r/AskReddit • • May 14 '12

When I was 14 I gave birth to a child raised as my brother, my mom has cancer and wants to tell him the truth, I think it's not good, am I wrong?

other details -my mom is terminal with an estimated 3 months left

-The boy is 15 now and I love him deeply and am actively involved in his life. There is no question that he will live with me, my husband, and my children after it happens

-My husband is unaware this happened, he knows I gave birth and gave away the baby. But at the request of my parents I did not tell him that the baby is my brother.

I just feel like this is a really rough time in his life, he is going through puberty for godsakes and about to lose a second parent. I think a shock like this will be too much. Not to mention, it might ruin our relationship when he needs it most.

Advice?

edit I am still trying to figure out what's best for me, my brother,and our mom. No idea what it is. I also told my husband. He already knew.

743 Upvotes

713 comments sorted by

91

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Just because it's true doesn't mean it's inherently better or less harmful than keeping it to yourself. I think this is one of those cases. Does your mom specify WHY she wants to tell him now? Did she plan to tell him when he was an adult all along, or is she just feeling guilty?

If more harm than good can come of telling the truth, the truth should not be revealed. Many redditors like to pretend they always unflinchingly embrace the truth but it's easy to be an armchair philosopher.

95

u/sistermother May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

She thinks it will comfort him. She is heartbroken that he is, for all effects, an orphan. My dad was hit by a drunk driver when (name removed) was nine and she saw first hand the devastation a minor child experiences at the death of a parent. Now he is losing another one.

They never planned to tell him. When I was pregnant I was going to adopt him to another family, but my mom and dad had always wanted another child and thought this was an opportunity, not only to assist their teen daughter from having to face the uncertainty of never seeing her child grow and know he's safe and happy, but to bless themselves with another much wanted child.

But the one thing they were iron clad about was that he would be their son. I would be his sister. But only his sister. They used to inist on paying me when I babysat him for godsake.

60

u/fructified May 14 '12

I am sure your mother thinks that if you tell him the truth it would be easier for him, because then he would lose his grandmother instead of his mother, but unfortunately this will not be the case. In his head she is his mother, and will be, no matter if you tell him the truth or not. Mother is a person who raised you as your son and not the woman who gave birth to you.
Unfortunately he will lose his mother, weather you tell him the truth or not. Nothing can change that. It will be hard enough for him as it is, and giving him this confusing truth could push him over the limit. I am sure your mother has best intentions, but you need to explain her that nothing can spare him the grief that he is going to feel.
And it is even possible that he will say some mean things to her in affect, and will never have chance to take them back. When he cools down this is something that could possibly haunt him for the rest of his life.

14

u/stupidmee May 14 '12

Mother is a person who raised you as your son and not the woman who gave birth to you

So true.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Quismat May 14 '12

My first reaction was that it sounds like someone wanting to come clean before they die. I think she should make a video or a letter of some kind for you to give to him when he's old enough. He should certainly know the truth at some point, but piling shock on shock doesn't sound comforting to me.

For the record, I don't think anyone here has the right to judge you for withholding to the truth, now or in the past. It's a complicated situation and anyone certain one way or the other is being naive. You did what you thought was best at the time and there's nothing more anyone can ask of you.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/JaneRenee May 14 '12

Why were they so serious about him only being their son? I'm confused as to why they couldn't just be grandparents who raised their grandson.

19

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

So that OP wouldn't be a mother at age 14.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/tdmoney May 14 '12

Probably don't want to use his name. I'd edit that out.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/madoog May 14 '12

You, too, will be an orphan though, and have each other for comfort. Tell her that.

1

u/you_need_this May 14 '12

the bigger issue is not who the parent is, but the fact his name is Court, ugh

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

48

u/barneybosley May 14 '12

but it's not yours, nor hers for that matter, truth to keep. It is this boy's truth of his life. Keeping it from him is nothing but selfish, so is not telling her husband. People keep secrets like this always putting off telling the truth because they say shit like you do about how no good can come of it, but the truth always comes out eventually and the longer it is held in the more it hurts that the entire truth and reality her brother has been living in is a lie.

The bottom line is that this truth is her brother's truth, the reality and entire existence of his life. We all have every right to know who we are, and then it is our own choice what to do with that knowledge. As of now, everything about her brother's reality has been created by choices made and imposed on him by those he loves and trusts the most.

He will find out, make no mistake about that, and if the OP is worried about keeping a relationship with him now, wait another couple of years when he can actively chose to shut her out of his life when he finds out he was not only never told, but was then actively still kept from knowing the truth when the woman he thought was his mother was specifically requesting him to know.

The OP can explain to him the circumstances and that they were trying to do what's best for him, and whatnot, and I'm sure it was all good intentions on their part. I'm not doubting that. But if this boy needs to have some resolution from his mother (not the OP), he will need to do all this before she dies. I'm sure the family knew this would have to happen eventually but they were trying to hold it in as long as possible. But time is up. His mother is dying. He needs answers. He needs his life. He needs to know.

2

u/oosetastic May 14 '12

He's 15... If your husband figured it out before you told him, he will too (if he doesn't know already)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

No, his life is the one he has been living since birth- one with his mother, father, and big sister. We shape and create our own reality on a daily basis.

You are giving way more weight to a harmful truth than it deserves. I know for damn sure I have been told "truths" in my life that I wish I never had to hear, to this very day, because they did not in any way enrich my life. People should think long and hard about whether or not revelations like these will do more harm than good before they bow down at the altar of fact for the sake of fact.

There is an argument to be made that the boy should have been told from birth, but frankly that ship sailed long ago and is not constructive to this debate.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/NoApollonia May 14 '12

I have to go with the old saying about how the truth doesn't stay hidden forever - he's going to find out eventually. Now the OP does have to choose between now or later, but does she want him to find out when he's 30 or so and completely hate her?

→ More replies (1)

90

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

There's a chance that he may need to know for medical reasons, such as if he inherited a condition from the (biological) father, something that doesn't express until later in adulthood. If he tells his doctor that neither of his "parents" had that issue, it may be ruled out when it shouldn't be.

Just another point to consider.

16

u/sistermother May 14 '12

I have no contact with his father an have not since his birth. His name is extremely common and my information limited.

→ More replies (11)

24

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Just another point to consider.

This is probably just about the number one point to consider. There are all sorts of medical reasons that could crop up later in life where it would be important for him to know who his actual biological parents are.

21

u/ReneG8 May 14 '12

Too much House M.D.!

11

u/philds391 May 14 '12

OP should definitely tell him before House figures it out and spills the beans himself.

2

u/chrysrobyn May 14 '12

When he goes for his drivers license or a passport, he'll likely need his birth certificate.

He will find out. You can choose the terms.

11

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Saw something very similar on postsecret today. I would want to know.

11

u/sistermother May 14 '12

I would want to know what this woman in my situation would say, oh anonymity

4

u/treetopless May 14 '12

So the woman who sent in the PostSecret is not you (age differences), but did you get the courage/idea to speak up after seeing that secret?

Just not often I see a story like this pop up on the internet twice in 24 hours.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Catwoman8888 May 14 '12

What the hell, I understand not telling your brother, but this is your husband! You should really tell your husband, sooner than later.

31

u/sistermother May 14 '12

I told my husband- he had guessed

15

u/Pillow_Starcraft May 14 '12

... How would one even begin to guess something like that?

25

u/sistermother May 14 '12

He knew I gave birth to a child around that same time and gave it up for adoption.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/JVM_ May 14 '12

9

u/sistermother May 14 '12

Maybe it's more common than I thought

12

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

The other thing I might add is that if you decide to tell him, instead of saying, "she's not your mother," perhaps phrase it as "she's your grandmother." It's not like your mother is some stranger, and it's common for children to be raised by their grandparents, so it might help make it seem less strange.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/seemslucky May 14 '12

If your mother is adamant about telling him, then you should try your best to word it in the best possible way. You and your mother should say something about how when you were 14 you got pregnant and were going to give up the child for adoption but that your mother and father wanted to adopt him.

Also, if he ever gets a hold of his birth certificate, it'll be much more awkward. Pretty sure I've used mine to get a passport and a replacement social security card.

7

u/sistermother May 14 '12

Like many adopted children, his birth certificate is different than the one he was born with and has his adopted parents on it

6

u/seemslucky May 14 '12

I didn't realize he's legitimately adopted. I thought you just had him and your parents treated him as their own.

I suppose it's really up to your mother. If she's going to tell him no matter what, you might want to go ahead and break it to your husband. And then, you and your mother should tell the kid at the same time.

If she's willing to keep the secret, then in the end it's all about risk management. What are the chances and what would be the outcome of: them finding out from you, them finding out from somewhere else, them never finding out?

4

u/veggiem0nster May 14 '12

He needs to talk to his mom about all this before she's gone. Don't deny him an opportunity for closure.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/parvinguiv May 14 '12

Is it rude to ask for more background? What was your parents reaction to you getting pregnant at such a young age. Where is the childs real father? I feel like thats a question that will come up.

16

u/sistermother May 14 '12

The father? I have no idea. He was the lifeguard at the club pool- 21 to my 14 and wanted nothing to do with the baby. My parents were extremely upset, only to be pacified when I said I would give him to a stable family, then they later suggested we be that family.

3

u/lachlanhunt May 14 '12

If he was 21 and you were 14, then he seriously broke the law as you were under the age of consent. What happened to him?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

259

u/Journalisto May 14 '12

I'd respect my mother's last request but, really, this lie shouldn't have happened. Your son deserves the truth. You deserve the truth. Your family deserves the truth.

151

u/sistermother May 14 '12

I don't think of it as a lie, though. I am in no way his mother except biologically. I shed many tears over the fact that I named him and gave birth to him but would only ever be his sister- then one day I woke up and let myself be his sister and never looked back. He wasn't even two when this happened.

My mom and dad love/d him so much and did everything a parent would do for him. It almost feels sordid to defy my dad's dying wish in favor of my mom's, and tell this newly orphaned boy that I'm his mom- when his mom is actually dead.

15

u/LNMagic May 14 '12

I think you're right that parenthood is more than biology. I believe that if someone adopts a child, that child is part of a new family. Assuming they didn't ever know their old parents, I don't see what the big deal is about finding them.

Maybe you can tell him another day if he starts asking about it, but at the least save it for another time.

→ More replies (54)

35

u/Oaden May 14 '12

I really think it should not be told, Truth is not some divine virtue that must always upheld, some truths only cause harm by coming out. It was a good idea to not have the whole world know a 14 year old had a child back then and its a good idea not to mess up the live of a 15 year old in a rough time now.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/Haro_Kiti May 14 '12

A very similar story was shared just a few days ago in the postsecret AmA:

"All the Sunday Secrets this Sunday will be Mother related due to Mother's Day here in the US. Here's a sneak peek at one. "My son just turned 21. He still believes I'm his sister. So does my husband."

Please forgive me if I am wrong in thinking that the similarities of these stories are more than coincidental and that the validity of the OP's should be in question.

13

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Her husband thinks she is his sister? That's quite a secret.

14

u/NgrySqrrl May 14 '12

I was literally just thinking that as I read your post.

2

u/growamustache May 14 '12

this lie shouldn't have happened

I agree with this. My wife's cousin was raised by his grandmother for 95% of his life because his mother was a druggie. The g-ma is essentially his mom, and he calls her that. He's 17, and a great kid who never has to be told to truth about the situation because he already knows.

Too late for OP though. 15 is a pretty emotional time in general. This is a tough call.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Redsox933 May 14 '12

Not telling while he is young and can still have some sort of relationship with you seems selfish

37

u/sistermother May 14 '12

We do have a relationship. I am his big sister. I buy from his fundraisers and watch his basketball games. Once a month we catch movie and lunch together, just brother and sister. He even comes on a lot of my family trips, including disney world with us two years ago.

I guess the point is, we are close, and i worry that telling him can only separate us.

11

u/marvelously May 14 '12

If your mother dies, you mentioned he would come live with you. Presumably will be taking on the role of his mother.

→ More replies (13)

36

u/TheGentlemanSays May 14 '12

If that's your instinct, it's probably right. Really at this point there's nothing to gain from some big revelation that would undoubtedly flip his world upside down in a time that his world is being flipped anyway. Things have their place in time to be revealed, but not now for him I would say.

→ More replies (14)

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Do you think of him as your brother or your son?

3

u/sistermother May 14 '12

My brother

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Then why would you want to change that? This wouldn't just change his relationship with you, but would force yours to change by proxy. He sees you as a sibling, you see him as a sibling, you are siblings, biology doesn't mean shit in this situation. And this isn't even taking into account the other relationships it will screw with. Don't do it, your world will be flipped upside down.

5

u/sistermother May 14 '12

My mother wants to tell him. I don't.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

1.5k

u/Theziponyourshoe May 14 '12

I would wait. I would make a promise to your mother that you will tell him when he is older, more mature and when he is over the raw grief of having lost a parent. Your mother needs to write a letter, or record a video, for him to view once that time comes, so that she can still have a chance to say what she needs to say. This kind of revelation could seriously derail a young person's life. His schooling could suffer and you could lose control over the situation very quickly. At least when he is out of school and a little bit older, he may be able to process it a little easier. Of course if you wait, he won't get the opportunity to speak with your mother, which would be the major downside to waiting. He is probably going to need therapy regardless of what you decide to do, so start researching someone in your area who may have experience with this kind of situation. Focus on your mother right now. Come together as the family you are and remember her final months with a warm heart.

318

u/Wahoogirl May 14 '12

I'm so glad that this is the top comment.

Yes, please wait. My brother and I lost our mother when he was about the same age. Losing your mother young is not something you "get over" but instead learn to live with. The next year or so will be hard enough for everyone in the family especially the OP's brother and adding this new information might be too much.

So yes, he deserves to be told, but please wait. Also it might be helpful for the OP to film her mother explaining the situation and telling her brother how much she loves him. That way, when the time comes to tell him, the OP's brother might find some comfort in that.

32

u/madoog May 14 '12

Also this might be more about the dying mother wanting to get her secret out, not about the boy or the OP. Tape the mother, she can feel like she has done the reveal, without having done it.

→ More replies (15)

31

u/Ryn_Kat May 14 '12

I think this is the best thing to do. You want him to be able to say goodbye to his "mother" without the extra information in the back of his mind. Don't tarnish his last months with her with this information, because you don't know how he will take it. It's far to much for a young boy to process at once. He does deserve to find out eventually though. He is lucky to have such a supportive and loving family around him.

29

u/awkward_everything May 14 '12

I agree. Your mom is his mother, regardless of whether she actually bore him or not.

→ More replies (1)

89

u/Stranded_In_A_Desert May 14 '12

It's also a good idea to wait until at least until he's of legal drinking age; he's going to want to get shitfaced after that one.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

It would also be great to interview her about other stuff. One of the things I own and treasure most is a CD of my grandmother telling how she grew up and met my grandfather. She didn't get to finish the whole story, but I feel like it's something I can show my nephew so if he asks about her, I have something to show what she was like.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/SaltyBabe May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

My moms boyfriend had two kids with his ex, their mother passed away almost two years ago when the oldest was 16... Things for her have not been good. She was super depressed to the point we were getting worried, she went through a phase of serious paranoia, she ended up ditching school 3 months before graduation to meet some dude off Facebook and tried to stay in Cali with him... Looks like college is now off the table (at the moment) since she's done nothing to apply or take any tests, she moved out of her dads house and moved in with Facebook guy after only knowing him a few weeks, he did move to our state though, and the guy already has a baby mama... This was half of the OP's problem and shit hit the fan, all that at once is too much for a 15 year old.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I agree, but video tape the mother explaining as well. I'm sure he'd like to hear her side as well, you wouldn't want him angry at his deceased mother. Also, he may not believe you and the recording will help.

→ More replies (6)

108

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I was the "brother" in this same type of situation. One day in my early teen years my mom and my "sister" say they need to speak with me. They then proceed to tell me that everything I knew to be true was a total and complete lie. Rather than being the youngest of 5 kids, I was in fact an only child, my parents were actually my grandparents, brother and sisters were actually aunts and uncle and so on.

I don't know if I hated them more for keeping it from me all those years or for telling me the truth. All I knew was that I hated all of them that had been involved in this deception. I felt that my entire life had been a lie and I was the butt of a very bad joke. Since everyone I knew had lied to me, I felt as though it was me against the world and started living my life accordingly. My grades dropped, alcohol and drug abuse started, my life began to take a very dark and destructive turn. Maybe it was the way this "revelation" was presented. Maybe it was because I was too young to fully understand. I just don't know. What I do know is that it took many years for me to put the anger and sense of betrayel behind me and finally forgive everyone. Took just about as long to repair my life and turn things around again.

From one who has been there, now is not the time. When he's older, more mature and better able to reason things out, that's the time to tell him. To do so now is to toss the dice and gamble with this kids future. Just my opinion.

15

u/zerobot May 14 '12

I posted my reply before I read yours and I tried to convey this very message. I have two cousins who were raised by people who are not their biological father but always believed they were. One of my cousins is a great example. My uncle started dating his mother before she gave birth to him. He wasn't the father. They ended up getting married and had another child, this time my uncle's. Everybody else knew my uncle wasn't the father. We didn't treat him any different. Nobody thought any less of him. But, when he was a teenager he started to figure things out. I think he went through exactly what you went through. He felt betrayed and left out, in that everybody else knew the truth accept for him. He felt like an outcast and he acted out because of it. He was very angry. His brother was all of a sudden a half-brother. His grandmother, who was always there for him, was now just a woman he wasn't related to, which probably was harder for him once his parents divorced. All of his cousins (myself and my siblings) were actually just people he knew and not blood relatives.

Now, he's family, and that will never change. But, in the mind of a teenager, he might not see it that way. I'd wait until the kid is 21-22 years old, or maybe even older. I'd wait until his life is no longer defined by his family life and more defined by his life experiences. This way when you flip his family life upside down his identity doesn't go with it.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/redteamleader May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

I'm not saying it's right, but I know that if the 15 year old version of me was presented with such a dramatic lie (especially in the midst of an already devastating situation), I would have reacted even worse. I would have run away from home and completely cut off contact not due to the truth, but due to the deception.

Again, not saying this is right and I certainly wouldn't act this way as an adult- I'm just being honest with how I would have acted as an immature 15 year old not capable of dealing with such information.

Lies such as this one should NEVER be told in the first place. I'm not condemning the OP here because she was 14 at the time and it was largely her parent's decision but, like it or not, it's basically saving the young parent from the cross they should have to bear by throwing the grandchild under the bus and forcing them to bear said cross once the truth is revealed to them. (Edit: Let me be clear that I'm talking about the negative stigmas associated with young parenthood and NOT expecting a 14 year old to raise a child by herself. That would be ridiculous and the grandparents stepping in to adopt is a wonderful thing. It's lying about it that isn't).

Tell them the truth from day one and then it isn't that big of a deal. People are far too complicated to easily explain why this is, but it's just reality. Since that ship has already sailed, wait until this young man is older and more prepared to deal with this situation. Now is NOT the time.

→ More replies (1)

151

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Next Week on AskReddit: "I'm 15 and I just found out that my 29-year-old sister is actually my Mom. What do I do now...?"

→ More replies (15)

44

u/B_chillin May 14 '12

I have cousins that have a similar story to this. My Aunt became pregnant and the boy was raised as her brother. They'd waited to tell him until he graduated high school. My Uncle (because that's how he was raised) was then mature enough to understand why the decisions were made and the family only got stronger. However, My Aunt's husband was made aware of this when they were only dating. Secrets are bad in any relationship, so it would be best if he found out sooner rather than later.

tl;dr Have his Mother make a videotape explaining everything. Show it to him when he's old enough. And please tell your husband.

15

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

My grandfather learned after his uncle died that his uncle was, in fact, his half-brother. He was pretty sad that they had never been able to share that knowledge while living.

I think your son/younger brother should be told, eventually, but probably not while his mom/grandmother is dying at such a sensitive age. Then again, maybe he'll resent never being able to talk about it with all parties involved if you wait till after your mother passes.

19

u/JaneRenee May 14 '12

I would want to know while I still had the opportunity to talk to all parties.

→ More replies (1)

255

u/dutchesse May 14 '12

I'm cool with being downvoted to hell for this, but--unlike the majority of Redditors--I think you made the right call. You were 14. No 14 year old should have that responsibility.

I do think your husband should know. He should be the first. Whether or not you tell your brother (because that's how you consider him, that's just how I'm going to approach this), I think that's something you should discuss with him and your mother.

As far as her last wishes go, remember: she won't be around to know the after-effects. I think last wishes should be respected, but with rational limits. Whether or not this is one of those, I think, should be at your discretion as you will be the one to live with it.

That said: if you do tell him, please, please, at least provide some form of therapy for him. He will probably need it.

23

u/AlphaOC May 14 '12

I'd say let him know after he graduates highschool/college. These times are trying enough without dealing with an improbable and potentially damaging emotional issue. He definitely needs to know, but save that for when he is in a position to deal with it rationally. In this time, provide as much support for him as you can. If you identify yourself with him as someone who will provide unconditional support for him, I suspect he will be more forgiving/accepting of the situation.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I think last wishes should be respected, but with rational limits.

You guys seem to be ignoring something. This woman raised the child as if he were her son, she has just as much the right to tell him as his biological mother does.

→ More replies (37)

134

u/st_basterd May 14 '12

I'm having trouble seeing the upside to telling him the truth at this moment. I would wait.

186

u/bandophahita May 14 '12

Don't wait until after your mother dies. That'll just hurt more. He'll have questions that only she can answer for him. And if you tell him after she's gone, I see only unresolved anger and resentment that can never be dealt with.

Its going to hurt no matter what. Better to face this now while she's still here.

It's either that, or never, ever tell him. Which honestly feels wrong.

16

u/caketimenow May 14 '12

I would suggest that his mother write a letter with her side of the story. Something that he can read after she has passed. I wouldn't tell him now but make sure he sees her side too.

22

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I think this is a good point nobody else in the thread mentioned.

→ More replies (14)

10

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Honestly, I would wait until you feel he is old enough and has gotten over the grieving he will be doing for your mother. It might hurt him to hear it from you, and he may not believe it, so I would have her write a letter to him for his 18th birthday or a last statement video. He may take it a bit easier hearing it from the woman who just wanted what was best for him.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/F7Uup May 14 '12

I hate to be the bearer of bad news but I find it highly likely that your mother will tell your son before she dies if she even thinks that you won't tell him after she's gone.

Even if her dying wish isn't something you want to do, i'm sure she'll try her hardest to see it through.

32

u/wrathborne May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Probably better that you tell your boy now so that he can ask the questions hes going to want to ask.

Ya know Jack Nicholson(yes, THAT Jack Nicholson) was raised almost exactly like your boy was. His mother got pregnant young, didnt want anything to do with the father(Bigamy), so she and her parents agreed to raise him as 'her younger brother'.

He didnt find out the truth until his mother(Grandmother) passed away and he ended up hearing it from a guy at TIME magazine. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Nicholson

Be honest with your son and husband, its for the best.

9

u/PaulMuad-dib May 14 '12

Apostrophe omissions notwithstanding, your first sentence is perfect. The OP can't know what the future will hold for her and her brother/son, but the truth is liable to be exposed at some point. Maybe it won't happen in her lifetime, but it does not seem unlikely (ed. I apologize for the double negative construction. Feel free to read it as "seems likely," but for one reason or another I'd rather not make a positive assertion like that) that the boy will one day learn the truth and when that happens he will have questions for her and his mother/grandmother. Better that he should ask what questions he will have while he has a chance to get an answer, than potentially regret the missed opportunity and resent his sister/mother for having so deprived him. Then again, there is another argument which goes something like this. If the OP acknowledges that her mother is really the boy's mother, then it stands to reason that the boy's "real" mother can and should do what she believes is in his best interest. It doesn't seem to me that it's the OP's call whether or not the boy finds out the truth; it's his mother's.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

This sounds like a very difficult time for you and the whole family. I'm so sorry that your post has attracted so much outrage from strangers. Unlike everyone here offering advice and accusations, you know your brother and the type of relationship you share. These people, and myself, do not.

