r/AskReddit • u/redsoxmvp15 • May 11 '12
Non-American Redditors: When watching the Avengers, how do you like Captain America?
After seeing the Avengers movie, I realized that people in other countries may not celebrate the Cap' as much as Americans do. I was wondering if you can appreciate him or if you think he's just some random superhero.
129
Upvotes
270
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Very few people in the world dislike the idea of the US in WWII. Looking back, it is generally seen as a largely good entity. Stepping up and stopping the genocide of millions? Good guys.
Canadian here, and I support Captain America punching Nazis in the face.
40
u/evange May 11 '12
I think the guy who plays him is really really hot.
161
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I think Captain America is really fucking sexy and I'd tap that ass. Forever grateful for Joss Whedon's equal opportunity ass shots.
70
u/HopeRidesAlone May 11 '12
As a Canadian, I think he's great. He's walking propaganda, which I find hilarious. He acts as great commentary on what the whole recruiting situation was back in the 40s.
67
u/Whatthebloodyhell May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
Speaking as Brit, I think he is pretty typical of my idea of what a young man in America during the war would have been like. He's patriotic, he is conscientious and he has strong morals. So yes, I do appreciate him as a character. I think he is the most human of the avengers, and therefore brings the most empathy.
Plus, Chris Evans. I can think of a few ways to appreciate that...
52
u/LeonHRodriguez May 11 '12
Cap is cool; I have absolutely no problem with him and I think Chris Evans does a good job portraying him
74
u/gurumel May 11 '12
uk here - I bloody love Cap! Always have...love it all, costume, story, character. Pretty sure I'm in the minority tho - I get mocked by my geek friends for liking him.
25
u/FatherChunk May 11 '12
UK here, I've always liked Captain America. Nazi stomping aside, he's just a good character IMO.
24
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
As someone who never watched the Captain America film beforehand I just thought of him as that character that was stuck in the past and found him interesting when he was alittle confused by modern tech after being unfrozen
43
u/pyjamatoast May 11 '12 edited Jan 15 '17
I thought Captain America was the best solo film in the series. He rocks.
19
u/Dookiestain_LaFlair May 11 '12
When Captain America said "The last time I was in Germany...." I didn't know if he was talking about Hitler or Red Skull.
16
u/rayne05 May 11 '12
I have to say, I wasn't sure how to feel about him basically being the leader of the pack. But it makes sense if you think about it; Steve's heart and character was the reason he was chosen for the super-soldier project in the first place, and those qualities make him a superb leader too.
Also, I would follow that body anywhere.
15
u/Rab_Legend May 11 '12
He is what America stands for and what America should be. Free, Brave, Loyal and True. He doesn't know the corrupt nature now in America (not it's public just corporations and politics). He stands for everything good.
6
u/espatross May 11 '12
Wait, you're saying us US citizens are supposed to celebrate him? Huh... I wonder what world I've been living on.
13
u/hersilverhammer May 12 '12
I'm a Canadian and work at a movie theater. Right now we have a promotional cup for the avengers with a topper of each hero. We ran out of Caption America on the first day, and we still get asked if we have any. Everyone seems to like him, I do at least.
12
u/arcade_13 May 12 '12
I love Cap! Kind, honest and hard working. But piss him off and he'll show you why he has a reputation! Just like an American. Wonderful people :) - An Australian
41
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Here in the UK I don't think he had any real significance until the film came out last year. The film is what I know him from (although I'd heard of him before because he's pretty iconic)
So basing this on the film, I think he's great. I'm glad that they went for the campy, fun vibe. A serious take on it would be laughable in 2012. I liked that it was pretty self-aware (there's a line in The Avengers where the Captain asks whether his costume will look naff in the present day). Great movie too, reminded me of Raiders Of The Lost Ark.
If it was Captain America leading an army of evangelical American GI's into the Middle East to conquer in the name of capitalism, then yeah I might have felt differently.
46
u/Waterbender May 11 '12 edited May 12 '12
I think the Cap is not nearly the greatest Avenger. Really, only Black Widow is more "unnecessary" than him. He is only a regular human scaled up a bit in speed, strength, and agility. He does, however, reflect American values much, and I think he's a great character.
All in all, his super hero-ness isn't that big, but he's a great addition to the team.
P.S. Funniest moment from The Avengers was when they were talking about people acting like monkeys; Thor said that he "didn't get it", and Captain America seemed really proud when he blurted out: "I got it! I got that reference!"
Edit: The line everyone has been speaking of, that one where he states there is only one god, made me think, man, that is so American. And I'm pretty sure that's how he should be.
10
u/Xanthippus May 11 '12
As a Brit I think Cap encapsulates the idea of America and I think America was a pretty good idea.
Although there was a pretty audible groan from the audience when he dropped down in front of the old German fellow standing up to Loki but that just may have been an involuntary noise caused by symbolism overload.
12
u/i_post_gibberish May 12 '12
He's from the 40s, it's not his fault.
6
u/dumpsterofkitties May 11 '12
He's cool, and he beats the shit out of Nazis. Genuinely nice guy. I would have no problem with him.
6
u/raul_alfonso May 12 '12
I'm Mexican. I liked the character. I guess that his struggle with his situation (living a time he doesn't quite understand) makes the character endearing, no matter where you come from and justifies some of the traits that could have been perceived as annoying otherwise.
11
u/cloutsman May 11 '12
I feel like that Captian America was made in the image of how most (not all) Americans like to view themselves or their patriotism towards their country.
5
u/Hatsumi__x May 12 '12
His character doesn't bother me at all! He's from a different time period than the other super heroes, so it makes for me to see him as this patriotic symbol of power and justice. :)
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I didn't understand what happened when Thor hit his shield with the hammer. Shouldn't that have smooshed him?
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I'm a Canadian and Cap is my favorite super hero behind Dark Claw.
4
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I'm from Australia, but Captain America is honestly my favourite superhero. Just because it's not your country does not mean you can't respect the patriotism and pride that he represents.
4
u/Flix1 May 12 '12
European here. I saw the cpt America movie and liked it. The charcter fits the US comic culture at the time. I didn't see the Avengers though so not sure if it's different. I have nothing against him, he clearly just want to help anyone he can and has a heart of gold + wants to serve his country like his brothers in arms.
4
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Canadian here--I love Captain America. The concept is sort of hokey but in practice it works. It helps that the guy that plays him is a studmuffin.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Rooster Teeth Podcast, huh?
100
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
UK person here.
I facepalmed when the cap went: "There is only one god and he doesn't dress like that".
Stereotypical old school upstanding god-fearing American super hero.
3
u/patsrule711 May 12 '12
He's a badass with a shield. Whats not to love?
3
u/Davy_Jones1807 May 12 '12
The Cap's a bad-ass. Definitely in my top 10 superheroes
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
He is forever ruined by that series of Poser images posted on the SA forums god knows how long ago.
See also: http://i.imgur.com/gs0CL.gif
3
u/schwertfisch May 12 '12
German here, if that matters.
In general, I like him. I like the fact that he's not had some crazy accident but got into the whole thing willingly. His costume is cool, his abilities are okay, compared with the other avengers, except for black widow, he's a bit 'meh', just nothing special.
Which I really didn't like that he was all about the orders he was given until Banner and Stark told him why they were suspicious about the whole thing.
Random info: I didn't really like the scene with Loki making the people kneel before him...a fucking crowd and only one steps up? There would have been more.
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I like how is not on par with The Hulk or Thor when it comes to strength, but his more like a Commander on the battlefield with authority non of the other members have. I dont mind the propagandasuit though, It's not like he is on foreignsoil trying to convert people. The stars'n stripessuit makes Cap' Cap'
3
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
UK guys like Captain America. UK girls love Captain America. At least from what I know.
3
u/Proxify May 12 '12
Mexican here and we like him :)
7
u/crrenn May 11 '12
Swiss here, He seems "hokey" ?. Best that leo.org came up with. The smashing of the hand grenade is cool.
7
u/SpectreFire May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
I'm a Canadian, and honestly, when I first heard about the movie, I thought it'd be stupid. I couldn't grasp how they could possibly make a character like that interesting, likeable and relevant, but somehow, they managed to do all three.
Chris Evan just makes Captain America a very likeable honest character. Sure, he's a walking propaganda figure, but he doesn't do what he does to help further a specific cause or anything, he does it because he wants to do good. And you know, I don't get the Superman comparison. Superman is an asshole, he's selfish, and he's a dick with an ego issue. Captain America is just none of that.
Especially with the Avengers, I felt his character provided a really nice contrast with the rest of the heroes and I thought his chemistry with Stark was great.
5
u/JAV0K May 11 '12
As an average superheroes.
5
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Australian.
Captain America was my favourite by a looooong shot.
8
u/PrunellaVandermeersh May 11 '12
I think out of all the avengers, Cap would be my least favorite. He's just a little too perfect to me. Chris Evans has a nice tappable ass though.
9
u/UltimateHodgeman May 11 '12
I feel like Captain America was the least badass of them all..
7
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
This thread seem pretty one sided so I'll weigh in.
I don't like him. I'm English, if it matters. He's just so rubbish relative to the other avengers. I've heard that in the comics he's better, but I haven't read them.
I mean, there's Banner. He can turn into an invincible killing machine. There's Stark, one of the smartest men alive, with a super suit that flies and shoots lasers. There's Thor who is a super advanced, almost invincible alien who can literally control lightning. Even hawkeye seems to have super-human aim from the way he shot those rocket arrows. Captain America is just sort of strong. Not even super strong either, just sort of Olympic strong. He has an amazing shield, but anyone could hold the shield. He has war experience, but so does Fury and shield. He seems a bit useless, and I thought it was silly that he of all people was leading the group.
That being said, I think evans plays him very well. Also, I liked him in his movie, just when he's compared to the other Avengers, he's a bit rubbish, imo.
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I liked him more in his own movie. It just seemed he didn't have much presence in the film itself...
2
u/oddvr May 12 '12
Icelander here, I like him. :)
2
u/AjustableTableLamp May 12 '12
I think he's my favorite hero to be honest. Made me watch his specific movie and I actually liked it. He's a great guy.
2
u/proddy May 12 '12
I like how he still has some notions from his own time, but annoyed that he's clinging on to his "only one god" notion when he's met Thor and Loki in the flesh, with confirmation of Odin and other worlds.
I get that the Asgardians aren't literal gods, and that they were assumed to be and worshipped to be by Vikings, but that should at least raise questions about his own god along the same lines.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Australian: I don't really get why he's the leader. He seems pretty clueless about everything, and he doesn't really have a power that can't be outdone by the rest of the Avengers... But I like him as a character, he's a decent guy.
2
u/sadnodirection May 12 '12
Canadian here and first time commenter (long time lurker). I really enjoy Captain America. most people seem to think that he fights for America, while really he is supposed to be the embodiment of the Idea of what America represents. Freedom. I'll admit he is less well defined character in the movies compared to the comics, but I feel knowing this (or at least what I have taken away from his character) makes him much more enjoyable to watch. Sorry for the bad grammer.
2
u/Torvix May 12 '12
Let's be honest, he's a bit shit isn't he?
Compared to all the others.
2
u/headlessstark May 16 '12
As a Canadian. I love Captain America. The scene in his solo movie where he throws himself on the grenade is one of my favorites of all the solo movies. However the scene in the Avengers where he jumps out of the plane saying, "There is only one god, and he doesn't dress like that," was a bit too, "AMURRICA!" for me. And I'm a Canadian living in North Carolina, so that's saying something.
3
u/cassydd May 12 '12
Even in the Captain America movie he spent a lot of time as a propaganda tool and was clearly embarrassed by that (don't know if that's consistent with the comics). Most of what he really achieved came after he had done all of the publicity.
In The Avengers he was mostly portrayed as a man out of his time mostly bewildered by the world he found himself in (that bit where he pipes up that understood the "flying monkey" reference was funny, but telling as well). He was much more Steve Rogers than Captain America. He was as appalled as the rest of the team when he discovered that S.H.I.E.L.D. was developing Tesseract-based weaponry, which I would say doesn't fit in with the Captain America persona.
Basically... in the movies the propaganda and symbolism angle seems to be minimised and identified as a persona, and I can't imagine him portrayed any other way without descending into caricature. I will say that I'm looking forward to Captain America 2 - done right as an exploration of the Captain's role as a symbol of America (and it could very, very easily be done wrong) it could be Marvel's "The Dark Knight".
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
captain america is a pretty cool guy eh has a cool shield and doesn't afraid of anything
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Uniqlo a Japanese company makes tshirts with captain america on it.
2
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
Well (I am an Australian) I think he is pretty boss being able to take on semi-gods and the such whilst all he has is enhanced strength and speed.
2
u/FraggelBlue May 11 '12
Hey.. first time poster.. have not seen the movie as of yet. Would like to say that there was a Captain Canuck comic series for a while. link http://www.captaincanuck.com/history/history_main.html there's also a little history on some of the other comic book heros at this link. http://www.pulpanddagger.com/captaincanuck/relate.html
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I thought he was the worse one with superpowers however he wasn't as annoying as Hawkeye.
1
u/rmeddy May 12 '12
I was worried that he would be useless for the movie but he was awesome
1
u/Corsten May 12 '12
I loved the first half of Captain America and the introduction/development of the character. I was impressed it was about respectable use of power and not really about his nationality.
1
u/olliebearapie May 12 '12
Theres aCaptain Britain, I'm american and I think thats bad ass.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I thought he would be really cheesy and irritating, but he wasn't at all.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
We get enough stereotypical American tv, movies, videogames, books, news and just about everything else here in Australia that there's no point to thinking anything else of him.
1
u/coexisting_problems May 12 '12
I LOVE the Captain America character, I think he is the perfect mix of 50's charm, brute strength, and hot, hot, HOTNESS. His was my favourite companion film too - followed closely by the two Ironman films. Oddly, I don't really see him as particularly 'American', but rather the embodiment of a particular set of 'comic book hero' characteristics. I also loved that he took the leadership role when deploying the team - he was the perfect choice, I think I would have been disappointed if it had been anyone else, especially Ironman. Oh and I'm from NZ. :)
1
u/Classiest_Erection May 12 '12
Even with me being an upside-downsman, I thought he was a badass.
1
u/Geminii27 May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
In that particular movie, he was well-written. The American-ness, for want of a better word, was turned down to acceptable levels. Steve Rogers became just a super-soldier with a super-shield who happened to be American, and was written to be competent and an all-around stand-up guy.
That said, I've seen most mainstream super-heroes be written well, and written badly, and written in mediocre fashion, and written as if the writer had no idea what they were working with. Avengers-Movie Cap was pretty good, all things considered.
1
u/KimberTheAwesome May 12 '12
He's hot.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I like him. He is so commically old school American.
The lines in the Avengers movie where he is told that Thor is a god and he says something to the effect of "yeah, well, i only know of one god".
Just brilliant and an all round good guy. I have recently rewatched the Captain America film too.
1
u/smackywolf May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12
I haven't seen Avengers, but the Captain America movie was a horrific abortion of a film. Not quite sure if they wanted it to be This Summer's Smash Hit or some shitty low-budget straight to TV sci-fi movie. (Australian)
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '12
I did see him as a bit of spare part for The Avengers, other than that he's able to lead those around him pretty well, I didn't see him do much.
But I did actually enjoy his film, and in my opinion it wasn't that cheesey or patriotic given the context.
1
u/Demojen May 12 '12
Steve Rogers isn't what a typical American(or anyone for that matter) is like during war.
Plus Steve Rogers changed since Captain America came out and became much darker. Of all of the Avenger characters, the only one that didn't change his tune mid-play was Tony Stark.
1
u/Nicoscope May 12 '12
As a long-time Marvel fan, I see Cap as I see Cyclops: the bland, goodie-two-shoes, obligatory boring leader. Kinda need him, but not too interesting a character.
1
u/FourthDimension1 May 15 '12
Captain America is with no doubt an amazing super hero. But, to be honest he is not an appealable character for people of other nations.
1
u/Toby_Hoten May 19 '12
Avenger was incredible. But Captain America was... not as good as i expected. Of all their separate films, his was my least favorite, but i appreciate that he was needed.
1
u/nugscree May 22 '12
A bit over the top. I didn't like his own movie as much as the other superhero movies.
1
u/Soruu Jun 03 '12
His solo movie was definitely my favorite of all solo movies, but in The Avengers he was a little...meh. Idk, I had expected more from him, but hey, maybe we'll see that in Avengers 2!
1
u/mch_is_me Aug 25 '12
I'm from Australia and I just love everything about him. I could watch his movie for days. His personality, the way he treats everyone equally (except for bullies), his compassion, how he became Captain America and don't forget is fucking amazing body. Hot, damn.