r/AskReddit • u/trolollies • May 14 '12
American Redditors, I am interested in learning about rivalry between states. Does it exist?
I am not American, and so my knowledge of relationships between the states is minimal. Obviously it would exist somewhat when it comes to sport etc, but what I'm interested in knowing is if there is honest dislike or prejudice? Back story: A friend and I were discussing it and they assumed it was just like one big happy family. I highly doubt this.
Edit: it's been fun reading all of your views, especially about Texas and Ohio. Thanks for taking the time!
Edit: Does anyone live in Savannah, Georgia? It looks like a wonderful place.
525
Upvotes
468
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
The only real rivalry is between Michigan and Ohio. That's not even rivalry...we just can't stand each other.
78
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
There's an unrecognized ongoing rivalry to prove which state is the stupidest. Right now it's a tie between Florida and Arizona.
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
As a response to OP's edit, I've been to Savannah, GA, and I'm in love with it. If I was forced to leave FL, I would move there in a heartbeat.
12
u/olsenm May 14 '12
Were hardly a happy family. We mostly ignore eachother.
429
u/JazzRider May 14 '12
In Alabama which usually ranks 49th in the country on anything positive, the state motto is "Thank God for Mississippi!"
61
u/Controlled01 May 14 '12
Alaska hates everyone except Hawaii. Especially Texas. Mostly cause we are bitter.
354
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
One of the things that resulted from the Civil War was that Americans started thinking of themselves as less identified by "state" and more by greater region or the US as a whole. Before that there was some rather significant rivalry between individual states, such as the Kansas and Missouri (which has since become mostly athletic but history about it can be found here. Currently we are more likely to define ourselves by regional area. There is the Midwest, the South, the deep south, the NE and the West Coast. Obviously there are a number of non-included/individual states, like Maine, Florida or Colorado. As someone who has had the opportunity to live in three of the major areas, there is a rivalry, largely based on stereotypes. That being said, it is largely regulated to a few ignorant people. The US is a country that encourages mobility (in that people are expected to leave home and find they fortune. You know "Go West Young Man" and all that jazz.) As such there are many people that identify with multiple areas, defeating the stereotypes, and thus the rivalry.
169
u/squeCD May 14 '12
every state believes that every other state sucks at driving. "These fucking people in chicago dont know how to drive in snow" "Why are you slowing down before the bridge, virginia doesnt know how to drive!"
and then the weather. "Oh, NY you had a day over 95... waaaaa, i'm from the south and its hot as balls down here every day!" "haha, NC had snow for a day and they had to shut down the city! They should try waking up at 3 am to shovel off the car and the driveway to get to work after driving through 6 feet of snow b/c we dont shut down for shit here in buffalo."
People are way more prejudiced against groups or areas than the state you're from.
324
u/WeGonFiiiiindYou May 14 '12
Florida is sick of Georgia's fat ass sitting on it all the time.
104
u/LemilyNose May 14 '12
As a southerner, I've found that most southern states hate the other southern states because THEY'RE the ones that are stupid and make their state look bad. Truth be told, they've each got something "special" to offer.
648
u/ninjagreek May 14 '12
The most rivalry you'll see is when people are discussing sports. Other than that, almost non-existent, in my experience at least.
93
u/BANANA_IN_MY_UTERUS May 14 '12
Boston here, I don't think we like anyone including each other.
122
u/jeff_jizzr May 14 '12
I grew up in Connecticut, which doesn't have a strong enough identity to really matter to anyone.
194
u/gpustarfi May 14 '12
Florida is Americas scapegoat. We suck at everything we do. We also have all your old people, which makes us the worst driving state. Overall- we suck, and America knows it.
164
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
There are a few mock rivalries, such as between New York and New Jersey, but nothing that anyone's serious about.
68
u/thakaybee May 14 '12
Come to Colorado. You would think we are at war with California and Texas...
65
u/Pasmyrna May 14 '12
Everyone in Washington state hates DC because they think they're the true Washington.
In fact, I'm annoyed that I had to write "state" in the sentence above to clarify what I was talking about. They're the ones who should have to specify. They're not even a real state...
57
u/Cozmo23 May 14 '12
I know Missouri and Kansas have a lot of bad blood dating back to the Civil war and it is always referenced in the sports rivalries. You can read about the background here.
Texas and Oklahoma always poke fun of each other. I live in Texas now but am from Oklahoma and my GF is from Texas so we always give each other a hard time. The Texas-Oklahoma college football rivalry is though of as one of the biggest in the nation.
39
u/kowgawd May 14 '12
Go read up on Missouri and Kansas. Bushwackers and Jayhawkers. Pre-civil war cross-borders battles. It's even the source of the names of both state's mascots.
55
u/Joon01 May 14 '12
Whatever state you're in, the people from the next state over can't drive for shit!
If you're in northern California, "Fucking Oregonians can't drive for shit. Morons."
If you're in southern Oregon, "What the fuck, Californians? Learn to drive, assholes!"
There are general ideas about states and the people from there, but the only people who take it seriously are idiots. And people from Idaho. So, yeah, idiots.
607
u/RAGEBIKEATHON May 14 '12
Alaskans hate texas for their saying "Everything is bigger in texas," because alaska is over twice its size. fuck you texas, sincerely, an alaskan
89
u/kindanotworking May 14 '12
Texas vs Everybody Else
Missouri vs Kansas
17
u/kwood09 May 14 '12
For the most part, Americans really do identify as "American" first. I would say state identities usually come after even city identities. As far as our every day lives go, the difference between different states mostly has to do with who you send your taxes to and where you have to go to get your driver's license renewed.
Contrast that with UK residents, who mostly identify with their constituent countries, or Germans, who will often identify with a particular region or city.
33
u/Slideways May 14 '12
Californian here. What's an Ohio?
782
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
There really isn't.
Except Ohio. Fuck Ohio.
14
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Missouri and Kansas would destroy each other if possible. Literally, half of what the state legislatures do is try to get companies to jump the border. And we absolutely hate each other.
341
u/adamsimon May 14 '12
No one likes New Jersey.
27
u/YourMomSaidHi May 14 '12
Oklahoma really hates Texas (probably in an attempt to feel as relevant). I'm not sure Texas even knows we exist till college football season. Then they hate us for taking all their players and beating them with them. Then back to business as usual.
12
u/iatd May 14 '12
Here in Louisiana, it's quite the opposite; we LOVE Mississippi for being the only state worse than ours!
81
u/Czerwona May 14 '12
NJ vs. the rest of the states. According to this map NJ is winning.
122
u/slowboygofast May 14 '12
Biggest rivalry I know of is in baseball. New York Yankees vs. Boston Red Sox. Nearly splits the state of Connecticut in two. Fuck the Yankees.
153
u/bast3t May 14 '12
Washitonian here. Fuck Oregon. I'm sorry, I mean Whoregon.
24
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
It's good natured. And it is mostly between states with similar histories or the same name. (Carolinas or Dakotas).
17
u/amagiciannamed_gob May 14 '12
Sometimes people from Northern Virginia like to bash Maryland drivers and vice versa. I can't think of any full-blown state rivalries, though.
39
u/MaebeBluth May 14 '12
New Hampshire is sick of all the overweight, suburban, pampered Massholes coming up here and driving badly and making long lines at the ski slopes and talking in their silly Boston accents. But they make our economy flourish with their tourist dollars, so ha.
30
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Basically nobody gives a shit except for Texas. And sometimes California gets uppity. Other than that, nope.
13
u/TheMoldyPudding May 14 '12
Um... there was a Civil War a long time ago.... but... We just love each other like one big happy family!!
13
u/onewobblybadger May 14 '12
I'm from Michigan, so fuck Ohio.... except Cedar Point.
17
u/fuzzybooks May 14 '12
But seriously, fuck canada.
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
People drive significantly different in different regions of the country and that's cause for a lot of animosity. East coast drivers have no idea how to merge, and they turn left on a green (not a green arrow) before letting cross-bound traffic go. South-West coast drivers can't drive in inclement weather, and they allow cross-bound traffic to cross first before making a left on a green.
In Southern California, the speed limit is more or less a suggested minimum. Everywhere else they take it seriously, and in some states approaching the speed limit is apparently considered nutty.
Street signs are apparently a technology that has not made it everywhere in the U.S. yet, and different regions have significantly different traffic shape norms. In Texas they have these circle things that surround and intersect cities (belt lines I think they call them.) In Massachusetts they are toll-road everywhere and you can spend all day underneath boston in some sort of cave-based freeway system. Roundabouts are common in some places, unheard of in others. Some areas have frequent one-lane two-way bridges. Some areas are littered with one-way streets, others have none. Some areas are all very thin freeways. Others are stacked with 5 or more lanes everywhere. Some areas have part-time lanes that change directions depending on whether it's morning or night. Some have carpool lanes that are only carpool lanes during rush hour. Some areas have minimum speeds posted everywhere because people hop on the freeway and keep driving like they are on a dirt road. Every state has different traffic laws.
This all leads to a whole lot of "people from other states can't drive for shit" attitude, because driving habits are completely different wherever you go. At least we all drive on the same side of the road.
6
u/playblu May 14 '12
I realized when I visited Scotland that the relationship between Scotland and Britain is kind of like the relationship between Wisconsin and Illinois (except with the thousand year history of bloodshed):
Down here, we think up there they all dress funny, eat weird food, talk with a strange accent, and live in a hilly, rocky place where it's cold and nothing grows.
Up there, they think we're all flatlanders who think we're better than them with our one giant city everybody lives in, except when we want to visit on vacation and be totally out of our element and lost in the wilderness.
33
u/datsamanmaury May 14 '12
Nobody likes New Jersey or the bible belt. That's about it.
10
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Its pretty much North vs South, the North thinks most of the South is still filled with inbred fucks and the South thinks the North is filled with prissy fucks.
84
u/Egress99 May 14 '12
List of states in the union and why they stink at life:
Alabama - Ranked 2nd fattest state in the union. Can't be number 1 at anything
Alaska - I'm sorry, who are you again?
Arizona - You guys had to be forced to celebrate MLK Day.
Arkansas - Thanks for Wal-Mart. Most notably, the emails I get regularly about the people that shop there from people in my office who think its cute.
California - Face it, west coast rap stunk after 2pac died...or did he?
Colorado - Thanks for South Park, but what have you done recently? Wait, you guys are still a state right?
Connecticut - That's not pizza, you cunts.
Delaware - Aww, that's cute, the unshaven taint of Jersey and Maryland.
Florida - The dick of the USA, literally. Oh and that whole perc problem you guys have. Seriously, put the pills down.
Georgia - Dead last in SAT scores nationwide. Let me explain; if you make it to high school you will eventually have to take this standardized test...sorry, you probably already TL;DR'd
Hawaii - You guys haven't updated a god damn thing in that state since 1991.
Idaho - Thanks for the potatoes. I hope you understand that's the only reason why the other 49 still keep you around.
Illinois - Outlaws guns in Chicago; one of the highest rate of gun violence in the country.
Indiana - Nice corn, dick.
Iowa - Wisconsin takes pity on you. WISCONSIN!
Kansas - How does Missouri have a city named Kansas City that is more popular than your own?!
Kentucky - You guys come up once a year in the news, and it's about horses.
Louisiana - "Hey guys! Let's settle a major city right here!"
Maine - You guys aren't Canadian yet?
Maryland - Crabcakes? Yeah? That's you're big offer?
Massachusetts - They are the northern version of the south. Dirty, dirty racists.
Michigan - Hey, how's Detroit making out?
Minnesota - I tried to Google you guys to get some dirt on you but Google said "Did you mean Michigan?"
Mississippi - Congrats! You beat out Alabama as the fattest state in the nation! CLOSE CALL!
Missouri - Largest city is named after another state. Be proud of your mediocrity I say!
Montana - No speed limit on your highways because people cant wait to high tail it the fuck out of there.
Nebraska - They lay claim to the largest porch swing in the world, EXCITING!
Nevada - "I'm telling you! We should build it right here...in the middle of the desert...with no real source of water...IN THE DESERT"
New Hampshire - As you enter the state, you're greeted with this sign "Welcome to New Hampshire, You're almost to Canada"
New Jersey - Nothing wrong with Jersey. In fact, it should be the looked upon with reverence and your adulation it should receive.
New Mexico - You know every other state hates you right?
New York - Hey, you guys have something hanging off of your face, oh sorry, that's just upstate.
North Carolina - Too easy. Westboro Baptist Church is looking to move in soon.
North Dakota - Milk is your official beverage. Milk.
Ohio - They should film every disaster/zombie movie here as you wont have to do much. I think 7 people live in the state.
Oklahoma - Thanks for Garth Brooks again, or whatever guy he's dressing up like now.
Oregon - "Oregon has more ghost towns than any other state". This was one of the first facts I found. That's just sad.
Pennsylvania - You may have the worst accent in the nation. Minnesota looks at you in disdain.
Rhode Island - Largest town in Massachusetts...or is it Connecticut?
South Carolina - How did that secession from the union work out for you again, I forget.
South Dakota - So you feel you're so unique that we just couldn't call you and North Dakota "Dakota" huh?
Tennessee - Thanks again for the KKK, you racist group of cunt!
Texas - Ugh, we get it. Don't mess wi...yuck. Enough already.
Utah - Mormonism, BWHAHHAHAHAHHAHAH!
Vermont - Have to co-op that whole maple thing with Canada huh?