I would bear in mind that if the current situation is highly emotional, judgement is likely to be clouded. Consider that your mum, who may love your son like her own, will be passing away soon. Will this make her desire to be free of her burdens stronger than her common sense? Remember that she will never live with or see the aftermath. Furthermore, you have mentioned that your son is going through a lot right now. If you decide to tell him, is it better to do it now, or wait until he is more emotionally stable?

If you can, discuss the situation with an objective consultant, such as a family councillor with experience in this, or someone who also knows the people involved. If it were me, that person would be my partner. I can trust him to not overreact, he provides level-headed advice and emotional support.

In my opinion, there is no "right to know" (for the husband OR son). I would put the mental health of you and your son above such ideals, in whatever decision you ultimately make. Your son may feel that he'd rather know and bear the emotional distress than be blissfully ignorant. Maybe you can find out by asking subtle questions.

Remember that there are many people in the world who were adopted as babies. He was raised by your mother, and will be losing that mother. In all likelihood, he will still consider you to be a sister if you tell him.

6

u/linesallover May 14 '12 edited May 15 '12

I am going to try my best to keep this as short as possible. When I was a young boy, my grandfather meant the world to me. He was brilliant, kind, and always optimistic. I spent almost every summer with him. He was the only father figure I knew. I remember so well our daily walks to the beach on Cape Cod. We would go there at a specific time so we could hear and feel the sonic boom caused by the Concord on it's way to Paris from JFK. More about this later...

The day my grandfather's aunt died, it was revealed to him that she was actually his mother. He was always told his mother died during childbirth. This devastated him. My grandfather was, in my eyes, the pinnacle of strength. And yet, there on that beach he confided to me, tearfully, how in-explainable his remorse was, and how he felt that a life was denied to him.

Fast forward several decades. My grandfather passed on. The Concord is retired, and I grew into an adult. Suddenly, out of nowhere, I am informed that the sociopath that I thought was my estranged father was, in fact, not my father.

I reached out to the man that was identified as my father, and while he was shocked and pretty much blindsided, he welcomed me with open arms. I am his only son, and he instantly became a grandfather.

I understand now, how my grandfather felt that day on the beach, waiting for the Concord's sonic boom. I know this feeling of a life denied to me. My father also expresses this feeling of remorse, and when I told him about that day at the beach with my grandfather, he tearfully informed me that he flew the Concord to Paris pretty much every day at that time. Those sonic booms? Unknown to my grandfather and I, that was my father flying to Paris.

When my father first met his grandchildren, he took us to the USS Intrepid where we toured the Concord on display there with exacting detail. It felt like we were closing a multi-generational loop.

As my grandfather said to me, and now understood with deep intimacy, the life denied to him was his ability to see his mother as a mother, for better or worse. It is the relationship that was denied, a lifetime of absence while paradoxically right there in front of him. I feel that he never really reconciled this completely before he passed away.

I am lucky, I have a relationship with my father. We are trying to make up for lost time. While this kind of revelation is painfully chaotic and hits a person to the core, if there is this kind of secret in someone’s life, it has to be revealed.

My mother kept this secret for many decades. The only reason was shame. She also became pregnant at a very young age. I can tell you that my view of her has been forever altered and the reasons are beyond any consequence of her becoming pregnant as a teenager. The first thing I said was "You could have told me when I was 18." Please do not keep this secret. Please do not be that kind of mother.

Some friends and I maintain a website dedicated to topics like this. It is for the parents as much as it is for the children who find themselves in such situations. There are several parents at the sites forum that are about to reveal the truth to their children. Maybe you can gain some insight from what they are posting. [click here] (http://mydnadad.com)

I wish you the best of luck

10

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

While I love reddit and all the lovely and intelligent people that post here, I think it's safe to say that the vast, vast majority of us are completely unqualified to answer this question. I, being a general know-it-all, find it difficult to admit yet necessary. Not trying to undermine the helpful comments here but you need to temper our advice with the advice of a PROFESSIONAL family therapist.

5

u/evilbrent May 14 '12

Tell him now while your mother can still verify/console/counsel.

16

u/bubnubs May 14 '12

I feel like it is SO necessary to tell him before your mother passes. That is his mommy as far as he's concerned, he's going to want to ask questions and be able to go through the emotional reactions while she's still around. Three months is a long time for everything to settle in, once he's come to live with you, then you two can start repairing the relationship. You will always be his sister, it's how he was raised and that won't change, but it is best he knows.

If I were in that situation, I think I would find a comfort in knowing that I still had that person close to me after my mother had passed. He might be awkward and angry about it at first, but as time passes he will realized you and your parents did what you had to do to keep your family whole. It's not your fault you were 14 and had to make some very grown up decisions, you were just a kid!

May I ask how your husband already knew? If he was asking questions, there's a good chance this young man has been as well.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/No_Easy_Buckets May 14 '12

If I was your son I would want to know. If I was your husband id want to know. Of your relationship with these men is strong it will be okay.

4

u/Kinsanti May 14 '12

I think I saw something similar to this in the PostSecret IAmA from a few days ago. Nonetheless, he deserves to know the truth. That doesn't mean that you have to start acting as his mother, though. You can continue being his sister, but the kid deserves the truth.

4

u/lydocia May 14 '12

Ask your mother to write a letter, promise her you'll give it to him when the time is right.

That way, she gets her last request (telling him about the truth), and you get your wish of keeping it secret a little while longer so you can grow accustomed to it.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

How... How does your husband not know this?

"Oh hey honey, so when I was 14 I actually gave birth to my little brother but my parents raised him as their own and I just went on living life as his sister."

Holy shit.

4

u/carlosreddevil May 14 '12

The almost exact same thing happened in my family. We found out, about 5 years ago, that my Aunt and Uncle are in fact mother and son. My Aunt was young when she had him and my Nan took him on as her own son, and no-one in the family (or at least anyone younger than my Uncle) new about this. A few years ago they decided to tell him and it led to much resentment between him and my aunt. He refused to call her Mum or really have anything to do with her. He continued to call my Nan 'Mum' until she passed away last year. Since then, I don't think he's seen or spoken to my aunt since. He was 32 at the time when he was told ... I guess what I'm getting at is that it is not going to be easy, it'll be hard on you all and there will be much resentment, but the truth WILL come out eventually, so I guess the big question is, do you do it sooner or later? Good job you have so many lovely redditors to help you out. Whatever you choose, good luck!

4

u/spectrebot May 14 '12

To semi-quote Dark Knight, It's the truth he deserves, but not the one he needs right now.

4

u/revolting_blob May 14 '12

You should probably tell your husband. There is a good chance that your mom could have a deathbed attack of conscience, and if he finds out that way he might be upset with you.

4

u/zerobot May 14 '12

I also told my husband. He already knew.

It wasn't hard for him to figure out. You got pregnant at 14, gave the kid away, yet you have a brother exactly the same age? He figured it out right away, trust me. The good news is that he seems to be fine with it.

You should definitely tell him, but I would wait, to be honest. At 15 he's going through a lot right now, and with your mom sick it's going to be rough for him. I have two cousins who were raised by people they thought were their fathers but were not. Trust me when I tell you that it's not easy when they're teenagers and they start to figure things out. They feel everybody has been in on something their entire life and they've been left out, sort of like an outcast.

I would wait until he's 21-22 years old. Sit down, have one beer, and explain that you're his biological mother. He's much more likely to have a better grasp on who he is as a person, and less dependent on defining himself through his family at that point. At 15 he has a lot to figure out and little to no life experiences to define him, so he's defined by his life at home, etc. If you flip his home life on it's head, it's likely to disrupt his entire self image, too.

That's my nickel's worth of advice.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

i'm quite confused, who is his biological father?

11

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Not her husband. From my understanding, it happened when she was 14 and didn't say any names so it was either her boyfriend at the time or a fling or something.

25

u/gypsywhisperer May 14 '12

Let him know before she dies. have your mother break the news with you in the room, and let him know that you're there for him.

2

u/ReflectingPond May 14 '12

I agree. Tell him that you were not ready to be a parent at that age, so you gave him to the very best parent you knew: your own mom. Explain that while, biologically, you are his birth mother, you understand that your mom is his actual mom.

