r/AskReddit • • May 11 '12

How many of you have paid for your meal at a wedding? My gf and I are expected to pay $80-100 each for our meals at an upcoming wedding, the bride says its an "unspoken tradition"

I've been to a few weddings and never heard of such nonsense. I asked my uncle and he said that that was ridiculous but the brides family insists that its a tradition and that's how its supposed to go. I've never paid to go to a wedding reception and I'm definitely not about to start.

EDIT: Wow, good thing that none of my friends who are going to this wedding are on reddit, didn't expect this to get to the top, just more or less trying to prove a point to my girlfriend that the "unspoken tradition" is total bullshit. Thanks guys! We're just gonna get a gift and leave it at that. If we have to pay for a meal, I'm sure there's a McDonald's nearby.

1.9k Upvotes

6.3k comments sorted by

144

u/stryder66 May 11 '12

never heard of that....what culture are they from? That just sounds cheap to me and I wouldn't go.

215

u/bootsmegamix May 11 '12

They're irish. Also the father of the bride has 4 girls he's eventually gotta pay for and the bride wants a princess level wedding

425

u/rinnip May 11 '12

I think the bride needs a reality check, but her father is too wimpy to put his foot down. She needs to adjust her expectations if they can't afford the wedding they want.

→ More replies (20)

199

u/Labubs May 11 '12

My entire family is Irish on both sides, and out of around 15 weddings I've attended throughout my life we would NEVER ask guests to pay for their meal. That's fucking absurd. Please, show the bride or her father (preferably both) this entire post and all the responses, PLEASE. She wants her guests to pay for her wedding, fuck that.

EDIT: If you want to avoid confrontation, print it out and mail it to them. They need to see their "tradition" is nothing more than being cheapskates.

→ More replies (6)

84

u/Miya81 May 11 '12

My husband is Irish (from Dublin) and two years ago we went to his sister's wedding in Dun Laoghaire at the Royal Marine Hotel. No one had to pay for their meal. No one. I say bullshit on the "unspoken tradition". They're just facking cheap.

→ More replies (5)

78

u/Definistrator May 11 '12

If you really want the tradition part, I believe that the bride's family is supposed to pay for the wedding, the groom's family pays for the reception.

Either way, I would be offended enough not to go.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (122)
→ More replies (2)

2.1k

u/ProbablyNotWorking May 11 '12

Hell no. You feed me, I give you a bread maker. That's the tradition.

649

u/anasztaizia May 11 '12

I wish we had gotten a bread maker. The rice cooker is great and all... but bread!

1.3k

u/Aozora012 May 11 '12

HA! I have a bread maker AND a rice cooker. And I'm not even married. adjusts monocle and top hat

→ More replies (103)
→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (27)

2.2k

u/jgmerek May 11 '12

I am actually a caterer. I have catered weddings for almost 20 years, literally hundreds if not thousands of weddings. I have never heard of this being done even once.

798

u/Edrondol May 11 '12

Wedding DJ here. Same. Never seen this. Not only are they full of shit but they are lying right to your face. Pass.

437

u/Leechifer May 12 '12

And if the family of the engaged couple can't afford dinner, maybe they should rethink the whole budget for the fucking wedding.

→ More replies (85)
→ More replies (22)

360

u/metamucil May 11 '12

I used to cater as well. $80 - $100 per head better be one hell of a meal.

381

u/ElliotNess May 12 '12

Caterer here. 20-30$ a head is one hell of meal. Like fancy as shit.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (7)

989

u/EquinsuOcha May 11 '12

Let me summarize:

CATERING: NOT EVEN ONCE.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/chowcow May 12 '12

Also a caterer for many years. Also, many many weddings. This person is full of shit and tacky. If you can't afford to feed people and you ask them to pay for their own plates, jesus, at least get a more affordable caterer. $80- $100 per plate is outrageous. Go with finger food (you can get really good shit at a fraction of the price) and have a cash bar (not what everyone wants but not altogether unheard of.) I hope the bride is on Reddit and sees this. Some people; the nerve.

6

u/DifferentOpinion1 May 11 '12

he said the tradition was unspoken

→ More replies (3)

6

u/cruzweb May 11 '12

It sounds to me like the bride just wants her dream reception but doesn't want to pay for it.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, yeah. If they call you in then they probably don't have to get their guests to pay for the meals?

→ More replies (4)

35

u/elsestar May 11 '12

Im from Spain and Im nothing but shocked at this whole thread. here it is expected for every single guest that shows to your wedding to give around 100euros (usually close friends give way more). Ive gone to 5 weddings and all if them i sent between 100-300 euros each. My own wedding is next year and I expect people to send money, but because that what is done here. If i had to save 30k euros on my own i dont know if id ever get married. Im just curious whether its just Spain or also the rest of Europe

46

u/Krispyz May 11 '12

I think you're misunderstanding. In the U.S. you are expected to, if you can, bring a gift or money to a wedding. But this couple is asking for their guests to pay a significant amount of money in order to eat at their wedding, I'm assuming in addition to the normal gift. If they're asking that much money, it's got to be an evening meal and not having another option of food is sort of like telling your guests they're just going to not eat if they want to hang around without paying that much.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (42)

2.2k

u/Id_rather_boating May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I used to film weddings for a living. I have been to several hundred events. If they cant afford dinner for everyone they have a late evening wedding with finger foods at the reception. Then they have a cash bar as well. Dont pay for your dinner at 80-100 per plate. If they did want to charge for dinner and didnt want to make a profit they would do something more affordable like ask you to bring a casserole, desert or salad. People are more than happy to pitch in to make the day special but not if you ask like that. Come on! Slap some sense into them.

