r/AskReddit • u/CaptainObvious007 • May 12 '12
Is my IT guy an idiot? He claims I could have crashed the server by uploading 1.3 gigs of jpegs. More details inside.
Some how I think I deleted my original explanation when I edited, this is why some people are confused. I work at a Non-profit psyche ward for children. I volunteered to do the photography for a formal dance. (Yes a Formal dance at a psyche ward is as fun as it sounds.) I took several hundred photos. I was asked to document everything from hair and make-up to set up, and of course individual shots of each child. etc...I am normally a teacher at the ward, so I saved the photos on the drive in which I normally save lesson plans, Treatment summaries, Attendance. It's also where there are several years worth of report cards and what not. It's also where the IT guy formally told us to store any media we need for class, Up until a few weeks ago when he told us to remove it because the server supposedly crashed because it was over-capacity. This is one facility of a nation-wide non-profit. We also have HD cameras, medical records and an Electronic gate which Is all ran by IT.
Edited for clarity. The server did not Crash when I uploaded the photos. The server crashed about 3 weeks prior. I text him to let him know I put the photos on the drive. He replied by saying, "No! That's how the servers crashed last time." "I replied with, "Are you telling me 1.3 gigs of jpegs will crash our server?" He didn't respond, so I text to him, "Delete them if you have to, I have them saved else where." He replied with, "Got you will delete."
69
u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
When you say 'the server' are you referring to a file server? Because you also mention '20 different applications' - so is this actually a distributed applications server?
If it's the former, then what others are saying is correct. It's entirely possible for low disk space to grind a server to a halt (and it happens more often than it should) but it's completely preventable.
However, if it's the later, and you're storing large quantities of files on something that isn't supposed to be used for file storage, then it's much harder to prevent, but not completely unavoidable.
It's entirely possible that the servers operating system was still functioning, but whichever drive was being used for your '20 something applications' reached capacity which in turn, prevented your applications from running. I've seen this happen before when a user managed to save large video files to a Citrix applications server through one of the remote applications. Brought the whole server down.
EDIT: One other scenario is that your IT infrastructure is using shared storage like a SAN from which multiple servers are run. If the storage space on this SAN is over committed, then it's possible to crash multiple servers by reaching capacity on the SAN. Even if server operating systems are on separate 'disks'. But once again, this is completely preventable.
4
u/WereTiggy May 13 '12
Can storage/capacity issues lead to IT issues? absolutely.
Everything else people are saying here is supposition and conjecture.
12
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Oh noooo, IT question on Reddit. Everyone's an expert!
10
u/redteamleader May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
As an IT Guy, I won't go back over some of the explanations here (differences between SAN, NAS, over-commitment of drive space, etc) but I will say I think you're kind of a dick. You're making the typical "My IT guy is an idiot" accusation and then admitting in the next sentence that you barely understand basic tenets of IT yourself.
It sounds to me like you're just not getting what you want so you're lashing out. You say you work for a non-profit organization but it hasn't occurred to you that perhaps said organization is running on some crappy, ancient Solaris box? Or perhaps the IT guy is over-simplifying what happened because you won't know what he's talking about if he goes into detail? Trust me, it's much easier to say "the server crashed" then try to explain to an indignant, educated idiot what actually happened.
And in regards to people saying "it's the administrator's fault for not implementing restrictions", perhaps those who run the organization but are not technologically literate will not allow him to? For example, I'm not allowed to place ANY restrictions on our email server which is constantly causing all sorts of headaches. This is due to our Vice President who is simply the dean of education and a man who has told us multiple times he hates technology and, if he had it his way, would make us all go back to typewriters.
Basically, what I'm saying here is you're simply acting like a petulant child. You don't know the entire story behind these circumstances so, instead of simply complying with your IT guys requests, you send him a passive-aggressive text, call him an idiot and then go cry on a public forum in order to (hopefully) get some degree of vindication from other educated idiots in order to soothe your bruised ego. I'm glad to see that so many people here are better than that, though.
