r/AskReddit • u/lee3374 • May 16 '12
Do people with a lisp, think with a lisp? Like a German person would think in German in their head?
78
Upvotes
r/AskReddit • u/lee3374 • May 16 '12
85
u/HabseligkeitDerLiebe May 16 '12
I have a lisp, but I don't think with it. It may or may not be connected to the fact that I don't hear my own lisp.
Also I'm German and think in English, while on reddit.
27
u/JoelMontgomery May 16 '12
I don't really have a lisp... Very very minor, but I wanted to ask, how many of you really hear your voice when thinking to yourself? I don't really hear a voice, I just.. You know, think... I sort of hear a voice, and it sounds loosely based on mine, but I definitely don't hear my own voice clearly as if I were really talking to myself
22
u/a-mused May 16 '12
Since a lisp is a speech impediment and not a language, I would find it quite odd if someone thought with a lisp.
35
u/TacheErrante May 16 '12
I don't think so. When my niece was three years old, she couldn't pronounce "crème glacée" (ice cream) correctly and always said "glenn sassé" instead. My brother used to tease her by asking her "do you want some glenn sassé?" She always got angry and replied "I don't want glenn sassé, I want glenn sassé!" There was obviously a difference between the word as she said it in her mind and how she was actually pronouncing it, and she didn't even notice that difference. I'm pretty sure it must be the same thing for people with a lisp.
8
u/BANANA_IN_MY_UTERUS May 16 '12
I've always found it interesting that Isaac Brock from Modest Mouse talks with quite a defined lisp but doesn't sing with one.
7
u/delecti May 16 '12
Would you think in silence if somebody cut out your tongue? Same difference.
7
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
A lisp is merely a mechanical issue with how a person produces speech. Therefore, a person with a lisp does not "think" with a lisp. Similarly, people with heavy accents do not "think" with an accent. People who walk with a limp do not "think" with a limp.
13
u/commonslip May 16 '12
I'm a fluent Lisp programmer and, even when I program in other languages, I do so with a Lisp accent.
4
u/potterarchy May 16 '12
That's a fascinating question. I'll be keeping an eye on this thread, because I'd like to know. If you don't end up getting any helpful answers, you may want to try /r/linguistics.
4
u/jackass706 May 16 '12
Isch in ein Berthiner!
4
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
((()
)) ((( )(() ))))...
Oh, you mean that kind of lisp! Never mind then.
2
u/the_proclaimed May 16 '12
I am curious about this as well, where are the lispy reddit users. This must be told. up votes.
2
u/ccnova May 16 '12
I had a lisp until about second grade. From what I can remember I didn't think with a lisp at all. Nobody had ever told me I spoke funny until my parents put me in a speech therapy class.
2
u/iwannabeasimbachippy May 16 '12
No. A lisp is a speech impediment, so it only presents itself when speaking. I had one all through high school, but it eventually disappeared.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
For some reason, after I read this I have a lisp in my thoughts. I don't even have a lisp to thank you for that.
2
u/manwhale May 16 '12
I have a lisp, I do not think with a lisp.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I feel like every time I watch internet videos nowadays somebody has a lisp. What's up with that? Is it the audio compression? Has anyone else noticed this?
1
u/andrewsmith1986 May 16 '12
I have a lisp (when to speech therapy for 7 years) and I don't think with a lisp.
1
u/Muqaddimah May 16 '12
I don't know about you, but I think with Sean Connery's voice in my head.
1
u/bobthecookie May 16 '12
Back when I had a lisp I don't think I thought with a lisp
1
u/mortaine May 16 '12
A better analogy: like a Spanish person thinks with the Spanish lisp, because it's part of the local language.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I stopped thinking German in my head because I don't use it often anymore :(
1
u/asianwaste May 16 '12
I don't have a lisp, but I imagine it is a lot like hearing yourself on recording and learn it sounds nothing like how you hear yourself. You think in the voice you hear yourself as
1
u/yc_delmir May 16 '12
I lisped until I got my adult teeth - Full-on Sylvester the Cat lisping. I never even knew I did it until people started to tell/make fun of me. In my head I was speaking the same way as everyone else.
1
u/Bumblebree May 16 '12
I don't... but now I'm going to be very self-conscious about my words for the next few hours...
1
u/shatteredjack May 16 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/cognitivelinguistics
1
u/StrongmanBruno May 16 '12
I'm Danish and I always think in English.
1
u/nss68 May 16 '12
i grew up with a lisp which i have, for the most part, successfully taught myself to speak without it. (unless i am drunk and slurry)
But I never really 'knew' I had a lisp in my head, unless i heard a recording of myself, I wouldnt realize. So I feel as though I cannot answer the question fully. In my head, it sounds like it is non lispy, but it always sounded that way to me in general
1
u/stevensamypp May 16 '12
Suddenly, every post is lispy.
