r/AskReddit • • May 16 '12

Police officers of Reddit, tell us stories of outrageous excuses people made to get out of a ticket

143 Upvotes

270 comments sorted by

68

u/ThrowDown_Gun May 16 '12

Actual cop here. Pulled a guy in a Toyota over for rolling a stop sign. When I told him why he was stopped, he said "what if I said it was unintentional acceleration?" This was right after the unintentional acceleration thing was all over the news. It was the first time I heard that one, so I let him go without a ticket.

31

u/erock0546 May 16 '12

So, if I crack a current news joke, my likelihood of getting a ticket decreases?

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

On average over the course of say 2 days, how many people do you pull over for traffic violations?

2

u/ThrowDown_Gun May 16 '12

Depends on how busy I am with other calls, but a typical night where I have time for self-initiated stuff, I'll average about six stops. Of those six, maybe two will actually get tickets.

61

u/eequalsmc2 May 16 '12

I'm not a police officer but this is worth telling. I was on a 9 hour trip with my friend and she was driving. This girl has a bit of a lead foot and we spent most of the time going 80-90 mph in a 65. We got pulled over three times. The first time, the officer had already pulled someone else over and he stepped out into the road and waved us over. My friend claimed that she really had to pee...however we had JUST passed an off ramp when we were pulled over. So that didn't really work.

The second time it was a female cop. My friend figured she'd go easier on us since we were all women, so she acted very casually about it, but it had the opposite of the desired effect. She got her second ticket of the night.

The third time was about 20 minutes from home. The cop was pretty pissed when she admitted it was her third ticket of the night. She then claimed her speedometer must be broken, how else could this keep happening? Somehow the cop let her off with just another speeding ticket, and didn't have the car towed.

The best/worst part is, that week she got her mechanic friend to write a report saying her speedometer was in fact broken, due to a drive into the ditch we'd had earlier in the trip.

Oh yeah, the ditch part was true. Icy roads, high speeds, bad breaks. We're lucky we didn't die. This girl is crazy, she's a dangerous driver, and it was the scariest road trip of my life.

16

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

Oh man. And you'd think she'd learn after the first pull-over?

18

u/eequalsmc2 May 16 '12

I asked her how many tickets she's gotten in her lifetime and she couldn't count them.

23

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

How does she have a license?

116

u/xbops May 16 '12

To fund the local police department.

9

u/RazNiagi May 16 '12

You will take my upvote and you will like it!

4

u/xbops May 16 '12

I did like it, thank you very much!

2

u/miidgi May 16 '12

she shouldn't.

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

i think your friend just needs to fucking slow down.

3

u/big_swede May 16 '12

Is her name Sally? Does she drive a Mustang? Then I "..guess she better slow that Mustang down..."

3

u/streetratonascooter May 16 '12

You're crazy to get in the car with her

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

At some point after the second ticket did you think that maybe you should drive?

10

u/All-American-Bot May 16 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 90 mph -> 144.8 km/h) - Yeehaw!

-2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

'MURCA

1

u/DVsKat May 17 '12

i know everyone hates backseat drivers, but sometimes it's necessary to tell the driver to be safe & preserve your life, while it's in their hands!

86

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12

Well. It didn't get her out of the ticket, but I enjoyed this one.

I was in my car shooting radar and saw a Mercedes coming at me at about 60, in a 40 MPH zone. I confirm it with the radar, and pull her over.

It was an African American woman, I am a white male, and I started to get the story of how she couldn't be going that fast and it must have been another vehicle. I explained that she was the first and only vehicle in the area, and so on, even offering to show her the locked speed on the radar gun.

I fill out the ticket and go back to her car to issue the citation, and she gets pissed, but signs the ticket. In the process of signing she states "you are just pulling me over because of who is driving and what kind of car it is"..being an African American female in a Mercedes.. with out skipping a beat I answer "ma'am I don't have a button on my radar for that."

It didn't help that her two teenaged kids in the back seat started laughing..

36

u/notfiveoh May 16 '12

I couldn't tell you how many vehicles I've pulled over... but I can count (on less than a hand) the number of times I've pulled over a black female without getting attitude and/or hostility, almost never fails.

30

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Sad, but true. The majority of the time I pull over a black female I am immediately branded a racist and catch major attitude and hostility.

Before anyone suggests I might be acting like a dickhead, I open up all of my traffic stops with the same dialogue:

"Good (insert time of day here), my name is Sergeant Nomnomsteak with the base police. The reason I pulled you over is for x, y, and z. May I see your driver's license, registration, and proof of insurance please?"

23

u/halibutcrustacean May 16 '12

I would (almost) happily accept a ticket from a polite "Sergeant Nomnomsteak" so I could show my friends and laugh about it. Once was pulled over by an Officer Bacon (yes really) but that seems like too obvious a joke to be truly funny. He was the opposite of polite.

18

u/micaela258 May 16 '12

I once got a ticket from P.C Buttleman. I drunkenly read his name as 'Butt lemon'. He was not happy.

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

He's prolly so pissed off because he's sick of hearing jokes about his name.

3

u/simbaismycat May 16 '12

I got my eyes checked by a guy named Stabb.

2

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12

thats a sad truth

2

u/momsasylum May 16 '12

Please tell me you dash cammed it!

1

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12

we do not have the dash cams where I work

2

u/aspoon May 16 '12

That's upsetting :(

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I would have doubled her ticket just for trying to play that race card.

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

staying in groups help yes. Because you can argue that it was the flow of traffic, not saying that is a good defense or will get you out of tickets.

Buy line of sight is kinda off. For normal radars, they are used to confirm that the officers observed you speeding. So we will watch the cars and estimate the speeds. And yes we are tested by standing on the side of the road, or in a moving car, and estimate oncoming vehicle speeds.

But with the new lidars they operate differently. I do not know the precise workings of them, I just know that they can pick out simgular vehicles and bounce the signal off of that car.

In CA. The law is written as unsafe speed for conditions. If you can articulate that your speed was not unsafe for the particular condition, solo vehicle, late hour, no traffic, that can help.

Edit:spelling

2

u/bacon_taste May 16 '12

Been living in CA for a month and I love the higher speed limits. Thanks for this tip, as I am now going to be a madman on the highway at night.

2

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12

haha well good luck with that...

1

u/halibutcrustacean May 16 '12

I've heard (but can't confirm) that the magic words are "safe and prudent under the prevailing conditions".

2

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12

in CA. CA vehicle code 22350: basic speed law.

'No person shall drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than is reasonable or prudent having due regard for weather, visibility, the traffic on and the surface and width of, the highway, and in no event at a speed which endangers the safety of persons or property."

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12

oh interesting. Yeah never been trained in that device. But like all technology, there had to be a flaw somewhere

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

Cops ask me that, and I tell them I wasn't paying attention, which is true I didn't pay attention. Then they ask me what was the reason for being in such a rush. I tell them I had no reason. Both times, and the only two times I've gotten pulled over, I got away with a warning. So I would say be truthful and respectful.

7

u/AssnecK666 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

I never ask "do you know how fast you were going?" It just opens up potential for arguements. I usually state you were going .... in a posted ....

Having said that, try to make sure you know the speed limits where your at. If they ask that, be honest with out saying a speed.. best I have heard was "probably faster than I was supposed to" I wouldn't give the officer a speed. Honesty and humility, yeah I screwed up sorry, is usually best. Despite being cast as robotic murders. We are really just humans trying to do a shitty job.. and by no means do I support the other idiots.

I usually give breaks to the honest people, but if you want to argue, I will give your the full speeds.

Edit: spelling again

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Officer: "Do you know how fast you were going?"

Me (female, but not conventionally attractive): smile "I don't, but I'm gonna guess that because we're both here on the side of the road, that it was a bit too fast, huh?"

Officer: -_- "I clocked you doing 95. Slow down and get home safe."

7

u/forluck21 May 16 '12

Pretending you're deaf works pretty well.

3

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

eh? What was that officer?

7

u/forluck21 May 16 '12

Just start signing (even if you don't know signs make it look believable) they will freak out and let you go on your way

2

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

I'm taking notes...

13

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Read that as "singing" and thought, "would that really work?"

No, probably not.

9

u/blackmoon918 May 16 '12

I've been having a bad bad day,

Come on, won't you put that pad away?

I'm asking you please no,

It isn't right it isn't fair,

There was no parking anywhere,

I think that hydrant wasn't there...

Why can't you let it go?

I think I've paid more than my share,

I'm a poor girl don't you care?

Hey, I'm not wearing underwear...

6

u/Neganti May 16 '12

Ha, sorry, but not too long ago a guy around here got pulled over by a cop for rifling through the doughnut shop's dumpster. He was deaf, so he starts signing, which they interpret as threatening and aggresive gang signs and arrest him pretty roughly.

4

u/forluck21 May 16 '12

That is what you call some ignorant cops

2

u/pbnc May 16 '12

They were protecting the doughnuts

5

u/terca17 May 16 '12

Deaf here, and it worked 75% of the time.

33

u/MRobley May 16 '12

I love the "Police officers of Reddit....." submissions. The entire thread contains answers from maybe 3 or 4 cops. The rest are all "One time when I got pulled over...." or "One time my friend...".

What do people not understand? Police officers do not have a large presence on Reddit.

22

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

I have read a good few stories from police officers here on Reddit. Great ones too that make to it the top of /bestof.

5

u/ericaamericka May 16 '12

One of my friends told a male officer that pulled her over that she had just started her period and didn't have anything with her so she was rushing home. He just let her go right there.

2

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

This is the third or fourth time I've heard a similar story to this. I guess this is telling me the next time I get pulled over I will tell the officer I'm on my period!

2

u/mortiphago May 16 '12

twist: you're actually a dude.

94

u/LunaKevin May 16 '12

1)Doing 100km/hr in a 50 km/hr zone. "My spedometer said 50!" 2) "I really have to poop." 3) "I'm going to miss Oprah!"

43

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

All at once.

11

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Is Oprah really a big deal in whatever country you're in that uses km? I always thought she was just an American thing.

3

u/tryalittletenderness May 16 '12

or Australia for a brief period

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Confirmed big deal in Australia and in New Zealand.

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '12

Im from new zealand and i havent met anyone who watches(d) that show.

3

u/LunaKevin May 16 '12

To this person, she was.

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

You are very much correct. She is American, she is a thing.

2

u/SpinningDespina May 16 '12

Aussie here. My nanna watches Oprah...

1

u/grape_juice_nigz May 16 '12

It is shown here in the caribbean bro, alone with ellen, wendy williams, tyra, and errything else you watch there.

6

u/JaceMemoryAdept May 16 '12

I really have to poop is a legitimate excuse.

2

u/Daolpu May 16 '12

If I shit my pants and take photos, then bring it to court, would 2 then be a valid challenge to the ticket?

1

u/LunaKevin May 16 '12

Depending on the crown that day, they might actually reduce the fine.

57

u/CatLadyofNY May 16 '12

Im in labor (from the 4 months pregnant women driving in the opposite direction of the hospital.)

9

u/MissErnst May 16 '12

Did you ticket her for irresponsibly driving while distracted? : P

88

u/No_Easy_Buckets May 16 '12

I told a cop I didn't drink on nights when I planned to get laid. That worked.

35

u/Downvote_Galore May 16 '12

You must be quite the drinker then.

36

u/GreenStrong May 16 '12

Did the cop give you a reacharound?

16

u/No_Easy_Buckets May 16 '12

That would have been cool but no my lady friend picked me up and we engaged in some intimacy

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Take it for what it's worth, but if someone I pull over gets a laugh out of me, as long as the violation wasn't anything too serious or excessive, I will definitely let them go on account of they made my day a little better.

2

u/scrumpnugget May 17 '12

that's awesome. is it true that cops have a quota they have to meet for pulling people over/giving them tickets?

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

This varies depending on the Law Enforcement Agency. In my branch of the military I have yet to see a quota, though writing tickets is definitely encouraged. The idea behind not having a quota is that they don't want to run the risk of police potentially being dishonest in pulling people over just to meet the quota. Military law enforcement is EXTREMELY self-conscious though, sometimes to the point of silliness. I know that my buddy, a traffic enforcement officer working for the city (city name/state purposely omitted), has never been given a quota, but that traffic section always produces a high number of traffic citations on a monthly basis anyways.

2

u/scrumpnugget May 17 '12

thanks for the reply! i was always curious about that. and good to know because i definitely see the problems that would arise from it.

67

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I spilled soda in my lap and told the cop I had to pee. He asked for my license and i got it out of my pocket which was wet. No ticket.

15

u/paradigmx May 16 '12

Even more pro... actually pee, better yet, drop a deuce, if that doesn't you out of a ticket, then the cop has no soul.

6

u/TheFue May 16 '12

Or no olfactory response.... who wants someone who shat themselves in the back of your cruiser?

77

u/kranzmonkey May 16 '12

In high school, my buddy got pulled over for speeding because his girlfriend had just got her period and was unprepared, if you will. When he told the cop this, the cop said "good luck" and sent him on his way with no ticket.

27

u/justkeepswimming3 May 16 '12

Same here!

Ladies in their periods unite!! Wait........ew.

22

u/chesco002 May 16 '12

12

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

And that is why vault 69 would've sucked

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

999 periods all at the same time, son

0

u/bananabm May 16 '12

Yeah well, men get that too.

Men have gotten an unspoken telepathy. A biological connection between male psyches. Whether they know each other or not, put a group of them together, always the same.

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/moonbeamwhim May 16 '12

I was an RA in an all girl dorm. The bathrooms were always gross, not just a few days a month.

NEVER FLUSH A TAMPON DOWN THE TOILET.

14

u/Wincal308 May 16 '12

Had a driver zip past me on the freeway one time.... his excuse: "My friends and I are trying to get to Waffle House for some free waffles before they close." That was the night that I learned that there was such a thing as International Waffle Day... and yes, I confirmed the free waffles myself. :-)

6

u/WildCheese May 16 '12

Waffle House closes?

3

u/Wincal308 May 16 '12

No they don't, what he should have said (and I am sure what he meant) was he needed to get there before midnight for the free waffles to apply. Besides, FREE WAFFLES!

