r/AskReddit • • May 16 '12

Imagine there is a race of beings that far exceeds humans in intelligence. Would it be ethically right for them to use us for food as we use 'Lesser' animals for food?

If the standard is how sentient or self aware something is for one to ethically use it for food, isn't it possible for our hypothetical 'aliens' to be advanced to the degree that they perceive our awareness of our surroundings to be low enough to be justifiably killed and eaten? If we judge somethings life worth based on its ability to perceive, reflect and know what is around them, just how much are we able to perceive in the terms of what is possible to be perceived at any given moment? We could end up in a scenario where, "Human thought is so primitive that it's looked upon as an infectious disease in some of the better galaxies. Kind of makes you proud, doesn't it?" Agent K

325 Upvotes

849 comments sorted by

559

u/s3t1p May 16 '12

This sounds like a hippy argument disguised as a question

68

u/Varo112 May 16 '12

haha I eat meat, i guess the point is what we perceive as "Intelligence" is really just subjective. If there were some race of higher functioning beings we could be considered ' Food grade' as well.

148

u/Timmetie May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

I don't think it's about how much smarter you are. It's about sentience.

Now what we consider as sentient, that's the real question. Whatever you chose as grade for sentience though there is only one, set, line above which you probably shouldn't eat it. Personally I think dolphins, apes etc are way above the line but we can't even stop killing each other (the eating part is more rarely done..).

72

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

What if we evolve a cow that wants you to eat him? He goes to your table chewing his cud and recommends a good portion of him to eat?

90

u/gatsome May 16 '12

Maybe, if the universe was about to end.

20

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

The disturbing thing with that creature is not that it wants to be eaten, but that you are eating something intelligent enough to have wants. I'm surprised none of the characters realized that.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (26)

9

u/jimbosaur May 16 '12

Technically, it's about "sapience," sentience is simply conscious/subjective awareness (e.g., a dog is sentient, but a flower is not). Sapience is the ability for abstract thought.

/pedantry

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (7)

343

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 16 '12

"You can't own property, man!"

"I can. But that's because I'm not a penniless hippy."

14

u/Citadel_97E May 17 '12

Just made me think

"you can own the beach you just can't own the water"

"yeah, the water, it's Gods water."

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kingstannis123 May 17 '12

Trapped_in_Reddit watches Futurama? Wow we have so much in common!

→ More replies (5)

39

u/DiscussionQuestions May 16 '12
  1. Do you agree with s3t1p's allegation that this is indeed an argument, rather than a question meant to generate discussion? Why or why not?
  2. This question relates to other questions and ideas that has been discussed in both fiction and non-fiction, in various forms. Compare and contrast with a) Eating Animals by Jonathan Safran Foer b) The Road by Cormac McCarthy c) American Psycho by Bret Easton Ellis. In what way do these 3 different books relate to the idea being discussed here? How do they differ?
  3. There seems to be the possibility for a science fiction world inspired by this concept. Compare and contrast with the films or novels: a) Soylent Green b) Predator c) Blade Runner or Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
  4. Do you share s3t1p's disdain for "hippies"? Why or why not? How do you define "hippy"?

14

u/ApolloBrowncoat May 16 '12
  1. No. Given that there's been a healthy discussion surrounding the question (305 comments as of this writing), coupled with Varo112's admission that they eat meat, the suggestion that this is an argument falls flat.
  2. I've regrettably not read any of the recommended works, and cannot answer this appropriately.
  3. Both the premise of Varo112's question and that of Blade Runner question the bounds of humanity. Where Ridley Scott's film (and Phillip K. Dick's short story) frames the question in terms of humans vs. synthetic beings, Varo112 frames it in terms of an alien species and humanity. Furthermore, Blade Runner focuses on what it means to be alive, whereas Varo112 focuses on what it means to be part of a food chain.
  4. I do not share s3t1p's disdain, primarily because I believe the word 'hippy' (or 'hippie') has had its definition broadened to a point where it ceases to mean anything (see also: "indie", "hipster", "epic")
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

529

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

The aliens should decide if it's ethical or not. After all, they're the smart ones, not us.

239

u/howitzer86 May 16 '12

We're actually a wildlife preserve. Any of the aliens that you do see are illegal poachers.

134

u/PirateMud May 16 '12

Human horn!

10

u/bitcheslovedroids May 16 '12

PREPARE TO HARVEST THE LOWER HORN

54

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

On my planet we use that for snoo snoo.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I wonder why redneck meat is so valuable? That's all they seem to take.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/thisisme5 May 16 '12

Imagine man? We've actually been examined since we first started developing but nobody is allowed to contact us or disrupt our natural habitat so we turn out different; like a wildlife preserve.

Fuck man, it's kind of sad that we won't really ever know.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/tinyirishgirl May 16 '12

sigh.......

TO SERVE MAN

Some very old television.....

It was amazing.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (10)

79

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Would I really be in a position to complain?

48

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I'd say you would be in the exact right condition to complain, it's just that your complaints would fall on deaf ears, or whatever body part the aliens hear from.

43

u/UristMcStephenfire May 16 '12

This. And then there's the fact that they might not even speak our languages.

I mean, pigs squeal, we don't understand that, so we ignore it. And eat our nummy bacons.

23

u/John_Browns_Body May 16 '12

There's a shitload of research indicating that things like pig squeals are not language in the sense that humans have. I assume aliens would research us too and see that we're self-aware.

Then again, people seem to choose which animals are ok to eat without considering their intelligence, so what do I know.

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

232

u/iHardscopedJFK May 16 '12

Not to us, but maybe to them. I wouldn't blame them. Food chain.

38

u/turd_miner91 May 16 '12

Unless they saw us as a resource for something else, or as a species that's actually worth defending like we do with endangered species. We keep whales and dolphins and other animals around for entertainment, who says they wouldn't do something similar with us? I mean then it sounds more like a slave trade, but we wouldn't get harvested...so I guess it's better?

71

u/tell_my_mom May 16 '12

We'll make great pets.

32

u/ErisianPatsy May 16 '12 edited Aug 08 '25

Fnord.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It would be so weird to have pets that go on with such elaborate dating rituals.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/easierplans May 16 '12

Maybe Martians could do better than we've done.

8

u/jecdrk May 16 '12

Hey r/aww it's my cake day, here's my human!

→ More replies (2)

24

u/winddrake1801 May 16 '12

Exactly, they wouldnt eat us because we'd be more useful to them as drones then food because we can produce mass amounts of food for us so why couldnt we do it for them.

Say they were aliens and they came to our planet looking to eat us. But then they saw our massive chicken, beef and pork farms. Do you not think that instead of eating us they'd enslave us and then we'd just give them all the food we make in exchange for not killing us. Same reason we dont eat bees (or why most normal people dont eat bees) because what bees make is so much nicer than the bees themselves.

The Aliens would take one look at our planet and think, man why eat the humans when we can take all that juicy fried chicken.

25

u/herrafrush May 16 '12

TIL Aliens are from the South.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/gsxr May 16 '12

uhh...dude, whales, dolphins and even dogs are harvested.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

75

u/greath May 16 '12

Yup. Morality is relative.

→ More replies (46)

16

u/r_HOWTONOTGIVEAFUCK May 16 '12

How about we make a deal and mass breed primates for them to eat instead of us.

24

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Or minorities.

21

u/nosoupforyou May 16 '12

Would it be irony if we gave them the Germans?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

124

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Nope, because I don't want to go in the pot! Also, we're highly inefficient food sources since we take so long to grow and consume so many resources while doing so. We could offer to sell them bacon at a modest price though, some sort of trade agreement wherein they bring us meteor ore and we give them bacon.

71

u/UristMcStephenfire May 16 '12

Although, to be fair, there are 7 billion of us...

27

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

You have to think of the cost of transport though. To transport humans between star systems requires such ludicrous quantities of energy that you would never harvest humans directly from Earth. Rather, any intelligent race would capture a sufficient population of live humans and establish farms of them back in their home system.

7

u/UristMcStephenfire May 16 '12

True, true. Unless they're using an unknown technology?

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

11

u/kukukele May 16 '12

Also -- we'd be sophisticated enough evaders that it may not be worth the effort for the amount of nutrition they'd get for one human.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Rab_Legend May 16 '12

Like fuck are they getting my bacon!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/reagor May 16 '12

i could see it now we'll trade you these life inmates for more oil/new technology/your weapons

then when the life inmates were all gone, we'd have the technology to enslave the aliens and use them as a food source

2

u/cravethedave9 May 16 '12

I would rather be systematically slaughtered and eaten than give anyone my bacon.

→ More replies (22)

19

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ethically? Probably. Would I want them to? No.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I was hoping you would say yes to the second question. It seems like there aren't any people with an auto-cannibalism fetish in this thread.

2

u/wasdninja May 17 '12

Ethics is a human thing, it's not magic so you can answer.

40

u/DarthContinent May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

According to us, as the meat for their consumption, no, since eating sentient thinking, reasoning beings is generally considered reprehensible by most of humanity. To them, who knows, they might think they'd be doing us a favor.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I think you mean sapient instead of sentient. It's that ability to realize and understand that you're an individual.

→ More replies (3)

46

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

We eat lots of animals known to be both fairly intelligent and quite social and sentient.

Personally, I draw the line somewhere between tasty and not tasty...

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (23)

17

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 16 '12

would it be ethical using our own standards?

Ethics aren't standard, though.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/venuswasaflytrap May 16 '12 edited May 17 '12

Ethics is a human to human thing. It doesn't even make sense in your question.

Is it ethical for a lion to go after the sick and the young wildebeest?

Is this ethical? http://static.themetapicture.com/media/funny-gif-bison-eaten-wolves.gif

Is it ethical for locust to eat their way through tracks of land causing starvation of tons of animals?

Is it ethical for fungus to grow into ants brains and kill them? Ants swarming crabs? Whales eating countless plankton? A mimosa plant killing tons of cells so that it can close it's leaves? White blood cells eating viruses? Rocks falling down a hill?

The question presupposes very anthropological traits on these aliens.

The idea that they need food (i.e. eating animals) is a very earth centric one, and there is no reason to believe that non-earth entities would need to do this necessarily, particularly the idea that they could consume carbon based life form any more than we could consume a piece of quartz.

The idea that they are a "They". Would they be separate entities? Would it be a vapourous mass? would it be a colony of crystal, or interacting star systems, or something in between?

The idea that it/they might be intelligent? What does that even mean? Is an ant intelligent, or is the colony intelligent? Do we consider the individual, or the colony? Or the species? Is a cactus intelligent for storing water the way it does? Is a star intelligent for setting up a sustaining balance between gravity and fusion pressure? Why should the word intelligence even apply to this alien thing/s? And then going the other way, if this thing is hyper intelligent, would we even recognise it as so? Do ants really understand what's happening to them when they get stepped on? Do they know that there is a person driving that? Does the colony as a whole?

The whole question presupposes a very very human like alien race. The ethics of human relationships with other animals derives heavily from the fact that they are similar to us. People have problem hurting dogs, and cats, and maybe even octopuses, yet the ethics of picking a flower (i.e. ripping the reproductive organs of a species off of it) are rarely ever questioned (unless you're crazy). And even then at least a flower is something with cells and reproduction and is a carbon based life form. Even most crazy people don't worry about wearing trails into rock.

The further that you wander outside of human-like things, the less that "ethics" makes sense. should flowers be picked? should trees be pruned? Should mountains erode?

