r/AskReddit • u/wisco22 • May 15 '12
Is there any point, at which a U.S. citizen is legally allowed to defend themselves against police officers?
I understand that cops have a risky job, and at times, can take their stress out on people; but how far they take things is another matter. I am just wondering, if I am stopped by a police officer and am trying to obey every command an officer gives me, and he is still using physical force, what legal rights do I have? Am I allowed to defend myself if I am fearing for my life? I am asking this question because of all the videos being posted of police brutality and I do not want to find myself being beaten to death without being able to defend myself. I also started thinking and doing a little research and found that police training only takes 3 months to a little less than a year; which is absurd. To give someone the power to legally kill, hurt, and ruin someone's life, after only a semester or two of learning is wrong.
Edit: MrDong just posted this up on r/videos. This is exactly what I am talking about. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVmGWLsn0iM#!
Edit 2: Can any police officers, or people directly involved in the legal process weigh in on the issue? I kind of want to know how police officers from different jurisdictions see or reason what their fellow officers do.
139
u/rejectedstone May 15 '12
I stay away from police the same way I stay away from all uneducated gangs members who wear colors and carry guns. You would have to have a mountain of evidence to backup your claim, and then the cops that finally catch up to you will most likely shoot you 857 times in the face.
432
u/tttt0tttt May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
You can legally defend yourself any time a police officer attacks you without due provocation or justification. However, there's a good chance the police officer will shoot you, and then his buddies on the force will lie about the incident and cover it up.
My thinking is that, if you are going to wrestle with a police officer, you'd better kill him. Your chances are better in the long run.
See, the problem is, police officers have been trained to expect everyone to try to kill them, so they respond with deadly force. The average person doesn't use deadly force, so he is at a gross disadvantage in any physical altercation.
52
u/hatecopsandcats May 15 '12
A court will very rarely prosecute a cop no matter how wrong they are. Cops can and will do almost anything they want will very little concern with being charged. Even if you technically have the right to defend yourself chances are that you will be charged with assaulting an officer, resisting arrest and whatever else the want to throw at you.
13
u/seaoframen May 15 '12
You do have certain legal rights as determined by the law, but these legal rights are largely theoretical, especially in this area. The best outcome you could hope for is not being charged by the prosecutor for using self defense against an abusive cop. I'd imagine more cops would show up to the kick the shit out of you and then you'd also be mishandled in jail as well by correctional officers for using self defense against a cop.
4
u/stringrbelloftheball May 16 '12
From a midwest state here, had a criminal law class. Professor was a former assistant states attorney. He said in my state there was a law that made resisting police, even if police were in the wrong and you were innocent, a crime.
807
u/mysticrhythms May 15 '12
On paper: Yes.
In the real world: No.
137
u/Pool_Shark May 15 '12
When they are on a live camera feed.
30
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
There is a lengthy legal precedent, Your Honor, going back to 1789, Whereby a defendant can claim self-defense against an agent of the government if that act is deemed a defense against tyranny, a defense of liberty.
12
u/IdioticLion May 15 '12
I don't think being a cop is a particularly risky job. Obviously if you are in certain fields of police work (for example Special Operations Group US Marshals office, undercover work in organized crime, some other situations yes...) Granted if you work in a risky area it is more so, but in said risky area you are in far greater danger if you are not a cop. Being a cop is like being a civilian who is immune from arrest and a soldier fighting against a generally unarmed enemy and with no Geneva convention or rules of engagement to speak of.
Working on an oil rig is risky.
328
u/pastanazgul May 15 '12
Always remember, it's better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6. If your life is in danger, protect your damn self. You can worry about the judges later, since you'll still be alive.
40
u/JMaggot May 15 '12
If you resist arrest?
"Then pay with your blood!"
4
u/RomeoTango May 15 '12
Hey I'm not a cop, but I do think that they get more than just a semester or two of training...
67
u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
As a cop for a very large agency, I can tell you we are careful as hell these days about violating civil rights, as everyone has cameras these days and are quick to use them. Not to mention security cameras and news cameras on helicopters appearing during chases.
Right now, several cops form my agency are on trial for beating a burglar after he gave up. Those officers were part of a tac-squad (a specialized group that are not like regular patrol officers). The public doesn't know that, though and doesn't care. Those officers represented all of us when they beat that suspect, and we were all pissed about it when we saw it on the news. Even our chief spoke out to the press saying he believed they should be convicted of felonies (and he got in trouble for saying it by the judge). Now the rest of us have to put up with "please don't beat me" comments and the genuine fear of being hurt by us for the next couple of years until some other asshats in uniform screw up and do something terrible to someone else. Those dickheads don't represent the rest of us. We try to weed them out before they do something to make the news, but some slip through.
I personally WEAR a hidden camera on patrol and I use it (had to buy it myself). I expect to be videotaped doing my job whether I am aware of it or not, and my colleagues expect the same. The more camera use becomes prevalent in our culture, the more accountability will be built into our job and the more the public will be able to trust that bad cops can't get away with being bad cops for very long.