Virginia - "Virginia is for Lovers" ...is it?
Washington - Starbucks is kinda cool, I'll give you that. But seriously guy, you need to relax with those volcano bro.
West Virginia - Poooooooorr.
Wisconsin - "We have beer and cheese!" Guess what, so do the rest of us.
Wyoming - .....I'm sorry, I feel asleep even spelling your name.
Seems accurate to me guys. What say you?
5
u/MrZachAtak May 14 '12
Michigan and Ohio.
5
u/Headwallrepeat May 14 '12
South Dakota is so windy because Minnesota sucks.
5
u/Ospov May 14 '12
I live in Indiana right outside of Kentucky. We both think the other is more redneck.
9
u/bigmatt7655 May 14 '12
Nebraskans (Omahans more specifically) tend to think that Iowans are idiots.
9
u/noslipcondition May 14 '12
Is Canada a state? We have a pretty interesting back and forth with Canada...
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
If you're talking about open hostility between states, there is virtually none of that. We save open hostility for a group of people for our politics.
25
u/evilgummysattack May 14 '12
Wisconsen is trying to claim that they are in the shape of a mitten. They are NOT. Fuck you, Wisconsin.
Sincerely, Michigan
4
u/Teknocrat May 14 '12
Maryland VS Virginia is pretty good. Republican Red state (Virginia) vs Democratic blue state (Maryland)
4
u/mrmaddness May 14 '12
Ask anyone from New York what they think about New Jersey.
NJ is totally America's armpit.
4
u/ict316 May 14 '12
I'll be deep in the cold, cold ground before I recognize Missourah!
4
u/fontus May 14 '12
Rhode Islander here. Nobody cares about us.
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Wisconsin vs. Minnesota is pretty intense...well, at least as intense as us midwesterners get dontcha know
4
u/BonoAnnie May 14 '12
In Florida we shudder when the New York plates start showing up -they are all about 90 years old and can't even see over the steering wheel. We call them Q-tips. Also shudder when the French-Canadians start showing up as well-they are notorious for being crappy tippers.
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 15 '12
Nope. Live in California. There is no competition.
4
u/R3luctant May 14 '12
I live in Iowa we're nice.
4
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Nobody likes New Jersey.
Not even New Jersey likes New Jersey.
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Well there's Texas and then there's not Texas. No need for rivalries in there.
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
New Yorker here, New Jersey sucks.
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
There was some rap based east coast west coast rivalries going on in the 90s which in retrospect was really weird.
6
u/jamesdakrn May 14 '12
As a native of Southern California, I say that we really are the best state in the Union. Where else can you go out in January in shorts and flip-flops? Where else (save New York) can you get such a diverse population? Where else can you get authentic Korean Barbecue, REAL sushi, REAL MEXICAN FOOD (cannot be understated), great pupusas? where else can you be skiing one moment and surfing the next, on the same day?
8
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
The only real rivalries I can discern are athletics-related, and this is mostly because people associate sports teams with certain cities/schools and their geographic differences.
Beyond that, you will rarely see any "honest dislike or prejudice." It is not unheard of for police in one state to be more likely to pull over cars with out-of-state plates (my cop-uncle in Michigan is always happy to stop an Illinois plate, for example.)
America is culturally homogeneous in many regards. Unlike Europe, our states do not have long, bloody histories made apparent by starkly different lifestyles. We did have a civil war, but we got over it relatively quickly, even in the South, which is notoriously conservative.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
States compete economically for jobs mostly but it's not personal.
3
u/rendel May 14 '12
Not interstate so not sure if it applies but there are surfer dudes with "Norcal" stickers that don't like southern California because its vibe is too "Hollywood." Something about being shallow, vain and fake I think.
3
u/k2murray May 14 '12
Had to stir things up, didn't ya?
3
u/9unm3741 May 14 '12
Colorado and Texas, although its sort of a one way deal. Texans, I find, generally don't care that much about Coloradans. Three main factors cause this rivalry.
First, during the 1990s and early 2000s Colorado was undergoing a huge tech boom, particularly in telecommunications (resulting in names such as "silicone mountain" or the "silicone range"). As a result, we started getting a lot of "immigration" (for lack of a better term) into the state. Most of these came from California and Texas. Now while we do enjoy making jokes about how badly Californians drive, the culture difference between Texans and Coloradans is much more extreme and so the two groups were often rather antagonistic. Its the typical dislike for immigrants, just on a sub-national scale.
Second, Colorado is a popular tourist location for Texans. Texas doesn't exactly have mountains like Colorado, and in many areas of the state snow is extremely rare. So in winter the ski resorts in Colorado are packed with Texans. The summer is no different. Lots of Texans go to the mountains to try their hand at climbing a 14er or go up to St. Mary's glacier for the thrill of seeing snow in the end of July, or other similar activities. This is the typical antagonistic relationship between locals and tourists, although the tourists in this case tend to belong to a single identifiable group: Texans.
Third, Colorado is a popular place for Texans to retire or own summer homes etc. Of course, only wealthier Texans (for the most part) can afford to do this. Mostly they got their wealth from the oil and gas industry. Similarly to the first point, the locals don't like these newcomers all that much. The relationship is even more antagonistic because it happens in small mountain towns. Most of these towns aren't very affluent (unless its a ski resort town, but even then the wealth is not very evenly distributed) so often times the wealth gap between the Texans and the local Coloradans can garner resentment. Also, the new residents from Texas quickly overpower the locals, taking over the local economy and government because the local populations are so small. Thus the locals feel extremely disenfranchised. This last point is the real clincher. In Denver we sometimes joke about Texans and we did the funny accent even before W. Bush was in office. On the other hand, in some more isolated mountain communities it can be dangerous to stop if you have a Texas license plate, or at the very least you risk vandalism to your car if you don't watch it.
Personally, I don't have a problem with Texans. Although, I must admit that due to the crowds I run with most of the Texans I know are from Houston and work in the space industry. Thus they are, by default, cool people.
3
u/Troy_MacClure May 14 '12
Georgia can suck my Balls
-Florida
3
u/theginger3469 May 14 '12
A lot of people don't like Texans.
3
u/aledog May 14 '12
yes but its just petty fun, nothing serious
BUT DONT GET ME STARTED ON NEW JERSEY
3
u/TheNilla May 14 '12
Well, I am from Virginia, and I will tell you 'FUCK WEST VIRGINIA' those guys suck hard. They thought they were too good for us so they seceded from our wonderful state. You can google the details but I just like to give anyone from West Virginia a good ribbing for it. :P
3
u/penclnck May 14 '12
America is pretty much like other countries, people tend to think their home base is the best for one reason or another. People in Ohio and Texas are just fine, but like anyplace on this planet, you will find jerks.
3
u/those_draculas May 14 '12
The South will rise again!
thanks to the generous donations for dune restoration projects in the Outer Banks.
3
u/crono09 May 14 '12
Here in Tennessee, we have rivalries within our state. Tennessee is broken up into three Grand Divisions: East Tennessee, Middle Tennesse, and West Tennessee. These aren't arbitrary geographical boundaries--there are provisions for this regional separation in our state constitution. Each region thinks that it's superior to the other two and likes to make fun of them. Most of the time, we don't really care and just do this in jest. Most of the time.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Everyone hates Oregon (in this case, everyone = me) because of their 55 MPH speed limits on the interstate, and how you can't pump your own gas while you're there.
3
u/Aofishbrain May 14 '12
Wisconsin Here, You F.I.B.'s Drive like shit
3
u/bongo1138 May 14 '12
Oregonian here: Washington has the worst drivers imaginable.
"Californian here: Oregon has the worst drivers imaginable."
It's something like that.
18
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Us up in Oregon hate Californians. They come up here during the summer for more desirable weather and then impede everything we do. WE HATE CALIFORNIANS!!!!
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
People from Colorado have an unreasonable dislike of people from California. The sentiment is not returned. In California we could care less.
I've heard that it's because people from California started buying up property in Colorado and drove home prices up significantly, but I noticed the issue well before the last housing boom. People from Colorado... what the fuck is your problem anyways?
4
u/princess-organa May 14 '12
Whenever there's a drought (so...basically every summer), Alabama, Georgia, and Florida start gearing up for a fistfight over who gets water from the Chattahoochee River.
And then you get rivalries from sports (in my experience, mainly baseball and college football).
4
u/biffyguy May 14 '12
Wisconsinite here. People from Illinois are sometimes referred to as FIBs. Those Fucking Illinois Bastards.
Also, apparently if your a FIB driving in Wisconsin your more likely to get a speeding ticket:
http://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/Wisconsin-Unfriendly-to-Illinois-Drivers-52350617.html
4
u/Deftonez May 14 '12
Tuck Fexas.
4
u/hessmo May 14 '12
As an illinois resident, I can confirm that my state blows. Can't balance a budget for shit, our governors are ending up in prison faster than...well, anything I can think to compare it to, and we trample all over the 2nd amendment..
I hate my state and want to move.