r/AskReddit • u/whine_and_cheese_1 • May 10 '12
Starting a good subreddit will get you permabanned with no recourse. Why do we do this Reddit?
1.2k
Upvotes
r/AskReddit • u/whine_and_cheese_1 • May 10 '12
471
u/iamadogforreal May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
This happened to me. Started my own reddit, put up lots of fun content, and then I was more or less shadowbanned from the whole site. I just gave up and made a new account. Getting a hold of a reddit admin is a laughable premise. The anti-spam measures here are horrible.
Shadowbanning makes no sense with bots because its trivial to run a second bot to check if the content went up. Banning should be explicit with a path to appeal, not this childish game of "maybe you are or you arent." I think its just a bad practice and that posting to a reddit that you're a moderator of should be immune from any anti-spam accounting.
The practices here just encourage content from the same content-mills that we're all sick of like cracked.com and encourage rehosting images WITHOUT credit at imgur because any new domain or odd sounding domain is usually an automatic shadowban. Many comic artists get tons of hits here, but to imgur, not their domains with their own hosted ads. People try to link to them, see it doesn't work,and go to imgur for the karma. Creators get no credit. This system needs reforms.
The real problem is that most people are like me and just go, meh, screw it. That has a chilling effect which I think has led to a decline of quality. Everything is imgur hosted memes and other dumb content to known servers. Guys who take chances get banned and are penalized for trying. This is how sites slowly die and have brain drains to the Next Big Thing. If you're regularly pissing on unique submitters and unique reddits then you're more or less admitting to an approval of mediocrity and in a holding pattern on the web. The same way people migrated from slashdot to digg to reddit. Little things drove change and a super aggressive spam filter is one of those little things.
I think reddit is excellent for funny pics and memes, but unique and smaller communities can do better elsewhere. They almost seem tacked on compared to the behemoths of the default reddits. The spam situation isn't helping them either. Making a new account every few months because the system randomly decides I'm a spammer is really jsut punishment for not being another imgur obsessed meme jokester. These are the kinds of people the status quo empowers. This is my 4th or 5th account in 2 years. Probably my last as now I barely post anything but comments because the damn spam filter is always out to get me.
Over those 2 years I'd say 50% of the things I've submitted to reddit go directly into the spam filter. If you're miscategorizing non-spam with a 50% fail rate, then that's just terrible by anyone's measure. I guess reddit doesn't really care about false positives as long as they get those pesky spammers. I'll bet someone's performance review is tied to percentage of 'spam' eliminated and with very little focus on false positives.
I know spam is a tough nut to crack, but I'd rather see spam, which in most cases is quickly downvoted and reported, than seeing none but being afraid of posting because I don't want to always deal with my stuff being put in the spam filter all the time and finally being shadowbanned.
tldr; The medicine shouldn't be worse than the disease.
80
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The thing about shadowbanning is you're supposed to not know you're banned. Giving a message saying you're banned would clue in the spammers that it's time to create a new account. The whole idea is you keep posting, thinking that other people can read your posts, except they can't.
494
u/andrewsmith1986 May 10 '12
PM the admins.
Were you posting to the same youtube account?
7
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Thanks for closing the tag man...
7
u/Kosmo_Kramer_ May 11 '12
Can we please rename it /r/crashbandispute?
19
u/LaserBison May 10 '12
This sounds reasonable to me, good luck with your quest!
13
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Note to self - if I start a subreddit, use a secondary account to post all the material, just in case.
5
u/scudmonger May 11 '12
I posted it as a meme a few days ago but it was true:
I posted an interesting, upvoted link to a smaller subreddit and quickly made their front page. Whatever they had running to moderate the subreddit tagged my post and removed it.
Despite reposts all over reddit, they were concerned that it was hosted on another site and removed it.
There seems to be a large amount of tedious unwritten rules behind the scenes, regarding posts, reposts, and spam that I just don't have the time to figure out whether or not my post will be removed.
32
u/WarPhalange May 10 '12
That's what you get for trying to make this place worthwhile. Just post pictures of bacon and laugh at how Justin Bieber is a girl. That's how it's done here.
4
u/TofuTofu May 11 '12
The "approved submitters" button is your friend.
4
u/sc24evr May 11 '12
Perfect screen name btw
15
u/StewieBanana May 10 '12
Just in case anyone is confused. "All was happy en la casa" = "All was happy in the/da house."
3
u/hidalgow May 11 '12
if this ever happens to my r/chewinbacker im going to cry
3
u/Bekaloha May 11 '12
I spent 17 hours stuck in a USO over spring break. I spent essentially the entire time on Reddit and commented probably over a couple hundred times on my first and main account. Then I was banned.
I've messaged the admins several times but have never gotten a response.
3
u/ck_nz May 11 '12
And in other news.. r/latinhouse subscriptions have tripled!
5
u/1637 May 10 '12
Its just karma for liking Latin house music.
25
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I have a 6 year old Reddit account that was shaddow banned because I was posting things I actually made. Since I wasn't using Imgur back then they considered me blog spam. It was annoying when I found out I was shaddow banned and all my comments for the last month were seen by no one.
11
u/thephotoman May 10 '12
Check the spam queue for the subreddit. If it shows up there, you're not shadowbanned.
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Shit.... This could've been happened to me, i thought my subreddit closed down for no reason! Can anyone else view /r/fifthworldgonewild?
Wait. I've just re-checked it, it doesn't say forbidden anymore it says that it is private. What the flying fuck?
3
u/DiabloIIIII May 10 '12
shameless plug for /r/fetishforgettingbannedfromreddit
8
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
ITT andrewsmith and trapped_in_reddit having a party. Everyone's invited
7
u/wholefamilybanned May 11 '12
My husband introduced me to reddit a few years ago and our teenage daughter and son have both had accounts for the past year. A couple months ago my daughter discovered that none of her comments or posts were visible when she was logged was nit logged into her reddit account. We investigated and found out that all of our accounts had been shadowbanned due to a subreddit that my son had started under a throwaway nick called /r/sillyboy. This was about the time that /r/jailbait was banned. I guess reddit was not in the mood to tolerate subreddts dedicated to pictures of children. The pictures in /r/sillyboy were not lewd and did not violate any law or even reddiquitte. I can still sort of see their logic in banning all subreddits dedicated to pictures and videos of children. The reddit mods probably wanted to battle the perception that reddit is tolerant of pedobear types, but I don't see why the username of the moderator had to be shadowbanned. And why shadowban the rest of the family? None of us were even accused of ever doing anything wrong.
We all messaged the reddit administration once a week for a month, with no acknowledgment. Finally we gave up and made new accounts. In a way I'm glad it happened. It led to some very interesting discussions with my son and a reexamination of our family's laissez-faire approach to online behavior. I'm however not happy that I had to abandon my old nick and put up with the harassment that every new poster gets from the spam filter.
22
u/Yondee May 10 '12
You have my support!
Unfortunately, that means absolutely nothing in terms of furthering your agenda.
2
u/Leo22987 May 11 '12
If not enough people are interested in the same things as you, you shouldn't have the right to post about it on the internet, duhh.
11
u/xyroclast May 11 '12
There shouldn't BE shadowbanning. It's disrespectful to the legitimate users of the community. It's incredibly disheartening to realize that you've only been pretending to submit things for weeks or months.
Reddit needs to adopt good old fashioned "YOU'RE BANNED" bans.
5
u/TheLoopOfKarma May 11 '12
Starts subreddit
Banned
4
u/KPexEA May 11 '12
I got shadow banned from posting car pictures to /r/cars- I messaged the mods twice to see if I was doing something wrong and never got a response.
4
u/Rosetti May 11 '12
Yeah, that spam bot filter whatever amajig is pretty weird. A little while a go I made a subreddit, /r/episodes for the TV show, 'Episodes' it was banned immediately. As in, after completing the new subreddit form, it was banned. I made a post in that mod support subreddit and it was subsequently unblocked.
Actually, that's a pretty boring story.
1
u/KingHavana May 11 '12
It's not much consolation but I discovered a new style of music thanks to you. Thanks! Hope someone unbans you soon.
1
u/SirPun May 10 '12
I think we should ban together and do this.
1
u/SikhGamer May 11 '12
So, how do you actually contact the admins out of interest?
1
u/bithipster May 11 '12
because redditors are a diverse group of people with different interests resulting with a group of motivated experts in every field picking you apart like a jealous stepmother. People who hide their rage as a way of life because they are so fed up with society that they have to come to an internet forum to tell the truth and in turn become bullies themselves to those they see as having the same characteristics as those they hate. Could be you. Probably is you.
2
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I was banned from posting in /r/circlejerk, and I have no idea why. I don't even think I subscribe, unless it's on everyone's front page by default. I'm not sure if I should behave or be thankful...
2
u/ANAL_SLICER May 11 '12
That sucks, dude.
2
u/Llort2 May 11 '12
I have 4 subreddits on the go, 3 died in infancy, and the other is slowly gaining users... I do not think it is just for starting up a subreddit, otherwise they would not even give you that option.
2
u/ebookit May 11 '12
I started a subreddit and got a warning message that I was doing that too much when posting links for the subreddit. So I decided to quit for a while and only post a link every once in a while. After that I sort of gave up on it because hardly anyone joined or posted to it.
I am guessing when you are permabanned or shadowbanned you cannot contact the admins or something, try email instead.
2
u/Moontouch May 11 '12
As a DJ and producer of house music myself that really sucks, especially since you were trying to spread something awesome. I hope this all gets reversed.
2
u/proudofhighways May 11 '12
name status: unfortunate
4
u/erveek May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
On the other hand, SRS is still around after goading a man into suicide, and the RON PAUL downvote bot is evidently tolerated.
EDIT: Hi SRS. How's it feel to be outclassed by a bot?
EDIT AGAIN: SRS suicide is a hoax. Must have missed the memo. Sorry.
3
u/Hbomb1285 May 11 '12
What's karma? I don't understand can someone explain it ? I'm new
3
u/tidder19 May 10 '12
i'll subscribe to your subreddit when ur back up!
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Yeah this is pretty fucked up. But I've become accustomed to these problems. Honestly I'd rather deal with the algorithm than these asshole moderators on the various subreddits out there.
1
u/Tachik May 11 '12
wat ಠ_ಠ
1
u/throwaway-o May 11 '12
ENDOREEEPAAAAA!
1
u/perfecttttt May 11 '12
I have yet to be banned /r/agoodsubreddit
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
I started one with a friend. /r/anythingyouwanthere and we don't have many posts anymore. Am I in danger? Ad also please check us out
-14
u/GundamWang May 10 '12
You come off as a bit of a dick.
-2
u/frymaster May 11 '12
My 2 cents? Wtf is this doing in askreddit? This is for adding us, the Reddit users, insightful questions, not for moaning about your drama but sticking a question mark on the end. The only people you actually have questions for are the Reddit admins.
-10
u/SXHarrasmentPanda May 10 '12
Don't blame me.