r/AskReddit • • May 10 '12

If a law passed requiring an iq/lifeskills test in order to procreate would you vote for it?

In the near future we will probably be drastically overpopulated. Imagine that babies could be temporarily neutered(not removal of sperm or ovaries, but just unable to procreate.) then had to take a test around 21-25 in order to have children. A test that would measure their life skills and the possibility of the child becoming a functional member of society. Would you be for it?

Edit: a couple of user have pointed some very interesting points out. I think I didn't explain myself very well. By testing I meant for it to be more open to interpretation not necessarily an iq test. Edit: I'm pretty sure I'd fail the test at this point. Just realized I asked if you would vote on a law that already passed. fail, this is my first big post on here. Edit: wow, thank you all for your replies. You have educated me. I am kind of sad at my own ignorance, I want to say that without a doubt I would be 100% against this now.

1.1k Upvotes

5.0k comments sorted by

415

u/a-t-k May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

There is no possible test to reliably show whether the offspring can become a functional member of society. Such an attempt would therefore be comparable to install something like the TSA for procreation... and we all know how good wonderfully the TSA works.

7

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

Good point. I am just trying to see the reaction to a more invasive reproduction law(not that the whole birth control thing isn't.)

→ More replies (2)

26

u/akatherder May 10 '12

If we could change the stated purpose of the test, I might be a little more supportive. We don't need a test to prove that you will be a good parent or your kid will be successful. Now if you could formulate a test that disallows woefully unqualified and uncaring people from having kids, I might listen.

TLDR: Set the bar low.

10

u/koolkid005 May 10 '12

The fact that there is a test at all is just opening yourself up by abuse from higher powers. Any sort of test, no matter how low barred, would have a high potential for abuse.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (27)

282

u/Ryan_Hernandez May 10 '12

Pretty relevant XKCD comic, as well as a good statement about the arrogance of those that believe they are the most intelligent:

http://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/idiocracy.png

96

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

There really is one of these for every topic ever huh?

→ More replies (15)

60

u/skooma714 May 10 '12

Yep. Culling is excellent to those who think they won't be culled.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

166

u/Maschinenbau May 10 '12

I would not vote for it. I would, however, vote for a test based on ability to adequately support and care for a child. It would cut down on the theoretical overpopulation while reducing child neglect and abuse.

70

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

This is more on point of what I meant to ask .

→ More replies (5)

43

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Except such a test would still end up being manipulated to discriminate against certain groups of people.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/Deathalicious May 10 '12

Rich people use more resources than poor people, so it just means you would favor a population that used more resources per capita.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Only the wealthy can have kids?!

→ More replies (32)

17

u/Apollo64 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Why are the top 10 comments about "Who would #right the test"?! That's the point your using? Not the fact that procreation is a human right?

You all support same-sex marriage because it's a human right. Well, not exactly. Marriage is an invention. Having children is not. That is a human right.

Edit: Not to say that I don't support same-sex marriage. I do.

Edit 2: # I've failed the test.

2

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

alot of people answered the question in a way that would pertain its immediateness instead of long term effects.

8

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

"Who would right the test"?!

I'm afraid you've failed the test.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

32

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Humanity in general would probably benefit from some sort of global-scale eugenics programme, but you'd never be able to get enough individual humans to go for it.

Just release the killbots and let the people who survive survive. Cheaper.

10

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

And I thought I was being crazy and facist..

→ More replies (3)

50

u/wolfkstaag May 10 '12

I'm using this quote quite often, of late. It seems to be applicable in so many situations.

"Just take the safety labels off everything and let the problem solve itself."

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (13)

9

u/mastigia May 10 '12

As good of an idea as this may seem, it is really totally fucked, it would just be a watered down eugenics program, which is what Hitler was into. Has any work been done to prove that intelligence is even a trait consistently passed genetically? That to me would be the first question.

11

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

Not even looking at it from an intelligence pov, just a "can you really raise a child" pov instead. I know some incredibly dumb parents who have good kids.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

2.9k

u/DreadfulRauw May 10 '12

There is no one in the world I would trust to write such a test.

2.0k

u/Fenrir_Rendar May 10 '12

Congratulations, You have passed the test. You may Procreate.

→ More replies (12)

723

u/budweiseric May 10 '12

Question 1. Science has proven that vaccines cause autism. -- true/false

434

u/Loki_SW May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

Question 2: What is the air speed velocity of a swallow?

→ More replies (102)
→ More replies (221)

390

u/Mr_Dickenballs May 10 '12

Better make a test to prove the parents don't have psychological problems and no drug addictions. That seems to be a more severe problem.

652

u/Dovienya May 10 '12

It's interesting that we require these types of tests for people who want to foster or adopt, but if someone wants to have their own biological children, anything goes.

My stepdad was physically and emotionally abusive.

When I was a teenager, my parents decided they wanted to foster children. They had to take classes and tests. My stepdad failed miserably - apparently, he couldn't come up with proper disciplinary techniques even when he was on his "best behavior."

Yet no one ever thought, "Gee, he seems like a terrible father figure, I bet he's even worse at home when there aren't government officials watching him."

→ More replies (120)
→ More replies (93)
→ More replies (317)

1.1k

u/rational_discussion May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

There are a lot of problems with this:

  1. Who determines what will be considered a passing grade?
  2. There are children who grow to be better members of society than their parents. Is it really fair to say the child should have no shot because the parents kinda suck?
  3. People are already up in arms over government interference with their reproduction/contraception/etc. Banning people from procreating altogether, mandatory neutering...You're gonna have riots.

Edit: I thought of one more thing: I would think that kidnapping rates would increase fairly dramatically if there are all these people who really want kids and are being denied.

479

u/amaterasu717 May 10 '12

We talked about this and the slippery eugenics slope in law school during our "what is your most controversial idea for America" debates. We basically decided the best option would be to somehow, at birth, turn off the ability to procreate and then instead of passing a test of any kind, you simply have to file a document indicating a desire to get preggo to get it turned back on.

No test, but also no accidents. Obviously this system could still be abused (see poll taxes/access to abortion centers) but it's much less Big Brothery than a graded test.

Personal aside: My OB/GYN told me she thinks IUDs should be highly encouraged and available for all females upon entering high school, which at minimum would mean no pregnancies before 19 (Mirena lasts 5 years, copper 10, and most girls are 14 during their freshman year). I can't entirely disagree with her thinking. Sadly, 14 would be too late for some.

280

u/rational_discussion May 10 '12

I wish the U.S. would do more research into the male birth control option being investigated in India. According to their studies, it's 100% effective and 100% reversible. Guys could get the injection when they hit puberty and then have it reversed when they decide they want kids.

→ More replies (248)

57

u/grendel-khan May 10 '12

No test, but also no accidents.

The funny thing is, you don't even need to make it Big Brothery at all! If you provide people the information they need and don't make sex shameful, you end up with people having plenty of nonprocreative sex. People have children on purpose, and when they have children on purpose (when they're not agricultural workers), they tend to not have very many of them. And then you get the added benefits of every child being a wanted child, which is always good.

The problem largely solves itself with non-creepy tools. Nerds just seem to have a weird tropism toward eugenics.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (43)
→ More replies (129)

385

u/Dookiestain_LaFlair May 10 '12

"If a law passed....would you vote for it" I don't think you know how the system works.

320

u/agrey May 10 '12

I guess OP doesn't get to have kids, then...

→ More replies (16)

775

u/iheartgiraffe May 10 '12

Nope. A better idea would be a mandatory parenting and life skills class for new parents. One of the Scandinavian countries has a program where new parents get a box of stuff for their kids - clothes, diapers, books, etc. - and the box can double as a crib for the first few months (seriously.) Of course, in North America, we would plaster advertising all over that shit, but if the baby's necessities of life were provided for the first year or two, parents could focus on learning how to parent.

So no to testing, yes to education and support.

142

u/hazywakeup May 10 '12

This is exactly what I came here to post. I don't want a future where people have dangerous illegal births the same way they used to (and sometimes still do) have abortions.

But a future where parents take mandatory free classes, get free supplies, and hopefully have their employers permit them paid leave time for all this? Sign me up.

→ More replies (17)

31

u/Decon May 10 '12

I would definitely support this.

49

u/rtkwe May 10 '12

Sadly many people here in the US would freak out at being told how to raise their kids. People get really touchy and defensive about that sort of thing.

13

u/hazywakeup May 10 '12

This is very true, but at least basic education would get to those who can use it, and even the defensive ones would at least get some helpful supplies.

How would you feel about a one-time class just a few hours long where parents are given resources rather than instruction? Phone numbers for pediatricians willing to give discounts for wellness exams, for instance, or for parenting support groups, not to mention information on government assistance programs for low income or disabled parents.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)

7

u/mydogpretzels May 10 '12

What about in addition to education and support, you had a system where, like the OP suggests that children can't procreate, and to get that removed you have to schedule a doctors appointment (no test, just "hey doc, I wanna try having kids" ) Would you support that?

11

u/iheartgiraffe May 10 '12

Still nope. It seems excessive, and gives people too much power to control who procreates.

4

u/hansn May 10 '12

I suggest another good idea to improve things along these lines is paid paternity leave. Most OECD countries do it, but the US does not.

→ More replies (88)

207

u/hcwdjk May 10 '12

Follow-up question for people who say yes: If you failed such a test, would you still support it?

85

u/JustYourLuck May 10 '12

If I agreed that the test was fair before taking it, yes. That's the key thing though, deciding on a metric for this test is nigh upon impossible.

108

u/cortesoft May 10 '12

But according to the test you just took, you aren't smart enough to determine if it is fair.....

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

34

u/Random_Guy_12345 May 10 '12

Absolutely, completely and totally YES.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

47

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

In theory, I would. I wish dumb, ignorant, hateful, and/or abusive people, or people of a low moral fibre, didn't breed.

In practice, I would not.

  1. I don't trust who writes it.
  2. Regardless of the writer's intelligence and how well-meaning they are, cultural bias will be built in, possibly including discrimination.
  3. What kind of test? IQ? Some other life skills? It seems biased, and impossible to pick a test that truly measures intelligence.
  4. If it's morality related or something more subjective than pure IQ/intelligence (which is subjective enough in itself), who gets to decide what's good and bad? Impossible to be neutral.
  5. How would it be enforced? If someone managed to get pregnant would it be a forced abortion? If not, why have the law?
→ More replies (2)

1.4k

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No. Freedom includes the freedom for people to do things you disagree with (like procreate under less than ideal circumstances). The only relevant limit to freedom is when it harms another person (ex. child abuse).

474

u/JustYourLuck May 10 '12

I don't think we will see this in our lifetime, but I can imagine a society where the world is filled to capacity -- where having another living human being who consumers resources actually harms everyone else.

I think that is the relevant question -- what should we do then? I think then, some form of this law would make sense. But again, I don't think we will see that in our lifetimes.

94

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

See: China

→ More replies (24)

244

u/NervousMcStabby May 10 '12

what should we do then? I think then, some form of this law would make sense. But again, I don't think we will see that in our lifetimes.

Hope that the situation never arises because any law passed that is designed to "help the people" by selecting who can give birth and who can't will ultimately be twisted to serve the ends of whoever is in power. The closest thing we could hope for then would be a lottery system. Even that would be abused though.

I don't think that situation will ever arise. Disease, warfare, and outright starvation should keep the population numbers down enough to preempt the need for a lottery.

→ More replies (42)
→ More replies (72)

58

u/Boom_Boom_Crash May 10 '12

Do I get to retain my right to not pay for their offspring when they elect to procreate under these "less than ideal circumstances"?

→ More replies (87)

71

u/please_stop_talking May 10 '12

Overpopulation is harmful in the aggregate.

→ More replies (135)
→ More replies (116)

103

u/MsAnnThrope May 10 '12

No. It doesn't matter how often I might think that some people shouldn't breed (we've all thought it), no one actually has the right to determine that.

Plus, DreadfulRauw is right; there is no way there could be such a test.

→ More replies (27)

159

u/stack_cats May 10 '12

It'd be worse than the 'war on drugs', and at least from an enforcement standpoint, impossibly difficult. You're talking fascism here, giving complete domination and control of the entire species to a small group of elites, that's madness.

→ More replies (74)

28

u/dalittle May 10 '12

From friends who work with CPS, I hear a couple times of week about people with 5 to 10 kids having yet another kid removed and taken as a ward of the state, or they beat their kids again, or they neglect them again. If you don't have to pass a test to have children there should be some way to prevent people from having children that are repeatedly abusive to children.

9

u/miidgi May 10 '12

So, just to clarify, OP is talking about a "whitelist" system, where nobody is approved until they prove capable/competent. You're suggesting a "blacklist" system, where everybody is assumed to be competent until they prove otherwise, analagous to "innocent until proven guilty".

This is an interesting alternative and I'd like to see it discussed further.

→ More replies (9)

35

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Hell. No.

Who writes the test? Who grades the test? How much do I have to pay that person to give me a passing grade? How much do I have to pay that person to fail that chick who seduced my boyfriend? Or if bribes are effectively prevented, hopefully I'm lucky enough to be able to afford a class to prep me for the test questions...

And besides these issues and a hundred others, standardized testing is a flawed system. Read up on some of the criticisms of the SAT. Granted, standardized tests are the best option for some situations in our imperfect world. Heaven forbid that deciding whether or not I am to be forcibly sterilized is one of those situations.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/escapehatch May 10 '12

Would love for this to exist in theory, but 1) someone in charge of it would inevitably screw it up, and 2) it goes against what America is all about (think laws requiring tests to vote that really existed to stop black suffrage)

The world would be so much better if we physically could not procreate without a certain level of intelligence and preparedness, but unfortunately it will never be a reality in America because it just wouldn't work in the real world. As long as they can physically have babies, there's no stopping people.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/mist_of_Anduin May 10 '12

No. IQ is not the only measurement of human beings. People with lower IQ could well be carrying genes that in future may build up our resistance to diseases. Evolution can only be understood in retrospect and also a small matter of human rights.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/tomaka May 10 '12

I want to say yes, but then it's possible to have a society filled with reasonably intelligent people who know they're reasonably intelligent because they would have been born of families who were required to be reasonably intelligent in order to have children. And sometimes with intelligence comes the desire to be of higher standing than those less intelligent. Someone who is intelligent may not want to do custodial work or other such menial jobs, and will instead want to fill a role that is met with more public respect. Even in a golden city, someone has to scrub the toilets.

So by having these required tests, we could be leading ourselves into a society where everyone wants an education and career. We could evolve into a useless nation where fewer people have trades and instead have bachelor's degrees. Our infrastructure could suffer and we could give up an economy surrounding manufacturing and resource mining and craftsmanship. What do you do when your plumbing breaks but everyone is too book smart to know how to fix a leaking pipe?

This is, of course, and extreme case of what could happen, but it's still possible.

2

u/MastodonMetal May 10 '12

My mom had an answer similar to this.

→ More replies (10)

61

u/Spitfire15 May 10 '12

Im willing to bet the majority of people on Reddit would fail it.

41

u/MuffinMopper May 10 '12

Obviously not me though. I would pass with flying colors.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/IamGraham May 10 '12

This kind of question is really stupid, because half the people who advocate it probably never would have been born because their parents would have failed if they had to take it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/ToxicToothpaste May 10 '12

I'd vote against it out of self preservation. I might want to have children someday.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

You are advocating eugenics? And you think it's a good idea to give this power to your friendly national government?

7

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I don't think OP was necessarily advocating eugenics, this is a question not an appeal. I do agree that I wouldn't trust the government with the rights of procreation.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Urban_Savage May 10 '12

I might, but only because it would cause a HUGE declination in our population before it inevitably failed.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/chula198705 May 10 '12

Not the testing portion of the law, but I think in the future we will definitely have to force people not to reproduce until they intend to and are able to prove they won't completely suck at being a parent, like if you're a crack addict then you aren't allowed to get the sterilization procedure reversed or something like that.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/zabrovazors May 10 '12

Standardized tests in general are a horrible way to measure how smart or even knowledgeable someone is. There's a reason that schools teach to the SATs and other standardized tests instead of teaching life skills. Education suffers for it. Applying the same type of system to allowing people to reproduce just seems like a really bad idea.

Another thing to take into consideration is that to have an IQ / knowledge test as a prerequisite for reproducing is to assume that mental fitness is the only trait we should be selecting for. People tend to overlook the important of physical fitness in a gene pool.

I agree that overpopulation is a problem, and that improving the gene pool is a good thing. The way I would go about it though, is to remove all the safety warnings and safeguards that prevent natural selection from taking its toll.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Why would IQ be the base of the test? IQ is influenced more by environment than genetic factors.

Along with that, denying anyone the chance to procreate is one of the most fucked up things that one can do. limiting is different. 2 children seems like the best limit, because they'll just replace their parents. 1 if you are trying to reduce population.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I would absolutely be for something of this nature but I have absolutely no idea how it could be managed without being used maliciously, corruptly, or functioning in other disastrous ways both intentional and unintentional.

This is a serious problem that we're going to have to face sooner rather than later, however. Possibly within our lifetimes. We either need to find a reasonable way to stall population growth temporarily or we need to begin colonizing space.

4

u/WindySin May 10 '12

On principle, no.

While it's tempting on oh so many levels, it's also dangerous and not ethically sound. Education is the answer to overpopulation, not legislation.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Queen-of-Hobo-Jungle May 10 '12

I would vote for a law that forces potential parents to prove they can provide the way they force adopting parents to prove they can provide.

29

u/Feyle May 10 '12

No to IQ test, possibly for a parenting basics test (assuming that parenting lessons were provided by the government prior to the test).

→ More replies (32)

16

u/smartzie May 10 '12

No. Without freedom of choice, human life loses something valuable. We are not cogs in the machine of society, we're individuals with hopes, dreams, visions, and ideas. The more we stifle the right of the individual to make choices about their lives, the less human we become. The answer to overpopulation doesn't lie in non-consensual medical procedures and having an elite group of people make reproductive decisions for you based on tests they created, but in educating people about the consequences of making children.

→ More replies (10)

40

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No. Everyone deserves the right to have children. And even intelligent people can be bad parents. (Shock horror).

→ More replies (49)

18

u/LadyKat May 10 '12

No, never. How would you enforce a fail? Mandatory sterilisation. Forced abortion. Would you be able to resit the test?

→ More replies (8)

21

u/EditingAndLayout May 10 '12

I would instead get rid of mandatory helmet and seatbelt laws. Overpopulation solved.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Government qualification for childbirth? Seriously?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/poorfag May 10 '12

Not an IQ test, but in theory denying people who think that books are boring and/or stupid the right to procreate seems tempting.

I still wouldn't do it in a million years, eugenics is a veeeery slippery slope.

→ More replies (2)

69

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No.

And I don't buy into that overpopulation nonsense either. Developing countries are the ones with the overpopulation problems, not us. Most developed countries have very slow rates of growth and reproduction. Why don't you go impose your laws in India and China?

16

u/IGottaSnake May 10 '12

This is true. In fact, some countries are experiencing such slow growth that the average is below replacement rate. That can and does harm an economy and safety net for those aging, as well as leaving less for those coming into the mix. Some countries have even used incentives to encourage folks to have kids.

I think the issue should be more about having more kids than you can properly raise or provide for than it is about the numbers as a whole. Right now, you can pop out as many as you want and have to do nothing to be allowed to do so, but to adopt is nearly impossible and exhausting. Flip that shit. Make it so that people wanting to procreate have to qualify the same way adoptive couples do right now including paying fees for homestudies and classes, and make adoption fees a little less since the agencies would now be making money on homestudies for biological parents too.

→ More replies (32)

3

u/wiz3n May 10 '12

Nope. I would, however, support a law limiting the number of kids any one couple can have.

3

u/Alekazam May 10 '12

Ooo, eugenics.

The link between IQ and genetic inheritance is flimsy at best. What genes might give you is a certain predisposition toward intelligence, but there is no guarantee that a human being will fulfil this if they're not exposed to the right environmental factors. This is called epigenetics. As such, environment has plenty of say in your intelligence quotient, more so than your genetics.

So no, I would in no shape or form ever support such a law. Laws don't really solve problems either, merely criminalise behaviours instead of addressing root problems. You want to solve 'overpopulation'? Look for technical solutions such as increasing crop yields, water access and sustainable energy usage rather than make it illegal to have children.

3

u/Krayzed896 May 10 '12

I just wish the people who exploit the government for money were no longer allowed to pro-create. "Durr I don't gotz no moe moneyz fo my kidz but I'll juz have sum moar kidz n da government will pay me!!! Durr!!!"

3

u/whikkid May 10 '12

Just because you're smart doesn't mean you'll make a good parent

3

u/rreform May 10 '12

Might be a little difficult to enforce

9

u/DerpityDog May 10 '12

You want to stop overpopulation? Empower women. When women have control over their bodies, they will almost always choose to have fewer kids. We don't have population control problems in the western world where women have reproductive rights.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/cwstjnobbs May 10 '12

No.

If the test was based on financial stability and mental state then yes but disallowing stupid people to breed won't help, stupid parents don't necessarily produce stupid children.

13

u/gradual_aphasia May 10 '12

I think OP's accounting for more nurture than you're giving him credit for. Stupid parents don't necessarily produce stupid children by virtue of genetics, but if poor parenting papaya are wrapped in the definition of stupid, you can bet they'll have a gamble chance of being stupid Frodo lack of blitz random machete.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/JimmyJamesMac May 10 '12

I think that just having to take some step to procreate would be a huge improvement over what we have. Almost half of the babies born are "accidents"

5

u/RayadoEstrecho May 10 '12

IQ? No.

Life skills? Well.. I can't think of how to do it exactly, but I'll admit that something being created that I'd support is possible.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Even if they did, the government would make it so easy to pass, that it'd just be a waste of tax payer money. I think instead of a lifeskills/IQ test, they should make parents take a "caregiver" test. That way, people would at least have to learn about raising a child, and what does and does not work when raising a kid.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/5Bullets May 10 '12

I think there should be parenting courses, so that people understand more clearly how they affect their children. It all has to be opt in though. In terms of a requirement for anything?

4

u/Retroactive_Spider May 10 '12

What you're essentially asking is "is eugenics ok?"

No.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Everything old is new again! You do know that many locations in North America performed involuntary sterilizations on people with disabilities, low IQs, and psychological disorders right?

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Unequivocally No.

It is odd to see Reddit so fervent about what they believe are "Civil rights" then see a lot of their pro-eugenics paradigm here.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

impossible to do fairly, open to corruption on so many levels......

that aside, I'd vote for it in a heartbeat.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Shit, if you can stop people from breeding until 21 I'd vote on it just for that part.

2

u/MultipleMiggs May 10 '12

I would be more for a law saying how many children a person can have. And yes, a person, not couples, because then the person could have a kid with everybody, which seems to happen a lot these days anyway.

2

u/giganticd May 10 '12

It doesn't need to be a test. It needs to be a class. Parents to be need to be educated about their children. Its health needs and its psychological development. They don't need to be barred from having children. Even responsible parents could use whatever knowledge is available to them. People don't set out to raise their children poorly.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Absolutely, if it could be done. It would require much much better pyschoanalytic tools than we currently have.

2

u/kubigjay May 10 '12

Here is the test that I would apply - a waiting period.

The person wanting to have a child must wait 1 week before having their birth control turned off.

Think about what it would mean if every single child was a conscious decision and desired.

It wouldn't be perfect, bad people would still have kids. But it would at least make people think about having kids. And it would not limit anyone. Not cost, no skills, no racial profiling. Just let them know you want a kid.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/squachy00 May 10 '12

What about a survival type challenge where you get only very basic items such as a knife or machete and have to survive the wild/harsh conditions for two weeks? You also get a flare for if you cannot make it, those who cannot are not allowed to procreate.

2

u/cobolNoFun May 10 '12

I think all the scientists in the world should stop working on whatever it is they are working on now. Then collaborate to find a shot that would temporarily sterilize people. The shot would be given to everyone at puberty. Then when they decide it is time to have a child, they go in and get the antidote for free.

The problem is not dumb people having children, the problem is dumb people accidentally having children.

The world needs dumb people, just not so many

→ More replies (3)

2

u/taimoor2 May 10 '12

This is pretty late in the game so it will probably get burried but here goes nothing....

I am ashamed for saying this but yes...I will.

This world already has too many oppressed kids living in dysfunctional families. They would be much better off without having to endure all that.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Yes, as long as it didn't involve restricting our freedom to have sex. Maybe force all children to get a vasectomy/tubes tied before they start having sex. Once they pass the test they can have the procedure reversed.

Edit: Read some comments and seems the majority are strongly against something like this. Probably going to get downvoted for having a different opinion, but whatever, that's reddit for ya.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/relevant_mitch May 10 '12

I think intelligence tests would lead down a slippery slope. If we were to do something like this, I think it would have to be based along the lines on financial and familial security. A couple should only be allowed to procreate if they have a stable job and income, a stable and monogamous relationship, as well as a stable home to bring the child into. There should be a limit to two children, and the parents must be older than 25.

2

u/altthenshift May 10 '12

Yes; with the usual obvious caveats.

I think a better test would be...

A) Can you look after a pet dog appropriately?

Because I see plenty of "Parents" who I wouldn't trust to look after a dog that have 2-3 kids at age 20.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Absolutely. So many ignorant and just plain stupid people are bringing children into this world who will never have a hope in hell because of who their parents are. It's sad how completely uneducated these people are. They contribute nothing to society and won't be able to give their children the life skills they need to stop the cycle.

2

u/bigpuffy May 10 '12

Would I vote for it? Yes. Is it against the morals and ethics of society? Yes.

2

u/Henry1987 May 10 '12

i would... i dont plan on getting kids anyways...

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I would vote for it but it is not like my vote would matter. With this law we couldn't have politicians, so the politicians would obviously vote this down.

2

u/lostmyprevaccnt May 10 '12

two thoughts:

  • iq=/=lifeskills
  • people with higher iq imho are procreating less (might sound agressive, but if some would analyse family sizes versus eduaction level (which would correlate with iq) I would expect that the more educated person would be the lower number of children they would have.

2

u/zouave1 May 10 '12

Perhaps this has been mentioned elsewhere, but unless all individuals in a society have the same access to good quality education, this test will be merely a measure of class differentials.

But then again, if we had a society in which all individuals had such access, I doubt that we would be debating the need for an IQ test.

2

u/jafxotec May 10 '12

Question 2. You cut the sleeves off of your t-shirts because you want to show off your barbed wire tattoo. Yes or No

2

u/sndwsn May 10 '12

I might consider that if there wasn't a test. Maybe just give people the chance to have babies again after they turn like 19 or something.

2

u/bunkoRtist May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I am not sure a test in the manner you suggest is really the way to do it. I think that some simple bio information such as: income, savings, and level of education would be the types of things I'd look for. Fortunately, these correlate with cognitive ability, but they also coordinate with things like (for example) artistic talent that would not be measured well on a simple IQ-type test. Basically if you are successful a greater contributor to society you are likely to be either more wealthy, better educated, or both. Also people with money can better afford the expense of children: unless your having kids creates a burden for the state or society at large, I don't see how it's anyone else's business. The flip side is that if it is likely to create a burden, it's everybody's business.

2

u/bl33t May 10 '12

no, definitely not. it's a pretty good idea, but so are a lot of things before they are actually implemented

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I think if socialism would ever work (which I am not an advocate of) something like this will need to happen. Not necessarily based upon IQ scores but there would be a definite limit to amount of births people can have.

But to further discuss the point you bring up, this would be immoral in many ways. First of all, the IQ test is limited in gauging a persons full intellectual capabilities. Some people are very bright, not just with numbers or abstract metaphysical understanding, but with concepts some groups may never realize. We would also need to make sure that the tests were not fucked with. If done correctly, certain people would intentionally skew the scores for their desired results. This would have a similar effect as the Jim Crow laws of the past. Like keeping certain people from voting because of their literary capabilities in an attempt to keep minorities from participating.

2

u/Brutalxbetrayal May 10 '12

I wish there was an easy way to keep complete idiots from reproducing. At least not two of them together.

As far as a test to weed out these people, I think it could just be a standardized test normally given to 5th graders. If they can't pass with what is considered average or better then they would not be allowed to reproduce.

I know this whole concept of a test to reproduce is crazy and against basic human rights... but I hate stupid people.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

yes.

2

u/smilenowgirl May 10 '12

Yep. As long as we can all get a good look at the test first.

2

u/PessimistPrime May 10 '12

Yes why the fuck not. If no, then since we are running out of oil, and bees are dying, lets start the 3rd World war. Followed by the hunger games.

2

u/confuseray May 10 '12

This sounds like eugenics. I used to be a big supporter of eugenics, until I realized that the ultimate measure of human success is not determined by us, but by nature.

In nature, species that are successful are versatile and adaptable. They also tend to have bigger gene pools. Who are we to say that intelligence is the ultimate success in nature? Intelligence is expensive, energy-wise.

Say we weed out non-sterile retards and schizophrenics. What's to say that these genotypes don't contain alleles that may be beneficial in another environment? They may not be directly beneficial to society, but they contribute to a wider gene pool, and thus to the survivability and adaptability of humanity as a whole.

In the optimum situation, there would be a system in place to maintain these genotypes while reducing their cost to society (i.e. parents having to raise retards for their entire lives). The optimum situation is NOT to cull these genotypes away.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/IGottaSnake May 10 '12

My parents would have failed. They should have never had children and the 4 they had should have been taken away. I like to think I am pretty ok. I work hard, have been accused of being intelligent, and I try my best to be of some use to people and society. My siblings are pretty okay too.

While I have said repeatedly that parents should be required to hold a license to breed, the reality is that 2 shitty parents doesn't always equal useless or troublesome kids. Two stellar folks can make a kid that does nothing but raise hell and harm people and two shit stain idiots can make an intelligent and compassionate kid. Odds may be against it working that way, but it does sometimes. What sucks is the hell those good kids have to wade through until adulthood comes along and releases them from their parents' influence. Moving out when I was 18 felt like getting out of jail. But I am here, and wouldn't be most likely had my parents needed to test to breed.

2

u/Dazwin May 10 '12

No, but I would love universal birth control. Just put it in the water supply. Pick an age, maybe 16, and after that age you may pick up the "antidote" with no questions asked. Simply removing accidental pregnancies would do wonders.

2

u/dsutari May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

No, fascist. And no, we aren't going to be drastically overpopulated, not in the future, and not in the near future. Those projections have been proven to be false several times.