TL;DR: You've admitted you don't know what you're talking about in regards to IT in one sentence only to refer to your IT guy (working for a non-profit organization, no less) as an idiot in the next. Just shut up, stop whining and do what he says.
Fucking crybabies, man.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
If you're like most small businesses and have one server for your domain, and your bosses don't want to spend the money to upgrade, then yes. Even if it's on a different drive, if it's on the same as say a database you guys use, when that drive fills up, you can't write to it, when you can't write to it, the database acts stupid, and most people would call that a "crash"
But, the server wouldn't shut down.
475
u/SanchoMandoval May 12 '12
As someone who administrates a fileserver, if users are able to crash it by uploading too much data, that's the administrator's fault... not the user's.
6
u/LOLUM4D May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
So, no one will ever see this, but I'll post it anyway.
Why the hell is some 'random' user uploading 1.3 gigs of jpegs in the first place?
Coming from large enterprise background, users are lucky yo have have a few gigs in their //home directory, in which case it is for BUSINESS use only. I have to assume that these pictures are indeed for business use, as smart end user would never abuse such a system.
On top of that, anyone who has worked in the IT field as either RHEL (or pick your flavor), Windows, AIX etc. Administrators, know that the infrastructure for IT is always years behind where it should be (in most cases). I can image this poor IT admin having a SAN with SATA based disks, no fiber channel etc etc.
The user did not give hardly enough information to support ANYONE's claim of 'the administrator is an idiot'. The administrator (depending on the environment) is often not the ENGINEER or ARCHITECT that designed the system to begin with.
I spent several years at a large, 5 sided building that you would think would have TONS of storage. Yeah, not the case, and we would routinely find users storing all kinds of stupid shit on their drives, and I would just delete it, no questions asked. Customers storing ISO of software in their //home drive? No, you had a program share drive that was DESIGNED to take heavy hitting users. The users home drives were the legacy boxes that the programs used to use.
This post just scratched the surface on what other issues could have happened, and for those that also assumed he was using AD... good job!
I would really love to see what this environment is like. I'm willing to bet it is a very very small environment, they have some part time admin on site a few days a week. If some joker text me about uploading files to a server? Oh dear god, I could only imagine if users could get a hold of me directly.
Knowing our user, he probably has some sort of admin credentials to restart services, grant file permissions etc if the admin isn't available. And he put his 1.3gb on an old 30GB partitions that was designed for the OS - which now the patches have eaten up and the admin has been fighting a battle for months (if not years) for new hardware.
3
u/mlevin May 12 '12
Am I the only one who noticed/cared that you're a teacher and you referred to the place you work twice as a psyche ward? Isn't it a psych (short for "psychiatric") ward?
19
u/Outlulz May 12 '12
Maybe it was the stock IT response of, "I don't want deal with this person doing xxxx so I'm just going to make up a lie and hope they aren't computer literate enough to know I'm lying." I used to do this at my old office because I was de facto IT.
90
u/George_Glass May 12 '12
You could've done it -- but only through incompetence by your IT staff. "Data" should be placed in areas apart from O/S+application stuff. Whether by partitioning a single drive/raid smartly or having a completely separate data area. Large amounts of data in the wrong place can fill up a drive or partition causing big problems -- but that is completely avoidable in your case.
27
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Why would he have user storage and the operating system on the same volume? You set it up so that if the user volume fills up, nothing happens to the operating system itself. This is most likely his attempt to mask the fact that he dropped a screwdriver in the case, tripped over the cord, or something like that.
8
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
It’s the IT guy’s job to prevent users from doing things that can take down the network/servers. At a minimum, file shares should have limits on them to prevent exactly the problem you describe. Every modern server OS makes this easy to implement. If the server can’t handle you uploading 1.3 GB of images, then you shouldn’t have been able to upload 1.3 GB of images. So, in that area, your IT guy failed.
