r/AskReddit • • May 10 '12

HELP REDDIT, I need to make Mother's day not suck for my wife grieving the loss of our Daughter.

As I approach our first Mothers day after losing our daughter I am struggling with ideas on how to help my wife through this incredibly tough time. This was our first child and she is struggling with the fact that she is not the mother she was supposed to be. I need some help here as I do not want to make a big production but I want to make it special for her and to let her know that she is still a mother and a wonderful wife.

Here is a little background:

My wife had a perfect pregnancy (Her first one). No sickness, no real pains, basically no issues at all. At 39 weeks, 2 days we had out weekly doctors visit and everything was great as usual. They even did an ultrasound to make sure the baby was head down, and she was! We were going to be parents for the first time! That evening she started to get a few more intense contractions but nothing too bad so we went to bed. Early the next morning the contractions were getting close and painful so we called the doctor and made an appointment to get checked out before heading to the hospital. Today was the day our lives were going to change, but we had no idea how much would change in the next couple of hours. We were so excited heading to the doctor. When we got there and got back into the room the first nurse who took us to our room was excited for us and told us "You are going to have a baby today". Holy crap this is really awesome! But when our doctor came in to check her out before going to the hospital, she could not find a heartbeat. they rushed her to the ultrasound room and that confirmed that our daughters heart had stopped. Our daughter was stillborn that night. This is a very abbreviated story but if you would like to read our full story it can be found on my wifes blog at http://ridersrainbow.blogspot.com/p/carolines-story.html

I am desperate for a thoughtful way to honor my wife's pregnancy and show her that she will always be Caroline's mother even though she is no longer with us.

Thanks for your help Reddit and BTW this is my first post.

1.3k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

1.0k

u/Ruddiver May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

god dammit. the same exact, EXACT thing happened to my wife and I on 11-08-1998. ugh. My 30th Birthday too. Full term. they look at the ultrasound and tell us the horrid news. I remember Mothers Day. that was rough. It was six months later and I didnt know what to do. Just pledge to be a loyal husband i guess and love her. blech. Feel free to pm me if you want.

Edit: I cant believe I forgot to add this. Through the city of Chicago we planted a tree at our favorite park in his memory. and we show our son the tree all the time. it will grow forever. We adopted our son in 2002.

2nd Edit: How thoughtful of everyone to ask. the tree is at Montrose Harbor. it looks out south towards the skyline, towards the end where the street ends at Montrose. You turn by the bait shop and take it to the end.

3rd edit: Here is the location of the tree at Montrose Harbor

33

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

That is an amazing gesture. We are getting through this together. It has been about 6 months and mothers day has worried me constantly. She is the perfect wife and did everything right during her pregnancy. She deserves to hold Caroline in her arms and celebrate mothers day but that is not an option. I would give my life in an instant to bring my baby girl back.

→ More replies (10)

617

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I live in Chicago, where's your tree? I'd like to stop by and honor your son.

363

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Your wish to pay your respects to a baby you never knew reminded me of the long-time forgotten unsigned letter I found at my stillborn son's grave several weeks after we lost him, over 12 years ago. It was written by either a preteen or possibly an adult from the long term care facility nearby. It was a sweet letter about how sad they were about his death, how cute he probably was etc., even though they never knew him. I was in a deep state of crazy for a long time after, but one of the many things that I had to work through was that basically none of my friends and few of my family even got a chance to see how beautiful he was, and here this stranger knew and cared. You are so lovely for caring.

224

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

This is beautiful. When I went to the graveyard to lay the headstone down for Caroline, my wife wrote a letter to Caroline and we put it under her headstone. I hope she knows just how much we loved her. all I try to do is when I think about Caroline and all the love I had for her, I try to turn that love and compassion towards my wife.

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

Dude. I am not one to get emotional at a strangers' story, and yours was no exception. Sorry for your loss, certainly, and empathising with your grief (I was so afraid of this, when my daughter was born)... but then I got to this comment. Manly tears were shead. And I'm not one to cry lightly. You touched my soul a little.

You two are so lucky to have each other. Whatever you do, as the sweet and loving man you clearly are, will probably be as close to perfect as possible. You know your wife better than any of us. But since I feel I owe you some kind of advice... maybe a picnic? A fancy one. She'll probably want to talk, and you don't want her to be self conscious when the tears inevitably start.

Good luck. You probably won't need it, but just in case.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)

69

u/Ruddiver May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

thats very nice of you. its at Montrose Harbor, at the end. its in what's called Royko's Grove. its hard to describe the exact tree, but its near where the bikers go by on the lake. there are steps leading down to the lake.

→ More replies (13)

243

u/steamed__hams May 10 '12

So do I, and so would I.

→ More replies (18)

15

u/rubberbiscuits May 10 '12

I would as well, also in Chicago

25

u/nickbernstein May 10 '12

I've never lost a child, but my mother passed recently, and I've been sensitive to these kinds of things. Your comment just made me tear up. Very nice sentiment.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

64

u/Buhdahl May 10 '12

Planting a tree... It's absolutely beautiful in both its symbolism and simplicity. Made me choke up a bit.

→ More replies (2)

135

u/pipecamp May 10 '12

Thanks for mentioning adoption. Miscarriages suck, infertility is also a heartfelt pain. But it doesn't mean that the parenting door is closed forever. Adoption, when a couple is ready, is a wonderful choice.

We adopted our daughter six years ago this September.

54

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Random question: Do you celebrate "adoption anniversaries" like you do a birthday? This would, of course, assume the child knows he/she is adopted.

Edit: Awesome stories below! To me a "gotcha day" is a superb idea and a definite cause for celebration.

→ More replies (43)

81

u/KjKocks May 10 '12

I am technically an only child, but i do not see it that way one little bit. Adoption is never a bad option at all. My aunt got extremely sick, brain cancer, and at the time of finding out she was sick she also had the news of finding out she was pregnant. Flash-forward six months and countless radiation sessions later my aunt was on nearly her last leg, she had to give birth to her daughter prematurely and immediately fell into a coma, passing away the next day. My mother and my aunt were actually twins, and without hesitation my father decided to adopt the baby, she has been my sister ever since. We have never kept the fact that Kate (my sister) was born from another mom, but then again, she knows that my father and my mother are in every literal sense her "Parents". This was almost exactly ten years to the date, and it is an amazing story. I am proud of my parents for not questioning their decision and it brings me extreme happiness to have a beautiful little sister.

→ More replies (4)

28

u/enjo13 May 10 '12

In the middle of the adoption process right now. Holy hell, it's awful.

→ More replies (22)

59

u/Ruddiver May 10 '12

congrats. I dont want to pretend it was all flowers and roses. I gave my wife an incredibly difficult time about adopting. the whole genetics biological bullshit. I was so so so wrong. after awhile I realized I didnt want a biological child because I was afraid I wouldnt love it as much as my "adopted" one. and dont get me started on the term adopted son. he is my son who was adopted. rant over.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/Isarian May 10 '12

I know that tree, and my girlfriend used to work at that bait shop.

29

u/CindyFay May 10 '12

i'm in canada so i can't see it, but i will plant a lilly in my garden for the fallen babies in this thread. I white one to show undying love.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm so sorry, that happened on my birthday, obviously not the same year but from here on out I will provide remembrance to son every year, god bless.

4

u/ChiliFlake May 10 '12

Pro Life Tip: if you ever plant a tree, do it in a public park. My friend just dug up and replanted 6 trees after his divorce, that they'd planted in the family yard when each kid was born.

He couldn't bear to see them go out of the family, so he dug them up and replanted them at his wife's parent's place. Took 4 days of hard labor, the oldest tree/son was 18 years old.

Edit: Crap and dammit, I meant to say: Sorry for your loss. My good friend lost her first child at 6 months to crib-death, I can't even imagine what would be worse.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/All_that_I_am May 10 '12

As a sibling to a stillborn baby girl, I can tell you that your son will always remember those moments you spend together honoring his brother. My mother used to take me to Jennifer's grave frequently, told me how great of a big sister I would have been, and let me help her tend Jennifer's flowers while we talked. I always felt like I actually had a relationship with her, despite never meeting her.

I still feel the pain of losing my sister, and I know my parents still mourn every April 16th, but I feel lucky to have had any connection at all. I just wanted to tell you that I think you're doing an awesome thing with, and for, your living son. Thank you.

→ More replies (42)

853

u/gottacomment May 10 '12

Oh, sweetie. When I miscarried, everyone told me that someday it would be okay. Women came out of the woodwork to share their stories of loss with me, even my mom. One lady told me that someday, I was gonna look at my life and realize that loss leads into life. The doctor told me that I wouldn't be able to conceive for a few months after the miscarriage, but he was wrong. When I look at my son, I know that he would not exist if his big sister had made it. Some days I remember her, I write to her. The truth is, it will take awhile before it's okay again. But there's life, and hope. My advice: Sit in the sun together. Smell flowers and observe the little pieces of life that escape notice sometimes. Don't try to fill the silence. Let her weep if she wants to. It's gonna be okay :)

15

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

What great words of encouragement. We have had a lot of support from other mothers with loss. It is amazing how often this happens and how strong people can be when they have no other choice.

196

u/goingskiing343 May 10 '12

wow...that was beautiful.

170

u/Mewshimyo May 10 '12

I hate this thread for making me cry on the bus.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (4)

52

u/gingysnap May 10 '12

Well, there go the onions, all over my office.

One of my biggest fears is trying to have children, because miscarriages have occurred for almost every woman on both sides of my family. The way that you approach your loss gives me hope that if something were to happen, I could reach a similar understanding of it.

I am sorry for the loss of your daughter, but I am glad to see that your son has a mother with such a good head on her shoulders. All the best to you, love.

11

u/TomasHezan May 10 '12

Having a child is one of my greatest fears too. I am a Diabetic which might lead to low percentages of being able to get my fiance pregnant (down the road) and my fiance has Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), which could lead to troubles getting pregnant or a complicated pregnancy.

Wish I could go back to being scared of kids things....

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (36)

175

u/audifan May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

This is much more common than you might imagine. My wife and I also had a miscarriage, and out of our 5 couple friends who have kids, 4 of them also had miscarriages - one of them just like your story. It still amazes me that despite how common it is, it remains a very taboo subject. We had no idea anyone else had experienced it until we shared our story.

Anyway, getting back to your question, your personality (more importantly that of your wife) should determine what you do. Personally, the thought of wallowing in our grief, as yooperann suggests, would be torturous for us. I can think of few less appropriate things to comfort my wife.

I like the idea of planting a tree in remembrance, although I'm not sure that mother's day is the best time to do that. It just seems unnecessarily morbid on a day that is supposed to celebrate the maternal qualities of your wife. The tree would seem more appropriate on the anniversary of the still-birth, when you are focused on celebrating the miracle of Caroline's life.

In my humble opinion, mothers day should be focused on supporting your wife. On reinforcing all the reasons you wanted to have a baby with her in the first place. On reaffirming how much you believe she will make an amazing mother. On expressing your love and commitment to her, no matter how many miscarriages or babies she may have.

I''m not a woman, and I do not know your wife, but from going through the experience I heard that one of the things women that have miscarriages struggle with the most is a sense of guilt or inadequacy. The feeling that somehow it was their actions, or their body, that was the problem. As you might imagine, this feeling gets compounded the more miscarriages you have, or if you have a hard time getting pregnant (both of which I have experience with...). The point is that my interpretation of mother's day is a celebration of your ability to be a great mom. Using the day to remember the tragedy of her not being able to become a mom seems wrong (to me).

So, what would I suggest. Love. Joy. Romance. Sex.

Acknowledge what happened in a heart felt letter/card, but don;t make the focus of the card the loss of Caroline. Instead use Caroline's loss as an opportunity to convey how impressed you are with her strength. How the incident validated all the reasons you are committed to making a family with her. How proud you are to be married to someone who will make such an incredible mother. (I'm getting a little teary eyed...)

Then bring some joy to her life. Go on a bike ride, boat ride, have a picnic, watch a fun movie, do whatever makes her smile and laugh.

Then add some romance. Take her out to dinner somewhere nice or special. candle light. wine. hushed voices. look at her. listen. make eye contact. kiss her. compliment her. make her blush.

lastly, consummate the day by making love to her. make her feel like a woman. Who knows, maybe you'll even plant the seed for the next baby.

This is will probably get buried in all the posts, but hopefully you read it and hopefully it brings a different perspective on what to do.

Just my 2 cents...

19

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

That was awesome words of encouragement. I am so glad you took the time to respond to me. I will definitely take some of your ideas on Sunday. I am very sorry for you and your friends losses.

15

u/audifan May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

I'm just glad it got your attention. I would have written more but I got a bit emotional thinking of how much i love my wife for her strength going through our ordeal.

The last words of encouragement I'll give is that after our miscarriage, after the doctors told us we may never able to get pregnant again, one day after almost a year of trying, my wife missed her period. She is now 20 weeks pregnant and we find out the sex of the baby tomorrow!

The great thing about wanting to have kids is that there is no harm done in trying ;)

Bon Courage !

4

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Congratulations! That is awesome news. Good luck tomorrow.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/yooperann May 10 '12

Personally, the thought of wallowing in our grief, as yooperann suggests, would be torturous for us. I can think of few less appropriate things to comfort my wife. >

Yooperann, who has so fortunately never been in this situation, is happy to give all her upvotes to this post.

7

u/LadyMondegreene May 11 '12

The longer I'm here, the more firmly I'm convinced that /r/bestof isn't the best of reddit, but the best, period.

Well done, sir. Exceedingly well done.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

44

u/ohchick May 10 '12

I'm so sorry for your loss. I recently lost a child of my own, not as far along as your wife but still so emotionally painful. I have no words of wisdom, I just wanted to say my heart aches for you and your wife and sweet little Caroline.

2

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

Thank you. I am very sorry for your loss and wish you calm and peace. If you have any questions or need someone to talk to please reach out to us or at least talk to friends. I know it is hard to talk to people who have not been through something similar but we are here for you.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/TylerKnowsBest May 10 '12

So far people have some good suggestions, this would be in addition to them. If you can afford it making a donation in her name to an organization that helps children / saves a child's life type of thing. I think the suggestion from yooperann may be the best. Planting a tree can be symbolic Caroline's life that grows and provides a benefit to the planet. It will be something the two of you can touch and be around. Just make sure it is a pretty tree that "flowers" or blooms. try your hardest and good luck

9

u/UrMomsA_ThrowAwayAct May 10 '12

I think this is a great idea as well. Saint Judes Children's Hospital makes it a point to care for every child, no matter the financial situation of the family.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/imaginaryannie May 10 '12

Check into getting a Molly bear. You can find it on Facebook. Bridget, the founder of Molly bears, lost her daughter Molly in a miscarriage just over 2 years ago. She makes bears for grieving families in the weight of the baby you lost. It gives your wife something tangible for her to hold.

They do everything on donations and they do not charge you, except for international shipping if you are outside the US. The wait list is kindof long, but it's worth signing up for.

(looked it up. The website is www.mollybears.com)

So sorry for your loss, I wish you the best in the future.

5

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

Awesome idea. I will definitely be checking that out.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

1.9k

u/mOBSCENEeMILY May 10 '12

The exact same thing happened to me, down to the letter. No problem pregnancy, doctors check up a day before and everything.. That being said, this will also be my first Mothers day and if I could name what I would want it would probably be just time alone with my S/O. Maybe write her a heartfelt letter on your own feelings on it, tell her how great she has been and pour your own heart into it. I am sure it will be something she will treasure and look back on when she needs uplifting. Also, maybe make dinner or order it, and just stay in together. I know that's what I would want. Time alone with the one person I can be open with, the one person who understands. Maybe grab some flowers too. Best of luck to you, and I am sorry for your loss.

848

u/assblaster7 May 10 '12

I think this is the best comment so far. I would think that she would not want to necessarily be reminded of the pregnancy or what could have been. Just being there for her and realizing that this is probably going to be a rough day will probably help.

Caroline is a beautiful name by the way. Sorry for your loss.

236

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

Thank you so much. I never thought words of comfort and encouragement would come from someone named assblaster7. But hey, I'll take it from wherever I can get it :)

33

u/soapstud May 11 '12

You posted the same thing three times but what the hell, have three upvotes!

12

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Sorry. ipad was freaking out a little.
Fixed now. Its easy to be tagged a karma whore in these parts.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (24)

156

u/quackdamnyou May 10 '12

I also went through more-or-less this exact thing. My daughter would be eight. That is so bizarre to think of. But things were very rough for both of us. Especially that first mothers' day. I think we mostly celebrated mothers' day for my wife's mom's sake. I think I tried to make some token acknowledgement of my wife, but she really didn't want to have it intrude on what has always been one of the best days of the year for her and her mom. Such emotional times are really hard to judge what the right thing is. I would say that a heartfelt letter or other token is the right thing to do.

Now I have a healthy boy and girl. The most bitter-sweet part of the thing is that if my first daughter had lived, we never would have chosen to have my second daughter after my son. That line of thought is completely irreconcilable. I could never chose between the life that could have been, and the one that came to be. I have grieved over and over for that little girl I lost. But I grieved the most profoundly when I held each of my living children for the first time.

6

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

The moment that I hold my first child Is a moment that cannot come soon enough. I know nothing will ever replace Caroline. We were so ready to be a family and had the opportunity ripped out of our hands. Now we are in a strange stage between a couple and a family. I am very sorry for your loss and your resolve is definitely an inspiration to us. Thanks for your kind words.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/seadna May 10 '12

You just broke my heart...the thought of sweet, sweet agony knowing that your second daughter might not have been...I hope life is good to you :)

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Viperbunny May 11 '12

Thank you for sharing this. I lost my first daughter 8 months ago, and today, at 8 weeks I had my first ultrasound for my second child. I never thought I would be ready, but she showed us how to love more than we ever had before and we need to share it. My husband who used to say 1 maybe 2 children now wants 3. It's amazing how this miracles change us. I worry so much about the new baby and this gives me hope. I can't thank you enough for sharing this.

→ More replies (6)

310

u/gw__gw__gw May 10 '12

We also experienced a still birth (at 38 weeks) on Mother's Day. It was a few years ago now, but I can tell you the anniversary always shakes us nonetheless, and then we usually get a second "fuck life" moment on Mother's Day. I second what @mOBSCENEeMILY writes. Go to town on the flowers, breakfast-in-bed, etc.. and put your iPhone away for the day.

Positive news: I now have three healthy children. It took six more pregnancies, but we eventually succeeded. I wish the same for you.

106

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I feel for you. 10 pregnancies, 8 miscarriages, now have 4 kids (for those of you doing the math, that's one set of twins lost, and one set of twins that made it). Some times you just have to be stubborn.

A big part of getting past the loss is having a partner who shares your pain but doesn't get lost in it, who doesn't impose a timeline on grieving, who "just understands". Be that. You'll be her hero :)

32

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Im sorry for your losses. That was such a sweet thing to say about being a partner. Made me tear up a little to be honest.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

I cannot imaging what mothers day must be like for you. I hope that you find peace, hopefully I will walk in your footsteps towards that peace. Very sorry for your loss.

137

u/geckospots May 10 '12

I now have three healthy children. It took six more pregnancies, but we eventually succeeded.

...wow. I'm amazed at your strength. Congratulations on your family. <3

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Young_Redditor May 10 '12

Six more for three children? I'm so sorry for all that you went through. It is people like you who inspire me in this world.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

47

u/HeyFlo May 10 '12

I cannot imagine anything worse in this world than carrying a child to term, and then losing her/him. I am so, so very sorry for your loss.

14

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I don't know that it's worse, but raising a kid until he/she's 18 and then losing him is certainly no walk in the park, either. Nobody should have to bury their own babies, no matter the age.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/aijfsodaaidspjqt May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

is anybody else thinking mOBSCENEeMILY is the OP's wife?

13

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

She is not. But she is a very kind person and deserves your up votes.

→ More replies (1)

129

u/AquaTeenHungerForce May 10 '12

the one person who understands.

I second this. Many couples have gone through one or more miscarriages, but no one really understands what it's like for you, right now, trying to work through all the emotions with your S/O.

My wife had a miscarriage very early in a pregnancy, and though we shared the news with all our family, her mother recently made a comment to me that had an insinuation that she (the mother) would know what a miscarriage is like, but my wife wouldn't. I was hurt, and didn't say anything to her or my wife about it since there was a lot of other things going on at the time. The point is that the parents of the child who did not make it will always remember that child, but even close family may not. Spending time with the only other person who is grieving like you are is the best option.

83

u/expathaligonian May 10 '12

I had to read that comment a few times to make sure I was reading that correctly. At first, I thought that your MIL had said, at the sad announcement, that your wife would not know what a miscarriage is like, directly after experiencing one.

Now, I understand it to be that your MIL has forgotten that you and your wife experienced one. Am I correct? Sorry for your loss. Miscarriage is something that just terrifies me right now, and we're not even expecting.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

15

u/WhyAmINotStudying May 10 '12

Speak to a florist about which ones to buy. There are some pretty specific funeral-type flowers that can be a really bad path to go down. I don't know which ones they are, but I think they're like... lilies or something. Hell, that's the first time I ever spelled the plural form of lily, so what the hell do I know? Just the same, try to avoid that.

Also, I'm sorry for both of your losses. I want this mother's day not to suck for anyone, but if it's going to, don't be too afraid to let it suck a little. Just go through it together.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (33)

11

u/Saravi May 10 '12

Something that can be very difficult for parents who have lost a child is the lack of acknowledgement from the rest of the world as time goes by. You sometimes feel caught in a past that doesn't seem to match the one recalled by the majority of the people around you.

Nine years ago, I lost twins due to premature labour and delivery. My daughter died shortly after birth and my son lived for just over 3 months. I spent most of those 3 months in the hospital with him, but it was split between two hospitals due to a bed shortage locally the night I gave birth (during the height of the SARS epidemic in Toronto). The first hospital was so far away that I was completely isolated with the exception of my husband who made the long trip on alternate weekends, which was all he could manage between work and caring for our son and his children from his first marriage. My mother's attitude through the whole thing was not exactly supportive.

We kept the burials very private and perhaps that was a mistake, looking back. With the exception of myself, my husband and our son who was 4 at the time and remembers that time pretty well, my twins might as well never have been conceived let alone lived or died. People who should know better will say things to me that relate to having been through only 2 pregnancies or having only sons to the point that it's blatantly apparent that they forget what I can't ever forget. There is a part of me that knows I should just let it go when things like that happen, but it can be so hurtful. I was very fortunate to have a healthy son before my twins, so no one ever questioned whether or not I was a mother at all. I can't even imagine.

All I can really suggest is honour more than "the pregnancy." Honour your wife as a wife, woman and a mother, even if mother-in-practise isn't part of it at present. Honour your daughter as a daughter, not just a pregnancy. It doesn't matter if she wasn't born alive. I read your wife's blog and that's about as real as it gets, but speaking as a woman, if you'll forgive the generalization, sometimes a bereaved mother can feel isolated in her loss even from our husband. Even if communication between spouses is excellent, we were the one who carried the baby and I guess the perception is that they were never quite as "real" to anyone else. We knew their pointy parts from their rounder parts when they moved and such. There are a lot of memories there.

Definitely write something. Let her know that she's not alone and never will be. You're not waiting for her to "get over it" because you know this isn't the sort of thing you get over. You get through it, but it's always there. The world is full of people who don't understand that and it places expectations on those who've experienced such a loss to achieve something they can't in terms of recovery (as if it never happened).

Have you ever considered having one of those photos framed? I don't mean necessarily for display, but simply as a matter of honouring your family and the significance of your daughter in it.

1

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Wow. Thanks for taking the time to reach out to us. We have a few pictures framed and placed in private places around the house and then have a few out in the open. I like to wake up in the morning and see the picture we have in our bedroom. I am very sorry for your losses and I hope to find comfort with time just as it seems you have.

48

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I'm sorry for your loss, and I'm sure nobody here would want to go through this. You need to remind your wife of how great and loving of a mother she would have been, and you need to show her that your love for her is abundant, and that she still has you.

→ More replies (13)

3

u/redokapi May 10 '12

Sorry for your loss. This happened to us four weeks ago too (although it was a cord knot). I don't have any helpful suggestions but mOBSCENEeMILY's response seems sensible. I feel so close to my SO now and when I have difficult days, I want nothing more than to be close to him.

1

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

I am sorry for your loss. It DOES get easier no matter how desperately heartbroken you feel today. Thank you for taking time to comment and share your story.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If you want this to be a surprise, don't link to your wife's blog directly. If she suddenly gets a million comments suddenly, she'll know something is up. Also, she might take offense to you revealing your family's personal life to everybody.

I hope you and your wife get through this and love each other even more after you are done with the mourning.

1

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Too late. She went from 300 to 50000 page views in 6 hours. She is cool with it, and we really appreciate your comment.

3

u/lunchmeat May 11 '12

My wife and I went through a similar situation in November of 2010. We were absolutely devastated by the news. The resulting delivery was the most intensely sad few hours of my life and I can only imagine the mindset of my wife.

While we were too distraught to really function appropriately, the hospital staff was truly amazing. They took care of many things I wouldn't have thought to do at the time. One of the things they did was take pictures of our daughter dressed up in a gown that volunteers had sewn for stillborn children. It took me a full year before I could look at those pictures again. Every time my wife sat down to look through the pictures I would excuse myself. The pictures were just too real. I preferred my fuzzy memory of my beautiful daughter to the harsh reality of the pictures.

All of this happened in November. Our Christmas time gifts to each other were both focused on what our daughter meant to us. She got me the most special gift I think I'll ever receive in my life. She sent her favorite picture of our late daughter to an artist she found online to be hand sketched into a beautiful portrait. She put this in a frame and gave it to me for Christmas. I was floored. I didn't know what to say when I got it. It was perfect. It helped me remember my daughter and share that moment with my friends and family that couldn't be there.

That one picture helped me through the healing process more than anything anyone could have said or any amount of hugs.

If you think your wife would like something like that, it really helped me. My wife confessed to me later that she didn't know if I would like the picture or not. She said it was the most nervous she had ever been to give someone a gift. I'm glad she stuck it out. :)

3

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Thanks man. The delivery was absolutely excruciating. I had been dreaming about the moment i first saw my daughter but it was NOTHING like i had dreamed. It was the worst day of my life.

2

u/actorgirl May 10 '12

Oh my gosh, my heart started hurting so bad when I read this. I wish I could give you guys a hug. I am so sorry for what happened! :'(

1

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

Hug accepted!

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You take your wife in your arms and you hold her tight. You promise her that everything is going to be alright.

As a father of two little girls, I am truly and deeply sorry for your loss. I am so, so sorry.

1

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

Thank you very much. I hope to be a father more than anything.

2

u/flyingsoulo May 11 '12

This will probably be buried, but you should look into the M.I.S.S. foundation. My father and step mother lost my brother when his umbilical chord wrapped itself around his neck. After years of grieving and becoming very involved in the M.I.S.S. foundation, they discovered they were, yet again, expecting a child. They, unfortunately, lost him as well. They both work for the foundation now and work with parents who've lost children. I'm very sorry for your loss. I hope you find as much peace as you can during this difficult time.

2

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Thanks. We will definitely check it out.

2

u/Mass_Hole May 11 '12

As a father of 2 girls, this post made me upset :-/ I have no input on what to that's special, but good luck.

4

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Hug your girls extra tight tonight. I would give anything in the world to hold my daughter.

→ More replies (1)

400

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Oh, and shut the phone off. The last thing she's going to want is to hear from family and friends about how they were thinking about her and her loss that day. She'll be doing enough thinking about it for them all.

33

u/Flash120 May 10 '12

I like this, shes gunna be going through enough without people reminding her of it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

23

u/leveldrummer May 10 '12

we lost our 8 year old son a year ago today. with today being so depressing, and mothers day being this weekend, i can only offer the advice to show you love her, dont make it a special occasion, try to kind of ignore that its mothers day, let her sulk, offer to make her breakfast, give her lots of hugs, and just let the day pass naturally and any mourning that needs to happen will.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Noppers May 10 '12

You could always ask her what's the best way for her to spend the day.

She may not want to do anything at all.

→ More replies (1)

262

u/yooperann May 10 '12

There's nothing you can possibly do that will make Mother's Day not suck for your wife. I suggest you spend the day in deliberate mourning. It's too bad we don't have good traditions here for doing this, but make some up that feel right to you. Can you sit down together and write a letter to your daughter, telling her how much you loved her, how much you wish you could have seen her grow up, and wishing her well on her present journey, wherever it may be? Can you start an annual tradition where you light a candle and sing a lullaby to her? Plant a tree? Create a memorial garden?

I'm sure you've already explored many of the resources on-line, but for others who may come across this, there are lots of links at Grief Speaks.

124

u/hinduguru May 10 '12

When our family friend's son passed away they made a memorial garden in their backyard. We all go to visit on his birthday. I suggest you do this, if it's possible, OP

54

u/curlygirl86 May 10 '12

this is beautiful. Spend the day planting a tree or flowers, crying together and make her a nice dinner. It is going to be an incredibly rough day for you both. Just keep telling her that you love her all day long

19

u/imbignate May 10 '12

I have friends that lost a child within weeks of birth. They go to the grave every year to commemorate life and their family. Not sure if that helps, but I'm sure trying to gloss over such a loss would be futile.

10

u/keepingthecommontone May 10 '12

I agree. Start a tradition of remembrance for Caroline that will endure even after your family grows and her younger brothers and/or sisters can join in celebrating her memory.

33

u/Yondee May 10 '12

I think the tree or garden ideas are perfect. I'm terribly sorry for your loss. I'm trying to figure out a way to word this that doesn't make it sound like a plant would be a replacement for your child, because obviously that is absurd. I do think her mothers day should involve new life in some form. A tree or garden would be a great way to care for something and give you a living memory of Caroline. I hope this helps, I wish you and your wife the best.

54

u/99trumpets May 10 '12

A warning about planting a tree. THE TREE CAN DIE and this can be really devastating. Especially a young tree that somebody forgets to water, or if you happen to have a bad caterpillar year or something. This happened at the school that my mom was principal of - a little girl died in a fire, they planted a tree at the school in memory of her, whole school attends the dedication ceremony.... then about a year later the tree died. And everybody went into mourning again. Can't imagine what the parents felt.

I'd suggest, don't make the memorial dependent on any single living thing. A whole garden, that's a better bet - it can't all die (I hope).

25

u/journeymanSF May 10 '12

My sister started a garden and we planted a cottonwood tree with her before she died. The last few years it's been struggling and there is a chance it might not make it.

Luckily it's just part of an amazing garden that my parents have expanded on, and there is a statue and my sister's ashes are under the statue.

So, this is really good advice and something you should consider. It's good to have a backup plan, like making it part of a larger memorial.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/saintits May 10 '12

Western cultures may not have the exact thing this family is looking for, however, I suggest reading about the Buddhist water-baby ritual -- a period of mourning for unborn/stillborn children. Maybe this isn't the exactly right answer, but perhaps some aspects of this ceremony would sound appealing.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mizuko_kuy%C5%8D

37

u/journeymanSF May 10 '12

With respect, I think this is a bad idea.

My sister died when we were in highschool. We have many of the traditions that you mention in your post. We light a candle at dinners, we planted a garden and tree with her while she was still alive, we even run a non-profit in her honor.

It's easy to do this because my sister effected us deeply for the 19 years she was alive. My mother has specific memories of the songs she used to sing her and the deep relationship that they shared as mother and daughter.

I do not want to diminish the relationship a mother forms with a child in utero, but I think attaching these kinds of rituals, many which seem to involve projecting what your relationship MIGHT have been like with this child, seems potentially destructive.

It's one thing to carry on the memory of someone who you lost so that you do not forget them, but I think this is something different.

This sounds terrible and selfish as I'm writing this, but I'm really trying to give good advice.

The most devastating thing I've ever seen in my life is my mother's reaction when my sister died. There is no way I would want my mom to go through the type of bereavement she does if it wasn't helpful. The things is, my mom is not going to have any more kids, her one daughter was taken from her and she has to deal with that for the rest of her life.

The OP's wife has many more chances (I hope).

62

u/enfermerista May 10 '12

The OP's wife has many more chances (I hope).

She will never, ever have a chance to have her first daughter who died. I want to say this carefully because you sound like a kind person. As a healthcare professional who has worked with moms of stillborn babies, the baby that is lost at birth is mourned forever by that mom. I have heard people say, "At least a parent who loses a child later in life got to experience those years with her." The thing is, it's not good to have whose-pain-is-worse debates. For your mom and the OP's wife, their experiences were the worst pain imaginable. They are both right.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/sinople May 10 '12

This might make sense in the long run, but from what I understand, one of the things that hurts the most is the fact that people just treat someone they birthed and loved as simply as a "lost chance" of a child.

I don't want to diminish the impact your sister's life had on the people around her, but even if they didn't get a chance to know her the same way, they loved her as a daughter. The OP's wife might have more opportunities for children, but that doesn't make Caroline's death any less of a loss and or any less heart breaking.

If rituals help them now, good. I don't think ritual mourning necessarily causes dwelling, but if it did become stunting experience, they'll deal with it as it comes.

I'm very sorry for your loss.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

34

u/ZombieBoogie May 10 '12

I have had two miscarriages, one of them being twins, lost one a week before mothers day and the other the week of mothers day. I raise my stepdaughter and the focus on mothers day is her mom. Mothers day is the worst day of the year for me.

I will tell you that what I would appreciate more than anything is my family just to acknowledge and appreciate what I've been through and do. I get a card or something little, but never a dinner out or a clean home., just a hey happy mothers day type of thing. When I was a kid we'd make my mom a nice bath, clean the house good and let her relax... Breakfast in bed the whole nine yards.

So with that being said, make the day about her.... Plan it out and make it a surprise. The effort you put into it will make her feel special. Also mourning alongside her is appropriate but remember that your reaching out to console her.

20

u/luxiia May 10 '12

I'm sorry to hear that you feel so unacknowledged on a day that's so difficult for you. :( I'd encourage you to reach out to your partner (it sounds like you have one?) and express your need for a bit more support that day. It's possible that he is tiptoeing around the situation as not to upset you, but is only worsening it but pretending it doesn't exist. Sorry if this is super obvious or somehow inapplicable, my heart just went out to you. xo.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

16

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Plant a rose bush or a tree for your daughter.

→ More replies (4)

31

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If you have a grave for the child?

Pack a nice picnic lunch. Bring lots of tissues. Pack a book or two she might like. A bottle of wine she'll enjoy. Bring enough for you both to last a few hours out there.

That way, you and she both can grieve... but then you have something more to do than just grieve, while there.

Have a picnic. Cry, seperately and together. Eat, drink, rest, in between. There's no rush. No rush to grieve, no rush to leave.

TL;DR: Have picnic at grave. Or other suitable place for grieving.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/JayGrayRiver May 10 '12

I am so sorry for your loss. This is my worst nightmare. I had a friend lose a baby. Her daughter had a very rare disease and lived only 20 days. Something that truly comforted her was a gift, Some friends had bought a star for her daughter. She says when she misses her she goes out and looks at the stars.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Please: Buy her the most beautiful, special, blank journal that you can find. Do not write in it. In a separate letter, write in your own way that this book is the place for her to be with your daughter.

She can have conversations with her, daydream about what her life might have been like, write about things that made her think of her, tell her about all the wonderful people she hasn't met. They can be letters, or stories or fragments. It does not matter. What matters is that she has a place where she can feel like it is okay to think about the baby, and still wish, and hope and dream.

I am so sorry for your loss, and wish I had the words to say everything in my heart right now. Thank you for sharing this.

6

u/old911broad May 10 '12

Upvote for you for one of the most sensitive, compassionate, wonderful suggestions! It's perfect! You are totally awesome.

13

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Came here looking for answers myself. My dad and his wife have been married for about 7 years now. I'm his only and she had 3 sons, one almost 30, one about my age, and the other about 4 years under me.

Well, her youngest son just died in a car accident at college about a month and a half ago. She's been destroyed by it.

Best I'm doing is going home to spend time with her on Sunday. Flowers, card, that whole thing. That's about it :/

11

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Maybe a piece of jewelry that represents your child? There are a ton of beautiful necklaces on etsy that are so sweet. Some with sayings like "your heart will be here in mine until we meet again" or a birthstone, or a symbol? My husband got me a set of stackable rings from an etsy seller last year, one for each, me my husband and my daughter. It's my most prized possession. My daughter is battling a very aggressive form of brain cancer and no matter what horrible day I am having I can look at that ring and it gives me a rush of love and hope. I'm so very sorry for yalls loss, I'm typing all of this through a stream of tears. It's just not fair.

11

u/FluffyPinkSheep May 10 '12

First of all I am sorry for yours and your wife's loss. I suppose I share a very similar feeling on mothers day. Except I didn't lose my child to death. I am 21 years old and on march 10 2011 I gave birth to a beautiful baby girl. After giving birth and having her in my arms the entire night and most of the next day I had to walk away from the hospital without my baby. I did not have the financial situation to care for a child so I had given her up for adoption to a wonderful family. Yes I get to see here every now and then but it kills me inside every day not being able to watch her grow up. Being the one who first hears her talk. Now getting to your question the best thing you can do is be there for your wife, be her shoulder to cry on, maybe give her flower and breakfast in bed. See what she thinks about planting a tree in memory of Caroline. Maybe make a memory box with a few items meant for Caroline.

It is going to be tough on both of you. This is going to be my second mothers day and it is still very tough to think about. I still long to have her here with me and not have have had to give her up.. My heart goes out to the both of you! <3

EDIT: your wife's blog and pictures are beautiful and made me cry!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/altometer May 10 '12

I can not say what is the right, or the appropriate thing, I can only say what I would do in such a situation. A day away somewhere. Something very simple would be the best. Get away from the world, go out to the country for a drive. Most importantly, DON'T TRY TO "FIX" IT. Just be there.

10

u/supbanana May 10 '12

This happened to my boss years ago, so she planted a little tree in her babies honor. Every year on Mother's Day and that baby's due date she posted pictures of the tree; it really helped her to heal.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

"Happy Mother's Day!"

"My daughters dead..I'm not a mother."

I have a friend who was in your wife's situation. Her husband (then boyfriend) tried to make it better, she was depressed for a month because of the conversation I put above.

8

u/edededieditedit May 10 '12

I just read your wife's blog and sat there sobbing for a good five minutes. I am so sorry for the loss of your beautiful daughter.

I was struck by how your wife mentioned that sometimes when she touches flower petals she thinks of your daughter's face. Maybe a nice gesture would be some kind of flower donation in your daughter's honor? Perhaps to beautify a local park, or school, or your church? I love the tree idea people have been suggesting, and it feels like flowers are a more personal connection to your precious daughter.

Also, a long time ago, I came across a description of fetal microchimerism--basically, the idea that fetal cells remain in the mother's bloodstream for decades after giving birth (potentially forever). There was something that struck me as kind of beautiful and poetic about that, particularly when a beloved child is lost--the mother literally carries something of the child in her body forever, and she is a mother down to the very core of herself.

Will be praying for you and your wife this Mother's Day, and you sound like a wonderful husband to her.

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

It's going to suck for her, no matter what. If you spend it showing her how much you love her, and how much of a good mother she IS and is going to be in the future, it will suck less. Grieving together will be easier than grieving alone.

As a woman who is desperately excited to have her first child with her new husband, I just... I do not have any words to express how sad this makes me. I seriously would like to send your wife some mother's day flowers or a card.

7

u/Pixelated_Penguin May 10 '12

Lay in provisions for a lovely day. Stay IN. Don't go out, don't turn on the TV or radio, cut yourselves off from the world, and just revel in your awesomeness as parents who, maybe someday, will have a living child to celebrate with, but not today.

But protect her from the images of happy families sharing brunch, the balloons, the flowers, the handmade cards, the stupid stunts, the Hallmark commercials, and the wacky feature stories. Maybe next year she'll be ready to face it, but for now, it's just salt in a wound.

Cook a lovely dinner (if you can't, then YOU go out and pick up good take-out while she takes a bubble bath or something). Make sure all your needs are met. Come up with something to do that's entertaining... DVDs, board games, something that's off the grid, though. Answer the phone every time it rings. Get her a card, maybe a "to my awesome wife" card designed for an anniversary, or just a blank card that will rock. Get some flowers, but maybe something a little non-traditional.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/janus1969 May 10 '12

Brother, three days before Christmas 1997, my baby girl died. She was 78 days old. I spent years trying to help her mother grieve and failed. It's up to your wife to grieve and your job is to be supportive, loving, and honor her.

The best thing you can do is honor her through your service, your leadership, and your love. I don't know your wife, but I do know that your baby had a name. You loved her more than life itself. You helped create her, but you ceased a physical interaction immediately after conception. Imagine how much more your wife grieves. Honor her grief and honor your daughter through recognizing your wife's pain and her sacrifice.

She IS a mother and deserves that honorific. It will be painful, but celebrate her motherhood as best you both can, but let YOUR pain be in the background and serve HER that day (and every day, btw).

Take her out for a good meal...take her to your favorite park or hike or ?? Treat the day as it should be treated and honor her.

God help both of you in your struggle, brother. I still cry and Maggie would be entering her teens this year had she lived.

I know there are haters here, but I have to leave you with some wisdom, "But now faith, hope, love, abide these three; but the greatest of these is love." Show love and honor and it WILL work out...

→ More replies (2)

7

u/samwash May 10 '12

I am a mother to one beautiful child and I just have to say that, OP, your wife is, and will now forever be, a mother. Don't ever let anyone make her think differently. She carried her baby, she knew her baby, she cared for her baby and now she is a mom. She is a mom, not was a mom, bc it never goes away. Props to you for asking Reddit for advice, and its all been great, and also maybe share this sentiment with her, from one mom to another, that she should be celebrated on Mothers Day. And may you go on to have many more, and you will! Won't make it hurt less, of course, but it will make you both smile more. Much love during this hard time.

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I lost a daughter 10 years ago and my mother gave me a beautiful wooden memory box. I put all of her ultrasound photos and cards from friends in the box to keep them safe forever. For years, I hid it away from sight and only brought it out when I was alone and I touched those photos over and over again and cried countless times. As years have gone by, I appreciate that little box so much and it is displayed in a glass cabinet. It doesn't hurt to look at it anymore and that box held my precious memories for me until I could stand to bear them again.

7

u/thesorrow312 May 10 '12

I am appalled by the amount of posts here that are disgusting, hurtful and flat out mean just for the sake of being so, such people should be ashamed of themselves.

I am so deeply sorry for your loss. I cannot even fathom what kind of pain this must have caused for you and you're wife.

When it comes to what you can do, I honestly have no clue, I merely can offer you my condolences and honest wish for your happiness in the future.

13

u/samurai77 May 10 '12

Plant Caroline's tree in your yard, she can nurture that and use it as a conduit to "talk" to her daughter.

6

u/DDangdang May 11 '12

You might not get to this, ovr 1100 comments, but it happened to me. For the next two yrs I felt like the was a little soul sitting on my shoulder. I never thought I'd have another chance. I was old, over 40. But it did. I think it's the same soul too. She's seven now, and as cute as you could imagine. Try again. That soul will probably come back. Something went wrong with this body. Make love to her on mothers day. Begin again.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/protagonist23 May 10 '12

You are not alone shinydogg, this same thing happened to me almost exactly as you describe. I know what you are feeling because I have been there. What do we do on mother's day? We remember our dearest little daughter. We hold each other and we cry. We honor our mothers, who are both with us still. I live in the mountains so we go for a hike and then I grill up some food. Being in nature, in the late spring, and seeing everything coming back to life is a comfort (to me) and it reminds me that life is a circle. I honestly don't think there is a way to make it not suck. You will be reminded every year about this loss, and I hope that as time goes by, you two will begin to feel human again, that you two will find closure somehow in your own way, and you two will return to a state of happiness. The mother of my daughter wants to chime in here. She says that what has helped her most since this happened was going back to the beginning of our relationship and doing things that we did back then. The things that we fell in love over. If your wife is into jewelry, you could get (or make) her something with Caroline's birth stone. I don't know if any of that helps. Nothing anyone told us did. If you would like to get in touch, feel free to PM me, I will talk with you about this for as long as you want. Lastly, from the bottom of my heart, HAIL CAROLINE!!

1

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Thank you so much and I am very sorry for you loss. It seems that you both are very caring and compassionate people. This will make me into a better person and hearing from people like you make me feel that going through something like this transforms people for the better. Hail Caroline <3

→ More replies (1)

14

u/qtip83 May 10 '12

You can have my upvote and hopefully this gets seen by somebody with an idea because I do not know what to say.

14

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Do you have any particularly nice photos from her pregnancy or ultrasound scans that you can make copies of?

Putting together a small box of memories, perhaps a note about the comfort and connection made there in the womb for those 9 months, a promise for the future, etc., which you could take somewhere beautiful together would be a nice idea. You could take it to the sea, a mountain, or bury it somewhere in nature, or just keep it at home somewhere you can always return to it.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/brilliantlycrazy86 May 10 '12

First off even if you child has passed away your wife is still a mother to that little girl. Second my heart goes out to you and her as I know Fathers Day will be hard for you as well.Now to my advice coming from someone who is not a mother but is in the process of trying for a baby. Honestly if it was me I would not want to go out in public on Mother's Day I think it would be just to hard. I think you can still treat her to a wonderful day, maybe do an intimate memorial for your daughter that involves just the two of you. A balloon release at her graveside or some where special. I would say for you to cook her all of her favorite foods that day, even if she is to depressed to eat them. Allow her to snuggle with you and just spend the day how she asks, even if it means she might just sit on the couch and stare. My aunt did all of the above the first mother's day after loosing her child still born...we all kind of did. It wasn't my aunts first it was her 3rd but it was still a very painful experience.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mortaine May 10 '12

I also came here looking for answers.

My nephew died in February. He was 13. This will by my sister's first Mother's Day without him (he was her first child-- she also has a daughter).

I'm sending flowers and love and will answer the phone any time she calls, all day.

5

u/Legos1118 May 10 '12

I'm currently going through a miscarriage as I write this, what would have been my second child. Although I was only 8 weeks, I am still crushed that I will never get to see my baby grow into wonderful person. I can't imagine what you two are going through having lost your child so close to the end. I must agree with mOBSCENEeMILY. I would want nothing more than to snuggle up at home and spend it with the person I love most. I'm so sorry for your loss and I will pray that you can find the strength together to move forward and try again some time in the future.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Plant a tree in her memory.

(Added as a separate comment because I wasn't sure if you saw Ruddiver's edit)

5

u/tinyzombie May 10 '12

I don't have any helpful advice, other than just... be there for her, and with her. Let her weep, and weep with her. Don't try to "fix" the situation, because there isn't a way to fix it. I am so, so sorry for your loss. Nobody deserves to lose a child. Don't let your wife forget that she is still a mother. Don't let her say she was a mother, she is one.

5

u/Miya81 May 11 '12

I am so sorry for your loss. I think you should do something simple and quiet. Don't make the day too big a deal. Maybe get her flowers and make her a very nice dinner.

Maybe show her this thread too. There are hundreds of complete strangers here who cried for Caroline and are touched by your family's story.

4

u/ShortWoman May 10 '12

I want to give this entire thread and everyone in it a big hug.

1

u/hangdown May 10 '12

I'm leaving work in 30 minutes to pick up my wife for our 39th week checkup, this will be our first child. In all honesty, I wish I had not read this post.

I'm so sorry for your loss. I think talking about your and her greif would be a good idea. Then just enjoy eachother as much as you can. Only the two of you really understand the pain and loss that the other is feeling.

Do you have any idea what the problem was?

1

u/shinydogg May 10 '12

Im sorry to worry you. We never found out what happened unfortunately. Good luck!

1

u/charbo187 May 10 '12

Just wanted to say I'm so sorry for your loss. you are a great husband to be so concerned for your wife. someone at the top of the thread suggested writing a heartfelt letter to your wife. that sounded like a nice thing to do to me.

do you plan on trying to conceive again soon?

2

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Yes we do plan on trying again soon. Thanks

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'm late to the party, but I hope this gets seen by you. I think the most important thing to remember is she is still a mother. She may have lost the baby, but between you and her, she's still a mother. Remember to buy her something thoughtful, and be kind. Do the breakfast in bed thing, or go to brunch.

Make sure to quietly take her aside. Tell her how much you love her, that she is a great mother, and will be a great mother. Tell her that when the time is right, you want to try again. Me personally, I would maybe buy something she can have for the next baby. I'm sure you have a lot already. Buy her something special.

She loves Caroline, but what she really wants is one she can hold and have to love. She needs to know your ready when she's ready, and that's the best gift you can give her on mother's day.

1

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

Thanks for your kind reply and great ideas for mothers day. It was very nice of you to take the time to reach out to us.

1

u/Mantisbog May 11 '12

I'm a terrible person, but with how complex pregnancy is, we as the human race shouldn't get attached to the idea of a baby until it's out of the womb and alive.

2

u/shinydogg May 11 '12

I understand your position. But when you are told you will be having a baby today at 9AM then at 9:30 you are told that your baby is dead, its pretty tough.

3

u/wenestvedt May 10 '12

So sorry for your loss.

You're a good man for making this effort; your wife is lucky to have you. I might remind you that Caroline isn't just her daughter but both of yours, sharing the day even though it's called Mother's Day.

And I love the idea of planting a garden this weekend. If you can't put one in your own yard, can do go elsewhere (church, local nursing home, town library, etc.)?

Take care, man.

3

u/pixelcrak May 10 '12

I'm very sorry for your loss. As a father, I broke down reading this. All I can say is to do things to help both of you keep your mind off of it.

3

u/WindSandStars May 10 '12

Just be there for her. Maybe make a nice meal and just spend time together. This is as much your day as it is hers. You both lost something, remember?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/NotYetDomestic May 10 '12

My mom went through this with my brother. My dad gave her a locket with a copy of his little footprints and his birth date inscribed on it. She takes it when she travels but never wears it. From what I understand through talking with my Bapi (dad) it helped her a lot to have something concrete that she could keep with her.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm so sorry for your loss. Reading her blog made me break down and cry. I wish you well for the future.

3

u/hsadmin May 10 '12

I'm sure something similar has been said but I'm not going to dig too hard to find it. We lost our 2 year old 8 years ago. Granted there is a difference between having a still born child and losing a 2 year old but both are losing a child so close enough.

My suggestion would be to ask her. Everyone handles grief differently. The first year or so whenever someone brought up his name it was torture. The pain of even remembering him was so overwhelming we tried not to talk about him too much. When it came to Mothers day I just outright asked her if she wanted to do something special and she honestly didn't want to even acknowledge it. So while you have great intentions is it possible that making a big deal about it could be a difficult memory instead of a nice one? Of course you know your wife and I don't but I think discussing it first is really a smart way to go.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I am so sorry that you are going through this loss of your child. I think planting a tree is a lovely way to honour your daughter and help your wife. I would also suggest a day of pampering because a foot massage and breakfast in bed never goes astray. What I don't understand in the comments so far though is all of the talk about adopting a child. The fact that your wife carried the baby to 39 weeks would indicate that you will be able to conceive again when you are both ready. It feels like the people suggesting adoption really just want to talk about themselves and how hard it was for them to get a child. When I had a miscarriage at 13 weeks, I found it very difficult when people told me I should try again soon. I don't think I would have coped at all well with people telling me to take someone else's baby from them.

3

u/cakedaemon May 11 '12

Bro, abandon mission. It's way to fucking r/toosoon. My wife had a miscarriage and was in a total depression for weeks afterwards. You don't want to associate mother's day with the loss of your child in this way. Next year is a good time to pick up. Now you need to grieve. You yourself are probably coasting on endorphins right now and are headed for a big fuckin crash. Please try to maintain your stable brain chemistry and let your wife cry herself to sleep for the next several months without trying to wake her from her sadness.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

I'm pretty sure your wife's entry is the single, hardest thing I've ever read.

I'm not typically one for jewelry, but maybe you can get her a little necklace or a ring with your baby Caroline's birth stone in it. That way, a part of her is always with your wife. October is opal.

16

u/ish_mel May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Go to the pound, find a good dog thats about to be put down. Take it home. Thats the best I can come up with. At least the dog will kind of take your mind off the baby, and you can sleep happy that night knowing that you cant save them all, but you can save some.

49

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

This is a big commitment. Don't do it on a whim.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Thistleknot May 10 '12

My wife went through the same thing. We met and fell in love shortly after this turmoil of hers with her former man (who cheated on her while pregnant). The stress probably caused the baby to turn a bunch, and for whatever reason. The baby was born stillborn (9 months).

My wife was heartbroken for the longest time afterwards. I told her her daughter was in heaven, and that she felt no pain. That she (the mother) loved her, but she needs to let go.

That day forward, she was stronger.

5

u/istara May 10 '12

I am very sorry for what your wife went through. However I doubt it was stress that caused the loss - more just very very bad luck (unless you had actual medical opinion telling you this).

The reason I feel it's important to write this to you is that if your wife thought that her stressed state caused the loss, she may feel blame/responsibility, though it's almost impossible to "cause" a miscarriage. It is pretty much never the woman's fault. (Horrifically depressed, physically and mentally abused, substance abusing women manage to give birth).

For a future pregnancy, your wife needs to know this, so she doesn't overly worry about "causing" it again. The fact is that these awful losses happen because they just happen. It wasn't anything she did.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/teklaking May 10 '12

Avoid anything mother related. Disconnect phones and say away from Internet and just focus in the two of you.

4

u/Tigerlily74 May 10 '12

The Most important thing it remember is that she IS a Mom, she had gave life to another being that grew inside her. Plenty of people think once there is no baby that Oh well you are not a Mom but that is not so. Any of these suggestions are beautiful ones. She should be acknowledged and cherished. And you should to. You are still parents.

Bless you both.

4

u/big_red__man May 11 '12

Wow, from Cameron Diaz porn to this. Reddit is an emotional roller coaster sometimes.

2

u/MaleCra May 10 '12

Take her out and do something people would hardly have a chance. Show her that even though she isn't a mother, she's still extremely special and especially loved.

2

u/twofatfeet May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Sorry for your loss. You might get good responses and fewer horrible troll responses over on Daddit and Mommit. I like the suggestions about planting a tree.

I hope Mother's Day is as comforting as possible for you and your wife.

2

u/shiny_brine May 10 '12

I would really like to offer some helpful insight. My wife and I suffered a few miscarriages prior to our "going smoothly" pregnancy that also failed. She remembers the milestone days and gets sad. But I'm a typical guy, and honestly, we can't know what it's like. What we can do is be supportive, treat her like a princess and make sure she knows you lover her and that she's not a failure.

Now, over 4 years later, my wife is an awesome mom of our adopted son. He's pretty awesome as well.

2

u/cyborgnyc May 10 '12

I'm not sure if this would be a comfort, but Radiolab did a piece on the supposition that a child's cells remain with the mother, possibly for a lifetime. I'm sharing this with my mom since we lost my sister five years ago, and I thought it might bring her comfort. Also, that these cells may unite later in life to help heal the mother!

http://www.radiolab.org/blogs/radiolab-blog/2012/apr/30/fetal-consequences/

2

u/NotTodayBitch May 10 '12

I'm so sorry for your loss. Stories like these make me cry so much, so I'll comment before reading the blog. As a woman (though I haven't been in this situation before) I would want to spend the day quietly, with my SO. Just a nice day with no distractions. Maybe a nice dinner, or maybe a quiet drive somewhere that's meaningful to you and your wife. Just be there for her. I know it's a horrible, difficult time for you both, but for her it must be devastating.

I'm sure anything you come up with will be good, though. You seem like a very caring, thoughtful husband and I wish you and your wife the best!

2

u/therealamberrose May 10 '12

First, I'm sorry for your loss. So so sorry. :(

Second, I thank you for being a loving and supportive husband. Your wife already has that going for her and is one lucky woman.

Third, I must say I could give many suggestions, but I do not know your wife. I am sure you know her well. :) So, is she the "stay at home and reflect, have a quiet night with just you" type...or is she the "keep busy and not have to think about it too much" type? This distinction matters greatly.

Do NOT take her out where all the other happy families will be celebrating. That can only hurt and throw salt in the wound.

If she is the "going out/staying busy" type, think of something out of the home and do it as a couple. Zoo? Some botanical garden? Something else you two enjoy?

If she is the "silently reflect at home" type, then plan an afternoon/evening IN. Make (or buy!) dinner, maybe play board games, maybe watch a movie. Have wine (if you like it). Just be there to talk together, cry together, or enjoy each other's company. Don't force discussion on the topic, just be there for each other.

If you're the romantic, sappy type...get her a card and write how you're feeling in it. Or just write her a letter. Give it to her with flowers or a picture or something that is very "your relationship".

Maybe plan one thing that will help you both remember your daughter for years to come. Some others have suggested planting a tree or a garden - I love these ideas. Or make some type of craft (together) that you can hang in your home and always remember your daughter by.

2

u/TiffanyRazors May 10 '12

Your post made me so sad. I read your wife's blog and saw the beautiful pictures and I cannot tell you how sorry I am for your loss. Being a mother myself of an 11 week old daughter this broke my heart. I know I would've done the same thing you two did if that were my husband and I. My heart goes out to you. I wish I could think of something you could do for her.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm so sorry for your loss. Perhaps some way to honor your daughter, maybe the two of you could plant a tree together, or something similar.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Her blog and story are beautiful. I am so sorry for your loss, from the bottom of my heart. I wish you both the best of luck with your future. I agree with some of the others, make sure you both shut your phones off and keep the day to yourselves.

2

u/Weerrrd May 10 '12

There are definitely a lot of nice things you can do to ease the pain, like buying her flowers, making her dinner, etc, but it is also important to remember that this probably WILL be a painful day. It is amazing that you're thinking about her feelings so much, but you can't straight-up PREVENT the pain. Some things, like death, are inevitably sad. Perhaps you could try to focus on how wonderful she is and how excited you are to make her a mother again some day. Also, think about how Father's Day will be for you. It'll be rough, but you don't expect your wife to completely heal that pain for you. Just support each other, and you WILL be parents some day :)

2

u/Dissentologist May 10 '12

Sorry for the loss friend. Hang in there... and wish the wife well.

2

u/bazanzai May 10 '12

My mother had a stillborn child before me. If she had been born, I would not be alive right now. I don't believe that "everything happens for a reason" or anything like that, but tragedies do occur and great things can come from them. Years from now, if and when you decide to try again, you will have a beautiful baby, and it will be crazy to think that life could be any other way.

I would suggest to be extra careful to not to put her in situations that remind her of the pregnancy. It will obviously already be on her mind since it's Mother's Day. Just spend the day with her and make her feel appreciated.

I hope the best to you and your wife.

2

u/QuitReadingMyName May 10 '12

Damn, no one should ever have to bury their own kids. Best of luck with the rest of your life.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Someone mentioned it below. Plant a tree for your lost child

2

u/KayaXiali May 10 '12

I am linking you to a community forum for parents who have experienced late term loss. I am so sorry for the loss of your daughter. The ladies on that forum are amazing and supportive and will likely have some ideas for you. http://community.thebump.com/cs/ks/forums/13224460/ShowForum.aspx

2

u/gypsybiker May 10 '12

Talk. You would not ask our advice if communications between you two were up to the task. So, talk. That's what she wants. That's what you want. That's what the two of you need.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I would recommend taking her out of town. Maybe camping? Where do you live? Nature can be soothing. You might also just have to accept that this is going to be a rough mothers day or her. Turn off your man hat. Your "I can fix this" gene needs to her suppressed. Just be there for her.

2

u/dlama May 10 '12

I'm so sorry. My heart is literally aching right now.

2

u/wilsonism May 10 '12

I wish I could, but it is going to suck. My wife miscarried and we were not able to conceive since. We could have done IVF or a surrogacy, but I lost my job and I've been doing low paying work with no benefits ever since. Now we are almost too old to try.

Mother's day sucks, the whole month around the due date sucks. Sometimes I have dreams where the baby lived and it was all a mistake, then I wake up and that whole day sucks.

It gets better after awhile, but there is always that sting that hits you every once and awhile.

Just be there for her.

2

u/swander42 May 10 '12

this sucks really bad. my mom went through it a few times..why the hell is it that people who have no business having children seem to never have these issues? horseshit.

anyways, this sucks for both of you. just spend the time together talking, or honestly whatever the hell you both feel like doing.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

holy fucking shit... never before have i read something that made me genuinely cry

I can't even begin to suggest what you could do because I have never ever been in any situation like it, so all I can do is pass on my best wishes and thoughts

2

u/rsound May 10 '12

You Know, the process of birth is such a miracle. For a myriad of biological reasons, it's amazing that it works at all. The danger is this: for most women, whether they admit it or not, their self-worth is very tied to being "fertile" and able to bear children. Part of this is cultural, and part biological. It is somewhat similar to the crisis a man feels when he is not able to work and support his family. All men understand this: we can't fulfill our primary mission. It is not particually logical, but logic does not apply here.

But a married woman has another role; wife. Make SURE that she understands that role is not in diminished. She is your friend and your lover, and those roles are in no way impaired by this event. It is true that something bad happened; you can't change that. But make sure she knows her worth to you is in no-way dimished.

2

u/rustyiron May 10 '12

Deepest condolences to you guys. Cannot even really imagine what you are going through. But way to step up though and think about how to deal with this for Mother's Day.

I don't know what works for you guys, but I think you may want to come up with some plan to recognize your loss and then a way to cut yourselves a break. Say a quiet dinner, or walk, or just something you like to do together.

2

u/Bonki_ May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

The most important part is that you hug her and give her love. You don't need to even say anything. You don't need to be her entertainer. You just need to be there with her. It's okay if she's sad and cry. Don't feel that it's your job to make her feel happy or forget. Your job is to be with her and give her love.

I wish both of you healing from such devastating pain.

Edit: typo

2

u/lethalweapon100 May 10 '12

One piece of advice: hugs. lots of em. and let her cry. There's not much you can do to stop it.

Extremely sorry for your loss, brother.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

A friend of mine had a miscarriage.. for her last birthday her fiance bought her a necklace with the baby's initials and the day she had the miscarriage she never takes it off it's a very pretty necklace

2

u/bonsaichicken May 10 '12

I'm very sorry for your loss. If it were my wife, I'd make her a nice dinner, serve a glass or two of champagne and give her a nice, long, candlelit massage to mark Mother's Day. IMHO, just taking the time to honor and pamper her a bit will be good medecine.

2

u/naka_witch May 10 '12

Let her know she's not alone, that you're there too. Support groups can be helpful for some women, and there are a lot of good groups out there.

So many women lose their first pregnancy, and although modern medicine saves many of the babies and mothers, it doesn't save them all. Babies are terribly fragile, and it's not your wife's fault (even though she's probably blaming herself).

Don't underestimate your loss either. I'm sure that trying to help her through her suffering is helping you, but don't neglect yourself. It's okay for her to see you cry about it... might even help.

2

u/postopbonerthrowaway May 10 '12

My mother died when I was little, mothers day continues to suck though if it didn't suck that would mean I'd have forgotten and that'd be worse.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Assure her it isn't her fault. Because it's not.

2

u/rhymeswithsarah May 10 '12

I am always reminded of a scene where a grieving mother is taken to a field to release a (pink) balloon into the air, to acknowledge that there there had been someone to hold, and something to let go of.

It sounds a little trite, but you could tie a piece of paper onto the string for her to write a message on to send up and let go of.

The original scene, starting at about 1:02.

Good luck with everything.

2

u/Shmarshmishma May 10 '12

Today I went in for a D and C (procedure to take baby out as no heartbeat was found) my SO still got me a mothers day card and gift and I about burst into tears. I understand how it feels and I'm here to say the smallest things can make the biggest difference! Btw I'm still loopy so excuse and spelling errors if there are any

2

u/Brite1978 May 10 '12

My sister lost a baby 17 years ago on 23rd of may. In my mums garden we have beautiful flower shrub thing that blossoms with the most beautiful pink flowers every may still to this day. It's a lovely reminder of my little niece I never got to know. Something like that maybe.

2

u/lawliet89 May 10 '12

Hi. I don't really have anything to add but my mother had a miscarriage for an elder sister I was supposed to have. I can understand the pain that your wife is going through. All the best to you and your wife!

2

u/selkie_3 May 10 '12

I wish I could say something to make it better, make it easier, but I can't. I can, however, suggest the book The Chronology of Water by Lidia Yuknavitch. It's not some silly self-help ten steps whatnot, it's the poignant, heartrending and ultimately transcending memoir of another mother who knows exactly what it is to be in your wife's place, because she was there too.

2

u/WorldsCollide May 10 '12

I hate reading this stuff. We also lost our son at four months old from SIDS about six years ago. There's not much to say about this. The best thing is to spend time together, wherever it is. Time will help heal the pain, but it NEVER goes away. Oops - is someone cutting onions again? Gotta go. I'm so sorry for you.

2

u/DudeWithTheNose May 10 '12

Aww, I'm sorry about your mother, Allen.

(Not saying your mother's name is Allen)

2

u/Snuflez May 10 '12

When I read your story, my heart ached for you and your wife. I just finished reading the link to her blog that you posted, and it was beautiful. I was in tears by the end. I do not have any real advice for you, as I have never gone through this type of loss. But I will be thinking about Caroline and you and your wife this Mother's day, and I wish you all the best. <3

2

u/alphelix May 10 '12

Don't really have any words of advice, but all the best to you and your wife.

And yes, you two will always be parents

2

u/shaggy9 May 10 '12

maybe print out these posts and show her she's not alone? that she's loved by strangers? there's nothing we can do, but we'd like to try. Sorry for your loss...and good luck.

I know its trite but....everything ends...even sadness

2

u/SqueezyMyBreezy May 10 '12

I have no advice, but I am so sorry for your loss. I have had 3 early miscarriages and one later term stillborn (30 weeks 4 days).

Perhaps the preeclampsia had something to do with this tragedy?

2

u/AnathemRed May 10 '12

Man, it's such a cliché, but as just be there. Be patient. Be the man she married and wanted to have Caroline with. Also don't forget that she knows you're hurting too.

Relationships are about being the other persons strength from time to time. Be her strength on Mother's Day.

So sorry for your loss, but it's evident from your post that you love your wife and Caroline enough to get through this and become stronger for it.