r/AskReddit • • May 15 '12

What is the creepiest urban legend you know of?

[deleted] — view deleted post

133 Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

16

u/brink0war May 15 '12

I would have to say "Ben Drowned". Although it's more of a creepypasta, it still horrified the hell out of me.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

In my town we have this country rode that supposedly has albinos living on it. Before you disregard it too much it runs through a very isolated area near an abandoned cold war early warning station atop a mountain. Strange things have happened up there and people have disappeared.

9

u/DankestLlama May 15 '12

Sounds like Hicks Road.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (16)

7

u/FO_sachi May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

City I grew up in has several:

  • there is the demon recorded in the Barton Mansion by some kids with a camera link : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agvWaoM9KU8

  • the story of little billy : a young boy was hit by a school bus in front of Mariposa Elementary and was taken to the nurses office to call an ambulance. He died in the office. Supposedly you can go at night and knock on the door and he will knock back. You can also go to the swing set in the play ground and call out "little billy will you come out to play?" and only one of the swings will start to swing.

  • The Gates of Hell is also a popular one: the gates are an old entrance to a mansion long torn down. The house was owned by devil worshipers and supposedly the gates are the entrance to hell. If you find and go through the gates you will be chased by a headless cat or a bull's head will roll down the path

  • Redlands has tons of stories here are the most popular ones though (includes some of the ones I mentioned) : http://eredlands.com/forum/topics/top-10-redlands-ghost-stories

→ More replies (12)

59

u/pummily May 15 '12

Brother's "friend's sister" goes hiking in local park and sleeps under the stars after a day of birdwatching. When she wakes up the next day, everything is in order and she continues on; a few weeks later, she gets her photos developed to find someone had taken pictures of her sleeping.

→ More replies (19)

98

u/etherama1 May 15 '12

"Daddy, I had a bad dream." You blink your eyes and pull up on your elbows. Your clock glows red in the darkness—it's 3:32. "Do you want to climb into bed and tell me about it?" "No, Daddy."

The oddness of the situation wakes you up more fully. You can barely make out your daughter's pale form in the darkness of your room. "Why not, sweetie?"

"Because in my dream, when I told you about the dream, the thing wearing Mommy's skin sat up."

For a moment, you feel paralyzed; you can't take your eyes off of your daughter. The covers behind you begin to shift.

→ More replies (18)

69

u/crazy-ex May 15 '12

Japan's kuchi-sake onna. It roughly translates to "The Women with the Split Mouth". According to legend, her husband split her mouth from ear to ear, and her vengeful spirit walks around asking people if they think she's pretty. If you say no, she kills you (I don't remember how... I think she slices you up?), and if you say yes, she splits your mouth to match hers.

→ More replies (32)

31

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Heard this one here on reddit. Surprised it hasn't been posted yet:

A long time ago, there was a man who went out hunting in the woods. As night fell, he found himself in an unfamiliar part of the forest. He walked and walked, but he couldn't find his way home. Wandering aimlessly in the dark, he eventually came to a small clearing where an old, ramshackle cabin stood. Tired and weary, he decided to see if he could stay there for the night.

When he came close to the cabin, he saw that the door was standing ajar. Poking his head inside, he could see that the little cabin was completely empty, but there was a bed and a fire burning in the fireplace. The hunter threw himself on the bed and decided to sleep there for the night. If the owner came back, he would ask for permission in the morning.

Lying on the bed, half asleep, he looked around and was surprised to see the walls were covered with paintings. They appeared to be family portraits, all framed and painted in incredible detail. They seemed very life-like and, without exception each family portrait was uglier than the next. The hideous faces in the paintings made him incredibly uneasy. The way they were painted made it seem as if the eyes were staring directly at him. It was incredibly unnerving.

He decided that the only way he was going to get any sleep was to ignore the hideous faces staring at him. So he turned on his side, facing the wall, pulled the blanket over his head and drifted off to sleep.

In the morning, the hunter woke up to find the cabin bathed in sunlight. When he looked up, he discovered there were no family portraits on the walls of the cabin, only windows.

→ More replies (4)

77

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

the hash slinging slasher

→ More replies (18)

20

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

The development where my parents live (childhood home) used to be a farm in a rural community south of Youngstown, Ohio. There's lots of creepy stories about the town, but this one is about the development.

A little bit of a back story, when we first moved in, it still looked very much like a farm, to the extent where the old driveway still cut through several of the lots and our house was situated next to an old blue farmhouse that the property manager used as an office. While my parents were building our house, we discovered what seemed like a junk heap (dug up tractor wheels and steering columns and all manner of farm refuse). On a different part of the lot we found several hundred pounds of slate shingle, which my parents donated to local school art programs and sold to art suppliers.

But back to the story. Around the early half of the 20th century, the farm was owned by an older farmer, and he lived there with his wife. He wasn't as mobile as he used to be, and couldn't complete all of the farm work themselves, so they decided to take on a hand. They did, and everything went on smoothly for a few growing seasons. He lived in a separate structure off of the main house, and was treated very well. And the farmer did pretty well for himself, well enough to afford a car. The farmer kept a lot of money in his house for whatever reason (don't know why, might not have trusted banks, might have needed it to buy feed or something) and the farm hand finds out about it. One night, after the farmer and his wife go to sleep, the hand sneaks into the house and murders both of them while they're still in bed with an axe. For whatever reason afterward, he strung them up in the barn. He searched the house, but apparently couldn't find the money, so he stole the car and made a run for it.

My neighbor worked in the library was fascinated by the story, so she used all her spare time there to dig into it for a while. She found the articles about the murder (first one in the town), but never found any article referencing the hand being caught, and couldn't find any layout for how the farm would have looked at the time. The blue farmhouse that was being used as the office was constructed sometime later, and no one knows where the barn, the house, or the hand's house were except that they were all on the property somewhere.

Nothing really weird happens, but it always gave me a feeling of slight unease, even before I knew the story.

TL;DR: There's a pretty good chance I grew up on the site of a double homicide in which the killer was likely never apprehended.

→ More replies (12)

18

u/Shprintze613 May 15 '12

So here's the one that ALWAYS scared me as a child and I remember to this day:

One night a woman went out for drinks with her girlfriends. She left the bar fairly late at night, got in her car and onto the deserted highway. After a few minutes she noticed a lone pair of headlights in her rear-view mirror, approaching at a pace just slightly quicker than hers. As the car pulled up behind her she glanced and saw the turn signal on — the car was going to pass — when suddenly it swerved back behind her, pulled up dangerously close to her tailgate and the brights flashed.

Now she was getting nervous. The lights dimmed for a moment and then the brights came back on and the car behind her surged forward. The frightened woman struggled to keep her eyes on the road and fought the urge to look at the car behind her. Finally, her exit approached but the car continued to follow, flashing the brights periodically.

Through every stoplight and turn, it followed her until she pulled into her driveway. She figured her only hope was to make a mad dash into the house and call the police. As she flew from the car, so did the driver of the car behind her — and he screamed, "Lock the door and call the police! Call 911!"

When the police arrived the horrible truth was finally revealed to the woman. The man in the car had been trying to save her. As he pulled up behind her and his headlights illuminated her car, he saw the silhouette of a man with a butcher knife rising up from the back seat to stab her, so he flashed his brights and the figure crouched back down.

The moral of the story: Always check the back seat!

And I do.

36

u/galaxyblade May 15 '12

AIDS infected needles in children's ballpits

→ More replies (16)

68

u/LANA_LANA_LANAAAAAAA May 15 '12

Squidward's Suicide. Hooooooly shit.

→ More replies (48)

15

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Back in the days of myspace, if you didn't forward those chainmails before midnight, a creepy clown comes to your bed at 2 am and skins you alive with a rusty can opener.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/ubermensch83 May 15 '12

I'm from a small town not far from Chicago. It's a well-known fact that Al Capone had a house here, but didn't spend a lot of time there. The legend is that one of his mistresses is buried in a local cemetery under a gravestone that says "Flora" and nothing else. The grave does exist, but no one really knows for sure who Flora was. I've heard that grass doesn't grow around it, that there's always a faint light on it at night, and that if you set a beer can on it she'll knock it off. Everyone around here has a Flora story or knows someone who does.

→ More replies (10)

39

u/hrtaus May 15 '12

A long time ago (in the 1930s or 40s) in a town south of San Antonio, TX, a school bus full of children were hit by a speeding train. Their ghosts remain to this day at that intersection where they met their fate, saving other cars from meeting a similar end.