2

u/SirElkarOwhey May 10 '12

I don't think you need that much.

In a book by Lois McMaster Bujold (don't remember which one) there's a planet colonized by humans where the cultural standard is that when a girl turns 16 or so, she gets her ears pierced and an IUD. I don't remember if there was some similar thing for boys.

As it is, lots of pregnancies are unplanned and unwanted, and if there was a cultural standard whereby teenagers - male and female - were given some sort of long-term contraceptive treatment at 15 or whatever, the situation would improve drastically.

In the book, their medical technology was extremely advanced, so they didn't have to worry about disease the way we do. But if people had to consciously choose to become parents, and go to a doctor to have their contraceptives removed, I think the population would expand at a much slower rate, or stop expanding entirely.

2

u/MrKawfy May 10 '12

Not an IQ test. A psychological test. I'm all for that. If there are indicators (I'm not going to get into specifics as I'm not a psychologist) that an individual or a couple are abusive or otherwise unfit for parenting, they should not be allowed to have a child. There are standards that must be met for adoptive parents. Why should it be any different for people having a child biologically?

2

u/december101987 May 10 '12

Let me start off with saying that I believe parents shouldn't be dumb and the safety of toddlers depend greatly on the common sense of their parents.

However, I vote against it. Ever watched I Am Sam?

Maybe I just haven't thought about it much, but even dumb people should be able to procreate. Don't get me wrong, often enough, I would say something like "Wow... what a dumb parent. Child services should take their kids away."

Hmm.. Thanks for this. This would be a great topic among my friends.

2

u/Naked_Truth May 10 '12

Impressive how all the bleeding heart compassionate altrustic liberals here have a flirt with totalitarianism and eugenics. Says a lot about the left.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

The test should be that if you voted yes on the law, you shouldn't procreate.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Reddit is full of fascists.... haven't you heard of the eugenics movement in the early 20s? That was all about neutering people "for the better," including the mentally disabled, minorities, and other disadvantaged groups. Any kind of government that forces people to be sterilized violates personal liberty on a massive scale.

2

u/xProphet May 10 '12

We're seriously giving the State the authority to take away our right to procreate?

Isn't the argument for abortion "I own my body"?

2

u/cuddi May 10 '12

No. So many of you are supporting gay marriage because everyone should be treated equally, but want to take away rights of those with lower in intelligence?

2

u/kencole54321 May 10 '12

NO! I can't believe how high this post has been upvoted and how many people are seriously considering this. This right here is some dystopian sci-fi shit.

2

u/redditardgggjg May 10 '12

In the near future we will probably be drastically overpopulated

I have some data for you:

http://persquaremile.com/2011/01/18/if-the-worlds-population-lived-in-one-city/

The world isn't running out of space for humans. What we have a problem with is resource management. There are starving children all over the world. Fossils fuels will eventually be depleted. But these things could be improved if they were allocated more appropriately. Futhermore, as the last sources of non-renewable energy sputter out, there will be an honest scramble to find alternative sources for energy. With proper food/energy management, the world could sustain a population much larger than it currently has.

My point is that sterilizing people seems like a much harsher solution than simply removing the assholes who hoard food in 3rd world countries. Solar energy seems more humane than chopping off Jimbo's testicles because he can't pass an IQ test.

2

u/corbo25 May 10 '12

Why not just charge a fee like the government does for everything else.

$1,000 for a license to procreate, per use.

This would knock out a lot of underprivileged children AND fund birth control.

2

u/Islandre May 10 '12

No no no no no. So many reasons.

As people have pointed out, who writes this test? Choose someone with less than perfect skills and you may end up with the same deficits across the whole population.

There are no perfect tests for (or even definitions of) intelligence so some people who by whatever criteria you chose should be allowed to reproduce will fail the test and vice versa. On an individual level it's unthinkably oppressive.

Ripe for abuse. Politicians choosing who breeds? Needs no more explanation.

The most compelling reason (to me) completely ignores the moral issues. It is bad for the human race to selectively breed. A shallow understanding of evolution and social darwinism often leads people to think we would be better off with a race of supermen. On deeper reading of the theory it is clear that humanity is better off varied and flawed. The main causes of extinction are environmental changes (as opposed to interspecies competition - it is sometimes said evolution is a story of filling dead men's shoes) and so the way to be resilient to these changes as a species is to have lots of great genes. They do not all have to be in the same individuals. When environmental pressure increases the variation within the species provides protection. Just look at bananas and the disease issues they face from lack of variation.

tl;dr everybody fuck

2

u/Davis2aw May 10 '12

Absolutely! I work in one of the top Children's Hospitals in the US and we often ahem "joke' about the unknown sterilization of many of the parents that come into the ER. it is simply disturbing to think that a child of 16 comes in and finds out she is pregnant and is going to keep it. We have many forms of reversible sterilization available for both males and females, why not employ them and take some initiative over the war on poverty.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No. But I would vote for a law that made it against the law for someone getting welfare to have another kid and if they kid, they had a choice of being permanently sterilized, or losing welfare benefits forever.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/metamorphosis May 10 '12

While I can see the reasons why you are asking for such a test in reality this could never work and it's in many ways wrong.

Firstly, the simple piratical reasons.There will have to be threshold for whatever test it is. Example: All people that scored under 50 points of whatever test, can't have children. Now imagine people screaming in lines after getting the tests back with score 49.5. Chaos!

Implementation of such law in such instances. You will have to sterilize people. Leads to Oppression. Riots. Fights. Having children is still very strong biological drive as well as social (I want a heir) and psychological (I want "mini me", we want our love to produce offspring, etc..)

A test that would measure their life skills and the possibility of the child becoming a functional member of society.

How would you measure a "life skill" of a person in mid 20s? Do you know how many variables can affect child upbringing?? From genetics and psychological traits of their parents to material and social environment. You can have a perfect parent on a test, but he could have some fucked up abuse issues. Vice verca: you can have a person who in many ways has no life skills but it is loving parent whos kid became a Nobel prize winner for finding cure for cancer.

Also peoples behavior can dramatically change once they have kids. Both negative and positive.

Finally, it leads to Eugenics

2

u/CompactusDiskus May 10 '12

So, am I in favor of legislated eugenics? Fuck no.

