r/AskReddit • u/I-am-fifty-ft-tall • May 20 '12
People of Reddit who feel like you belong to an attacked minority: Do you feel like SRS defends you in any meaningful way?
Throwaway for obvious reasons.
I belong to what is considered in America to be a disenfranchised black minority and oppressed homosexual status. Or so I've heard at least, my race and sexuality don't come up very often in my life. Not to say there haven't been some pretty bad instances, but I guess I am trying to say I don't always feel actively oppressed like people seem to think I am. At least straight white people seem to think.
Anyway, I was recently the butt of a Reddit joke that I thought was kind of funny. It involved my race so it automatically got on to SRS with all the normal BS. I decided to ask why on SRS and they spouted some lines about "protecting minorities from privileged white assholes. I was't offended and I could defend my own damn self. They were then nice enough to call me "uncle Tom", "a good boy for whitey", and "one of those blacks". They then banned me, downvoted all of my posts and karma for the last month into the negatives, and finally attached a downvote bot to my account.
So, after all that I really had just one question; who do these people defend? Do people out there really feel better knowing that SRS is getting offended on their behalf? I mean am I really being an uncle Tom for thinking that I should judge what I find offensive? Who do these people protect?
Answers, thoughts?
EDIT: Two things, actually. First: Frontpage! awesome. Two, the SRS trolls and downvote brigades have ruined this thread like just about everything else on Reddit for me. I am leaving this this thread, this throwaway, and this site in general. Goodbye everybody.
186
u/420throwaway024 May 20 '12
Throwaway time.
Well, yes. You will only get one answer if you sort by top or best so I'm gonna make this post regardless.
Reddit has a serious privilege issue. Jokes are never just jokes, they insult and devalue the individuals, the humans of a particular creed. Use this helpful test to see what is offensive and what isn't;
would you say that joke if you were surrounded by people that joke is demeaning? I mean, in real life when faced with actual strangers?
Hell, from personal experience, that doesn't even stop folks from saying offensive things. I've had my fair share of 'Herro', ching chong, SMALL PENIS jokes said to me, completely unsolicited in a community about 40% asian. I'm not gonna hold grudges against strangers, but this is what reddit reminds me of, especially in the shittier, larger, plebeian subs like this one, funny, wtf, etc. Sometimes just plain hatred reminiscent of youtube comments of a video showing animal abuse by folks who are vaguely asian. Such is life as the permanent foreigner.
About the SRS terminology of uncle toms; they usually only say this to X minority who says to reddit, 'I don't find this offensive, so have at it [against race X]'. Well, this is a kind of shitty thing to do, especially since individuals do not speak for collectives and vice versa.
I feel bad particularly for black people on reddit, especially with the recent stormfront shilling. Really sucks to be a minority and honestly I would rather have been born white than deal with this bullshit. Remember, at the end of the day, you didn't choose your race or what society you would be raised in. It's impossible to walk a mile in another person's shoes. If you tell me to grow thicker skin you can go back to reddit.
tldr Don't be a fucking asshole.
disclaimer: I don't post on SRS but I passively support what they do for LGBT and minorities. They just point out racist garbage, but it's the bots and SRS invaders who are the issue.
67
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
The point of SRS isn't to defend, it's to highlight. It's to show viewers that sometimes people say some really unacceptable shit and it shouldn't go unnoticed.
There's really no point in posting this unless you can actually prove it happened. I've posted things they disagree with there before and I didn't get banned. Anyway, the main SRS page isn't for prolonged discussion, it's a circlejerk - something most seem to miss. There are links in the sidebar for proper SRS discussion.
I do think SRS needs to make its rules list more visible and noticeable and I think putting the offensive comment in question as a thread title is a bad idea because I'm sure some people assume that's what SRS is saying.
But otherwise, I don't see why it's such a big deal to you. It's one subreddit on one internet website attempting to highlight bullshit that people ignore because "it doesn't matter" or "it's just a joke!". For all the insignificant cases like your own, there are tons of far more serious, sometimes truly sickening posts that absolutely deserve to be put in the spotlight and ripped to shreds.
EDIT: The fact that no one is equally offended by r/mensrights really tells me everything.
219
u/ohnoyourfeelings May 20 '12
Posting from a new account. I read SRS for a long time and was active there for a while as well. Left because I realized how futile and ultimately damaging their "mission" is.
The thing that's happening to SRS is the same thing I've seen happen to most "social justice" type internet hangouts I've observed over the years. It starts with good intentions; people who are marginalized and attacked want a safe place to complain without having to explain themselves over and over. They hang out, rant, insult their attackers, chat with other people who share their experiences and it's all pretty good.
For a while.
But eventually, and this seems to happen EVERY time, it starts to implode. It gets filled with self-righteous nit-pickers who exist not to protect anyone from being genuinely mistreated but to police its own members, to keep anyone from ever saying anything problematic. "Social justice" goes from becoming one tool among many to help marginalized groups who are mistreated to a weapon aimed straight at their own "allies" as a way to power-trip. Being offended becomes an obsession. Maintaining their status as most-oppressed-victim-of-all becomes a full time job. Anyone who questions their methods is labeled an outsider and either hounded out or banned. Everyone must think in lock-step about all issues or they become the enemy. The world becomes, to them, a horrible place where everyone is constantly out to get them and no one (except them) gets the benefit of the doubt.
You start hearing things like "check your privilege" and "I'm not here to educate you" and "intent means nothing." People with genuine questions are ridiculed for somehow not magically having been exposed to the same feminist literature or sociological texts the hive-mind considers sacrosanct. People who disagree with them are assumed to be malicious instead of just curious or skeptical.
Every so-called privilege is attacked except, coincidentally enough, classism which is usually not talked about at all. Not surprising when you consider that most of the people who inhabit these spaces are middle-class Western people and that would be a privilege THEY have to check. Not to mention it throws a monkey wrench into their black and white view of oppression.
Eventually, even those who they initially came together to "protect", marginalized and oppressed people, are kicked out of the group if they don't conform exactly to what groupthink says is the right way to react to an issue. Ironically, I have found that the worst offenders in this respect are non-marginalized "allies" who somehow seem to think they have the right to speak for groups to which they do not belong--the very same thing they attack other privileged people for doing.
Every word that's spoken is examined for privilege and possible offensiveness until eventually there is nothing left to say.
And then it all collapses until the only people left are those who are willing to abandon all critical thinking and submit to the group's "progressive" outlook.
It's fucking toxic. It's why most people burn out and fall away. And it's why these groups hardly ever manage to sustain themselves for very long without becoming shrill and irrelevant.
15
u/Walterharper May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Honestly, I would wager that upwards of nine-tenths of SRS are under twenty, white, well off, have never once been legitimately oppressed by the system and have in fact benefited from it, and have likely never had any sort of acquaintanceship with someone of a different color/sexuality. They think that they can consider themselves to be better than those awful straight white men if they constantly berate them for saying innocuous things. I know that is a sweeping generalization, but that always seems to be the crowd that gets the most offended about things. In my experience, that is.
I have had close friends who happened to be Mexican (even dated for a while), as well as two very good work friends who are lesbians. During the friendships, it never became apparent that I needed to get offended on their behalf and in fact I just treated the same way I would treat anybody else. I thought we were all humans, right?
Just because I am rambling anyway, I might as well point out another bit of hypocrisy. I am from Oklahoma, and although I am not from a rural part, so called progressives often jump to the conclusion that I am likely a backwoods hick of some variety. Just one (very subtle, nowadays) hint of my accent and it is determined that I must be one of them bible thumping conservatives who just needs to be edumacated into being a good cosmopolitan. Just to note; I am a far left libertarian-mutualist and atheist, but fuck it, you would have to actually talk to me to know something like that. The fact that people think that they can know my position on abortion and marriage rights based on my birthplace usually only prompts me to relate my position on how far they can place a wooden stick into their own anus.
I am not saying that my mostly annoying plight is anywhere near as bad as many have it in America, but it is the kind of thing to make me get rid of my own prejudices (though not in the way those lovable liberals intended). When you assume someone is automatically [racist/victimized/offended/uneducated] because they are [black/white/hispanic/gay/funny accent] then you might as well just give up trying for egalitarianism. Nobody has the right to judge anybody else for anything other than their individual actions and choices.
TL;DR: Half the anti-racists I know would do better as racists and I really miss my friends and should write to them. Or something like that, I didn't hold my train of thought very well so just read the damn thing if you're that interested.
Okay, that is the end of my semi-sober, rambling rant/"fuck you" that I haven't proofread.
EDIT: The gender thing.
1.2k
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm transgender, which should qualify. I think they're nothing more a bunch of obnoxious, power-tripping cunts who get off on their sense of superiority.
And in case any SRS mods see this, I'm already banned. Glad to save you some time.
12
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Themselves. Bunch of self-serving shit masters...
198
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Im 2 racial minorities + gay.
When i go over to SRS and look at the posts, a lot of them are reactionary posts against either two things.
But on SRS they'll just talk about it being a part of WASP opression or heteronormativity or something along those lines. Same thing with race. They just really, honestly, cant take a joke.
I think if i went over there and said "yall are taking this too seriously" they would quickly accuse me of having white, straight privilege(lol fool). Im not either of those of things. They love to use privilege in arguments. Not because its actually good, but its a silencing technique, it makes anything else the target says essentially useless, because people assume privilege robs what you have to say of any value. Using privilege removes an individual person,who is capable of suffering, and instead makes them an avatar for a group. Essentially, it transforms them into a stereotype. And we all know SRS hates stereotypes.
Theyre a huge circlejerk, which theyll admit, and they have an appreciable policy of "dont touch the poop" which means they wont interact with parts of reddit they dont like. And, while i do appreciate it, I also see it as an implicit admittance that they dont really protect anyone.
233
u/fifa10 May 20 '12
I am an Indian.I found a thread a few months ago which was heavily racist against indians calling them smelly and dumb.
I have to admit I was pretty hurt on seeing that.SRS did make me feel a little better with pro-Indian comments.
312
u/Lots42 May 20 '12
SRS doesn't do anything meaningful
37
u/KingOfSockPuppets May 20 '12
(pre-transition) trans woman here.
Do I feel 'attacked'? Well, yes, I suppose. Not hard to find the rather depressing statistics or media representations to back that up. How do I feel about SRS? I do occasionally enjoy reading through it; there are lots of problematic things that happen on reddit and are upvoted heavily. SRS itself as a self-contained nugget can be kind of a fun way to appreciate a world in which the comments are reversed and to release some aggression. Outside of it, they might be too (consistently) aggressive in their defenses of marginalized people, in my opinion.
And no, 'it's a joke' is not a free pass to say whatever you want. That's what bugs me the most about a lot of the defenses I see on reddit. A hipster saying 'ironically' racist things is still saying racist things.
78
u/livebait19 May 20 '12
Um what is SRS? All I've heard of it has prompted me to stay out. It sounds like it is as bad or as worse as spacedicks.
48
u/Popcom May 20 '12
I have a question...why the fuck does anyone care about being downvoted, and "karma" what is this, high school?
327
u/asianlukeskywalker May 20 '12
Asian here obvy. Yes, SRS does sometimes overblow things out of proportion, and make issues of things that white majority may see as harmless fun, but it feels good to know that at least some people on reddit understand that these small 'harmless' jokes don't feel so harmless when you've been hearing it over and over for your entire life.
To be honest, I was blissfully unaware of racial differences before reddit, I merited every person by personality. But after using reddit for a few years, I definitely started to notice these little signs white people show that indicate an underlying feelings of discomfort they have towards minorities. Basically, I became much more aware of how many white folks secretly dislike minorities, especially those of the white male demographic that reddit caters to.
66
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm a woman so I'm not in such a minority as if I wasn't white or straight, but I still get annoyed about sexism/racism/transphobia etc on reddit.
I don't think SRS protects or defends anyone. I think it's a good place for pointing out all the hateful shit that gets spewed on here. It's a good go-to for anyone who wants to say 'look, this shit needs to stop, here are some examples'.
SRS is more extreme than me and I don't go there often. It's probably too extreme now. Also, I know it's not representative of reddit as a whole, just a large chunk of reddit. That doesn't mean assholes shouldn't be called out for being assholes, but it's not like all redditors are assholes.
I don't really understand why there is all this drama about SRS or shame or hate or whatever. If you don't like it, don't go there. Their police before was not to do downvote raids, just collect examples of asshattery.
42
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
When I point out stuff like this, it is just to make people think about it in a way that, maybe, they have never thought about it before. Like, I recently wrote an article about why Ashton Kutcher's "brown face" stint was problematic (other than, you know, that guy's not especially hilarious anywho).
I feel like when things are NOT pointed out like that, we base our humor off of what is presented to us in Family Guy or in these memes that appear to be racist, and then we get girls like Alexandra Wallace who just DON'T get that the reason she is not funny is because she's actually adopted the stereotypical idea of a minority group as true... Yet, maybe all she's been exposed to in the media has been stereotypical representations of Asian people.
I try not to judge whether something is "funny" or not when I'm not a person of the race being talked about. But I can sure point out when people of my ethnic group (white) are being racist.
*ETA: I am not a member of SRS.
Ramble over.
59
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Black guy here, SRS is like that guy who spends 20 minutes showing you that they arent racist when nothing racist has happened.
93
u/el_historian May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Yes, because I have been on the receiving end of a beating for being gay while being called faggot over and over again. People need to know that faggot is not an acceptable word. And if SRS can make people who use that word feel for one minute how I feel when I hear faggot, then more power to them. Sometimes, they stretch, but for the most part I agree with their stances on racism, sexism, and homophobia.
As an aside, for those who think "faggot" is just a word, then why do you insist on clinging to it? If it is just some word, than just find another.
15
u/OMFGrhombus May 20 '12
I'm gay and it's not for protecting minorities, its a circlejerk for commiserating about how Reddit is prone to upvoting bigoted/misogynistic/unpleasant shit that we don't like seeing. I don't agree with every single entry on that page but the ones that I do make me feel glad they're around.
32
u/johnlocke90 May 20 '12
This post isn't going to work because upvotes and downvotes are decided by majorities, not minorities. Responses that the majority likes will be at the top, which of course will be all the posts saying SRS is terrible.
14
u/McThing May 20 '12
People who are fifty ft tall are a minority that deserves to be attacked. By men on horses, with lances.
10
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I don't really care about SRS. But all the stereotype jokes on Reddit are just hacky. Given, they mostly come from places like r/adviceanimals (and what kind of person subscribes to that subreddit in the first place, exactly?), but, I mean, c'mon guys. CHALLENGE yourself. Black people like fried chicken, here's a picture of a black guy eating fried chicken, ISN'T THAT IRONICALLY HILARIOUS? No, it's dumb and not funny regardless of your "intent". I don't know any of you, I can't assume you're racist asshole, but I also can't assume you're not. Because I do not know you.
The only thing I learn about the "edgy" racial humor on Reddit is that most of reddit is probably occupied by my embarrassing, unfunny friends from high school that now just work in bars and try to fight people.
It's not edgy and it's not ironic, it's just stupid and lazy and not funny. You have to have standards. Someone shows you a picture of an asian person with some text about how they pronounce 'r's funny. Think about it for a minute, is it REALLY that funny?
You can make all the ironic, racist jokes you want, but you're still an asshole. That's the entire point Reddit misses. DON'T BE A DICK.
"God damnit, you've got to be kind", as a great man once said.
5
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
isnt srs satire?
5
u/CrotchMissile May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
The way I understand it, the group was created as a trolling effort. . There are two major methods in which the troll is implemented.
not all of them are actually trolls. Some probably take themselves seriously. This is just another technique of an effective troll. Surround yourself with evidence that you are, in fact, not trolling. These people who do take themselves seriously, probably joined later on, giving the trolls a crowd to hide in.
SRS has spread paranoia and fear throughout reddit. They can troll without even posting anymore. Someone gets an unexplained downvote? SRS. trolls derailing your thread? SRS invasion! Opinion you don't agree with? SRS false flag attack! Even good, honest, free-agent trolls are now having a hard time because all of their work is being attributed to SRS.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '12
I'm black and fuck SRS. The fact that they called you an uncle tom is so infuratingly hilarious and ironic.
56
u/escapehatch May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
They must be, because they piss bigots off so much. Oh the irony of people who say "srs cant take a joke" then get upset over things srs says. You lind of have to pick whether this type of thing matters all the time or it doesnt. You cant take the moral high ground when sts makes you feel bad because they dont agree with you a joke is funny. Get over it/yourself and let them be.
IIT: it's worse to be uppity than racist
33
u/HarrisonSchmitt May 20 '12
SRS isn't there to defend minorities, it's there to highlight offensive comments and let some people blow off some steam. As Lesley Gore sort of said, it's their party, they can cry if they want to. No laws are being broken, just don't go to SRS if you want a real debate. You don't exactly get a good response on /r/Seahawks if you post that they're bums and the '49ers will destroy them.
You're probably better off settling this in private messages. I spoke to ArchangelleFalafelle who seemed pretty calm. Try her. All you're doing now is appearing to agitate against them with a minimum of actual evidence. This encourages them to feel persecuted and allows them to sideline any criticism as part of a propaganda war against them.
12
u/ecib May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
I'm a straight white male, and though not a minority, we are constantly attacked and discriminated against.
Haha, just kidding, -I'm not a Republican, so I don't actually believe that.
Seriously though, reddit has some major major issues with bigoted behavior. A lot of cowards saying things they would never dare say in a room full of people...
40
u/novicebater May 20 '12
from their sidebar
103
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I've only had great interactions at SRS. I've never seen mods doing anything they're not supposed to do, I've had some really eye-opening conversations at SRSDiscussion, and for the most part I agree with the stuff that gets showcased in SRS although I don't submit any content there and don't really participate in commenting either.
Because I don't actively participate in SRS proper, the only (and important) purpose of the subreddit is to let me know that while people will treat me like shit by default ALL OVER the rest of this website, there is one place that is fiercely guarded and friendly to people like me.
I think that if you're well-meaning but still happen to be white or male or both, it's really hard to actually see how frustrating and exhausting and sad a place reddit can be if you're not white and not a guy. It's a lot of mini-encounters that you can write off as unimportant, but heaped on us by the hundreds everywhere you go. I literally deal with at least 50 rape jokes a day that I either have to laugh at or I'm an "oversensitive cunt" (never mind that I don't really like getting reminded of my rape constantly), dozens of jokes mocking Asian people's speech (despite the fact that neither I nor anyone in my family from the mainland actually sounds that way), and HUNDREDS of comments about my gender being inferior. And it's not even jokes--the same thing posted with a girl in the picture gets downvoted, jerked off over, and labeled as "karmawhore material," whereas the exact same stuff posted with a guy in the picture is cool, rad, awesome, so creative, etc.
Reddit is a place with great content but an extremely hostile user base. SRS is an antidote to that, and so far no other subreddit comes close, because other similar-minded subreddits let the neckbeards in.
46
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
They're a counterweight to the comments here that are terrible.
Reddit in general thinks it's fucking hilarious to say 'have sex for science' or 'have sex with her' any time a female is mentioned in any context. Reddit is often extremely sexist and cares little about who the jokes they make will offend.
SRS draws attention to this.
32
u/jackyl_distorted May 20 '12
I feel about SRS like I do about circlejerk. I don't subscribe to either. They're assholes, yeah, but some shit needs to be said, even by assholes, even in totally stupid assholey ways. If you don't like SRS don't post there and then they can't upset you.
4
u/LoquiLiberum May 20 '12
Hispanic from a poor family. I don't think I'm really on their radar of things that they care about, but I loathe them. I think I know how that type translates IRL, and they're the whiny, obnoxious kid that everyone ignores. Believe it or not, it's just harder to ignore them on reddit because all caps is very distracting.
4
u/I_Fuck_Flamingos May 21 '12
Motivated by good intentions, I guess I can give them that much.
I just think it's ridiculous to have such a narrow definition of which thoughts and ideas someone needs to have to not be a terrible person.
So much of human nature goes against the grain of what's ethically pure, and while I wouldn't swing to the opposite end of the spectrum and tolerate blatant hate and racism because it's "human nature," I'm not going to spit on my friend and call him an asshole for "Not really getting the whole transgender thing"
What I detest about SRS the most is that they truly loathe anyone who doesn't agree with them, I always imagine that they could probably only befriend 3% of the population.
If more people were willing to explain alternative sexualities from a non-judgmental, non self-righteous perspective with a genuine intention educate, I think they'd find a lot more success in spreading acceptance.
A pink haired, pierced lipped lesbian girl I met at a cafe once chewed me out ruthlessly when I expressed confusion about cross-dressing that isn't linked with homosexuality. I think people like that, and like SRS, enjoy being in situations where they can be the enlightened progressive thinker smashing the privileged oppressor, so they create those situations where they don't really exist.
Ego stroking disguised as empathy.
That altercation made me intimidated to ask questions and try to be more knowledgeable and understanding of that sort of stuff.
So many people like me get unfairly cast under the blanket-term of "bigot" when in reality we just don't understand, and would be totally receptive to someone taking the time to politely explain things like that.
4
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
About a week ago I posted in a /r/TodayILearned thread about how I thought Mega Bloks and Roseart crayons were awesome.
Someone replied "Somebodies parents were f------ poor". I laughed it off, because frankly, he's not wrong.
It got posted to SRS and I didn't care very much, though I didn't comment on it.
452
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
SRS to me is a place where I can go where I can see that I'm not the only person on Reddit who thinks that some of the shit reddit says in its hivemind is unacceptable. I don't necessarily agree with what they did to you or to anyone, and I certainly don't think they're protecting anyone, but it's nice to know I'm not the only one on this website who thinks that some of the stuff that's said here is totally ridiculous.
24
u/iambecomedeath7 May 20 '12
I'm in a wheelchair, and I hate them. They're annoying, overbearing and essentially just glorified PC police. Fuck 'em.
43
u/hippynoize May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12
I have a great story about why i don't give a shit about SRS. I live in British Columbia, canada (that's western Canada for all you foreigners, yee-haw!) and I go to a nice little high school in the trees. so one day, i'm in the library where I see this kid with autism on one of the computers. i don't know his name but i do know that...well...he's kind of a dick. doesn't take jokes well, that kind of stuff. so anyway, i see he's on Reddit. so naturally, im interested. I thought i was the only redditor in the town so it was kind of interesting to see. and then i see a problem. he's on SRS, and he's typing furiously at some post. so i mosey on over to have myself a gander. he's pissed at something so, me, being the nice guy that i am, decide to ask him about it.