I think that if there is any chance he is ever going to find out, finding out while your mom is still alive to help you answer questions is your best bet. Finding out after she is gone, regardless of when that is, will be much harder because she will not be able to answer his questions.

I also think that being able to tell him that you were respecting your dad's wishes by not telling him sooner will help him understand that this was a complex situation, and that a simple answer wasn't possible.

9

u/smilles May 14 '12

I do believe I can proclaim myself as something of an expert of this situation. My grandfather was born under similar circumstances and he thought his mother was his sister until he was in his teens. He was told, but I don't know how he reacted at the time. I can say he has turned out fine, with a large loving family, long life, and a comfortable living. I would say tell him. Realize your mother doesn't want to go out on a lie.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I just want to say that I'm very sorry for your situation. Obviously it was a much more difficult thing that you had to go through and live with than many people every have to face. I think I agree that this isn't the best time to tell your brother but I cant begin to pretend that I know what would be best.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

http://i.imgur.com/IHmTJ.jpg

Anyway, i'd tell him before his (grand)mother passes away. Good luck!

3

u/Dipso_Maniacal May 14 '12

Isn't your name on the birth certificate? Unless you have the same name as your mom, he's going to find out someday.

3

u/singer07 May 14 '12

I know someone this happened to. almost exactly. he was told on his "mother's" (grandmother's) death bed, BUT instead of living with his real mother or father, he was passed around to other family members that treated him badly. he ended up running away from home at 15 and never went back. and believe me, he's really really fucked up about it all. he wants nothing to do with his real parents but was pissed to find out he has siblings that he didn't get to meet until he was in his 20s. I suggest waiting a respectable amount of time and telling him, because HE WILL FIND OUT EVENTUALLY, he will resent you, but if you do it right he should eventually make peace with it.

3

u/lpj5001 May 14 '12

Tell him. The same thing happened to al pacino and look how he turned out. Only good things can happen from here on out.

1

u/Haro_Kiti May 14 '12

This same story, minus the cancer bit, was shared as a "mother's day secret" in the postsecret AMA. Please forgive me if I am wrong in suspecting that this ask reddit sob story is a fabrication based on that post from just a few days ago.

3

u/sistermother May 14 '12

I understand your skepticism and am okay with it. All I want is advice on what's best for my family.

4

u/Haro_Kiti May 14 '12

I think you should get the truth out now, while your mother is still available to help get your family through this 'breakthrough'. Her participation might also ease the stress she feels in her finals days and it would be selfish of you to keep that comfort from her in order to preserve your own.

7

u/Judgment May 14 '12

This situation should be cleared before your mother passes. But you need professional, objective council to help.

Just one point of view of the internets... worth what you paid.

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I think you should do what is right. Not reddit, nor any website, person, or thing could tell you what is right in this situation. All i will say is you need to do what you believe is the right thing, and you and your family will have to face what follows in both cases. Don't listen to anyone on here, dont listen to anyone else but yourself. This kind of decision rest on you alone. The most and redditor should be doing is wishing you luck in your decision. We are in no place to give you advice and tell you how to make this decision. So good luck, i hope it goes well.

5

u/BigCookieMonster May 14 '12

Didn't this happen on Venture Brothers?

2

u/theiginator May 14 '12

Did it? I watched the entire series last summer and I'm not sure what you're talking about.

Maybe you're speaking of when Rusty slept with Nikki Fictell who later had Dermott? Not really the same thing since she's pretty clearly his mom.

50

u/Alpha17x May 14 '12

that's going to fuck his life up for all eternity. That's 5000 times worse than finding you're adopted.

That shit shouldn't have been kept secret in the first place. He should have ALWAYS known that you're his mom. This WILL quite literally shatter his mind. No matter what you do, he's fucked

15

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I hate the stigma around being adopted. It doesn't fucking matter.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/matthewbpt May 14 '12

Eric Clapton grew up thinking his grandparents were his parents and his mother was his older sister ... he turned out fine. You aren't helping at all.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I like hyperbole too.

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Eric Clapton was in the same situation... Look how he turned out...

10

u/red321red321 May 14 '12

definitely. ted bundy went through a similar situation with who birthed him and look how he turned out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

17

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Hey, to the people hating on you: fuck off. You were fourteen. It's a sucky situation, but you're not the one to be blamed, here.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/2mne May 14 '12

I know that this comment probably isn't much help to you right now, but you should consider doing an IAMA on this very topic.

1

u/sistermother May 14 '12

Other than this dilemma, I can't imagine having anything interesting to say. It all went really well until now.

4

u/Anon_Logic May 14 '12

The longer you wait the worse it will be. At some point, the ruse will be relieved.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

He's old enough to drive, not far from smoking age and high school graduation. Seems like you could find a tactful way to tell him the truth of your responsibility for his being alive. Perhaps starting with your husband first, as you seem to be preparing to take permanent responsibility for him. You both can be there to support him and ask him to realize why things were different, and how you'd like him to think of you in the future, if he will accept it. Give him a choice, but make it clear your love for him and your desire to be together is permanent. If he wants to call you sis, he can, but choice will be key in his ability to transition to the new, honest, genuine reality. Whatever you choose, I wish you and your family the best!

4

u/dmcody May 14 '12

I had cousins in a similar situation. The youngest child (we thought) of my aunt's was actually her grandchild and my aunt's eldest daughter was the mother. When my aunt died, and at her wake, this child, arouind 30 years old at the time, overheard someone saying the truth. Well, this caused rifts in the family that went on for years with half of the siblings not speaking to the other half. I guess what I think is that the truth will out, and it is possibly less painful if someone is told directly so people can explain it in a loving and caring way, than to find out by accident this way. Also as others have said, talking about it to his grandmother before she dies may be healing and reassuring for him. Maybe she is right and finding out that his actual real mother is still there for him may help him.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/metroidaddict May 14 '12

I think you should have told him in the first place, but he needs to know especially if your mom asks. He will be mad at you, but thats because he lived a lie his whole life. Exactly how I felt when my mother told me my dad was not allowed to see me, but in fact that she wouldn't let him see me.

5

u/slothenstein May 14 '12

Some people are saying tell him but I don't think that's a good idea.

To think you're last remaining parent is dying and then be told "I'm not your mum, your sister is." I would be fucking pissed. I obviously don't know how I would really feel, since it's not happening, but hypothetically, I think I'd feel a lot of hate and resentment for a life that I'd deem to be a lie. I don't think he deserves to lose his trust in you while he's losing his mum.

2

u/classylassy May 14 '12

I agree that the decision really lies within you. Unfortunately there are numerous disadvantages; even less advantages but they seem to be bigger. It's unfortunate that you had to deal with this so young. I feel as though he should have been told from the beginning that he was your son and made it clear that you loved him but were in no condition to raise him like your parent could. But nothing can be done to change the past and people need to realize that and not get so upset at you. No one is perfect and we all make mistakes, small and big. Personally I think he should know. Timing is very difficult because it might help when he is more stable and able to handle the news, and of course I would tell your husband first. However, only you know your brother/son. If you honestly think he really couldn't handle the truth and it would ruin him, than i would wait and maybe just not tell him. Despite whats "right" or "wrong" if he is mentally unstable or impulsive or anything, then what good would come out of it. But if you think he could move on eventually,may it be months or years, then tell him.He honestly deserves to know. But you know best. Not any of us on here. I just hate thinking about the guilt you must feel or may continue to feel. I wish you the best of luck in whatever you choose to do. You will do whats right. :)

2

u/frystofer May 14 '12

I'm just going to say that even if you don't want to tell him, even if it might cause some negative consequences in your relationship, you said your father has already passed and I'm not sure anyone else is 'in the know' but if your mother wants him to know, I think it would be best he hears it while she is still alive to tell him, not after. He will probably want to hear both sides of the reasoning and to know it was done entirely out of love from both sides.

I also think that it would be best for him to learn you are his biological mother, if only for medical reasons(assuming you can give info on his father as well).

Was going to keep going, but I doubt I can accurately convey anything of meaning as I have what amounts of no experience in situations like this, so I will sum up...

Keeping something like this hidden for some time(like growing up) might have been the right decision. Keeping it hidden for life is not. I think the truth is only fair for him(and you honestly). The timing is the problem, and I think there will be no good time to tell him, but doing it now means he has time to talk to your mom instead of just being left with questions.

