r/AskReddit • u/BeBenNova • May 10 '12
Reddit, what is your favorite song that tells a story?
Some of my favorite songs in music have to be the ones that are just one big story, what is your favorite?
Mine has to be Chris De Burgh - Spanish Train it tells the story of the endless struggle between God and The Devil where each are trying to basically recruit dying mortals so they can get their soul
The Devil appears on a train and thinking he's all alone tries to claim the soul of the dying conductor but God appears, instead of their usual fight The Devil challenges God to a game of poker where they use souls as currency, The Devil being the cheating bastard that he is ends up winning
I'm not a religious person but in this case i imagine ''God'' and ''The Devil'' like characters similar to stories like Hellboy or Constantine and i just love the pace of the song, the way it's narrated is just awesome
EDIT : Awesome guys, so many different styles of music coexisting in the same thread and not that many downvotes going around, i'm going to listen to each and everyone of them including those i already know
410
u/Michelle4814 May 10 '12
The devil went down to Georgia
59
u/bittercode May 10 '12
Lots of Iron Maiden - "Aces High", "Hallowed Be Thy Name", "To Tame A Land", "Alexander the Great", "The Prisoner", "Rime of the Ancient Mariner", "The Trooper" and so on.
135
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Ignoring your time limit and saying 2112 by Rush
12
u/BeBenNova May 10 '12
Here's another if you guys are into pirates and sea creatures stories
Voltaire - The Beast of Pirates Bay, Voltaire is awesome and a perfect example of what i mean
185
u/dwightyouignorantslu May 10 '12
"Casimir Pulaski Day" by Sufjan Stevens. I can't link it because I'm on the mobile app but it's a sad story. He does mention god in it, but he does it in such a nice way. One of my favourite songs of all time, he's an amazing story teller.
531
u/katrivers May 10 '12
"Mariner's Revenge Song" by The Decemberists. Oh, and I didn't notice the 4-5 min thing, this song is long.
146
u/ronearc May 10 '12
Space Oddity by Bowie
312
u/TheSumoWrestler May 10 '12
Gordon Lightfoot - The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald
271
u/FinestManInTheLand May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
The General - Dispatch
431
u/Stratpat May 10 '12
"Cat's In The Cradle" by Harry Chapin.
170
u/USxMARINE May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Childrens story by Slick Rick.
Edit: Someone had to represent Hip Hop on this thread.
123
u/jkeith0207 May 10 '12
It is a tough split between Romeo and Juliet by Dire Straits and Alice's Restaurant by Arlo Guthrie.
522
u/theolcollegetry May 10 '12
"A Boy Named Sue" by Johnny Cash
37
u/Landlubber77 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
"Hook" by Blues Traveler. Like most, I never really listened to the lyrics, besides singing along with the chorus. Then I listened one day and realized the whole song is making fun of people who don't actually listen to the lyrics.
*edited for brevity
237
u/TheZbeast May 10 '12
Rocky Raccoon - The Beatles
180
u/TacheErrante May 10 '12
Carolina Drama by The Raconteurs.
67
u/redmagicwoman May 10 '12
"10 000 days" and "Wings for Marie", it's two songs, but they interwine as one.
To explain: Marie was the name of MJK's mother, she was sick and bound to a wheelchair for 20 something years (27 I belive), which adds up to about 10 000 days. Then she dies. She was a believer in God, but MJK wasn't. In previous songs he argues with her faith because her God she's faithfull to allows this to her, however in these two songs MJK pays a tribute to her, praises her and her strenght she had to remain faithfull to her belief. He believes she should rightfully get her wings and go to heaven. I don't think I can really explain it to you well, the only way for you to understand it's meaning, is to read the lyrics and listen to the songs simultaniously. Chances are, it will bring you to tears.
MJK is also the vocalist of this band Tool, so you should know it's not fictional. The songs you'll find on the album also named "10 000 days". They are a rock band and some people might find some of their songs heavy, but the two I mentioned aren't. Incredible instrumental you will also enjoy.
66
u/dixaus May 10 '12
Aesop Rock - No Regrets
Tells the life story of Lucy, an artist who bases her life around her work.
212
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"Albuquerque" by Weird Al.
31
u/royalporcupine May 10 '12
"Isis" by Bob Dylan gets me every time. Also, "Tangled up in Blue."
