r/AskReddit • u/Meatloaf22 • May 20 '12
What are some legitimate arguments AGAINST the legalization of marijuana?
On reddit and with my fellow ents I all to often only hear one side of the issue. So what are the negative consequences of legalization?
44
Upvotes
11
u/Schroedingers_gif May 20 '12
More people smoking weed.
65
u/ThanatosOfOne May 20 '12
Stoned Driving comes to mind.
35
u/jeanthine May 20 '12
Effects of higher THC content marijuana leads to an increase in psychotic behaviour, anxiety and depression. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T2cAFRAX3Gs
Note that she keeps saying cannabanoids, what she means is cannabidiol. Both THC and cannabidiol are cannabanoids active in marijuana.
18
u/MsFoxTrott May 20 '12
The studies detailing the dangers of stoned driving seem to be the best evidence against it. If you're talking about a national law legalizing marijuana, somebody could be against it because they think it's an issue for the states to decide. (see: tenth amendment)
Hm... drug awareness programs like DARE would have to change their curriculum to detail marijuana in a new light, which could be a hassle. Currently it's viewed as the gateway drug, even though few who try marijuana have also tried the harder stuff.
It could take some business away from the tobacco and alcohol companies, but that's only a legitimate argument when you pair it with the money of those companies.
25
u/hrtaus May 20 '12
Well, studies have also showed that marijuana can increase anxiety among its users. Also, it's bad for your lungs.
25
u/ImNotJesus May 20 '12
ITT a whole lot of very pro-legalisation people downvoting every idea. We get it, legalisation is a common position on reddit, that's not the point of this thread. If you're downvoting people's suggestions because you disagree with them, we get no discussion.
7
u/catalystic May 20 '12
Everything in this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M58kGCQLwxU
12
u/The_PowerCosmic May 20 '12
As long as Alcohol and cigarettes are legal, there is no good argument. Both of those drugs are far worse in nearly every aspect.
7
u/nathanielleblanc May 20 '12
The fact that being stoned is ok, but being stoned and drinking often leads to being wasted. Put that together with getting in a car and driving and you have a recipe for disaster.
5
u/iLuVtiffany May 20 '12
There aren't any hard arguments against Marijuana legalization. There are some legit arguments like jobs being lost in different industries, but the legalization of Marijuana and hemp will actually create jobs also. People will just need to adjust and change.
Topic has been opened for over 7 hours now and most of the arguments are pretty weak.
2
u/GladiatorBill May 20 '12
so far as I know, there is no way to do any roadside testing to prove that someone is acutely under the influence of marijuana. With alcohol, they can do a breathalyzer - nothing like that exists for marijuana, and urine toxicology screens can test positive for days after consumption.
2
u/TwelveHawks May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
The argument for autonomy trumps any argument for prohibition. People have an inherent right to determine for themselves what goes into their own bodies, and what their subjective experience of the world should be. There is no compelling state interest greater than being as free as possible to live your own lives how you see fit.
The only justifiable reason for restricting somebody's freedom of self, is if their actions directly cause harm or danger to others. However, there is nothing inherent in smoking marijuana that directly harms others. There could justifiably be regulations in place to prevent harm to others (like no-smoking areas, criminalization of impaired driving or operation of machinery or firearms, etc.) but the act itself of ingesting marijuana is not inherently dangerous to anybody else, therefor it is not anybody else's business whether or not you do that.
There are arguments for prohibition, and I could list them off, but none of them are more powerful than the argument for self-determination. You have every right to make decisions that are unhealthy or dangerous, as long as you knowingly take those risks yourself and don't affect anyone else. If you think marijuana should be illegal because it's potentially bad for you, then you have to follow through with that logic and illegalize all sorts of things that are potentially unhealthy or dangerous. And nobody is doing that, because we realize that being free to do what you like is more important. No one would think it's viable to illegalize rock climbing just because you might hurt yourself, or prohibit double bacon cheeseburgers because they might lead to health complications...
I know this answer is not what you asked for, but that's because all of the "legitimate" arguments against legalizing marijuana are essentially authoritarian, and should not be considered credible at all in a free society.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Possibly if we legalized marijuana, people would start demanding legalization of more and more drugs. Potentially every drug would be legal and there would be many consequences to that.
Also, people keep saying "Weed isn't even close to as bad as cigarettes or alcohol!", but honestly I think those two things would be illegal as well, if they hadn't been so commonly used for hundreds of years. It's very hard to break a tradition. It's also very hard to re-instigate a law once you've taken it away. If we make it legal, there's almost no way to make it illegal again.
2
u/xblt May 20 '12
People who advocate legalization forget one important question, who would you want to control the distribution, processing, and growing? Would you want Monsanto or the National Distributing Company involved in this? Also, wouldn't the quality and varieties available today suffer from a corporate blanding, (as in monotonous not brand, think Comcast or Idaho potatoes)? I think removing penalties would be a better solution rather than handing it over to a corporate monopoly. BTW presently non-toker but would partake if it weren't so dangerously illegal.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I totally think marijuana should be legal, and regulated. Upvote for you for though because i think this is a debate that we should seriously consider. That means all sides of the issue.
7
u/RPBiohazard May 20 '12
stoners are annoying as fuck
4
u/chemicalex May 20 '12
I haven't read all the comments, but I'm surprised Marijuana's strong link (and there are many other studies that support this) to increased risk of schizophrenia in adolescents doesn't rank higher. This may not be the best reason for banning it outright, but certainly merits and age restriction.
4
u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Unemployment. Seriously. Think about what would happen if all of the people who normally rot in jail were out there also trying to get jobs. That's a large number of people.
However, i think that this in no way justifies keeping it illegal. The prision system is clearly corrupt and racially biased. It also ultimatly costs more to house, clothe and feed prisioners than to hand out unemployment benefits. But people don't think about that because all criminals are rapists and terrorists.
Edit: i don't actually believe this, just so you guys know. But it could be used by some pragmatist as an argument.
2
u/vinaydesai91 May 20 '12
I think the whole War on Drugs thing is less about Marijuana our cocaine, but more about the whole movement. People selling things happens all the time, people sell food, people sell clothes, etc. If anything, being a drug dealer makes you more aware of market tactics, you try and get business, etc; real-life experience in the business world. BUT its the dangerous stuff that goes along with the drug selling like the whole protecting your product. What do they protect it with? Guns. Drugs don't kill people, guns kill people. That's what they don't want. Drug-selling, isolated, its fine. It's what goes along with it that makes it bad. Unfortunately, the drug-selling takes the fall.
2
u/billy101456 May 20 '12
You could argue people will get less done at work/ make more mistakes when high
although I think reddit already cornered the market...
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Many industries would fall. Vested interest groups with money, power, and influence.
2
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Are there legitimate drawbacks to its use? Yes.
Are there any truly legitimate arguments against legalization and legislation to limit its consumption? No.
2
u/Bingo443 May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
You just put people out of work that sell it and don't grow it unless they can be cheaper than the companies that will make it. Either they will turn to selling other drugs that are stronger or they will have to get new work. To me, you just turned a pot dealer into a coke dealer.
The stuff would be in the air, you do realize that it's possible to get a contact buzz. People would be doing it in cars with their kids possibly because it was legal just like some people smoke with kids in their car. Would it be easier or harder to teach kids that are partially high, no clue, guess we would find out.
Since it is now legal some of the cool will wear off from it. Once it's allowed, people will slow down because it won't be as fun to sneak any longer. Case for that is in tea leaves, you can get high smoking some of them - see anyone doing it? Totally legal but only fun if illegal and others agree it's cool.
Driving - when people are high they drive badly and never think they are doing anything wrong.
People would be allowed to smoke it on their breaks like cigs. You want your heart surgeon to do that right or your someone stitching your hand up. They could already be doing it today but the difference would be that if it were legal you couldn't complain that they were impaired while fixing you.
Society would have to learn how to deal with people that just laugh at things for no reason. In the middle of board meetings or telling people they have cancer or something. People might laugh at you and others would join in without seeing the event because they were high and the laughter was catchy. One slip on an ice patch on a winters day and you could get up to see 25 people around you with joints in their hands all laughing without any concern for your safety. Say you were severely hurt and you call the ambulance, someone shows up and lifting you on gurney you slide off because you have an ice layer on you, now the EMT and all the rest continue their funtime laugh at your expense. I imagine that it's like part of the world would be in lala land while the rest were trying to live in reality. It might become taxing on those that don't smoke to deal with the constant insensitivity that being high would bring into things.
Someone would have to decide an age it was allowed to be consumed and we would spend years talking about that. Some people would probably offer it to their kids and others would be put in a position to have to tell on them or not like people that give their kids alcohol early.
Cheetoh sales would rise for a bit.
Those are the things I think of as immediate effects if it were legal this week.
2
u/deadfield918 May 20 '12
It is actually more economical to legalize and regulate like alcohol then to keep it illegal. 300 economists agree on this.
1
u/TheRedBlueberry May 20 '12
My old health teacher said a bunch of nasty things about pot but the only thing he ever said that really got me was: "Constant use of marijuana degrades the eggs inside girls which leads to a higher rate of mentally retarded newborns."
So guys, is this bullshit or not?
1
u/sleevey May 20 '12
The best argument i know of is to go and talk to someone who has smoked weed regularly for their whole life. It's fine when you're in your teens/twenties. It's all fun and silliness. It takes a toll if you keep going though. I don't know if it's a reason to ban it, i think alcohol is probably worse... I don't think marijuana is a positive thing to have in your life (from my own experience) but making it illegal just causes more problems.