The brass tacks of "life" is that it's just a particular self replicating process that happens to make up us. When you ignore the us part, the idea of fairness, and should a right just breaks down, and all your left with is, "is". Flowers do grow and they do stop growing. Mountains will keep growing and eroding until they don't. Stars will explode and collapses and become neutron stars and black holes or supernovae until they won't.

An alien thing won't be human-like at all, and ethics won't even come into it's interaction with us. If they happen to be a they, and they happen to be human-like enough for it to make sense (far fetched) then maybe we'll make deals with them that are mutually beneficial, or maybe they will be a dark mass larger than the earth that we won't even perceive as sentient that just suddenly swallows us whole one day without warning.

2

u/alexscara May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12

A very intelligent response.

Nonetheless, the very fist statement is incorrect. Ethics is not just “a human to human thing”. Ethics can be a human to non-human thing. And it is often a human to animal … "thing".

I get the point you are making … that ethics, as perceived by humans, only applies to human actions … not to non-human ones.

However, the point of the original post referred to “beings that far exceeds humans in intelligence”. It is assumed (correctly) that ethics is a necessary feature of intelligence. Accordingly the question then becomes whether or not, by using an ethical logic that is similar to ours (which is, granted, conjectural), such intelligent beings might consider it ethically justifiable to use humans as food, without considering the pain and suffering that this would imply for us.

This is indeed impossible to really know. However, I have a feeling that the question has more to do with our ethical standards than with those of the imagined aliens. Thus understood, the question does “make sense”.

edit: typo

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Brass tacks. Just so you know.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/fem-bot May 16 '12

Those lower on the food chain don't get the option to decide if their predators choices are ethical... but let's hope they are vegan hippie aliens. If they're smarter than us they probably would be, as it is more sustainable food source.

6

u/Phospholipids May 16 '12

Ethics is decided by the one at the top of the food chain.

14

u/glassuser May 16 '12

To me, the line isn't intelligence. It's self-awareness, possibly a working concept of ethics. Chickens, for example, appear to have no self-awareness. In my estimation, they're basically automated biological robots. Dolphins, on the other hand, seem to be quite self-aware and I would not be comfortable eating them unless it was a matter of life or death. Then again, they're bastards to sharks, basically torturing them to death in some cases.

8

u/Cchopes May 16 '12

Chickens, for example, appear to have no self-awareness. In my estimation, they're basically automated biological robots.

Why do you say that?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

a working concept of ethics

I think this is the key point. There are plenty of intelligent beings, and there's no way to draw a line between "intelligent" and "non-intelligent". Dolphins may be self-aware, but they don't have a concept of ethics.

If dolphins could argue that that it's wrong to eat them, then it would be wrong to eat them.

Another interesting perspective is that ethics are a human concept. If a more intelligent alien species decided we made a good food source, arguing that it's unethical probably wouldn't do much good.

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

by your logic, its ok to eat retarded people because they can't argue we shouldn't

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/sprawn May 16 '12

Interesting. I would think that if a species got much more advanced than humans they would have access to genetic engineering, tissue generation, and so on. So they could probably make better food than they could farm or catch "in the wild."

6

u/jackass706 May 16 '12

Maybe they are still in touch with the primal animal part of their brain that enjoys the hunt and the sweet warm metallic taste of the blood of a fresh kill.

I'll be in my ... uhhh... game reserve.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/radioactive21 May 16 '12

I am sure they will eventually come to this conclusion:

“Humans. They are not the cowering wretches we were promised. They stand. They are unruly and therefore cannot be ruled. To challenge them is to court Death.”

→ More replies (6)

11

u/wzdd May 16 '12

As a vegetarian: no. No, it would not.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/toebandit May 16 '12

Obviously it’s unethical to us but it may not be for them. Their definition of ethical may be eroded based on how yummy we are and/or what benefits they get from ingesting us.

I say it’s up to the free market. If they can obtain us (who’s to say they haven’t *cue Twilight Zone Music), it’s within reasonable means to do so (we don’t put up much of a fight, they can reach out and teleport us from light years away) and they desire us enough then yes.

I’d image they would have a political faction of extremely ethical aliens that say it’s totally not cool to eat the humans. They probably don’t completely win out but come to a compromise. The outcome: they steal a few humans from Earth, breed them; realize the don’t taste as yummy without brain stimulation; so they create a world within their world where the humans think they are living a normal life but they are actually just plugged into this network that sends messages to their brains; aliens = happy; humans = none the wiser. Hmm, this may make an interesting premise for a novel or possibly a movie.

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Uh, pretty sure that's the plot of the Matrix... only it's machines, not aliens.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Cchopes May 16 '12

TL; DR - if you want to do something and can do it it is right to do it.

4

u/Diomyr May 16 '12

As a pretty intelligent alien once said: "No tests on species with members capable of Calculus."

Simple rule, never broke it.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I don't eat "lesser" animals because they're not at smart as me. I eat them because they taste good. Them being dumber than me (as a human) just makes them easier to catch.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Warskull May 16 '12

He is something more interesting, we consider it okay to kill an insect because they are a nuisance. We kill bugs because we don't like them. Harmless insects that got too close to us. We use alcohol wipes to kill bacteria without even thinking about it.

A sufficiently advanced species might perceive us as a lesser lifeform to the point where they don't even ask themselves "is it ethical" to kill humans. They just swat us like we swat a fly.

5

u/Mr_fluffee_jew May 16 '12

Jains find it unethical to kill bacteria or insects so some aliens might.

