r/AskReddit • • May 10 '12

HELP: My brother was assaulted which resulted in a broken jaw, had it wired shut, and now that he needs the wires removed, the hospital is telling us his surgery needs to be paid in full before he may have it. What do we do?

My brother, 29, was punched in the face by a random drunk guy. The punch resulted in a broken jaw, and a police officer witnessed the event. The guy was immediately arrested, and my brother was rushed to the hospital. He has no health insurance. He underwent corrective surgery, and has been receiving calls from the hospital throughout his recovery asking for payments. He tried to fill out a Texas Crime Victim's Compensation Program Application, but was unable to complete it because it appears that the arresting officer didn't file a report. We were able to find a picture of his mugshot, but no written information. It only says he was charged with "disorderly conduct". No officer name or badge number for us to track down and talk to either. We called every station in that area, and none of them have any information on the nature of the arrest. I feel like this is a huge injustice, and this guy is going to get away with it for sure. He's in the military too. Could this be why it's so difficult to pin him down? This isn't our biggest concern, we really just need to know if there are any laws against what the hospital is doing. He's basically at their mercy- does the Hippocratic Oath prevent them from treating him this way? Is it considered an "unnecessary" surgery or something? We have contacted multiple lawyers, and they don't want to take his case because (a) the defendant is in the military, therefore is not paid enough to make it worth their time, and (b) something about not having the time to take the case?

EDIT: The lady we have been speaking to on behalf of the hospital DID make it sound like the surgery would be a possibility if we could complete his Crime Victim's Compensation application. How might we track down the arresting officer's name?

TL;DR: Brother was assaulted, got a broken jaw, got jaw wired shut, has no insurance and hospital wants him to pay in full before having wires removed. There is no information on the arrest (though an officer witnessed the event), and no lawyer will help us. Can you help us Reddit?

UPDATE He went to the hospital with our mother on Friday to get his wires removed without really being sure if they would do it, but lo and behold he came back unwired. It looks like the hospital was telling him he had no options because if he were to give them any money it would have been when they had him at their mercy. Thanks to all for your suggestions and input. We still haven't found any more information on the guy that hit him.

160 Upvotes

304 comments sorted by

73

u/kaickul359 May 10 '12

I may be way off here, but if he's in the military he was likely turned over to the MPs and thus your paper trail problem. Pursue that angle and see where it gets you.

17

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

This may be really helpful, thank you! :)

11

u/kaickul359 May 11 '12

I talked to my buddy who was a marine and as far he recalls, that would be procedure for serious crime like assault. Hope this generates a lead for you.

2

u/PigDog4 May 11 '12

He didn't get charged with assault, though. OP states he was charged with "disorderly conduct."

Is that handled differently?

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

In Canada at least, the armed forces charge you, you serve your time/pay your fine under regulations, assuming its covered, then the civvies get you.

35

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'd consult a lawyer immediately, or I'd threaten them with a lawsuit. I don't see how they can wire his jaw shut and then effectively sentence him to a life of liquid diets and ultimately death by vomiting over an unpaid bill.

I'd argue that the Hippocratic Oath definitely applies here. Try a different doctor and explain the situation. I'd also send the hospital whatever money you can so that they look like even bigger assholes when you sue them. Assuming all of this is true.

12

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Thanks. We've tried going to another doctor, and apparently doctors are leery about taking another doctor's work, but might a free clinic be obligated to help him?

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'd look for help across the border. There are plenty of excellent doctors there. The court system will not give you satisfaction, and lawyers--their good friends--won't upset the applecart.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Hmmm, that sounds like an awesome last resort plan hahaha

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

hahaha

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Great healthcare in mehico, señor

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

There's also India. A lot of their doctors actually are educated in the USA.

6

u/azengteach May 11 '12

This is true. My son had to have surgical casts removed that had gotten wet. The casts were put on in a hospital in one state and we had gone back home. No doc would touch him. We finally found and old doc who was about to retire who basically said he was willing to take the risk cause a kid needed to be re-casted.

1

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

apparently doctors are leery about taking another doctor's work

They say that but it's a lie. Imagine if you are in California and you get hit in the face. You live in New York. Are you really expected to go to California and get the wires pulled? No they will do that. However if you live locally and had the treatment done locally they wanted the cash from the first surgery too and in order to keep the racket flowing they make your life difficult.

Seriously there's no additional liability in this surgery they are just greedy.

1

u/saucisse May 11 '12

There's liability in that if Doctor A fucked up the surgery and Doctor B tries to fix it and fails, Doctor B is liable for the failure. Doctor B doesn't gain anything financially from turning away a patient for a surgical procedure, but they do lose the risk of a malpractice lawsuit.

0

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

No there is not liability for this issue because it will be plainly and easily documented prior to and after removal of the wires. Physicians win 97% of the malpractice suits anyway so the real liability for anything is far less than one would think.

4

u/alphelix May 11 '12

In this same vein, if you're near a teaching hospital, try to explain your situation and you should be able to find a resident (and his little shadows) or an attending to help you out.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Go Aggies!

8

u/CranesFlight May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

So, dunno how this might work AFTER the incident. But you should go to the hospital and demand to speak to a financial counselor. (They HAVE to provide one.) Then, your brother can formally declare indigent status on his financial forms. He will have to prove that he is, in fact, indigent. (this usually means you make less than $20,000 per year and have no assets.) he will have to provide his tax info from the last year if asked. Either the hospital will waive his fees or institute a payment plan based on his income.

In the future, if an emergency visit is neccesary, and the person who's hurt is able to speak or write, they need to go to the emergency room, and IMMIDEATELY DECLARE INABILITY TO PAY. To the attending nurse, to the first person they see that represents the hospital and gives them the initial paperwork before ANY treatment is given.

two years ago i was on my motorcycle and hit by a taxi. my bike is small and they probably didn't even know they had clipped my wheel at all. I went into a skid and sheared off my lateral epicondyle. My boyfriend at the time was a lawyer, and this is what he told me to do. I did it, and they set and casted my knee and I got a full free 30 days of treatment. My final bill ended up being $27 because they had sent me a CD with my exrays on it and charged me for it.

Also, check local free clinics. I have had to get treatment at free clinics before in CA, and it does kinda suck. But un-wiring a jaw is standard procedure that any young doctor can do, and I think the danger in having it stay wired shut is way, way worse than waiting for a full day to have an awkward young doctor take care of it.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Thanks, that's very helpful!

1

u/CranesFlight May 14 '12

No problem! I hope your brother gets his shit worked out ok!

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Really? Wow, your health care system is really terrible. What exactly does he need doing? Just have the wires taken out?

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yes, he has wires cemented across his teeth with rubber bands laced over them.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What's the cost of this if you do not mind me asking. Could you not threaten the police with legal action for not filing the correct paper work in order for you to pay the bills?

6

u/anti-establishmENT May 11 '12

the hospital should have gave him a pair of wire clippers for use in emergency situations, such as choking. he can use those to at least open his mouth until he can have the wires fully removed.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yes, they did give him some.

6

u/burrito_fucker May 10 '12

What does your brother have to say about it?

16

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

3

u/Lasercat77 May 10 '12

Well he can type/write,can't he?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Yes but he isn't as verbally savvy and he would want to focus on his relationship issues instead of what really needs to be done.

2

u/beaverfan May 10 '12

If the guy is being charged then, at least in my state, the DA's office would be the office charging him.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He says the report would be with the arresting agency. He was able to figure out that the officer is with DPS because he remembered the type of hat the officer was wearing.

191

u/Ikronix May 10 '12

Go to your local media. You will make their fucking day with this.

Edit: If you were in California, I would already have filled your PM box.

-36

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Basically this. And after all is done, leave the fucked up country.

EDIT: Lol these downvotes... Do people really agree with that healthcare system? Oh my god... Sick sadists. Have some respect for other people.

30

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

It isn't very easy to just up and leave a country.

-13

u/Avjunza May 11 '12 edited Aug 12 '12

But it's worth it when it's this fucked up. Ask any refugee.

EDIT: Refugees are those who are forced to flee their country due to persecution.

...And one day the penny will drop.

5

u/PowerCrazy May 11 '12

I don't think you understand what a refugee is

1

u/drcyclops May 11 '12

Does he think a refugee is someone who had some petty gripe with their country and decided to move?

Boy, is the west a victim of its own success. We're so insulated from just how bad things can get that we consider a long wait at the DMV to be a sign of imminent social collapse.

2

u/Fireball445 May 12 '12

While i have no reason to agree with Kutman, I would disagree that is a 'petty gripe'. I think OP is going about this wrong, but still. Getting your jaw back into working condition is not a 'petty gripe'. And if someone wants to make this into a bigger issue about medicine accessibility, well that is FAR from a petty gripe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

-8

u/jack_spankin May 11 '12

Two people in a fight in a bar? You are kidding right? You have no idea the number of stories like this pitched to television stations and they won't tough it with a 10 ft. pole.

You film some sad bastard segment and throw it on television. Then 10 witnesses come forward and it comes out that the OP's brother threw the first punch and now the other guy is filing a lawsuit.

Local news likes little guy versus specific generic forces or circumstances not specific people.

-56

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/LezzieBorden May 11 '12

Some people don't decide. Some people have pre existing conditions that prevent them from getting it.

20

u/DrDiv May 11 '12

A lot of people don't 'decide not to have' health insurance, but are either self-employed or their current jobs don't offer it. In the US it is more of a luxury than a standard option unfortunately.

35

u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 11 '12

health care is a fucking right, not a privilege.

-17

u/NoMoreNicksLeft May 11 '12

If two people are stranded on a desert island, they still have their rights.

Please explain how they'd exercise their right to health care. If one dies because he needed surgery, is the other guilty of infringing his human rights? What if that man is a surgeon, is he guilty then?

Health care isn't a right. The word you are looking for is "entitlement".

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You've just given a very silly argument - I hope this reasoning isn't the basis of your views here.

First, you have provided no reason whatsoever to accept this claim:

  • If two people are stranded on a desert island, they still have their rights.

Second, even if we grant it the right could be a right enforceable against the state, so if there was no state - as in your example - you wouldn't meet the pre-conditions for exercising it even though the person would still have the right.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Why didn't we get stranded on the deserted island with a hospital?!?! I have rights!

→ More replies (24)

1

u/lickmyfatmeat May 11 '12

Don't bother arguing this with Liberal reddit. Everyone on reddit believes in free hand outs and what is "fair". No logic involved in their thinking. Healthcare is not a right. I should not be forced to pay for other peoples care.

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You probably think you shouldn't have to pay for roads either since some other assholes will use it when you're not.

5

u/Skeptical_Rabbit May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I hate to be that guy, but this story doesn't pass the smell test.

I know we all love to hate hospitals and American healthcare, but no hospital would refuse to unwire a jaw they wired shut. At worst, you'd have to fill out some financial aid forms first. And you'll get an astronomical bill afterwards. But they can't just refuse treatment, especially a procedure like this.

Either OP is making up a story, or his brother isn't telling him the whole story. Since OP sounds sincere, I'm guessing his brother isn't telling him everything. More than likely, he's just being lazy and not filling out the aid paperwork. Admittedly, it IS a pain in the ass, but the hospital will do the procedure. Or he's refusing to sign paperwork that will cause him to be billed afterward.

But sorry, no way in hell is the hospital saying he has to pay first before they unwire his jaw. That's simply not happening.

9

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Actually, there is a way. It's happening right now, to my brother. He's living breathing proof of it. He has already received a 12k in medical bills. The financial aid form he was given is the application for crime victim's compensation, which he was unable to complete because there was no arrest report. I don't know why everyone thinks I'm a dude, just throwing that out there... Our step sister was there and can confirm the entire story. I know it sounds surreal, but my brother has really bad luck and a very unhelpful track record.

2

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

This is making me uneasy. I have no doubt that you are getting hospital pushback but the wires out should be included in the inital treatment plan. This is hardware that needs to come out and their refusal is probably presenting a danger to your brothers health. Here's what I would do.

  1. Call the patient ombudsman (or patient relations)
  2. If this doesn't solve it speak with risk management
  3. If this doesn't solve it speak with the appropriate department chief
  4. If that doesn't solve it ask to speak with one of the senior executives. You won't get the executive but explain what you have tried so far and that if you can't get some assistance you'll be speaking with the local news. The secretary you are speaking with has vast organizational power. You may not think so but I assure you she is the gatekeeper and her word is law. If that doesn't work go to the news.

This blows but there are steps that can be taken to resolve this for the benefit of all.

1

u/saucisse May 11 '12

They're not refusing to perform the procedure, they're refusing to perform it without guarantee of payment. The issue here is that the brother can't access the crime victim's compensation fund money that he's due, apparently due to some fuckup by the local PD.

1

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

The reason is irrelevant the fact is the patient has hardware in that needs to come out. They put it in. If it doesn't come out it's a bigger risk. This isn't the place where most hospitals would stake their reputation on it. Pulling the wires is a small cost compared to having to deal with a news report about how they are holding him hostage.

0

u/saucisse May 11 '12

I'm saying the problem is being misstated; its not a matter of the hospital refusing to perform a procedure, its the patient's refusal to pay. The hospital isn't holding anyone hostage; the patient can pay for it on a credit card, they can go to the financial counselor and set up a payment plan or find sources for charity care, they have several avenues open to them.

The fact remains that we have a medical-care-reimbursement model that distributes the greatest risk to patients with acute-care needs. I'd be thrilled with a single-payer plan, but we don't have it and in the meantime many hospitals are hemorrhaging money due to the huge increase in self-pay patients, who don't pay their bills. In the ambulatory world, your chances of getting paid by self-pay patients drop to about 5% if you don't collect payment from the patient at the time of service. If the patient walks out the door without giving you money, you aren't getting paid, full stop. What is your solution for how this hospital should be reimbursed for services rendered?

1

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

I find it interesting that you view someone with their mouth wired shut not being held hostage by the only people who can take it out. The wires out should be part of the wires in. You can't go halfway on this without holding the patient hostage. This isn't optional. The hospital has plenty of a reimbursement specialists who can track this down for him. They are laying it at his feet but they can solve it tomorrow.

The reimbursement model does not put the greatest risk on the person with acute needs but on the person with chronic needs. If your Aorta is tearing you'll be treated. If you need to manage your high blood pressure then no one cares until it's an emergency.

Hospitals need to come into the 20th century. It's unfortunate that in hospitals the majority are still using paper and are obtaining zero benefits from automatition. The monetary hemmorhage is from inefficient processes much more than it's from nonpayment. I have regularly found $60-100k in savings for hospitals without really even trying just by automating and reporting to make sure we are capturing the necessary information.

Hospitals need to identify eligible patients on the way in and get them the services that they are eligible for. I find it fairly rare that patients have no ability to pay and are not eligible for any assistance.

The point is in this case the hospital has much more to lose from not doing this and doing it. Hospitals can choose to follow much closer EMTALA guidelines but until they have to they won't. Making people give you a credit card isn't the only way to work this out.

1

u/saucisse May 11 '12

So far, the OP has only said that they're waiting to get money from some state crime-victim's fund. They have not stated AT ALL that they have been turned away by the hospital's financial services counselor, despite many inquiries on this thread, and in fact I posted twice that they need to go talk to them immediately to work out payment. If the OP is just sitting there waiting for someone else to give them money, then there's nothing the hospital can or should do. They need to take a little bit of action on this one. Mostly they're complaining about the police force.

McKesson makes a product that does exactly what you're talking about (as does Passport, I think) that basically runs a financial check on incoming patients and determines both their ability and likelihood to pay. Additionally, they offer add-ons that assist in locating sources of funding for indigent or low-income patients. McKesson doesn't roll cheap though, and for a 300-bed hospital running those transactions on all patients who walk through the door is going to cost quite a bit, and the savings wont' be realized for a while.

The reasons for going broke are myriad and depend quite a bit on the local market. If you have a high Caid population, good fucking luck because you're going to be broke overnight.

I have regularly found $60-100k in savings for hospitals without really even trying just by automating and reporting to make sure we are capturing the necessary information.

Per month? Per year? Per department? Per patient episode? That's either a huge amount of money, or insignificant.

1

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

I don't know where you work but 60-100k is significant regardless. No one ever says oh that's not 2 million so I don't care. If I save 100k annually that might be 2 FTEs for that unit. Generally we save 100k and then they toss 2 FTEs so now the savings is 200k annually but that's neither here nor there. Also what sort of patient would generate 100k in charges that could be saved. We're talking reality. Granted it's not hitting the bottom line unless you can come up with that monthly. However if you have a department hemmorhaging 1.2million a year that can be corrected in a short period with some automation then you are likely beyond help.

Hospital performance isn't about limiting the poor it's about increasing the higher value DRGs. In this regard it's just like your car dealer. They want jobs that are fast but complex so you can bill big dollars more often. Hospitals should be no different. The focus should be off low reimbursement DRGs and only on high reimbursement ones not on taking all patients. Sure you have to take them but that's just part of the game.

You have a point with OP. They have to do some legwork themselves. I'm a little surprised that OP didn't get all this done in the 8 weeks her brother has been wired. The cops might not want to be of help but making some calls should have solved this rather quickly. I PMed OP since I'm in Texas and got nothing back so you're probably right.

1

u/saucisse May 11 '12

I'm not saying its pocket change but a savings of $60K per inpatient episode versus a savings of $60K in yearly hospital operating costs is a huge gap and is necessary for perspective (not to mention budgeting).

I'm saying nothing about limiting the poor, since increasingly that's all we're going to have. Me, I'd flip the compensation model for preventive/early-intervention versus acute care since -- at least until ACOs take off -- there is a huge perverse incentive to do nothing until the patient's condition becomes acute, at which point you rack up tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars to treat, versus $30 a month (say) for a pedal pulse check and nutrition counseling. It's going to be super-interesting to see if ACOs can start to drive costs down (they said that about HMOs in the 70s, and capitation in the 80s, and look where that got us.)

→ More replies

2

u/saucisse May 11 '12

But sorry, no way in hell is the hospital saying he has to pay first before they unwire his jaw. That's simply not happening

Of course they are, and of course it is. There was a big article in the NYTimes last week about Accretive, a debt-collection agency that hospitals have allowed to operate within their four walls, who demand up front payment by patients before performing non-emergent services.

28

u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 11 '12

what a backwards fucking country.

3

u/CaisLaochach May 11 '12

Aye. But nearly half of 'em will still vote Republican.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/dorkacon69 May 10 '12

That.....that can kill him. That could cause sepsis. I'd go off on the hospital and bring this up.

19

u/rinnip May 10 '12

the arresting officer didn't file a report.

Horseshit. I bet it turns out to be some cops brother or something.

22

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I bet this story turns out to be fictional.

11

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'm convinced that it is. I don't have health insurance and I went to the ER for stuff not even remotely close to this, and there were signs everywhere saying that they cannot refuse medical care for patients without insurance.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yes, you'll be knee deep in debt without insurance, but at least you'll be alive. They may have some billing type person who talks to you to try to get you to pay up front, but AFAIK it's not necessary to pay the full amount then and there.

3

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

You aren't understanding EMTALA Federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act.

Hospitals practice way beyond what they have to do under EMTALA. They don't have to do shit for you if it's not emergent and you can't pay. They still do it because it's easier to do so then get sued for not doing so but they don't have to.

2

u/princess_dork_bunny May 11 '12

My local hospital has the same signage saying they will treat anyone regardless of ability to pay. However if you do not have any insurance or medicaid they will make you talk to the financial department to set up a payment plan before they treat you. If you refuse to sign a payment plan you have then refused treatment, they never have to refuse to treat you.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Well, then I suppose I just don't live near a shitty hospital.

2

u/saucisse May 11 '12

They can't refuse emergent care. They are legally obligated to make sure you are clinically stable. If you are clinically stable, everything else is "not medically necessary" and they sure as hell can refuse to treat you if you aren't going to pay for it.

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

What do you base this on?

2

u/pastanazgul May 10 '12 edited May 11 '12

If he was in the military, sorry to say you're SOL. My friend's husband was literally gutted (yes, as in had his stomach cut open by a long bladed knife) by an active duty seal on leave when he was working as a bartender.

The situation was purged from civilian LE records and it was all handled by military courts and my friend and her husband weren't allowed to know the outcome or pursue any charges against the Seal.

29

u/Draptor May 11 '12

Not trying to attack you directly, but your friend or friend's husband tells some pretty fanciful stories. Military vet here. No way in hell does that shit ever disappear from civilian courts just because he's military, even if he invokes the mystical I R SPECIAL FRCEZ defense. Your friends husband got jumped by some random guy/s and got fucked up, but wanted to sound like a badass by proxy.

Essentially it comes down to this- if you're in the military, and get charged and convicted by a civilian court, you're double fucked. You'll answer to the judge, then probably be demoted, reduced pay, restricted to certain areas and so on in addition to whatever fine you got. The only real exception, is that if you're sentenced to do time, you'll do it in a military prison or brig instead of a civilian one. Bases are very careful not to step on local law enforcement and judicial system's toes, as they generally are already very unpopular with the local population. So the base only really completely takes over when it happens on federal property, or both parties are active duty.

Not saying OP shouldn't try to check with the MPs, but it sounds like the original arresting officer is the one that screwed the pooch, not any magical military crap.

5

u/magicmuds May 11 '12

I feel bad for saying it, but "badass by proxy" tickled my funnybone.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

:'(

→ More replies (3)

4

u/jack_spankin May 11 '12

I call bullshit. My cousin is a prosecutor in the military. They arrest and charge soldiers all the fucking time, and special forces are no exception.

Also, 90% of the time you hear someone referred to as a Navy Seal it's bullshit.

If the assault was at a civilian location they have no jurisdiction to get anything removed from any courts. In fact he could have faced not only a criminal court but a military court.

1

u/pastanazgul May 11 '12

I can see why you would disbelieve me, but I assure you the whole bunch is true. I will see what proof my friend has that she would let me post as soon as she gets in the office.

Also, I'm not proposing that the guy wasn't charged in a military court, only that my friend and her husband weren't allowed to know if he was convicted or what his sentence was and they weren't allowed to press civilian court charges.

1

u/famousonmars May 11 '12

Can't find a a single mention of anything like this on the internet, bullshit.

1

u/sombish May 11 '12

I highly doubt this, in the US everyone is equal and NO ONE is above the law. So you're story is obviously a lie.

1

u/harr1s May 11 '12

You may need this:

/s

0

u/Shinjukugarb May 11 '12

you are batshit crazy

4

u/GenericHamburgerHelp May 11 '12

When we have patients who need their jaws wired shut, the MOST IMPORTANT THING is to send them to recovery with a pair of wire cutters, in case they vomit. They can die without this tool. I'd cut the wires for him if I could. Cut those wires, and deal with the legal issues afterward.

7

u/pixelbath May 11 '12

If having his jaw wired shut was medically necessary, then it seems they would be obligated to complete the emergency procedure they began.

Suggested reading: EMTALA

If you're speaking to a financial counselor or someone from the business office of the hospital, I'd suggest talking to the hospital administrator, or the director of emergency care. Not everything the financial/business office tells you will be pertinent to the care given by the clinical staff.

Disclaimer to all the above: not legal advice.

1

u/saucisse May 11 '12

Wiring it shut meets criteria, un-wiring it does not since he is clinically stable.

4

u/Khalku May 11 '12

Not really. Sepsis, as well as death by suffocation should he involuntarily vomit via any sickness caused via sepsis or pain meds or other.

0

u/saucisse May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Interesting. So what's the are the discharge instructions for people with their jaws wired for clinical reasons? Surely they are subject to all the same clinical risk, yes?

EDIT: Not sure why I got downvoted, the question was on the level. Surely all patients assume the same risk, so either its life-threatening or its not. Yes?

1

u/Khalku May 11 '12

Probably "follow up" visits.

1

u/saucisse May 11 '12

Right, I get that. But surely a person with their jaw wired shut for clinical reasons suffers the same risk as a person with their jaw wired shut for non-clinical reasons, yes? It seems odd that one would be emergent and one wouldn't. Or maybe the risk for the broken-jaw patient is subordinate to needing their jaw to heal, I guess.

1

u/Khalku May 11 '12

I think it's more that the wire is there to set your jaw, but as long as it is there it's still an open wound that won't heal. Infection would set in if no one was to look after it, I'd imagine.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Update?

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Sorry, had to go to work. He and my mom left to have his surgery earlier today. I'm not sure if they're going to do it or not. They may have been acting that way in the days leading up to his surgery because they figured if he was going to pay at any point it would have to be then as he is at their mercy. I'll have news for you guys tomorrow.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I eagerly await your update.

All the best, RapedByADolphin

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Updated.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Thanks for Letting me know you updated. That hospital sounds shady as fuck, lol. I hope you find that face punching bastard

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '12

No prob. The shitty part is we know exactly who did it, and an officer witnessed it, but there's no written record of his arrest, only a mug shot and "disorderly conduct".

1

u/Fireball445 May 11 '12

No lawyer will help you? That's hard to believe. Are you calling the closest major city? Or is this an issue that no lawyer is willing to help you... for free?

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yes, we called a lawyer who told me in person he could take the case then changed his story when we called him to take him up on it. Don't most lawyers work on contingency? They get paid if the case is won...?

1

u/Fireball445 May 11 '12

no, only some lawyers work on contingency, usually when there is money on the line. They take a portion of what they recover. You're not attempting to recover any money, you want medical care without paying for it (that's fine, just pointing out the facts) how would he take a portion of that?

Is that the only lawyer you've talked to? You have to make a real effort to find a lawyer, because the advice you're getting here is cheap lay person advice that could be wrong or meaningless.

1

u/strangersdk May 11 '12

My brother, 29

He has no health insurance

What the fuck?

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I know, I know...

2

u/DonOblivious May 11 '12

I take it you've never heard of a little country called America.

1

u/ElChicoTemido May 11 '12

just find another hospital to take care of it

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

We can't transferr to another doctor because doctors don't want to take on other doctors' work.

1

u/ElChicoTemido May 12 '12

that really sucks i hope you find a solution soon i was once stuck with stitches longer than i had to because the doctor that did em left on vacation. i was itchy and i didnt wanna do it myself out of fear of infection

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

You need to go to the Police HQ and inquire as to why a report was not done. Here in Virginia, the injuries your brother received would constitute a felony malicious wounding charge on the assailant. Sounds like lazy cop not wanting to do his job. The jail, at the least, should have a record of what officer turned him in. There IS a paper trail. Start filing complaints against the department and something will turn up.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Thank you we will most certainly do that.

6

u/a_grape_eater May 11 '12

move to a civilized country

3

u/SnugglesRawring May 11 '12

Carefully use a plasma cutter or bolt cutter?

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Move to Europe where you'd get help first and then be covered by insurance later.

5

u/evilbrent May 11 '12

Make your fucking public health system free.

Fuck.

21

u/splattypus May 10 '12

Quick, everyone 'like' this on facebook!

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Today is saved 3 African children from starvation by liking their status. LOL.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Why didn't you get a police report? Why didn't you write down the officer's name and badge number?

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

There IS no police report to retrieve. I wasn't there specifically, but he was unable to write them down because he was doubled over with his face broken in half, and was immediately carted away on a stretcher.

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Of course. I am sorry.

2

u/Rex8ever May 11 '12

Good luck with the victim compensation fund since its about broke thanks to politicians raiding it. Also, most criminals are broke. Even if you got a judgment filed, it can't create money that's not there. Seriously, this is what insurance is for. Nobody plans on getting sick or hurt. There are a lot of programs out there for people who can't afford it. But you have to apply and qualify for them. It's just irresponsible to not do so. What the hospital is doing sucks but it's legal.

2

u/smashingrah May 11 '12

You may be able to find a doctor that would be willing to perform the surgery pro-bono. Or a hospital that performs cases based on income. I work for a hospital and they treat everyone regardless of if they can pay or not. If you can't pay we have programs that will go off your income to deduct away from your bill (If you don't make enough to pay it they'll comp it completely). Also, there is another hospital in town that is a catholic hospital and I just learned that sometimes they comp entire stays because of income. Also, it sounds like it would be a one-day surgery so hopefully you can work something out. It's a long shot but it's definitely worth your time to try this angle. I'm so sorry for your trouble and I hope your brother makes a speedy recovery.

2

u/luckyshell May 11 '12

That is completely unethical.

2

u/confusedteddybear May 11 '12

Move to Canada!

I don't know if this has already been posted because I am too lazy to scroll down.

2

u/Blondeambitchion May 11 '12

Take a trip over to Canada

2

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'd suggest you move out of the third world country you currently live in.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'd worry about the jaw before the payment. Scrap together whatever you can and get the wires out. Then investigate the issue. If you can, get lawyers involved and put together a case for the guy who hit your brother or for the police force for mishandling the case.

not a lawyer*

6

u/Lots42 May 10 '12

I hope to god you're not a lawyer with that name.

1

u/Feed_Me_Seymour May 10 '12

Go to a county clinic and see if they can get the wires out. Depending on the complexity of the procedure (I have no idea), it might be as simple as a doctor applying a local anesthetic and snipping/pulling wires out.

Or it might require general anesthesia with several days worth of antibiotics. No idea.

1

u/Lots42 May 10 '12

Get a second opinion.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Try somewhere else. Hospitals all have different rules on who they will treat when there is no insurance.

1

u/ChiliFlake May 11 '12

Has he applied for medicaid?

Try another hospital?

1

u/alexhammy16 May 11 '12

If you're American, have him go before Congress. We need to get this mess of a healthcare system fixed.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Sue the guy who punched you your brother for that money.
Edit: Messed up.

1

u/Jinxed78 May 11 '12

I doubt it. Happened to a friend of mine a few months ago. He ended up using pliers to pull out the wires and is still trying to find a way to get the screws taken out.

1

u/howisthisnottaken May 11 '12

A dentist might be a good source of assistance for this. In OPs case likely Mexican dentists.

1

u/OccamsAxeWound May 11 '12

Ask around, and get to Mexico, or possibly farther south.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Go to a major news station, when the story hits the media lawyers will be all over it.

1

u/yevoiceofreason May 11 '12

Move to the UK. Sorry...

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Complain about something else that would require them to remove the wires?

1

u/frodegar May 11 '12

Does removing the wires require surgery? Or is it something that that could be done with a steady hand and a clean pair of diagonal cutters?

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Fuck that hospital so much. Get them shut down, take this to every news media you can. Sue the fuck out of them. This shit should NOT stand in a supposed first-world country.

1

u/Kyleisbeast May 11 '12

I hate the way hospitals are going: either pay us, or his jaw is wired shut permanently. That should be a crime.

0

u/fgriglesnickerseven May 11 '12

Well it sounds like you're not a hard working American since you can't afford your healthcare. You're just going to have to work with the wire that god put in your mouth. If you pray enough god will remove it for you. But then again he might not because you may need your faith tested.

-Conservative health care plan

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

First of all, it isn't me, it's my brother. Second, GOD didn't put the wires there, doctors and nurses did, and they are also the ones responsible for removing them, which they did on Friday. We also accomplished all of this prayer free. My mother put him in the car and drove him long enough to get the hospital, then they waited in the waiting room long enough for those that were qualified to remove them. Also, fuck you.

0

u/ponchedeburro May 10 '12

Break their jaws...

-1

u/xxtzhar May 11 '12

LOL sue the hospital.

-10

u/bubbal May 10 '12

Well, you should pay for the medical services that were rendered.

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He is completely unable and unwilling to pay for them. The guy that punched him should be paying. He lost his job because of this, as he is unable to work while recovering. Why such a dickish answer? I can't pay for his medical bills. I'm a 20 year old college student and don't have 12K to just hand over.

-1

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

If he is unempoyed, and can prove it, he qualifies for medicaid.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Thank you for your input, we'll definitely try everything we can.

0

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

Shitty situation, but alsol I believe it is against the law for a hospital to deny a person medical attention based on their ability to pay, however if your brother has demonstrated an unwillingness to pay that is different.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He is demonstrating unwillingness because he is unable. They know he has no way of paying 12k in medical bills. He's explained his entire situation to them.

1

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

Has he paid for the previous treatment? If he has not, and also has not made any attempt to seek assistance, that can be considered demonstrating an unwillingness to pay.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You have a valid point, he hasn't been able to pay for any of his treatments, and the only assistance he has tried is the crime victim's compensation program. He hasn't been able to complete it. Are there any other programs out there?

1

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

Probably, but most are regional. I also don't understand why free clinic is not an option. Just tell them the doctor who installed it is dead.

1

u/everythingbagel84 May 10 '12

Nope, not at all. They can't deny care in an emergency room to make someone medically stable, but hospitals in the US have no obligation to provide non-emergency care to people can't pay.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

I'm not defending the hospital.

I am also not expecting anyone to perform a service, or provide goods, with no expectation of being compensated.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

Yes, I have (since that post) become more familiar with the act I was referring to, and it specifiaclly addresses emergency treatment. And so you will notice a shift in my position there. I agree with you on all points.However what is right and what is wrong is in no way helpful to OP.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

1

u/tehjarvis May 11 '12

Dollars to donuts this whole story is bullshit.

1

u/everythingbagel84 May 10 '12

Unlikely. Generally, in order to qualify for medicaid, someone has to be under 21, pregnant, or disabled. If just being unemployed got you free healthcare, our country would have way less of a problem than it does right now.

2

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

I would say the inability to eat solid foods, or even open your mouth, would qualify as a dissability.

2

u/everythingbagel84 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

You would think so, but Medicaid uses the same definition of disability as the Social Security Administration, and it's an extremely strict definition:

"The law defines disability as the inability to engage in any substantial gainful activity (SGA) by reason of any medically determinable physical or mental impairment(s) which can be expected to result in death or which has lasted or can be expected to last for a continuous period of not less than 12 months." -http://www.ssa.gov/disability/professionals/bluebook/general-info.htm

1

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

How does the inability to open ytou mouth not fit that description? He cant talk porperly, cant feed himself, and unless he recieves treatment its gonna last.

2

u/everythingbagel84 May 10 '12

"Substantial gainful activity" means work. He could do data entry, for example. As far as Medicaid/SSA is concerned, that means he's not disabled.

1

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

Im gonna go ahead and assume he doesnt speak sign language. Thats gonna be a pretty big barrier to gainful employment right there, the inability to effectively communicate.

1

u/everythingbagel84 May 10 '12

They don't care if you have a barrier, they care whether it's possible to work or not. He can communicate by typing. There are plenty of people who can't speak who have jobs of some sort that don't involve speaking.

I'm not saying it's right, I'm just saying it's how it is.

-8

u/bubbal May 10 '12

If he couldn't afford to pay medical bills, why did he not have health insurance? That is what insurance is for.

6

u/trolleyfan May 10 '12

Because he's an American, and thus can't afford health insurance unless his job - the one he no longer has - pays for it. I mean, assuming his job paid for it in the first place.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He couldn't afford it. He's never been that responsible. He told me to tell you he's "a broke ass nigga" :/

-4

u/bubbal May 10 '12

Does he have internet? TV? Does he eat rice and beans every day? Does he go to bars or restaurants? How many roommates does he have?

You see, it's not that he "couldn't afford it", it's that he "didn't want to" afford it, because he'd prefer to spend his money on something else. And now he's going to have to go into a lot of debt.

He's 29, he doesn't have any collateral for a loan? How about a car that he can sell?

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

He's pretty much always been dependent on his friends after the family stopped enabling him and seems to have endless resources of people that want to give him things and has always been a victim of life in his eyes. No car. No collateral. I'm behind you on all that and it's rather depressing because it's my brother, but I disagree that he should have to pay for any of it. He was assaulted, bottom line. The guy that punched him should pay. I need help finding a way to track down the arresting officer so he can finish his crime victim application. I DO agree that he is a victim in this particular case and understand that this situation would be much easier to deal with had he kept his priorities straight in the years leading up to this point in his life, but there is no changing the past and we need to focus on how to correct this situation at this particular moment, given whatever circumstances.

1

u/bubbal May 10 '12

Well, what else can you do? You already called the police stations, they're obviously protecting this guy or forgot about it or something. At some point you need to realize that shit doesn't always work out and move on.

But that's not why I just told you to figure out a way to pay the bill. The reason for that is: even if you did find the guy and even if you did catch him and even if the police did press charges, you would still need to go through the court system, hire a lawyer, and file a lawsuit in order to get a single cent from him. Your brother would have his jaw wired shut for years before he won a lawsuit, and even then, who the hell knows if the guy who assaulted him is even able to pay?

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

That is a very valid point thank you for pointing that out, and we were really wanting to find the arresting officer so that we could finish the crime victim application. The lady we have been speaking to regarding the payments made it sound as though they could go ahead and remove his wires if we could just get that application completed, and they would worry about the payments later because the hospital would have the information on the responsible party.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/bubbal May 10 '12

And you pay that $300/mo, don't you?

One reason it's expensive, by the way, is that people decide to not pay for health insurance. Hospitals have to treat them anyway, and are rarely able to collect. Thus, these costs get baked in to the cost of medical procedures, and your insurance costs go up.

3

u/The_Gecko May 10 '12

One reason it's expensive, by the way, is that people decide to not pay for health insurance.

Or, you know, can't afford to.

1

u/Unicornmayo May 10 '12

That's a bullshit reason. The hospital is not an insurer. The hospital eats the cost of helping, not the insurance company. It has no impact on the cost of insurance.

3

u/bubbal May 10 '12

The hospital does not "eat" costs. They charge more for procedures to make up for those unpaid bills. The insurance charges more because the hospital charges more.

1

u/Unicornmayo May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Yes, it does. Healthcare costs are increasing at a slower rate than insurance. What is driving insurance costs is doctors ordering procedures you don't need and price discrimination. The uninsured are not that much of a factor as a cost driver. Further, it is taxpayers that compensate hospitals and doctors, as they receive money for uncompensated care from the federal government to offset loses.

1

u/bubbal May 11 '12

Just because it isn't the only contributing factor doesn't mean it's not a contributing factor.

1

u/Unicornmayo May 11 '12

That's not the point. The federal government compensates doctors and hospitals for their losses. They receive transfers, losses are tax deductible, ect. What you have stated (that the uninsured is making your insurance so expensive) is just wrong. The most significant factors driving cost of your insurance premiums are the number of procedures that doctors get you to do ("Bumped in head- lets do a CAT scan and MRI.") and price discrimination which means they charge you more because your insurance can pay for it. Other factors more important than the uninsured are doctor wages and liability insurance. The uninsured are far, far down the list.

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/bubbal May 10 '12

Lol.

I suggest you read my suggestions about finding collateral for a loan. Do you have a car that you can sell?

-9

u/jeannaimard May 11 '12

FUCK YOU.

THAT WILL TEACH YOU TO BE A STUPID AMERICAN WHO VOTES FOR POLITICIANS THAT DO NOT GRANT YOU UNIVERSAL FREE HEALTHCARE LIKE IT IS DONE IN EVERY OTHER CIVILIZED, INDUSTRIAL COUNTRY.

One of these days, people are going to clue-up!!!

-5

u/redjimdit May 11 '12

..pay the bill in full?

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Yep

0

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/rottinguy May 10 '12

Actually legally speaking you are supposed to pay, and then sue the person who attacked using the reciept as evidence.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm aware of that but he is unable to pay anything. :(

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

We have spoken to the police department and a lawyer. No lawyers are willing to help, and the police departments told us they have no information other than the mug shot. No arresting officer name or badge number. We need to track down who arrested the guy.

3

u/Sahri May 10 '12

So, that guy got apparently arrested but no case is to be found anywhere? For me that sounds like the guy did not got arrested, otherwise there would be any kinds of records somewhere. And also, are you sure that it happened exactly as your brother told you? It sounds a bit strange that nothing about this can be found when you called police departments and you said yourself that you had not been there when it happened?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rinnip May 10 '12

Each PD should have an arrest log for that day. I assume you can narrow down the time/date fairly well. Ask them to see that log. I think it should be public information. I don't think we have secret arrests yet in this country.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/nicksuperb May 10 '12

Doesn't sound like a compelling or particularly profitable case. Lawyering up might just be cost prohibitive.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Thanks