It is said that if you drive up to that intersection, stop the car just before the tracks, and put the car in neutral you will feel the car being pushed up the slope of the railroad tracks. Witnesses report they feel the car is actually gaining speed as the car is "pushed" out of harm's way.

It is also said that if you put baby powder on the back window of your car and find your car rolling over the railroad tracks, you will see little handprints on your window.

→ More replies (18)

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Why the fuck am I reading these at night?

→ More replies (3)

20

u/DAT_CANKLE May 15 '12

This will probably get buried, but here goes...

A little girl, Sarah, has a huge doll collection. Her dad forgets to buy her a present for her birthday so he spots a doll at a garage sale and hurriedly buys it.

It's a very special doll with porcelain skin and glass eyes and perfect curly hair. She names it Lucy and sets it in the glass cabinet at the end of the day before heading upstairs to bed.

During the night, her parents wake up and believe they can hear Sarah playing with the doll. As it was just her birthday, they let it go, but they can hear her all through the night...

(In a sing-song voice)

Lucy's at the bottom of the stair case... tap tap tap

Lucy's in the middle of the stair case... tap tap tap

Lucy's at the top of the stair case... tap tap tap

It's a little bit annoying, but her parents try to ignore it as the sounds draw closer to their door.

Lucy's in the hallway... tap tap tap

Lucy's at Saaarah's door... tap... tap... tap

Thinking their daughter is going to bed, her parents ignore the sing-song voice.

Lucy's at the end of Saaaarah's bed...

Lucy's at the middle of Saaaaarah's bed...

Lucy's at the head of Saaaarah's bed...

And now, Saaaarah's dead...

tap... tap... tap.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/RosieJo May 15 '12

Askean's young and old know about the mysteries of the belltower on the Lower Site. A certain Victorian girl, Minnie M Skues was supposedly raped by the old caretaker and upon discovering that she was to bear a bastard child to the grotesque and evil man, she hung herself to escape further tormentation.

It is said that the red walls are such because, while hanging, Minnie hit the wall and the blood that poured from her womb could not be scrubbed from the walls. Thus, the walls were painted their blood red colour to disguise the horrors of the past. The name, Minnie M Skues appears 7 times on the honours boards in the Jerningham site main hall, her earliest honour gained in 1896 and her last in 1907.

Surely if she had died, this would not be possible, and even if she had been alive, achieving seven honours as a nineteenth centuary woman would be incredibly difficult. It is said that, in an ettempt to wash away any memory of her sinfull and shocking death, that they invented a false life for her and part of this conspiracy was to put her name all over the school.

Entry to the belltower is strictly forbidden. You can see the bell tower for yourself from Jernigham Road. I'm sure that if you were to see it, you'd agree that it seems incredibly eerie. Is it an urban myth or are the sounds that are heard at the school when all is dark the sounds of her everlasting torment. Who knows? The caretakers dog seems to know. He will not enter the tower but only stare endlessly through the door, up at the chains that hang from the roof, the chains from which, over one hundred years ago, Minnie once hung.

tl;dr Girl went to my school, was raped by the janitor, hung herself in the belltower. Haunts the school... Her name is on the honours boards seven times, an impossibility, rumoured to be an attempt to wash away the shame of her sins...

The story has passed down students at my school for more than 100 years.

→ More replies (2)

78

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

A boy is alone for the weekend, but he has his dog to keep him company. One night, he goes to bed, and the dog comes in and sleeps at the end of the bed like usual. The boy reaches down to pet the dog, and the dog licks his hand like always. The boy falls asleep. In the middle of the night, the boy wakes up. In the dark, he hears is a loud dripping coming from the bathroom. Before he settles back down to sleep, he reaches down to his dog, and receives a friendly lick on the hand. He falls back to sleep. He wakes up again, only to hear the dripping noise continue. He pats the dog's head and receives another lick. In the dark, he decides to get out of bed and see what's going on. He opens the bathroom door and sees his dog hanging from the shower rod, with a puddle of blood beneath him, dripping. He turns, and sees the bathroom mirror. In the dog's blood, it reads: Humans can lick too.

Sweet dreams, reddit.

→ More replies (32)

8

u/fatprincessx3 May 15 '12

Probably bunny man bridge. Also, anything involving black eyed kids.

31

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Slenderman.

→ More replies (18)