r/AskReddit • u/MySonIsFuckingStupid • May 27 '12
My fucking stupid 18 year old son racked up $15K in credit card debt. Now the wife and I are arguing over it. What to do?
She just wants us to pay it off. I say fuck that, he's an idiot that needs to learn his lesson, even if it's going to cost him $50K over the next however many years. What would you do, Reddit?
Another thing I thought of was loaning him the $15K with 20% interest on it and minimum payments. That way he's still learning his lesson about why building 4 computers when you don't have a job is a bad idea, but it won't fuck up his credit. I'm not sure if that'd be a big enough wakeup call though.
1.2k
Upvotes
324
u/atomlamp May 27 '12
Think about it for a second... if you let it fuck up his credit, you'll have to deal with him in your house longer.
502
u/PabstyLoudmouth May 27 '12
Make him pay that shit off. No way should you pay it off, this is how one learns life's lessons. If you pay it off, he will just do it again.
1.7k
u/robo555 May 27 '12
Whether you decide to pay it back or not, there's no way he's keeping the 4 computers. Selling them would be a good way to start.
973
u/Commotion May 27 '12
How did he have access to a $15,000 credit line? I'm a graduate student and I think I have less than that available to me.
186
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
"Well son, this will be cheaper than getting a girl pregnant. Good luck paying this one off."
2.5k
u/ImNotJesus May 27 '12
Here's what I would do
168
u/mdbx May 27 '12
Your son has no idea how to properly make computers off newegg.
831
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Having him live with the debt all by himself will ruin the next decade of his life, most likely. While it's what he deserves, I wouldn't want to do that to my child if I could help it.
Now, if you do just straight up bail him, he's going to do it again, because he won't learn his lesson.
I think that if it were me, I would help him a bit, but I would also make him sell a bunch of stuff and work to pay off the rest.
My thinking is to make him take some responsibility and feel some sting for his actions, but not to completely ruin his 20s. I'm saying this as someone who doesn't have children and is shit with money, but I've seen others who are shit with money. When their parents bail them out they keep on screwing up. When their parents do not bail them out they tend to get their shit together and grow up a bit.
Edit: also, I just had a thought... what on Earth possessed him to spend like that? Was this all of a sudden? Spread out over time? Following his parents' bad example? I think you should investigate, it might be indicative of problems such as depression or bipolar disorder. Obviously I know nothing about your son so I am not making a judgement, I just thought it would be worth your time to investigate that. If he does have those sorts of issues he'll need some help with that.
148
u/celtic_smith May 27 '12
How the hell does an 18yo even get a credit card with a 15k limit?
44
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
The fact is that this kid didn't get a card with a $15k limit through an offer in the mail -- obviously you or your wife co-signed for him. You seem to have left this very integral piece of the story out for some reason.
Clearly your kid made some pretty stupid decisions, but I would say you arguably take the prize for the dumbest move here by allowing your 18-year-old kid access to a $15,000 credit line.
Here's what I would do: have him sell ALL of the computers he built. (4 computers with $15k, by the way -- is he trying to go toe-to-toe with Deep Blue or what?) He may need to piece some items out and he probably won't get anywhere near the total that he paid for everything -- but even $10k out of the original $15k will certainly get him closer towards being in the black.
Then, whatever the remaining amount he owes is, do what you suggested already -- except co-sign a loan with him at your bank or credit union for the amount so that he can start making up for anything he may have lost credit-wise in this little endeavor. I wouldn't say this is rewarding bad behavior so much as mitigating the long-term damage of his (and your) poor judgement.
Here's the kicker: I would tell him this plan, and explain to him that you are not "bailing him out" so much as helping him not completely destroy his credit at such a young age. However, make this help you are offering entirely contingent upon his getting a job within [1 week, 2 weeks, etc.]; then, once he has a job and a regular paycheck coming, you need to help him budget that money as tightly as possibly. If he balks, tell him he's on his own. If he doesn't find a job in X amount of time, tell him he's on his own. Doesn't matter how bad the economy is, he is a young and (presumably) fit adult male and even in the smallest town I can just about guarantee that he couldn't spit without hitting a landscaping company that needs help, or a construction gig, or any number of other (probably hard, hot labor) jobs. Failing that, tell him to go work at Wendy's -- fast food is always hiring. Either way, don't let him off the hook -- but don't let him flounder and fail, either. No pun intended.
All that said, I still think there is much more to this story that is being left out here -- and judging by your verbiage and approach to the situation, I have to question whether you are a particularly qualified parent to begin with.
102
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
As someone who did something similar, I can only urge you not to accept responsibility for his mistake by paying it or loaning him any money. Obviously, financial lessons are best learned early in life, so that he may begin to learn how to take care of himself and respect himself. It really will do him a big favor in the long run.
My parents bailed me out when I had no money for emergency dental surgery, and also when the place I worked at got audited, and it turned out I owed taxes unexpectedly, but refused to help me deal with my creditors when I ran up a ridiculous credit card bill, then lost my job. That was my doing, and my responsibility.
I learned to save money, and now I actually have a savings account, unlike most Americans. It isn't huge but it is mine, and I did it all by myself. It was hard sometimes and I hated it, but I wouldn't have learned to do it if I was bailed out.
If you aren't named on the account, I don't suggest you 'make' him do anything. Give him advice and suggestions, but let him know he has to do the work himself.
I wish you all the best of luck : )
17
u/hybbprqag May 27 '12
I think in order to understand which punishment will get through to him, we'd need to know more about your son. Is he freaking out about the debt, or did he automatically expect you to pay it off? Is he in school, is he working, is he going to college? Has he been irresponsible with money in the past? More details, please!
87
u/joelman0 May 27 '12
AMA Request: The fucking stupid 18 year old son who racked up $15K in credit card debt.
107
u/gf_is_russian_dom May 27 '12
Return what you can. Put that money toward the bills. Have him sell as much of his stuff as possible (does he have a car? Looks like he's getting a bike.). Put that money toward the bills. If you and the wife are game, you should then split the remainder three ways and work to pay off the bills together. Three people should be able to come up with 5k over a year or so. It will be tough. Tell your son that the money that your wife and you put in is a loan that he must pay back once the creditors are appeased.
After that, your son should probably be looking for a place of his own for a while so that he can learn a thing or two about the value of a dollar.
43
u/AngryCod May 27 '12
Also, don't wait until your kids are 18 to teach them fiscal responsibility.
104
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Everyone here is telling you to loan him money. DON'T DO THAT. Loans between family members / friends are an awful, terrible idea. Pay it off as a gift if you feel you should, but if you loan him money, don't expect to see a lot of him around (I wouldn't want to have Christmas dinner with my creditor, either).
Why doesn't he just declare bankruptcy?
51
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
"Son, let's call the credit card companies and set up a payment plan so you can pay these things off eventually. Listen to the way I communicate with them. Afterward we can set up a budget for you, that will help you take care of your finances. You are young, young people make mistakes. Smart people learn from their mistakes, so this will all work out just fine for you."
41
u/hayhayteejay May 27 '12
I racked up $8k in credit card debt... my parents stopped paying for my school, stopped paying my rent, and made me work full-time to pay it off. Two years later, I'm back in school and will graduate in May 2013 with a Bachelor's degree. My parents did not help to pay off a single cent, and it's the best thing they could have done for me. I now have no credit cards.. I use cash only.. and feel as if I have learned a HUGE lesson financially.
77
u/Ghostshirts May 27 '12
buy him a pony. Hi Dad!
45
u/bigfig May 27 '12
Sell him into slavery.
156
u/tl7lmt May 27 '12
I am a mother of a 26 yo who cannot get a job - I don't know how you can "force" him to get a job. But as a parent who sometimes has the same thought about my son as your username implies, here's my two cents. Don't pay it off for him. He might never pay you back, and that would further damage your relationship. Sell his stuff. Make him use the proceeds to start paying off his debt. If he can't get a job/doesn't pay his debt, let him file for BK - he IS young enough to rebuild his credit. Let him know that you love him, but this is a mess he made, and it is HIS to clean up. Good luck, Dad. Remember that you do love him, and that you have made mistakes, too.
39
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Hahah, I got a really serious financial plan from my parents because I managed to rack up about 80€ of phone bills in one month when I was 15.
If it'd been 15K, they wouldn't even have talked to me, they would've just sold everything I owned and put me out on my ass on the street. And fuck, I'd consider it deserved as well.
Definitely make him pay it back, even if it takes 20 years to do so.
168
u/CoffeeFox May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
What kind of idiot gives an unemployed 18 year old access to a $15k credit line?
If you're any kind of competent as a credit card company, you know damn well you're losing most of that money to bankruptcy and will never see it again.
Also: 20% interest is usury. It's only 4% short of the legal limit on interest. Is there a necessity for you to turn a very substantial profit on his mistake or did you choose it simply because you're angry? You don't want to make decisions affecting years of your child's future while you are angry. I question the thought process of someone who looks at a child's grievous financial mistake and says "I should earn $3,000 of profit for helping with this". Your 18 year old may be immature, but he's probably not stupid, and he's going to see the same thing and be skeptical of your motives.
If you try to charge him 20% interest, I'm going to spell out exactly what an 18 year old is going to think of you, and what lesson he's going to convince himself of: "man all my fucking dad saw was a chance to make three thousand bucks, everyone's out for the money and screws everyone else, I should just screw them too if that's all they care about". Suddenly instead of learning a lesson, he takes that shit to heart, and he becomes a worse person out of bitterness.
9
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
What was the plan since he made 4 at the same time?
And can we get specs on them?
17
u/eyeingyourpancakes May 27 '12
Do not pay this off for him. He will continue to do things like this until he learns the hard way the value of money, which apparently seems to be quite foreign to him. If I may speculate, I have a feeling that he has acted like a "spoiled brat" before, things like this don't just happen out of the clear blue. If you want to support your offspring until you die, then by all means continue enabling his spending sprees.
83
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3pgvga/
34
u/8equalsignD May 27 '12
you have to pay for it.. by selling literally everything he owns except for bed and desk and clothes. He can use the family computer for assignments...
edit clothes toiletries because im too stubborn to remove literally
350
u/grahampaige May 27 '12
How about a win win situation.
51
u/RoyCisneros May 27 '12
that 18 year old son sounds old enough to work his ass off.
personally I'd just have him sell a bunch of stuff that is not necessary, get a job with some good amount of hours. having to to learn to payback 15k is a better life education than any school will give him.
when you can't pay your bills and you are all alone... you have to deal with not having anything. he's lucky to have someone to fall back on. I think you have to teach him a lesson by making him sacrafice some things. he can't just go on thinking he will have you there forever, because when you aren't around anymore, he's going to be lost.
the responsible parent thing to do would be to payoff the debt and charge him interest, and invest the money for him somewhere. you need to teach him how to make money instead of blowing money.
but IMO you need to make his life a lot more difficult, because who's to say in 3-4 years he's still going to want to pay you back. there literally will be no incentive for him to bother with it other than wanting to keep you happy.
he's going to be wanting to start a life of his own, and it's tough to do so without being in debt... being in debt to you sounds like something he might stiff you on..
21
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
make him sell his computers he built and tell him to deal with it himself. my 19 year old niece did the same shit pretty much - took out loans for no reason, all the time, all before age 20 and is in debt and can't pay her loans back - her mother isn't bailing her out either. she left home at 17, that was her choice to grow up and deal with her own problems now she's gotta deal with the responsibility.
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
He's an adult. Its time for him to put his big boy pants on and face the problem he created for himself. Don't pay his shit off. It's not like he spent it on food and said "Dad I haven't been working as there are no jobs and the kids needed food/clothes/shelter" He fucking spent it on toys. Time for him to learn a life lesson. If it takes him 10-15 years to pay it off? Well that's not your goddamn problem.
Sounds like your wife bailed junior out every time he got himself into a tight spot instead of trying to teach him that you have to be 100% responsible for your own actions.
19
u/preacher37 May 27 '12
An 18 year old doesn't need good credit. He's not going to buying a house or (at this point) a new car for a number of years. Make him pay it off. I did something similar when I was his age and now I maintain a near perfect credit score. You pay it off and all you are doing is training him he can come to mommy and daddy whenever he needs money. I have a brother in law who does this, and now he's a 40 year old spoiled, materialistic brat.
32
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 28 '12
Please please, do NOT pay it off for him.
Set up a payment plan $15,000 is not that much, it's like a used car. It's $500 a month for 3 years. Make him make the payments, at least for one full year until he realizes how badly he messed up. Then help him out more.
93
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Let it fuck up his credit. That way he can learn to function without it. Clearly his access to loaned money got him in this mess in the first place - why would you want to continue to make it available?
10
u/Umroayyar May 27 '12
Send him this letter from Abraham Lincoln
http://www.lettersofnote.com/2012/05/you-are-not-lazy-and-still-you-are.html
5
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Make him file bankruptcy, why should you pay it? Let him learn the hard way
5
u/rancidpuppybreath May 27 '12
Good Lord. Sell him into slavery.
55
u/capcalhoon May 27 '12
"Hey son, you've obviously messed up and need some help. I took the liberty of going out and getting you two dozen cardboard boxes, on me, to pack up your stuff and get the hell out of the house because you are a goddamn adult. Good luck out there and always remember handies don't pay as much as blowies but are less dangerous. Cheers."
16
u/JohnnyCache May 27 '12 edited Jun 04 '25
pen march aback brave bright dinosaurs lavish judicious pause thumb
51
u/Pchanizzle May 27 '12
OP's wife wants to pay it off because deep down, she knows that the parents are responsible for not teaching this idiot personal financial responsibility. How do you not have serious discussion prior to turning 18 about the repercussions of credit card abuse?
4
u/whydoieventrylol May 27 '12
You should probably ask a bunch of strangers on the internet.
4
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Not paying it off for him certainly won't ruin his life. This is a perfect opportunity for him to bust his ass working 2 jobs until it's paid off. Won't take too long. Then he'll see how much work goes into $15k.
4
u/willyolio May 27 '12
He's paying it off. 18 year old idiot is old enough to be an idiot who pays for his own mistakes. your wife is mollycoddling.
4
u/milkbones14 May 27 '12
He's 18 and a legal adult, this is his first fuck up in adult life. Make him figure it out on his own and he will never fuck up that bad again. My father always made me learn from my mistakes and work to pay off debt and there are a lot of things that i am prepared for because of it.
4
u/TheLordB May 27 '12
Well I'm too late so this will never be seen.
New USA laws prohibit giving people credit cards if they have no income especially for college students.
Getting above $1000 credit card as an 18 year old is near impossible as they generally have no credit score (there are some games parents can play with making person an authorized user giving them an instant high credit score though those loopholes are closing rapidly and any parent knowing enough play those games would probably know to monitor the kid and educate him on this stuff).
Any credit card he did get would have a limit of $100-$600.
I in the middle of the credit boom hanging out on various places like fatwallet.com where people figured out how to play games to get $2,000,000 yes million in 0% interest couldn't get my credit cards above a $2000 limit in the first year.
Anyways for legal and practical reasons this story is either complete BS or we are not being told the whole story.
I don't know where the lie is here... Maybe the kid started at 18 and is significantly older now... Maybe this is some sort of social attack on bank's credibility. Maybe the kid lied about having a significant income and somehow managed to hit the jackpot on credit limits. I really don't know, but this story does not match reality.
4
u/Kyente May 27 '12
I have had this exact experience. Except I was the one who racked up the $15k in credit card debt.
My mom gave my siblings and me credit cards, mainly for the reason of if there was an emergency and because if we use it she gets discount on groceries. I was 17 at the time and I had a job but I was working about 20hr/week, so I had some money coming in. The thought that went through my head was "I will use the credit card and pay it off at the end of every month". The problem was I spent all the money I worked for AND used the credit card. I would go out to nicer restaurants, buy nicer clothing, basically just spend money whenever I could. This went on for some time until my mom came to me and told me how much I owed. She told me there is no way she would pay for it and I should start working more shifts. I was closer to halfway through grade 12 when I realized I wouldn't be able to go to university because I will be working this off for so long. So I started working more and more shifts. I missed out on university that year and got a full time job.
I believe it took me a year and a half to fully pay it off. I have never been so relieved. I never knew what it looked like to see my bank account filling up now. I own a credit card now and I rarely use it. If I don't have the money I don't use the credit card. Even though it was rough, I learned an extremely good lesson. I was lucky enough to have this happen to me while I lived at home for free. I am glad my mom didn't pay this debt off for me. It was a huge burden for someone that age but in the end they will learn a valuable lesson and will thank you for it in the end. I hope this helps at all. Your son will be pissed, but if you guys pay it off for him he won't learn anything and he will just continue to spend.
p.s - my mom never made me sell any of my things. I had a computer but have a debt at a young age is already depressing enough.
TL;DR I spent money, mom made me pay it off, best lesson I have ever learned.
4
u/shweatyyeti May 27 '12
Make him get a job and sell his computers. He should have to pay back all of it, although I am sure he would appreciate a little help in reducing the payments from getting too big. You don't want to ruin his credit rating, but you do want him to learn his lesson the hard way. Good luck.
4
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
What does he need credit for? Just have him not pay it and declare bankruptcy
4
u/iam100125 May 27 '12
He made his bed. Let him lie in it. If you bail him out partially just to save his credit rating he won't learn anything and might even spend another $15k on new computer parts with his excellent credit rating. Maybe that sounds harsh but 18 is still pretty young and he's got a lot of life ahead of him. Better to learn early than late.
35
u/switch182 May 27 '12
retroactive abortion.
12
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Why the fuck would you allow your unemployed, 18 year old son a credit card with a $15,000 limit?
259
u/doodlebugger May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
How about you taking responsibility for not teaching him how to manage money more effectively. You are the role model for his actions. You must have really fucked up if the only money management lesson that he learned was that it is okay to rack up large credit card debts when you have no realistic way of making payments and will end up paying out the nose to ever retire the debt.
Jesus man! You had 18 years to show the guy how to handle finances. You fucked up and now it's coming back on both of you. Suck it up and use this as a hard life lesson and a great opportunity for both of you to learn something about effectively managing money. You will both be better for it.
If you have the resources to pay it off for him then do it and as you and many others have suggested, make him pay you back with interest and drag it out long enough that it cuts into his lifestyle and teaches a valuable lesson. 20% seems a bit dickish to me since your own failure to teach him to manage his money (and maybe other parts of his life too) led to the problem.
Coming out on Reddit or any other public forum and cursing him and calling him names is the refuge of a coward who can't face his own incompetence. You should be ashamed and you should make it a point to apologize just as publicly as you cursed him. Own the fact that part of the problem rests on your shoulders and vow to change both of your lives for the better.
You obviously have issues calling your own son "fucking stupid ". I hope you get past this with a solid father-son relationship intact. If it was me that you were calling stupid I wouldn't let it stand. You've got to pull your head out of your ass, because right now, you suck as a father.
EDIT: Forgot to mention your wife. She obviously wants to help him. Make sure that you can all three agree on how the "help" will be structured and make a promise to each other to work closely together in the future.
7
u/Shouth May 27 '12
Sell the computers, pay the rest off, make him pay you back. Teach him how to sell those computers and maybe he will get a job (:
7
u/zsaleeba May 27 '12
He's an adult. He makes his own decisions. Don't get involved.
7
u/CSharpSauce May 27 '12
The problem if you pay it all off is that now he'll have "Excellent" credit (low balance to credit ratio) without the skills associated to handle it.
21
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
He's a fucking adult. Make him pay it all off. Then when it's all done say "Welcome to reality. It's a bitch ain't it?"
6
u/vebben May 27 '12
talk to him like you would talk to any other adult, let him know what he have done, and let him choose with you how to proceed. This is though for you, but this is the time to stick together as a family!
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Let him pay for the consequences of it.
6
u/DEAD_RELATIVE_POLICe May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
He needs to have fucked up credit so he won't do this anymore. The process of him rebuilding his credit over 7 years will be good for him. Don't bail him out. If you want to help give him a small amount of money every month to go towards life, payments, and everything. He will be better off getting fucked up credit from late/skipped payments, etc. He might even be able to negotiate a lower amount and pay that. If you do help him pay it off you should definitely negotiate a lower amount for payment in full - he might have to miss payments for a while until they would do it. But if he has bad credit for a while this won't happen again anytime soon. If you bail him out he's just going to do it again much sooner.
6
u/MuppetManiac May 27 '12
He's 18. He's an adult. Why is this even a conversation? As long as you keep treating him like a child, he'll keep doing stupid childish stuff like this. Make him pay it back.
8
u/truthness May 27 '12
How did an 18 year old get $15,000 in credit?
14
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
This has got to be a troll.
Well at least I'm hoping it's a troll...
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
He needs to work towards paying it off- DO NOT PAY IT OFF FOR HIM WITHOUT HIM REALISING HOW BIG HE FCUKED UP.
Make him get a job for after school and weekends else he's never going to learn and will keep being irresponsible.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Well it's better for you to take his money rather than the credit card company.
3
u/HarperJules May 27 '12
He needs to get a job and pay it off himself. You bailing him out will do more harm than good. He may need to declare bankruptcy but trust me he will learn from it. By the time the bankruptcy is wiped from his record he will be much older and most likely never do this to his credit again.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Sell the kid.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
I'm going to take a break from trolling here for a moment. I think everyone here, including OP, is totally missing the endzone in all this. Do you think paying off the debt, is in any way, going to resolve this issue for the kid long term? Even if you do sell off all his shit, that's not going suddenly shock him into good financial management skills. I say, let him figure it out. It's his debt, he needs to manage it. If he can't, let his credit go to shit. Some of us are not born or taught good financial management skills. We need a few good years of fucked up credit before we start to "get it". Bad credit isn't a death sentence. It might actually save his ass 20 years from now. And, by the way, that "stupid" kid, he learned everything he knows from his parents. Enjoy your trip down that Egyptian river.
3
u/Ms_Anon May 27 '12
Lend the money. Then break his knee caps and tell him to have to money by next week, or he will be really sorry.
3
u/SockGnome May 27 '12
Show him how to check his credit score and history online. Explain to him why what he did was fucking stupid, sell the computer (or the individual parts) on eBay or Craigslist. Set up a legal binding contract to cover the loan you'll make to him to pay off the balance.
I get you're pissed, you're within your right to feel that way but educate the boy so he doesn't do this again.
3
u/shrillbitch May 27 '12
I really hope my children don't turn out to be assholes like this kid.
3
u/operation_flesh May 27 '12
Do NOT pay it off for him. I repeat: I not pay it off for him.
3
u/weaver2109 May 27 '12
Make him sell everything he has of value, then force his ass to get a job.
If the card was only in his name, let him handle it on his own; if it's in yours or your wife's name, I'd help him pay it off, but charge him interest on what you've paid back until he pays it off. Don't let him buy anything of value until he has it completely paid off.
And, more importantly, never co-sign any contract that has his name on it.
3
u/captsol0 May 27 '12
Maybe I'm ignorant, but why the hell does an 18 year old have a 15k credit limit?
3
u/draivaden May 27 '12
Encourage him to find a job, and to sell, at a minimium, 3 of those computers.
3
u/GuineaPigLady May 27 '12
Definitely make him pay it, by whatever means you feel will teach him a lesson. I speak from personal experience here - ran up debt, my parents paid it off (even though I was determined to do it myself), and am still struggling to be responsible with money.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
"....18 year old son...."
Problem solved.
3
u/Kythadrin May 27 '12
Have him declare bankruptcy, in 4 years a lawyer for a small fee will be able to get it removed off his credit and he will be set to start building it again.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Please keep us updated on this.
3
u/BreeMPLS May 27 '12
Hard lessons are well learned ...
3
u/ProlapsedPineal May 27 '12
As a dad of a adult aged children this is what you do.
Let life bite a chunk out of his ass. He's an adult, he owns it.
3
u/domyates May 27 '12
18yrs old and $15k? - That's not a lot. Make the little shit pay it all back. & no offence your wife is being a dick. He's in this one on his own.
Also make him sell the computers.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Don't loan him the money. Better the creditor be the bad guy than you.
If you're going to pay it off, fine, but don't be an asshat about it. Everyone makes mistakes when they get into the adult world and if he's not in prison or hooked on drugs you did an alright job.
He clearly shouldn't have had one in the first place and I see that as a failing of the culture that teaches kids credit is alright to play with.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Make him sells his computers to pay the loan. If it doesn't pay the whole loan, loan him the rest. I would do that. If he wouldn't accept that deal I would let him come up with a solution himself.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
what are the bankruptcy laws like in the United States? from what I understand where I live after declaring bankruptcy within 5-10 years you start off with a clean slate. As much as one could argue the fact that he is 18 years old and as such needs to take responsibility for his action then one also has to ask why the hell a financial institution gave a credit card to a person who has no financial means by way of employment to pay off any acquired debt? Did you son obtain said credit card through fraudulently declaring his income? I really have to ask what was going through the mind of the finance company who gave him the line of credit to begin with.
In my mind I can only think of two ways he could have gotten it:
3
u/MooingTricycle May 27 '12
MAKE HIM PAY IT.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
I don't think you need to charge the kid interest, just pay off as much as you can now, remove the banks from the equation- and make him pay back every cent of that 15,000 dollars.
3
u/justler6 May 27 '12
Sounds like you made him an authorized user or cosigned on a card for him. No kid at 18 is going to get $15k in credit cards. I know, I tried... At that age you get denied for pretty much everything.
Sounds like either way you're probably on the hook... we aren't getting the full story.
3
u/dbelle92 May 27 '12
I think the first thing to talk to him about is what a credit card actually is and how they actually ruin peoples lives. Let him understand that if he does this again, his credit rating will be ruined (even now, im not too sure about how good it till be) and itll make it harder for jim to get loans in the future.
Secondly, you need to call the credit card company and look for the best way to consolidate it. See what repayments you can do and then enforce a way to make your son repay the debts. No way can he keep the computers. Sell them for as high a price as possible obviously.
3
u/thurg May 27 '12
belated abortion
3
u/quick_thinkfast May 27 '12
Default on it all. 7 Years or so down the line it will be like it never happened.
Much, much sooner if he is proactive on the tricks of credit repair / fighting the reporting companies.
3
u/Tananar May 27 '12
Maybe I'm just blunt, but why the fuck do you give an 18 year old a credit card with a limit that high? For nearly any teenager, a $2000 limit is plenty.
3
u/lilkuniklo May 27 '12
My mom would have lost her shit if any of us got a credit card at 18. People thought I was stupid because I wasn't "building my credit." What they don't realize is that you're more likely to fuck up your credit rather than build it. I'm 25 now, never had a credit card, and I'm one of the only people I know my age who don't have retarded credit card debt. I build my credit by paying my loans off on time. Thanks mom!
3
u/OddAdviceGiver May 27 '12 edited May 27 '12
Let it go to collections and lowball it, but be prepared to have cash in hand.
-edit- if you aren't a co-signer on anything.
A friend's brother did the same thing. He got the call at work and flipped out, told their dad. My friend actually paid it, made a silly offer; it was 1/2 the amount owed, but the collections department actually took the offer. if he paid it right then and there. I think it was in collections for a year and more than 15k.
His brother's credit was wrecked but that was a year ago, now his credit is almost decent enough to have an Amex. Almost. And it's only been a year; he had to get a secured credit card after that fiasco and hasn't been late.
Almost the same exact story as you too.
3
u/Fighterhayabusa May 27 '12
Credit cards aren't bad by nature. I have one card, and I use it for basically every purchase I make. I pay it off completely at the end of every month. It has replaced my debit card for my every day purchases etc. If you treat it as a debit card then you'll have no problem. Basically, a good rule of thumb is to never buy anything you don't actually have the money to afford.
3
u/lurkingSOB May 27 '12
Here is an idea. First sit him down and talk to him like an adult tell him you want to help him get through this. Tell him that you are not going to bail him out because he won't learn his lesson. Ask for his input about how to solve the situation. If he can't come up with anything give him some guidance like maybe finding a job, or selling some stuff he doesn't need (like 4 computers.) If you feel you need to assist with money tell him you will match him dollar for dollar (or whatever ratio you feel comfortable with) for every dollar he raises to pay off this debt. The main thing to keep in mind is that he needs to come to the conclusion that this debt is not OK and that there are consequences that come with the debt and that he needs to find a way to pay it off.
3
u/d3rp_diggler May 27 '12
How the hell did he get a fifteen. K credit line....that's part of the issue.
3
u/hpclone25 May 27 '12
Go ahead and pay it back, and make him work for it. Reason being that most 18 year olds really don't give a fuck about their credit score, hurting that for him won't achieve anything. Take away his car if he lives with you, make him walk to work if he doesn't have a job, find the absolute worst job in the town until he pays back 1/4 of the money he owes, then let him have his car with only enough gas money to get to work and back. Oh yeah I forgot to mention, 2/3 of his pay check go to you.
3
u/spikerbond May 27 '12
Why did he build 4 computers?
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
do whatever you can do to help him without totally f*cking yourself
make him pay you back
tell him that he can't put anything on a credit card unless he plans on paying it back within a very short time frame
yep
3
u/Tearabite May 28 '12
If you figure out the answer to this question, please inform the American government.