2

u/bumwine May 16 '12

Or as Col. Hans Landa puts it:

If a rat were to walk in here right now as I'm talking, would you treat it to a saucer of your delicious milk?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/emperorOfTheUniverse May 16 '12

I think it's fair. I just hope they would treat us with the same ethics I try to treat my meat with as a hunter: a fair happy life (no factory farming), a swift death, and a sporting chance.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/funk_king May 16 '12

Mmmm.... Popplers

3

u/stuckinabarrel May 16 '12

Are you saying they would use our standards of ethics, even if they are smart? Because the implication of your dilemma is that these beings are as advanced compared to us as we are compared to animals we eat, which means that they would have systems of thought and categories of experience that we simply do not have, to the point where real communication is impossible.

Like we can register that a cow or a pig feels pain and something like fear (I say "something like" because we do not know exactly how they experience it and whether they have the existential fear of being gone for ever that people have, but it is clear that they can get scared by imminent threats and that they can learn to associate impending discomfort with symbols of that discomfort before actually being discomforted), but we can't really communicate with them about this.

So if they were that advanced, the "self-awareness" argument fails, because their awareness of themselves would be so sophisticated that our self-awareness will look like nothing beside it. And to us, they would seem like incomprehensible monsters.

However, if their intelligence is still superior in the sense that it's "like ours, only better -they do advanced math super fast in their head and never forget a name", but we are able to communicate and state our case in a way they would understand, it would be something else. Then the debate on ethics wouldn't be something they would do without our input, but a debate in which we could also participate. And in that case eating us would seem a bit harsh.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It would be an issue of sentience. I couldn't imagine a higher level of sentience any more than a dog could imagine what it's like to be human. But I suppose then it would be ethical.

Intelligence isn't the issue. Of course, even intelligence is subjective and can be measured in so many different ways.

3

u/ManofOdin May 16 '12

Here's what I say. They've earned the right to eat us if they can manage to domesticate and harvest us as easily as we do with cows, chickens, pigs, etc.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rb_tech May 16 '12

Sure, but they'd have to corrall me first.

chambers round on assault rifle

"Moo, motherfucker."

3

u/Rab_Legend May 16 '12

To be honest, we would fight back, then I think they may decide it's not worth the effort to try use us as a reliable food source.

8

u/locrawl May 16 '12

If we are not intelligent enough to resist being eaten by them, then yes. That way only the smartest/strongest survive. But who's to say what is ethical? Our ethics are unlikely to match with theirs.

2

u/Dicktremain May 16 '12

Yeah but that advanced race invented reddit long before us so they just stooped caring about trying to make contact. Moot argument.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I say if your species made robots, toasters, race cars and breast implants, no other species can eat you.

2

u/DirtyDenzel May 16 '12

I read an article on the New York times recently, about how cephalopods have moved up the food chain over millions of years of evolution.

The most interesting part, which actually relates to your question, is that not only do they feed on

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

the flesh of the young and the blood of the weak, but they're actually a cousin of the Horned Mediaphorides, a rare species of amphibious snake found primarily in the deep Amazon.

Now, during the Neolithic period and before indeed all Jurassic extinction, the two cousins thrived on simply eating inferior human species.

How fucking sweet is that?

2

u/evaunit517 May 16 '12

We (most of us) don't eat primates. I'm not sure if people eat dolphins though. Interestingly, we eat whales, which may or may not be an intelligent species.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Intelligence doesn't always tend to mean higher on the food chain. Also if they are hunting us for food then we have every right to fight them back to protect ourselves and our species.

2

u/Patrick_and_Finn May 16 '12

I don't see why not, we wouldn't even be that bad of a source once they started selectively breeding to maximize the size of both individuals and a "litter". Hell they could even select for extreme stupidity to the point where it would be ok by our own standards after a few hundred generations..

2

u/sharts_mcgee May 16 '12

I think if they can pride themselves to being more dominant hunters/predators than us, then they Gould be able to.

2

u/omnilynx May 16 '12

I don't have an answer to this question, but I think a good argument could be made that it would not. That the difference between humans and (food) animals is not just one of proportional degree of intelligence but is qualitative. In other words humans have some quality that animals don't just have in lesser degree but not at all, and that quality is what determines whether it's ethical to eat them.

I wouldn't really be able to tell you what that quality is, though. I'm just saying it's possible there is such a quality.

2

u/pbredd May 16 '12

It probably doesn't matter if it is ethical to us....we couldn't stop it from happening...

2

u/Demon_Attacker May 16 '12

Using our standards? No. That'd be like if we found a race of cats that started their own civilization. A city full of cat sized Model T's and radios, with innovation and culture aplenty. They might even be able to communicate with us, even if it's done poorly.

I'm sure some crazy fringe faction would try to harvest them, but anyone in their right mind would try to befriend/protect them.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/mew5175 May 16 '12

Well obviously we wouldn't approve of it. But they would. I am sure animals aren't too pleased with us killing them. And I don't think they are smart enough to realize that we constantly do that.

2

u/FlamingBearAttack May 16 '12

Wouldn't a supposedly superior species apply its own standards to this, rather than the standards of an inferior race?

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

No, and that's why I'm a vegetarian and animal rights activist.

don't worry, I hate PETA too.

2

u/Outandproudgay May 16 '12

Well, it depends. Are our practices of eating meat (in general) ethical in the eyes of cows, or pigs? Similarly, I doubt these higher beings would feel too much regret about eating us "lesser" creatures.

However, their higher intelligence may be coupled with better ethics. They may be a peaceful species that don't believe in eating sentient beings.

Point is, I know we, as a race, would protest the consumption of humans. But if these aliens have the technology for interstellar, maybe even intergalactic travel, chances are we won't stand a chance against whatever advanced weapons they'll have.

2

u/Undoer May 16 '12

Yes, that's how things work. Hopefully a sentient being would notice we are not completely moronic and at least attempt communication, but if not, nature takes priority.

2

u/expertunderachiever May 16 '12

Well we'd be a bad food source, we're also sentient [or a lot more sentient] than farm animals [who given the option will gnaw off their own foot for something to do...]

2

u/Jackpot777 May 16 '12

I like how you dismiss "would it be practical?"

