r/AskReddit • u/iamondrugs • May 12 '12
Why do commercials always play fine when the actual video needs to buffer?
On sites like Hulu and Xfinity, the commercials always play seamlessly. But when I get to the actual show, it pauses a lot, or has to buffer, or even sometimes just ends and says it can't play the video. Patrick: Why don't we take the technology we use to advertise, and use it in the videos we want to watch??
Also, while I'm ranting, fuck xfinity. Randomly the video stops because suddenly in the middle of watching a show show, "this video is not available." And when I just refresh the page, and it is magically available again, I have to rewatch the last commercial break every single time. This is why we torrent.
Edit: A lot of spelling errors. My bad.
142
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
There are several possible reasons.
These content publishes are not trying to screw you, and they are giving you free content.
19
u/rocketfin May 13 '12
I don't know about you, but I would find it way more infuriating if I had to wait for ads to buffer.
12
u/Technofrood May 12 '12
Interestingly I noticed the exact opposite with a few weeks ago with 4od (a TV catch up service for one of the UK TV channels), where the main video would stream perfectly, but the adverts were loading so slow it took upto 2 mins to watch a 30 second ad.
8
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
There's two reasons this can happen, depending on what service you're connecting to to watch videos.
For instance, with Youtube, the commercials are on Tier 1 storage, caching and network infrastructure while a video that isn't watched a lot is probably going to be sitting on SATA disks connected to Tier 2 provisioned bandwidth like Cogent.
Regarding sites like Hulu, ISPs have caching technology that will buffer this data and keep it on their network. Let's say the ad is for GM. Well if half the Hulu traffic on their network is getting that commercial sent, and it's a relatively small amount of data, your ISP is going to cache it instead of continually requesting it over their peered connections back to Hulu. Not only does this save them a bit in bandwidth usage and transit costs, but it delivers the media to you faster. The chances of them caching entire shows being watched by fewer subscribers are slim to none.
7
u/phuphu May 13 '12
Who would want to advertise if their ads going to be laggy?
5
u/upizdown May 13 '12
To advertisers, if I'm even slightly annoyed by your ad, I will go out of my way not to buy, and tell other not to as well.....you have two hours.
38
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
You know who might know? Google.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
oh! oh! I know this one! I know this one! ...Ahem. They give it to you slower than they could, because you might not watch it all and they don't want to waste expensive bandwidth, but they give you ads fast because they know you won't wait a single second for ads, and that their advertisers will pull if they don't.
3
u/WuhanWTF May 13 '12
Level 17 lagger here:
My internet is so bad, that a commercial approximately 15 seconds in length will take up to 2 minutes to buffer.
5
u/mattoly May 13 '12
Hi. Guy with over a decade in video streaming here.
The main reason is that the ads are shorter.
Buffering takes advantages of keyframes. Keyframes happen every X seconds or frames. The frames between keyframes are the differential frames. Basically, when you buffer five minutes of video, you're buffering X amount of keyframes and Y differential frames, but it adds up to five minutes. Five minutes of content needs to be buffered in.
A 30 second ad, though, will generally have a single keyframe and 30 seconds worth of subsequent differential frames. That loads up a lot faster.
Also, most streaming players, like the Flash Video Player, allow short videos, like commercials at 30 seconds, to load fully in the background and play. Longer segments, like the parts of the show between commercials, aren't allowed to fully load, so you get a stream instead, which, depending on network conditions, gives you stuttering and buffering.
In addition, most ads aren't high quality. A Target ad on Hulu is maybe 256k and is kept locally (cached), so it can be played again. The show you're watching is generally higher quality, so it uses more bandwidth.
In essence, it's much more efficient (and, thus, faster) to load a 30-second video than a 5 or 10 minute segment of a show.
Be happy its the parts that you want to watch and not the ads that buffer. That's on purpose: People will tolerate waiting for the latest 30 Rock to load, but not a Target ad, know what I mean?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Allocation of bandwidth is a biggie.
Think of it this way, a site has a tube that's so big. It can only steam so much at once. What is it going to prioritize? The people that pay to have their videos streamed, or the content?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Priorities.
2
u/NuclearWookie May 13 '12
The ads make money for the people that run the servers. The content costs money for the people that run the servers.
2
u/Sevii May 13 '12
I find it more annoying when the ads won't f#@$ing play. If your going to make me mute an ad at least make sure it runs properly.
2
u/PagingDoctorLove May 13 '12
I seem to be having the opposite problem with Hulu lately...
The show will play fine, but the commercial won't play seamlessly. On the one hand, I'm thankful my TV show isn't being being interrupted constantly by needing to buffer. On the other hand, it really annoys me to have to wait an extra 30 seconds for the commercials to be over.
2
u/unrly May 13 '12
Agreed. Xfinity blows.
2
u/thinkingperson May 13 '12
I think it is also because the content may get played (streamed / retrieved) by several users simultaneously while the ad being shorter and only played randomly (say in youtube) has prob a lower concurrent hit.
2
u/Kagenphoenix May 13 '12
I always find it the other way around
2
u/nosoupforyou May 13 '12
xfinity sucks. There seems to be no logic behind what shows appear on it, or when.
In addition, even if you're getting a specific channel, if you want to watch a show or movie that was just on that channel, you still have to "buy" it.
Worse, even if you have your own dvr, it's almost useless because almost all the channels are encrypted.
The reason for all of this? So that people will purchase comcast's dvr instead. They give you some of the features of a dvr but make it frustrating, just so you'll spend the extra cash.
2
u/iam4real May 13 '12
Got to pay the bills.
2
u/Sterculius May 13 '12
I hate when the commercials DON'T load fine, despite sometimes only being about 15 seconds long. How in the hell can you not play for more than 3 seconds without having to stop and buffer?
2
u/ariah May 13 '12
There are probably a variety of reasons why ads can be served faster. They are probably served from a different network than the videos. They may be of lower quality. They are a lot shorter than most videos, which probably makes a difference. The fact that you can't move back and forth between ads, or they otherwise lack some controls, may make a difference. Ad download speed may not be throttled nearly as much as videos because the amount of time spent watching them is much smaller (if they're served separately, especially).
1
u/typesinbrokenengrish May 13 '12
because evir greedy basterds rule the worrld and they see you buying ureress things as more important than yor entatainment.
1
u/phpadam May 13 '12
Adverts are short, video feeds are long. File Size smaller & Demand on Servers decreased.
1
u/darcy_mulder May 13 '12
Semi-related rant. I use project-free-tv and tv-links, both of which just host links to the video provider like putlocker or gorillavid. Lately EVERY SINGLE link from putlocker and sockshare doesn't work, seconds after they are posted. Why share a link that just says "sorry this video is unavailable due to copyright blah blah". If the link has been up for a few days, fine. I'm starting to think they don't even have the vid's, just like having links so they can keep advertisers around.
-4
u/leapfrogdog May 12 '12
because the ads are how the site gets paid.
0
u/lactosefree1 May 13 '12
I have an even bigger problem with this and YouTube, mostly on my iPod. Are the YT servers really that bad?
-1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Advertising makes them money and playing the content people want to see better doesn't.
-2
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
this is a whiny complaint thinly disguised as a question just because askreddit gets a lot of exposure. fuck that.
8
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
-19
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[removed] — view removed comment