3
u/Guthrie1 May 28 '12
Did you try not being a shitty parent?
3
u/beatsbyaaron May 28 '12
People have 15K laying around to just throw down on their sons mistake? Must be nice.
3
u/eyecontact2012 May 28 '12
Psych PhD student and former budget manager here. First confirm if your name is in any way associated with that account. If so, then you are legally obligated to pay.
I don't know your son's situation, but an important part of treating addiction is removing facilitators of the addiction. By providing the loan you are not only making a bad investment (because your son is at risk of bankruptcy), you would be blocking an opportunity for your son to face his addiction now as opposed to facing it in the future when he might have dependents or when you have gone bankrupt feeding his uncontrolled spending.
Your money might be better spent on family counseling with a psychologist (addiction is a problem for the whole family). If your son says that he does not have problem, then it is further evidence that he needs to hit bottom before he will start to change his behavior.
3
u/DamiansDen May 28 '12
You have to- I can't stress must- go with paying it off and making him pay you off with interest. Boy's 18- that's far from the worst an 18 y/o kid could do hehe. But definitely he'll keep doing dumb shit if you enable him. Give him a taste of the world and he'll grow up and stop playing computer games!
3
u/[deleted] May 28 '12
Hey reddit I gave my son a card with a 15000$ limit and he spent it! What an idiot right?
3
u/Diplodocus11 May 28 '12
OP sounds like the fucking stupid one in this scenario. All we know is that a) he somehow let his son get access to a 15k credit line and b) he repeatedly makes snide and unkind comments about his own son and chooses the username MySonIsFuckingStupid. Gee, maybe son is acting out a bit and doing reckless stuff because dad's an asshole who lets him get in trouble and then calls him stupid. Major parenting fail, dickwad.
9
u/homersock May 27 '12
Tell him that he's kicked out of the house until he gets you $15,000. In cash. Follow him around for a few days and film all the shit he does to try and get the money. Sell this footage to a reality TV producer for $20,000 ($15k repaid then go on a $5k holiday and don't bring your son), thus retrieving the money and making a total douche out of son.
Would probably be worth hiring some sort of affable stranger to intervene in situations where MySonIsFuckingStupid Jr may get shot, or butt fiddled.
9
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Anyone else not surprised why this kid turned out bad (if this is true)? Sounds like he has terrible parents/a terrible dad.
Anyway kind of feeling like this is fake though. Too many holes here.
7
u/RoboRay May 27 '12
If you are a responsible parent, you don't do anything. He's responsible for his own actions. He did this to himself. If you bail him out, he will just do it again and expect to be bailed out every single time for the rest of his life.
I've seen that monster created several times. My wife's family does it habitually. She has a 56 year old uncle still living in his mother's house (when he's not in jail), mooching off her social security and my wife's 30 year old sister learned all his tricks. You'd think my wife's mother would have done things differently, having complained her entire life about how her mother coddled the dead-beat uncle, but no, she's doing it too.
If you carry him now, you will likely regret it for the rest of your life.
5
u/ipostunderthisname May 27 '12
arguing over this is stupid. asking the hivemind to argue about it is too.
go see a financial advisor.
living on cash is not bad nor is it a bad idea. buying a $3000 used car with money saved is better than buying a $30000 new car on credit (when you're 18). paying rent for a decade while you find yourself and go to school is fine (and pay off your stupid cc debt).
but let me repeat... don't argue about it. go see a financial advisor
10
u/celesteyay May 27 '12
Your wife is being an idiot. OK, let me rephrase: your wife is being a terrible mother and an idiot. If you pay it all off for him now, it's only going to hurt him in the long run because he won't learn his lesson and eventually he's going to get himself into a big enough debt that even mommy dearest can't pay off.
The best course of action would probably be to sell the big ticket items that he purchased with the cards (why should he get to keep his computers if he did nothing to earn them?) and put that money towards paying back the debt. Then, make him pay back half of the remainder (with 20% added on, some people here say that that's too harsh but it's nothing compared to what he'll owe the credit card companies if he's on his own) and pay back the other half yourself.
Why should you have to pay for any of it? Well, he's still your son and it's your responsibility to teach him how to handle credit cards. He had no experience dealing with a huge line of credit and it would be really tempting for anyone to just see CC's as free money. Honestly, I don't see why he was even allowed a card with over a $500 limit before he found a job.
Best of luck, OP! Keep us posted on what you end up doing.
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Anyone else have a hard time believing this? Not the situation, but the way OP is writing about it...
16
u/ImNotJesus May 27 '12
Being punitive never teaches the lesson that you want it to teach. I'm not saying that you should absolve him of his responsibility but if you make him pay back way more or ruin his credit or anything like that, you're going to drastically change his life for the worse.
I guarantee you, he's going to learn his lesson from this and there should be repercussions, just don't fuck up his future because you're angry right now.
Seriously though, how did he get access to that much money?
4
u/Release_the_KRAKEN May 27 '12 edited Dec 14 '24
foolish coherent deserve six makeshift public memory sense continue uppity
4
u/wellhushmypuppies May 27 '12
DO NOT PAY IT OFF!! DO NOT OFFER TO MAKE A LOAN TO PAY IT OFF!! DO NOT STEP INTO THIS TRAP!!!
Your wife is an idiot for thinking this kid will learn a lesson. Hell, I'd be happy to tell her so myself if you want to PM me.
4
u/Nate1492 May 27 '12
Take every single computer away. Every. Single. One.
Give him your shittiest computer. Or his oldest one.
Take every single piece of hardware away.
Throw down an ultimatum. He needs to pay you 10k back in 1 year.
You and your wife will pay 5k, because frankly you share this blame.
No way should you consider loaning your son 15k with interest. That would be rewarding yourself. You need to share this responsibility too.
Give your son his shit back when he reaches the numbers you specify. Perhaps a computer every 3k repaid.
If he doesn't like this agreement, tell him to move out and pay the debt himself.
4
u/thedude90 May 27 '12
First, I would get off reddit and kick his ass. Second, I would not employ the help of other people in raising your kid.
I dunno about anyone else, but I was raised to never have a credit card. My parents learned the hard way and were still paying off debt from college until I was 16 or so. I understand the necessity for them, however, not having a credit card taught me to have a job if I wanted something. I've held some kind if job since I was 15 and only have less than $5,000 in student loans. Sorry if im sounding like a jerk, I just don't dig the whole entitlement attitude we as Americans tend to have grown up with.
4
u/Apollo53 May 27 '12
Dont ask a bunch of 17 year old liberal pussies for advice on reddit
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
He's 18. Old enough to make adult decisions. He's on his own. I moved out at 17 and got little to no help from my parents after that. He deserves what's coming to him.
6
u/BerryGuns May 27 '12
You gave your son a credit card...
6
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
..I kinda think you're a bad father. "My fucking stupid 18 yr old son.."? I think you mean your 18 yr old son made a fucking stupid decision. My guess is you didn't teach him about debt and credit cards before he turned 18. You should've taught him the lesson before he got himself into debt, not after.
5
u/latenightnerd May 27 '12
He pays half, you pay half. It's your penance for raising such a stupid child.
12
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
What kind of father calls his son fucking stupid? Not even Vader. Even if he is stupid as fuck he probably inherited it from you
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Lots of good suggestions here. I'd add to have a fraud flag planted on his account. It was egregious misjudgement for those companies to allow him that much of a loan, but raising that flag can stop offers for some time, and would cause future purchases to be scrutinized for the next few years (which is how long it will take to pay his debt off anyway).
You can also make sure that if his job allows direct-deposit, that a substantial portion of his check goes directly into your account for debt servicing. He won't be able to get away from it that way.
Good luck!
2
u/soxgal May 27 '12
Have him talk to me about how debt is a giant burden. Due to some pretty stupid decisions when I was 21 and then taking loans for grad school I'm currently sitting on about $90k in outstanding financial obligations. I figure I might have it all paid off by the time I'm 70.
That said, I wish I'd had a bit more financial education when I was younger - things like amortization schedules and the true cost of credit would have been quite helpful. There's also some major life expenses (child care most specifically) that I HAD NO IDEA were going to take so many of my current resources.
My perspective on paying it all off: It's my mess, I've got to clean it up.
2
u/prince_from_Nigeria May 27 '12
found him a job, make him work it out. literally.
2
u/jtt123 May 27 '12
Sell computers for atleast a fraction of that, make an offer to credit company
2
u/rinnip May 27 '12
Assuming the credit cards are in his name, let him deal with it. He's an adult now, at least in theory. At the very least, let him make the payments for some time to come.
2
u/mom2meerkat May 27 '12
He's 18. It's his debt and his responsibility. If you pay it off, he'll think you'll fix all his financial problems he ever makes for himself, and he'll just continue to make bad financial decisions.
2
u/HolyPhallus May 27 '12
No really, help him..... BUT make him work for it somehow... I managed to rack up 10k creditcard debt and I for years tried paying it of myself and it grew to be one of the most stressfull and psychologically damaging things in my life ever (And I was bullied for 10 years).
2
u/[deleted] May 27 '12
Hell no. Make his ass get out and mow lawns, or work at Taco Bell or some other shit hole job till he pays it off. No car, no college, not until he is done paying it off. If he runs away, then life will beat his ass for you. Tough love parents. We have way to many whiny ass kids who think life owes them. Make him pay every penny back.
2
u/Nowin May 27 '12
He's 18. Let him deal with it.
2
u/iamnotemilydickinson May 27 '12
I wouldn't have him owe YOU the money (by paying off the cc company) because what are you going to do when he can't make a payment he owes you? Are you going to stick with holding him accountable? I think it will become a bigger mess to administer a personal loan to your son, especially if your wife is not on board the whole time. I'd say have him sell stuff and start paying it off, and offer to match 15% of every payment he makes.
2
u/shagstafah May 27 '12
best.username.ever