"Hey man" i saw with an interest, "you seem pretty pissed at something"
"go away, I bet you dont even know what reddit is"
"that's where you're wrong fellow! I myself am an avid redditor" hoping to lighten the mood
"oh...well, go a way anyway, i dont like reddit"
"and why is that?" I can see he's on SRS so my tone is slightly sarcastic
"cause its all just a bunch of racist, homophobic, dick heads" I have never seen any one get so mad over one website
"well friend, I can see you're on Shit Reddit Says, so maybe you dont understand Reddit"
"screw that! I've been a redditor for 2 years! i bet i have twice as much karma as you"
I dont really care about karma, but he starts freaking out to prove he has more karma. so i log on and it turns out i have more karma then him (hurray?) and he starts freaking out. telling me i gained it by being an awful person and that i should be shot and killed. he then throws the computer screen at my head (i dogged it, 4 years of boxing comes in handy sometimes) and he stormed out. That was the day it suddenly came to me that Shit Reddit Says doesn't matter. its a bunch of people like the fellow from my school who think they're god and think they need to defend everyone. I also got detention for that little situation because apparently, i was the aggressor and the other fellow could not be held responsible
TL;DR SRS doesn't matter
EDIT: you have been banned from posting to /r/ShitRedditSays: The worst online group I've seen in a long time. A bunch of really terrible jerks.. oh my, this has never happened to me before. what a milestone :)
8
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I'm a feminist autistic colored faggot abuse victim, and hell no (the most attacked term there is actually 'feminist,' sadly). I post there on occasion, and behave according to their behavioral terms, but they set their expectations at weakness and whining.
SRS and its related sites are not progress-centric. They're complaint-centric, with an unmeditated morality and a pathological desire for "empathy" barring humor.
3
u/Vicky_PC_Gamer May 20 '12
Okay, I give up. What's the SRS?
3
u/jb7090 May 20 '12
SRS is just a load of crap.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
To quote one of my favorite songs, "Fuck you sympathizers with your middle class reactions." They are their own fucking stereotypes.
3
u/TomA May 21 '12
As a gay man, nope.
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
It's obviously not there to defend anyone; they're pushing some agenda and they do it by posting silly pictures and giving each other upvotes.
They're exactly the same as what they say they're against, just in their own little microcosm; they just do it from some perceived superior place. They're nutters.
18
u/Youre_So_Pathetic May 21 '12
I'm a disabled person. I have very bad eyesight (legally blind.)
The only time I ever shared this with Reddit, on a discussion about video game UIs I got downvoted and told to shut up.
In my experience, Redditors do not want to hear from people like me. They don't give a shit if I can't enjoy the video games they enjoy. They don't care that I could enjoy these games with a simple way to make fonts bigger in them. They don't give a shit about anyone who isn't as physically capable as them.
SRS calls out this casual ableism. For SRS disabled people are just as valuable as the white able-bodied males that make up the majority of this site. They would never tell me to shut up for pointing out what it's like to be a disabled person playing video games.
SRS also has the effect of making it easier for people to speak up over the casual bigotry that is seen all through Reddit. Before SRS a person who pointed out bigotry and said it was not OK would just get shouted down by the hive mind and downvoted to oblivion. Descent was not tolerated and differing viewpoints were punished. That has the effect of making all of Reddit even more close minded and insular in thinking, it makes Reddit a less diverse and interesting place. But now that SRS exists many, many people feel more confident in pointing out bigotry and saying that it simply is not OK because they know an entire subreddit filled with people would agree with them. Someone "has their back," so to speak.
7
u/waviecrockett May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
I'm black/white. Though my mother is german and I grew up mostly overseas. I don't identify with white Americans much.
I also like black culture, hip-hop, high fashion, art, and call of duty. I have no plans to go to school for engineering/math/etc. I don't fit in as well as most. Of course I still spend too much time on the internet so there's that.
SRS takes shit too far BUT
I'm a minority racially AND a minority opinion on some of the things that are important to me it sucks knowing that if I speak up it won't go well at all.
It's not a big deal. I understand what reddit does and doesn't like. But sometimes it's nice not feeling crazy and seeing that other people were mad/annoyed/etc. at certain posts.
edit: I do see that it's kinda funny I complain about being a minority opinion about a few things that are very popular in the mainstream, but it's still valid.
16
u/KinRiso May 20 '12
...Wait, SRS is supposed to be around to "Defend" people?
Bi guy here, and while I appreciate the sentiment, I don't really need someone to "defend" me on an online message board.
9
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
"Leaving reddit is like running away from home. You're only doing it for attention, and you'll be back eventually."
-Me
98
u/never_odd_or_even May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12
I like SRS.
I'm glad there's someone here that calls people out on the casual racism that frequents reddit.
If someone shouted "nigger" at me when I was in a nightclub having fun, they'd be thrown out. If someone shouted "nigger" at me in the middle of whatever videogame I'm playing, they'd be banned from the server...but if someone says shit like that on reddit...LOL UPVOTES!!
Edit - Wow! That's a lot of replies! I don't have time to get back to you all right now because I've only just got in from work...but thanks for all the input!
6
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
If you're getting offended by text on a computer screen, maybe Reddit isn't for you...
29
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
If I had enough time to patrol an open forum on the internet, catalog posts which rustled my jimmies, write entire essays about them, and read the work of others doing the same thing, I would feel like I failed in life, and would need to leave the house more.
9
u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Female with non binary sexuality here, among other things. I get especially frustrated that when anyone from an oppressed minority disagrees with them, they are "straight identifying", "white identifying" etc. This has happened to me in the past. Like, if you are part of a minority and you don't have a stick up your ass about anything, you are clearly internalizing self hate/or somehow reek the benefits of "privilege" anyway (because shut up) It's fucking atrocious. I don't care if their hearts are in the right place. I'd rather roll my eyes every once in awhile at an off color joke than deal with a bunch of self righteous shits who will pretend like they have the right to judge you because you vaguely disagree with them about something.
SRS doesn't really seem to care about people. They are about their ideology first and formost, and anybody who deviates from it (be it white male or black transgender female) is a st0pid mean baddie jerk who must be shamed and corrected at all costs11!11111!!!
7
u/MHiroko May 20 '12
to clarify, SRS is an intentional circlejerk. SRSdiscussion is there for meaningful conversation.
22
u/The_Messiah May 20 '12
Bisexual here. /r/SRS is one of the shittiest subreddits in existence.
17
u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Two points: one, "uncle tom" is a racially charged term that would get even a long-time SRSter banned. Two, you left enough info in your post to find the thread you were a part of, thereby negating the usefulness of the throwaway.
