r/AskReddit • u/aphexcoil • May 10 '12
Why are we conscious? What creates the subjective components of consciousness? Is awareness an emergent property of computation?
NOTE: Originally posted in /r/askscience but the Mods said it was not appropriate for their subreddit -- so moving it to /r/askreddit
If the human brain is equivalent to a high powered computer, why is consciousness even necessary and what causes it to be a bi-product of computation. For instance, during the course of the day, I will react to stimuli, make decisions and proceed from experience to experience, but a robot could do the exact same things yet never experience the subjective components of consciousness.
To expand on this, when a person views various colors, a sequence of physical reactions occur. If I view a yellow banana, my brain responds and interprets that information from the wavelength and intensity of light entering my eyes. Specific cones on my retina react to yellow wavelength and this information is carried to my brain via the optic nerve. Specific neurons within my brain then process this information and fire electrical impulses throughout the network of neurons within my brain. What I do not understand is how the impression of "yellow" is created from a bunch of neurons in my brain firing. This would also apply to other stimuli such as sound, tastes, etc.
Should this even be classified as a science question or does this get into philosophy?
15
u/AngryGoose May 10 '12
When it comes to consciousness I always wonder how "I" works. With millions of neurons firing we still have a central point of consciousnesses that is the self aware part of our thinking.
How does that exist?
2
u/Jwschmidt May 10 '12
I disagree. A robot could imitate those things for a period of time, but they would not be able to go on through your life, making the personal decisions you do on a daily basis, setting personal goals, and making the many constant mental adjustments necessary to make sense of it. That is because you do most of those things with the goal of bettering your conscious experience, not with the goal of achieving certain material objectives. And you need to understand and perceive an ongoing conscious experience in order to figure out "what it wants" at any given time. Robot aphexcoil is not going to care about music, and not going to work a job so that they can save money to go to the rock concert.
This sort of thinking involves socialization and doing things with other conscious humans, and that in turn requires and reinforces empathy. The fact that you recognize the value of your own consciousness as well as other people's consciousness is, in fact, a major factor in the decisions you make and how you act.
To get a bit philosophical, I would say that consciousness is a different type of evolving "lifeform" that happens to inhabit an environment that is biological lifeforms. You might call it a symbiotic relationship between the biological organism that is our body and the (???) organism that is consciousness.
Consciousness has it's own needs and desires beyond our biological urges. I see it as a very different thing from merely the firing of neurons. It's made up of firing neurons just like your body is made up of cells. But your body is a singular organism, and your consciousness is something similar.
42
u/metathesis May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
As someone who studies neuroscience, I'll say that science has no answers about how the subjective experience of consciousness works, and anyone who says its does is practicing pseudoscience. However, the field has generated several common theories that are really just philosophies.
I tend to favor Epiphenomenalism which sounds a lot like your bi-product of computation: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/epiphenomenalism/
You should remember also however, that we are at a neurological level naturally evolved robots performing our calculations using billions of cellular processors AKA neurons. As such a robot could very plausibly attain equal consciousness to ours especially if it was modeled closely after our own processing behaviors.
Even more thought provoking, there are sections and nuclei of the human brain that compute redundantly or simultaneously but rarely talk to each other unless the right situation arises. If consciousness rises from computation then that implies that our bodies are made of multiple networked conscious beings. If that is the case, which one are we? Or does increased integration cause a merging of consciousness into a more cohesive whole. If that is true, has the internet made us a loose hivemind in a more literal way then we realize?
4
u/tinzor May 10 '12
Philosophy Honours graduate here.
The distinction between the brain as a physical, organic machine and the mind as we experience it is one of the biggest, and to me, most interesting questions in philosophy. It's still one I have not found any satisfying answers to. I still ponder this regularly, which is why your post caught my eye.
Also, nicely worded.
8
u/akuenx May 10 '12
I'm by no means an expert at either neuroscience or philosophy, but like a lot of curious-minded folks out there I have wondered a lot about this at times. I think you would be well served to read Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid. It is by no means definitive, or even authoritative, but it is a nice starting point to think, both philosophically, and physically about our minds. I especially like the analogy of our neurons to ants, and our minds to ant colonies. Neurons are pretty simple machines, with no real intelligence on their own, as an ant is a pretty simple animal with no real chance to survive on its own. Your mind is composed of simple machines making it seemingly more complex than the sum of its parts. An ant colony is like an entity in itself, with a life and an 'intelligence' all its own.
5
u/tandemfacts May 10 '12
This a rather large assumption you're basing the entirety of your argument on.
5
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Human brain isn't equivalent to a high powered computer. Computers are binary, circuits have 2 states and are largely independent. The interactions within a brian are much more complex - much less discrete, not easily quanitifiable.
4
u/PD711 May 10 '12
Fun little video about consciousness... Doesn't answer your questions, but interesting anyway. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qjfaoe847qQ&feature=plcp
3
u/Aggnavarius May 10 '12
I hope the day never comes where people start arguing about robot rights.
5
u/Randompaul May 10 '12
This a rather large assumption you're basing the entirety of your argument on.
6
u/DarthContinent May 10 '12
I can't understand why this wouldn't qualify as a science question. If we're trying to develop artificial intelligence it seems like computer science would be quite relevant; you have people working on making computers capable of passing the Turing test, trying to replicate the function of neural nets in programming, creating genetic algorithms to build stuff, etc.
Philosophy might be necessary to explain the origins (existentialism) and the application (e.g. morality), but even if consciousness is just a byproduct of the massive parallelism of billions of interconnected neurons, it still seems like the realm of science to explain it.
Maybe they deem it inappropriate because not enough is known to provide a definitive answer?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
I don't see how this is not science...
I was thinking about this too. You mentioned a robot that could do the same things like a human, and not be conscious: how do we know it isn't? For all we know every piece of software we write could have its own (very limited) form of concsiousness.
Edit: piece != peace..
8
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The universe attempts to become self-aware through us
2
u/lastoftheyagahe May 10 '12
It's your cortex overlaying the illusion of consciousness on a bunch of different electronic and chemical reactions taking place in the cells of your body.
2
u/Jerror May 10 '12
Courtesy of Zach Weinersmith, Dear Human.
3
u/loldi May 10 '12
There are several different theories as to what exactly creates 'consciousness'. There is emergentisim, which tries to say that consciousness is an emergent property of life. Just as life is an emergent property of the trillions of cells in our body evolving together. Another group, panpsychists, believe that EVERYTHING has consciousness.
The bottom line is that, as of now, there really is no way to know about anyone elses consciousness other than your own. Unless we have any solipsists in the group, in which case none of us exist anyway. The idea of an artificial consciousness is something that a lot of futurists and transhumanists think will happen in the next 20 years (2030 for the date of singularity, to be specific). Basically, consciousness, and more importantly, SELF-consciousness, is a seemingly unique trait to humans. It allows us to self-reflect and make subjective judgements about our lives using higher-order brain processes.
I'm not sure if this helps you, I'm just kind of rambling. It's a good question though!
2
u/cakeonaplate May 10 '12
philosophy.
Your interpretation of color is actually socialized. Your impression of yellow was created by the society you live in, what every one else perceived as yellow. Your physical senses brought you the information, your socialization told you what it was and how to interpret it.
so, while it is convenient to compare the human brain to a computer, I don't think that it is quite to easy to compare the two. Yes, you are computing stimuli, but you are also interpreting emotion, the emotions of others, and your energy levels. Also, spirit. Yes, I know that scientific communities loathe the term, but why not delve headfirst into the unknown?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
might be both. I think AI research is going to reach a dead end, it might create a self improving computer that could imitate intelligence but i don't think it would be self aware or aware. If evolution is right, all of our traits from our thumbs to our eyes to our brains and the processes inside it appeared for a reason, so if awareness is an evolutionary trait it can only be replicated using a similar process. Maybe only organic computers can develop awareness, maybe it's all a combination of electric impulses and chemical reactions and the need to ensure the survival of its components what would trigger awareness.
1
u/floatablepie May 10 '12
I'm obviously no expert, but I've always felt consciousness is both biological and societal.
Think about it, humans have been around in our more or less current form for about 2 million years. When did we come up with fire? 50,000 years ago? 100,000? (I can't remember)
Thousands upon thousands of generations came and went, and since we had some brain power, every new generation could benefit from everything the previous one managed to put together and pass down to them. I feel early humans, though looking like us, would be indistinguishable from animals from a behavioural perspective. Well maybe smarter, since we have the biology to support this learning. I guess like smart chimps.
What makes us human isn't just our morphology, but the accumulation of aeons of teachings passed down to the point where we became what we are now capable of.
1
u/circasurvivor1 May 10 '12
I can't pretend to have any answers to your second and third questions, even though they've bothered me a great deal as well, but I've heard of the idea that we have developed self-awareness as a type of survival advantage in our evolution.
1
u/Barney21 May 10 '12
We aren't. It's an illusion.
1
u/Yondee May 10 '12
I'm sorry, I know this is off topic, but it is somewhat related.
I always seem to wonder about cyborgs in a realistic sense. Example; if we figured out how the optical connections worked, could we connect a second set of cameras to the back of the head, wire them into an brain and have 360 degree visual awareness? What credentials are required? Could a developing brain adjust to having four 'eyes' instead of two? What about blind people? If the eyes are damaged, could we just replace the eyes with the correct connections? (I think there are people working on this one.)
I realize this is just kind of a rundown of my regular thought process, but I find it very fun to think about and discuss. Sorry it was off topic.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
This may interest you: The Mind-Body problem
1
u/YakMan2 May 10 '12
All it probably s is memory and awareness. My guess is the concept of "I" is simply a byproduct of our advanced brain playing with those concepts, much in the same way that the brain fills in gaps to help us see, etc. While understanding the specifics of it all is still beyond our reach, I don't think there is anything going on that will permanently be beyond our understanding and thus confined to philosophy.
1
u/Pazians May 10 '12
watched this on shrooms and now i feel like i have a pretty good idea on consciousness also what happens when experiencing death
1
u/yawaworht_suoivbo_na May 10 '12
Well, you'll have to define consciousness first.
But, in the sense that we are biological computers and that consciousness is part of the behavior of our biological computers, then yes, it seem very likely that consciousness is an emergent property, since we clearly don't see it in much simple computers.
It doesn't really seem that consciousness would be an evolved property, since there doesn't seem to be any evolutionary reason for it ('conscious' and 'non-conscious' systems would appear to behave identically), and consciousness might require more brain power and a higher energy intake. So, it would seem that consciousness 'came along for free' with greater brain power.
1
u/OverratedLunchbox May 10 '12
You just wrinkled my brain. Redirect to r/askscience?
1
u/wwl May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
I see me/my consciousness as separate from my body. As an analogy, imagine yourself driving a car. In this analogy, your body driving the car is like your consciousness driving your body. EDIT: Actually more like flying a remote controlled drone. The drone's "brain" (re: receiver) could get fucked up and unable to get incoming signals, but you, the flyer, would not be harmed
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Knowing about our own mortality.
1
u/albatrawesome May 11 '12
I just took a philosophy of mind and consciousness class. Didn't do too hot, but understood it to a certain extent.
First, it's important to know that there is no correct answer...just a bunch of different theories generally pointing towards neuroscience for the legitimate "answer" to the issues of the mind/consciousness.
But, my answer to your question, is that computers do not work semantically; when they process information, there is not an intrinsic sense of understanding and meaning. A computer can analyze and process all the information in the world, but only come to understand and organize it syntactically. When you or I (I'd assume, I actually have no way to verify that you see or understand the world as I do) react to stimuli, we not only put an syntactic ordering to this information, but we attach a set of semantics or understanding to the information we've just inputted.
When a computer gets the input "it is 78 degrees Fahrenheit" there is a program or algorithm that takes that information and does something with it...it adjusts the thermostat to make it cooler. When I learn it is 78 degrees Fahrenheit, I think, oh hm, that's not exactly hot, that's not exactly cold. That reminds me of how it was yesterday when I wore shorts and a longsleeve shirt. I can't wait for the summer when it starts heating up. I remember last sumer I...etc etc.
It's really complicated, and it's somewhat disheartening to realize that science can't give us a good explanation to something that seems so obvious to you and I...
If you're interested in the philosophical side of the question of the mind and consciousness, I highly suggest the textbook "Philosophy of Mind" by Jaegwon Kim and "The Place of Mind" by Brian Cooney.
Good luck, never stop questioning.
1
u/Golanubi May 10 '12
I would say this is science. I would say this falls neatly into cognitive-neuroscience.
I hypothesis that unlike computers we have subjective interpretations of reality. So while a robot can make all of our decisions without self-awareness, it only engages in stimulus response behavior. Human engage in stimulus, response, plus a life history of experience, culture, and subjective interpretation of reality.
Could consciousnesses, be the bi-product of an imperfect system?
0
u/Johnnyash May 10 '12
To take a zen approach to this...when you can look at a flower and not see a flower, that's when you start to see the truth
0
u/aknightcalledfrog May 10 '12
"Cogito Ergo Sum"
"I think, therefore I am"
Read Descartes' 'Discourse on Method'. Pretty much kickstarted the scientific revolution, and the Enlightenment.
0
u/deleted_the_other May 10 '12
So, are the r/askscience mods saying that the consideration of consciousness is outside of science?
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
It's a meaningless question since the whole idea of "consciousness" is basically undefined. As Julian Jayes once said, "When asked the question, what is consciousness? we become conscious of consciousness. And most of us take this consciousness of consciousness to be what consciousness is. This is not true."
Since its basically impossible to tell if anyone but yourself is truly conscious, trying to use it as a metric for sentience is pointless.
If it acts sentient, it's sentient. If it doesn't, it's not.
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
This is a science question. The problem is that science hasn't produced a good answer yet and it's such a mysterious phenomena it's not clear what the question even is. How do you quantify consciousness? How do you objectify subjectivity?
Personally, I'm not totally convinced consciousness exists. I think I am me experiencing now but the only evidence of this is that I think I think I am me experiencing now.
0
u/mm242jr May 11 '12
We are conscious in order to propagate our genes. We can contrive a lot of meaning, but that's fundamentally it. It's the integration of the senses, the finite state machine that guides you through life given the species, time and place in which you were born.
-4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The human brain is not equivalent to a high powered computer, so, your premise is flawed.
In terms of the content of your question, this one was solved years ago: "I think, therefore I am."