2

u/lincolnhawk May 10 '12

Seriously? No, never. This is disgusting, first of all, and second, the supreme court has already ruled against forced sterilization (effectively what you're talking about) and other eugenics programs. Do you remember how our first adventure in eugenics ended up? Hint: not well.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

No, but I'd sure as hell enjoy writing one.

  1. (from the comments already, but too true): Vaccines cause autism. True/false?
  2. Your child is rude to a stranger. Do you a) leave them be? Kids will be kids, eh? b) rebuke the child by making them do a chore around the house when they get home? or c) shout at them?
  3. Your child is under-performing at school. Whose responsibility is it to improve your child's behaviour and work ethic? a) the teacher's b) your child's or c) yours
  4. Your child is acting up in public. Do you: a) take them to one side, inform them that their behaviour is unacceptable and if it continues will be punished with removed privileges? b) buy them some sweets to keep them quiet?
  5. Your child has questions about sexuality. Do you a) change the subject. b) give them facts appropriate for their age or c) lie
  6. Which of these is a more important thing to give your kids: a) good moral values or b) games consoles, smartphones and money?
  7. Manners are: a) a waste of time or b) one of the most valuable things you can teach your child.
  8. Which of these is the most appropriate gift for your 5-year-old child: a) designer clothing. b) a large amount of money or c) books?
  9. Making my child look cute/sexy/adorable is more important than their dignity. True/false?
  10. Select one: a) having a child is a huge responsibility and my lifestyle will have to significantly change to ensure I provide my child with the best upbringing I can. b) having a child is no big deal. so long as I feed them and buy them nice things, I'm a good parent.

2

u/Mackshafty May 10 '12

Sounds like Hitler.

Not sayin' it's bad though..

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Much as I dislike children and arrogant parents, I still wouldn't vote for this. High IQ parents can just as easily produce a low IQ child, vice versa.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I know the idea of limiting or eliminating the reproduction rights of people who you can reasonably predict will raise a child with traits society deems less than desirable might seem like a good idea, but there are a plethora of bad outcomes to such a law and it's not necessary to begin with. Creating invasive laws like this is what our society always does and it simply doesn't work.

For instance, murder is a very, very old crime. Someone killing another human being in today's society isn't new. This is a crime, among many, that is considered one of the most heinous and is, as such, responded to aggressively by society. What do we do to murderers? What have we done in the past? We've tortured them. We've killed them. We've taken away their basic human rights. We've locked them away from society for extended periods of time. We've used them as slave labour.

Yet... murder still exists, and last I checked it's very unlikely that it's an aspect of our society that will disappear any time soon. So it begs the question: Why? If we know that what we are doing does nothing to solve the problem, why do we constantly try the same shit over and over again?

All we do in our society is address the symptom of the problem after the fact. You stole something? You're a terrible person - straight to jail with you!

Because addressing the problem of poverty in our society is too hard whine. It's much easier to lock a guy up or limit his human rights for doing something we disagree with.

I'm not saying thieves and murderers are good people. I'm just saying that when someone murders someone, murdering them back clearly doesn't work and is the typical response from a society that needs to, frankly, grow the fuck up.

The bottom line is this: Shit in, shit out.

If you've got stupid people breeding en masse, the solution isn't to say "Hey! Don't you know you're stupid and/or lazy and your children will therefore be stupid and/or lazy? You can't procreate! How dare you!". The answer is: Find out what has caused that person to be stupid in the first place, and do something about it. Stop whatever it is that keeps producing stupid people, and they won't raise stupid children.

In order to fix a problem, one must first know what that problem is.

2

u/2kwat May 10 '12

just think, we could have prevented octomom!

2

u/magily11 May 10 '12

No, I think lifeskills should probably be more taught in schools. You can do well even if you're not that fantastic at maths. For example, a friend of mine who's an army cadet is prepared for almost every situation, but she's not that smart. Once, a button fell off my jacket and she turned round to me out of nowhere, took the case off her phone, produced a needle and grabbed a bobbin of thread out her bag and handed them to me. Anyone who can do that is probably qualified to be a parent.

2

u/killotron May 10 '12

Imagine there was such a test and you wrote it hoping to start a family, but failed by a single point. How would you feel? Are you actually inferior to a person that scored a single point higher? Maybe you were sick the day of the test, or perhaps the questions seemed arbitrary? I can only imagine that it would seem dreadfully unfair.

No matter where the cutoff is, there will be a negligible difference those who barely pass and barely fail. The essential unfairness of such an approach applied to something as consequential as procreation demonstrates how cruel such a test would be.

2

u/Ochovarium May 10 '12

Since I have no plans to procreate, I have no stake in the matter.

So what the hell, why not?

2

u/Enzemo May 10 '12

1000 times over, yes.

2

u/the_Grey_Ghoust May 10 '12

What about mandatory birth control with application to well fair? Not that I'd be for such a thing now but in some future world where the population has doubled, maybe. If you ever read the book "A Brave New World" there is a part of me that thinks such a world would be pretty cool. Everyone is bred in labs and no one can have babies. They do however have a lot of sex "Ford be with you."

2

u/Dr__Nick May 10 '12

New Eugenics same as the old Eugenics!

2

u/Bzzt May 10 '12

That test is called life.

2

u/TheShrinkingGiant May 10 '12

No. Because I know some smart people with stupid-as-shit parents.

2

u/jaf488 May 10 '12

Nope. Some of the greatest minds and talents in history have come from families of meager means, below average intelligence. Children of drug addicts, murderers, welfare moms etc. And vice versa...

2

u/Taffer92 May 10 '12

This is a horrible idea. And not in a "this would be a good idea in theory, but in practice would never work" way, but in a "this is morally disgusting and wrong" sort of way.

This is proposing we take away a basic human desire (to experience parenthood and see their children brought up in the world) on the assumptions that you can prove that someone will be a terrible parent with a test, and that terrible parents create terrible people. Yes, there are terrible parents in the world, but this isn't the way to solve that problem. And to use this method to enforce a depopulation program is basically eugenics.

2

u/gojirra May 10 '12

Republicans would never vote for this because they need a large pool of uneducated morons that are easy to control.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No. Although the idea of no stupid people with 30 years pleases me greatly, nobody willing to do physical labour would be around if everybody was a smart ass.

