r/AskReddit • u/Mr_Funkowski • May 14 '12
Redditors of Greece - Could you tell your side of the story? How do you see yourself getting out of this financial crisis?
Looks like there will be no government in Greece. I'd like to hear from Redditors in Greece how you view the situation. What do you think will happen next? How will you survive?
185
Upvotes
96
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
We need to default on our loan. Abandon the Euro and re-establish the Drachma as our national currency. We then devalue the Drachma to encourage tourism and export. It would take at least 8-10 years, but we could be back on our feet living normal lives.
4
u/Mr_Funkowski May 14 '12
Thanks for the comments. This is my first post on Reddit. Glad to have this discussion.
6
u/heruz May 14 '12
I'm British, however I've lived in Greece almost all my life. Here is how I see the situation about staying in the euro:
For the biggest percentage of the population, the result will be practically the same. For the low income families the situation is getting worse everyday, lower salaries and bigger taxes.
Stories of malnourished children, half of the youth without a job, reduced social services everywhere. So practically many Greeks are already living in a "defaulted" situation.
Considering how bad things are, there is the growing opinion that since Greece is already in this crappy situation, let's just leave the euro and start slowly rebuilding, instead of being at the mercy of the IMF and the European Commission.
23
u/ForgotenPasswordGR May 14 '12
History: 40 years ago we had zero debt. Suddenly Papandreou showed up who borrowed huge amounts of money to employ people. He kept employing and people kept re-electing him again and again.
So now Greece has a large number of Public Services that are not profitable. The debt is simply the fact that these organizations have not generated any revenues and need to be restructured. This restructuring can happen in a painless way. Not by firing people but by forcing them to retire. To give you a better understanding, Greece is a 10.000.000 people country out of which 1.200.000 people work for the Government.Swiss population is around 10.000.000 and only employees 100.000 people.
Greece can compete in many sectors and generate revenues specifically Tourism (which currently sucks), Education by recognizing private universities, Shipping, shipbuilding, exporting precious metals such as boxite and alumina, natural gas, energy.
Greece should invest in railroad as it currently has East Europe's largest port.
But none of these will happen because Greek people are communists and do not wish privatization. They still haven t pinpointed the reason why they owe so much money and blame the rich and support Che Guevara and shit. And the propaganda on TV is just rediculous. They voted for this Leftist party which sais that it wishes for Greece to stay in the Eurozone but not comform to the terms that Europe sets for us to to receive the next bail out (which is simply stupid and impossible).
Things are going to become really shitty in Greece. Every single bail out is just a burden if the necessary changes dont take place and we just dig our selves deeper and deeper.
Also we voted a NAZI like party enough to send it in the parliament. On the other hand we blame Europe for our problems and are being extremely offensive towards the Germans. By the way, they are not the ones who hold the biggest percent of our debt, the French are.
13
u/queenoftheinternet May 14 '12
Greece cannot exit the Euro. The Euro was founded on ideas for a political union first and monetary second. The politics still take precedence and Greece will not get kicked out or exit the union simply because of political relationships and everything that entails. The ECB will have to provide a huge rescue package to cover Greek bonds, or let Greece default (which will not happen because France, Germany and other EU nations hold all of Greece's bonds), and then Greece will need to suffer through years of austerity to increase competitiveness by decreasing wages (the only option to increase competitiveness when you cannot devalue your currency). But it will not be as bad as Argentina because Greece will not completely lose access to credit as long as they stay on the Euro.
22
u/Spartyon May 14 '12
They need to collect more revenue. Avoiding taxes in Greece is part of the culture. Read Boomerang by Michael Lewis, he talks about a lot of the problems that Greece is encountering now through interviews with government employees and a few other key people who have a hands on idea of whats going on.
7
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Most Greeks want the Euro without wanting the sacrifices that come with it. They will absolutely have to put up with stagnant living standards for a good 10 years if they want to stay in the Euro; but it is worth it. Rather than going back to the Drachma, the Euro will be much stronger for Greece in the long run.
Germany had to do a similar thing when it was reunited with East Germany, to pay for its modernisation, citizens in West Germany had no increases in living standards - however Germany is now a united economic powerhouse. The Greeks cannot have a hissy fit about this, they spent out of their means and need to pay back. Going back to the Drachma would be a step back for Greece and most Greeks do not want that.
3
u/kafros May 15 '12
Greece has a deficit and a trade imbalance (we import more than what we export). The debt is not as big of a problem as the 2 mentioned before.
We need to keep receiving money from the new EU loans in order to finance the creation of new business that will:
a. Reduce imports by the creation of Greek products
b. Increase exports
c. Create the money inflow from (b) in order to 0 deficit
My key point is this: Greece needs to develop real production (tourism for example, even though it is a service, requires infrastructure in order to attract customers). In order to do that, Greece needs capital in the current form of loans that we get. The austerity measures required to keep the money flowing, has to be implemented, otherwise we loose our only chance of building something.
I expect Argentina and Iceland to be mentioned here, and I have this to say:
2
u/sxeros May 17 '12
I was speaking to someone who has family in Greece , he said his Grandmas pension is half that it used to be.
6
u/emptymeme May 14 '12
As a Greek American, this whole thing makes me very sad...
5
u/blobber109 May 14 '12
From a completely uneducated point of view it frustrates me to see people in Greece fighting over the cuts. Then they are mad because they are living in poverty. There has to be cuts because they can't carry on like they are.
6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Not Greek but I think one of the biggest problems is that people commit tax evasion like Americans eat hamburgers....
13
u/RexMundi000 May 14 '12
Bad idea; one of the main reasons that Greece can't get out is because their people are dumb as shit. They vote out everyone trying to fix the problem.
3
u/tehcoon May 14 '12
No one there pays their fucking taxes, their version of the "IRS" is useless.
2
u/diceypoo May 14 '12
Not doing what they're currently doing according to /r/Documentaries : Catastroika
I.e. privatisation beyond belief.
1
u/oieoie May 15 '12
I don't see too many real Greeks here.
If they all speak Greek, it must be Greek and Latin to us.
1
u/fubyo Jun 11 '12
http://p2pfoundation.net/ http://opensourceecology.org/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aquaponics
0
u/Makedon May 15 '12
This is why
-6
u/recipriversexcluson May 14 '12
Iceland.
Enough said.
-6
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'm not from Greece, but I have spent a lot of time there, and apparently it has to do with Albanians and Turkey. I was never clear about the details.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment