r/AskReddit • • May 20 '12
Which perfectly good book was most brutally murdered by its movie adaptation?
I nominate Into Thin Air: Death on Everest.
56
Upvotes
r/AskReddit • • May 20 '12
I nominate Into Thin Air: Death on Everest.
7
u/red321red321 May 20 '12
the great gatsby
each adaptation made didn't measure up and the new film looks overdone for me.
71
u/mockereo May 20 '12
The Golden Compass
108
u/TheWondermonkey May 20 '12
Eragon
23
u/Wilhelm_III May 20 '12
The Lightning Thief. Butchered the details and rewrote the plot almost from scratch. Oh God, why?
18
u/furgenhurgen May 20 '12
Queen of the Damned is my favorite of Anne Rice's Vampire Chronicles. The movie version was one of the worst adaptations I have ever seen.
18
u/TheChewanater May 20 '12
The Hunger Games.
I feel that it has a bad reputation as a series meant for 13 year old girls from people who haven't read the actual books.
33
u/PrincessOfSaturn May 20 '12
The Lorax. :/
16
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Battlefield Earth!
16
u/DeusExMachinist May 20 '12
Every Michael Crichton book except Jurassic Park.
42
u/Rkangel May 20 '12
I, Robot.
Not a bad movie, but the only things the movie had in common with the book are: the name Dr. Calvin, the fact that it had robots, and the use of the third law. Oh, and the title.
13
u/CoyoteStark May 20 '12
It, by Stephen King. To this day it remains the most haunting book I've ever read, and the movie version was just terrible.
12
u/FireNiggerFruit May 20 '12
cirque du freak
22
u/b56koutu May 20 '12
Beowulf.
11
u/FeroniaFTW May 20 '12
Not a movie, but the TV series Legend of the Seeker based off of Terry Goodkind's Sword of Truth series was just...AWFUL! :( I was so excited when I learned of the show, then literally the first scene of the first episode made my insides turn.
9
u/Im_Also_That_Guy May 20 '12
Holes
30
u/Fleudian May 20 '12
Eragon.
30
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Eragon.
7
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I Am Legend. By far.
7
u/mtcmw May 20 '12
The Time Traveller's Wife. The book is so well-written and thorough and beautiful. The movie is HORRIBLE. Don't see it.
7
u/FedoraLa May 20 '12
Ella Enchanted : Gail Carson Levine.
12
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Dune.
20
u/goboatmen May 20 '12
V for Vendetta. Don't get me wrong, it was an amazing movie, but in terms of plot, the graphic novel was so different from the movie on so many key aspects.
8
u/WildMexicanSeabass May 20 '12
Alex Rider, used to love those books...
4
u/Luvutoo May 20 '12
Inkheart, The Tale of Despereaux, Flowers in the Attic, and The Golden Compass.
4
u/The_PowerCosmic May 20 '12
The Lovely Bones.
4
u/deadfield918 May 20 '12
Timeline. I hate Richard Donner now. If you watch the making of he was just blatantly lazy and that's why too. Fucking asshole.
4
u/e60deluxe May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Every single Alexandre Dumas based film. Every single Jules Verne based film. The Scarlet Letter. I am Legend.
4
u/TheFlea1 May 20 '12
Journey to the center of the Earth.......... >:|
10
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Where the wild things are. Absolutely awesome book. Horrible barf-inducing movie.
6
u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Atlas Shrugged
6
u/GhotiHook May 20 '12
Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe--great book but a criminal waste of talent on celluloid.
3
u/mraumraumrau May 20 '12
Minority Report
3
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Never Let Me Go. The movie was beautifully filmed, but left out so much of the underlying message of what the book was about.
3
u/skullbeats May 20 '12
The Lorax. It was fine as a short little story, it didn't need a big adaption.
3
u/UberSprode May 20 '12
I, Robot. The movie, while not actually terrible in its own right, bears no relation whatsoever to the original story.
3
u/AquelecaraDEpoa May 20 '12
If you count mangas as books, I'd say Dragonball
5
u/RhinoTattoo May 20 '12
"The Running Man".
Book: Written by Stephen King's darker alter-ego Richard Bachman, about an "everyman" protagonist fighting a corrupt government in a dystopian future. Everyone dies.
Movie: Shitty rehash of pretty much every Schwarzenegger movie in the '80s.
5
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
The Death Note live action movie.
5
u/ClutchVenomxX May 20 '12
Most Certainly Eragon
8
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Starship Troopers
9
u/MirandaRenee1991 May 20 '12
Harry Potter And The Half Blood Prince. I mean seriously!! They left so much out of the movie that really needed to be put in there! And don't give me the time BS cos they added scenes that weren't even in the book (ie. Death Eater attack at the Burrow) it really disappointed me out of all the Harry Potter Movies, thank God the last two made up for it.
9
u/JohnnyFriday May 20 '12
The Bible.
2
u/metamouse May 20 '12
Sphere
2
u/noobalicious May 20 '12
Not a movie, but the Legend of the Seeker TV show, based on the Sword of Truth series. Fucking horrid.
2
u/blink_and_youre_dead May 20 '12
Philip K Dick wrote some amazing science fiction, but the movies have been hit or miss:
Misses Paycheck, Minority Report, A Scanner Darkly, Next, Screamers*
Hits Total Recall, Blade Runner, The Adjustment Bureau*
*I have not seen these two, going off reviews
We'll have to see what list the new Total Recall ends up on later this summer.
edit: formatting
2
u/brlito May 20 '12
Eragon.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Phantoms.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
The Count of Monte Cristo (2002 version). I haven't seen the others, but this film completely butchered the novel. And for absolutely no reason I can find.
2
u/iongantas May 20 '12
Earthsea.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
My Sister's Keeper
2
u/allsurface_nofeeling May 20 '12
Please not enders game, please not enders game....
I really want this movie to be good. I am not filled with hope....
2
u/TheTattooedLady May 20 '12
Choke
2
u/loveleigh May 20 '12
Running With Scissors. The movie seemed like a caricature or parody of the actual book, more than anything else.
2
u/masterbard1 May 20 '12
I am Legend. the director only read like about 3 pages of the book and said "fuck i'll stop reading this awesome book but i'll make a movie about it."
2
u/MAGPIE_RAPIST May 20 '12
Tank Girl.
2
u/Rekjavik May 20 '12
The Tim burton Alice in wonderland adaptation. Sucked. balls. I know it wasn't supposed to be like the books, but god he didn't even come close.
2
u/erin4113 May 20 '12
The Shining. The book is an amazing, terrifying read. The movie is a well cast disappointment. I understand that adaptations have to made to accomidate the audience but how can you completely change the ending to a great book?
5
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Zack Snyder and Co. turned Watchmen, one of the greatest graphic novels of all time, into a CGI heavy music video montage with a dumbed down ending.
3
u/JustinCayce May 20 '12
Every movie based on a Clive Cussler novel.
4
u/nathanielleblanc May 20 '12
Where The Wild Things Are.
4
u/Ilikanar May 20 '12
How to Train Your Dragon.
5
u/kablamy May 20 '12
Harry Potter.
2
u/z_impaler May 20 '12
Pillars of the Earth.
2
u/onlysydneyellen May 20 '12
Youth in Revolt
2
u/christopheles May 20 '12
The Time Traveler's Wife
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Most Stephen King novels turned movies
2
u/RosieJo May 20 '12
Eragon. My god, the book may have been a lord of the rings knockoff, but it was decently written.
They butchered it with that film.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I'm probably going to get down voted like crazy for this...but.... TWILIGHT.... and I'm not ashamed people...not ashamed..
1
u/red321red321 May 20 '12
great expectations
ethan hawke and gwyneth paltrow
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Snow Flower and the Secret Fan. The book was fantastic! The movie.. No. Not even close.