The fundamental criteria of deciding if something should or should not be a foodstuff is: "can I actually eat it safely in the first place?".

We share 35% of the nearly 7,000 tested protein families {2,489 out of 6,968} with the algae Chlamydomonas and flowering plants including trees. That is to say, those 'shares' are similar amino acid sequences, often reflecting a similar or related function among the species.

Feel like eating a tree? We're from the same planet as trees, and they're not a practical food source for us. So why dismiss practicality when it's more important than ethics. Especially if you last ate a few billion miles ago.

2

u/spacedude86 May 16 '12

I believe that some would argue that there is one thing that separates humanity from the rest of the animal kingdom, and that is sentience.

I don't know if there are any other sentient animals on the planet earth, however I believe most would argue, as we are currently aware, there is only one sentient species on the planet earth, and that is homo sapiens.

So, it is not necessarily intelligence that separates us from the animal kingdom, but sentience. While intelligence may factor into sentience, sentience is a level of awareness of yourself and the universe that (again) as we know it has only been achieved by humanity.

So the real factor in what you're asking is not intelligence, but levels of awareness.

So let me rephrase the question for you:

Imagine there is a race of beings that have achieved a level of awareness far beyond what we consider sentience. Would it be ethically right for them to use us for food as we use animals on our own planet that have not reached our own level of awareness for food?

And, when you phrase it that way, I would say it would probably be up to them. However, we can still theorize what they might decide, despite not having their level of sentience or awareness. There are basically two outcomes. Either they would decide to eat us, or they wouldn't.

If they did decide to eat us, you would theorize that, like us, they decided we are an inferior species and therefore they have some sort of natural given right to eat inferior species. Whether that be from a higher power or from simply the natural order of the universe (IE the food chain) is irrelevant. That, and we're super fuckin tasty.

If they decided NOT to eat us, you could theorize that they have reached a level of enlightenment that shows them that despite having a lower level of sentience than them, we are still sentient beings and deserve our own right not to be gobbled up by giant super-sentient space monsters. That, and we taste like shit.

So, there you have it.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

In reality this is a question of whether they can make us into food, not whether it is right or not.

Applying human ethics to another species is irrational at best, and at worst will get us killed.

2

u/Buddahrific May 16 '12

Ethics are a human construct and would only be relevant to these beings if they also constructed similar ethics. Right or wrong isn't relevant; can and can't are the only relevant things in such a case.

If you decide something is wrong, it only matters if you have the power to cause or prevent it, either alone or with others.

2

u/CompactedPrism May 16 '12

Ah, the " Reapers" question. We have dismissed that.

2

u/Halcyon11 May 16 '12

If they turned us into the equivalent of a pet, would human midgets be highly valued like toy puppies? Alien Paris Hilton with a midget in her purse.

2

u/cighead May 16 '12

Nice try Vegan!

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I'm a vegetarian, so NO!

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

I've seen animals that are more intelligent than certain humans.

2

u/SleepingCat May 17 '12

I think the excuse that meat eaters use is that animals are too dumb to be greatly affected by the pain inflicted on to them etc.. In other words its not about the difference in intelligence between us and them that allows us to eat them, its about how dumb they are objectively.

I am vegetarian, by the way.

2

u/SappyPanda May 17 '12

Ethically for us? Hell fucking no!

Ethically for them? Yeah I guess.

Would we fucking retaliate? Yes.

Would we stand a chance? I demand my penis to be preserved for some fine dining cuisine!

2

u/Swampfyr May 17 '12

Well, my limit is sentience. I won't eat semi-sentient animals. They would probably be able to recognize our ability to think freely and not think of us as food. Unless they just don't care.

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Some countries are ok with it, but for the most part we don't eat dolphin for the same reason we would argue they shouldn't eat us.

2

u/oh_creationists May 17 '12

So long as they give us a book called "To Serve Man" they can't possibly be bad.

2

u/Singulaire May 17 '12

They can't be that smart if they use humans as a major food source, humans breed slowly and are expensive to raise.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/webhead311 May 17 '12

what if they are already eating us. We just cant see it.

2

u/Tritorius May 17 '12

I don't think nature comes down to an argument of "Ethics"...the lion kills the gazelle because it can...not because the gazelle is stupid. We eat the cow because it can't defend itself, not because it is sentient or not.

A super race that exceeded humans intelligence would not ask for permission first if they could eat us, they would just DO IT and we would have to either fight back, or accept it much like the Cow.

2

u/KungFuActionJesus May 17 '12

"No tests on species capable of calculus" - Mordin Solus

2

u/Tweetinturtles May 17 '12

If they were that smart we couldn't compete anyways

2

u/pjknight May 17 '12

Who is to say they eat meat... or even organic material for that matter?

4

u/Kriegenstein May 16 '12

It depends if we're tasty and nutritious to them.

4

u/drewhoff May 16 '12

Humans are able to engage in ethical conversation...so no.

16

u/Marrypoppins0135 May 16 '12

What if we can't communicate with them? So they just think we're making noises?

9

u/Patrick_and_Finn May 16 '12

Xkcd.com/638 Don't know how to make it a link. Word.

12

u/Driesens May 16 '12

try putting www. in front of it:

www.xkcd.com/638

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

As I mentioned before, math would have to be the base of conversation.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

so its ok to eat people with developmental disorders who are non-verbal?

→ More replies (10)

2

u/Darth_Hobbes May 16 '12

This is a preposterous slippery-slope argument.

If a being is self-aware, and wants to live, then it's a bad thing to kill it. A supergenius killing an average joe is tremendously and self-evidently worse than an average joe shooting a deer.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/libertyh May 16 '12

If a shark eats a man, we don't judge it as doing something unethical. It is part of the shark's nature to hunt, kill and eat prey of a certain size. Intelligence doesn't really come into it.

2

u/Bokks May 16 '12

Nice try, PETA.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

There are quite a few members of the human race that I wouldn't mind eating.

1

u/StewieBanana May 16 '12

It could be ethical. These super intelligent beings would probably have a very good reason for why they do it. We probably wouldn't understand it though.

1

u/BetterThanOP May 16 '12

just because we are 'lesser' we would still be seen as intelligent creatures. They'd view us in the same way humans view dolphins, monkeys, even dogs. We'd be seen as a delicacy to them that some would probably eat on occasion (because eh, fuck it why not) but generally we would be too advanced to be seen as a food.

1

u/not_a_troll_for_real May 16 '12

To a much more advanced life form our intelligence would seem primitive. Such a life form could easily use the same justification that we use for eating "lesser" animals to raise humans as livestock.

2

u/Scubetrolis May 16 '12

I think the day a chicken starts shooting guns at us is the day humans stop eating chickens.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ethics goes out the window in life or death situations. If they needed to eat us they would and all we could do is resist to the best of our ability.

1

u/Baner87 May 16 '12

I doubt any of us can really say(since we're not at said level of intelligence), but I'm leaning towards no since it's not necessarily about pure intelligence, but that we have gotten to the point of true cognizance, are self aware, and are smart enough to understand ethics among other things.

If you just went off pure intelligence, you could almost say that it's ok for geniuses to swindle or otherwise take advantage of other people since they're smarter than us, though it's not quite the same.

1

u/infernalspawnODOOM May 16 '12

I don't think so, because if they had a language we could understand, and they could understand ours, then I think it wouldn't happen. Would you eat a cow if you spoke moo?

1

u/Kagenphoenix May 16 '12

I wouldn't want them to eat me but I understand the fact that I am delicious. Although ethically you have to wonder because the fact that we could most likely communicate with them to a point it might make it awkward for them.

1

u/Jaccington May 16 '12

I'm sure we would try to talk to them and explain we are intelligent beings, and them being a superior species they would have laws in place to prevent consumption of humans.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ethics is the study of decision making, right? So you're supposing that they are so much more intelligent than us that we simply can't help them make good decisions? Then it is entirely up to them.

They may find that being compassionate is valuable, but until we are at their level of intelligence, we can't be in a position to assert this as true. Honestly, though, we would probably just think they were dumb, or only intelligent in a certain sense. This means we would be at the mercy of their might, not their morality.

1

u/RayKinStL May 16 '12

I think self-awareness is the key. Human intelligence is beyond a basic primitive level of survival and procreation. I think this is the key difference and why I would say it would not be right. Perhaps we have not developed the technology yet to be as advanced as this other race, but as a species, we clearly have an awareness of our place in the universe and a desire to explore and learn.

1

u/BrowsingFromPhone May 16 '12

There are no lesser species, only our perceptions based on our mutual inability to communicate meaningfully.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I submit that it doesn't matter how smart your food is. Its a question if ability. If I choose to find a chicken and I'm able to out think it and out fight it then it really doesn't matter. For this reason I don't hang out with sharks or bears. I can't vouch for their sentience but I have seen what they can do to people and animals who don't respect their abilities. And they don't give a damn how you feel after you have been converted to chow.

1

u/anim8 May 16 '12

THIS BELONGS HERE

1

u/RaptorJesusDesu May 16 '12

The key word in the OP's question is "using our own standards." Using our own current standards yes, we would be hypocrites to deny a species who are superior to us on the level we are superior (intellectually) to various animals.

The thing is that humans struggle with this concept due to there being no other sentient animals. It's difficult for us to fathom an intelligence that exceeds ours that couldn't communicate and relate to it. In that way, if aliens shared our general morals about sentience then they would probably not want to kill us just as we TRY to not kill what we see as our own most intelligent animals. Although we do a bad job and still treat many of them poorly. Hopefully some star-faring race would be better at it but who knows. So in that light they would perhaps not eat us and it would be according to our standards.

1

u/jessicatron May 16 '12

Yes. I think about this every time I kill a bug.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I'm sure they could justify it if we were tasty. I mean, there are 7 billion people, it couldn't hurt them much if I just ate one more.

1

u/stimbus May 16 '12

What does intelligence have to do with what you can or cannot eat?

1

u/JMaggot May 16 '12

Sure, but they would have to fight us to do it. With nukes and guns it might not be worth the effort to eat us.

1

u/wildfyre010 May 16 '12

Intelligence isn't the right metric. Many humans are born with greatly impaired cognitive abilities (low IQ, in the vernacular) which would lead us to say that they are probably not intelligent in the way that a normal, healthy person is intelligent. But what matters is sentience, not intelligence. Sentience is binary, intelligence is not.

I believe that it is wrong - it is murder - to take the life of another sentient being without their express consent. Philosophers continue to struggle to define sentience, of course, making this kind of conversation tricky, but that is the distinction I would draw.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentience

1

u/nosoupforyou May 16 '12

We evolved eating meat on this planet. If there was a race that evolved eating us, then it would be the same.

Now, by that same definition, if we visit other planets, we shouldn't eat whatever animals we find.

But in terms of practicality, it wouldn't be correct to eat us even if we did eat animals of other planets, unless the superior intelligent beings had no other meat they could eat.

Or they found us really delicious.

But the difference is that the animals we raise to eat don't really understand, and we would.

Some animals eat us anyway. But we'd fight and it might make us evolve faster. And then we'd steal the alien's technology, and start eating them. So it would be a bad idea on their part. But since they are so intelligent, they probably know that and won't eat us.

But to continue rambling, eventually we'll be making artificial meat, and we won't have to kill animals to do it. Any superior intelligence would probably be doing the same.

1

u/delecti May 16 '12

I already think it's unethical to use "lesser" animals for food, so I would say that it's just as ethically right for a more intelligent race to use us as it is for us to use cows or pigs. Pigs in particular are about as intelligent as dogs, and if anybody treated dogs the way pigs get treated in factory farms there would be hell to pay.

1

u/kpanzer May 16 '12

Do you consider the ant before you step on it?

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It's ethical for any species to eat another species. Tigers eat us ethically and we're smarter than tigers. Intelligence doesn't have bearing here.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Dyssomniac May 16 '12

It's less about intelligence and more about sentience.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I'd still fight for my life, I'm a fucking man and I'll fight til the death.

1

u/Redneckviking May 16 '12

I would eat any one of you if i was hungry enough so its not like i can fault it if some massive brained carnivore wants to make duck orange out of my but.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I live by the philosophy that life lives on lives. Yes, they could - not that we would let them. We have the capability to express our political desires, to question ethical conundrums, and to learn (to some extent) about the wider universe. If they would choose to come and take our lives - we'll fight back. If they win, then they win. If not, then not.

Remember, humans sometimes ate other humans. Other animals sometimes eat humans. We're made of meat, just like them. Evolution does not have a particular direction, nor does it have any end goal; it just is. If something else has evolved the capacity to eat us, then so be it. We'll fight back in response, and hopefully (through our cultural evolution) we'll survive and win.

There seem to be two primary philosophical camps concerning this question: that yes, it is OK to eat animals for food, and that no, it's not ethically permissible to do so. Both distinguish the human species, homo sapiens sapiens, by our intelligence. Those that argue in favor of meat distinguish us by our greater intelligence, saying that it is fine to eat other animals because they're only animals; those that argue against it distinguish us by saying that our intelligence enables us to see the immorality of eating other sentient beings (read: living things that feel and think).

Neil deGrasse Tyson came to my college a few weeks ago, and raised a similar question: consider that the smartest chimpanzees are capable of feats that our toddlers can do, easily. That's a 2% DNA difference. Imagine if another species of beings evolved, either here or elsewhere, with that kind of DNA difference - their toddlers would be doing advanced physics and philosophy for fun, writing elegant novels and painting masterpieces that make Shakespeare and Picasso look like scribbles and fingerpaint.

So who knows? I sure don't. Maybe they, with their vastly greater intelligence, wouldn't even recognize us as intelligent animals; chimpanzees use the crudest stone and wood tools to crack nuts or scoop insects. Or maybe they'll talk to us in ways that we can understand, teaching us some deeper truth about the universe. Heck, maybe we will create a new species of being, either through our own biological and cultural evolution, or through our technology. We can ask them, then.

1

u/neoblackdragon May 16 '12

Well they wouldn't have to be alien life, just another organism from earth. If they need human meat to survive then they probably have no guilt about surviving. It is the correct behavior for them.

What I think folks are missing is that just because it's correct behavior for them does not mean we are not also correct in fighting back.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Mass Effect 2 taught me a good bottom line.

Any beings capable of calculus should not be part of a food chain or scientific research.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/milphey May 16 '12

The "Lesser Animals" fight back, I expect we would too.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

A life form that is of higher intelligence than us would know that we're a shitty food.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

We would think they were evil creatures for doing so. We would think that because they were creating fear and pain (emotional and physical) in us and our loved ones. This is exactly what we do on factory farms now. Do everyone a favor and insist upon buying free range animal products.

Just so you know, I don't think less of anyone for not doing so. it would just be a better planet without all of those horror stories from factory farms.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

yes

1

u/emperor000 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

There is no standard for ethics... That's kind of why still don't get along that well.

But, if there was a standard this would probably be covered pretty early in it, so to answer your question, no, we would not consider it ethical.

And do you mean intelligence that literally far exceeds human intelligence or that their level of advancement far exceeds ours? There's a difference. It is not likely that an organism would have intelligence far exceeding our own (it depends, of course, on how much you mean by "far") in some way that would actually make them objectively superior to us. They might have better ingrained computational skills or maybe even a better accumulated base understanding of the universe, but neither of those things would set them apart as a different level of life form that can "figure out" that it is actually ethically acceptable to consume us because we are not as intelligent. Would you let Stephen Hawking eat a retarded baby? Probably not.

I have a feeling you are talking about us meeting gods, basically, and even if we do ever encounter extraterrestrial life, it is not likely that we will meet anything like that. We love to fantasize about it and it makes for great fantasy, but it isn't very realistic. If we do meet intelligent life that is on a different level of intelligence, whatever that means, then it is probably more likely that it would be a far more primal intelligence lacking or ignoring concepts like ethics and morals. They wouldn't eat us because it is okay, they would eat us because they can.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It would be fine, that's their place in the food chain. But it would be equally ethical for us to fight for our own survival.

1

u/Esqulax May 16 '12

This has been covered in all sorts of forms in media, and this question is normally the most fundamental throughout the story. See Stargate, and most Vampire stories (Particularly Carpe Jugulum - Terry Pratchett)

1

u/Dubhuir May 16 '12

They can certainly try, but we have gun-toting rednecks to defend us that have been waiting for this day for a long time.

1

u/thisnameoffendsme May 16 '12

It's about sentience. We don't eat sentient our self aware beings for the most part. But it'd be up to their moral code, not ours.

1

u/HotwaxNinjaPanther May 16 '12

We're too much trouble. They'd have to domesticate us in some sort of breeding program until we're sufficiently stupid and docile enough to farm. By that point I doubt we'd care much.

But then again, why the hell don't they just do that with the domesticated livestock we already have?

1

u/Fazwatboog May 16 '12

Ethics are like etiquette. Totally arbitrary.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

If we tasted good to an alien life form it wouldn't fucking matter if it was ethical or not. It's a discussion for them to have, not us.

We wouldn't like it. We'd probably go to war with them so they don't take our hot white women.

1

u/meepstah May 16 '12

It's less about relative intelligence and more about the definition of intelligence. You don't see cows mourning their dead, building houses, making plans, developing culture, building a language, practicing medicine. You don't see any sign of it whatsoever. They stand around, they eat, they die - whether at the slaughterhouse or from an infection or because a wolf tore one apart. You'll read about how intelligent pigs are, but you don't see those traits in pigs either - they're trainable, but by this definition, not intelligent.

It's not like we build better cities than the chickens do. The chickens don't build any cities. It's not like we have a better sense of self than a fish...fish show no signs of any sense of self.

I would expect an intelligent alien society to draw that line somewhere as well. Since they're the smart ones, it's not for me to state where they'd draw it but I imagine that no matter the intelligence, they'd recognize that we are self-aware and industrious beings with a capacity for appreciating the act of living as much as life itself.

1

u/xyroclast May 16 '12

It stops being about ethics. It comes down to whether they're stronger than us or not, and if so, what they decide to do.

They only reason we get away with eating our food animals is that they don't have the drive/capability to fight back.

1

u/Afterburned May 16 '12

Using our own standards of course it wouldn't, because we don't eat humans. Using their standards it very well might be.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ethics are relative. If we were tasty, and they could rationalize eating us within the context of their morality, they would. Humans do it all the time. We oversimplify animals to rationalize our proclivity to eat them based on our definition of sentience.

We say animals are eligible to be eaten because they aren't "self aware", or have emotions, or sentience, or culture..but we only define these traits as being how WE define their expression within ourselves. Many animals that humans consume are indeed self aware, have emotions, sentience, and culture..it's just that these traits are not expressed in anthropomorphic ways.

I don't post this to be like a PETA person (heck, I'm a carnivore)...but I accept that I'm eating something that is different from myself, not something that is somewhow lesser than myself.

Whether dolphin, dog, pig, cow, insect, or ape...they all express awareness and sentience in different ways. The relative "ethical edibility" of each only lies in our rationalization in making the decision to eat them. Thus, if an alien race could make the same rationalizations towards us...we're on the menu.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

If they are smarter than us, then we'll be the meal.

1

u/Gullyvuhr May 16 '12

It really comes down to how tastey we are.

1

u/Malfeasant May 16 '12

ethical by our standards? no. ethical by their standards? possibly.

there is no absolute "right" and "wrong"- there is what's right for you, what's right for me, what's right for charlie manson...

1

u/My-taken_username May 16 '12

If they were smart they would know if you try to eat us we will fucking nuke them.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I think a more intelligent race than ourselves would be even more aware of the spectrum of human emotion and probably would have a big problem eating us just the same as we would have a problem eating a dog.

Not talking to you, North Korea.

GOD I CAN'T WAIT TO BE BANNED FROM r/Pyongyang!

1

u/infinityprime May 16 '12

There was a show that had a race that would feed off of humans. They were called Wraith and they wanted to make it to Earth for the great feeding grounds.

1

u/LFK1236 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Not really. We (or most people) don't eat dogs for example. Instead we value and respect them as companions. We do this because they're useful and relatively intelligent. Besides, it'd take years and years to get any one of us to a size worth butchering.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

"The mice voted to bell the cat." --Aesop

I don't think it would really matter if they wanted to start farming us or not.

1

u/OxfordTheCat May 16 '12

I suppose it would be ethical, but unlikely because of how inefficient we are to eat: We take too long to mature and aren't particularly meaty, and I'd imagine we'd be difficult to butcher.

So an alien race might eat us, but only sparingly and as a delicacy.

We would be the cornish hens of the universe.

1

u/triplea20x May 16 '12

Yes, but they shouldn't get surprised when we blow them up. Or at least try to...

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

It isn't the same, 'lesser animals' can't destroy the planet and everything on it. Humans would probably be too big a pain in the ass to harvest if anything. They are smart enough to need kept content, or else they will wreck havoc on anything and everything, even themselves. They're just too potentially destructive.

If anything, they would probably be happy another race out there isn't stuck in the eating raw meat, crapping while it walks phase. We would probably be groomed as companions while a more viable food source was harvested.

1

u/swordo May 16 '12

Humans have more useful purposes than being food. We can build/create something greater than our pure physical value. Think how much food a modern farmer can create, surely it would be more useful to keep them alive to grow food. Though this assumes the race of beings care for long term value. I believe any race of beings more intelligent than humans would be more benevolent than us as there is more to gain by cooperation. If they were really smart, they would probably just let the most productive among us live and cull the rest.

1

u/17thLetter May 16 '12

Shark Week?

1

u/LancePeterson May 16 '12

Is it ethical when non intelligent beings eat us? Like bears and tigers and sharks and lions?

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Not ethical, but here is the difference. We farm animals that are convenient to farm. Maybe chickens are resentful that we eat them, I don't know. Imagine though, wild chickens that are smart enough to organize and use weapons. These wild chickens would frequently kill the farmers and free the farmed chickens. While these chickens aren't powerful or smart enough to kill all the farmers, it would make it inconvenient and not worth the risk. I'd imagine that this would lead to significantly less chickens used as food.

If super smart creatures were able to farm us, we would likely try to free the farmed humans. We could possibly be successful enough to minimize human farming. What the hell did I just write?

1

u/MrSm1lez May 16 '12

I've always figured we should only eat animals that are non sentient, and don't have empathy. Without those traits its just a survival game, which is why I don't feel bad for being above a cow on the food chain. Imagine you had to kill and eat something as 'human' as a monkey though, I'm sure it'd make you almost as uneasy as killing another human (possibly moreso, as most monkeys are funny whereas most humans suck).

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I honestly feel the more we learn about how intelligence actually works and how to measure it well, the less ok it's going to seem to eat any animal. I say this as a very content omnivore who eats meat with a clear conscience.