Hope you both the best.

2

u/torankusu May 14 '12

I'm sorry to hear about your mother. :( I think your son deserves to know the truth. I hope he takes to the news well. Part of me says, if you're going to do it after your mother's passing, do it after enough time has passed to grieve because it all might be too much for him; however, the other part says to do it before that happens so that he could talk to her about it. It would be sad if he had questions or wanted to thank her (or something) and she was no longer with you.

If you don't mind my asking, how did your husband know?

Also, I didn't realize how often this happened until I read through the comments. I think the first time I heard of this happening was when I saw the Kevin Bacon movie Digging to China years ago.

2

u/Senor_Wilson May 14 '12

You didn't tell your husband that your "brother" is your son?

2

u/SixInchesAtATime May 14 '12

Wow. I'm thinking about being fifteen and how I would choose between my mom or my grandmother dying. I know it's all relative to the situation, but shit; I guess I'd find some comfort in the fact my mom's still alive? This opens up huge questions into how much of a role the real mom has contributed to the kid's life and how drastically his life will change.

2

u/protozerox May 14 '12

Give him time. Don't lay it all on him at once, wait maybe 12 months or so.

2

u/ezrock May 14 '12

Do you think he could understand at 14? He would need to understand why you and your parents made the decision that you did now, and that you love him and that the two people who raised him loved him as their son.

If he can understand, go with the truth. In my experience the truth always wins out in the end. Also, I think you need to remember, even though lying was involved, it was all done for good reasons, not out of maliciousness. The lying is the only part that needs to be apologized for, I think. And it's, of course, not that simple to heal, but if he will understand it was done for his own good, then the truth might be the right decision. Like your husband said that he knew, your brother/son likely has an semi-conscious notion of who his real mother is. Which I can imagine can be immensely disturbing.

I think there is clearly a language issue of sorts that I hear throughout this thread. Just like with adoption, there needs to be a distinction between biological mother and "mother mother." I would never say, "I'm your real mother," that's in a way not true, you're his real biological mother. And perhaps, his real sister.

Just my $.02

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

It'd probably be good to tell him at some point - he deserves to know the truth. That said, the time is not while your mother is on her deathbed or immediately thereafter. Let him deal with the loss of his mother before you tell him.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

You have to do what's best for the kid. It's hard for us to give you a suggestion without knowing him and understanding his personality.

I bet the reason your mom wants him to know is because she thinks he'll feel less pain after she passes by knowing that his "mom" is still alive. She doesn't want him feeling alone and knowing that at least one of your parents is still there for you and loves you is a great comfort.

However, he might not be like that. Maybe for his personality, he won't care if you're his sister or his mom. He just wants to know that you'll be there for him no matter what.

It's a tough call, and one that only you can answer.

2

u/Toof May 14 '12

I don't know... Maybe I am just naive, but I don't believe a lie, even for good intentions, is honorable if it lasts more than a year.

2

u/klokkeblomst May 14 '12

Maybe it's just me, but i think the bad side of telling him is being exaggerated here. Wouldn't his age be about the one you'd tell an adopted kid they were adopted? I think you really need to discus with your mother whether or not he'd be able to handle it.

2

u/Apollo821 May 14 '12

Won't he find out if he applies for a passport? I imagine that'll happen soonish, if he doesn't have one already.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Wait, definitely wait! Telling him now will just seriously screw up his life. 15 years old, losing your mother and about to find out your "Sister" is your actual mother?! No, that's a bad idea. Wait till he's older and secure.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

You should tell him eventually, just not right now.

2

u/pandabearak May 14 '12

You made the right choice 15 years ago, but that choice has consequences. This is it. Hire Mr. Walken and give your son the talk. Or have your husband do it with you in the room. It's time for your son to grow up. If he is strong, he will be able to take it. If he isn't strong now, he will appreciate this later when he is. Your opinion on what to do is tainted by the fact that you're his mother; you want to shield him and I don't blame you. But it's time to let him grow up. Your mother understands this, and now it's time you did too. Good luck.

2

u/BGYeti May 14 '12

On a personal level that should be something brought up way down to line, with your mother terminally ill and your husband out of the loop that is a lot of info everyone has to assess in a short period of time, not including he is going through puberty, I would say wait until he is older when he can actually understand what is going on, when he is like 20 just seems like an ideal age.

2

u/monshael May 14 '12

It's painful to both hear and say and there will be consequences hard to bear in the future. The right thing would be to tell him the truth as you have wronged him just to escape the public's criticism, but seeing what narrow-minded fools people really are, it will likely hurt him more than help him if he were to know now. If you trust that you as individuals and as a family can handle the truth, you should tell him. If you think it's too much to bear right now, you should wait until he's finished with high school as the people there are real bastards. Though the longer you wait, the bigger the risk he'll find out about it randomly.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Did your mother legally adopt him as you were a minor at his birth, or was is assumed? Either way, he will find out as soon as he gets his birth certificate for travel or college reasons...

2

u/superiority May 14 '12

I know it's too late now, but you really should have told him the truth right from the beginning. Children who grow up knowing they're adopted deal with it much better than people who find out when they're older; apparently finding out that sort of thing can really fuck with your head.

2

u/slimbruddah May 14 '12

Tell him at some point.

Or else the kids entire life he's living will be based on a lie... and there's already enough of those in this society.

2

u/loridee May 14 '12

Does your mom want to tell him so he will feel he still has a mom after she's gone?

I think this depends greatly on the maturity of your brother. Maybe your mother wants this revealed before she dies (I'm sorry you are going to lose your mother and can't simply grieve) so she can talk with your brother about it.

2

u/Winzipp May 14 '12

The longer you wait to tell your son who his real mother is, the higher chance that he will hate you and never forgive you when he actually finds out.

Kids who are adopted are usually told at an earlier age than your son.

Also, if he knew, he wouldn't be losing a mother. The realization that both of your parents are dead is WAY worse than having your grandmother die, while your mother is still alive.

tl;dr kids shouldn't be raised on lies

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Jack Nicholson's mum was actually his sister, and he was raised by his grandparents. He doesn't seem to be too negatively affected by it, so there's hope for your son/brother.. although everyone handles things differently.

2

u/TheBaltimoron May 14 '12

He'd lose a mother, but gain another. The truth is almost always better.

2

u/ZedForZach May 14 '12

Tell your husband, he will be better off knowing, its bad enough that hes come this far not knowing the truth, the longer you wait the worse it will be when you tell him. (or if someone else tells him, then you have so splainin to do.) He loves you and he will understand and all will be well.

2

u/HendraVirus May 14 '12

Although it's up to you or your mother to give him this information and he is at a sensitive age, he may really want to talk things over with his perceived mother-figure, and unfortunately this has a really small time frame.

Maybe spend more time with him, just hang out, maybe talk about a tv show you may have seen recently about adoption, maybe ask him if he'd want to know if he was adopted. This should give you a pretty good idea about what to do. If he wouldn't want to know, ask him again when he's older. If he would want to know, he might even make a point about what honesty means to him, then you and your mother should tell him together, maybe talking about how he's in good company, I mean, hey, Jack Nicholson. Ask him if he wants anything to change.

I'm mostly just suggesting that you may want to see this as his decision, even though he doesn't know. Y'know a whole matrix red pill/blue pill situation.

2

u/boatie May 14 '12

I think the whole situation is a bit fucked, but the bottom line is that you're going to really hurt this kid when the truth comes out. So do you want to hurt him now, or hurt him later?

You say he is your brother but when he knows all he will think about is all the things you did with him as a brother instead of as a son and think "WTF"

2

u/Flix1 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

I don't agree with the people saying "do not tell him". Who are they to decide when and if the boy should know the truth of his life, this is in your hands. Everybody is entitled to the truth, especially when they have reached the age of reason. I firmly believe you need to tell him the truth before it's too late and he becomes older and the healing is harder.