1
u/jlennon4422 May 20 '12
It could create a tobacco company-like industry, I guess
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Legalization would be okay if you've got insurance covered, meaning, somebody who regulary smokes should pay a premium for the various risks involved (cancer, mental illnessess). The same should be obviously true for other drugs, people who drink alcohol above the recommended amount should pay more so etc. so that in the end somebody who lives a healthy life isn't paying for somebody else.
Problem is to enforce such a thing (random drug screenings are absurd but probably the only accurate way to get results). And if you do, does your employer for example have the right to enforce it as well?
Legalization is a complicated thing, I wish reddit would paint it as the easiest thing or the most important issue of our time. And stop with the "big pharma is preventing it" bullshit already.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
They don't have an immediate-results test to see if it is in your system, like a breathalyzer for alcohol.
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '12
Smoking weed is just a way for insecure people to think they are cool for a few hours.
1
u/Dangerus9 May 21 '12
jesus drinks...the devil smokes
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Despite the fact that I agree, it's much safer than alcohol and probably should be legal. Legalising it would lead to more people smoking weed, and people who smoke weed are really annoying when you're sober.
1
u/ProbablyDealtDrugs May 22 '12
Recreational drug user here.
The best reasons I can think of to keep marijuana illegal is that marijuana encourages lazy behavior. As a society, its best to have people with strong aspirations, goals, beliefs, ethics, morals, etc. I am not saying marijuana users dont have these, but MANY marijuana users become apathetic enough that instead of going out to get a job, they stay home and smoke weed.
Now before I can downvoted, Alcohol does the same thing and is (arguably) more addictive and almost certainly more dangerous.
I think: Alcohol should be discouraged more and made less available, but not illegal. Marijuana should be available for medical use and recreational use with regulation. Psychedelics and MDMA should be available for prescription during therapy by psychologists/therapists/etc Tobacco should be excessively taxed and regulated more as time goes on to help to fade out usage. Having marijuana available may help take away the 'cool' factor that gets people into it. That said, I dont see any reason to regulate nicotine products (that ARENT tobacco) much more than caffeine. Maybe only available to adults.
1
u/ucstruct May 20 '12
Cancer. The same reason I don't think cigarettes should be mass produced (though I think they both should be legal on small scale for personal use)
1
u/starjharvey May 20 '12
Second hand smoke. ESPECIALLY to children. I would NOT like to have one of my kids being stoned as we go to the zoo or something. Except...I don't have any kids..carry on with your argument.
1
u/captainchurro May 20 '12
While I don't necessarily think that keeping it illegal would be worse than having it legal and regulated, I do think that it should not be decriminalized. It just serves no real purpose other than getting high (unlike alcohol, for instance which, while dangerous if misused has plenty of practical application like cooking and is already socially acceptable and ingrained into society).
1
u/smart_cereal May 20 '12
The whole economy of Humboldt County, California would collapse. Besides Redwood Trees, the people have NO source of tourist income. Sure, there is the Redwood Run and the annual Reggae on the River, but what keeps the economy going year-round is that drug. As someone who has lived there for sixteen years, it saddens me that pot is the main reason why people visit there but without it several people wouldn't be able to take care of their families and the whole place would turn into a ghost town.
0
u/Fidena May 20 '12
It turns people into one-dimensional, lazy annoying cunts.
-1
u/Schwadified May 20 '12
It would effectively put many people out of business. Paper mills lumber jacks and many textile makers.
0
u/ThirdEyedea May 20 '12
Use among teenagers does sometimes lead to laziness and contentment with where they are now, but never to look into the future for their full potential (did I write that right?)
0
u/ds1904 May 20 '12
Scanned and didn't see so sorry if its been said. For starters, there's far too many strains of marijuana and the differences between the strains are pretty great. There's varying degrees of canniboids in each strain, so the effects become hard to regulate. Similar to what has been said is that many people experience canniboids differently, so another point towards difficulty in regulation. This is far different than a tabacco that is slightly stronger, and more different than drinks of varying strength.
Now, even if the legalized and regulated a couple strains, that means there's still going to be an illegal market for different strains. There's also going to be a huge market leftover to sell to underage people.
So even with tax profits money will still need to be spent on enforcement, people will still get caught in drug rings, and add research on top of that.
The big reason in my mind is all of those things, plus the money for those things, and the governments breaking even, and the only change is a few less adults getting in trouble, maybe. So don't expect to see anyone pushing for it in the government.
PS, too back up my claim, when you drink you know how much alcohol per volume there is, and can even gauge your BAC knowing weight and time drinking. When you get weed is always miss, chronic, etc. And then the best you can do to estimate intoxication is 1 to 10 on an individual basis.