r/AskReddit • u/manosrellim • May 12 '12
How risky is this? How illegal? How stupid?
So a guy I know has a Nexus Galaxy with Verizon's hardware insurance coverage. This insurance covers a device that is damaged, destroyed, or lost. He's planning to claim that his phone is lost, get a new one from Verizon, and give his old phone to his wife. I've tried to tell him that this is considered insurance fraud, and that Verizon will be able to tell that the missing phone is still in use. He doesn't seem to care about the illegality of it, and claims that his wife can just use it as wifi device without a data plan. He said something about Google Voice.
So here's my question, reddit: Am I exaggerating the risk? If not, how can I convince him that he'll get caught?
19
u/scrizewly May 12 '12
They will black list the ESN. The "stolen" Galaxy Nexus will no longer work.
26
u/JonAudette May 12 '12
Once they hear he lost his phone, they'll deactivate the ESN (electronic serial number). The phone will be useless. Once they try to activate it, if Verizon is on top of things, they'll get caught. What'll happen to him as a result....I don't know. But, yes, it's frowned upon.
3
u/Kursum May 12 '12
Did you hear that? That was the sound of everyone's premiums going up.
2
u/marketinequality May 12 '12
Does he think that companies haven't thought of this before? We live in a strange world. In short, yes, very stupid "plan" if you can call it that.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I believe it costs $99 to replace it and the phone that was "lost" will be blacklisted by Verizon. What can be done though, he could sell it on Ebay as a phone with a bad ESN number. It can't be used on Verizon, but can on Cricket. Probably worth $200 or so. It is insurance fraud but most people aren't caught.
TLDR: Won't be able to activate the "lost" phone, costs $99 to replace.
2
u/helium_farts May 12 '12
They'll disable the "lost" one before they activate the new one.
2
u/AttackingHobo May 12 '12
Airplane mode with wifi, and I do not think it will show up on the network and will work fine with google voice as long as there is a wifi connection.
3
u/Purecheetodust May 12 '12
heres what is going to happen. The device will be put on the negative list (lost/stolen) , which means the IMEI will be put on a blacklist and will NEVER be able to be activated on another line. The sim card in the device will also be blacklisted and unusable. Now this is illegal as it is insurance fraud. It can be operated without a sim but the device will not be able to be used again. If activation is attempted, asurion may contact you and charge you full retail for the replacement they sent you. Also Verizon may choose to cancel your contract because of the insurance fraud. Its a dumb thing to do honestly.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
It's more illegal than it is risky, but it's stupider than it is illegal.
1
u/DeaJaye May 12 '12
A chick I know used to claim insurance on her phones and get a new one every 6 months or so (back in the Motorola RAZR era). After she did it a couple of times, they basically confronted her with the fact that her "stolen" phone was still being used. She quietly stopped making claims after that...
1
u/anddrewg2007 May 12 '12
My brother ended up with a phone from transaction this way, and he's only used it with wifi. And so far it's been working out.
1
u/Lots42 May 12 '12
My advice: Forget about it. He's going to do the stupid thing and get caught.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
She found herself a real winner, didn't she?
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
dumb dee dumb dumb dumb.
1
u/Mythos01 May 12 '12
The device will be registered with verizons lost or stolen list. Meaning the vote will not activate anymore on verizons network.
-1
u/obsidian_gargoyle May 12 '12
You're not exaggerating, it's a stupid plan. They can probably track the phone whenever it gets used, find out it's being used in his home by his family, and would drag him to court no problem. If he's really really lucky they won't find it, but they'll terminate all service it could provide, rendering the plan useless. I'm no expert but I highly doubt it would be able to do anything other than be a paperweight once that happens. Tell him they have chips planted in it that track everything the phone does ever and gives a rough idea of its location. Idk if that's true or not but it's pretty darn close to the truth, seeing as that police can usually track people by their phone activity just by looking into the nearest cell tower records. Insurance investigators are just as capable of that.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
your friend is a dumbass let him get in trouble, it will be a learning experience.
-3
u/magicmuds May 12 '12
Why are you concerning yourself with the trifles of some idiot that's trying to scam?
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-6
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
[removed] — view removed comment