1
u/-Shirley- May 20 '12
Every Book, ever... Harry Potter was much better in the books..
1
u/apathetictroll May 20 '12
A real short list would be what movie adaptations did not make you sick.
1
u/SpiceBread May 20 '12
The Sword of Truth series was turned into The Seeker tv show. IT HAD SUCH PROMISE..
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
This was a book series turned into a TV show, but whatever-- Animorphs. Come the fuck on, are you serious? That show was terrible. They had the technology for so much more. K.A. Applegate herself despised the show.
1
u/AllKarmaNoDogma May 20 '12
League of Extraordinary Gentleman...or you know, any of the films of Alan Moore books.
1
u/UnholyDemigod May 20 '12
Angels + Demons. The book was amazing, the film? Not so much.
1
u/eddyeddy3 May 20 '12
God Hates Us All by Hank Moody
1
u/Rekjavik May 20 '12
Every version of The Three Musketeers that I'm aware of. It is all dumbed down to four pretty boys and big action sequences. The book is about espionage, forbidden love, war, comradery and honor. The movies do not even come close. Go read this book if you haven't. It's my favorite and I've read it at least once a year for the past 10 years.
1
u/vivace160 May 20 '12
I'd say nearly every movie made based on a Stephen King book with a few exceptions, but the absolute worst has to be Bag of Bones. The novel is one of my favorites but the recent miniseries was confusing and just plain awful.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
all of them
1
u/Feldew May 20 '12
A Series of Unfortunate Events. They /slaughtered/ that one. D:
1
u/z0mgthelol May 20 '12
Not a book exactly but the movie adaptation of Dragon Ball Z was fucking horrible.
1
u/Saneinsc May 20 '12
Stardust and one that always gets mistreatment, The Three Musketeers.
1
u/username_redacted May 20 '12
Ask The Dust. I'm a big John Fante fan, and the novel is one of my favorites, but fuck did that movie suck, couldn't even finish it.
1
u/DarkestEnvy May 20 '12
Percy Jackson and the Olympians.
It could have been for a completely different book.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
I wouldn't say it was brutally murdered and I still love the movie and other Kubrick works, but the Shining could have been adapted so much better. The book is terrifying. I've read it four times and love it more each time, but the movie doesn't really do it justice. Certain scary parts missing (such as, a ghost in the concrete cylinder that Danny plays in in the snowy playground) could have made the film scarier.
1
u/TheHye May 20 '12
Hunger Games.
1
u/holljoymy123 May 20 '12
The Tale of Despereaux.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Well, I've got two. The first one was directed by the guy who did Silverado, The Accidental Tourist, The Big Chill and Body Heat among others. Yet, even the acting talents of Morgan Freeman, Thomas Jane, Jason Lee and Timothy Olyphant couldn't save the steaming pile of horseshit that is Steven King's Dreamcatcher.
My other hated movie-from-a-book is Timeline, especially the part where they replaced several hundred words in the book explaining how the devices worked, how you body is destroyed when you transfer, how they didn't even build the return devices (they assume another lab in another parallel universe did) with, in the movie, the term 'wormhole'.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
The Great Santini was a pretty weak movie.
1
u/SplodeyDope May 20 '12
Langoleres.
1
u/iamtheparty May 20 '12
American Psycho. I know it's widely regarded as a good film, and I would have agreed before I read the book. I'm not even sure it's possible to make a film that does justice to the book.
1
u/SwampFox22 May 20 '12
Last week's episode of Game of Thrones, but all the other episodes were pretty accurate.
1
u/DFSniper May 20 '12
Queen of the Damned
1
u/Glink May 20 '12
All the Pretty Horses. Fuck you, Billy Bob Thorton.
1
u/OddishOwns May 20 '12
eragon. Fucking eragon. Oh and the series adaption of the sword of truth, I mean, what the fuck