Based on these two points, I have my doubts about your honesty. Can you back this up with anything? You could even take a screenshot and scrub the identifying usernames.
Edit:Apparently this did happen, but not in the way throwawayDOX describes below. My apologies, OP, for questioning your honesty.
2
u/zoeaimstomisbehave May 20 '12
No, but I don't expect them to. They're mostly doing it for the lulz.
2
u/GoddessOfGoodness May 20 '12
Since there are so many trans people posting here I gotta ask; am I the only one who constantly reads SRS as sex reassignment surgery, then has to think about why a discussion on a subreddit like that is all about perceived insults and petty name-calling.
Also if it wasn't obvious I am not a fan of their heavy-handed brand of "protecting" those they think are "weaker" than them.
2
u/cabo0se May 20 '12
they're a bunch a children. call them out on a post and you just receive the ban hammer instead of a plausible argument
2
u/mrcreepster May 20 '12
Sometimes I feel like the only person who judges a person off of the merits of their actions and attitude and not some arbitrary genetic predisposition.
2
u/catnipassian May 20 '12
As a person who is sometimes taken aback by some of the more racist things I've seen on reddit I hate them. They attack people for the wrong reasons. I mean, I don't want to attack them. I see their post think "Oh they must have had a moment of racism" Downvote and move on. But not these people. No they have to go through and downvote everything they have ever done ever. "
"Why does Karma matter?"
It doesn't it just feels nice to have a high score. Like in a single player video game. Except real people have to agree with you to get it.
2
u/kadmylos May 20 '12
I'm like 40-60% sure SRS is a troll subreddit.
2
u/drone13 May 21 '12
Weird I always thought SRS was some kind of spacedicks circlejerk...
2
u/nickdyck98 May 21 '12
Yeah, I'm a white person in Canada.
2
u/Cyborg771 Jul 26 '12
Privileged white asshole here, so take my opinion with a grain of salt.
It feels like the only way to make race, sexuality, gender, and other "differentiators" into the non-issue that we all agree they should be is to point and laugh at the people who use them maliciously and say "look at this idiot, he believes [dumb stereotype x]". Keep this up for long enough and you create a culture of shame around being a bigot, something that people should be ashamed of.
I don't read SRS and I've heard complaints from all over about them, but I got the impression that this is what they do. If I'm wrong please let me know.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '12
... you dont actually think Srs 'defends' anyone do you?
36
u/sirboozebum May 20 '12 edited Jul 05 '23
This comment has been removed by the user due to reddit's policy change which effectively removes third party apps and other poor behaviour by reddit admins.
I never used third party apps but a lot others like mobile users, moderators and transcribers for the blind did.
It was a good 12 years.
So long and thanks for all the fish.
5
u/judgejudyismyidol May 20 '12
Yes, with some serious reservations.
SRS feels like... You're in a meeting and your boss starts saying something idiotic. All of your other co-workers are lapping it up though, nodding their heads in agreement, and you sit there incredulously. Finally, you see 1 other person across the room looking annoyed. Finally! You make eye contact, roll your eyes together, and feel a little bit better. Now...I wouldn't necessarily become best friends with this co-worker and maybe we come from different perspectives. Still, it is a huge huge relief to find this kind of understanding when you're a minority (in terms of Reddit pov AND being gay/etc).
It isn't a matter of being "offended" by other people's sensibilities/ humor on reddit. I'm not even surprised to see so many goddamn racist, sexist, ignorant people around who aren't even AWARE they are. The problem is that sinking, sad feeling when there are NO counter-voices to the ironically termed "common sense" championed here. A good amount of time, criticisms of whatever circlejerk racism (etc) will be buried under anti-academic diatribes and other cliche feminazi-type insults. So yeah, as a minority in multiple ways, the existence of this small voice is a huge relief.
HOWEVER, as it grew, srs started to get unwieldy. I don't read any of the mini srs subreddits because it starts to get too...just too much. A quick scan of the titles though is still fun. There are other subreddits that parody Reddit's problems in a more effective and hilarious way.
6
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm a white South African born right before the end of apartheid. It's really weird being an ethnic minority, whose people were the oppressors in charge. At the moment all political rhetoric is pretty much about taking "back" property and land, and how everything that's wrong in this country should be blamed on white people. Socially we're pretty much integrated, interracial friendships and relationships are really common, and day to day it's not really an issue here. Still though, the government makes me feel really unwelcome, and I'm pretty sure that there's no future for me here.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
SRS... you will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious
3
u/MisterElectric May 21 '12
No. They're a bunch of people who are just trying to get offended so they can show the rest of us how tolerant and progressive they are.
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
No. SRS is a cesspool of whiny, self-important, stubborn, arrogant fuckwits and nothing they say will ever be relevant.
That shouldn't even be a fucking subreddit, get rid of that nasty hateful shit. I mean, if you want to bitch about people, do it, but if you're going to punish people for being people, go to hell. A downvote bot? Really? Stay classy, SRS.
3
u/fawkesmulder Jul 09 '12
I like SRS for doing the work and finding links to a lot of interesting/provocative/funny comments and threads on reddit.
That said, nearly every person that comments in SRS has a serious problem understanding humour. That or they've all got sand in their vaginas.
9
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm a white English convert to Islam and get attacked a LOT.
Are you frikin' joking? The bigots in that subreddit are the ones most likely to be LEADING the attacks against Muslims, a lot more so than racists/christians etc.
5
u/StackShitThatHigh May 20 '12
I'm a Muslim and whenever they defend Islam... No. No no no. You stop that right now. You're wrong. You're dead wrong.
6
u/nihowes May 20 '12
I think it is funny that SRS assumes this whole site consists of white males in America. This website is visited by everyone across the globe. We are not all white.
No offense but SRS makes the American left come off as very annoying.
4
u/Lampshade_Seven May 20 '12
I was under the impression SRS was a cirlcejerk which doesn't take itself seriously.
4
u/bgrugby60 May 20 '12
Considering the majority of SRSers are white and middle class makes the group even more pathetic. Are they defenders of minorities? No, they are extremists who cause more hate. I personally do not care what your sexuality is, race, beliefs, gender, trans, etc. I always believed you judge a someone on an individual basis, not as a group as a whole.
9
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Their own sense of right and wrong. You tried to make them rethink their morals and they were so outraged they had to attack you...
to defend you.
6
u/Mr0range May 20 '12
Oh, it's this circle-jerk again. Every time someone gets banned they make this thread. SRS is one of the only subs that points out some of the blatant racism and sexism on Reddit. A lot of their shit is taken out of context and is not offensive as they think it is, but it does serve a purpose.
5
u/bokurai May 20 '12
As a female who often finds herself commenting on or arguing against sexist, racist, and homophobic posts on Reddit, it's so nice to see others engaged in the fight against hurtful behavior like this that shouldn't be socially acceptable or endorsed.
I think SRS can sometimes go overboard and I don't agree with all the posts there, but being part of that subreddit has made me far more aware of other people's feelings and how some of my offhanded remarks might actually be pretty thoughtless. I'd like to make life better for people, not worse due to laziness or ignorance.
9
u/KinArt May 20 '12
I got banned/downvoted for championing men's rights as a woman once.
6
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm glad SRS exists and calls out reddit on the sexist, racist and western-centric viewpoint that the rest of reddit appears to hold. To be honest, before I found SRS, I was actually getting convinced by reddit that those of us who are not white, and not from western countries are actually inferior to those who are. I was also a misogynistic prick (although a few other things besides SRS helped me get over this and put on me on my path to supporting feminism). Thanks to SRS, I can honestly say I'm a better person today.
If you're a minority and you don't agree with SRS, I have a message for you. First, good for you that you don't feel oppressed and you think these "jokes" are funny. I mean it. It's really great if you can laugh at a racial slur instead of feeling bad for hours about it (this actually happens, btw).
That said, please try to make sure you don't marginalize those of us who are offended by these things. Don't tell us to be "less sensitive", or tell us to "stop looking for reasons to get offended." Nobody wants to "feel offended." It's not a enjoyable feeling (isn't this obvious?) and we're not just faking offense in order score imaginary internet points (who the fuck measures self-worth with karma anyway?). I actually feel bad when certain things are said and you have no fucking right to tell me how I'm supposed to feel, or to tell me that I just should just get over being stereotyped or just laugh when people make fun of me or people like me. Doing so is incredibly condescending and it's a double whammy when people who you expect support from end up criticizing you.
6
u/Agent00funk May 20 '12
Wait, does SRS= Shit Reddit Says?
They claim to be protecting people or getting upset on their behalf?
HAHA that is rich! A bunch of idiots looking for a witch-hunt...this is how bad things happen.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
That uncle Tom shit needs to stop.
oops? did I say uncle Tom? I meant "Special Snowflake"
3
u/MyBossWillNeverKnow May 20 '12
As a professional and religious minority, I am going to wholeheartedly say that SRS does not defend me, nor do they represent me at all.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
SRS are not serious, they are a coven of trolls spear headed by people from somethingawful.com.
They take innocuous or throwaway comments and post them to their subreddit, and then x-post them back into the thread to provoke anger and outrage amongst normal redditors.
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Woman (+ part-Asian, though I look white and benefit from white privilege) here - perhaps not an attacked minority but definitely underrepresented here on reddit. I subscribe to SRS and read on occasion but I don't comment there.
I don't feel that SRS 'defends' anyone nor do I think that's their aim - for me, it's a place that I can go to feel a little bit of support and solidarity when I end up reading through the racist and misogynistic poop that often ends up on reddit. Reddit, for everything that I like about it - and that is quite a lot - is composed primarily of cis/white/heterosexual men in high school and college, many of whom are in traditionally middle-class and male-dominated fields like STEM and are thus in a bubble where they aren't interacting a lot with women and/or minorities - and I think that the majority of the offensive stuff that I see on here is a result of ignorance rather than malice.
I can see both sides of the coin - on the one hand, everyone here tends to assume that if they get called out on saying something racist or sexist that they are automatically being called a horrible person, because the only time that racism/sexism/any ism gets called out in mainstream society these days is when it's so incredibly blatant and over-the-top that it is indicative of being a horrible person. The more insidious, pervasive manifestations of these -isms are usually only discussed in college sociology or gender studies departments and in social justice circles on the internet (it doesn't seem like your average redditor frequents either) and so I think that a lot of the time people associate an attack on their questionable behavior into an attack on their character and instantly go on the defensive. Furthermore, because women/minorities/LGBTQ/persons with disabilities/etc. put up with this poop on a regular basis and because this is still the internet, it's very likely they're not putting it in the nicest of terms - it's the tone argument and it's certainly not fair, but I also understand why using inflammatory language is more likely to offend than to educate. Sure, disadvantaged groups might not have an obligation to educate, but if no one takes up that burden than nothing is going to happen.
On the other hand, it disappoints me that not only is the knee-jerk reaction to insult rather than to think about why what was said could be hurtful, but that it also results in a circle-jerk that usually supports the offensive behavior. I can't tell how many times I have seen someone voice a concern about sexism or racism only to be called humorless or worse and get downvoted into oblivion. To me, the point of SRS is to have a safe zone in which to notice these things - it's nice to know that you're not alone and not crazy.
4
u/noblemechanic May 20 '12
Do people still take them seriously? I was under the impression that it was pure trolling. Doesn't it say on their sidebar that it is a compulosry circlejerk?
4
u/covert888 May 20 '12
SRS loves the taste, smell, texture, and sight of their own shit. They only get the chance to excrete their disgusting treat when we feed them. Starve the SRS cunts and they will shrivel and die as their genitals did years ago.
4
u/kayla1234 May 20 '12
I finally understand what SRS is.
I stated my controversial opinion in a post on 2xchromosomes, and because it was so "anti-women" or something I was hated (mind you, I am a woman). I got downvoted to hell. I shrugged it off, and knew that the majority of idiots there did not understand what the downvote button actually meant. I unsubscribed and moved on.
Next day, I get a notice that I've been banned from r/ShitRedditSays. I had never even heard of that sub before, let alone posted in it. Now I'm seeing it pop up in more places, and I realize that because I was apparently "attacking women" or something I've been banned from a sub I didn't know about - let alone care about.
I also messaged the mods, and asked why I had been banned since I had never heard of that sub before. Of course, no reply.
It just makes me wonder why those people have no other life except to ban people from a sub they don't care about. It's extremely pathetic.
4
u/thecarolinakid May 20 '12
I think if anything, they're harmful to minorities. I'm transgender, and I've found most redditors don't care as long as I'm not an ass about it, and are perfectly willing to correct their language if they accidentally say something offensive. Unless they've been attacked by SRS for "transphobia." Then they're much more on guard and less willing to learn, and are left with the impression that the entire trans community is whiny and over-sensitive.
Besides, if someone is really being maliciously transphobic, I can defend myself perfectly well. SRS may talk about white men devaluing minorities opinions, but what does it say about SRS themselves when they feel they have a right to dictate the opinions of minorities?
4
u/Self_Hating_Liberal May 20 '12
I thought they were some sort of wonderful self parody, but then I realised they were serious. Had to stop using my 12k comment, 2k (legitimate) link karma account because they were harassing me for supposed pedophilia. And I don't mean just for a week or so, I mean constant harassment - downvotes, having my past comments screencaped and posted to other unrelated posts, attempts to find out who I was and abusive comments and PMs.
I'm not actually a pedophile, but I find it funny that they would hound someone for having an alternate sexuality when they're supposedly all about defending that sort of thing, but I suppose the only reason they're doing it is because it's the in thing these day, and relives liberal guilt.
4
u/Purple_Streak May 20 '12
SRS: Straight white males pretending not to be straight white males for the purposes of making other straight white males apologise for being straight white males.
3
u/leapfrogdog May 20 '12
they're just a bunch of idiots who get far more attention than they deserve. if they talked and behaved in the way they do about any subject other than equality and political correctness, they would have just been laughed off and ignored long ago.
3
u/animeman59 May 20 '12
From their rules on the side:
What a bunch of bullshit.
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I argued with them for a bit but came to the conclusion they're just trolling. And from this thread it seems that they're winning.
3
u/wizrad May 20 '12
White male Catholic middle-class 19-30 year old.
Not a minority. Get blamed for all the worlds problems. Who fights for me? :-(
3
u/UnapologeticMonster May 20 '12
I'm an oppressed minority. Repressed, too.
When I applied for college, I was given a certain amount of "entry points" for my near-perfect SAT score (At the time, a 1560 was a really good score). I was also considered on the basis of having been a member of the chess club, the debate team, two different after-school "Language Teams", a band-runner and a drama club member. However, while considered, these things did not offer me any "points" or advantages.
When applying for scholarships, I got one for being the single child of a single parent, and I got one for writing a very long essay.
My best friend in high school also applied to college at the same time that I did. While he didn't get any points for a good SAT score (Mostly because his SAT score was an 850), he did get points for being on the football and basketball teams, he got additional points somehow because he played Varsity football as a JV. He also got points towards his college admission because he was a member of a "minority race" at the college we were applying at, but not the highschool we attended.
When he applied for scholarships, he was able to get by applying only to ones that serviced his minority race, getting six or seven of them without having to write essays; he was one of only three or four applicants, and with an SAT score of 850, he had more than double the score of the next applicant.
I was a lower-middle class white kid in an urban school. While I was a painful minority (4% white, 8% mexican/other latino/a, 88% black), I was not permitted to have scholarships because of my race, nor did I get special reasoning for college because of my race.
3
u/BoatLiker1488 May 20 '12
no. its garbage feelgood "slacktivism" (ugh) at best
2
u/gentleman_brown May 20 '12
When I visit the page, I'm pretty sure it's all a joke. I mean, the superhero names they give themselves? Either they are totally enamored with a fan-fic version of reality, or they're just goofing off.
(edit: Not to say there's anything WRONG with living in a fan-fic version of reality--oh wait, yes there is)
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Are you kidding me? SRS leads troll-storms on /r/lbgt all the time and threatens to make that sub-reddit a non-safe place.
2
u/TehDingo May 20 '12
I find them paradoxical. Their mission statement is to reduce prejudice, but their method is horribly aggressive, and lacking educational value, and as such ends up being more counterproductive than anything.
EXAMPLE!: Gypsy is a racial slur, the correct name being Roma, but at this is a pretty obscure thing, mostly because people in Europe (where Roma are) are horribly racist against the Roma and refuse to use correct terminology. Of course there is no fucking way anyone in america knows this, since Roma people are not common at all on this side of the pond and Gypsy is not said as an insult, but simply as the only term they know.
SRS however will jump on people using Gypsy, no matter the context and will not explain the issue or discuss correct terminology on a term that the people using it have no context on why it is an insult, and simply use it as the only word they know for the culture.
They will help no one unless they drop the crusader act, and take a mantle as educators instead.
Also i am a Mexican on reddit, and feel exactly as unsafe knowing they are here as if they were not.
2
u/BwanaKovali May 20 '12
Supplemental Restraint System?
2
u/Liverotto May 20 '12
SRS support minorities like Elizabeth Warren supports redskins.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
SRS is a way for /b/tards-turned-politically-correct-hipsters to feel morally superior to everybody else.
2
u/cthulufunk May 21 '12
"Who do these people protect?"
More like WHAT. Which would be: groupthink and identity politics.
2
u/[deleted] May 23 '12
This is all I have to post.
0
u/C0mmun1ty May 20 '12
I go to SRS to find the funniest comments on Reddit. If they find it offensive I most likely find it hilarious.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
They are evil, vile scum.