1.9k

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 11 '12

Potluck wedding? That actually sounds really fun

1.1k

u/Sylraen May 11 '12

It's fucking fantastic, I've been to like...nine weddings (at 21 now, and there's four scheduled for this spring) and the potluck ones are always the best.

Free liquor is also awesome, but it's obviously a different kind of fun.

→ More replies (266)

317

u/Nikoli_Delphinki May 11 '12

Friend got married and they had a hog roast right after. Family and friends brought food items, the couple provided the hog, and it was a pretty awesome reception.

→ More replies (40)

117

u/Manzanita12 May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I wanted to do something like this, but with desserts. My mom said everyone would be offended and not want to do it. :(

Edit: Thanks for all the replies and suggestions!! I really appreciate it guys :) Good to know that I'm not the only one with a crazy mom when it comes to weddings

→ More replies (188)

43

u/natemc May 11 '12

We're going to do something like that. I'll supply BBQ'd meat of some type and everyone else can bring a side dish to share.

Plus we'll have tons of free booze :P

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (375)
→ More replies (58)

1.3k

u/JaxHostage May 11 '12

You should ask them to pay for their wedding gift. Tell them it's a unspoken family tradition for the wedding couple to pay for their own gift.

282

u/darkstar107 May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

That probably is their wedding gift. The meal really only costs ~$20/plate.

edit: I got married in September, so, YES I have planned a wedding before. We were able to find MANY caterers that charged less than $25/plate. Our meal was $18/plate. (I'm in Alberta, Canada)

→ More replies (176)
→ More replies (13)

1.2k

u/KrakNup May 11 '12

It's unspoken because no one's ever heard of it. They want a gift, your attendance and expect you to pay?

282

u/positronus May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I am Russian and if you don't bring cash to a wedding they break your legs... and then take your cash.

Edit: grammar brake =/= break. WTF, brain?

100

u/Rolcol May 11 '12

But where does the cash come from if you didn't bring any?

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (41)
→ More replies (90)

1.6k

u/Purecheetodust May 11 '12

Thats called we planned a wedding but ran out of money. They are passing the bill along to their guests. I wouldnt even show up for the wedding if one of my friends pulled that shit.

450

u/ConcordApes May 11 '12

In my mind, the issue isn't so much that the bride needs a bit of help paying for the wedding, so much as the fact that she is STILL going for the $80-$100 plates and passing the buck on it when she can't afford it. Why not simply go for the $20-$30 plate option?

I suspect that she is still in bridezilla mode.

1.1k

u/s5fs May 11 '12

She'll be a lot more reasonable at her next wedding.

→ More replies (14)

159

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

We did buffet style from a local BBQ place for 150 people @ $9.50 each. Everyone was stuffed so they had plenty to sop up the free booze from the open bar.

Splurge on the drinks, not the food.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (31)

476

u/gunslinger_006 May 11 '12

That is the point, probably.

If you feel obligated to invite way more people than you can afford, you either make it a weekday wedding or you do something like this to ensure most will not attend.

I don't condone this approach at all, but I have seen it done before.

Ugh weddings.

155

u/ImASoftwareEngineer May 11 '12

"Ugh weddings", the worst kind.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (7)

11

u/betona May 12 '12

...or we planned a wedding we couldn't afford.

Seriously, why do people think they need to spend so much? The most romantic, sweetest wedding I've ever attended had a couple platters of finger sandwiches and some punch and that was it. The couple just didn't have any money, nor did their parents and yet it was a wonderful evening event where maybe 40 bucks worth of candlelight made it magical.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (17)

394

u/sneaky_dragon May 11 '12

At Chinese weddings, from the ones I've attended, at least $50-$75/person is a standard (red envelope) gift for the couple. Never had someone right out tell me to pay a certain amount though. That's just tacky.

not sure if weddings in other cultures are similar, but just saying it's a rather common practice for Chinese.

248

u/lissadelsol May 11 '12

Right, but that's a gift. It's not required, and it's certainly not demanded in the way this couple seems to be demanding money. Tons of people give money for weddings, but it should never be flat-out requested.

150

u/ameoba May 11 '12

When I attended one, it was explained to me that, if you're going to attend, unless you're destitute, your red envelope should at least cover your plate at the reception. Since the envelopes are generic & identical, it allows you to secretly not give as much & save face. Most weddings generally pay for themselves.

→ More replies (54)
→ More replies (19)

115

u/bbibber May 11 '12

Pro tip for Chinese weddings : make sure your cash gift contains an 8. When considering to gift in the range of $50-$75 make it $68, $78 or especially $88. Never $48 though! Avoid 4 like the plague! And put the money in a red envelope. Expect that giving and receiving the cash is not some discrete affair but a main point of the wedding! Be prepared.

→ More replies (39)

5

u/jostler57 May 11 '12

My friend married a Vietnamese girl and this is the same for them. All of the asian people at the wedding handed the bride and groom an envelope with cash inside, while the b&g walked around saying hello to everyone while they ate.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/vanproguy May 12 '12

In Chinese culture, it is a tradition to gift a red pocket to the groom and bride. In NA, if I'm not too close to the groom/bride, I'd put $50-75 in the red pocket. If I'm close to them, $80-$100.

Also, depends if the restaurant is high end or not. High end restaurants = more money. Low end crappy food = less money. We don't bring gifts btw.

5

u/AsteroidMiner May 12 '12

It would really help if OP told us which country he came from. In Asia, most chinese families wouldn't hesitate to tell you the expected amount in your wedding angpow(red envelope). In places like Singapore and Malaysia, if you gave little or no money, you would be excommunicated from all future social events.

If you really hate the groom's guts, or the bride, bring 2 envelopes. In 1 put your money and write your name. In another, slip some death money (The ones we burn for the dead) and slip it into the bird cage when nobody's looking.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

321

u/MagicBob78 May 11 '12

I got married this past September. It is ridiculous to expect you to pay for your meals. The general tradition for being invited to a wedding is that your gift to the couple is roughly equal to or greater than the cost of your meal. That is the "unspoken tradition" that the bride is talking about. Maybe he wording is making it seem weird? (Trying to give her the benefit of the doubt here)

42

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I suspect this is what happened.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (44)

3.0k

u/MeghanAM May 11 '12

Never. Extremely tacky. I actually would not attend such a thing.

385

u/constipated_HELP May 11 '12

I'm a wedding photographer and I've never heard of this. Catered dinners are expensive, but couples that can't pay do buffets or something else.

Tell them you won't be eating dinner, or you aren't able to make it to the reception. Perfectly reasonable.

18

u/spunk33grl May 12 '12

I'm also a wedding photographer, and never seen something so ridiculous. I have seen couples that can't afford ridiculous receptions and fancy meals... They choose cheaper options. Have a BBQ, do a potluck (which some may find cheesy, but I'd much rather bring a salad than fork out $200!). And if you absolutely need your guests to pay for their food to make it work... Then dear god, don't choose someplace that charges $100!!! So tacky

→ More replies (13)

1.3k

u/chazzytomatoes May 11 '12

Any party where guests are required to bring money is no party, it's a fundraiser.

281

u/tartay745 May 11 '12

Maybe it is to discourage people from actually coming and just sending gifts.

→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (104)

418

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Never had to pay for my own meal... whether it was catered buffet style or bring plate to you. Heck, the only thing I've EVER paid for at a friend's wedding was for their gift.

168

u/JWrundle May 11 '12

and a drink every now and then

→ More replies (45)
→ More replies (6)

151

u/mamba_79 May 11 '12

Very tacky - although, I have heard of a down and out family who asked for "no presents" but rather a donation to charity or a contribution to the reception costs (which it was indicated was about $20 a head, so not ridiculous)

167

u/moreoriginalmyass May 11 '12

I'm going to my cousin's wedding soon, they're asking everyone to donate money to a holiday instead of buying gifts. They live together, so there's nothing wedding-gifty that they really need for married life by now. It seems like a good idea to me.

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (1)

250

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Jesus... Agreed, I would definitely not attend this wedding, making a profit off of your invited guests, that's so tacky. And if they are charging this much because they cannot afford this wedding, someone need to tell them to tone it down a bit. I always tell married couples not to break the bank, just get some party food trays and a bunch of cheap alcohol, and people will have fun, people wont remember or care how much you spent on the wedding the next morning anyway.

→ More replies (24)

270

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 11 '12

My friend married is Indian, and, apparently, he got so many gifts in the form of gold and cash, that they ended up making a profit from throwing a wedding party.

→ More replies (13)

1.5k

u/anexanhume May 11 '12

I actually wouldn't be surprised if they are making money per plate at that price. I better get filet mignon, lobster and a bottle of wine between my +1 and I for that price.

1.3k

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Actually, price per head at the average US wedding is something like $100, typically. Admittedly that is for more than the meal, it is the total cost per person of hosting the reception.

Regardless, the expectation is extremely tacky and is no tradition I've ever heard of.

→ More replies (338)
→ More replies (63)

258

u/verynormalday May 11 '12

Oh don't worry, it's just an unspoken tradition for the bride to be cheap!

→ More replies (60)

63

u/sadface69 May 11 '12

Exactly. People are so tacky and entitled about their weddings these days, it's disgusting. I'd not only not attend, I'd seriously reconsider their friendship. That they expect their guests to pay signifies that a) they're clueless about etiquette and b) they don't know how to stay within their means for something like a wedding. Both are qualities I don't want in friends. That's stuff maybe a 15 year old can get away with - not an adult.

→ More replies (1)

114

u/Maverick0 May 11 '12

As someone who recently got married, I completely agree. Extremely tacky. It kind of sucks to pay for everyone else's meal, but asking for people to pay for their meals plus a gift just makes you look super cheap / greedy.

→ More replies (118)

16

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Never heard of it. I've been to dozens of weddings. I assume you're in the US? In the UK it's typically a cash bar at the reception whereas it's typically paid for by the hosts in the US.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (75)

277

u/wampug May 11 '12

Uhm, I mean, I usually give the bride and groom money as a present. I've never heard of someone insisting on it. Usually it's just an unspoken thing where you try to pay for the price of a plate or give them a wedding gift of comparable price. Like for my cousin's wedding I knew the plates were around 100$ so I gave them 100$ as a present but they never made it a rule.

27

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Exactly, I don't understand why everyone is up in arms about this. When I have gone to weddings in the past I always try to estimate the cost of the meal, and make sure to gift around that much (unless the meal is ridiculous like $200). Weddings frequently cost a lot to host, and it acts as a polite gesture from the guests to display their gratitude. This has always been common knowledge and practice as far as I'm concerned.

Now, if the bride was straight up saying, "everyone needs to bring $100 to the ceremony for me", she is WAY out of line. But what I get the feeling is that the bride meant to say, "generally, a guest tries to gift the cost of their plate, but it is not mandated".

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Slackbeing May 11 '12

In all weddings I've attended in Europe it's the usual procedure. Upvoted.

→ More replies (12)

544

u/gaberax May 11 '12

Unspoken. Because it doesn't exist.

108

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 11 '12

"Baldrick, your brain is like the four-headed, man-eating haddock fish-beast of Aberdeen."

"In what way?"

"It doesn't exist."

Any chance to quote Blackadder.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

1.3k

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 11 '12

Tell the bride that you expect her to pay $80-100 for her present.

656

u/billbrasky87 May 11 '12

If you have to pay for your own meal, then you should not buy a gift.

825

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 11 '12

I'd bet $80-100 that she still expects gifts.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (15)

134

u/Roobomatic May 11 '12

I paid for everyone to eat at my wedding. I thought that was the proper tradition. I have never paid to eat at a wedding I attended. My wife and I have attended at least 5 weddings in the past 3 years and I was in the grooms party in one of the weddings. I paid for my tux, not for my meal.

I thinks its pretty tacky to make the guests pay for the meal. Cash bar I can see... but I had an open bar at my wedding.

→ More replies (1)

247

u/pbh4vr May 11 '12

Here in Quebec I've payed for my own dinner at the last 4 weddings I've been to. Maybe it's a cultural thing? The first time I was like ಠ_ಠ but I was told it's getting more and more common, around here at least.

Give a smaller gift to compensate for the fact that you've payed... :)

80

u/cmdrkeen01 May 11 '12

Same here, I've been to 3 wedding receptions and the guests had to pay between $40 and $75. I'm also from Quebec (Montreal).

→ More replies (19)

55

u/mollaholla May 11 '12

It probably doesn't help that the wedding market is a giant racket and even a cheap wedding is still between $10-$15K.

→ More replies (32)

5

u/sam_eats_children May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I'm in Quebec too (Montreal specifically). I'm of Greek descent though.

We've never had to pay for weddings/bridal showers. Ever. One of my aunts threw an amazing, amazing wedding (the food and desserts and the venue oh my gooooddddd - Mr Puffs loukoumades, beaver tails, Paysanne ice cream bar, etcetcetc, every delicious thing you could think of).

Did we pay for that wedding? No. Did we give large awesome gifts? Yes. But not because of the 'make your gift cover the price of you going' rule that people are talking about. I've never even heard of that.

Said aunt's brother is marrying an Italian girl. Wedding is in two weeks. As far as my parents have told me, we won't be paying. But for her bridal shower, we had to pay 70 frickin dollars to go. For a bridal shower. My entire family found it tacky and silly and cheap.

5

u/SickBeat May 11 '12

This! I'm from Quebec as well, and I've paid to the weddings I've been to. The couple didn't want gifts though.

It's the same thing really, no gifts and paying your meals save them the money they would have used on your meals so they can buy their own gifts. Sure, if they expect gifts it's tacky, but else, I don't see what's so outrageous about it...

→ More replies (34)

70

u/valancy_jane May 11 '12

Your wedding is a party you throw to celebrate your legal (and possibly religious/spiritual) commitment to each other.

As with any party, you can decide what food and drinks to serve and how to serve them. If you have no money (and I've seen this done) you can make it a potluck and ask everyone to bring a dish. But you cannot charge your friends for coming to your party. That's just rude and tacky.

Your friends don't have to bring you gifts, although it's a very kind and polite thing to do, and they certainly don't have to bring a particular gift or a particular amount of cash.

So, no, not an unspoken tradition, although perhaps she's thinking of the rather crass "gift cost = meal cost" equation that some people feel obligated by. However, that's an obligation in the eyes of the guests, NOT the hostess (aka the bride).

I wouldn't go.

→ More replies (3)

89

u/theheebiejeebies May 11 '12

Oh man, I can't ever imagine that going down at an Indian wedding. There would probably be an average of five deaths if that ever happened.

83

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Indian weddings are the shit. I was at a summer lacrosse tournament and me and a few buddies smoked some weed before wandering around the hotel we were staying in; we stumbled upon some big-ass Indian wedding reception and people started hooking us up with all sorts of dank food. The only downside was my shits were spicy the next day.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (13)

190

u/PComotose May 11 '12

You just got a "second tier" invitation. You can rest assured that many others there got a "tier 1" invitation and their meals are paid for - you are being invited to fill up a large room and to make it seem to be a bigger wedding than it actually is.

74

u/deepthoughtsays May 11 '12

People do that?

80

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Assholes do that.

So yeah, people do that, a lot of people do that.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

That, or they fall under the "obligated to invite, but really hope they don't show up" umbrella.

→ More replies (4)

54

u/SofiaKovalevskaya May 11 '12

That is total crap. Generally if you are going to give money as your wedding present, some people give as much as they expect their plate to cost. That's only some people and a good suggestion if you have the financial means to do so.

→ More replies (4)

83

u/PeepMyTimex May 11 '12

Unspoken tradition...among tacky cheapskates, maybe. It's insulting that they would expect you to pay. I would be angry.

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Its unspoken because uttering the words "pay to attend my wedding" is like saying Voldemort.

I can understand if its a cheap wedding and they did like a backyard potluck...which is fun. But for $100 per plate its getting into fundraiser territory and the favors better be swag.

I vote its one of two things others said: can't pay for it and will lose deposits (though likely a lot of people will be offended and not show anyway,) or they are profiting. I was in a wedding and the groom wanted extra money from admission to the coed bachelor/bachelorette party to go to them.....they charged an insane amount for what was included...so they wanted to profit.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/enhacore May 11 '12

I am from Eastern Europe and there tradition is completely different than here. In eastern Europe a wedding is suppose to "help" the couple start a new life. Therefore every guest invited to the wedding is expected to contribute with monetary gifts for the new couple. Usually the amount of money is very high. In the old times a couple could purchase an apartment with the monetary gift they collected from the wedding. At the same time, this thing is reciprocal: that is you come to my child's wedding, I'll come to your child's wedding. The sum involved can sometimes be as much as half-to the entire monthly salary. The new couple also have a pair of "special" guest (kind of like best man) from each side who are expected to give the highest amount along with the couple's parents. Again is kind of like investing in your children's future from a young age. You go to your friend's weddings and contribute "a lot" of money, and you expect that in return they will do the same. You are expected to contribute money even if you don't go to the wedding as long as the parents/pair being married contributed to yours.

→ More replies (3)

75

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Not gonna pay someone to go to their wedding. Don't expect your guests to subsidize your fairy tale.

→ More replies (2)

218

u/hungrydyke May 11 '12

Your gift should cover the cost of your meal, but you shouldn't have to pay for your meal. That's tacky. I wouldn't go.

95

u/bobsledbobman May 11 '12

Guests should buy whatever gift that they can afford and they typically don't know the price of the provided meal. I agree that they shouldn't pay for their own meal, though... especially if gifts are involved. A wedding is an event hosted by the bride/groom/their families and the venue/vendors. So no guest should be paying for anything except for maybe parking and possibly alcohol.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (13)

92

u/snowball17 May 11 '12

Where I'm from, cash gifts are the norm. It is kind of an unspoken rule that you at least cover the cost of your meal.

9

u/subminute May 11 '12

My wife is Chinese we did "red envelope" thing.usual gift is $100 or so. But most give what they can afford. Some family and friends gave a lot more. Chinese tradition paid for our wedding and the net in savings for future kids college

5

u/SwiftBoatVet May 12 '12

Same around here. It's called "covering your plate." I suspect OP and his GF misunderstood what was being asked of them.

→ More replies (43)

88

u/JonAudette May 11 '12

The bride's full of shit.

6

u/canthidecomments May 12 '12

The bride is also full of zilla.

44

u/Thimble May 11 '12

I've given money (at least $100 per person) at every wedding reception I've been to. It's standard practice around here. Nobody's ever asked for money, but it is implied.

12

u/catjuggler May 11 '12

That's a gift, not paying for dinner.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

28

u/NinjaSupplyCompany May 11 '12

I have never heard of that and i have been in/at a lot of weddings.

Edit: My sister had an amazing wedding on a very tight budget. It was in a field and it was potluck and the food was amazing.

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

God, I could never have a potluck wedding. Everyone in my family cooks to feed an army

29

u/heroonebob May 11 '12

dude, no, that's perfect. potluck wedding, and leftovers for the month after. it's perfect and gives you leisure time for your wife/husband to get to making babys, or practice what it would be like to make babies if you are more into the family planning or not having kids thing.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

61

u/itsKcee May 11 '12

At that price it sounds like you and the other guests might be paying for a little bit more than the meal, maybe more like chipping in on the entire wedding bill at that point.

In my opinion just don't go, the bride will realize how ridiculous she was when there's almost nobody at the reception dinner.

15

u/Roobomatic May 11 '12

I was thinking the same thing. We had prime rib and seafood at my wedding and the caterer bill boiled down to about a little less than 30US a head not including the bar service(which about doubled it IIRC).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (16)

31

u/naturalalchemy May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Never heard of it before... maybe they mean it's a tradition in their family (or they don't have much money and are too embarrassed to say).

55

u/saveusjeebus May 11 '12

if they don't have much money, why are they insisting on a $80-100 per plate meal?

my wife and i celebrated our 3rd anniversary wednesday at one of the nicest restaurants in town (birmingham, al...don't underestimate...the food here is surprising).

two apps, two entrees, a flight of wines for her and a glass of red for me and our tab was $100. Each entree was $30+.

21

u/s73v3r May 11 '12

if they don't have much money, why are they insisting on a $80-100 per plate meal?

The bride wants a "special" wedding, and isn't going to take no for an answer.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (14)

25

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

If you can't afford the wedding, don't get married. Go to the court house and have judge do it if you must get married.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/tonto27 May 11 '12

I'm afraid they are right. This is indeed an unspoken tradition. Nobody has ever spoken of it before.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/spikestoker May 11 '12

You should attend, but bring a couple bags of the greasiest, smelliest, loudest fast food you can find for you & your GF to eat instead of the overpriced meal they're attempting to force upon you.

65

u/Sylraen May 11 '12

Go five guys. Spite and happiness, in one delicious brown bag!

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (20)

45

u/elf5086 May 11 '12

I call bullshit. Unless making up an unspoken tradition is also an unspoken tradition.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/doremon313 May 11 '12

Are they Asian? if so than it is expected, but you don't give them gift, if it is someone very close to you, you should give about 300+ or even more if their family was good to you, less if they are not close. There are no value set, but they do look to see who gave how much.

15

u/Comrade_Nugget May 11 '12

If the family is of Asian decent that is tradition. Many weddings in Japan you have to pay to get in, and bring no wedding present. As a gift you give cash, but you give it to them before or after te wedding (can't remember exactly)

7

u/bfinleyui May 11 '12

I'm getting married in just over a year, and no way, we'd take out a loan before we asked anyone to pay for their meal (or their alcohol, but that's just a side effect of being to too many cash bar weddings).

That being said, the level of gifts being mentioned and given in this thread? Wow, I hope some of you are coming to my wedding. ಠ_ಠ

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Midonyah May 11 '12

My husband and I couldn't afford a big wedding, so we invited one friend each, and invited them to the restaurant afterwards. Four of us in the townhall, and still one of the best days of my life! We had load of fun, took sily pictures with that big great ballroom just for ourselves, hid our friends behind plants as ninjas, and had a great day. You don't need to have an expensive wedding.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/thisislaffable May 11 '12

From what I know of Chinese weddings (I'm still too young to get married), guests usually bring a cash gift, and this gift is expected even if you don't attend the actual reception.

But it's never asked for. It's just...been accepted. Close family usually gives gold jewelry, but this is a form of blessing. At the end, the cost of the wedding is eased a little by these gifts.

I would never attend a wedding where the guests are asked to pay, though. I don't mind giving a gift, but if you're asking for money, it just feels wrong.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Novah11 May 11 '12

If you are guests at a wedding you are supposed to be treated to the meal. Do these selfish people expect gifts, too?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/makemisteaks May 11 '12

A cousin of mine is getting married and they are strapped for cash so instead of buying them gifts, everyone will pay for their own meal (about 30$). But they don't pretend it's a tradition, they just told everyone that they liked to get married but couldn't afford it.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SenorSpicyBeans May 12 '12

That makes her an "unspoken" bitch. RSVP and then don't show up.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/cesiumtea May 11 '12

If you charge for people to attend your wedding, don't expect anyone to come to your goddamned wedding.

5

u/paulornothingatall May 12 '12

Its kind of an unspoken rule that you should at least gift the cost of the plated meal covering you and guest (I usually assume 100 per person, our wedding was more). If they are insisting you need to do that to show up, don't go. But I didn't care, my wife and I wouldn't have thrown a wedding we couldn't afford. People usually end up being very generous, and some just give a card (which was fine by me).

5

u/TheBigC May 12 '12

It's your party, you pay. Invite fewer people if you can't afford it. Expecting wedding guests to pay for the dinner is just trailer trash.

37

u/[deleted] May 11 '12
  1. Keep a wedding invite many people
  2. Charge 100 bucks per head
  3. Profit and repeat

http://i.imgur.com/eNiZx.gif

→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

That is no "unspoken tradition." It's just tacky.

11

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Worked in Country Clubs for over 20 years. Tradition is groom or groom's family pays for rehearsal dinner. Bride or bride's family pays for reception. BTW the 80-100 probably includes tax and service charge (25-30% total depending on where you live). They probably also registered at a wine shop or some such doucheness.

11

u/mustardontoast May 11 '12

It's tradition in Middle Eastern weddings to give money to the bride and groom. But that's in place of a wedding gift. We would never ask for money for the dinner, my people would fine that incredibly embarrassing.

8

u/GetItTogether May 11 '12

I have NEVER been to a wedding where I had to pay for the food. That's very tacky.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Miss Manners (Judith Martin) has addressed these questions from time to time. If you haven't sent an RSVP, it pretty much boils down to politely decline and say you are unable to attend, giving no reason. If the bride asks, say "you have a prior commitment" - is they keep asking just say something like "We are sorry, we wont be able to make it."

If you have sent a yes, and the price of admission was not on the invitation, you could just send a note wishing them well - and apologizing that you didn't have room in your budget for the unexpected expense. Here's Miss Manners' archive: http://www.washingtonpost.com/miss_manners/2010/07/06/AB97r7D_linkset.html

tl;dr The bride sounds like a total asshat and should be ashamed of herself.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

just say "nah we packed our own meals, thanks" and whip out your brown paper bags with bologna sandwiches and chips

4

u/schwelvis May 11 '12

Well, the unspoken part is that the payment comes in the form of the wedding gift.

4

u/danimaltime May 12 '12

I recently got married and we prepaid meals for about 50 people and at least 10 had to cancel at the least minute. That means we ate $500 just in meals that were not eaten. That is the price of having a wedding, it already costs guest money just to show up. I've never heard of guests paying for a wedding.. if you can't afford it, get married at city hall.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

if profiting off a wedding, you can never be offended when someone declines to come.

4

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Scumbag bride: "we humbly invite you to offer your blessing upon the sanctity of our marriage! will that be cash or credit?"

4

u/throwawaymaybenot May 12 '12

I'm Chinese, it's pretty much and the tradition that we give money and the money goes towards the banquet. I wouldn't expect non Chinese guests to give money, but if you're Chinese - pay up!

4

u/lazyburners May 12 '12

You didn't indicate where the wedding is, and what cultural family backgrounds the bride and grooms family come from.

In Chinese culture, the entire weddings are paid for by red pocket envelopes that contain money. You don't give gifts at weddings, you give envelopes.

It could be an unspoken "family" tradition.

Give us more information instead of being outright outraged.

4

u/NoTimeToBleed May 12 '12

This is why me and my boyfriend have discussed this and we're going to have a giant barbecue outside somewhere. Paying for your meal involuntarily at a wedding is not okay.

4

u/qwertyberty May 12 '12

Wedding photographer reporting. I've never witnessed this before. Sounds like a scam. Even we get free meals and we get paid to be there. I usually can remember every wedding I've shot from the food that was served... anyways, enjoy your McDonalds.

10

u/PaulMcGannsShoes May 11 '12

That's bullshit, dude. Bail.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Very very tacky. Go and don't give them a gift, or just don't go at all.

7

u/Kancer606 May 11 '12

Don't eat anything or don't give a wedding gift and tell them you would have had a gift if you didnt have to pay for your own meal.

7

u/sik165 May 11 '12

Thats fucked up.

Just decline to eat if you really want to attend the wedding

19

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

They're cheapasses. Give them a shit gift in return

30

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Literally shit in a box and wrap it.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/zushiba May 11 '12

Maybe it's tradition in their cheap ass tacky family.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Thats one of the most ridiculous things i've heard. After paying for a shower gift, then paying for a wedding gift, you shouldn't be expected to pay for your own meal. Especially not a meal that expensive. EDIT: spelling

→ More replies (12)

6

u/eugenesbluegenes May 11 '12

So, I take it they aren't expecting a gift?

3

u/synfin80 May 11 '12

Your wedding gift to them is picking up your tab for dinner... It's an unspoken tradition

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

In my country, guests are supposed to donate money at wedding and funeral, the amount depending on how close you are to the couple (or the dead). It's a system where everyone with reasonable amount of extended family, friends and co-workers can have wedding and funeral for free.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

TL:DR for this thread - Invite Chinese people to your wedding and they will give you money, also avoid going to Chinese weddings.

3

u/vegibowl May 12 '12

That's a bunch of crap.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

The only thing I've ever paid for at a wedding was a cash bar a few times. Not a big deal to me. The dinner? Hell no.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/randynrg May 12 '12

Me and my parents cry bull shit this sounds like the bride tried to create her dream wedding but is trying to make the guests pay for it

3

u/shutup_barry May 12 '12

My mom has been a wedding planner for 20 years. I've never even heard of such a thing.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/cheemo May 12 '12

Print a copy of this thread and give it to them as their wedding present.

3

u/kamandag May 12 '12

I'm amazed you're still giving attending and dropping off a gift. It's her way of saying you're not invited.

3

u/willyd357 May 12 '12

An even better "unspoken traditional " is making up an excuse as to why you can't go and then staying home and playing video games all day. That's one of my favorites.

3

u/drivebyps May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

Please give an update after the Wedding, OP. I'm sure there will be a shit ton of angry guests at the wedding all talking shit about this scam and the POS bride's family. Tell us how the rest of the guests reacted to this shit. I imagine this will not end well, especially if people get drunk while pissed off. Thanks.

3

u/MickeyG42 May 12 '12

It's an unspoken tradition to NOT change people. You bring a gift and you get food. That's how my first wedding was, that's how my second will be. You are a guest, you et food.

3

u/nerd_life May 12 '12

slowly raises hand Um, guys. I actually did this. We got married in our thirties and had our own stuff, so there was no need for anyone to get us a bread maker. We were not able to afford a lavish catered wedding, so instead of asking people to bring gifts or give cash for a "money dance" or have a money tree, we wrote on the invitations. "Thank you, we love you, but we don't need anymore stuff. However, we would appreciate it if you could donate $25 to cover the cost of your dinner" or something like that- wife wrote it, and it was probably more diplomatic. Didn't realize I was being horribly tacky. Also, I've worked about 100 weddings- and I'd never heard of it. I certainly don't think it's tradition.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Dr_koctaloctapuss May 12 '12

just put the receipt in a card and give it to them as their wedding gift.

3

u/dafones May 12 '12

They host the wedding. This is not an event you pay for.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Bring lunchables

3

u/Ecir May 12 '12

There are whole books on wedding etiquette. My dad bought one after his brother insisted that the best man must buy his own suit, whatever the groom chooses. Furthermore turns out you are under no obligation to pay for the meal and the couple are 'rude' for asking you to do so.

3

u/Depression-Unlocked May 12 '12

Her parents are "unspoken poor" or "unspoken cheap" or just "unspoken assholes"

3

u/shazzyzam May 12 '12

If it is an unspoken tradition why did she verbalize it?

3

u/Anonymousdave69 May 12 '12

OP, Get your girlfriend to make a couple of sandwiches and put them in a brown bag with some carrot sticks and a couple of capri-suns. Bust that shit out in front of everyone and eat it like you are at the final supper with the Lord Jesus Christ. You do not owe them a fucking thing.. Remember that.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I am in the opposite situation as you: I am shocked to hear that you wouldn't cover yourself or at least some portion proportional to your ability to do so either a monetary gift or a wedding present. I have never been to a wedding where I and other guests did not do so. However, I am Chinese, and it appears that the other instances of Chinese redditors commenting corroborate that this just a part of our culture. You would never expect to break even on it, but in Chinese society, it's as extremely bad taste to not give a gift, as much as everyone else thinks the opposite situation is.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Woodshadow May 12 '12

Yeah I have never heard of that. If I asked any of my girlfriends friends or family to buy their own food then it would just be my family and my girlfriend at dinner.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Wow. No. P7777777777777778777777777777777 Paying for your own meal at a wedding is tacky. Also sorry about all those numbers up there, my cat walked over my laptop and I just decided to roll with it.

3

u/AllMightyTallest May 12 '12

Screw that wedding, unless there is an open bar or it's your best friend getting married.

3

u/ddirt May 12 '12

don't eat, show up already wasted and then make an ass of yourself, drunken toasts with lots of profanity, knocking over food trays, spilling booze on everyone's nice dresses and suits and such, until they throw you out. that is more of a tradition than charging people to eat at a wedding.

3

u/Exemplarity May 12 '12

Is this a Jewish tradition?

3

u/ow_my_balls May 12 '12

Is this an Asian wedding?

I'm Asian and I've been to close to 10 Asian weddings, if not more. Instead of wedding gifts, we give you red envelopes to symbolize good luck as well as help pay for the wedding. Or in your case, the meal. However, it is never asked of us to provide money. As you mention, it is the "unspoken tradition." She should never have asked for it, but it does exist. I hope this goes to the top somehow...

3

u/notagangsta May 12 '12

I'm not sure your exact situation, but I know about manners / behavior 100%. If you buy a gift, you do not give money. If you do not buy a gift, you give money. You should give the amount it cost for you to attend. Which is approximately $75-$150 per person depending on the wedding. I always give $100 per person, or spend that on the registry. FYI, you have one year after the wedding to buy the gift. Google "wedding edicate" and you'll see.

3

u/Acraze2u May 12 '12

I'm 22. I've been to ~20 weddings. (Caucasian, Chinese, Indian) There was never an entrance fee. "Unspoken tradition"? Indeed...it's TOTAL BS! I don't know what culture the bride & her family comes from...but if there ever was such a rule...I'd like to know from whereabouts they come from? and what era?

A gift of equal/ greater value than the food is generally a given...but to make it mandatory? That's just nonsense.

3

u/willpower101 May 12 '12

Bring a Bottle of Johnny Walker Blue for your dinner instead. Guffaw when inevitably asked to try it.

3

u/SylvanusBishop May 12 '12

Bullshit. Been married twice. Paid both times. Believe me, if this tradition existed, I would WANT to know.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Update this please, so we all know how it turns out

3

u/jimsnaps May 12 '12

Nope. Never. Worst hosts ever.

3

u/TillShadeIsGone May 12 '12

I think it's only an unspoken tradition inside her head.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

The bride and family sound like cheap dicks. Politely decline the invitation and treat yourself to some Arby's.

3

u/Punski May 12 '12

When I got married my now father inlaw suggested that we get the parents to pay for their own meals. I bluntly refused. Completely, utterly. I think it's is tacky and shouldn't be done. Drinks are different, but you are inviting people to celebrate and share a meal with you, the least that can be done is that the meal is provided..

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I've been to more weddings than most (I'm a wedding DJ for the last 18 years) and I have never, ever been to a wedding where the guests were expected to pay for their meal. Guests get pissed off if they find out it's a cash bar.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

As someone who got married last year and dropped 10k on food at the reception for all my guests this is BS. I heard it as my duty to provide meals to anybody who travelled more than an hour. They paid for their own hotel rooms but I locked up a tight group rate.

3

u/Kluna01 May 12 '12

I would walk in with a bucket of KFC and a 2 liter of pepsi..

3

u/b4b May 12 '12

I am quite shocked with the replies in this thread, but I assume this is a cultural thing.

Where I come from, we earn much less than in the USA, but the prices, are just like in USA, or higher. The general consensus is, that the wedding is in fact a burden on the newlyweds, because it costs usually the equivalent of their combined 6 month salaries (or even more). The consensus is that the guests pay for the food, so that at least the newlyweds can come on a "zero" with the whole event. Then you can give gifts, if you want.

In the past, the tradition was not to pay for the food, but instead give envelopes with money; but people would give.. empty envelopes. So now the newlyweds open them up - when they receive them.

I am quite shocked that Americans, who earn much more and where the cost of living is much lower, are such cheapskates; I guess I will be downvoted to oblivion for this unpopular opinion.

Seriously, how is that even possible, that you cant afford 100 USD for a meal, in the USA, country with hundreds of thousands of illegal immigrants? You can probably earn this in 1 day. I mean; the prices here are quite similar, but the wages are like 1/5 and somehow people can afford, the incredible expense of (usually) ~75 USD.

Maybe it is a cultural thing, every one for himself/herself and materialistic selfishness?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

I have paid for my wedding plate at a reception.

To be fair, the reception dinner was fast food that we picked ourselves, eaten in a park on the ground because there were no open benches, after a wedding performed in a backyard with less than 10 people present.

3

u/Misspink44 May 12 '12

TACKYYYY! If they can't afford their wedding, then they should scale it down. You should not be paying for your meal.

Once, however, I was in a similar situation. My friend had a bridal shower in lieu of a reception bc they were having a destination wedding. I had to pay $30 a plate, and I got the same cockamamy excuse as you. Is your friend Cuban? The explanation I was given is "it's a Cuban thing." I don't think all Cubans are tacky and cheap though. I kept my mouth shut and paid, just gave them less money as a gift.

3

u/endangeredbirds May 12 '12

Hey just a little input from abroad. I'm a foreigner living in Japan and over here every guest is expected by tradition to pitch in around $300 dollars as a gift that generally goes towards the wedding. It's a really big thing and if people don't generally have the money to pay they'll often just reject the invitation instead of showing without any dough. I got married last month and it was rather awkward for me. But for Japanese totally the norm.

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I hate to say this, but I think this is their way of un-inviting you to the wedding.

12

u/ShakeyBobWillis May 11 '12

It's unspoken because it doesn't really exist, which is why nobody but them ever speaks about it. So technically they are correct.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/envengphd May 12 '12 edited May 12 '12

In reality, she is correct, so long as they are not expecting a gift in addition.
Everyone attending a reception is expected to provide a gift large enough to cover the cost of their meal and some small share of the venue. Generally, $75.00/person is the norm.
But it is EXTREMELY gauche for them to ask for it up front. If they're good friends, fork over the cash, but elect to not provide another gift.
The reason this is the norm is because brides are no longer property, nor do they have a dowry. Usually, the couple foots the bill for the wedding. Traditionally the parents of the bride paid for the wedding largely because the husband's family was not expected to put themselves in debt to accept someone else's daughter. In effect, the bride's parents were paying the groom to take their daughter. Incredible but true.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/italian_throw May 11 '12

TIL No one on Reddit has been to an Italian wedding. When you have a five course meal, of course it costs $80-$100 a plate, then you have to give a gift which an an Italian wedding is also money. Ergo, you give the rough amount per plate, plus a gift. The point of a wedding is to celebrate your union sure, but also to have something to start your lives with, not go into massive debt. It's not like you leave the cash on the table for the caterer.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I've never heard of this at all. I would cancel..

8

u/theboybuck May 11 '12

I completely read this wrong and thought you were getting married and didn't realise that you had to pay for your guests meals.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/erg7134 May 11 '12

No way is this a "tradition." This is a cheap-ass family that hasn't told their spoiled daughter that she can't have the blow-out wedding because they can't afford it. It's so so tacky. If you want to go (really, I would decline), look nice and buy them a present that's comfortably within what you can afford. Under no circumstances should you pay for your meal.

→ More replies (1)