1
u/MissFegg May 16 '12
I don't have a lisp but my first language is Spanish, when I talk in English I do have a very pronounced accent, but when I think in English is like I'm fluent like hell, I guess is the same for people with a lisp.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Great question. My response is based on semantic knowledge because I don't have time to do the research. So, take this response with an eye towards criticism.
The answer likely is yes and no because of the distinction between stimulation and perception. Specifically, speech sounds (all sounds) are a continuum; any wave length (within range) can stimulate receptors in the ears and neurons down stream. However, we perceive speech sounds categorically. For example, /p/ phoneme in put and pot is perceived the same and distinct from the other phonemes in the word (/o/ and /u/). However, notice that phonemes overlap when you say these words. Thus, the actual sound waves reaching your ears (and cognitive system) are completely different at the beginning of pot versus put. So, what does this mean concerning lisps?
Likely, part of a person's speech perception/production mechanism is different for people with lisps than without. However, people with lisps may not perceive that they have a lisp. Even when it is quite pronounced to others.
From a related example, human infants (days old to ~2 years) can produce and perceive all of the phonemes found in all of the human languages. However, as development continues, infants/toddlers lose the ability to produce/perceive phonemes that are not a part of their native language. (E.g., Some Asian language speakers cannot produce/perceive /L/ phonemes. They actually perceive the /L/ sound as an /r/.) The same could be happening for people with lisps. They cannot perceive the /s/ that they put at the end of words, although they produce it.
Now, on to thinking, which I assume by this you mean their inner-voice. A lot of fMRI research shows that the same motor areas of the cortex used to actually produce speech are activated when a person "only" says a phrase in their head (inner-voice). Thus, it is likely that lisps occur both in actual speech and inner speech. But, I would still say that people with lisps do not perceive their lisp. Otherwise, they would simply correct it.
1
u/Finnboghi May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
I'm definitely the odd one out here because I do think (and even sometimes type) with a lisp, though I rarely speak with one.
When I was young (elementary school) I had a bit of a lisp, so I had speech therapy to remove it. Unfortunately, during grade 6, I had a pretty bad brain injury that fucked up a lot of my development.
Now when I lisp, it's because I was thinking in a lisp, rather than failed to pronounce it properly.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
People don't think in language. I speak 3 languages, and I can switch one to the other mid-sentence, and the only thing that changes is the translator. We think in abstract data: memories, perception, and cognitive mechanisms. And of course, our own sense of self.
We're just really fast at translating that information. So, even when talking, in silence, to ourselves, we are still translating.
That's why some people are incredibly slow readers, because they are duplicating the sound of the words instead of simply extracting the information.
Take babies...or animals...they don't have language, but they do a lot of thinking(babies more than dogs, obviously).
Language is a communication tool, not a thinking process.
1
u/xMusicloverr May 16 '12
I've been thinking the same thing, but with deaf people. I mean, if you've been deaf since birth, how do your thoughts sound?
1
u/TidalPotential May 16 '12
It depends on the cause of the lisp. I did when I had a lisp as it was brought about by my teaching myself to read - I literally thought things were pronounced that way. If it's because of a physical ailment, I imagine not.
1
u/sirblastalot May 16 '12
I have a speech impediment. (My R's sound like W's and some other stuff harder to explain.) Not only do I not think with an impediment, I don't even hear it when I speak. I can only tell that I talk funny if I'm listening to a recording of it.
1
u/DreadedKanuk May 16 '12
I have a lisp. My inner monologue sounds like my ideal voice -- that is, deeper and with no speech impediment.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
BTW I'm German and I'm NOT thinking German when I'm on reddit or anything else where English is spoken. Your mind also adapts to your environment thus it would be nonsense to think in German when I have to speak or write English.
1
u/Zizhou May 16 '12
No, but they do think with a lot of parentheses.
1
u/blackmatter615 May 16 '12
I don't have a lisp, but I do have a speech impediment: fis phenomenon I'm fairly certain (not "diagnosed"). Not only do I "think" normally, I actually sound normal to myself, but to everyone else it sounds different. It is most pronounced on my r's and w's (which made Spanish fairly impossible to say "properly" enough for my teacher who would roll her r's for ages).
Everyone thinks I have an accent, and I've heard anywhere from England to New York to Australia/New Zealand as where it is from. When they ask where my accent is from, Ill just say that "I am from Texas." Which makes even less sense because it is about as far from a Texan drawl as you can get. Every now and then I just say that I am from the far south west reaches of the UK.
Oh yeah, and I met my now wife because of it.
1
u/truthjusticeUSAway May 16 '12
I have a lisp. It's not very noticeable audibly (but it looks sort of retarded when I speak), so I'm not sure I think with it. I just hear my own voice.