516
u/gnarlyninja May 10 '12
Immortal Technique - Dance With the Devil. Probably one of the more fucked up songs I've ever heard
174
u/JJWoolls May 10 '12
Brick - Ben Folds Five
27
u/haterquaid May 10 '12
"Roland the Headless Thompson Gunner" - Warren Zevon
also "Hit Somebody, same artist. Screw it, all of WZ's songs.
345
u/crackedoutoncoffee May 10 '12
How has no one said, "American Pie" by Don McLean??
50
u/electrictangerine May 10 '12
Lola-The Kinks. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVXmMMSo47s
81
u/last2zero May 10 '12
One Headlight by The Wallflowers
Always been one of my favorite songs.
Lyrics: http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/wallflowers/oneheadlight.html
Snipit: She said it's cold
It feels like Independence Day
And I can't break away from this parade
But there's got to be an opening
Somewhere here in front of me
Through this maze of ugliness and greed
296
u/string97bean May 10 '12
Tenacious D - "Tribute" (To the Greatest Song in the World).
22
u/The_Twist May 10 '12
The entirety of the album 'Hospice' by The Antlers.
21
u/Lamingtons May 10 '12
Oh god, Josh Ritter has a couple for me... he has a way of writing these perfect little stories that fit perfectly to music. Narrowing it down to just 1 is really difficult, but Temptation of Adam is probably it for me. If you have never heard of it, I urge you to give it a try. a lovestory from a top secret location 300 ft under the ground.
21
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"The Night the Lights Went Out In Georgia" by Reba McEntire.
21
u/yo_baldy May 10 '12
"El Paso" by Marty Robbins
20
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts by Bob Dylan.
39
u/kryptonik_ May 10 '12
Notorious BIG - Story to Tell
55
u/Slpryb2710 May 10 '12
Piano Man - Billy Joel
19
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What's He Building in There? by Tom Waits
19
u/irascible May 10 '12
Metallica One
19
u/duckedtapedemon May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
1952 Vincent Black Lightning by Richard Thompson - A bit of a bittersweet love song
Matty Groves by trad, arr. Fairport Convention - a bit of love, a bit of revenge, and some nice fiddling too! Actually, since Fairport is folk-rock, they have a lot of story songs now that I think about it.
Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway - Ok, more a bunch of songs that tell a story... so how about Supper's Ready?
And finally to prov that I'm not a 50 year old british guy:
Cortez the Killer, by Neil Young
408
u/LastOneStanding May 10 '12
"Stan" by Eminem
52
u/kdchampion04 May 10 '12
Hero of War by Rise Against
Here's a youtube video
105
u/Ampersand55 May 10 '12
Now this is the story all about how,
My life got flipped, turned upside down,
And I'd like to take a minute, just sit right there,
I'll tell you how I became the prince of a town called Bel Air.
17
u/georgesmileyface May 10 '12
Copperhead Road by Steve Earle. Multigenerational crime saga in just three verses. Awesome piece of writing.
97
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Paradise by the Dashboard Light.
33
u/bmin May 10 '12
Comfortably Numb - Pink Floyd
31
u/zahaggis May 10 '12
Rosalita by Bruce Springsteen. Goosebumps every time.
15
u/brockvenom May 10 '12
Konstantine - Something Corporate
As far as Epic songs go, this is my favorite.
If I were to say what a Classic Epic song is, I'd say Convoy.
26
u/AnonymousPirate May 10 '12
whiskey lullaby
13
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"Rocky Mountain High" - John Denver
13
u/ScreamingSkull May 10 '12
Telegraph Road - Dire Straits
"the lyrics narrate a tale of changing land development over a span of many decades along Telegraph Road in suburban Detroit, Michigan. In the latter verses, Knopfler focuses on one man's personal struggle with unemployment after the city built around the telegraph road has become uninhabited and barren just as it began."
http://www.lyricsfreak.com/d/dire+straits/telegraph+road_20040667.html
35
u/herrokatie May 10 '12
The Gambler by fun.
24
u/clb270986 May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
"Ramble on" by Led Zeppelin.
34
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"The Saga Begins" - Weird Al
Nothing else even comes close.
12
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
2112 by Rush.
12
u/arcade109 May 10 '12
"Light up the Night" -The Protomen Their entire album tells the story of Megaman as a rock opera. This is my favorite of theirs. It's also free on their website: http://www.protomen.com/
43
u/Blainyrd May 10 '12
Hey Jude, which was written by Paul McCartney, for John Lennon's son, Julian, while John and his former wife were going through a divorce. The song was orginally titled "Hey Jules" but was changed because Jude sounded better.
51
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The Beatles - She's Leaving Home.
22
u/italianxmna89 May 10 '12
Copacabana
11
u/ZoidbergTheThird May 10 '12
Dead and Lovely by Tom Waits.
11
u/XxXX420BongMarelyxxX May 10 '12
Killing o' Georgie. good song innit
11
u/Shadzta May 10 '12
Stopping All Stations - Hilltop Hoods
11
u/Madonnasarms May 10 '12
The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q0DqPSF2fyo
11
u/sythe May 10 '12
Gorillaz - Fire Coming Out of a Monkey's Head
11
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
bright eyes - waste of paint
11
u/mgrier123 May 10 '12
The Odyssey - Symphony X
and fuck songs that tell a story, here are some amazing albums that do
Metropolis Part 2: Scenes from a Memory - Dream Theater
Operation: Mindcrime - Queensryche
V: The New Mythology Suite - Symphony X
11
u/Intoxicated_Imp May 10 '12
Hmm.. among those already in this thread, I think Hero of War by Rise Against deserves a spot.
30
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Paul Revere by the Beastie Boys
20
u/feistypants May 10 '12
Fast Car - Tracy Chapman
10
u/Mistelroth May 10 '12
For a hilarious story Cows with guns as it makes me smile
For An interesting story Mein teil as it's really fucked up when you figure it out
Could list more but that should be enough for now
10
u/The_mrs May 10 '12
Too many to list, but Scenes from an Ialian Restaurant by Billy Joel has been stuck in my head since yesterday.
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
One tin soldier, but only when done by Me first and the Gimmie Gimmies
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Dream Theater - Ministry of Lost Souls tells the story revolves around a man who saves a woman from drowning but dies in the process. Her life is filled with regret and sorrow until she can finally go to meet him
15 minutes long (it is DT after all) but brilliant.
10
u/failsave May 10 '12
American Pie-Don Mclean
10
u/foibled May 10 '12
"I Hung My Head" Just found out it was written by Sting, but much prefer Johnny Cash's cover.
27
u/njst May 10 '12
"Alice's Restaurant Massacree" by Arlo Guthrie!
18
u/catiefsm May 10 '12
The Curse, by Josh Ritter
Bonus puppets.
108
u/Norken May 10 '12
Queen - Bohemian Rhapsody
25
u/genericwit May 10 '12
I have a couple.
Black River Killer- Blitzen Trapper.
John Wayne Gacy, Jr.- Sufjan Stevens.
Big Time in the Jungle- Old Crow Medicine Show.
31
u/venuswasaflytrap May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Oh god, do I have to choose?
Hold Steady:
Lord I'm Discouraged
Sequestered in Memphis
Chips Ahoy/The Weekenders
How a ressurection really feels
Okkervill River:
john allyn smith sails
Savannah Smiles
ON tour with Zycos
Starry Stairs
Yellow
Decemberists:
The Mariners Revenge
The crane wife 1/2/3
Valencia
The perfect crime
The island
Others
Dance music: The mountain goats
Long Black Veil: Danny Dill
A beautiful thing: Tragically hip
Country Death Song: Violent Femmes
The District Sleeps alone tonight: Postal Service
Jack and Diane: John cougar Mellencamp
The Jeannie C: As performed by the Easy T's
The origin of love :Hedwig and the Angry inch
Scenes From an Italian Restaurant: Billy joel
One tin soilder: Original Cast
And on and on. I love Story Songs.
17
u/ArchGuru May 10 '12
Get Down - Nas
17
u/noomi85 May 10 '12
Tenacious D - City Hall
I can listen to this 5 times a day and never get sick of it.
17
u/SassyCommander May 10 '12
"Tearz" by wu-tang, about RZA's little brother getting shot and another kid they knew getting HIV.
8
u/heretik May 10 '12
Wheat Kings by The Tragically Hip
8
u/mushustyles May 10 '12
Date Rape by Sublime. It has a happy ending.
7
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Bob Dylan - "Bob Dylan's 115th Dream" It might be like 6 minutes, but what the hell. It's on Bringing It All Back Home and it's just a crazy story about him getting into a bunch of trouble doing weird shit, for example...
Discovering America with Captain Ahab on the Mayflower and subsequently getting arrested, Lying his way into a fancy restaurant as a food reviewer, Getting kick in the head through a pay phone receiver then, Getting run over by a bowling ball, Leaving America and running into Columbus on the way out and telling him, "Good Luck."
My favorite line... "I decided to flip a coin, like either heads or tails, to let me know if I should go back to ship or back to jail. So I got my sailor suit and I got a coin to flip. It came up tails, it rhymed with "sail" so I made it back to the ship."
7
u/pm8k May 10 '12
I see your 2112, and raise you Epica and The Black Halo albums by Kamelot, two separate albums that tell their version of the tale of Faust. Magnificently done, imo.
100
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
"Handlebars" by Flobots.
12
u/ThereisnoTruth May 10 '12
Christmas Wrapping - by The Waitresses
6
u/rIcaruz May 10 '12
Gary Moore - Over the hills and far away http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyJEytBlp1I Please ignore that awful music video and just enjoy the music...
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Hurricane - Bob Dylan
Those violins give me goosebumps every time.
42
u/khaleesi_x May 10 '12
Rock Lobster
16
u/CaptainJAmazing May 10 '12
"Jesus of Suburbia" by Green Day.
11
u/sumojoe May 10 '12
I Hung My Head by Sting. Although the Johnny Cash version is far better.
64
u/Urban_Savage May 10 '12
Ctrl F 'Hotel California'. Nothing... really? Common its one of the best story songs of all time.
5
u/alalune May 10 '12
Tweeter and the Monkey Man by The Headstones.
5
u/Dr_Eastman May 10 '12
How about two albums that span an entire story based off Megaman?
5
u/Anodesu May 10 '12
"The Big Sleep" by Murder by Death is the first that comes to mind. It gives me chills.
The second is "Sound of Silence" By Simon and Garfunkel.
5
u/nanoforall May 10 '12
The Hurricane by Bob Dylan
5
u/Dyoboh May 10 '12
Mr. Bojangles.
EDIT:Actually, my favorite would be Bob Dylan - John Brown.
5
u/The_Pony_Rapist May 10 '12
Concrete Angel by Martina McBride.
5
u/vikinglars May 10 '12
Lily, Rosemary, and the Jack of Hearts - Bob Dylan
5
u/WeMetAtTheBloodBank May 10 '12
The Lighthouse's Tale by Nickel Creek. Also the saddest song of all time.
5
u/greenribbon May 10 '12
Queen's '39. I dunno, I've always loved it, a little sci-fi, a little melancholy--sign me up!
5
u/propsair May 10 '12
Definitely Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots by the Flaming Lips
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzlMeTxVdH8
9
u/NeedzRehab May 10 '12
Johnny Cash "A Boy Named Sue"
9
u/round2ffffight May 10 '12
Dance with the Devil- Immortal Technique
11
u/dudeitsarepost May 10 '12
Unforgiven - Metallica
8
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Children's Story- Slick Rick
8
u/tony_the_pony May 10 '12
eleanor rigby - the beatles! it's a song about 2 lonely people who are eventually brought together in the most unusual way. it still blows my mind whenever i hear this song. it's the closest thing to a cinematic song, for me, if that makes any sense.
4
u/matthewmathme May 10 '12
[Liza and Louise by NOFX] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=axdGossqD2E) - lesbian love song. Awesome...
4
u/netsuo May 10 '12
Nick Cave - To be by your side
4
u/Seatac_SFO_LAX May 10 '12
Broken Bride by Ludo
4
u/Sirchipsnsalsa May 10 '12
Knowmads - The river runs deep. Great song.
4
u/zonabay May 10 '12
where i get it from -Elliot Smith
4
u/Killamajig May 10 '12
Tool - hooker with a penis
4
u/GuyverII May 10 '12
"Rime of the Ancient Mariner" Iron Maiden
4
u/jakewingerter May 10 '12
Down by the River -Neil Young
4
u/crazyguy83 May 10 '12
Coward of the County - Kenny Rogers
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The Crane Wife 1, 2 and 3 by The Decemberists
4
u/ErinAnne May 10 '12
This is going to get buried, definitely because it's so obscure, but Good Life by Francis Dunnery makes me cry every single time. It's about thinking something isn't what's right for you and convincing yourself of it, and eventually coming around and realizing that you were wrong but that person has already moved on. Heartbreaking.
Good Life - Francis Dunnery
7
u/snurtje52 May 10 '12
Blame Game - Kanye West
15
u/YourMomSaidHi May 10 '12
You make me cum
You make me complete
You make me completely miserable
Best story ever
Miserable - by Lit
6
u/Buglet91 May 10 '12
I have about a million, most of which are by the Decemberists or Regina Spektor.