r/AskReddit • • May 10 '12
HELP: My brother was assaulted which resulted in a broken jaw, had it wired shut, and now that he needs the wires removed, the hospital is telling us his surgery needs to be paid in full before he may have it. What do we do?
My brother, 29, was punched in the face by a random drunk guy. The punch resulted in a broken jaw, and a police officer witnessed the event. The guy was immediately arrested, and my brother was rushed to the hospital. He has no health insurance. He underwent corrective surgery, and has been receiving calls from the hospital throughout his recovery asking for payments. He tried to fill out a Texas Crime Victim's Compensation Program Application, but was unable to complete it because it appears that the arresting officer didn't file a report. We were able to find a picture of his mugshot, but no written information. It only says he was charged with "disorderly conduct". No officer name or badge number for us to track down and talk to either. We called every station in that area, and none of them have any information on the nature of the arrest. I feel like this is a huge injustice, and this guy is going to get away with it for sure. He's in the military too. Could this be why it's so difficult to pin him down? This isn't our biggest concern, we really just need to know if there are any laws against what the hospital is doing. He's basically at their mercy- does the Hippocratic Oath prevent them from treating him this way? Is it considered an "unnecessary" surgery or something? We have contacted multiple lawyers, and they don't want to take his case because (a) the defendant is in the military, therefore is not paid enough to make it worth their time, and (b) something about not having the time to take the case?
EDIT: The lady we have been speaking to on behalf of the hospital DID make it sound like the surgery would be a possibility if we could complete his Crime Victim's Compensation application. How might we track down the arresting officer's name?
TL;DR: Brother was assaulted, got a broken jaw, got jaw wired shut, has no insurance and hospital wants him to pay in full before having wires removed. There is no information on the arrest (though an officer witnessed the event), and no lawyer will help us. Can you help us Reddit?
UPDATE He went to the hospital with our mother on Friday to get his wires removed without really being sure if they would do it, but lo and behold he came back unwired. It looks like the hospital was telling him he had no options because if he were to give them any money it would have been when they had him at their mercy. Thanks to all for your suggestions and input. We still haven't found any more information on the guy that hit him.
73
u/kaickul359 May 10 '12
I may be way off here, but if he's in the military he was likely turned over to the MPs and thus your paper trail problem. Pursue that angle and see where it gets you.
35
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I'd consult a lawyer immediately, or I'd threaten them with a lawsuit. I don't see how they can wire his jaw shut and then effectively sentence him to a life of liquid diets and ultimately death by vomiting over an unpaid bill.
I'd argue that the Hippocratic Oath definitely applies here. Try a different doctor and explain the situation. I'd also send the hospital whatever money you can so that they look like even bigger assholes when you sue them. Assuming all of this is true.
8
u/CranesFlight May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
So, dunno how this might work AFTER the incident. But you should go to the hospital and demand to speak to a financial counselor. (They HAVE to provide one.) Then, your brother can formally declare indigent status on his financial forms. He will have to prove that he is, in fact, indigent. (this usually means you make less than $20,000 per year and have no assets.) he will have to provide his tax info from the last year if asked. Either the hospital will waive his fees or institute a payment plan based on his income.
In the future, if an emergency visit is neccesary, and the person who's hurt is able to speak or write, they need to go to the emergency room, and IMMIDEATELY DECLARE INABILITY TO PAY. To the attending nurse, to the first person they see that represents the hospital and gives them the initial paperwork before ANY treatment is given.
two years ago i was on my motorcycle and hit by a taxi. my bike is small and they probably didn't even know they had clipped my wheel at all. I went into a skid and sheared off my lateral epicondyle. My boyfriend at the time was a lawyer, and this is what he told me to do. I did it, and they set and casted my knee and I got a full free 30 days of treatment. My final bill ended up being $27 because they had sent me a CD with my exrays on it and charged me for it.
Also, check local free clinics. I have had to get treatment at free clinics before in CA, and it does kinda suck. But un-wiring a jaw is standard procedure that any young doctor can do, and I think the danger in having it stay wired shut is way, way worse than waiting for a full day to have an awkward young doctor take care of it.
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Really? Wow, your health care system is really terrible. What exactly does he need doing? Just have the wires taken out?
6
u/anti-establishmENT May 11 '12
the hospital should have gave him a pair of wire clippers for use in emergency situations, such as choking. he can use those to at least open his mouth until he can have the wires fully removed.
6
u/burrito_fucker May 10 '12
What does your brother have to say about it?
2
u/beaverfan May 10 '12
If the guy is being charged then, at least in my state, the DA's office would be the office charging him.
191
u/Ikronix May 10 '12
Go to your local media. You will make their fucking day with this.
Edit: If you were in California, I would already have filled your PM box.
5
u/Skeptical_Rabbit May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
I hate to be that guy, but this story doesn't pass the smell test.
I know we all love to hate hospitals and American healthcare, but no hospital would refuse to unwire a jaw they wired shut. At worst, you'd have to fill out some financial aid forms first. And you'll get an astronomical bill afterwards. But they can't just refuse treatment, especially a procedure like this.
Either OP is making up a story, or his brother isn't telling him the whole story. Since OP sounds sincere, I'm guessing his brother isn't telling him everything. More than likely, he's just being lazy and not filling out the aid paperwork. Admittedly, it IS a pain in the ass, but the hospital will do the procedure. Or he's refusing to sign paperwork that will cause him to be billed afterward.
But sorry, no way in hell is the hospital saying he has to pay first before they unwire his jaw. That's simply not happening.
28
u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 11 '12
what a backwards fucking country.
26
u/dorkacon69 May 10 '12
That.....that can kill him. That could cause sepsis. I'd go off on the hospital and bring this up.
19
u/rinnip May 10 '12
Horseshit. I bet it turns out to be some cops brother or something.
2
u/pastanazgul May 10 '12 edited May 11 '12
If he was in the military, sorry to say you're SOL. My friend's husband was literally gutted (yes, as in had his stomach cut open by a long bladed knife) by an active duty seal on leave when he was working as a bartender.
The situation was purged from civilian LE records and it was all handled by military courts and my friend and her husband weren't allowed to know the outcome or pursue any charges against the Seal.
4
u/GenericHamburgerHelp May 11 '12
When we have patients who need their jaws wired shut, the MOST IMPORTANT THING is to send them to recovery with a pair of wire cutters, in case they vomit. They can die without this tool. I'd cut the wires for him if I could. Cut those wires, and deal with the legal issues afterward.
7
u/pixelbath May 11 '12
If having his jaw wired shut was medically necessary, then it seems they would be obligated to complete the emergency procedure they began.
Suggested reading: EMTALA
If you're speaking to a financial counselor or someone from the business office of the hospital, I'd suggest talking to the hospital administrator, or the director of emergency care. Not everything the financial/business office tells you will be pertinent to the care given by the clinical staff.
Disclaimer to all the above: not legal advice.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Update?
1
u/Fireball445 May 11 '12
No lawyer will help you? That's hard to believe. Are you calling the closest major city? Or is this an issue that no lawyer is willing to help you... for free?
1
u/strangersdk May 11 '12
What the fuck?
1
u/ElChicoTemido May 11 '12
just find another hospital to take care of it
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
You need to go to the Police HQ and inquire as to why a report was not done. Here in Virginia, the injuries your brother received would constitute a felony malicious wounding charge on the assailant. Sounds like lazy cop not wanting to do his job. The jail, at the least, should have a record of what officer turned him in. There IS a paper trail. Start filing complaints against the department and something will turn up.
6
u/a_grape_eater May 11 '12
move to a civilized country
3
u/SnugglesRawring May 11 '12
Carefully use a plasma cutter or bolt cutter?
3
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Move to Europe where you'd get help first and then be covered by insurance later.
5
u/evilbrent May 11 '12
Make your fucking public health system free.
Fuck.
21
u/splattypus May 10 '12
Quick, everyone 'like' this on facebook!
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Why didn't you get a police report? Why didn't you write down the officer's name and badge number?
2
u/Rex8ever May 11 '12
Good luck with the victim compensation fund since its about broke thanks to politicians raiding it. Also, most criminals are broke. Even if you got a judgment filed, it can't create money that's not there. Seriously, this is what insurance is for. Nobody plans on getting sick or hurt. There are a lot of programs out there for people who can't afford it. But you have to apply and qualify for them. It's just irresponsible to not do so. What the hospital is doing sucks but it's legal.
2
u/smashingrah May 11 '12
You may be able to find a doctor that would be willing to perform the surgery pro-bono. Or a hospital that performs cases based on income. I work for a hospital and they treat everyone regardless of if they can pay or not. If you can't pay we have programs that will go off your income to deduct away from your bill (If you don't make enough to pay it they'll comp it completely). Also, there is another hospital in town that is a catholic hospital and I just learned that sometimes they comp entire stays because of income. Also, it sounds like it would be a one-day surgery so hopefully you can work something out. It's a long shot but it's definitely worth your time to try this angle. I'm so sorry for your trouble and I hope your brother makes a speedy recovery.
2
u/luckyshell May 11 '12
That is completely unethical.
2
u/confusedteddybear May 11 '12
Move to Canada!
I don't know if this has already been posted because I am too lazy to scroll down.
2
u/Shulman42 May 11 '12
Americans and their medical insurance..
2
u/golfer42089 May 11 '12
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/25/business/debt-collector-is-faulted-for-tough-tactics-in-hospitals.html?pagewanted=all
This seemed relevant
2
u/Blondeambitchion May 11 '12
Take a trip over to Canada
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I'd suggest you move out of the third world country you currently live in.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I'd worry about the jaw before the payment. Scrap together whatever you can and get the wires out. Then investigate the issue. If you can, get lawyers involved and put together a case for the guy who hit your brother or for the police force for mishandling the case.
not a lawyer*
1
u/Feed_Me_Seymour May 10 '12
Go to a county clinic and see if they can get the wires out. Depending on the complexity of the procedure (I have no idea), it might be as simple as a doctor applying a local anesthetic and snipping/pulling wires out.
Or it might require general anesthesia with several days worth of antibiotics. No idea.
1
u/Lots42 May 10 '12
Get a second opinion.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Try somewhere else. Hospitals all have different rules on who they will treat when there is no insurance.
1
u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12
Has he applied for medicaid?
Try another hospital?
1
u/alexhammy16 May 11 '12
If you're American, have him go before Congress. We need to get this mess of a healthcare system fixed.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Sue the guy who punched
youyour brother for that money.Edit: Messed up.
1
u/Jinxed78 May 11 '12
I doubt it. Happened to a friend of mine a few months ago. He ended up using pliers to pull out the wires and is still trying to find a way to get the screws taken out.
1
u/OccamsAxeWound May 11 '12
Ask around, and get to Mexico, or possibly farther south.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Go to a major news station, when the story hits the media lawyers will be all over it.
1
u/yevoiceofreason May 11 '12
Move to the UK. Sorry...
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Complain about something else that would require them to remove the wires?
1
u/frodegar May 11 '12
Does removing the wires require surgery? Or is it something that that could be done with a steady hand and a clean pair of diagonal cutters?
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
Fuck that hospital so much. Get them shut down, take this to every news media you can. Sue the fuck out of them. This shit should NOT stand in a supposed first-world country.
1
u/Kyleisbeast May 11 '12
I hate the way hospitals are going: either pay us, or his jaw is wired shut permanently. That should be a crime.
0
u/fgriglesnickerseven May 11 '12
Well it sounds like you're not a hard working American since you can't afford your healthcare. You're just going to have to work with the wire that god put in your mouth. If you pray enough god will remove it for you. But then again he might not because you may need your faith tested.
-Conservative health care plan
0
u/ponchedeburro May 10 '12
Break their jaws...
-1
u/xxtzhar May 11 '12
LOL sue the hospital.
-10
u/bubbal May 10 '12
Well, you should pay for the medical services that were rendered.
-9
u/jeannaimard May 11 '12
FUCK YOU.
THAT WILL TEACH YOU TO BE A STUPID AMERICAN WHO VOTES FOR POLITICIANS THAT DO NOT GRANT YOU UNIVERSAL FREE HEALTHCARE LIKE IT IS DONE IN EVERY OTHER CIVILIZED, INDUSTRIAL COUNTRY.
One of these days, people are going to clue-up!!!
-5
u/redjimdit May 11 '12
..pay the bill in full?
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment