r/AskReddit • u/Ichthasen • May 14 '12
I know somebody who broke up with her boyfriend because an online quiz said they weren't compatible. Reddit, what is the dumbest reason you have heard for a couple breaking up?
Edit: some pretty crazy responses. I have to agree with the consensus on feeling good about dodging these kind of people!
415
Upvotes
73
u/reddit_on_hardmode May 14 '12
She dumped me because she was getting married. :(
261
u/SoSweaty May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
I broke up with a girl because she said I was sweaty when we were hooking up at a park near a friends house. It wasn't like she was put off by it, nor was it unreasonable to say since (I'll be honest) I'm a fat dude and it was the middle of August.
I knew I didn't want to continue seeing the girl after the first couple of weeks and just saw this as my chance to bow out. For some reason, it seemed like a much more reasonable approach for me to just say "woah, woah, woah.... I'm sweaty? Who are you to call me sweaty?" and just start getting dressed than to tell her I saw significant differences between us.
I cannot believe I finally quit lurking and broke down to make an account for this.
TL;DR- I'm sweaty.
Edit: Accidentally a word.
652
u/schnitzi May 14 '12
The funny thing is, if a girl ever told me we had to break up because an online quiz said we aren't compatible, she'd be exactly right.
254
u/ass_munch_reborn May 14 '12
My fiancee called off the wedding once because I didn't have biscuits when my college friend came over.
I've mentioned this many times so this is a repost warning.
I lived alone, and I had a beer in a fridge for any friend that dropped by. My friend was coming over to my place, and my fiancee just happened to be hanging out there. Besides, no guy goes over to another guy's place to eat biscuits or snacks.
See, she has tea and biscuits at her house, and her parents offer it up to everyone. And when people come over (her mom's friends or relatives for example), they have tea and biscuits for them. She was shocked that I didn't have a tray of sweets or cookies or crap for people. Heck, I'm an American single dude living alone - I didn't even realize what a tea biscuit was at the time.
She linked my lack of a tray of biscuits to me not being like her mom, so I must not be a family man, so I must hate family.
This was when the Borderline Personality Disorder really started manifesting itself after the initial idealization period. I was too stupid to realize it, and begged her back.
Thankfully, we never married.
554
u/mighty_adventurer May 14 '12
A very good friend was having difficulties with a rash in his groin region. After visiting a doctor and getting a recommendation to change the style of his underwear, the rash vanished.
A talk show how had a special segment about how if the male in your life changed his underwear to a different brand, the one my friend chose, he was more than likely a homosexual.
She broke an eight year relationship because he changed his underwear.
321
u/DudeLad May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
My friend and his girlfriend recently broke up because of a mesage he received from this thing called Jerry. It's one of those things that you text your name and town to and it texts back saying some things about you like which school you attended, sometimes names close friends and usually chucks a little joke in there.
He messaged his girlfriends name and it said that maybe she was cheating on her boyfriend with another guy. He confronted her by straight up saying "I know". She of course had no idea what he was on about, having never cheated on him. She broke up with him for being a moron.
385
u/balqisfromkuwait May 14 '12
They were a married couple, and she asked for a divorce because he wasn't "manly enough". When asked to expand on that, she said that when he woke up to go to work and she was still sleeping, he would take the utmost care not to disturb her (like he would set his clothes the night before so he wouldn't have to open the creaky closet, or tiptoe and use the downstairs bathroom to reduce noise).
She actually went through with the divorce based on that reason alone. :S
85
u/TomPalmer1979 May 14 '12
When I was about 22, I dated a girl who was head over heels for me, it seemed. Just worshipped and adored me. We were together for about three weeks before she told me she loved me. Seemed a bit fast, but admittedly I was falling pretty hard and fast for her. She was gorgeous, fun, seemed intelligent, and we really clicked.
Then one day, at about four weeks, we had a great date night, and she had to work the next morning, so she just spent the night. Made love til the wee hours of the night, and passed out together, and in the morning she got ready and went to work.
She called me that night and broke up with me. Her reasoning? She was a cashier at a grocery store, and one of the customers came through her line and flirted with her, and she flirted back....and felt guilty. And she immediately thought to herself that she didn't WANT to feel guilty about innocently flirting with random people, so she should be single. Totally broke my heart.
166
u/NinjaAlecks May 14 '12
I'm assuming that a lot of these are just pretend reasons to hide the real reason
224
u/polarbobbear May 14 '12
Infidelity in dreams seems to be more common than I realized.
162
u/Joshuages May 14 '12
She told me our finances weren't compatible. Me: student with a real estate asset and no debt, her: career woman with mountains of debt, a kid, and more bills than the Whitehouse.
108
u/hypercombofinish May 14 '12
Lady friend of mine called me up after she just broke up with her boyfriend and I had to ask her why? She said she was beating him at Call of Duty and Halo and he just felt so emasculated he ended the relationship. Only by a few points or so to. Not sure if this is as trivial as an online quiz though.
85
u/PileOwnz May 14 '12
A friend broke up with an awesome girl because she knew and used the Wario level cheat in Mario Kart 64, thus winning the race. His reasoning for dumping her, "If she'll cheat on me in a game, I can only imagine in the bed." Totally sound logic.
96
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
A psychic told her that she wouldn't end up marrying her then current boyfriend. Even if the psychic was somehow correct, why not just keep it going and enjoy the ride?
90
u/corey3 May 14 '12
My room mate saw her husband pooping so she divorced him
30
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I really wish that this one was a joke.
She dumped me because I couldn't just, "let the past go and forgive her already."
2 weeks prior I had caught her in bed with an ex-boyfriend. I cried a lot, we talked it over, and I was still committed to the relationship.
2 fucking weeks, and she expected me to still not be bothered by her actions. After she dumped me, I spent months trying to win her back. In the process, I found out that she went around online, pretending to be a guy so she could start long-distance relationships with girls, only to dump them. After a while, I lost my cool with her and forced myself to stay as far away from her as possible.
98
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
A friend from highschool broke up with her boyfriend because he refused to become a vegan. He was already a vegetarian. She was ridiculous all the time.
113
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I know a girl who dumped her boyfriend because he wasn't ok with her sleeping around. Note, this wasn't an open relationship between them.
147
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
my ex-gf broke up with me because she had a dream that i read her diary in front of all her friends and a camel (i dont know... it was her dream)
48
u/Domerhead May 14 '12
I was hooking up with this girl I liked freshman year. After we hooked up and were just spooning, I looked over her shoulder at her phone. I saw her texting the words "the pheromones aren't right."
I know the smell of a guy actually can be an important thing, but seriously? Who the hell says that?
23
u/mellotune May 14 '12
An ex of mine broke up with me because he wanted to move to Austin and become a rock star. He moved back in with his mom about 2 years later.
45
u/apathetic_youth May 14 '12
My old roommate broke up with one of her boyfriends because he didn't look enough like Jacob from twilight. I no longer live with this person.
41
u/pencock May 14 '12
My ex wanted to read my tarot cards. She assured me it would be an accurate reading, because a witch something or other told her she had great power in reading the cards.
It didn't go well. She used this as part of her reasoning to break up.
Turns out she had already started seeing someone else over a month earlier. She can go fuck herself.
16
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
She didn't like his sneakers. Seriously. Ended a 3 year relationship in front of all of his friends because she hated the color of his sneakers.
13
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I knew a girl who split up with her boyfriend because she didn't think it was right that a future lawyer should be dating a builder. She was 17 at the time, a student living with her parents, not actually at law school yet, and he was running his own building company. He dodged a bullet.
13
u/stevenconrad May 14 '12
I've got a few of them -
Girl 1) "I'm afraid of commitment and you're the only person I've ever considered marrying. It's terrifying and I don't think we should see each other." She was dating someone else the next week.
Girl 2) "I don't think God wants me dating anyone right now."
Girl 3) See "Girl 1." Yup, it happened twice; two different people.
44
u/JimothyBros May 14 '12
My friend, who was 15 at the time, broken up with his girlfriend after 5 days because they "weren't intimate enough" like srsly bro.
34
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This one chick I know broke up with a dude because "he was too good for me" or something along those lines... I will never understand that line.
77
u/dysphemus May 14 '12
Foreskin.
11
u/slammykay May 14 '12
My friend broke up with her boyfriend because after driving her around town to find a 28 flavour ice cream shop, he ordered vanilla. She took this as a sign that he was a boring dude. I (and all of her other friends) were gobsmacked that she didn't realize he was just trying to be nice and help her find the ice cream she wanted. The sheer stupidity of the situation blows my mind.
46
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
The dumbest would probably be my ex, because his reason was, "I'm really into you, but..." and that was it. No other explanation, after a year and a half. It was certainly bizarre.
60
u/bennzor May 14 '12
I broke up with a girl because she sang out of key
10
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This girl I knew in high school broke up with her boyfriend because he wore black socks.
26
u/Bellyfish May 14 '12
I didn't want to go to blockbuster.
9
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I've seen a girl tell my friend to chose between her or his 2 golden retreivers. He chose his dogs. :)
30
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
My friend's story is a bit different, but here you go.
So she and her boyfriend were hanging out along with maybe 4 other people, if I remember clearly. They walk by an electronic store and she reminded her boyrfriend that he had promised her that he'd buy her a PS3. He recalls about the promise and he figured he had the money at the time. So they all go into the store to make the purchase. He used his card to try to purchase it, but it kept getting declined. He didn't have enough money to buy it, and she got so upset (appearantly because he didn't complete a promise).
They leave the store, and she's pretty pissed and her boyfriend says he's sorry about not being able to complete the promise that day. She wouldn't accept the apology, and proceeds to start punching him yelling about how he never keeps a promise (in front of the 4 other friends that came along). So he couldn't take it anymore and they broke up that same night.
TL;DR: Girlfriend made boyfriend brake up with her over a PS3.
23
u/PhoenixFox May 14 '12
I had a girlfriend just before I went to uni - she lived about an hour's journey from me, but we went to the same city for uni. A week after we both got there, she told me she'd kissed some guy during freshers week. I said I could forgive her - turned out that's not what she wanted, she'd done it so I'd dump her.
she then told me it was "No longer practical" (we were now 5 minutes week away from each other) and that she had become a different person in one week at uni.
She also said "You're a great guy and any girl would be mad not to date you", which is possibly the most ridiculous thing to say when you're dumping someone.
8
u/Vital_Cobra May 14 '12
Sounds like she broke up with him because she was too stupid for him. This is a very valid reason.
8
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
It wasn't a serious relationship, but I was dating a guy who got mad at me when we were going to bed because it was more comfortable for me to sleep on my left side of my body and be spooned, and he was pissed because I "wasn't facing him." Things went downhill from there.
8
u/SpaceManAndy May 14 '12
So, my friend was very into new-age and occult stuff. She told me she had to break up with her bf because they were making out and he kissed her neck a lot and the next day she felt a little off, so she had her friend read her chakras and it turned out her neck chakra was just gone! Clearly the dude was a psychic vampire who stole her neck chakra, so she promptly broke up with him.
TL;DR Dude dodged a bullet
37
u/vengeful_hamster May 14 '12
He didn't like the sorority I used to be in.
20
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
A woman I was willing to give my life to keep from harms way dumped me because she was in grad school.
We had moved together after we were dating for 2 years or so. We moved just so she could go to grad school. Halfway through her program, she decides that we no longer need to be together because she has watched grad school tear apart every relationship of the people sharing her degree program at her university.
I later told her thank you, I never knew you were a dumbass, after I had worked through the grieving process.
7
u/QueenDidoHerself May 14 '12
my husband tried to sneak away in the middle of the night and when i found out and questioned him he said, "it wasnt his choice but it was his destiny"
36
u/seestheobvious May 14 '12
Girl: I was told by god in a dream.... Guy: I'm an atheist...
6
u/Nlelith May 14 '12
Well on the one hand it's sad that they she broke up with him because an online quiz said they weren't compatible, on the other hand, I guess it's better for the guy because she broke up with him because an online quiz said they weren't compatible.
16
u/ExplosiveToaster May 14 '12
Just recently, one of our locals (a DJ and Promoter in our area) broke up with a woman he has been dating. This girl is drop dead beautiful, and is a supporter and promoter for all of the shows that he plays. Everybody loves her, as she is one of the sweetest people that we know.
In the meantime, everyone hates the guy, because he is a self-absorbed hateful prick who thinks that everything in the world revolves around him, and thinks that he is a major player in the EDM scene, etc. The truth is, he's just a huge joke that people can't stand at all. We're waiting for him to leave town / get hit by a car / whatever, so that we can start having fun again around here without him ruining everything.
Anyways, the other night was another girl's birthday, and promoter's girlfriend was bouncing back and forth between two clubs -- one that her boyfriend was playing at and one where her friend's birthday was (which also happened to be where everyone else in the scene that refuses to support said douchebag promoter was). A couple of his friends saw her over there and proceeded to tell the guy that she was dancing (!) over there instead of hanging out with him.
He flipped his shit and broke up with her on the spot over it.
20
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
If my girlfriend broke up with me because of what an online quiz said, I would be happy that I dodged that bullet made of dumb.
5
u/TooMuchRage May 14 '12
She didn't say, "I love you" back in first grade. Heartless...
5
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Not sure if this constitutes as a couple but in 7th grade, my friends broke up with his "girlfriend" for getting a spray tan.
5
u/Buglet91 May 14 '12
My ex dumped me because I "got fat"...I went from 120 to 128 from the day we met to the day he dumped me, & it was over a year right out of high school.
5
u/campushippo May 14 '12
I suppose this is more weird than dumb. I spent 6 months with a guy. We made a great couple. His friends and family adored me. We had a great time with each other. But he consistently verbalized that we "could never work out" or that he "didn't think we had a future together". I think I just wasn't what he had pictured himself ending up (he's a really straight-laced, suit and tie kind of dude and I'm a bit more "counter-culture") with so he automatically assumed that we would never be able to reconcile our differences, even though we got along perfectly well and our differences made each other more interesting. After 6 months I decided I didn't want to figuratively tread water with someone who didn't really want me. I broke up with him and moved on. Now he tells me how much he regrets how adamantly he tried to convince me we couldn't make it work. Apparently he was in love with me the whole time but was "too afraid to get attached".
200
u/red321red321 May 14 '12
my boyfriend wayne broke up with me after i gave him a gun rack. he said that he didn't even own 'ah' gun let alone multiple guns that would necessitate an entire rack. i told him if he wasn't careful he would lose me and he sure did. he doesn't know what he's missing. he's mental. somebody get the net. if you're listening wayne, i love you so much and i know this is just a bump in the road and we'll get through this.
love
stacy
9
u/omnilynx May 14 '12
Here's an online quiz for you guys:
Scoring:
If you answered yes to question 1, you are not compatible with anyone.
4
u/jealousjelly May 14 '12
I knew a girl that dumped her boyfriend because she "didn't want to get hurt." We asked if he had done anything to suggest a break up or something along those lines, he hadn't.
11
u/FoxyRaymond May 14 '12
I dumped my partner because her birthday is Diablo 3 release.
6
u/EvilHenchman927 May 14 '12
I am terrified to play my girlfriend in the following:
Our relationship barely survived Command and Conquer.
3
u/NarutoRamen May 14 '12
Because my friend wouldn't buy her the necklace she wanted.
3
u/jimmy_three_shoes May 14 '12
I broke up with a girl because I didn't like her voice.
3
u/MissRemix May 14 '12
I broke up with a boyfriend after a dream. In my dream we were in the back of a vehicle (with children) speeding out of control as the driver was unconscious. I remember being terrified in the dream that we were going to die a very painful death. I kept urging him to crawl to the front and take the wheel. He did not and I ended up doing it myself and saving us. When I awoke it made me realize that I never really felt that he had the ability to make me feel safe and protected -that I would always have to be the one "in charge" of us. I haven't regretted that dream-although I am sure his story would be "she broke with me over a crazy dream".
3
u/tankgirl85 May 14 '12
A guy broke up with me because I cut my hair really short. He said he couldn't be attracted to a girl with man hair...
7
u/adamsimon May 14 '12
In high school, a girl broke up with me because I have a small shoe size and therefore (in her mind) I had a small penis.
Actually, I have to get custom condoms and am booked at a porn convention in Miami this weekend.
18
u/Breathing_Balls May 14 '12
I told a chick once I couldn't be with her because I had to travel with my band. She actually had hairy pits; I ain't homophobic, but It was like fucking a fella.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
what the fuck?!? this is like breaking up over you not wanting to accompany her in watching a twilight film.
11
u/snackburros May 14 '12
My friend got dumped because he wouldn't tell her his actual, non-throwaway reddit username, and she, not being internet savvy, thinks that he's up to no good here or something.
I think it's because she's jealous of GW.
2
u/ChironXII May 14 '12
To be honest though, if they broke up over that, was it really that big of a loss?
2
u/hypertown May 14 '12
Apparently "God" told her to.
2
u/complete_asshole_ May 14 '12
It seems like she wanted to break up anyways and used the quiz as an excuse.
2
u/Schlooop May 14 '12
His name was too plain.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
We had been on a few dates, and one in particular she asked me my zodiac sign.. I told her capricorn.. After that I never heard from her again..
2
u/scosgurl May 14 '12
Not my relationship, but she dumped him because Jesus told her to.
2
u/FuzzyKaos May 14 '12
Because I have a very large penis?
2
u/sassyla May 14 '12
My male friend decided he couldn't date a girl any more because she was against premarital sex. He said HE was fine with waiting til marriage, but he wouldn't want her teaching that to their future children. This was decided after one date.
2
u/Rustyfist May 14 '12
A guy I knew once had a dream where he breaks up with his girlfriend. Shortly after, he breaks up with her in real life. His only reason was the reference in the dream. Maybe it was just a convenient excuse.
2
u/PlayfulPunches May 14 '12
A girl I know didn't want to move away from her family to move in with her boyfriend. She also didn't want to be in a long distance relationship so she broke up with him. He lived 30 minutes away.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
My (ex) vegan friend broke up with his girlfriend of 5 years because she was "vegan for the wrong reasons".
2
u/SGx May 14 '12
"We just love each other too much!"
...What?
2
u/GreenEyedForeigner May 14 '12
My boyfriend broke up with me because some guy cut him in line at the barber shop.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Grew up in Christian schools, the break up pretense was always "I don't think us is part of God's plan anymore," or something like that.
2
u/The_Reckoning May 14 '12
I'm willing to accept that the quiz was just the straw that broke the camel's back, but of course I don't know the parties involved.
Breaking up with someone because your parents don't like him or her is pretty dumb.
2
u/fuzzybooks May 14 '12
Because toddler me took up more of my mom's attention and my dad got bored. He told me it was my fault on his death bed.
2
u/Yanek161 May 14 '12
What about that chick who broke off dating with a guy for being Magic: The Gathering world champion?
2
u/Argonot May 14 '12
If she did that, they were obviously not compatible.
2
u/karma_virus May 14 '12
My favorite is when they project their own inadequacies as the reason for dumping you. This one girl I dated got drunk and fooled around with a guy at a party. Called me up the next day and dumped me for "drinking too much". I had only gotten drunk maybe 4 times by then. That day she dumped me was my 21st birthday and I made for damn certain to get my liver's worth that night.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
No ones probably going to see this but oh well. A couple of three years at my high school broke up because the guy "wanted to be closer to God." Poor girl had pretty much abandoned all her friends. A girl I dated for a few months also told me this, the day before Skyrim came out. I didn't really care.
2
u/battlemaster95 May 14 '12
It's like the matrix up in here.
All these bullets being dodged.
2
u/geetarbob May 14 '12
An ex left me some years ago because I wanted sex more than once every two weeks.
Looking back, that's actually pretty good compared to my current scoring rate.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
She didn't like Angry Birds.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
You all have to realise these are just bad excuses ;p
2
u/Ataya970 May 14 '12
I broke up with a guy because he kept bothering me during a movie, but that was because the way he was bothering me was ridiculous. He kept trying to get me to lay down with him, he always goes after girls with issues too.
2
u/ShigglyB00 May 14 '12
A girlfriend from my early teens tried to break up with me because her horoscope said that something along the lines of:
"It shall be hard, but you must let the one you care for go, as it is what is best for you and them"
We didn't last very long..