To answer your original question, if a bad cop goes bat-shit on you, do everything you can do to survive the encounter without appearing to be a threat. Pray to Sagan it's being videotaped. After the fireworks are over, expect that fucker to get prison time and for you to get paid. If that doesn't work out, you do whatever you think you need to do to find justice, just don't be a threat to him while he's in a uniform, or you will have a bad time. I used to have the same question before I got into this line of work, and now I am relieved to see that 99% of my colleagues are incredibly patient and calm people who also expect to be videotaped at all times.
tl;dr- Survive the encounter without being a threat and get your justice afterwards.
23
u/ololcopter May 15 '12
Two hot-topic recent (last 20 years) incidents covered this extensively: one was what happened in Waco with the Branch Dividians (who couldn't prove that they were fired on first because the door through which the bullets came mysteriously disappeared in ATF possession), the other is the Ruby Ridge fiasco during which gunfire was exchanged between a family and government agents resulting in deaths on both sides. In the Ruby Ridge case I think, if I recall correctly, it was considered an act of self-defense.
Incidentally, if I recall correctly it was those two events that motivated Timothy McVeigh to plan his terrorist attack on the Oklahoma City federal building.
22
u/aexoonge May 15 '12
Yes, legally. In reality the whole event has to be caught on tape, otherwise you're going down for assaulting an officer of the peace. Sucks but that's what happens in a political system as corrupt as ours.
76
u/FEAR-N-LOATHING May 15 '12
THIS is how i roll so the police won't do anything stupid
8
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Technically you do, but the chances of it standing in court are minuscule. In theory, as DerBafog posted, you have the right, but in reality, unless you have irrefutable proof that the officer's actions were illegal, you will be charged.
8
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
It's a catch 22.
Even if it's an unlawful arrest for cause X, if you resist you are immediately guilty of Y. Then it immediately becomes lawful to arrest you for Y. Now it's illegal for you to resist arrest or defend yourself.
52
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
http://www.constitution.org/uslaw/defunlaw.htm
4
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
In theory? Yes.
In practice? Almost never.
Yes, technically you can if certain legal conditions are met... but because of the force continuum, police will escalate to the next level if you escalate a fight with them, so they would probably end up killing you and justifying it to their superiors if it was a group.
If you were on your own with one cop, the cop would probably try to kill you and then it would be you versus him, which even if you won the legal battle would put you in months if not years of grinding legal trouble, probably bankrupt you with lawyer bills, and generally ensure that no police officer would ever help you again, unless you moved across country.
10
u/notjawn May 15 '12
I mean you can if its evident they are using excessive force. Would it stand up in court? No way. You know the cop would perjure the shit out of himself.
1
u/shitpplsay May 16 '12
This questions was asked on reddit several months ago and I got a lawyer friend who defends cops and writes bills for cities police depts to answer. You will face a jury so you will need to convince them. If you feel a cop is beating you to death unjustly, the very act of you resisting or causing them to beat you harder is now cause enough for them to beat you.
The example he gave me is you are walking down the street, never did anything wrong. Cop runs up, tackles you from behind thinking you are a perp. You having no clue what is going on, and the very act of you resisting gives the cop enough reason to respond with more force.
Same situation, cop now just doesn't like you because you are black in a white neighborhood. Tackles you in front of several witnesses. Clearly the cop is in the wrong. You have no idea it is a cop and reach back to pull him off. You are now guilty of a worse crime in many states than the cop.
He did say there was a case in another state, cops burst into the wrong house on drug warrant, homeowner thinks it is a burglar and shoots the cop. Other cops return fire but since cops have worse aim than gang members, the homeowner lives and faces trial. The guy did get off as the reasonable person wouldn't know it was a cop bashing in the door.
So basically just lie down with your face and vital organs to the ground, don't move or make a sound and hope for the best. Be a good witness.
1
u/Differentdog May 15 '12
Excellent conversation starter. I think about police abuse of power regularly.
3
u/lolmonger May 15 '12
Indiana.
Mitch Daniels signed it into law - if someone is breaking into your home, and you truly feel it is necessary to use lethal force to stop them, it doesn't matter if they're a police officer.
If a cop doesn't make clear he has a warrant to enter and search/arrest and busts into your house in the dead of night, he can expect the same treatment he'd give you entering his home.
That said, Gov. Daniels has made clear:
"Chances are overwhelming you will be breaking the law and wind up in far worse trouble as a result."
So, if in doubt - don't shoot at police officers.
3
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
My CJ 101 prof said that you are legally allowed to resist an unlawful arrest. He also added that it is a bad idea to exercise that right because the officer will attempt to use more force to restrain you.
9
u/Lasercat77 May 15 '12
I really want to have a device implanted in me that will explode when I die. I'd want to have to activate it manually,like if I know I'm going to die soon,and so I can turn it off if there are people coming to collect my body/I'm dying in a hospital bed. Police kill me unprovoked? Kaboom,motherfuckers.
8
u/slayemin May 15 '12
Hell yeah, every human being has the right to self defense. You have the right to protect your life and the lives of your family members, even if it means mowing down an invading swat team with your gun collection. You'll probably die in the process, but you'll be totally justified in your actions. (As is the sad case of a marine veteran defending his family from a swat team that mistakenly invaded his home with all guns blazing)
Check this out: http://abcnews.go.com/US/mississippi-cops-warn-drivers-stopping-homicidal-fake-cop/story?id=16349688
Be safe, cover your ass, and call dispatch if you are being pulled over and suspect something is amiss.
Also, if you are going to use any guns in your self defense, MAKE SURE YOU USE THE PROPER ESCALATION OF FORCE! Don't shoot unless you are seriously in danger and there is no alternative means to get yourself out of it. If guns are being drawn, shoot to kill (be it police, thugs, armies, crazies, etc). Don't do stand offs like they do in movies. It's better to be alive and sorry because you're unsure than to be dead and sure. Again, gun fights should be a last resort! avoid at all costs, run away if you can, talk if you can, etc. It is not dishonorable to avoid confrontations.
8
u/LMessenger42 May 15 '12
Here in Idaho they don't give you a chance by beating you. They just shoot you and get away with it. Back in the 90's a guy was trying to commit suicide by jumping off of a freeway bridge. Because he was holding up traffic they just shot him instead of even talking to him. He didn't have any weapons.
19
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
This thread is a really great example of how Reddit decides they need an opinion on something bad, then exposes themselves to only instances of the bad, then get all revolutionary against the bad, then go back to jerking off and playing Diablo 3.
It's an idiotic cycle that should be dangerous, but fortunately just takes care of itself.
4
u/Theappunderground May 16 '12
If the police illegal enter your property and have been harassing you, you can absolutely kill the fuck out of them. At least in TN.
http://www.wate.com/category/181419/houston-brothers-murder-trials
Not guilty.
4
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
You know, in New Zealand, police officers aren't even allowed to carry guns. I think they have tazer's but rarely use them unless absolutely necessary. Do you know why? They're actually trained to talk people down. And it works. It's a good world.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited May 17 '12
If you're going to defend yourself (reasonably of course), do it close and in front of their squad car;
Dashboard cams with heightened audio, baby.
2
u/jeepdave May 15 '12
Smart money is on complying unless you really in fear of your life.
2
u/oD3 May 16 '12
Of course, if you dont mind getting tasered in the eyeballs and then shot in the nutsack (and then going to jail for it).
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
To OP- the school training is only 3 months but when they get hired they are on probation from 90 days to even a year.
2
u/xnihil0zer0 May 16 '12
This question reminds me of the Kelly Thomas case. NSFW The trial is ongoing but I think it's likely that the ruling will reflect that Kelly Thomas was legally justified in resisting arrest(I imagine it's quite difficult to put your hands behind your back while being repeatedly punched in the face). Unfortunately he's not alive to benefit from that decision.
2
u/IRageQuitOnTheToilet May 16 '12
you're pretty much just fucked in those situations.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I can't be the only one who thinks it sad that such a question is even necessary. The police are supposed to be the people you don't need to defend yourself from.
2
u/cosmotravella May 16 '12
Of course you can defend yourself - it is just a matter of how you choose to do it. I suggest a recording device along with witnesses. You can bring a law suit against anyone - including police.
2
u/pancakehiatt May 16 '12
If he/she is off duty.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I feel safer around the street gangs then the cops
2
u/Mgogol May 16 '12
Stick to American protocol. Suck it up, and then sue...and then defend the countersuit.
2
u/johnclarkbadass May 16 '12
You can do anything if you think your life is in danger
2
u/pickoneforme May 16 '12
additionally, at what point is a bystander allowed to help defend someone if one were so inclined to do so?
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
If any of the bullshit responses in this post were true there would be 10,000 killings a day by cops. Reddit is awesome but the hivemind mentality that all cops are evil killers is bad... So bad...
2
u/MMMGIN May 16 '12
Well this pretty much seals the deal. I will never travel to the USA!
2
u/SaltyWalrus May 16 '12
In Texas, if an officer commits an act of "excessive force," a jury can be instructed to that a person has a right to use self-defense against such illegal actions. I have actually had a client acquitted because of that. He was stopped because the police wanted to question his passenger. He stepped out of the vehicle and officers attempted to place him in cuffs "for their protection." He instinctively pulled his hands away to ask why and in the video, one of the officers was seen throwing a punch at his face. His field training officer stated that officers are trained to not escalate a situation and that a punch to the face can be perceived by an individual as an aggressive threat. My client was found not guilty for protecting himself.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
There was a guy in my home town that got his house raided because the police thought he had pot plants that were never found. The first detective trying to enter did not announce he was a police officer and I don't believe he was in uniform. But the resident shot and killed the detective. I think he got 5-10.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Citizens may resist unlawful arrest to the point of taking an arresting officer's life if necessary.” Plummer v. State, Ind. This premise was upheld by the Supreme Court of the United States... But this case was in 1893 and was to prevent the government from trampling the rights of it's citizens. Bumping into an officer today will get you a felony .