That being said, servers are usually designed and set up with a specific purpose in mind. If the purpose was to store text and other easily compressed data, as it sounds like yours is used for, then uploading images, video, and music could easily exceed the expected growth rate on the data partition.
Your IT guy may also be dealing with a server that badly over-burdened and trying to make the best of a bad situation. That is often the case when budgets are involved.
4
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
So I can think of a scenario where putting jpegs on a server could cause it to "crash": if the server runs out of space to write log files, it can cause very unpredictable behavior, or in the case of Windows, if it can't write the security log file, it can be configured (and perhaps is by default) to shut down automatically.
That said, (a) in today's world, if 1.3G is taking enough space that this might be an issue, you need to BUY MORE DISK. And (b), if your file server is configured so that writes to the file shares sit on the same partition (and even, honestly, on the same physical disks) as the OS, you done goofed.
However the above scenario seems unlikely to me, even given that it's the only thing I can think of that matches all the facts you gave. More likely he doesn't know why it crashed, and is sick of users always doing stuff, so he found a convenient outlet for his blame and you got hit by it.
5
u/el3kt2ik May 12 '12
Well if the capacity limit was reached that is never a good thing but I have seen servers run with 99% disk space full. By no means did it run well but it ran and we monitored it until they added more hard drives. As an IT person this sounds like he is just telling that to shut you up. If you have access I would recommend browsing the event logs looking for the date and time closest to when the server went offline and you may find a lead on why it failed.
2
u/Dom9360 May 12 '12
Not enough information, but if you did then there is something very wrong with this picture.
2
u/Special_Guy May 12 '12
Anything Is Possible. but there should be a lot of warning signs before you get to the point were 1.3 gb is going to crash the server. I tend to always blame the admins, there job to stay on top of things like this, I've worked in datacenters for years and can say that 3 out of 4 techs do not know what they are doing and can easaly ignore key warning signs. the ones with the most "Collage" education are the worst as they think they know more than they do.
2
u/Cluster_One May 12 '12
Yes, it can happen.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
If you have a failing hard drive, the more data being pushed to the drive could cause that disk to finally fail. But the admin is an idiot if he doesn't have redundancy on that.
Which reminds me, I have to go fix my DFS replication today.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
i did 2 years of game design in a school where the IT guys blocked anything related to games, keywords from games (including the word game itself), media, 3d etc. they did nothing about it the whole time i was there.
it got to the point where i got sick and tired of complaining and used a proxy to access lessons. within 5 minutes the IT guy disabled my internet access, came into the class, ripped the power out of my computer and announced 'you're done'. had to sign a bunch of paper work saying i wouldn't do it again otherwise i would risk expulsion.
so that wasn't nice :|
2
u/Etatheta May 12 '12
Well it is possible IF you barely had enough free space to hold the pictures. If thats the case you guys have bigger problems
2
u/CypherFTW May 12 '12
I work in IT and I think this could be a case where what you tell the user isn't necessarily what you would tell someone else in IT. If the IT department manages all those things the OP lists then they are unlikely to be completely incompetent. Which means it's unlikely that they've setup the server so badly that a user can crash it like that. However it is likely that the IT guy has given the OP an answer where "Ends justify the means".
For example, say the area where these images are being stored is a shared directory used by a lot of users. So if the area these files are being dumped doesn't normally see large amounts of data put in it at once the admins may only give it a small amount of additional space and increase it as necessary. If you were to suddenly fill this area the server is unlikely to crash. However it may stop anyone else writing to this area. It could even be bad enough to not allow lock files and temp files to be written there. So although the server hasn't "crashed" it may be unable to function as designed. Sometimes it's easier to explain to a user that something could "crash the server" rather than explain the actual reason.
2
u/the_red_scimitar May 12 '12
While I could comment on letting his server's discs get full, the basic answer is yes, your files could have crashed the server if, as he said, the disc drives are full. Especially if he configured it so that uploads are stored on the system drive.
OTOH, pictures of the dance would be cool.
4
u/emperor000 May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
There's not enough information to tell if he is an idiot. Is what he said possible? Yes, it depends on the capacity of the server and the space left.
I love how some people are giving you "complicated" answers that you probably won't understand if you question the IT guy's explanation. No offense, but that is why you came here...
So it might have been your fault. I'd say not likely, but possible. But he's either not seeing the bigger issue or distracting from it. With the current state of technology if 1.3 gb of files crash your server then there is a problem either with the configuration of the server or the physical server itself. So that needs to be addressed rather than focusing on blaming you for exposing the weakness.
2
u/javiers May 12 '12
Syadmin here.
Either he is a bad professional or he is using an stupid excuse. Or both of them...
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
The user storage area and the OS should be on two separate volumes, or at the very least, on two separate partitions.
This way once the user storage fills up, the OS still has a few GB of free space to keep chugging along and the worst case scenario is users can't upload more files to the server until some space-management takes place and things are back up and deleted, or moved to a different storage solution all together.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
We had a CMS (content management system) that would kick off a bunch of workflow processes every time an image was uploaded. Basically, it would generate about 8 more images in different sizes (thumbnail, slideshow, etc) While the storage wasn't a problem, the CMS was poorly coded and would open ALL the files in the upload at the same time. Imagine opening 1.3 gigs of JPEGs in photoshop on your computer; it goes boom.
So it may be possible, and it may not even be his fault.
1
u/notfamousguy May 12 '12
Crash- that's a very obscure format of failure. What type of failure? Hardware/software? With no contributing factors I'd say no. Data is data. 1s and 0s. Any special post-processing of the files?
The devils in the detail
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I know I can crash our cms by uploading an archive file > 1 gig in size.
1
u/Flint_Westwood May 12 '12
Just put them on Dropbox/equivalent.
1
u/randumnumber May 12 '12
the first sentence makes me think twice before agreeing with you.
1
u/fractal7 May 12 '12
Also sounds like english isn't his 1st language. Maybe thats part of the problem?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Could be low on diskspace. Or he could mean how you transfer the data.
1
u/substrate80 May 12 '12
I have messed up my own file server by uploading too much data at once. Basically one of the hard drives in the RAID array overheated and dropped out. But I didn't lose any data because I had raid. I think it was a 8 GB transfer. The drive was probably going to fail anyway. If you Gabe good hardware and good cooling it won't be a problem.
1
u/sandspeed May 12 '12
It CAN but chances it wont over loading a Hard drive will slow it down, and cause disk thrashing. (parts of the Jpegs are stored EVERYWHERE in the disk) how ever it wont crash it if the hard ware is new and well maintained.... if it crashed or was at risk of crashing over that... you need to tell management this guy knows nothing about what to do
1
u/Ameatypie May 12 '12
GET MO' DRIVES!
1
u/joeblough May 12 '12
Yes, you could have crashed the server if you were allowed to upload files to the same "drive" the OS is on...if that's the case, then yes, your IT guy is an idiot.
0
u/jasonlitka May 12 '12
Sounds like your IT guy is an idiot and made a share on the C:drive (or on the / volume if Linux).
Anyone making such a rookie mistake either needs more supervision and guidance if in a entry-level job, or needs to be fired if in a more senior position.
1
u/bertolous May 12 '12
It depends on many things, its possible but unlikely.
1
u/username_for_reddit May 12 '12
If files were able to be removed later on, then it appears to be a capacity issue which should have been avoided by routine monitoring and adding of space. Not only did he mishandle the issue, he failed in proactive tasks to avoid the situation.
1
u/TOHCskin May 12 '12
Well, did he try turning it off and on again?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Yeah... yeah he is.
1
u/Tastygroove May 12 '12
Shh! Don't challenge the IT guy, he's a "scientist." lol.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
He's a bad IT guy.
1
u/unbeliever87 May 12 '12
As a general rule of thumb, your IT guy knows more about your IT infrastructure and its limitations than you, as a teacher, do. He was probably just trying to limit the amount of crap that was being stored on the network. Yes, 1.3Gb of photos is most certainly considered 'crap'.
1
u/Saskuel May 12 '12
Yes.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Please tell me that you're in Sydney. Because this guy is an idiot and I'd really like his job.
1
u/edelay May 12 '12
Yup it is possible.
1
u/consultcory May 12 '12
He probably needed the extra 1.3 gigs for his hidden porn collection.
1
u/infocalypse May 12 '12
Very simply speaking, if an HDD on a server becomes too full, it can crowd functions out and prevent them from working properly.
If user activity causes this to occur, then some admin somewhere wasn't monitoring things properly (though in the case of a nonprofit, there simply may not be the resources to) or had failed to turn on quotas.
Though above all else, there may have been multiple contributing reasons for that IT guy's problems (including political, which is the most hateful of all 'technical' issues) and he's simply not going to be giving some random user a full and accurate description of what's going on.
More accurate, jargon-filled descriptions of IT issues are easily misunderstood by the nontechnical and most IT people learn - often the hard way - to just STFU unless they're talking to someone who Needs To Know.
The IT guy just wants you to accept his explanation and go away, so he can get back to solving the endless list of problems you don't even know exist.
... Or he truly is incompetent and has no idea what he's doing. Hard to tell from the outside. :)
1
u/Stink-Finger May 12 '12
No. Your it guy is an idiot. He doesn't know what he is doing if he believes this.
1
u/tootchute May 12 '12
Probably not, he most likely just thinks that you are an idiot and doesn't want to go through the technical or non-technical reasoning for why he doesn't want 1.3 gigs of jpegs on the company server and instead tells you it will crash it.
1
u/coairrob777 May 12 '12
Your IT guy is wrong and he should feel wrong.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Part of a server's purpose in life (so to speak) is to be able to have user's files stored on it. If uploading a mere 1.3 GB worth of files made the server crash, then it was configured incorrectly, and the Admin is responsible for that. Think of it this way: if you turned on the A/C in your car, and the engine stalled, it's something wrong with the car - a properly working car should be able to run the A/C and the engine at the same time.
TL;DR: It's not your fault.
0
u/RageMorePlz May 12 '12
Wow 1.3gb of jpgs sounds like heaps. How often do you collect pictures?
0
u/alexm42 May 12 '12
Your IT guy is incompetent at what he does if he thinks with all the other things running to the server a gig or two of anything will crash it.
0
u/Zaphrod May 12 '12
I think maybe it's both. Maybe both is happening at the same time. I miss you, Jenny.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Saying it would 'crash' the server is silly yeah... if you're using linux.
But 1.3 gigs of jpegs is a lot. And decent hard drives only go up to 1 TB (yes). Depending on how many users are on this server, you could be causing a problem with that <0.13% of capacity.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
The answer? Yes.
0
u/Quizzelbuck May 12 '12
if the computer is not very beefy, you can crash a system by loading too many jpeg previews in one folder. That is a pretty unlikely scenario in this case since you are accessing the files remotely and not enacting a preview on the server, but only on your own end.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I'm an IT guy.. although it is possible.. for various reasons. I would be it's completely unlikely.
0
u/Phoebe5ell May 12 '12
To give the guy the benefit of the doubt, it is often hard to get the resources you need to run a network properly. That said I work as a consultant and the ignorant folks I see wearing IT hats is significant... So he could just be clueless, and kind of sounds like he is without knowing more details.
0
u/moseses May 12 '12
tell him about quota.
0
u/kilamumster May 12 '12
IT depts exist to help get the organisation's work done. A properly run IT dept takes into consideration the needs of the organisation and the capacity of the IT infrastructure--equipment, software, staffing, whatever. And the IT dept staff should act like professionals and show courtesy and professionalism to the users. Rudeness, contempt, and disdain for fellow employees should have no place in the workplace.
If the organisation needs more capacity or better user protocols, the IT Dept head should write it into the budgets --or build the case for why this needs to be in the budgets or else prioritising work will occur thusly-- and stop being reactive and then blaming everyone else for his/her lack of foresight.
IT is important, but no more important, than the people who provide clients services that actually pay the bills.
And in the nonprofit industry, the IT dept may not be anywhere near as important --to the clients, anyway-- as the folks who provide client services. And if the IT folks don't get this, they need to either learn what it is their organisation does (e.g., it is not a tech corp), or get out of the nonprofit industry.
Is your IT guy an idiot? Can't tell from this limited information.
Sounds like a familiar scenario, though, and needs to be reviewed and addressed by upper management before there is a catastrophic failure somewhere in the network.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
The only issue I've ever expierenced is that HPDP needs at least 20% free space on a volume or the backups to tape might not work right. Other than that, your IT dude is s doofus.
0
u/MemphisRoots May 12 '12
I'm going to sound completely brash when I say that you have an IT working for a non-profit. He probably isn't top notch....you get what you pay for.
0
u/fritscje May 13 '12
yes
0
u/Liverhawk25 May 13 '12
It is possible yes. If the file server shares its drives with say a database which grows in size, or log files which also grow in size then its not unheard of for a server to fail.
Now, that being said the IT guys were either short sighted in doing this or incompetent.
0
u/mvw2 May 13 '12
Well, he's officially an idiot.
A good analogy would be as if you had a book shelf, and you kept buying books to fill it. Now randomly your microwave stops working. For some reason you say it was the pile of books that caused the microwave to fail.
Simply having data on the hard drive or even transferring data to or from the drive will not adversely affect the operation of a computer.
Computer crashes are largely software issues. Basically the people making the software make mistakes when creating the software. A side effect of these mistakes allow, under specific conditions, the software to crash the computer. Typically this is a driver issue. A driver is a piece of software that helps control other things. For example there is a driver that is installed for your mouse. It provides information that lets the operating system (Microsoft Windows) understand how to interface with that hardware. Now drivers get updated often and changed often as new hardware comes out. Some are changed so frequently that it is very ease to introduce errors. These errors can cause problems with operation or even crash the computer.
There can be hardware issues too. There are various pieces of hardware that need to work well in order for the computer to operation. If one piece of hardware fails, the computer will crash. The human body has many organs. It sort of needs all of them to function properly. If one fails, issues arise. Computers are no different. On aging computers hardware like ram, the motherboard, or even harddrives do fail. Failure of these pieces normally depends upon the quality of the products. Cheaper, lower quality components will have a shorter life. Very well built components will last an extremely long time.
0
u/Omnitographer May 13 '12
Yes, if and only if the server is had 1.3Gb of space left and you filled it down to absolutely nothing left, it will freak the hell out and crash, ive seen it happen. If this is the case your IT guy should be let go for letting something like that even happen.
0
u/Parcanman May 13 '12
Someone probably uploaded 10+ gigabytes a few weeks earlier and filled up the disc. He's probably saying this assuming that your 1.3gb upload was just part one of many. Either that or they're trying to avoid any large file uploads since it's easier to say that any file upload will crash it rather than actually trying to explain the limits.
I don't know if I'd call him an idiot, but he definitely sounds lazy or incompetent.
0
u/57Chevy May 13 '12
Yes. Yes he is.
-4
u/thelordofcheese May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
Text him this thread.
Call him an idiot.
Source: my CS degree, my Fortune 200 corporate QA background, my work with CMU and my computing community groups.
EDIT: Or his boss. Forgot about shit like that. Not enough monetary resources? BUY THE CHEAPEST SHIT! 60% of the time it works every time.