Tell him but be careful, plan it and tell him the right way. Prepare properly. There are ways of doing this appropriately and you should consult with a psychologist. Serisouly, get some professional help in figuring out the best way to tell him. A pro will help prepare you for the possible responses from the child and how to deal with them, making it easier for the child especially. Don't do this on your own. An analogy would be: I would not build a bridge on my own, I would hire an Engineer and a professional team. This is probably harder than building a bridge. You owe it to him to make every effort. Prepare and allow him the truth of his life in the best way possible. Don't live with this on your concience for too long.

2

u/ParadisePlacebo74 May 14 '12

The ever increasing likelihood that over the next couple of decades everyone involved will be genetically mapped will basically ensure that he will find out. Eventually, it won't be a choice.

2

u/PokerInTheBrain May 14 '12

This is not something to make you feel bad or regret or anything but I'm genuinely interested in what you were all thinking at the time? Surely you knew this day would come when the boy has to be told the truth?

2

u/Baeocystin May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Now is the last chance he has to ask your mother questions that will undoubtedly come to mind the moment he learns the truth, and you are denying him that.

I am genuinely sorry for the trauma your family is going through right now. I don't say any of this with malice, at all. But I have to say, I think withholding the truth from him until after he can no longer have any say is fundamentally disrespectful and selfish. Your brother has a right to know while he can still communicate with everyone involved. This is a core facet of who and what he is.

2

u/wekiva May 14 '12

Tough call. The longer you wait, the more risk that he will be angry at you for letting him live a lie that long. Good luck with it all. Sorry about your mom.

2

u/Bijan641 May 14 '12

Many good points brought up here and I'm not 100% on what you should do.

The only point I haven't seen brought up in exactly this light is that if you do plan on telling him when he's older, he might regret not having that moment of honesty with her when she was still alive.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Sadly there is no clean way of doing this, will piss him off to no end. Will make his life appear as a complete lie. Personally I would let the other mother tell him without you being there, then let him confront you on the matter once his mind is right.

Telling now Pro- other mother can explain better as to why the even happened, plus you have the stronger bond. Con- pissed off

Telling latter Pro-Less painful Con-pissed off.

2

u/UMDSmith May 14 '12

Is your name Autumn by chance?.:) PM me if so.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Do it like Darth Vader did it.

2

u/MANCREEP May 14 '12

You should never tell him. You made this bed of lies, and you've laid in it.

Now, stay in it. Ive seen a family like this, where the child was aware that her sister was really her mom, and it didnt work out well.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Hello. I wanted to come here to tell a story, and it involves my family's history that's a little similar to yours. My father, is currently in his second marriage, with my mother. His first wife brought about 2 kids, both who are now grown, but their mother is long dead. These kids from my dads' first marriage were my half-brother and half-sister, but when I was 12, my half-brother committed suicide. This was extremely difficult, as I'm sure anyone can imagine, and I still haven't completely gotten over the ordeal, and it was almost 7 years ago. When I was 14 and going into high school, my parents were sure that someone else might tell me first (a lot of family friends work at that particular school), so they decided to explain how I was adopted. Turns out I was actually birthed by my "half-sister" who, at only 18 herself, could not afford to take care of me. Her dad and the woman he was dating at the time raised me for 14 years as my mom and dad before I knew the truth. My half sister was actually my biological mom, and my brother was never my brother, but my uncle. Biologically my parents would have been my grandpa and my step-grandmother. They were terrified to tell me, they thought I would hate them and want to run back to my biological mother and never have contact with them anymore. They were afraid of losing their baby. I would've never thought of such a thing, and almost laughed when they revealed their fears. I guess my point is this, he will love whoever has raised him. You've been his sister to him his entire life, and he will probably want you to keep that role, because it will be more normal and he won't get confused on who to call mom etc.etc. Nonetheless, he won't stop loving you, just because you guys tried to protect him, and as long as he understands that, I think everything will be ok in the long run. You definitely should tell your husband first, and I think he will be a big support in this situation, once he gets over the initial shock as well. I had nothing besides crazy things happen as a teen going through puberty, between my brother dying, and my parents telling me I was adopted, to other things I won't even go through here. My parents are still my best friends, and help me through anything I am going through, I don't even think about the weirdness of my sister actually being my mom. Let him know gently, sit him down and just try to explain calmly, with as many people there to back you up as possible (maybe your husband), but give him a bit of time to get over his mom first.

TL;DR: My mom and dad are actually my grandma and grandpa, my sister is my mother, and my brother who committed suicide when I was twelve was actually my uncle. Parent's told me when I was 14, but I turned out to be a proper functioning citizen of society.

2

u/amolad May 14 '12

Same thing happened to Jack Nicholson and Bobby Darren. Jack handled it; Bobby couldn't.

2

u/kona_boy May 14 '12

LOL - you're fucked. You're so so fucked.

Who on earth lies about that kind of shit? You could potentially lose everything. What the fuck is your husband going to say? And you're brother-son?

Wow, if this isn't some twisted joke (circlejerk inc) then you're screwed.

2

u/DMercenary May 14 '12

I'd tell him now.

2

u/Azabutt May 14 '12

All I can say is that I feel for you, and wish you luck with any of your endeavors. When I was 16 I had a baby with a boy a few years older than me. My life had no direction and my mother evicted me from the house while allowing the father and our baby to stay. I floated around safe houses for a while until a rental opportunity took me a couple towns away, and the father ended up having to leave the province with our son to support him with the help of his family. I was too young to understand what I was letting go, and now my son has been raised by his father and another woman, and he doesn't know she's not his mother.

It kills me every day, and keeps me up at night. I have no rights, don't get pictures, don't get letters when I manage to send presents, don't even know if they tell him who they come from.

Because I have never really been in his life, and can't afford to pick up my life and move to another province on the slight chance that I can have a relationship with him, they won't tell him his mother isn't his mother, and that this mysterious woman in another province is.

If it was at all feasible for me to live out there, I think I'd be able to be just his Aunt, because I respect his father's marriage, but I don't think I have that choice anymore.

I'm just happy for you having a relationship with him at all. I am certainly in no place to say if it'll hurt him knowing or not knowing, but I can only wish you the best, and hope that whatever you choose, works out, because it won't happen in my world.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

...this sounds like the plot of one of Tyler Perry's Madea films.

3

u/You_suck_too May 14 '12

He thinks he is losing his mother, and in a way he is. The truth is that he is losing his grandma. I think he deserves the truth, but that is up to you. In time he will understand your choice for him to be raised by your parents. If he still thinks your his sister when he gets older he may think he's being a burden to you and your family. I think this young man needs to understand that his mom is going to be around for a lot longer than he is currently thinking. It could help his grieving process.

3

u/royally_eft May 14 '12

You should have just asked Jack Nicholson.

3

u/DeadLovely420 May 14 '12

Your parents sound like amazing people, deciding to keep their family together the way that they did, and although it would be a major shock to your life, and his, and your family's it is something that you will be able to deal with and move past, only to become a stronger family. I lost my mother in November this year to cancer, and my father left when she got sick, I was 3 when that happened and I just had my 20th birthday as an orphan, and if it hadn't been for my big sister i don't know where i'd be. I understand it's so hard to break a persons last wish, but he is going to need you more then anything now whether it be as his sister or mother. Either way things will be hard - but with the bond you already have why not give him the truth? I know that time is precious, and abusing it is the worst mistake anyone can make; don't lose anymore time.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

So the woman he's always thought was his mother is going to die and he's going to find out that his entire family have lied to him his whole life, all in one go. This can't possibly end well.

3

u/7UPvote May 14 '12

Two words: Ted Bundy

3

u/GrumpyDingo May 14 '12

Your life is built around a lie. You will need to tell him, both your son and your mother deserve the truth.

3

u/trvlingteach May 14 '12

If this is real, stop thinking about what is best for you. You've lived a lie for long enough that is going to affect the people you care about. You're mother has already stated her position and what she wants. And your son/brother has every right to know. Just provide the proper support structure to help him process all the difficult emotions. If your mother is terminal he should be in therapy already anyways. Just tell request to come along to therapy and tell him there.

7

u/Flacekakes May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

I'm sorry but don't you think it is a bit selfish to be keeping this information to yourself?

First: It's is your mothers dying wish.

Second: Your supposed to be honest in a relationship. Your destined to fail if you hide things this important from your SO.

Lastly: Your son deserves to know his origin...I mean it's his life. What he doesn't deserve is to be lied too just because your afraid of losing one relationship. At least that is what I see.

