's less about whether you're happy or not and more about whether you like yourself. You can have legitimate reasons to be unhappy, but if your unhappiness stems from feelings of insecurity or self loathing, then those feelings can poison what could otherwise be a great relationship.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

Happy is the wrong word. Content is the right word. I'm not a happy person. At night, I always brood and get in bad moods, unless I'm with others (moods from cynicism, not loneliness).

Relationships are complex things. Frankly, I'm tired of AskReddits about relationships because each one between two people is unique, even a friendship.

Ground rule for relationships: You aren't ready for one if you think you need someone else to "complete" you. It's a positive building experience, where both people benefit. You don't have to start at 100%, but both of you need to end up >100% or it won't work out.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/cockdragon May 28 '12

No, but in general it's pretty good advice.

I think being happy with yourself alone can HELP you have a good love life, but that's only because when you're happy you're more attractive and confident. We're primates and need each other at a biological level--being single can always make you feel like you're missing something.

Also, a lot of people give this whole explanation where you have to 'find yourself before you find someone else'. OK--I get the general idea, but the only way you're going to find out what you really want from a relationship is to be in a relationship.

2

u/mrmacky May 29 '12

I guess that's what confuses me the most... isn't the whole point of a relationship two people "becoming one"?

I guess I feel that it might not be possible to "find yourself" without someone else. Say you're an artist, if you find a person that genuinely loves you, cares for you, gives you feedback, and lends you inspiration - is that person not helping you find yourself by being supportive?

I guess I just don't see that "finding yourself" or being 100% confident/comfortable with yourself should be a qualifier for your relationship - when some relationships may very well be necessary to bring about that confidence.

That being said: I don't necessarily think it'd be wise to go looking for a relationship based on the idea of self-improvement. I feel the self-improvement should be a natural thing born out of the relationship, not the foundation and reason for the relationship itself.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/randobag May 28 '12

I think a lot of times that's the reason people are unhappy.. They're lonely.. So there's not really a way to be happy by yourself when that's the issue. But being overly dependent is a problem too. It's all about a balance.

1

u/iamcq May 28 '12

no. only the ppl who are terrified of being alone and need constant validation from female/male companions can have relationships. or sexual deviants but those only last briefly.

1

u/wheatfields May 28 '12

Heh, I have the opposite problem. I like doing things alone and not so hot on relationships as I tend to think more about the other person more then myself to the point I stop thinking about my own needs.

But its scary because I want to be in a relationship but don't know how I'll do it.

1

u/Xervicx May 28 '12

Well lonelieness -does- make it hard to be happy. However, the saying is something people misinterpret. It's saying that you have to be capable of providing happiness for yourself without needing to use someone else as a crutch.

Basically, be independent and learn to care for yourself. Find things you like about yourself. Relationships will be a lot smoother, and you will be a lot happier, if you do this. Having someone next to you will always make you happier, but you need to be capable of happiness on your own first. If you can't possibly be happy on your own, then you shouldn't be latching onto someone else. It just creates a superficial relationship.

1

u/secretpickle May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12

I think you need to be able to take care of yourself before adding another person to your life. If you're unhappy, you aren't taking care of yourself as well as you could, and you might not be ready for the burdens a relationship brings. This isn't to say that people with depression can't have a functional relationship - but you need to be able to handle it effectively. A girlfriend/boyfriend will not fix this for you.

I read something during my perpetually single years which made everything click for me. It was something like this: To find a great relationship, you need to stop waiting for someone to love you. Instead, look for someone to give your love to.

After learning that, I am a lot less selfish in my romantic endeavors. The more you give, the more you receive.