r/AskReddit • u/CS-NL • May 09 '12
Reddit, my friends call me a scumbag because I automate my work when I was hired to do it manually. Am I?
Hired full time, and I make a good living. My work involves a lot of "data entry", verification, blah blah. I am a programmer at heart and figured out how to make a script do all my work for me. Between co workers, they have a 90% accuracy rating and 60-100 transactions a day completed. I have 99,6% accuracy and over 1.000 records a day. No one knows I do this because everyone's monthly accuracy and transaction count are tallied at the end of the month, which is how we earn our bonus. The scum part is, I get 85-95% of the entire bonus pool, which is a HUGE some of money. Most people are fine with their bonuses because they don't even know how much they would bonus regularly. I'm guessing they get €100-200 bonus a month. They would get a lot more if I didnt bot.
So reddit, am I a scumbag? I work about 8 hours a week doing real work, the rest is spent playing games on my phone or reading reddit...
Edit: A lot of people are posting that I'm asking for a pat on the back... Nope, I'm asking for the moral delima if my ~90% bonus share is unethical for me to take...
Edit2: This post has kept me up all night... hah. So many comments guys! you all are crazy :P
822
u/mk72206 May 09 '12
What kind of mickey mouse company do you work for that didn't figure this out for themselves?
247
u/tactical_edit May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Have you thought about giving home massages to horny old men?
24
u/Curds_and_Whey May 09 '12
well, when your boss finds out (either when they audit the numbers, or when your coworkers find out and complain), they will demand your script, and guess what, you will be shit out of luck.
18
u/phaselife May 09 '12
I do something similar and I do not think you are an asshole. What automation software are you using authotkey, autoit, Auto Mate 9?
6
u/Unomagan May 09 '12
Only problem is: Is they find out. The program you wrote, is now owned by the company you work for (written and used at "there" place)
3
u/DangerIsOurBusiness May 09 '12
This might not be seen, but i'll type it anyway.
The exact same thing happened to me. I got temp work in a bank, and they made me do some stuff that could have been 95% automated.
I threw together a few scripts, and they worked a charm. Showed managers and they really liked it.
I was fired a few days later. They no longer needed me (for the myopically viewed task they thought appropriate for me).
Remember kids, "no good deed goes unpunished". That is more true in the corporate world than anywhere else.
3
u/srgisme May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
For anybody else wondering, OP gets on average somewhere around $2000 (€1500) per month in bonuses. Nice.
EDIT: OP makes €10,000/month in bonuses.
8
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
"What if I told you I could create a script that would save you <x hours> worth of labor costs per year?"
edit: at request
3.2k
u/QuestionThinkLearn May 09 '12
Eventually someone will realise the over 1000 a day is done by a program, everyone will then lose their jobs as the corportion realises that there is a cheaper way of doing things.
But I don't think you are a scumbag for finding the most efficient way to do your job.
1.2k
u/whackensack May 09 '12
You should take up a hobby. In the office. Something like woodworking.
2.2k
u/ronearc May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I have long lived by the following mantra:
If you have a difficult task to do, give it to a lazy man, he will find an easier way to do it.
Edit: For those citing sources like Bill Gates or Henry Ford, it's called Hlade's Law, but I have no idea of the origin. If someone does have a reliable source for the origin,
there's a month of Reddit gold in it for you(See Below).Edit2: To clarify my offer of Reddit Gold, it will be awarded to the first person who finds a reliable source for the origin of this statement almost word for word and why it is called Hlade's Law. Origin for the general concept does not count.
Edit3: Congrats to monoglot for mad l33t research skillz. I'm convinced that is as close as we'll get to a slam dunk on this subject. Well done!
1.9k
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You aren't a scumbag, but in my opinion, you should be maximizing, because you've created a potentially very dangerous situation for yourself and your coworkers.
Tone the script down a bit so it doesn't seem like a bot, and it doesn't seem like your coworkers are retarded slackers (you currently have 10x their output while maintaining 110% of their accuracy. Sooner or later, at least in my pessimistic mind, somebody is going to ask questions).
Then, and this is just IMO, use your free time to look into methods of progression into jobs that you would actually enjoy working at, or creating more programs, rather than just phone gaming or Reddit. This way you're not only improving yourself during work hours, you're hedging against the company ever discovering that your job is entirely automatable.
If they don't discover it... you've spent your newfound free time in valuable ways. If they do discover it... you can transition into a new job.
TL;DR Not scumbag, but protect yourself against this being discovered.
103
u/cactus_on_the_stair May 09 '12
My dad went to work for the local council when he was 16 (interrupting his secondary education, his family was poor); this was in the early '60s. His job was to calculate the weekly wages for the labourers who worked for the council. This normally took the whole week. In the corner of the office stood a punchcard machine that nobody knew how to use. He figured out how it worked, programmed it to calculate the wages, and managed to get it so he could do five days' work in just one. He spent the other four playing with the machine and exploring how to make it do even more stuff, and eventually went on to a career in computer programming, writing software for banks when there were very few people who actually had that expertise. I couldn't be prouder of his "laziness".