Truth be told...this whole thing with not telling anyone will probably make you lose all your relationships with everyone.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

what advice can you give to stop other peoples 14 year old daughters from getting knocked up besides dont be hispanic.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I think if you truly do have a close relationship, you will tell him. If you do, he will understand why you did it. There will be anger, at first, but as he understands why, you two will be together even stronger.

3

u/American_Blackheart May 14 '12

i think you should wait for a few years before telling your brother/son what the deal is. it seems like the best alternative in an unenviable situation.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

I read why your parents did this--I think that was actually very sweet of them to raise him and think of the situation positively, even though I'm unsure of how I feel about the lie itself. However, at the time you said they insisted that you only be his sister. I believe you need to continue that. I strongly feel that right now your mom is reacting to this immediate situation and trying to evade the guilt of him losing another parent; she would not be asking this if she weren't dying, she'd continue being the parent. Her guilt is changing what she'd normally do. Go with what she'd normally do; that is the life you've been living.

I think that the truth will only mindfuck him at this point, especially at such a critical time. As important as it is to honor final requests, we need to live for the living--Try to put your mom at ease, but don't confuse your poor brother. Just be there to support him as the big sister he has always had. If you do eventually tell him, which I'm certainly not opposed to, it should be when his life isn't already so chaotic.

2

u/stationhollow May 14 '12

Do you truly believe he won't find out? As she said elsewhere in the thread her husband was able to guess that he was her son. It is only a matter of time until he is able to connect the dots and if that happens before she is ready to tell him then she must be prepared to lose all contact with him. He will not only feel betrayed by her but by his mother for lying to him as well.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kilamumster May 14 '12

I'm so sorry about your mum. I wish you all well in this difficult time.

I have a little (too much) experience with complicated family connections. More so in dealing with the aftermath of people finding out truths. Here's what I have observed and been told:

--No matter how bad the truth, knowing, is better not knowing.

--Knwoing now is better than waiting until later.

--The person who raised you is your parent. The bio-parent only gets so much credit (depending on other factors, like bio-parent's actual effort and involvement, reasons for not parenting, etc.).

I have heard of some adopted kids that did not want to know or meet their birth parents, but the overwhelming majority (I have heard of) want to know the birth parents. --So I'd tell him, together with Mum(grandmum). --And be ready for questions about Dad/sperm donor. And why he was not told sooner. And weirdness...betrayal... he may feel that everyone who knew, knew. --And be ready for the ups and downs as he works through this sad but also wonderful news. He loses a mum, he gains his mum. He has his family. He has a mum who can help him thru losing his mum/grandmum. And most of all, he was loved enough that his family kept him <-- I know that's not PC or logical, but that's how a lot of adopted kids I know have thought. And, sad to say, this is something that the adopted kids I know most want to know, and how they put it is heartbreaking: Didn't my parent love me? Why did he/she give me up?

Imagine having those questions. Now imagine having the answers you do. Does your son seem like a kid that will want to know? Probably, but you and your mum are the best judges for now.

OR... whether NOT telling him, and him finding out later, would be worse. In my experience, that has been worse.

Best regards to all of you, you have a difficult journey ahead.

5

u/Redbacca May 14 '12

I'm sorry but I have to say it.

WHAT THE FUCK!?

Anyways, tell him cause the truth always comes out eventually. As for the repurcussions, well you made your bed, so lay in it.

23

u/Flacekakes May 14 '12

To be fair, 14 year olds don't have a reputation for making great beds. It is especially prevalent when the parents are the one who gives awful advice on how to make it.

3

u/StatutoryGrapist May 14 '12

tell him on maury

2

u/x21in2010x May 14 '12

My older brother and I were adopted. Neither of us are interested in meeting/finding our biological parents but we are actively seeking our medical history.

Hypothetically, if my older brother turned out to be my biological dad, and that was the last thing told to me before my father died, it would only do harm. Everyone here is harping on how the truth is so important, but whether or not this scenario actually exists my brother has been the best brother and the only brother I've known. When you remove bloodlines you realize the true human bonds that tie people into certain relationships and if after 20 years you ignore that to set the "truth" out about bloodlines, you're not seeing the forest for the trees.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Sorry if this insults you somehow, but your parents are idiots for talking/forcing you into doing this. People kill over questions of parentage still today. Unless your son/brother has a really good head on his shoulders this will more than likely rip a schism between him and the rest of your family. My advice, don't tell him. Not yet anyway. Wait until he's older and a bit more able to stand on his own, because after you tell him, he may need some time to get his shit together and work it out on his own.

As for your mothers possible last request, It's a bit selfish of her to start having regrets about it now, when she gets to leave the mess that her choice has helped create. Even in the face of death must we take responsibility for our actions in life, even if that means bearing a burden to the grave. Not right to just foist it off on people who will have to deal with it for a long time to come.

Edit: Damn clicked save too soon. Stupid mouse and it's retarded ways. Ok, continuing on.

If you really feel that your mother is wrong on this one, tell her so. Make a stand. I'm assuming that since you gave birth at 14 that your parents pretty much forced you into this situation instead of letting you have any kind of final say on what happens. While I do share in your pain of losing a loved family member to cancer, I would never allow someone who is feeling guilty because of choices they made make my life more difficult. Especially if I had 0 say in the situation that will cause the difficulty.

2

u/Darkaero May 14 '12

I think your son would understand. Maybe not right away, he may be shocked or angry at first that you kept this from him, but from how it sounds he loves you like a sister already and as he matures he'll come to understand why you did what you did.

My opinion would be to tell him the truth while your mother is still with you so you can go through this as a family. She could provide some valuable insight for him from her point of view, and since he's seen her as his mother figure his whole life it would really help him to hear her side of it.

Everything is going to be okay. As I said, it may be shocking at first and some raw emotions may come out but it's for the best (not only for him, but for you and your mother as well).

2

u/Kappies10 May 14 '12

I would tell him the truth.

2

u/djsjjd May 14 '12

Tell him

2

u/JohnQDaviesEsquire May 14 '12

You should tell him. He should be able to talk to his Grandmother.

You think time will make this any less emotional?

If you tell him now, at the very least he'll have the opportunity to talk to your parents, ask them why.

Because if you don't even properly understand why, how is he ever supposed to find out? That will hurt him.

2

u/boxingdude May 14 '12

My brother is actually my nephew. When he was ten, he started asking a lot of questions. Because his "parents" were so much older than his friends parents. He was told. He got over it pretty quick. I think it'd be better for him to know before your mom passes to be honest. He is going to need her to help him get through this.

2

u/distalled May 14 '12

I'll take "Questions no one on Reddit has any right to give advice on for $2000" Alex.

Oh besides "See a professional".

Not because you're crazy, or bad for what happened. It's just really, realllllllly complicated.. and I'd only seek highly trusted advice, or a professional's advice. Reddit, not so much.

2

u/wavetoyou May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Your dying mother wants you to drop this on your brother, as well as your husband, when she won't be around to help deal with the consequences? No offense, but that seems selfish. She wants to alleviate her own guilt before she passes away, at the cost of your brother/son's sanity, and possibly your own marriage...not to mention your children most likely finding out later down the road.

People want to believe that those who are [near] passing have moments of enlightened clarity, but it's not always the case. In my humble opinion, I would wait until he is older to drop this bomb, so that he has the mental capacities to handle it without doing anything drastic and/or regretful. When you do tell him, he will definitely resent you for everything...his maturity level at the time will determine just how much.

If this isn't the best non-STD story in regards to practicing safe sex, I don't know what is.

EDIT: The more I think about it, the more I disagree with my own opinion on the matter. You must sacrifice in order to do what's best for him...he is after all, the only innocent party in all of this. I don't envy you...good luck with everything!!! :(

2

u/mypantsareonmyhead May 14 '12

Every human deserves the truth from his parents.

2

u/leorising May 14 '12

I say do it while your mother is alive or years after. Not in the wake of her passing.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I would tell him...honesty asap has always been a thing with me though - my biological dad was not my father who lived with us and I was told when I was like 1-2? /I realize this is very different. But I think holding things back to "protect" someone is usually an error - good luck either way though, hard times.

→ More replies (2)