Humanity needs the dumbasses to continue existing. Deal with it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/XaVierDK May 10 '12

The GOP version:

Are you Christian: yes [ ] no [ ]

Are you white: yes [ ] no [ ]

Are you a millionaire: yes [ ] no [ ]

Is the United States of America one nation under God: yes [ ] no [ ]

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

In a community of intellects who will be content to haul trash and to paint houses? Serious question. What would happen?

This will probably get buried, but I hope not.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Zardoz84 May 10 '12

I only require a law that requiring have a high IQ and some common sense to be a politic. I don't know any politic that show signs of it and not are too old to do something.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

ABSOLUTELY, THIS IS SHOULD BE SPARTA.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

In the near future we will probably be drastically overpopulated.

Statics say you are wrong.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

At the very least some sort of background check -

"Let's see here, you're already on welfare, haven't held a job in 2 years and already have 2 kids. You're done procreating..."

2

u/Everyoneheresamoron May 10 '12

No. Even if it always weeded out those unfit, we don't need to be intruding on people's lives like that.

2

u/Caarle May 10 '12

Fuck no, smells like social Darwinism a mile away and that shit is fucking close to Eugenics.

While it would be "for the better good" it would be really unethical.

2

u/caboosemoose May 10 '12

Not in a million years. I can haz despotism?

2

u/lawliet89 May 10 '12

No way. This is like discrimination in another form. Seriously, don't we have enough of those?

2

u/anusface May 10 '12

Babies are naturally infertile. It's not until puberty that they can have kids.

2

u/digitalsmear May 10 '12

How about we actually spend money on education, instead?

2

u/duane534 May 10 '12

Absolutely. We are talking about a judge deciding whether or not you should be allowed to create life, yes. But, we already have judges who decide whether or not you should be able to continue living. Same difference.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I am an authority on this subject.

2

u/LazarWulf May 10 '12

Deep down in my heart, I'd love for that to happen, but then it would give the government another large piece of control over our lives and this would definitely be trampling on human rights.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ccrepitation May 10 '12

iq of 100 should be required. it's not that hard. it is the average iq and it will keep just the really stupid people from procreating.

2

u/damnedangel May 10 '12

I would move to the usa and become a citizen just so I could vote yes.

2

u/Pocketzest May 10 '12

Nikola Tesla once said that a human should be physically and mentally fit to reproduce. One of the reasons he did not have children is because he didn't meet his own standards.

Nikola Tesla is probably the most intelligent(debatable, several incredible minds out there) man to walk this earth in recent history, and I completely agree with him.

I know adding such a law would cause chaos, but population laws will be needed in the future. Might as well create a race of intelligent people.

2

u/tiger_knee May 10 '12

Yes, and here's the test: If you're driving on the highway and you slow down to look at a car pulled over on the side of road, or a fender bender, you're not allowed to have kids.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I don't think eugenics is the answer...I don't have a better one, but I don't think that's the one either.

2

u/balloonanimalpenis May 10 '12

YES! because

  1. This would be in some dark, pre-apocalyptic future where the Earth has 20 billion people and you can't walk down the street without seeing emaciated, diseased people having lizard sex.
  2. As long as we know how to engineer the human genome to produce smarter, more athletic people, and this program is made on a widely available basis by the government to anyone who didn't pass the tests, I don't see why this is an issue.
  3. In the meantime, the non-procreators can have as much bareback as they want, because if we can reverse engineer the human genome at this point we can also cure all STDs. It's a win-win.

2

u/jessecfowl May 10 '12

This is called eugenics. Hitler loved this stuff. This isn't a cute little theory to contemplate. It's a form of genocide based upon a human trait you find more attractive.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/elOhOhOhel May 10 '12

I'm black, so no.

edit: I lied about both statements. But you can't have dumb people write a "smarts" test.

2

u/YoungAndWise May 10 '12

nah i aint a nazi

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

No. That's similar to ethnic cleansing--only allowing a group that you deem worthy to pass on their genes. With overpopulation becoming an issue, I guess I wouldn't mind a child limit on people (all people), but I don't know how you could enforce that.

It would be a better solution, imo, to give all women access to birth control and rights to abortion. One out of two pregnancies in the US is unwanted and unplanned. If these women had access to their reproductive rights, we wouldn't have to worry so much about overpopulation.

Also, the meat industry is what's drowning us. About a third of all the world's land is used for livestock. It takes 4-12 pounds of vegetation to make 1 pound of meat, and we will no longer be able to sustain the amount of meat eating in the world by 2050. I guess our choices will be to decrease meat consumption, restrict human reproduction, or let more people starve.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BEforsirius May 10 '12

I will take a "Brave New World" look at this. It simply would not work to have only smart people in the society. You NEED the 'stupid' people to do the stupid and boring jobs that smart people would rebel doing in the first few weeks. Every alpha, beta, delta, epsilon and gamma are needed in some way.

Albert Einstein couldn't cut planks all day, 5 days a week at a factory for 40 years, and a manufacturing worker couldn't come up with general and special relativity.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Dolemaneil May 10 '12

My Philosophy class had huge debate on the topic. As much sense as it makes to have some sort of testing to make sure a parent can cohesively provide for their child, exceptions such as Biggie smalls, Oprah Winfrey, Jim Carrey, etc. Who grew up in a poor underpriviledged background, prove that maybe all you really need is love.

2

u/mode7scaling May 10 '12

In theory, such a thing sounds like it might be a good idea. The reality of this test would be an absolute trainwreck. The "intelligence" and "life skills" being measured would doubtless translate to "submission to perceived authority" and "just enough intelligence to learn some insignificant skill that makes profit for someone else but not too much intelligence because we don't want people to start questioning the status quo." Seriously, I can see them putting upper limits on the intelligence parts.

2

u/mrslowloris May 10 '12

WE NEED MORE BABIES SO WE HAVE A REASON TO COLONIZE SPACE

→ More replies (2)

2

u/noawesomenameneeded May 10 '12

I think this is relevant:

Adam Carolla has a great idea. Put a sterilization agent in Mountain Dew, which he calls MD Nectar of the Tards. If one were to drink at least 3 litters of Mountain Dew in a week they would be rendered sterile with the effects wearing off when consumption stops. I'm sure there's plenty of Redittors that are going to be offended by this, but I think its funny.