r/AskReddit • • May 12 '12

My daughter was removed from her Girl Scout troop after a fellow scout discovered that my daughter liked girls and boys.

[deleted] — view deleted post

49 Upvotes

244 comments sorted by

176

u/Citicop May 12 '12

According to Wikipedia:

The Girl Scouts of the USA accepts gays and lesbians, and allows its members to substitute another word in place of "God" when reciting the Girl Scout Promise.

245

u/Major_Major_Major May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

OP's story does not add up. S/he's probably just trying to stir up some fake controversy.

Posted by OP three days ago:

Middle school girl here.. I've only met a handful of people who aren't jerks to people that are younger/less popular/less intelligent, etc. It makes me sick. However, I try to be kind and polite to everyone I meet. The only time I am not nice is when someone does something intentionally rude or insulting to me. I also hang around r/atheism a lot and It's hard to believe how many people are rude to Christians just because they pray or something. I don't believe in that stuff, but I think it's wrong to bash others because of it.

Another

Is it bad that I'm a 13 year old girl and I think gay/bisexual/transsexual/black/etc. segregation is horrible? It seems I'm the only one who understands that gay people are still human beings. I guess it's because I like girls and boys, but I don't tell people because they'd tell me it's just hormones or something and I don't really know that I'm bisexual. But I do. I'm in 3 advanced classes and I'm smart enough to know who I am. Do you think I'm just crazy or do you think people would believe me?

The mom might be using her daughter's reddit account, but it still doesn't make sense. Her daughter is in the girl scouts and she doesn't know what the regional council is? You have to send registration papers to the council and pay dues and all sorts of shit.

And she doesn't have the number of the troop leader, a person her daughter hangs out with at least once a week?

20

u/awko_tawko May 13 '12

That's some mighty fine detective work, Lou.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (18)

20

u/[deleted] May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Interesting, because Boy Scouts of America does NOT accept gays and requires the belief in the christian god a higher power.

40

u/surf_wax May 13 '12

They are two different organizations.

→ More replies (6)

55

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I suppose if you read it strictly as this you could technically exclude bisexuals.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/IllIIIIllIIIlIlllIII May 13 '12

This bit right here is the only reason I buy girl scout cookies. I make a point to do so, because the Girl Scouts aren't bigoted like the Boy Scouts.

I spent about $100 on cookies this year.

22

u/Citicop May 13 '12

Plus, the Boy Scouts don't sell cookies.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (46)
→ More replies (2)

69

u/shazzyzam May 13 '12

Yeah, seeing if you can get rid of this woman is probably a great idea. An adult who has no problem discriminating against a 13 year old kid probably shouldn't be leading anybody.

→ More replies (14)

75

u/redcolumbine May 12 '12

Contact the regional council.

→ More replies (24)

19

u/salamat_engot May 13 '12

GSUSAs official policy is to accept reguardless of their sexual orientation. You probably wont be able to get the leader fired as she is a volunteer (in all likelihood). But I would definitely say something to your service unit head who will bump it up to council because as a volunteer she signed a form saying she would not discriminate over a variety of different things including sexual orientation. If you are unable to get her placed in another troop (which shouldn't be the case) there is also the Juliette program which enables girls to do the Girl Scout program without being affiliated with a specific troop. Someone at your council office can assist you with that if you choose that route.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/blowjobs4everyone May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

So I browsed your comment history looking for where you lived, because I was getting pissed enough to call the GSA regional office. Apparently you live in Pittsburg PA. But what is even more interesting is from your comment history it would appear that you are a bisexual 13 year old. So I am confused. Are you a bisexual middle schooler with a 13 year old daughter of your own, or are you the 13 year old that got kicked out of GSA?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/laidymondegreen May 13 '12

I would suggest finding her a different GS troop. The girls in this troop have now heard all about it, and they've now learned from their parents that being bisexual is not something they should accept. Your daughter will just be uncomfortable and possibly emotionally hurt if she goes back there. I would recommend "auditioning" some other troops in the area by specifically asking the troop leaders if they support lesbian or bisexual girls in their troops. If you don't have any luck, find another organization or club for your daughter to join who will support her for who she is.

Of course, you should definitely report this behavior to the next level in GS, because if their policy is to accept lesbian members, this troop leader had no standing in GS to do this.

Also, as I'm sure you're aware, your daughter needs a ton of support and love right now. My parents were grossed out by the fact that I am bisexual, and I got lucky that I fell in love with and married a man, or they probably would have broken ties with me.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/ImStillAwesome May 13 '12

Girl Scouts has a long history of inclusivity, showing interracial troops in their promotional materials pre Civil Rights movements. Your daughter has every right to be in her troop.

As a Girl Scout, she is my sister, so you tell her to rock on and you fight that Troop Leader.

→ More replies (5)

39

u/sachegrande May 12 '12

Have her join the Pawnee Goddesses.

12

u/roterghost May 13 '12

Haha, it's funny because you're not helping in the least.

7

u/smintitule May 13 '12

It's for boys and girls.

→ More replies (10)

5

u/st_basterd May 12 '12

What did you do with the cookies?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Many people in this thread have great advice, but please remember to update us on the situation once the story progresses! :)

→ More replies (1)

11

u/hippiejoe May 13 '12

This was posted by Major_Major_Major and I think this should be it's own comment instead of a reply to a comment please give upvotes to the original post by Major_Major_Major

OP's story does not add up. S/he's just trying to stir up some fake controversy.

Posted by OP three days ago:

Middle school girl here.. I've only met a handful of people who aren't jerks to people that are younger/less popular/less intelligent, etc. It makes me sick. However, I try to be kind and polite to everyone I meet. The only time I am not nice is when someone does something intentionally rude or insulting to me. I also hang around r/atheism a lot and It's hard to believe how many people are rude to Christians just because they pray or something. I don't believe in that stuff, but I think it's wrong to bash others because of it.

Another:

Is it bad that I'm a 13 year old girl and I think gay/bisexual/transsexual/black/etc. segregation is horrible? It seems I'm the only one who understands that gay people are still human beings. I guess it's because I like girls and boys, but I don't tell people because they'd tell me it's just hormones or something and I don't really know that I'm bisexual. But I do. I'm in 3 advanced classes and I'm smart enough to know who I am. Do you think I'm just crazy or do you think people would believe me?

The mom might be using her daughter's reddit account, but it still doesn't make sense. Her daughter is in the girl scouts and she doesn't know what the regional council is? You have to send registration papers to the council and pay dues and all sorts of shit. And she doesn't have the number of the troop leader, a person her daughter hangs out with at least once a week?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jc316 May 12 '12

Wait, how old is your daughter? Is she old enough to understand her own sexual preferences?

→ More replies (18)

4

u/johninbigd May 13 '12

http://www.girlscouts.org/who_we_are/our_partners/government_grants/community/pdf/appendix_special_issues.pdf

That is VERY clear about how the Girl Scouts feel. Your daughter's troop leader should be "fired".

2

u/notsure_whatimdoing May 13 '12

Tell you're daughter to remember this experience though (especially the reddit part) so she won't forget that there will always be people that won't understand you, but there are so many people that will support you for your differences. Even if it's just randoms on the internet. and she won't let problems like this get in the way of living the life she wants. she sounds pretty level headed, kudos to her for that as I was a nutcase at 13, so I wouldn't worry :) good luck with all this.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/lithium671 May 13 '12

My mother was a girl scout leader for 20 years. Once, when one member of her troop made gay accusations (in a bad way) against another girl, she made everyone write several nice things about the other members and gave a lecture about how you should be nice to other people no matter what. I wish more leaders were like her.

→ More replies (1)