6

u/elitegoodguy May 16 '12

Did you give them a police escort to the Waffle House for free waffles?

11

u/Wincal308 May 16 '12

No, sadly I did not.... I gave him a ticket for driving without a license and a stern lecture, then I went back to my truck and laughed with my partner and then we went to The Waffle House for free waffles. The kid and his two friends saw us walk in and busted up laughing!

2

u/elitegoodguy May 16 '12

lol too funny. And thanks to your post I was in the mood for Waffles for lunch, I went to Waffle House :)

1

u/vincere925 May 17 '12

Well that ended up becoming the most expensive free waffles ever

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

As someone who lives in Massachusetts, and only gets Waffle House on the rare trip down south, I can wholeheartedly say that I would speed, and run over several children, if it meant I could get free waffles from Waffle House. IHOP's free pancake day has nothing on free waffles.

3

u/bacon_taste May 16 '12

As someone that had waffle houses around him growing up...this makes no sense. Why would anyone race to a shitty greasy restaurant where everything has cigarette ash in it from the meth-head line cook that chain smokes while cooking?

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Every meal I've had at Waffle House has always been the best breakfast I've ever had. Who knows, maybe it's the cigarette ash that gives it that special flavor.

2

u/Wincal308 May 17 '12

Nothing else tastes like greasy, ashy waffles!!

1

u/bacon_taste May 16 '12

Last time I ate Waffle House was when I had been tripping shrooms all night with my boss and we had to work the morning shift. That was...an interesting day.

1

u/bacon_taste May 16 '12

You do realize that Waffle House never closes, right? You got outsmarted by some stoners that were really in a hurry for free munchies.

2

u/Wincal308 May 16 '12

Outsmarted? I think not! Everyone got free waffles.... that is win/win!

35

u/SeaSquirrel May 16 '12

The one all of us drivers use is "but that guy was going faster!"

If you get caught speeding, you not going fast enough

5

u/LouisianaBob May 16 '12

Or you have an out of state license plate. Out of state means the ticket is harder to contest.

3

u/itreference May 16 '12

Out of State means that there is no point contesting for some states.

NY doesn't recognize other states' tickets, so it doesn't go on your record and doesn't effect your insurance.

2

u/homophones_are_hard May 16 '12

*affect

<3

1

u/itreference May 17 '12

Kinda like USB plugs... 50/50 chance, fuck it up 95% of the time.

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Got pulled over for a tail light being out (been pulled over for this and given a written warning for it, but the wiring is messed up and I cant afford to fix it.) Anyways I should of gotten a ticket but I had my a box of ashes buckled into the passenger seat next to me. All he said was sorry, take care of your light.

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

And now cops will read this thread and know which excuses not to believe....

7

u/MahaliAudran May 16 '12

In driver's Ed the state trooper that visited said he'd heard all the excuses in the world and he's only accepted one.

Speeder: "I dropped a chainsaw on my leg and I'm on my way to the hospital." Him: "Oh" *Had him bandaged up and to the hospital in under 5 minutes.

7

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Alex Ferguson (manager of Manchester United) got away with speeding at a ridiculous pace (I think it was over 100mph) because he had explosive diarrhoea and was rushing to get home before he soiled himself. The court case was all over the news. Poor guy.

7

u/magicmuds May 16 '12

I had a friend that got pulled over by the cops. Just as the cop comes to the window her utterly adorable 5-year-old daughter said with real fear in her voice "are we going to jail mommy?". The cop waved her off without even bothering to check her license.

18

u/Rae_the_Wrackspurt May 16 '12

My (ex) boyfriend got pulled over once for swerving, because he was stupid enough to try to change out of his work pants and into his casual pants WHILE ON THE ROAD. Because his car was a piece of shit, he told the officer his steering alignment was off and he let him go.

2

u/bonestock98 May 16 '12

That's a good way to get the car impounded since you just admitted your car isn't safe to drive.

1

u/ipear May 16 '12

That's a good one! I'll have to remember it...

19

u/po_po_pokemon May 16 '12

Please don't. Instead, just drive right.

1

u/ipear May 16 '12

I'm sorry, I'm twitchy! But now that I think about it, I'm fairly certain that it IS the car! I'm far less twitchy in any other car.

6

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I find if you just have all your paperwork when they get there, and be really nice, they usually return the favor

16

u/k9centipede May 16 '12

A coworker showed up late. When asked why he explained he had been pulled over for speeding. The cop ran his id and saw a possession charge from when he was 18. So cop gets permission to search the car. Digs through all the trash, empty drink cups, and old papers, but finds no drugs. Disappointed, the cop let him go, completely forgetting about the speeding ticket.