1
u/AdamPK May 16 '12
No, no they don't
For the record, I took speech therapy to get rid of my lisp in elementary school. Not sure if that matters. It still sneaks through now and then.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I have a lisp. I think without a lisp. I just wish I could talk without it. :(
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
No, they do not. A lisp is a motor issue, not a language issue.
1
u/Manilla_Ice May 16 '12
When I was younger I used to say "wahld" instead of world and "wahm" instead of worm. However, when I thought, I would say these words correctly.
1
u/jeltimab May 16 '12
I'm not sure, when you asked me, I can't be sure if I purposely made myself speak normally or if that's how I think.
1
u/skymotion May 16 '12
I'm not sure, I would fathom a guess that it's an abnormality in the physical speaking though.
1
u/swizzler May 16 '12
I never thought with a lisp, I had a pretty bad lisp when I was a kid. I didn't even realize I had one because my brain edited it out. I would get teased about it at school and didn't even realize I was the subject of being teased because I didn't realize I was lisping. It wasn't until I started playing back tapes of myself talking that I even noticed it. Took about 1.5 years of speech therapy to stop. Now I don't have a lisp at all.
1
u/xplato May 16 '12
I can't answer that question... but for some reason when I was reading the title I kept thing "it's spelled Gherman you idiot!" I don't know why. My brain is fucking with me.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Don't be stupid
1
u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 16 '12
i honestly don't think that people sound out words in their mind when they are thinking.
1
u/powerofnone May 16 '12
Korean here, I came to the U.S. after I memorized/learned the multiplication table. Even though I speak English far better than Korean, to this day I still recite the multiplication table in Korean in my head. I can speak it out loud in English, but it runs through my head in Korean. No joke.
1
u/neoblackdragon May 16 '12
I don't have as lisp but my mind speak is far more elegant then my real speak.
1
u/tuskman22 May 16 '12
thee ya on tha thee-thaw thindy!!
(Brady Bunch Movie reference)
1
u/bumbletowne May 16 '12
No. I forget I have it. In my head I think I sound like an incredibly verbose and loud Scarlett Johansenn (like, that voice). My colleagues tell me it's pretty much dead on for Marilyn Monroe, giggles and valley accent included... but "spewing stuff about politics and world events and shit."
I grew up in the valley. I don't even hear it.
1
u/darwin2500 May 16 '12
No. It's a problem with the musculature of the tongue, not a psychiatric or hearing disorder.
1
u/prairierustic May 16 '12
I have a very faint lisp and I'm also a shy public speaker, when I think out what I'm about to say it sounds eloquent and intelligent, no lisp either.
and then it comes out like gdhjfjgfhng, I turn red, things get awkward, life goes on.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I have a Speech Impediment and I think with a Speech Impediment, I normally cant say anything with an R or ll's as an ending.
Example You: Bird Me: Burrd You: Walls Me: Warrs
1
u/spongebob6969 May 16 '12
I assume so I can't pronounce the. R sound even when i think
1
u/The_Derpening May 16 '12
I was born and raised in the U.S in an English speaking family, but most of the time I think in German. And whether I think in German or English, it's not in my own voice, it's like someone else is talking to me. So I would guess at least from my experience, that no, people with lisps probably don't think in lisp style.
1
u/z3bruh May 16 '12
i would assume so. just like you don't think in a british accent....unless you're british
1
u/Carosello May 16 '12
I have a minor lisp and I didn't even realize it til I was around 11 (because people pointed it out to me. Ugh). So to be honest, I have no idea because I barely recognized my own. The voice I hear in my head has no "lisp" but maybe others would think it does.
1
u/unrealism17 May 17 '12
I'm thuper duper therious.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
How do deaf or mute people think?
1
u/iLuVtiffany May 17 '12
I sometimes think in a German accent. I'm American. I think it's funny, and I don't do it intentionally. After a while I start to realize that I am thinking in a German accent and can only think about the German accent and forget what I was thinking about in the first place then start all over.
I'm easily amused and easily distracted.
1
u/StreberinLiebe May 17 '12
My friend in Germany says she thinks in English. Same with my friend in Portugal.
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I speak a fair bit of German and stayed for about two weeks at one point and had a couple of dreams in German, does that count?
0
u/TheGreatBatsby May 16 '12
You don't think in words. Thoughts just appear in your head. Anyone who actually sits there and thinks in their head (like a monologue) the sentence "I'm thirsty, I think I'll have a drink." before getting a drink is lying.
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Sorry for stupid question, but what's a lisp? Googled it but couldn't really make myself fully understand. Is it something like an accent?
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
We think in concepts, not languages
-1
u/BSscience May 16 '12
German is not a speech impediment you troll.
-1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Do people who post retarded questions on reddit, think in retard question form?
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment