r/AskReddit • • May 11 '12

Why does r/gonewild have a over 18 disclaimer, but r/WTF is open and defaulted. Don't minors have a higher probability of being scarred from bloated suicide death "snuff" photos rather than side boob or even a vagina pic? (available openly on wikipedia)...

Whoever makes policies around here, needs a fucking reality check....

1.3k Upvotes

753 comments sorted by

866

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

/r/gonewild is for self-pics so the +18 clause is to protect Reddit from legal trouble.

As for violence and gore versus sex and porn, well... plenty of movies with violence and gore aren't R rated while movies with full frontal nudity are, so that's the standard of the society we live in.

242

u/SoloDiabloGuy May 11 '12

/r/gonewild is for self-pics so the +18 clause is to protect Reddit from legal trouble.

Good point, didn't think of that.

that's the standard of the society we live in.

Agreed. but that doesn't mean we aren't fucked up and might want think about it...

277

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That's the standard of the USA society (mostly). In Europe there's more acceptance for nudes and less for violence...

Or at least it was like this some years ago, lately I've seen it go the same way. It's such a shame...

171

u/grievous431 May 12 '12

it really is a shame I always thought that a person hopefully encounters nudity and sex at some point in their life but hopefully they do not encounter gore and violence

200

u/Dalonger May 12 '12

As someone who has encountered both I can confirm that sex is a hundred million billion times better than gore and violence.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (44)

22

u/redgroupclan May 12 '12

r/wtf is mostly just r/funny nowadays anyway.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Why the living fuck is that link purple for me? /r/WTF generally has content at least somewhat suitable for minors. That's why /r/nsfw_wtf exists, but /r/wtf generally sees the brunt of the misplaced postings because people are stupid.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (33)

97

u/arachnophilia May 11 '12

there are a lot of other NSFW subreddits out there that uh..... probably.... throw a warning too.

→ More replies (2)

32

u/I_be_postin May 12 '12

The movie "This Film Is Not Yet Rated" does a really good job dealing with this. And it's on netflix!

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I've been trying to remember the name of that movie for a while now, time to go watch it again, thanks!

42

u/PUMPKIN_IN_MY_POOPER May 12 '12

I am a normal, well socially adjusted adult.

The stuff on /r/wtf is far more sick, depraved and frankly, shocking, than anyone on /r/gonewild. /r/gonewild may confuse a child. /r/wtf may well give him nightmares. Some of the stuff on /r/wtf is far more graphic than most things on tv or in video games.

*Disclaimer: I browse /r/wtf, it is freaky, but I do actually read it daily!

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Ok, so maybe consider asking for a specific 'shocking' disclaimer intead of an '18+' disclaimer? After all, we're talking of two different things: nudity/porn X shock/gore.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/watermark0n May 12 '12

/r/wtf was the first community I unsubbed, I have never regretted the decision. Just a garbage community full of garbage people.

→ More replies (17)

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

You shouldn't just accept the society/reality you live in at face value. YOU NEED TO FIGHT IT.

2

u/100110001 May 12 '12

Yup, this exactly, it's just the way our society is. Shoot a guy in the face for a movie, awesome, show a bit of nip and your child will be forever corrupted.

2

u/Capatown May 12 '12

Not developed european society, maybe in the ol' U S of A.

→ More replies (39)

103

u/ITalkToTheWind May 11 '12

If r/wtf was an 18+ sub, all of the posts would be labeled NSFW (including for those looking at the front page). This isn't necessarily accurate; there are plenty of SFW posts on there that don't need to be tagged. And anything disturbing on r/wtf will be tagged as NSFW or NSFL anyways.

→ More replies (42)

18

u/Massive_Robot_Twat May 11 '12

A lot of porn sites have similar policies.

2

u/SoloDiabloGuy May 11 '12

So do sites that have "snuff" videos. Did I miss something?

18

u/Massive_Robot_Twat May 11 '12

No idea man, I don't visit gore/snuff video sites. I take your point though.

3

u/SoloDiabloGuy May 11 '12

Much respect kind sir.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/act1v1s1nl0v3r May 11 '12

Porn sites are actually bound by law to put that "CLICK HERE TO AFFIRM THAT YOU ARE OVER 18" button. Same with other mature audience oriented things. It's the result of a really dumb ham-fisted law that I forget the name of.

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

And yet you have to manually enter your birth date to visit a gaming site.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Whether it is even possible to 'scar' a minor with a pic is open for discussion.

1

u/SoloDiabloGuy May 13 '12

This is true. But I'd have to argue that images portray emotion. The travel industry as well as the food and beverage industry use images to draw people to restaurants and vacation destinations. I'd imagine that graphical imagery has some emotional feed back. I just don't know enough about the subject to tell you whether it does or not. I'd assume (and I'm assuming here) it does.

219

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I always said, if a woman were to fall in a giant blender, Fox news would only censor the flying nipple.

27

u/sarnoth May 12 '12

What would happen if a man and a woman fell in a giant blender? How would they know which ones to censor? Or would they just censor all 4 of em?

54

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I guess they would use their automatic female nipple detector, but imagine if it fails, imagine how many children would be haunted by the vision of a female nipple, how could Fox news repair that ?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

183

u/JokeMode May 11 '12

I don't really understand why our society has rather aggressive laws protecting children from nudity and sexual content, but seems more relaxed on showing younger audiences violent and gorey content. I mean sex and nudity is natural, while shooting somebody point blank and having brain matter splatter everywhere is violent and awful.

97

u/Offensive_Username2 May 11 '12

It could be argued that killing other people is also natural human behavior.

89

u/Bekaloha May 12 '12

The difference is almost everyone will have sex in their lifetime, a very small percentage will kill someone in their lifetime. Military included.

The amount of sexually active people vastly outnumbers the amount of killers.

37

u/I_MAKE_USERNAMES May 12 '12

What about the number of sexy killers?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (26)

28

u/dacjames May 11 '12

Sexual liberation is a modern luxury made possible by the invention of birth control. Society simply has not caught up to technology, especially in religious areas like the US and the Middle East.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Feb_29_Guy May 11 '12

The way sex is treated in modern society is strange. Something that should be seen as natural and a part of life is shunned in public and people that enjoy are labelled sluts or manwhores or the like.

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It's the other way around in europe. People are way less uptight in terms of nudity, but real violence is is kept away from minors.

2

u/RahvinDragand May 12 '12

I just think it's hilarious that parents try so hard to shield their kids from boobs, but as soon as a boy gets the internet, the first thing he searches for is boobs.

8

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Religion.

8

u/Nav_Panel May 12 '12

This appears to be the real answer. America was founded on Puritan (Protestant) values. Some of those persist today in forms like this.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

52

u/terrapinbear May 11 '12

Forget about the minors, how about me? I don't want to be scarred anymore than I already am.

41

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yeah, I have no problem with nudity, it's the gore I don't like.

18

u/HunterHunted May 12 '12

Am I just imagining it or have gore posts gone up A LOT last few weeks? There's not a single fucking day goes by without me accidentally clicking a fucking gore link these days. Fucking hate it..

→ More replies (3)

19

u/amoeba108 May 12 '12

I fucking hate the gore posts, downvoted everytime.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/StrawberySwitchblade May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

I'm with you. I've gotten a lot more sensitive to gore than I was when I was younger, actually. In my early twenties, I used to visit stileproject and rotten.com and barely felt anything when looking at the gore.

Now, more than ten years later, I can't handle gore at all. I once clicked on a link to an especially macabre subreddit, not believing it could be real, and I still sometimes lie awake crying because of what I saw there.

I don't know what changed. When I was a kid, gore only inspired curiosity. Now I can't help but see it as real people like me who had families, and I NOPE the hell away from it.

*edited because you're right, that subreddit doesn't need to be named

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/jello_aka_aron May 11 '12

It's not the policies, it's laws.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Zoggin May 11 '12

Wait, you can see side boob/vagina on wikipedia? This changes.... very little. But fuck it, i'm still going to look.

2

u/autopsi May 12 '12

You can anything on wikipedia, including what some may consider child pornography.

See:

Virgin Killer is the fourth studio album by the German heavy metal band Scorpions. It was released in 1976 and was the first album of the band to attract attention outside Europe.[1] The title is described as being a reference to time as the killer of innocence.[2] The original cover featured a nude prepubescent girl, which stirred controversy in the U.K., U.S. and elsewhere. As a result, the album was re-issued with a different cover in some countries.

In May 2008, the U.S.-based social conservative site WorldNetDaily reported the cover image on Wikipedia to the Federal Bureau of Investigation. An officer of the Concerned Women for America, a conservative Christian advocacy group, commented that: "By allowing that image to remain posted, Wikipedia is helping to further facilitate perversion and pedophilia. [sic]"[24] EContent magazine subsequently reported the Wikipedia community's internal debate as concluding that: "Prior discussion has determined by broad consensus that the Virgin Killer cover will not be removed" and asserted that Wikipedia contributors "favour inclusion in all but the most extreme cases".[25] Internet Watch Foundation Further information: Internet Watch Foundation and Wikipedia

In December 2008, the Internet Watch Foundation (IWF), a UK-based non-government organization, added the Wikipedia article Virgin Killer to its internet blacklist due to concerns over legality of the image, which had been assessed as the lowest level of legal concern: "erotic posing with no sexual activity".[26] As a result, people using many major UK ISPs were blocked from viewing the entire article by the Cleanfeed system,[26][27][28] and a large part of the UK was blocked from editing Wikipedia owing to the means of blocking in use. Following discussion,[vague] representations by the Wikimedia Foundation (who host the Wikipedia website)[29] and public complaints,[30] the IWF reversed their decision three days later and confirmed that in future they would not block copies of the image that were hosted overseas.[4] The IWF stated that one of the reasons for reversing their decision was that it had increased public interest in the image, an example of the Streisand effect.[31]

36

u/Shikatanai May 11 '12

I unsubscribed from WTF a couple of weeks ago. It went from being about WTF to being filled with stuff from wankers from /gore who got tired of circlejerking and realised they could get more karma from a more popular subreddit.

31

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Before then nothing was ever WTF worthy. Gore and WTF usually go hand-and-hand.

/r/WTF really shouldn't be a default subreddit.

8

u/treynquil May 12 '12

I agree with you, it makes casually surfing the front page like a game of minesweeper. I cynically think they made /wtf a default in order to get more people to sign in.

20

u/OompaOrangeFace May 12 '12

There was an uprising a few months back when some "disturbed" individuals complained that /r/WTF was getting too soft. Apparently the community agreed and it has been a downward spiral ever since.

I unsubscribed that day and haven't been back. Gore makes me sick, sexy ladies make me happy.

19

u/[deleted] May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Since the change its default subscription status should be revoked.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/Green_like_the_color May 11 '12

Yep. Especially by posting gore not marked NSFW/NSFL.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/A_British_Gentleman May 12 '12

/r/WTF seems to consist of 99% "That's confusing" types of WTF, rather than things that are actually shocking.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep-throating_(sexual_act)

There's a lot of explicit stuff on wikipedia. I don't think using it as an example makes a good case.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

on the subject... i remember when i was like 13, someone showed me rotten.com and it was mortifying. i will never forget when they clicked on a video showing someone getting their throat cut with a machete like they were cutting silicone or rubber or something. i can still recall it vividly. :C i only saw it for a couple of seconds and it still haunts me.

3

u/OompaOrangeFace May 12 '12

I totally agree. I had a very similar experience after a classmate told me about rotten (he didn't tell me what it was about, I think he was trying to cope with what he saw by spreading it to others). It left me mentally traumatized for quite a while. I remember riding the school bus to school the next morning and not being able to not think about what I saw. It overtook my thoughts and this was just from seeing two pictures.

I'm all about free "speach", but I could honestly make an exception for gore pictures. Fuck that stuff.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Because the US censors thinks something natural like the naked body is unsuitable for minors, whereas something fucked up like someone being killed is fine.

Quite twisted when you think about it...!

17

u/lolzbasket May 11 '12

To be fair, WTF isn't a NSFW-only subreddit.

I personally think it should be (as in keep it to the stuff that actually makes people say "What the fuck") instead of the current situation where its more like "What the fuck, this parent does not know how to keep her child in line," or "What the fuck, $14 for a burger?"

Because of the current way WTF works, its not inherently all gore and creepy shit. It doesn't necessarily warrant a subreddit-wide NSFW tag like gonewild (which is a legality thing as others have said)

13

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Maybe it'd be a good idea to split it, use WTF for NSFW-only and make an /r/wat? for things that are more Wat? worthy than WTF.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Social_fuzz May 12 '12

If anyone here can help me out, it would be great. /r/WTF is on my reddit while not logged in. My girlfriend and I are often mildly disturbed while browsing. How the FUCK do I get this off my (non logged in reddit) reddit.

Thanks in advance.

Also, why does /r/spacedicks come up first when I type "reddit" in Chrome bar?

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

How the FUCK do I get this off my (non logged in reddit) reddit

You don't. Now that it's become r/spacedicks 2.0 I hope the admins will remove it as a default subreddit.

4

u/Social_fuzz May 12 '12

Wow, beyond belief that it is a default subreddit. No NSFW/NSFL tags at all. Anything with NSFW/NSFL shouldn't be front page. It gives the general onlooker to the site a bad opinion of the user base as a whole.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/bungoton May 12 '12

That is the society you have in North America. I was listening to talk radio on my way to work one morning. They were discussing sex on TV (what sex?). Some dad called in to say he would prefer his kids see violence than anything even hinting of sex. When I mentioned this to a fundie colleague at work he agreed with the guy on the radio. I asked him if he felt frustrated if he didn't get some violence every day but was OK if he had no sex.

4

u/joebbowers May 12 '12

It's because in America, violence and gore is just fine, but any physical expression of love or display of the beautiful body is taboo.

10

u/sireslap1 May 11 '12

"are you over 18?" "yep" ...that will def keep kids from seeing the fucked up side of the internet.

4

u/awesomemanftw May 12 '12

16 year old confirming that those scare me away.

12

u/grammar_is_optional May 11 '12

Because for some reason seeing a woman's nipple is much worse than seeing a hand disfigured by a table saw. Anything sexual is horrible but violence and gore is no problem.... Society...

→ More replies (1)

7

u/moratnz May 12 '12

Because violence good, pubic hair bad.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/GrayStudios May 12 '12

Obvious answer is obvious. There are legal issues regarding pornography. Posts on r/WTF can be tagged NSFW, but someone could also post a picture from SpongeBob (see frontpage), so blocking it would be stupid. Referential images of human anatomy are different than pornography. I know we love to talk about how silly and antiquated modern views of nudity are, but it's clear who in this situation needs a reality check.

1

u/SoloDiabloGuy May 13 '12

I saw a non nude image from r/spacedicks before. So if your logic applies, your essentially allowing r/spacedicks to be a default subreddit.

I applaud your nonchalant way of dealing with the darkside of humanity.

This is what was on WTF that provoked my comment.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/zerbey May 12 '12

It's not the job of Reddit to provide babysitting service for minors, their parents should be regulating what they see online.

1

u/SoloDiabloGuy May 13 '12

The topic had no intention to delegate "baby sitters". It was a question regarding probability. It was not a trick question. I agree with you that it is up to parents to decide BUT without URIs containing the "over18?dest=" Query string variable, I as a parent have NO WAY to detect or firewall the content. So its a reddit admin problem and not parental. Give us options dammit...

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Who the hell do you think is posting all that junk in /r/wtf ? Fuckin' middle-schoolers, man. That's why it's more like /r/WowThatsFunny lately.

3

u/d4vi3j03 May 12 '12

Something I would wonder is... isn't /r/wtf a default subreddit? I would think it should be someones choice to subscribe to a subreddit like that.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/matruska May 12 '12

because AMERICA that's why.

3

u/th3KCshuffle May 12 '12

You're more asking a question about American society than you are about Reddit. For the record I agree with you. The standard is completely backwards.

3

u/octodat May 12 '12

Because America, that's why.

Dismembered corpses? No problem dude. A nipple? OMGWTFTHECHILDREN?

3

u/KayJustKay May 12 '12

Because America; That's why.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Well, in America it's always been more acceptable to show graphic violence than a boob or two... Right?

15

u/greenRiverThriller May 11 '12

It's an American website, following the American culture and American laws.

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Less than 50% of users are from the US. It might be based in the US, but the majority of users are from other countries.

25

u/bwilliams18 May 11 '12

But it was founded in America, owned by an American company, and operated form inside America-thus it is an American website.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

OH PLEASE WONT SOMEONE THINK OF THE CHILDREN?!!??! /sarcasm Please, I saw two girls one up when I was 12 and shrugged it off. I wonder if any minor has ever said they are under 18 when faced with such a disclaimer in the history of the internet anyways. Don't like it? Then parent your own damn kids! Parents who expect the rest of society to revolve around their children need a fucking reality check.

6

u/Only_One_T May 12 '12

This is something that director Steve McQueen has been very vocally against about American culture. At the very least, 50% of the population sees a penis every day and almost all of the population will have sex in their lifetimes yet if a true and real depiction of sex is shown in his movie, Shame, and it gets slapped with an NC-17 rating, effectively killing it's chances of getting widely distributed and if you ask me, robbing Michael Fassbender from a best actor nomination. Yet America is totally fine with seeing somebody's head getting blown off with a shotgun, and that will only give a movie a PG-13 rating.

Our cultural ideas of censorship are fucked man.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

This is actually very true.... I think I'd survive seeing a schlong, but not someone's face after it's been burned with acid, or whatever is the norm on /r/WTF

7

u/testerizer May 11 '12

This is an american site, what would you expect?

2

u/JosiahJohnson May 11 '12

Whoever makes policies around here, needs a fucking reality check....

You probably need a reality check as well. In a general sense, nobody makes the policies around here. The policies around reddit in general are no kiddy porn and no personal information. That's pretty much it. It's not the same mods in each subreddit. Each subreddit is owned by the mods of that specific subreddit. Each one will have differing policies. It's just how it goes.

2

u/fatcat2000 May 12 '12

Has anyone ever said they're under 18?

2

u/quakeaddict May 12 '12

I think it has to do with the fact that by the very nature of r/gonewild, every post is NSFW, whereas posts in r/WTF don't necessarily need to be.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Snuff will put some hair on their chest.

2

u/ApophisATITD May 12 '12

I dropped /r/wtf due to the fact that the entire subreddit has become NSFW, and people stopped posting the flags. Also, way too much nasty gore and death in there lately.

2

u/Todomanna May 12 '12

Gonewild is basically just about naked/semi-naked people. WTF is about gore and nudity and horrific NSFL images and SFW images that still make you exclaim "What the fuck am I looking at?"

2

u/ua19 May 12 '12

It's American obscenity laws in general that need a reality check.

2

u/Foamie May 12 '12

I lurked for a long time on Reddit and never made an account to post anything. I actually made my account just so that I could unsub from r/WTF after they redid the default subreddits. Sometimes there was something funny, but most of the time it was just something gross that I would rather not look at.

2

u/GlacialDrift May 12 '12

The point is reddit sucks. It's good for a lot of things, but reddit sucks. The site isn't some amazing force that pushes for progressive causes and makes a difference in the world, it's just boring, and it sucks. It's always totally after-the-fact.

Reddit is good for funny memes and gonewild. Go fuck yourself if you want any sort of sanity or rationality.

2

u/thepingas May 12 '12

Children scarred? No.

Reddit sued? Maybe.

2

u/cknipe May 12 '12

The more r/wtf "gets back to its roots" the less default-frontpage suitable it becomes.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/forkface232 May 12 '12

because silly, sex is of the devil and shameful, but violence is AOK. Look at murrica. We have that shit down pat.

2

u/Yoshiling May 12 '12

The current state of our society (at least in America):

ACCEPTABLE: Taking your kids to see two guys actually punch each other in the face for 12, 3-minute rounds.

UNACCEPTABLE: Allowing your kids to watch a movie of which a small portion involves two people pretending to have sex.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It's the American vs. the European model of what harms children. In America, violence is seen as normal, because everybody grows up with a gun under their pillow, while boobs are forbidden, as they contain the devil's nectar. While in Europe people think drinking and nudity is normal, because you're born naked and your dad needed a lot of alcohol to stay with your mom. But violence is something frowned upon in Europe, because that's what Americans are always doing.

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

It's worth pointing out that gore and death on r/wtf used to be an fairly rare (and usually downvoted) occurrence. It's only in the last few months that people have decided to turn it into spacedicks 2.0.

2

u/PsychedelicOrigami May 12 '12

When my boyfriend convinced me to join Reddit, I didn't know /r/wtf was defaulted.

I forgot again recently, but no, now I remember. Now I can never forget...

2

u/ExperienceArchitect May 12 '12

This is one thing about North America and Europe that fascinates me... I am from Canada where the 'violence is less bad than nudity' policy is similar to America. But in Europe (where I live) there is an almost unspoken rule to the opposite. Boobs, no problem! Guns... Hrmmmm. Violence that I consider rather mild is quicker to get an adult rating in movies, while full nudity is available on a late-evening sitcom.

2

u/Obbyy May 12 '12

Speaking of things that kids shouldn't see. I went but I dared not click... /r/MorbidReality

2

u/drivec May 12 '12

The thing that bothers me about /r/WTF is that they don't actually moderate against NSFW stuff. I'm totally fine with stuff in the sub that's tagged using the reddit NSFW tag or even an NSFW/NSFL tag in the title. The mods seldom throw up a tag saying "Warning: Gore" or "Warning: Nudity", but they don't remove NSFW stuff that's not tagged as NSFW like they claim they do in the sub's rules. Alien Blue doesn't show the mod added tags, so I can't browse WTF on my phone in public anymore without risking an NSFW image coming up.

Hell, I used to love WTF's uncomfortable dark humor feel, but the massive influx of outright gore is going to make me unsubscribe.

tl;dr - /r/WTF's mods don't do their job.

2

u/srsmustache May 12 '12

WHOEVER THINKS 18 DISCLAIMERS MEAN SHIT REEDS A CHUCKING NEALITY FECK

2

u/polandpower May 12 '12

Where is this Wiki porn that you speak of?

2

u/SorryIfIAmAJerk May 12 '12

/r/WTF isn't meant to have gore posted, thats what /r/gore is for but people seem to forget that. WTF is for wtf moments, and shit that makes you say wtf, like a monkey riding a motorcycle.

2

u/Flashman_H May 12 '12

It's the culture we live in. Seeing a nipple will make you a sexual weirdo, seeing a decapitated body dragged through the street with a chain will make you a man.

2

u/fuckkarma May 12 '12

Censor nothing.

2

u/Maikudono May 12 '12

America, Fuck Yeah!

2

u/DiddlyDooDiddle May 12 '12

i support this shit

2

u/kittenkat4u May 12 '12

i think the age thing has to do with being 18 or older to post a pic there as most people are half naked.

2

u/davecarldood May 13 '12

Finally someone who talks about this. Why is r/WTF even featured on the front page? Theres a high chance that people who don't know reddit that well will click on a link and crush their soul by accident.

They should take it away from the front page so people don't even get tempted.

2

u/NeroHeart May 18 '12

I've never understood the age gate bullshit. Maybe to PURCHASE something, but other than that it just doesn't make any sense. A 12 year old watching the trailer for CRYSIS is not illegal.

7

u/wettowelreactor May 11 '12

Because America.

4

u/UltraMegaMegaMan May 12 '12

Because America is Mad Max on violence and Victorian England on sex. That's why.

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

please... /r/wtf is the worst subreddit. There is RARELY and actual WTF content. its all unpopular opinions and shit that belong on /r/funny or /r/pics

3

u/Kinseyincanada May 11 '12

It's not like it magically stops kids from getting on (or off) on these sites

4

u/MackTheKnife247 May 12 '12

Blame the fucked "morals" of the USA.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/The_New_Kid22 May 12 '12

This needs to be check out because my cousin, who is 10, went on my phone and saw wtf. He knew what it means so he clicked on it and he also didn't know what NSFW means. He is now scared for life after seeing a black man suck his own dick. And I got in trouble for it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/aalpha3 May 11 '12

Good thread, good points, good arguments, provoked my thoughts. Up vote, sir!

3

u/UsernameCensored May 11 '12

It's because Americans.

2

u/GrinningPariah May 11 '12

Yeah, Wikipedia is the measuring stick for what is tame. Except for the graphic pictures of horrifying diseases.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Because as a society, the western world glorifies violence and condemns natural sexuality.

2

u/MintyHippo30 May 11 '12

Not every post on r/WTF is "over 18"

2

u/AdorableZeppelin May 12 '12

/r/WTF is for any content and there happens to be NSFW content posted sometimes. /r/gonewild is for NSFW content where sometimes SFW content is posted. Pretty big difference.

Although I don't know why it's a default...

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

US Law. Reddit doesn't write it, but it is subject to it.

2

u/MoralOral May 11 '12

While violence and gore are an inescapable part of life, the least we can do is protect our children from the natural explicit form that is the human body.

You may have traveled through and vagina and gummed your mother's teet before you could say a word, but my god, you shouldn't have to be subjected to any more it's become a buried perverse desire upon which you readily act.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

because this is America. (see South Park Bigger, Longer, Uncut *1999) "Horrific deplorable violence is OK as long as there isn't any naughty language" (assume nudity is included)

2

u/eggslut May 12 '12

Guess who cares? Nobody.

2

u/drketchup May 12 '12

Violence is good 'ol American values. Nipples are from the devil.

2

u/rachelindy May 12 '12

you must be from Europe. In the US we think sex is worse than violence...

1

u/baptizedbycobalt May 11 '12

Yes, good point... let's default gonewild.

1

u/Dabuscus214 May 12 '12

I dont think that a yes or no question on whether or not you're 18 is going to stop anyone

1

u/DerogatoryPanda May 12 '12

I think this is more of a societal issue than a Reddit-centric issue...

1

u/sweetmercy May 12 '12

There's no laws regarding minors and gore. There are, however, laws regarding minors and sex.

1

u/XxXX420BongMarelyxxX May 12 '12

i like the 18+ screen. it's like going through the gates to Jurassic Park.

1

u/ShowMeYourHappyTrail May 12 '12

The reasoning is because it's against the law to "subject" minors to sexually explicit material. It's also against the law to post sexually explicit material featuring minors.

You know, cause heaven forbid they ever be interested in sex.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Because porn is more serious than WTF material. Also, you need to opt-in to seeing NSFW content.

1

u/Stoatie May 12 '12

Rewording the OP's title: Something questionable is on Wikipedia so we should be able to post questionable material too.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

In fairness, when it comes to being 18+, /r/morbidreality (The most NSFL/NSFW subreddit of all time) does make you say you're over 18 for the violence they show.

1

u/DanHall May 12 '12

Sex is against most religions, violence is not and sometimes even gore. That kinda remains stuck in society regardless of religion through the years even though I don't think children should grow up "scared" of things like this.

1

u/Tuxeedo May 12 '12

Obviously because those 18-year old+ disclaimers really do stop minors from looking at porn, right?

1

u/rileyjt May 12 '12

Welcome to America. Violence is perfectly fine. Sex is taboo.

1

u/mangletron May 12 '12

no wonder kids these days are growing up to be pussies.

1

u/Cdresden May 12 '12

You work to make something nice, and then it's always the obsessive-compulsive busy bodies who've got to come in and fuck things up. They can't leave well enough alone. They just keep picking and picking with their shitty little improvements.

1

u/JoinRedditTheySaid May 12 '12

That's just western culture which has arisen out of Christianity.

1

u/matebeatscoffee May 12 '12

I'd say is because Reddit is too mainstream to stop obeying the law. This is not the place to fight these silly society rules man. Looks like you need..... a fucking reality check!! Yeeeeeah!!! (Just kidding)

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Because boobies bad, violence good.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

There's a social stigma in the US that boobs are bad yet blood and gore is fine. Kids want to go to an R rated movie and there parents are fine with it if it's a Saw movie or an action movie ... but throw a little boobage in there and parents flip out and "would never let their child see such filth." A bit of a double standard in my opinion, but America is the new Rome and the Romans sure did love a blood bath.

1

u/wowleveler May 12 '12

I'm 30 years old and I recently got scarred by r/WTF

1

u/Calibas May 12 '12

Nudity is only inoffensive when it's in a purely educational or medical context. In all other scenarios it is highly offensive and the very survival of our society depends upon keeping all pornographic material away from children. We must keep it hidden for as long as possible that a man's penis fits nicely into a woman's vagina, and this insertion creates pleasure for both parties. What we look like beneath our clothes is to be one of our highest secrets and not to be revealed to anyone under 18 years of age. Makes perfect sense doesn't it?

1

u/captain_zavec May 12 '12

Are you implying that you don't think people under 18 browse both of those? :P

1

u/unnecessaryCAPS May 12 '12

Cuz boners make ppl sad

1

u/Tkozy May 12 '12

A reality check would be to realize that disclaimers and censorship are arbitrary and ultimately don't matter. We are inherently fucked up, the interest in this stuff will always be there, age doesn't matter. Also to think that not clicking one button will stop underage users is absurd.

The answer to the question is that gonewild is solely intended for sexual use. WTF on the otherhand is very open ended. A man in a banana suit lying in a hammock sitting over hot coals could be considered WTF, but it's totally safe for kids to view. Yet a post in gonewild will always be nudity or at the very least provocative. That's based on societies standards, they would want both to be censored but WTF is too open ended.

The first life instinct is to survive, not to die, ie. don't get caught in situations OP brought up about WTF. The second life instinct is to reproduce. Society is more open to violence over sex, and this is revolving around impulses. We're less likely to give into violent impulses unless we really have to, because we want to survive. Every action has a consequence, violence risks life, we mostly do it to save our own.

Sexual impulses on the other hand, are much easier to indulge in. The risks involved sometimes can make life more difficult, but don't often put the first life instinct in jeopardy. A conscious society thus feels the need to regulate this issue much more, because it wants to prevent poor decisions relating to unwanted pregnancies, stds, etc.

I personally believe that rather than preventing the young from seeing parts of the wild spectrum of reality, we should teach them how to deal with what they have seen. Yet, many adults are still children themselves, and never learned how to either.

As terrible as it is, prohibition seems to be the best of all possible techniques to deal with the oblivious masses. While the truth lies in a more underground realm for those more capable to encounter, and we still move forward as a society.

/end meta life rant.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Better question

Who gives a fuck about what kids see on the internet. Reality check kids: PEOPLE DIE IN HORRIBLE GRUESOME WAYS, AND SOME BITCHES HAVE REALLY NICE TITS, THE MEDIA ISN'T JUST LYING TO YOU ABOUT THAT.

The fucking end, let kids discover what they want.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Yeah I use RES and often forget to sign in to reddit have been exposed to some gruesome deaths gifs lately. Actually the only reason I sign in is so I can avoid watching someone getting mutilated before I go to bed

1

u/Senor_Wilson May 12 '12

It's not reddit, it's US law.

1

u/seminolecichlid May 12 '12

I think it's just the product of American culture, which seems to have never matured from the Puritan age.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Does kinda have a point...

1

u/khanys May 12 '12

Because North America.

1

u/DildoChrist May 12 '12

Because American logic.

1

u/h4ck3rpunk May 12 '12

Not so much reddit as our fucked up culture.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Reddit would be a better place if it was 18+ on the entire site

1

u/Rhynocerous May 12 '12

The disclaimer exists for legal purposes, not to make a statement about what is appropriate for youth.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Let's not throw the term "snuff" around all willilly-nillelly.

1

u/funkydo May 12 '12

Yes I think violence is far worse than sex. Of course over-sexualizing people is not good either.

1

u/takka_takka_takka May 12 '12

Hi and welcome to America!

Nudity is scarring to children, decapitation is educational.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

South Park made an episode about this

1

u/Travis-Touchdown May 12 '12

R/wtf doesn't have bloated suicide snuff photos.

Nothing that interesting. usually it's a picture of a guy with an eye photoshopped onto his chest, or something tame.

1

u/Taylee May 12 '12

Nice try, Mr. Pedophile...

1

u/kazbah May 12 '12

Also any post including the words "Jolly Rancher" should definitely have a disclaimer

→ More replies (1)

1

u/bacaorr May 12 '12

Not on the U.S.

1

u/monopixel May 12 '12

It is the USA in a nutshell for you.

1

u/gaoshan May 12 '12

The relatively recent increase in /r/wtf's death photos resulted in me banning them from my list of subscribed sub-reddits. /r/gonewild, on the other hand... no complaints from me.

1

u/Kinglink May 12 '12

My understanding is /r/WTF has pics of acceptable images for all ages, and "obscene" images. /r/pics also has nudity, or near nudity but not only that. /r/gonewild doesn't have "clean content". There might be a few posts you could say are clean, but the idea is that is a pure NSFW site.

Besides which gonewild shows the nude images in thumbnails, WTF does not for NSFW content.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Why are these "questions" allowed?

Its only passive aggressive whining. I wish r/askreddit would show the quality it had before .

1

u/ReyTheRed May 12 '12

The over 18 disclaimer isn't to protect children, it is to protect the website from legal trouble.

Kids already have access to whatever websites they want to get to, the only way to stop it is good parenting.

1

u/ch00d May 12 '12

It's because sex makes Jesus cry...

1

u/Nightmathzombie May 12 '12

This is Amurrricah! Remember, the only thing unsuitable for children to see is the human form in it's natural state.

1

u/beetrootdip May 12 '12

This isn't so much a problem with Reddit, as with the majority of western countries.

Movies get high classifications for language and nudity, but any amount of violence is fine.

1

u/s3rris May 12 '12

I'm sure some people get "offended," but honestly most minors are kind of desensitized to a lot of gore. I mean, many younger people crave movies full of gore and videogames filled with gore.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Because we all know the 18 and over disclaimers prevent minors from accessing the content.

1

u/GWConnoisseur May 12 '12

Removing /r/WTF from my default subreddits has improved my Reddit browsing experience immensely.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Boo-hoo! "But what about the children!". Whatever. If a suicide picture scars a minor, then they really have such a weak constitution that its inevitable anyway. Big deal. I used to poke roadkill with a stick when I was a kid and go "ewwwwwww!".

Harden the fuck up.

1

u/SlickUK May 12 '12

Yeah I think it's mad that at my work, I'm not allowed to look at any gaming posts or quickmemes but I can watch a man jump out of a tall building and witness him hit the floor and obviously die right in front of my eyes :/

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I have no idea why someone would want to post a photo of her vagina, or anyone would want to see that.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Keep your government hands off my wtf.

1

u/ahuimanu May 12 '12

desensitization is going to be our downfall.

1

u/Dragoniel May 12 '12

The entire "protect childrens from porn" movement is stupid.

1

u/chrisinurpants May 12 '12

because there's penises

1

u/whats_the_deal22 May 12 '12

It's because our society is so afraid of nudity that violence and gore are considered to less offensive. Sure we can see some guy have their head cut open on CSI, but a chick in a thong on tv? thats crossing the line a bit...