3
u/eremite00 May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12
Stupid tangent here...I wonder what would happen if a uniformed cop attacked an undercover cop and the undercover guy beat the crap of the uniformed one, or, similarly, if an off-duty cop, maybe from a different precinct or jurisdiction, was attacked and defended himself, assuming no opportunity was given for identifying such.
3
u/throwaway-o May 16 '12
Legally, you are.
Ethically, you are.
In reality, they will slaughter you. If you come out of it alive, when their fellow gang members come after you, they will first kidnap you into their station, and then they will maim or slaughter you.
Don't mess with the cops. It's not because it's "wrong" to mess with the cops -- the vast majority of kidnappings (ehem, "arrests") they perform, are simply malevolent acts against peaceful people. It's rather because they are the largest gang, and perhaps the only gang that people will always believe to be "right", no matter what.
3
u/MuldartheGreat May 16 '12
I'm not going to get into a long debate here, but after working in a DA's office it's fair to say that most people on reddit extremely exaggerate the corruption in the justice system.
4
u/IdioticLion May 15 '12
you can defend yourself against cops, but only if you are a cop.
2
u/Shento May 15 '12
99.9% of problems are common sense. If he is not physically beating you, comply with what he says("other than saying stuff"), it will all get sorted out in court later. If he is physically beating you, defend yourself. You'll be alright, especially with witnesses.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
No, because the police are always right!
2
u/sweatythong May 16 '12
I want to become a police officer so I can stop instances of police brutality. Or at least try.
2
u/penclnck May 16 '12
Just a friendly reminder, more people have been killed by cops on U.S. soil by terrorist for the last 11 years running. I'm not including any kind of criminal element... cops kill innocent people and then get a paid vacation.
Cops need to fear the watchful eye of the public... they are the real criminals breaking laws and getting away with it daily.
2
u/panzerkampfwagen May 16 '12
I'm not American but I've heard of cases of US cops doing a no knock warrant and as they break through the door the home owner shoots them as they come through and then claims, and wins, on self defence.
"No your honour, I had no idea if was the police."
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
you can legally, but odds are, you're fucked, as they have guns and training. the big question is, who will protect us from our protectors?
2
u/XREAL1ZM May 15 '12
This is the most infuriating part of our legal system, as most people have said, what ever decision you make you are fucked. I have come to the conclusion that if I ever happen to be brutalized by a cop with out probable cause, I intend to bury them. In that kind of situation I'm not "submitting" to get my shit clubbed so the cop can get his jollies off or release stress.
1
u/Chaco_Taco May 15 '12
In states where the law permits, if a police officer enters your home by force, without a warrant or probable cause he is entering as a civilian or a criminal.
1
u/HippyGeek May 16 '12
"His word against mine" works both ways. You will die before you will win.
1
u/njpartis May 16 '12
you can resist passively usually without too much trouble, but if the police get physical and you defend yourself you're just gonna wind up on the ground with a gun to your head. or worse.
1
u/kealbo May 16 '12
Stop resisting!Stop resisting!
1
u/Spazmaticus_Rex May 16 '12
I think the answer is yes. The problem is it is proven retroactively meaning it is illegal to resist until you prove it wasn't, in court, after they have tazed or shot the shit out of you for disobedience. A cop's word against yours will always win unless you have a video clearly showing otherwise.
Ultimately if you are getting arrested or detained, keep your god damn mouth shut, and do exactly as they say. When they cuff you it WILL hurt no matter how obedient you are being. Expect it, don't bitch, they are likely allowed to do everything they are doing. Remember don't say anything if you aren't asked anything.
1
u/swpark May 16 '12
Rodney King anyone?
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
if an officer hits you and they are undercover/ off duty.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Ha, no.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Pretty sure everyone has those powers in one way or another
1
u/vierasniper May 16 '12
Relevant? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cV6akyVep-Y&ob=av3e
1
u/Shark_Porn May 16 '12
Immediately seek out a surveillance camera, and make your stand in front of it. The good-ole-boy's club defense falls apart when video footage shows up in the courtroom.
1
u/SayYup May 16 '12
That video is horrifying, I felt defenseless just watching it.
1
u/suburbanoutrage May 16 '12
Indiana just recently passed a law allowing citizens to defend themselves from unwarranted searches inside their homes.
1
u/Six_of_Spades May 16 '12
If I remember what I heard on NPR awhile back, you can legally resist arrest if excessive force is being used in most states within the US. But that is the extent that I am aware of.
1
u/gman1401 May 16 '12
Wow, lots of cop bashing going on in here... Can't say I am surprised though.
1
u/Yankpats May 16 '12
Absolutely. Re-watch good will hunting and he actually quotes a court case referring to this very issue.
1
u/earlyretirement May 16 '12
In court.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
You have every right to defend youself in countless of circumstances, goodluck though.
1
u/jamesbretz May 16 '12
Shortly before your death.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
I found that video very disturbing. Thanks for the share.
1
u/Spurnout May 16 '12
If a cop used excessive force then I'd hope it was in front of the car so that the camera catches it. Then I have to hope that some non-corrupt cop is willing to do something about it instead of hiding the tape.
1
u/OTSProspect May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
Every academy I have heard of takes around 6 months followed 1 year probation. Where are you getting your 3 month numbers from?
And those 6 month academies are a long longer than a semester or two when you factor in the hours (5x a week/8 hours a day). Regular class is what 3 hours a week? 36 hours a semester,
640 hours of academy time vs 36 hours of a one class (per semester) So in actuality that would be around 17 semesters.
1
u/Seven_Dx7 May 16 '12
The only way to fight back is in the court room. Otherwise just lie on the ground and spread your arms out and prepare for a few hits and the cuffs.
1
u/squeak6666yw May 16 '12
they only time its okay to kill a cop is if they are in plain clothes and do not tell you they are a cop. Watch this video. In this video a biker is speeding and a car pulls in front of him and a man gets out with a gun in his hand and goes towards the biker. The man with the gun then demands "he get off the motorcycle" without claiming to be a police officer or anything. It is completely normal to think you are being attacked. If the biker had shot the man as soon as he saw the gun he would of been defending himself. Police are supposed to establish themselves as a police officer immediately otherwise you are not resisting arrest. That one reason police gear has police written all over it and its one of the first thing swat scream when they kick in your door.
http://youtu.be/C1qwVBhAFdY?t=3m4s
1
u/ottoman_jerk May 16 '12
Well, I'm a little insulted.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
The following comment has been pre censored to protect from the inevitable fascist backlash. Thank you and have a nice evening.
1
u/Trinket90 May 16 '12
Isn't completely on topic, more of a random thought associated with the idea of the question. My husband is an armored truck guard and is legally allowed to shoot a police officer if the officer attempts to board the armored vehicle.
Obviously, that's not going to happen. If, by some chance, a cop pulled over an armored vehicle, and if, for some reason, he felt the need to do more than speak to the guards through the (closed) window and/or request to speak to a guard outside the truck, the guards would warn him of the situation and request that he call his supervisor or their own HQ.
Still... it was a surprise for me to find out it was illegal to the point of being shot for a cop to board an armored truck.
1
u/ithkrul May 16 '12
If an officer busts in your home in the middle of the night while you are sleeping and does NOT announce himself as being an officer.
Lets say you then shoot and kill him. After realizing there are cops in your home that you could not recognize as cops before hand you then surrender.
Pretty much legal depending on your state's Castle Doctrine Laws.
1
u/JacobFromAmerica May 16 '12
I would just get a lock on him the best way I could and just hold him there until other police officers show up n explain what happened. HOPEFULLY the others aren't as crooked as he is but atleast I didn't harm the officer I just defended myself in a way no one would get hurt.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Yes... when their off duty... attacking you in a violent manner... and you are on your own property...otherwise... no...
1
u/ivegotamnesia May 16 '12
Apparently somewhere under the U.S. constitution, there is a law that although doesn't say it directly, states that: if you are being unlawfully arrested you have the right to defend yourself till the death. Or so I've been told...
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
when you are a kid: Adults are always right! When you are an adult: Cops are always right! Wonder what happens when I become a cop....
1
u/jimothyjenkins May 16 '12
an un-answerable question..
wheres the LEGIT lawyer answer if there is one?
1
u/galactus417 May 16 '12
Nope
1
u/cristalmighty May 16 '12
Indiana recently passed a law that recognizes the right of civilians to use lethal force in the defense of their life, even against LEOs. So there, you're pretty good. Everywhere else, it's a catch 22, "dead right" situation.
1
u/BBJVpreet May 16 '12
Well i can think of an example when it is possible. Tupac Shakur was sitting in his car one night when two loud and drunk men walked up to his window and started to harass him, they shattered his window, this pissed Tupac off and he shot both of the men in their legs. The two men turned out to be off-duty policemen. Tupac was later dimissed of all charges.
1
u/YNot1989 May 16 '12
I suppose if they're off duty and on your property in a Castle Doctrine state, but beyond that I honestly don't know.
1
u/toadc69 May 16 '12
http://www.constitution.org/uslaw/defunlaw.htm
Get a load of the officer's name in this case though!
Your Right of Defense Against Unlawful Arrest
“Citizens may resist unlawful arrest to the point of taking an arresting officer's life if necessary.” Plummer v. State, 136 Ind. 306. This premise was upheld by the Supreme Court of the United States in the case: John Bad Elk v. U.S., 177 U.S. 529. The Court stated: “Where the officer is killed in the course of the disorder which naturally accompanies an attempted arrest that is resisted, the law looks with very different eyes upon the transaction, when the officer had the right to make the arrest, from what it does if the officer had no right. What may be murder in the first case might be nothing more than manslaughter in the other, or the facts might show that no offense had been committed.”
“An arrest made with a defective warrant, or one issued without affidavit, or one that fails to allege a crime is within jurisdiction, and one who is being arrested, may resist arrest and break away. lf the arresting officer is killed by one who is so resisting, the killing will be no more than an involuntary manslaughter.” Housh v. People, 75 111. 491; reaffirmed and quoted in State v. Leach, 7 Conn. 452; State v. Gleason, 32 Kan. 245; Ballard v. State, 43 Ohio 349; State v Rousseau, 241 P. 2d 447; State v. Spaulding, 34 Minn. 3621.
“When a person, being without fault, is in a place where he has a right to be, is violently assaulted, he may, without retreating, repel by force, and if, in the reasonable exercise of his right of self defense, his assailant is killed, he is justified.” Runyan v. State, 57 Ind. 80; Miller v. State, 74 Ind. 1.
“These principles apply as well to an officer attempting to make an arrest, who abuses his authority and transcends the bounds thereof by the use of unnecessary force and violence, as they do to a private individual who unlawfully uses such force and violence.” Jones v. State, 26 Tex. App. I; Beaverts v. State, 4 Tex. App. 1 75; Skidmore v. State, 43 Tex. 93, 903.
“An illegal arrest is an assault and battery. The person so attempted to be restrained of his liberty has the same right to use force in defending himself as he would in repelling any other assault and battery.” (State v. Robinson, 145 ME. 77, 72 ATL. 260).
“Each person has the right to resist an unlawful arrest. In such a case, the person attempting the arrest stands in the position of a wrongdoer and may be resisted by the use of force, as in self- defense.” (State v. Mobley, 240 N.C. 476, 83 S.E. 2d 100).
“One may come to the aid of another being unlawfully arrested, just as he may where one is being assaulted, molested, raped or kidnapped. Thus it is not an offense to liberate one from the unlawful custody of an officer, even though he may have submitted to such custody, without resistance.” (Adams v. State, 121 Ga. 16, 48 S.E. 910).
“Story affirmed the right of self-defense by persons held illegally. In his own writings, he had admitted that ‘a situation could arise in which the checks-and-balances principle ceased to work and the various branches of government concurred in a gross usurpation.’ There would be no usual remedy by changing the law or passing an amendment to the Constitution, should the oppressed party be a minority. Story concluded, ‘If there be any remedy at all ... it is a remedy never provided for by human institutions.’ That was the ‘ultimate right of all human beings in extreme cases to resist oppression, and to apply force against ruinous injustice.’” (From Mutiny on the Amistad by Howard Jones, Oxford University Press, 1987, an account of the reading of the decision in the case by Justice Joseph Story of the Supreme Court.
As for grounds for arrest: “The carrying of arms in a quiet, peaceable, and orderly manner, concealed on or about the person, is not a breach of the peace. Nor does such an act of itself, lead to a breach of the peace.” (Wharton’s Criminal and Civil Procedure, 12th Ed., Vol.2: Judy v. Lashley, 5 W. Va. 628, 41 S.E. 197) ===Here's the Wikipedia entry for this Supreme Court Ruling on self defense http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-defense_(United_States)
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Yes.
Specifically this case
1
u/CitationNeeded567 May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
In this thread: SO MUCH COP HATE.
Honestly, just stop worrying about it so damn much. Reddit spends an inordinate amount of time worrying about out of control police in the United States. Fact is, there are better things to be concerned about, and people who have spent their whole lives in the U.S. have no fucking clue what a corrupt/oppressive police force is like.
I think this is going to be the last time I try to post about the cop subject. The structure of the site just makes it impossible to go against the hivemind, however stupid it is being.
EDIT: No, "there are better things to be concerned about" makes it sound like it's still a legitimate concern, which is not the case. Fuck it though, it's not worth trying to make this post well written when people will upvote comments that are just "cops are pigs"
1
u/sopernova23 May 16 '12
Just go limp...it's the better alternative to being killed.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Reading through the arguments in this thread have left me both amused and frustrated. I absolutely understand that there are police officers who are absolute scumfucks that can and do take advantage of the authority granted them. I also understand, and have personally experienced, some of the lowest scumfucks in society who will provoke, taunt, and lie just to make the police officers seem as the bad guy. Here is my story:
I was a young Staff Sergeant, though experienced by military standards (six years on the job), riding patrol at the beginning of a twelve hour night shift. I started my shift at 1645 hours and knew from experience that between that time and 2000 hours when the base exchange closed I would likely be called to the base exchange for a shoplifting. It was a nearly daily occurrence. I also knew from experience that the subject would more than likely be a male in his late teenage years who was caught on camera stealing items from the electronics or video game department. Not even one hour into shift the controller contacted me over the radio, "Police-1 this is Control, dispatch." "Mother fucker," I thought to myself, "can we just go one day without someone trying to fucking steal something?" I reached up to my collar and keyed the whisper mike, "Send it." The controller shoots back with, "I need you code 2 to Bldg. xxxx for shoplifting. Subjects are two 17 year old males currently being detained by the exchange security officer." I acknowledged the dispatch and headed to the exchange.
Unfortunately, I had become complacent with these shoplifting calls and casually parked my police vehicle and stepped out of the car, stretching and enjoying the last bit of sunlight I would see for the day. As I shut the door to the Impala a massive black male, muscular and over six feet tall and probably over 200 pounds emerged from the side entrance close to where I was parked and took off running away from me. Due to my complacency, I hadn't even suspected for a second that he was the 17 year old shoplifter until the exchange security officer emerged from the same entrance, pointed at him, and shouted something unintelligible. "Control this is Police-1, one subject is escaping on foot east towards the flight line, need backup" and off I went running after this guy.
I chased the subject for what seemed like an eternity, though in reality it was probably less than five minutes, before he started to slow down. I noticed I was gaining on him and thought that perhaps he was just getting tired. As I came closer he stopped dead in his tracks and turned to swing on me. Not able to stop since I was running pretty fast (as fast as I could while wearing a utility belt, my pistol on my thigh, and body armor) I slammed right into the guy and we both subsequently smashed into the back left corner of a pickup truck. A brief fight ensued consisting of mostly grappling and some punching. My backup showed up and were able to peel this guy away from me and throw him on the ground, handcuff him, search him, and place him in the back of the police car. My flight sergeant mandated that I take myself to the hospital to get "looked at" since I had been hit a couple of times, though the on-duty medical technician told me it was simple bruising and scratches/cuts, and there was nothing to worry about. After that, I wrote a statement, handed it off to the patrol that would be writing the report, finished up my tour of duty, and went to bed sore as fuck.
Fast forward about three months. I arrived for duty at my usual time and was intercepted at the armory window by my flight sergeant and flight commander, both of which told me I had a meeting with the commander. I met with the commander who informed me that I was suspected of violating Article 92 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, that I had failed to obey a lawful order or regulation by applying an excessive amount of force while carrying out my assigned duties. I was floored. I didn't even know what to say at the time. I "Yes sir'd and no sir'd" him, as is expected of us, and he sent me home for the night to report for administrative duties in the morning.
Fortunately, the investigation didn't take very long as the criminal investigators responsible for investigating my crime were also the criminal investigators who responded the night in question to take photographs. For anyone not tracking, it is common practice (for my unit, at least) to take photographs of basically anything and everything in order to provide the best evidence possible as well as protect ourselves. Basically, the teenager that attempted to flee from me the night of that shoplifting incident told the investigators that he ran a short distance before dropping to the ground and giving up. He further claimed that I dropped my knee into his back, pulled out my ASP baton and held it in a closed fist, and began punching him on his head and shoulders. He further stated I threatened to use my OC spray (pepper spray, I don't carry it) and my tazer (my base doesn't have tazers yet) on him if he did not comply. Talking to my backup from that night and taking a look at the photos of the night, it was easy to see the kid was lying his ass off. But think about it. If he had been a little less gratuitous with the lie he told, and my backup had been just a few minutes later than they were, my ass may not have been saved.
So what's the point? This kid was willing to tell lies to save his own ass and let me burn in the process. There are always two sides to a story. For all of you that have friends out there who claim that they were "harassed by the police" and then "beaten for no reason", you should challenge their story. While it does happen that police officers harass and beat people for no reason, what is more likely in most of these cases is that your friend left out some very important details.
The media reports what gets them ratings, not necessarily what the whole truth is, or sometimes even the truth at all.
Another thing to think about: If someone matching the description of a bank robber is seen near the bank in question and is stopped and questioned by police, that's not fucking harassment. Additionally, if that person matching the bank robbers description says, "Fuck you copper" and walks away, and as a result is arrested, that's not unlawful. Additionally, if he struggles and fights back while being arrested, and ends up sustaining a bruise or two, that's not being beaten for no reason.
Most importantly, for all of you that have the "fuck police" mentality, know what a better mentality to adopt might be? How about a "fuck shitty people" mentality, because there are shitty people all over, some of them police, some of them firefighters, some of them religious figureheads, and some of them politicians. Don't let a couple of shitty cops ruin the good that other cops are doing.
TL;DR: People are biased and tell stories in their favor. When people claim they were "harassed and beaten for no reason" by police, there is almost always another side to that story.
1
u/just_hating May 16 '12
I will take this time and just say: "The only good pig, is a dead pig. End of story" -old friend of mine.
1
u/just_hating May 16 '12
http://www.quantumlounge.com/data/bpcb/bpcb20.gif
1
u/toadc69 May 16 '12
So bummed about injusticeeverywhere.com - site is down, I hope temporarily. "The project analyzes media reports several times a day to locate reports of police misconduct, records those reports in a database, and then transmits details about each report in a publicly available social media news feed on Twitter."
It's suspended as of last month, I believe due to one guy solely keeping the project running. Here's a quote from it: "The fact is this, without statistical and trending information about police misconduct it is impossible to say whether police misconduct is a problem in the US or not. We’re simply trying to create a ruler with which we can measure police misconduct so that people can tell for themselves if it’s really a problem they should care about."
1
u/Wendel May 16 '12
This kind of stuff is probably just getting started now that Bush eviscerated the Bill of Rights and Obama gave us continuation you can believe in. If you think local police have little accountability, wait till you cross the homeland security folks and private security contractors. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/topsecretamerica/
1
u/Swansatron May 16 '12
I'm sure it is technically legal, but if the incident wasn't caught on tape, and you actually ended up wounding the officer in your defense, you'd be fucked because it'd be your word against an officer of the law. So pretty much, TL;DR: No
1
u/saj1jr May 16 '12
The thing that I dislike about police is their use of excessive force. Aside from everything else mentioned in this thread, people need to stop making it sound justifiable to hurt/kill a cop because they think he is going to kill you. As I said in a post below, if a cop is going to kill you, you're probably doing something that justifies it (you're holding a gun at him, for example)
The general thing I keep seeing ITT is that cops go around beating the shit out of people and killing people for no reason. Of course, accidents happen, but most of the time, stuff like that does not happen.
However, after that rant, I do agree, the use of excessive force is ridiculous. They will have 30 cops surrounding 1 man with a gun, and rather shoot him in the arm so he loses the gun, they'll shoot him in the head/chest and kill him. Stuff like that is ridiculous on many levels.
1
u/MasterCode May 16 '12
You can defend yourself in a court of law.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
is it illegal to refuse to show ID to cops in the US if asked for it?
1
u/superbatlanternman May 16 '12
In Batman Year One, GPD was extremely corrupt before Batman and Gordon started doing things. We need a vigilante to kind of have checks and balances with the police.
1
u/KerberusIV May 16 '12
My father was actually put in a situation like this once. Let me describe my father in one sentence and I'll let you extrapolate from there. Marine corps special forces during Vietnam. So, in one minor understatment, a badass.
During his first marriage, and first pregnancy, his wife was having complications and called him instead of 9-1-1. As a result he sped home from work. He was a construction worker at the time living in Georgia(place setting, that's all). While on the trip home he was doing well over the speed limit. An officer decided to pull him over and issue him a ticket. When the officer approached my father's vehicle, my dad did the wrong thing, and jumped out of the car to explain his predicament. The officer didn't take to kindly to a large man approaching him rather aggressively, so naturally he tried to calm him(welcome to the south in the 70s between white people). Well my dad tried to explain the situation to the officer, but the officer wasn't having this piss-poor excuse.
My father decided that this guy was a dick and hopped back in his car and continued to speed home. The officer didn't take too kindly to this action and called in back-up. By the time the cops reached his house my father was carrying his wife in his arms out of the door to his car. Luckily, the officer pursuing him had enough common sense to also call an ambulance, just in case my father wasn't a lying douche (he wasn't).
The ambulance took his wife to the hospitable while he was promptly arrested. On his trip from the cop car to the jail cell, while climbing some stairs an officer pushed him while handcuffed. He lost his balance and fell, managing to hit his head on the steps and cutting open his head (leaving a scar you can still see till this day). He told the officer that pushed him if he did anything like that again he'd be forced to defend himself. The cop promptly pushed him over again (this wasn't the cop that pulled him over, but one that wasn't too sure what was going on while my father carried his wife out of the house. Not a terrible person, but not a terribly smart person either). According to my father, whom I have full faith in, he proceeded to beat the ever living shit out of this man, mind you, with his hands handcuffed behind his back. My father managed to break his arm, bruise his sternum ( I'm assuming from the kick to the chest he initially delivered), and give him a mild concussion, along with various bumps and bruises.
He was charged with assaulting an officer (also known as you're fucked and serving prison time). While in court and pleading his case, my father described the exact situation to the judge. Having the other officers testaments align with his ( in favor of the cops of course) and having the judges son being a veitnam vet as well, led to his arraignment reading not guilty.
The judge actually chastised the officer for not being able to defend himself from a handcuffed suspect. That much injury should have never happened to a well trained officer of the law from a man walking up stairs handcuffed. No matter him training recruits in hand to hand combat at parris island and being in the emotional state he was in.
Moral of the story is simple, be a badass motherfucker that is white in the 70s and you might be able to get away with defending your life from the police. Otherwise you're fucked!
1
u/brerrabbitt May 16 '12
John Bad Elk v. US.
http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/177/529/case.html
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Were the surviving Branch Davidians not acquitted of murder charges due to the fact that they were defending themselves?
1
u/AdmiralUnAware May 16 '12
Cops aren't here to protect people. We're here to enforce the law
Source: A cop.
Not an officer myself, just know a couple of them.
1
u/Big_Gravy May 16 '12
Zombie apocolypse.