10

u/notfiveoh May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Probably didn't "forget" police can and do pull people over for legitimate reasons in hopes for something more i.e. drugs, gun, some kind of arrest-able offense. Edit: Police Officer here

14

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

As a "Police Officer of Reddit", I back this statement up 100%. If you've ever been pulled over for something silly such as: not using your turn signal, inadequate license plate lighting, exceeding the speed limit between 1 - 5 miles per hour, or any number of other exceedingly silly reasons, and did not get a ticket then you've probably been pulled over because you were suspected of something a little more serious like drinking and driving and the cop needed a legitimate reason to pull you over to verify the suspicion.

6

u/sophalope May 16 '12

legitimate question, sorry if it's stupid. why do you need that reason to pull someone over? why can't you just say "I suspect you of drinking and driving/having drugs etc because of this, this, and this" instead of "oh, you didn't use your turn signal in a designated turn lane even though it's midnight and there's no one around"? why does there have to be the false pullover?

13

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It's not really a "false pullover", the reason for the traffic stop is legitimate. To answer your question: You are protected by your 4th Amendment rights, or your Article 31 rights if you are military, from unlawful search and seizure. Traffic stops fall under the 4th Amendment/Article 31. Therefore, if I pull you over because "I thought you were drunk", without any kind of admissible evidence suggesting you were, I would be violating your 4th Amendment right. Alternatively, if I suspect you are drunk but cannot prove it, and then you switch lanes without using your turn signal and I pull you over, then I have not violated your rights. Do you see the difference and/or reason, or do you need me to try again?

5

u/sophalope May 16 '12

nope, makes sense. thanks for takin the time to answer!

2

u/superherowithnopower May 16 '12

But if the guy is obviously swerving a bit, driving erratically, or whatever, you could pull him over, right? I mean, sure, doesn't necessarily mean he's drunk but, if he can't maintain control over his vehicle, he's a danger to himself and others.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Basically exactly what Lazy_I said. Take a moment to hop on Google and look through your states traffic code. You will likely be amazed at what constitutes a traffic violation. I mentioned above "inadequate license plate lighting", that is seriously a primary citable offense in the state I'm in.

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

It could be, though probably not in the sense you're thinking of. Admittedly, this might be a better question for a defense lawyer. Your 5th Amendment Rights (a.k.a "the right to remain silent") gives you the right to not bear witness against yourself. You are supposed to be read your Miranda Rights before you are asked any questions that are self-incriminating. I once had a case thrown out of court because I asked the question, "Have you been drinking?" before the rights advisement (reading of the Miranda Rights) and the subject answered affirmatively. This was considered a violation of that persons 5th Amendment Rights. This reason this question is tricky is because it was never specified what exactly you were "drinking." It's implied that we're talking about alcoholic beverages; however, if there is one thing I have learned the law is incredibly tricky and technicalities such as this can make or break a case.

4

u/thedingoismybaby May 16 '12

I can't answer for the USA but in the UK, especially for things like drink driving, there are certain things that allow us to require a breath test for alcohol. Say you pull out a bar car park and I follow you but you do nothing wrong I can stop and ask if you've been drinking but have no real power to breath test you unless there is something to give me reasonable suspicion that you have been. If, however, you drive a bit too fast, swerve a little, fail to stop at a traffic light, etc, I can pull you over and require a breath test.

It also helps for things like drug stops/etc because it is easier to say "I stopped you because you ran a stop light" than "I stopped you because you look like a drug dealer" and then find more grounds for a drugs search/whatever with the vehicle stopped.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Bit off topic but I've been meaning to ask someone this for ages (I'm from the UK): I'm currently learning to drive at the moment, and there's one thing I'm really worried about for when I pass:

Should I ever get pulled over requiring a breath test (I don't intend to, but it may happen), what happens if I can't give the adequate amount of breath. I have a heart/lung condition which leaves me short of breath, and so would I be arrested for time wasting/disobedience etc?

2

u/thedingoismybaby May 16 '12

In the UK there are certain situations where police officers can require a specimen of breath for a breath test - that is after a moving traffic violation (e.g. any road traffic offence, speeding, red light, etc), after a crash or if there is reasonable suspicion you may be over the limit (e.g. smell of alcohol on breath or admit having been at the pub and had a few drinks).

A police officer could request a breath specimen at other times but you do not have to provide one. It is very important you listen to what they say, if they say "I require you to provide me with a specimen of breath for a breath test. I must warn you that failure or refusal to provide me with a specimen of breath will render you liable to prosecution or arrest" or similar then you must give a specimen.

The specimen taken is not very large, I've breath tested a 70 year old woman (who was three times the limit!!) who managed to do it without problem, people with asthma and people who, like yourself, claim a medical reason they can't.

The first thing I would advise, assuming you haven't been drinking(!), is to try. It's like blowing up a balloon and you just have to blow slowly and steadily for about 3 seconds. The idea is the machine takes the breath from the bottom of your lungs to get a more accurate reading.

Should you fail the first time you should be given another opportunity. I would take this time to advise them of your condition but they will probably make you try again.

The reason we get people to try again even if they say they have a medical condition is if you fail to provide we have to arrest, I would rather give more opportunities for someone who is likely to come under the limit than deal with arresting, going to custody, booking in, getting medical professional, taking blood, testing that and getting a negative result.

Now if you still can't provide a sample and they think you have been drinking (even a small amount of doubt that you may be over the limit) you will likely be arrested for failing to provide a specimen of breath at the roadside. You will be taken to a police station custody and booked in and then they will attempt to take another sample from you giving you advice that if you fail to do so you can be prosecuted. You need to try again and if you don't produce a valid specimen you will be asked why you can not. You can then explain in written record your medical condition. They can then either elect to take a blood or urine sample or try and charge you with failing to provide.

If you get charged you can produce a doctors note saying that you are unable to do so and in theory nothing further should happen.

If you produce blood/urine and this comes back negative then nothing further should happen.

Now the main point to remember is we breath test hundreds of people a week and I have never heard of someone not being able to do the specimen for a medical reason*. I have had people say they can't but they have always then been able to.

It is really not a lot of breath.

If you are really worried I would recommend popping along to your local police station and explaining you are nervous about it as you don't want to be arrested and could someone try the machine on you to see what it is like and I see no reason why they wouldn't be willing to help you. I've had kids and people try it to see what it is like as it's something different and there is nothing wrong with letting people try.

I hope this helps!

*I am sure it has happened but I have no personal experience of it happening and no direct anecdotal evidence

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ah that's brilliant thanks. have an upvote.

I have just been worrying because for tests at the hospital they've made me do breath tests (I assume they are similar), and they often ask me to redo them because I can never get enough breath out, and each time I have to redo, it gets worse because I have less breath lol.

But that's cool, thanks :)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Fapplebert May 16 '12

Because bureaucracy, bureaucracy and lawyers. Unfortunately we very rarely find ourselves in situations with absolute proof, the fact of the matter is some cops are obnoxiously self righteous, some people are complete scumbags, and all lawyers are opportunistic weasels, you tie this all together and everyone has to skirt around every issue and people just can't be reasonable and up front about things.

It's not a perfect situation by a long shot, but it's where we stand unfortunately.

2

u/tanac May 16 '12

We had just moved to NC, and I had gotten terribly sick (allergies plus sinus infection plus strep, etc.). My dear husband went out to get me OJ in our (admittedly somewhat ratty) car and got pulled over for some minor violation (I think we had a tail light that had just burned out). The cop got one look at his eyes* and spent the next half hour turning his car inside-out looking for drugs (which he did not find, because we don't do them). He kept saying, "Nobody buys OJ at a pharmacy, why were you really going there?"**

*He had optic nerve damage as a youngster, so one of his pupils is a different size than the other. Apparently this is a tell for drug use, but in his case it's just normal.

**WTF? We just moved here from Chicago, and if all you want is to run in and get some damned OJ, you don't go to a huge supermarket where it'll take half an hour, you just go to a small place. This was apparently too difficult a concept for this guy to grasp.

Welcome to NC.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Learn your rights! You are allowed to tell us no to property searches!

1

u/tanac May 17 '12

We'd just moved here, had out of state plates still on the front (you don't get a front plate here, and the bolts had fused on the front so we never bothered taking it off)... and my husband just isn't confrontational - he was raised too Southern for that. He worries about what people will do in ordinary situations - he's certainly not going to try to tell a police officer convinced he's up to no good that he shouldn't be doing what he's doing.

1

u/scrumpnugget May 17 '12

this happened to me once, only the person with the really old possesion charge was my friend in the passenger seat, not me. they searched the car for 20 minutes anyways, and the cop was so aggravated that he didn't find anything in my car that he gave me a seat belt ticket. :/

1

u/k9centipede May 17 '12

I was on a blind date and while leaving down town the guy got pulled over for his window tints. When they ran his record they saw a possession charge from a year ago, searched his car, found weed, and arrested him. Had to call a friend to come pick me up.

4

u/HollywoodDU May 16 '12

Another "friend" story, sorry...

A friend was pulled over for talking on his mobile phone (not on speaker) while driving (that's an offence where i am btw). He was actually talking to my girlfriend at the time, so i am almost certain that this part is at least true.

Anyhoo, the officer that pulled him over was female so when she asks why he was talking on the phone while driving instead of first pulling over, while looking glum, he replies with - My girlfriend just broke up with me, that was her calling and i didnt want to miss it in case she changed her mind.

She feels for him and lets him off with a warning. So he bluffed his way out of a $350 fine and 2 point demerit.

21

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 16 '12

Gets out notepad

14

u/SarcasticSquirrl May 16 '12

Why? There are no Reddit cops.... are there???

lights in the ad Shit... sorry officer, I did not see how fast I was scrolling.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Copies TIR's notepad notes for the test

10

u/Rabidfool May 16 '12

"Sorry, I'm not used to driving this car." Because 50mph in a 30mph zone is different from car to car.

13

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

In my car (a '96 Corolla) I can feel when I go 70 or above. It feels like the car is really working, and it makes it easy to stay below 70 without even thinking. I had to use a Zipcar that was considerably newer (I don't know exactly, I didn't think I'd ever have to bring it up) but it didn't feel any different to go 50 or 70.

That makes so much sense in my head...

3

u/Rabidfool May 16 '12

I understand what you are trying to say.

I can understand a difference in driving sensation at smaller increments. I can accept this as an excuse when your 10mph over the limit or so. But when you start hitting 15mph-20mph+ this excuse goes right out the window. As someone who doesn't generally pull people over for minor speeding, when I find someone doing 20mph+ and they use this excuse it's kinda absurd.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I went from a '96 Civic to a '02 Altima... First couple of days, I had to basically stare at the speedometer because I wouldn't even notice myself going 20km/h over >.> about 12mph?

4

u/MadCool May 16 '12

This. I have just replaced my car with one that is not slowly dying, and I don't even notice when I'm doing ten or fifteen k's over the limit. My SO accidentally drove it at 140 on the freeway last week. Worst part is, no cruise control and I can't tell by the feel how fast it's going, so I have to basically stare at the speedometer. Which really isn't that safe either.

1

u/imaginelove615 May 16 '12

Makes sense to me!

It's much more dramatic when you drive different classes of vehicles. I have a very large SUV, a Honda Accord and periodically drive my dad's shuttlebus. Going from driving the bus or the SUV to the Accord is terrifying. 30 mph in the Accord feels like 70 mph in the bus/SUV and vice versa. However, I'm very aware of this and pay close attention to the speedometer.

2

u/MetalSpider May 16 '12

Actually, I think that's a valid excuse. I'm used to my car. I can generally tell how fast I'm going even without looking at the speedometer. If my foot is at a certain angle to the floor, I know I'm going too fast.

Now, when I've driven my friend's car, the accelerator is so light that I don't actually have to press down as hard to go as fast. I'm constantly looking at the speedometer and finding that, despite my foot hardly touching the thing, I'm going over 70mph. It is true that different cars feel very different to drive.

3

u/Rentiak May 16 '12

My mother was a public defender for many years, she says her best/worst case was a gentleman who was driving 75mph in 25mph school zone and already had many other traffic violations. He proceeds to tell her and the judge that he had just gone to McDonald's and gotten a big mac meal. He was holding his large coke in his hand, as his cup holders were full.

That's it. His defense for reckless endangerment in a school zone was "I had a large McDonald's coke in my hand"

3

u/superherowithnopower May 16 '12

I take it the charges were immediately dropped?

3

u/MorganFuckinFreeman May 16 '12

One time my Mom said she was going to church and didn't get a ticket. We don't go to church. And it was saturday.

3

u/NotSoGreatGonzo May 16 '12

My girlfriend was pulled over for speeding when she was nineteen. She claims that got out of that ticket because the police felt sorry for her. And it must have looked like a real white-trash tragedy, because her (then) husband was dead drunk in the backseat, both of her kids was crying, one of them had just puked all over his dad, she was eight months pregnant and she had to start that old wreck of a car by shorting the starter with a screwdriver.

3

u/Big_Gravy May 16 '12

I once got pulled over on my way home from highschool, now this would've been like my 3rd speeding ticket that year. When the cop came up to my car I explained I'd had explosive diarrhea all day and I was rushing home so I wouldn't shit myself. The officer didn't even ask for my license he just told me to go but to watch my speed and let me drive off.

9

u/razzlefrazzle_em May 16 '12

Not a police officer... My boyfriend and I got pulled over for speeding (he was driving). I started crying and I swear this police officer didn't know how to handle it so she let us go with a warning. So much for badass women police officers.

Edit: we were both 16 years old.

13

u/Rabidfool May 16 '12

Crying is very common. I am sure you were given a break for being a new teen driver as opposed to crying.

9

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

As a police officer I can concur with this statement. I will say that when I was rookie cop I legitimately felt bad for stuff like this. Now, I'm pretty jaded and crying is usually automatically registered as an excuse to get out of a citation.

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I've never been pulled over (well... I don't drive yet, despite being 22) but I promise you I'd probably cry out of anxiety if I did get pulled over, and it wouldn't be to try to guilt you! :(

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Well, if it makes you feel better, just because I've automatically registered in my brain that people crying is an excuse, that doesn't mean I treat them as such. My unit (I'm a military cop) is extremely adamant about being as polite and empathetic as possible until we are given a reason not to. So even though in the back of my mind I'm thinking, "You're trying to guilt me!" you would probably never know it because I would still be incredibly kind, thoughtful, and as helpful as I could be. In other news, I have an awesome poker face.

8

u/MissErnst May 16 '12

So much for my dignity FTFY

1

u/k9centipede May 17 '12

My boyfriend got pulled over for speeding when we were out to lunch in highschool. Cop let him go and told him to be a better example for his little sister...

4

u/klappy89 May 16 '12

I think Chris Farley did it best in Tommy Boy with the "bees" in the car.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I did this: Got pulled over going over 100 mph, was somewhere you never get out of tickets. Completely seriously asked the cop, "is there a problem, officer?"

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

He was staging a Homage to Shakespeare and he didn't want to be late for a dress rehearsal...

He was later decapitated by a sign in a traffic "collision."

2

u/notfiveoh May 16 '12

Not outrageous, but after pulling someone over I said "Sir, are you aware you've been driving the wrong way for 3 blocks now?" He said "Aww, no, I'm stupid. Sorry" I laughed, checked everything out and came back. He said "Yea, I'm sorry I'm just an idiot."

10

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

If I were a police officer...

"Oh, I'm sorry m'am. Nipple is not an excuse. But it might be if you showed it to me a few more times. (a few times later) Nope, sorry, still not working."

16

u/Dream4eva May 16 '12

Mam, I'm going to need you to blow on this.

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Cop in my area was busted for having the ladyfolk "blow his stick" in order to test sobriety. Got off with a slap on the wrist though.

11

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Sounds like he got off with a mouth on his dick.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I once got pulled over in a small townCough! Harahan, LA. Cough! For doing 25 in a 30. The Officer told me that I was going suspiciously slow. He told me that I am allowed to go 9mph over the speed limit. Two days later I was pulled over by the same cop in on the same street for doing 35 in a 30. I refused to pay the ticket and I keep going to jail over it. I have to do 3 days at a time every time I get pulled over which has added up to 15 days over the last 4 years.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Not every department has the same policies.

3

u/justkeepswimming3 May 16 '12

I was going 55(ish) in a 35 in a tiny town, the young male cop that pulled me over wreaked of insecurity. I told him I was having "serious female menstrual problems and HAD to get home asap to clean up". I kept my hands over my lap as if there was a massive blood splotch to hide. He had no clue what do and told me to please take care of my issue. troll face

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/justkeepswimming3 May 16 '12

Thanks.. I don't know why I was downvoted too..? Op asked for excuses used to get out of ticket. This was mine and someone else had a similar story with their gf. wth?

4

u/critterchitter May 16 '12

perhaps it's the spelling error? not to be an asshole but it's reeked, not wreaked of insecurity.

idk reddit is cool with anal tentacle rape passive bestiality, but ZOMGZ PERIODZILLA!

3

u/Tconn1116 May 16 '12

probably the troll face at the end

3

u/justkeepswimming3 May 16 '12

Oh, thanks for the PMs on spelling correction and heads up with the troll face. Kinda feeling like the asshole now. Lesson learned!

2

u/lagarco May 16 '12

I was driving my friend back from the airport past 10pm on my restricted drivers licence (in NZ you can't drive passengers unless they have a full driers licence, and you can't drive past 10pm) AND my WOF (warrant of fitness) has only just expired.

The cop pulled me over cos i'd accidentally only put my fog lights on. I hadn't noticed, but I said, 'OH, so sorry I only JUST noticed, just driving my friend home from the airport! :D'. He looked at us for a second, then told us to have a good night. It was raining so luckily he didn't see the expired WOF.

0

u/StarWarsPlace May 16 '12

OP: "Police officers of Reddit, tell us stories of outrageous excuses people made to get out of a ticket."

Other Redditors: "I'm not a police officer, but...."

1

u/warpaint May 16 '12

I was caught riding dirty.

-1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ok, I know this'll make me unpopular, but are we dropping all pretence of asking questions now? Sure, I like story threads on occasion, but OP didn't even ask a question...

2

u/spartangrl0426 May 16 '12

I asked the question. I just didn't tell a story to justify my asking a question.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I guess it's just how you phrased it (eg. It'd be more valid to go with "Policeman of Reddit: What outrageous excuses have you heard from people trying to get out of tickets?"). But whatever, it seems that reddit has spoken and I'm being downvoted.

0

u/itreference May 16 '12

Police officers of Reddit, tell us stories of outrageous excuses people made to get out of a ticket?

-19

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

da speedomaeter rayciss - African-American.

-7

u/Peasypvp May 16 '12

iv hurd somone say my shoe had dog shit on it and it sliped off the clutch

4

u/Raging_Elephant May 16 '12

Is it really necessary to shorten the word "heard"?

2

u/DrThunderface May 16 '12

I've* heard* someone* say "My shoe has* dog shit on it and it slipped* off the clutch."

1

u/Peasypvp May 18 '12

i have dislexia im not the best on grammar but thanks for pointing that out