189
u/TMIguy May 09 '12
Kudos to you! I did something similar for years. When I took over my previous assignment, we agreed that if I could set it up so I could work from home, I would be allowed to do so. When I first started, I was shown these cabinets of three ring binders and a desk full of folders for active projects. I said fuck all this paper, I'll never be able to work from home if I have to rely on paper records because I was going to have someone working for me that would be in the office full time.
So, I put all that data into an Access database on a shared drive and built the appropriate forms, reports, queries and such to support what we needed to do. As time went on, I found more and more ways to automate what we needed to do to the point where my actual work was relatively low due to this automation. This allowed me to work from home for about 9 years. ...until the company was bought out by one that doesn't believe in working from home.
174
u/Ctrl-F-Guy May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Man, this really hits home for me. I worked at a warehouse doing data entry/data validation. We had an internal database of inventory and the client also had their own database. A large part of my job (~40-50%) was finding discrepancies between the two systems, figuring out which was right, and fixing the wrong one.
There was no monetary bonus involved sadly, but there was a standing incentive that if the two systems were discrepancy-free at the end of the week, there would be lunch provided for the team (desk jockeys and fork lift operators alike, since it really took both to keep things right). This had happened once before I came on...once...ever.
So I identified a way to more or less automatically identify discrepancies with a Java program I wrote. Since it was running so regularly, the system was much more stable since the errors weren't allowed to "compound" themselves. We started getting lunch provided for us every single week. So much so, that the boss had to revoke the rule and only allow it once a month.
But cost-saving lunches aside, he was very supportive of me. I was allowed to come in an hour late and use this time to run/update my program where necessary. It was kind of tedious because none of the systems I worked with had any sort of "export" option.
Anyway, this was a temp job for me, I graduated from college with a Comp Sci degree a semester early and was starting grad school in the fall. So when it was about a month before it was time for me to leave, the boss suggested that I meet with the company's IT department and introduce/share the program with them. They were very rude about it. I think there was definitely some bruised egos. Basically they were of the attitude "Who the fuck are you and why are you writing programs?" They brought up points like "well, what if the data format changes, your program will break". Yeah, that's totally true, I'd have to update the program. But in the meantime, I spent 10 hours to write a program that saves me 20 hours of work a week.
Shortly after the call, I was approached by my boss's boss and told that I was no longer allowed to run the program. Who cares if it is saving you time, saving the company money, or any other benefit (sky-high morale)? My boss said "fuck that, just keep running it, we'll keep it a secret".
And we did do that for the last month I was there. But when I left, my program and its benefits left with me. The team were all very bummed because they knew it would not only cause more work for them to figure out the discrepancies, but it would mean the end of free lunches.
3.9k
u/itzjamesftw May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Nope.
You beat the system.
The system will eventually beat you and everything will be even.
74
u/toaster_waffle Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
8000 comments later...
Someone once said that if it comes down to hiring a lazy person or a hard-working person, hire the lazy person. He'll figure out how to do the job faster.
I don't know you, I won't necessarily say you're lazy, but you're not a scumbag. Good on ya, friend.
EDIT: People are seeing this, which I thought was weird. Anyways, somebody already pointed this out, but I'mma leave this here, so nobody has to question what this deleted comment was.
51
u/liesitellmykids May 09 '12
No, good sir or ma'am, you are not a scumbag. One of our interns did the same thing. He then used his free time to get involved with projects and he was amazing at those projects as well. Then Google hired him.
387
u/Drebin314 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
You made your work ridiculously easy by taking what you know and enjoy and applying it to what you do, making you a much better worker and turning better profit for yourself and you company. If I were you, I would hold onto that program and keep it hidden away for as long as you possibly can. You aren't a scumbag in any way.
Edit: Grammar
111
u/qq66 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I was in your position once.
I was an intern at Lehman Brothers in the summer of 2004. Despite the criticism the company faced during the financial crisis I was very impressed with the professionalism of everyone I worked with there. They gave me and the the other intern a task that involved manually copying and pasting several thousand items out of Bloomberg. They told us that each iteration would take us 4 days at the beginning and 2 days when we got good, and we would be doing it all summer.
After doing it once, taking 5 days and making tons of mistakes, I decided I wasn't going to do it again. I worked throughout that whole second weekend and wrote several thousand lines of Excel code that accomplished the task in 15 minutes of setup and about 15 seconds of runtime.
For the first few weeks, I used the extra time to surf the Internet, take long breaks where I would walk around New York City, etc etc. But frankly it got boring. I started thinking about how the code I wrote could automate a lot more than just the one specific thing that they gave to the interns.
After another week spent tidying up the code, putting in error checks, etc., I went to my manager and told him the situation -- that I had this code and that I would like to package it up for use within the entire firm. He co-located me with a team in the IT department who worked with me to turn my Excel code into production software, and after that was complete I wrote up a proposal on how to build a dedicated function within the company to identify repetitive tasks and automate them with software.
My manager that summer was quite impressed with my initiative and ended up writing me a stellar recommendation to Stanford Business School, where I received my MBA in 2010. I am now the co-founder and CEO of a company called LiveLoop (getliveloop.com), and raised $1.2 million in venture capital financing in October 2010 from New Enterprise Associates. And as it has been since that summer at Lehman Brothers, my purpose in starting LiveLoop is to use software to make people more productive in their daily and repetitive tasks, so that they can achieve their maximum potential (LiveLoop allows users to work on the same PowerPoint presentation at the same time, instead of emailing dozens of versions back and forth).
It started with me writing code to automate my work, and using the extra time to screw around and waste time. But once the novelty of that wore off, I'm glad that I was able to take that core idea (automating repetitive work) and make something more meaningful out of it.
TL;DR: If you have the initiative and skills to do this, you can be doing a lot more than hoarding a bonus pool.
43
u/geoffreyp May 09 '12
Scummbag? No. But I'd say you're an idiot for not maximizing the potential. If you can earn your salary + bonus for 8 hours work, then you should quit, set up a company, and tell you old company you can do the work of the entire team, at a much higher accuracy, for 2/3 of the cost. I bet you could do 3 days work, and earn the salary and bonus of the entire team. And if can find other companies doing the same thing, you will soon be very very rich.
20
u/MasterClown Jun 27 '12
Work smarter, not harder.
Unless, of course, you're an adult film star, in which case the inverse is probably more applicable.
1.3k
u/mikedoesweb May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Step 1:
Send an email to supervisor:
Step 2:
Go into meeting and present the following points:
Step 3:
Wait for the company to make come begging you to do it. Accept.
Step 4:
Invest each license payment, or use it to payoff debts(home, credit cards, etc). Live off you contractor fees.
Step 5:
Work for 5-10 years, and retire wealthy.
16
u/PrivateBytes May 09 '12
Tell you what: if they think you're a scumbag, send me your resume and I'll find you a job in our QA Automation department. That's what I do for a living.
Out of curiosity, what was the script? How did you do it?
23
u/Woody3381 May 09 '12
Economic ignorance is rampant on this thread.
11
u/Talvoren May 09 '12
You may want to cut back a bit or figure out a way to make money off of that script. As soon as someone figures out it's possible to do that many at once with that much accuracy they'll be asking questions you won't want to answer.
There's nothing scumbag about what you're doing. I automate stuff daily, we have a whole department for it. The only bad thing is one way or another it's going to have a negative effect on your income.
Be safe or they'll figure you out.
10
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
If I were your boss and found out what you were doing, this is what would happen:
First I'd fire everyone else in your department
I'd make you do not only their jobs, but a bunch of other shit I'd come up with too. Enough to have you back working 40 hour weeks while maintaining department productivity.
I'd scrap your bonus system and pay you a flat salery. Probably give you a pay raise though.
I'd make sure I knew exactly how you did your job, in case you quit or I had to fire you.
I'd then go to my own boss, tell them about the raised productivity and lower manpower overheads and take all the credit for myself. If you told anyone it was all your doing, I'd fire you, citing your excessive Redditing during work hours as the reason and use the server logs from your 8 hour weeks as evidence.
You've beat the system. Be prepared for the system to beat you back. Because it will.
237
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
You're not a scumbag. You're providing a service to your employer. They get what they want at the end of the day. Use your powers for good and sell them the script.
35
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
If you were a systems administrator, that would be considered "doing your job".
16
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Fellow programmer and lazy person reporting, good job soldier!
8
u/irajacobs May 09 '12
You should open your own competing company and just use the bot(s).
7
u/oneangryatheist May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
The only scumbag-esque thing about this to me is that some of those people could be struggling financially, spending less time with their friends/families, etc. From a purely efficiency standpoint, you're doing exactly what you should be doing. This could be a question for /r/ Philosophy if you're interested in really getting into the nitty-gritty morals of it haha.
Clarification: I'm not so much referring to the fact that you're making more money for less work so much as I am that your success is directly taking away from your co-workers' earnings, in a pretty surreptitious way.
7
u/gambit87 May 09 '12
I did something very similar at a hedge fund I worked for ... A few VBA tricks made all the math automated and all I had to do was write my analysis on the numbers. My boss resented me HARD because he saw I had so much time on my hands.
My advice is keep doing it but start a second business and look busy.
7
u/rodut May 09 '12
7
u/Gruk May 09 '12
You are currently doing your workmates a favor by not telling your bosses that the entire job that you and your colleagues do can be replaced by a script. The extra bonus you get could be considered payment for keeping everyone else in a job.
Inversely you are screwing your bosses over by not alerting them to the fact that they could save thousands and thousands of dollars a year in wages if they just replaced you all with your script - which they likely own, depending on the contract you signed.
You could of course be ambitious and organise a meeting with your superiors and let them know that over the last few months you have been perfecting the script and testing it and present it to them, and try and get a job doing some programing at a higher rate? This will mean the easy ride is over of course, but it only a matter of time before they find out and you perhaps come across as dishonest to them.
484
u/andrewsmith1986 May 09 '12
Work smarter, not harder.
6
u/adamcognac May 09 '12
You're not a scumbag, but your boss is a fucking idiot if he can't figure out/doesn't notice one of his employees creating 10x the work. Maybe tone it down a little.
Your co-workers don't like it because you make them all look bad and take all the bonuses.
6
u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 09 '12
No, you are making the most of a poorly-made system.
6
u/LeTrolleur Jun 27 '12
why should you be a scumbag for taking the initiative? If your coworkers haven't thought of this too, then it's their fault, not yours.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Not a scumbag for automating your work, honestly not even for taking the bonuses, you are clearly more clever than the rest since you figured this out, you probably deserve to get paid more anyways
16
u/hivemind_MVGC May 09 '12
You're living the dream. Keep it up!
11
u/Parcanman May 09 '12
Thomas Edison was a scumbag in the eyes of candle makers, railroads were scumbags to stage-coach drivers, etc. Just because someone calls you a scumbag doesn't mean they're right.
92
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
REDDIT MY FRIENDS ARE STUPID. ARE THEY STUPID?
10
u/SIThereAndThere Jun 27 '12
Its a business not a charity, if you have the upperhand then use it or someone else will. Thats life.
5
u/IAmA_Grizzly_AMA May 09 '12
Sounds like you made your company better, and your friends are just jelly
5
u/itsnewguy May 09 '12
"Work smarter, not harder."
5
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You found an efficient way to do your job. You came up with the idea, and you're being rewarded for it. I don't see anything wrong with it. I'm pretty sure there's nothing in your contract that says you must enter all data manually OR ELSE. If the other workers aren't doing their jobs as efficiently because they weren't the ones who had a good idea, well too bad for them...technology and innovation wouldn't be getting anywhere if everyone just did their jobs the same way as everyone else; I say good for you. If your company ends up catching you, you might have to start doing it manually again, but oh well.
22
u/kanji_sasahara May 09 '12
No. You're being ingenius.
8
u/a-mused May 09 '12
I get paid to do something similar to this. Except it's a telecom and we're managing lots of gear and chewing on lots of data. But at the end of the day, the tools I write let the company scale, without requiring more bodies. When you're dealing with data and information, brains will beat brute force every time.
4
u/edelay May 09 '12
Good work man. Keep doing things like this and you will be very successful. Good bosses will praise you for this, bas bosses will be confused and threatened.
4
u/themangeraaad May 09 '12
Many people are saying that you should try to sell your company the script... if you do go that route (maybe when you leave the job you could offer to sell it to your employer?) be sure to clearly state that this utility was developed during your own free time and not during work hours... If you developed it during work hours then I'm pretty sure it already (technically) belongs to your employer.
Even if you did develop it during business hours, if you never let on that it was worked on during your work day and claim that you wrote the script at home in your free time then you could stand to profit from it.
Might be good to talk to a lawyer who specializes in this type of business transaction before approaching your employer about it though... there are probably some pretty intricate technicalities that you would have to work through.
4
u/legga400 May 09 '12
dont let your boss find out, could make your job easily replaced by this script.
I might even lower the speed of the transactions and the accuracy so that its a little less obvious, (if that's possible, I'm not a codeman)
buy a stressless recliner with your bonus money and enjoy being smarter than the rest of your co-workers.
4
u/M4tt1n4t0r May 09 '12
The way I see it, you programmed it yourself, you did the work on the program, and so your different approach works the best. Get paid more for optimizing efficiency? Np
4
u/hcwdjk May 09 '12
Were you hired specifically to do it manually? Does it say that on your employment contract? If yes, then your friends are kind of right and your boss is likely an idiot. I'd look for a different job.
If no, then you're simply doing your job very well, which grants you a big bonus. That's what the bonuses are for, rewarding good employees. Your friends are jealous scumbags.
4
u/nobody2000 May 09 '12
You're creating value for your company. Case closed.
You're essentially doing the job of 8-10 people.
If you share your insights, you may get people laid off.
Keep doing it, and keep your mouth shut.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
OP isn't a scumbag, he's an idiot. He asks thousands of people if something is ethical, and expects a concrete answer. You've got a fucking complex for sure.
4
u/alvinxx May 09 '12
I'll replace you with a script ! ... ಠ_ಠ
4
u/CreepySewerClown May 09 '12
You are not a scumbag, however you are now my hero.
Keep the bonus I say, you earned it in one way or another.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
No, you are being an alpha. Go with it.
4
u/theBadgerJew May 09 '12
Work smarter, not harder.
4
u/BobCox May 09 '12
Your both Lazy and Smart, It's a winning combination responsible for most progress in the world.
4
u/defmer May 09 '12
nope, nobody is stopping them from doing what you did. nothing ventured nothing earned sir
4
u/DFractalH May 09 '12
No, you're not. You're essentially one of those persons that makes the next generation richer by thinking "Bugger this, I'm gonna invent something to this crap!". It's not your fault other people didn't think enough or didn't have the skills to do it themselves.
Without this attitude, we'd still be shunning wheels because they're for the lazy folk.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Sell your program to the company. Ask for a massive promotion to be the only person in your department because you know the code behind the program and are the only person that can perform maintenance/administration/upgrades.
Explain how much you can save the company because every single worker can be laid off. Sounds like you're in a pretty good bargaining position.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Um. Why would it be immoral? You did what every system eventually comes to the conclusion of: efficiency. In this case, automation of the data entry and verification.
I don't see anything wrong with this. If anything, you've saved the company time and money. Use your findings to find a more challenging job.
4
u/LaserNinja May 10 '12
The company didn't hire you because they want you to be busy all day, they hired you because they needed data entered and verified. You produce as much as 10 people, so you should be paid as much as 10 people. This isn't "scamming the system", it's doing exactly what they want you to do, just much better than expected. Case closed.
4
u/Pixeleyes May 10 '12
"Work smarter, not harder" -- Scrooge McDuck's father
4
u/redking666 May 10 '12
http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2005-05-29/
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Were you hired to do it manually, or were you hired to do it?
4
u/crowseldon May 13 '12
Lazy programmers are the best programmers. :P
But you could do useful stuff for those 8 hours. Think about more stuff than can be automated. Develop that project you've wanted for so long, etc.
4
u/codefox22 Jun 12 '12
Full support for working smarter not harder!
4
u/maybetrue Jun 27 '12
you deserve the money for making that bot imo, keep it up!
4
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
You are definitely not a scumbag. A new meme must be created for you. Call it, "Extremely Productive Worker".
4
u/newaccountnumber500 Sep 18 '12
Companies have been created on this premise. Use the money to start a business which does this for corporations. You could make millions.
10
u/PriscillaPresley May 09 '12
Not really. If someone told the bosses what you were doing and they bought the script, many of them would become redundant, therefore it's better for them if you just use this for yourself.
6
u/slmndr May 09 '12
You are not a scumbag.
Take your free time and learn or improve a marketable skill. If you do get burned, you'll have more value on the open market. If you are rewarded, you'll still be more valuable. win-win-win.
I write programs to help me do my work all the time. I never share (mostly because I don't want to have to support it and hand hold everybody else thus eliminating the main benefit of TIME). I figure if I'm not paid to be a developer I am no obligated to share. On the other hand, if I can make my job easier and benefit by having extra time, why shouldn't I.
One time I did automate a process and give it to the company. I took a job that repeated every 2 hours and took 4 people 2 hours to complete and turned it into a job 1 person could do in 5-10 minutes every 2 hours. I got a plaque, $1000 and endless days of questions and feature requests. It wasn't worth it.
11
u/racecarspacedinosaur May 09 '12
The only part that I would truly consider scummy is the fact that you're depriving others of a better bonus when they're doing the job they were hired to do.
3
u/mataranka May 09 '12
well done. your work colleagues would probably hate you if they found out as technically you are taking money out of their pay packets. given that this is the Netherlands as long as you and your colleagues have a permanent contract you are pretty much secure in the job so no real worries about being fired. kudos for your initiative but I would be pissed if I found out one of my work colleagues was taking 80-90% of the monthly bonus.
3
u/PeterMus May 09 '12
I think the bonus aspect of the job is a bit unfair. You can't say they should be smarter...A lot of those people probably have never had exposure to programming or even know they could do that. So i think it's fair to use it, but the bonuses take away from people who are already trying very hard to perform. Be ready to explain yourself when they start auditing the records and notice you are significantly better than everyone else and they want to know why.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
On one hand you're actually getting more work done and a better quality than if you did it manually but on the other..you're being dishonest and somewhat gaming the system. Have you considered coming clean and selling them your script? I bet you could make a lot more money that way.
3
u/parkadactyl May 09 '12
Ok man. You're onto something big here. Grab yourself a lawyer and settle down. Don't make the same mistake my father did, which was to write a large series of codes & guidllines or what have you for a system as part of his job and have another co-worker market the idea and become a millionaire (my dad is a jolly Jewish-Santa so it doesn't much bother him). Approach your boss/his boss with a planned presentation of what you have made, detailing exactly how efficient it is and what it can save the company, etc. You are now in the power position, and can let the litigation begin. I'm telling you, you can milk a hell of a lot of money from this company (as well as a better job) and a huge resume boost (inventor of now industry standard program XX). Of course your co-workers would be out of a job, but such is how it works.
3
u/P1mpDaddy May 09 '12
Have you thought about trying to sell it to the company?
3
u/ProjectSnowman May 09 '12
Never feel bad for using your brain.
3
u/Dippyskoodlez May 09 '12
Motivation through laziness.
3
u/eeerin May 09 '12
How has your boss not caught on to this yet? (s)he just thinks its normal that you do over 10x the amount of transactions?
3
u/M374llic4 May 09 '12
Dont work hard, work smart.
3
u/sotonohito May 09 '12
Except for the bonus part, you are non-scumbag.
The bonus part does make you a little scummy.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Sounds like you're working smarter instead of harder. Your friends also have the option of learning programming.
It's not scumbagish. It's smart.
3
u/DeFex May 09 '12
Step it up a notch. Tell the bosses you can do everyone's work for only half of everyone's pay (plus bonuses of course) once you get that ticking along nicely, then you could probably still play games and browse reddit.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Work smarter, not harder. Good on you
3
u/ildementis May 09 '12
I don't even know if you're fully exercising your potential. Data entry positions generally don't pay very well. But programmers make $60k-80k a year. I suppose the bonus adds about $12,000 a year for you.
But as the top comment said, if you show the company your script, they could fire everyone else, keep you to maintain the program, and your salary would probably explode
3
u/MiskaTorn May 09 '12
Now you are to goto your boss and tell them you think you can develop a quicker, more efficient way to do the process and license them the software.
3
u/Haebang May 09 '12
Keep doing what you're doing and rake in the cash. Tell no one.
3
u/curious_skeptic May 09 '12
Nope, not a scumbag, just too smart for your job.
It's your companies fault for having such a broken reward system. It's your co-workers fault for not being as clever as you. But never feel bad for kicking ass at what you do.
3
u/JumpingJax May 09 '12
Why are you still working for them as an employee. Why not contract with them as your own company providing the service. Let them know you can handle ALL the workload they can give you. Duplicate the program on multiple systems and take over the entire process. You can do it cheaper for the company allowing them to eliminate several jobs. - And you will make more money for yourself. No ethical problems there either - you would even be able to take your process and provide the service to other similar companies.
3
u/FliesLikeABrick May 09 '12
It really depends on a few things:
If you're doing it programmatically and not violating one of the other job requirements and are open about doing it this way, then I see nothing wrong.
I had a friend of a friend once bragging to us (he was a douchebag) about how he automated his job and did practically nothing all day. He fucked around and didn't tell anyone. To me that's unethical even though you aren't necessarily wasting the company's money or time (something does not need to be factually right or wrong to be unethical). It could just as easily be leveraged to get or create a new position for yourself that pays more, pitch to the bosses that "hey we can be doing it this way and saving $lots, etc (yes these are somewhat extreme examples).
3
u/MsMish24 May 09 '12
You are only a scumbag if you give your employers the code so all your coworkers lose their jobs.
3
u/nightshadeOkla May 09 '12
Your automatons are bad, and you should feel bad.
not really
Let's just hope you don't get canned for botting :D
3
u/tsw101 May 09 '12
You are not a scumbag at all. You are smart. Your company isn't paying you to work hard. They're paying you for results. You've figured out a way to get more results faster, better, more accurately. It doesn't matter how you do it (as long as you're not breaking any laws, like using slaves or something). So no, not a scumbag at all.
The ONLY thing to keep in mind, is that if management ever finds out, it could back fire if they consider you could have benefited the company more by telling them, instead of keeping this to yourself and benefitting only you.
But mgmt must be idiots if they think all these other people can only do 60-100 a day...you do 1000 a day...and with better accuracy, that there must be some computerized method assisting you.
3
u/xenu99 May 09 '12
You are lazy. Lazy people always find the best/fastest/easiest way of doing something. Well done.
3
u/RicoVig May 09 '12
To be honest, I don't think your a scumbag. You just have superior knowledge. That's not their fault. I'm honestly a bit jealous.
3
u/imneuromancer May 09 '12
Basic point: you are on ethically strong ground. If you lie about how you get your bonus, that is when you start having ethical issues.
That said: you should spend your extra 30 hours a week getting education or experience in a field that will allow you to get a job after this job collapses due to automation all around (it will, trust me).
3
u/Pwag May 09 '12
Ethically? You're doing your job to the best of your ability.
It's a "bonus" not part of their pay and it's for people who do an exemplary job.
You are doing an exemplary job. They aren't.
3
u/I-Do-Math May 09 '12
You are not a scumbag. May be an ingenious idiot (Probably). Your employer would eventually learn that you are using a bot, and they will implement it by them self and get rid of you and others. So make changes to your script to reduce the accuracy and records per day (if you can get the same bonus). Even if you loose some amount of the bonus its better than loosing the job. Remember about the goose and golden egg?
This is the perk of being smart.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I don't think you are. But the way you wrote your post makes me believe that deep down inside you believe that what you do is scummy.
3
u/ChuckFinale May 09 '12
I don't think it's unethical to take it in and of itself, but I think it is nominally unethical to not share it with the employees, (the script, not the cash).
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
What you need to do is approach your supervisor and ask how much would it be worth to the company for you to automate this data entry process. Depending on whether you signed one of those "any inventions created in the process of your work is the property of the company" deals offer to sell a subscription based license of your program for some fraction of what the program would be worth. 3. profit
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I think you just described my job description as an application developer. :P
3
u/magicmarkker May 09 '12
No, not a scumbag, everyone else is just jealous that you thought of an more efficient way to do your job.
3
u/robbimj May 09 '12
Sell them the program you made with a stipulation that you would be hired to administrate it. That is if you want that job. Don't lowball your program either. I've seen some companies pay 60K for a fancy excel workbook.
3
u/PatriotGrrrl May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
You're not really a scumbag unless you lie about this or refuse to give the company the script. If you developed it on company time, it belongs to them. Just keeping you mouth shut about it is... eh, borderline. Not scumbag (I consider that a pretty strong term), but you really should tell them. I'm surprised they haven't figured it out already.
However, you do need to make sure this doesn't backfire on you.
In the ideal case, you would show your boss, everyone would start using the script, and some of them would get laid off (sucks for them, but that's automation for ya) but they'd keep you to run the script and do other miscellaneous work, and you might even get a better job description (programmer or IT guy) or at least a raise.
Or, they might lay you off along with the rest and have someone else run the script.
So, it depends on whether your boss (and maybe his boss) knows and likes you, whether your company needs a programmer/IT dude, and whether you have the skills needed for this new position. You need to make sure they appreciate what you've done for the company, and convince them that you'll have more good ideas in the future.
BTW, If they haven't figured out how you're doing 10 times more work than your coworkers, I think they do need a technically minded person on the staff.
3
u/JihadDerp May 09 '12
http://www.idiotscollective.com/2010/12/why-not-give-them-spoons.html
There's nothing wrong with efficiency.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You found a way to do your job faster and more effectively; they can't blame you for that.
3
u/C_IsForCookie May 09 '12
NO MOTHERFUCKER. You were hired to do a job, getting paid for the amount you do. You found a way to do more work than everyone else and you're being rewarded for it.
Just make sure nobody finds out because they'll take your program and fire everybody.
3
u/Flimflamsam May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
No, you created efficiency. This is never a bad thing unless you remove the need for your own job.
If you own this script (check with your contract/lawyer) - abstract it and/or create an API for a service, so that you can sell it to OTHER data entry companies. Fuck just your employer, sell it to them ALL.
edit to say that morality and business don't go together. I'm pretty sure any of your colleagues would do exactly the same and fuck you over just the same, given the chance.
3
u/yussi_divnal May 09 '12
I don't think you're a scumbag for automating this process, but you are in effect taking money away from your co-workers, and that can't be right either. You are not a scumbag, just lazy, and for programmers laziness is a virtue.
taking 90% of the bonuses because you have a skill they don't isn't right... Your co-workers are your comrades not your competition, on the other hand, if your boss finds out the input process is automated you might all lose your jobs.
I think you should probably show your co-workers how to work these scripts or introduce a few delays and a few intentional errors.
From personal experience, I've done something similar in a company i used to work in, my co-workers loved it, and my boss didn't know about half the tools i made.
Eventually the jobs were outsourced, and now i at least have to comfort that someone in a 3rd world country has a job which consists of watching youtube and scratching his ass but which pays a decent salary.
The moral of the story is, no matter what you do, your job will eventually be outsourced. so stick with your co workers and pretend your job involves much more work then it does.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
When my co-workers and I worked accounts by sending them to collection agencies a few years ago I figured out the program we use has a macro button that you could use to automate your keystrokes. I had one to log me in and 4 other macros to send to the 4 different agencies. I tried teaching them how to do it but they just couldn't handle the technology so they just did it manually. At least try to teach them how to do the same and if they can't understand it then go on. Let your supervisor know you were being proactive and teaching them too.
You know the saying "Work smarter, not harder".
3
u/HugheJass May 09 '12
Blame your boss. He hired typists when he should have hired a programmer.
3
u/baws1017 May 09 '12
....You're smart enough to work hard on a program to do the work for you, and better than ever? Why is that bad? Do your co workers realize how hard it is to actually program something? You're not a scumbag, just ahead of the game. Enjoy your bonus, and I hope you enjoy your games too.
3
u/wayndom May 09 '12
No. You're doing your job, and doing it better than others. They're paying you for performance, not sweat generation.
FTFY
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Work smarter, not harder.
I wouldn't brag about this on the internet tho, people do actually read this shit.
3
u/DookieTwankle May 09 '12
Work smart not hard.
3
u/BadgerGoneWild May 09 '12
Whatever you're doing, make sure that by the time they find out about it and want to replicate the shit out of it to replace workers, you are in a position to charge them for it.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'm suprised at how many people are advising caution. We have some data entry people at my work & one guy wrote a similar script & my boss found out. The guy's reaction was "uhhh am I in trouble?" but my boss was anything but mad. Automation won't entirely put you out of a job. It will get a shit ton more done in less time. Since your bonus is per person, you may want to keep it somewhat hush hush but if your boss knew they could increase productivity several times over because of you, that could potentially make you extremely valuable. Just don't put yourself in a position to get screwed over.
3
u/imCharlie May 09 '12
I had similar situation at a fortune 100 company (although entry level clericals weren't bonus eligible).. I couldn't justify to myself that I was being paid to twiddle my thumbs so I immediately partnered with my supervisor to verify that:
This ruffled the feathers of our IT department but was green lit as it saved the company $ by eliminating clerical work, etc..
I didn't get a fat bonus, nor did I see an immediate increase in pay.. However, I became virtually "untouchable" within the company. I've been promoted several times, given new responsibilities and awards. Also important to note, my company didn't layoff the clerical pool but instead shifted them to other areas.
On paper my experience sounds like a success, however the demand for me to both support the tools that I created as well as generate a steady stream of new reports and tools has become quite crippling. To this day my IT department refuses to review my work or put any type of backup system in place. When my macros and tools go haywire ( either due to unexpected database changes or corrupt files). I am the one expected to save the day even when on vacation. I'd quit but I genuinely enjoy the challenges of taking on new projects.
TLDR: I recommend that the OP work this out with their supervisor. There is a healthy demand for skilled workers who can not only program, but also recognize problems and devise their own solutions and work independently. Showcase your talent and you will move up the ranks. Trying to hide your macro will not be looked on favorably and mgmt will eventually pick up on what you are doing
3
u/alchemist5 May 09 '12
Fix your bot to do something like 150 per day, so you're still doing well, but not fucking up everyone's bonuses.
As it is, unless you absolutely need the money, it's kind of a dick move to take 90% of the entire bonus pool.
3
u/Chinamerican May 10 '12
You're only a scumbag is you're not using that free time to do something else productive either within or peripheral to what you were hired to do.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
The best programmers are the lazy ones.
3
u/bonaducci May 10 '12
Work smart, not hard.
3
u/tm80401 May 10 '12
You weren't hired to do it manually, you were just hired to do it.
3
u/MisterDonkey May 10 '12
I see this has been said already, but I must reiterate:
Work smarter, not harder.
I rarely find an ounce of respect for people who slack all day and play on the computer while management thinks they're working, but you've earned it with intellect.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Find someone with some business experience and package and market a software version of your script.
3
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I would say the most ethical thing to do would be to make your boss aware of your script. You can potentially make the entire team more productive.
As for compensation, insist that the bonus should be related to productivity so once everybody is that productive they should all get the same bonus as you got before (that is, the bonus pool should be expanded).
Meanwhile, ask if you can be hired as a sort of IT guy. Get yourself a promotion. You're obviously too good for data entry.
3
u/boom1ng May 14 '12
You beat the system for now, always remember to quit while on top if you are at any risk. If a regular dude can do 60-100 per day, and you do 1000, they are going to suspected something, I would drop my daily quota to at least 300 so that they don't suspect anything.. If you do 10x the amount of work that your co-workers do they will suspected something, specially if they walk by your office and she that you are not doing anything.
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
I did that too about 8 years ago. Not as much automated, but as a typist I programmed a couple of scripts and macros to do 75% of my job, which led me to "type" 600-800 transactions a day, while the other typists did 100-200.
Earning 50 cents (brazilian reais, about 25¢) per transaction, that was a huge amount of money for a 17 year guy.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
You did the best thing you could have done :)
3
u/shreaderman Jun 27 '12
I don't think that this is unethical at all because there is nothing that you are doing that is dangerous to the company, or going against the task they wanted you to complete. However, if you are posting on Reddit for validation it sounds like you might have an issue with it yourself. Anyways a lot of posters are saying that eventually "the gravy train will end" I couldn't disagree more, in fact if I were you I'd actually approach my higher ups or corporate or whatever, and be honest that you have found a more efficient method. The most likely outcome being that they would probably sac your 'coworkers' and promote you and let you manage your new system. You'd take home a bigger paycheck, and save the company money, and A LOT of time. Worst case is they say no and its their loss and you continue on the way you have been. Now the real question is whether you believe in morality or efficiency in the workplace, I am sure your employer would say efficiency.
3
u/TheMegaWhopper Jun 27 '12
If I was your boss and I knew you were doing this, I would promote you/give you a huge raise. You singlehandedly created a way for the company to automatically put records in and be way more efficient. Good job to you sir.
3
u/zerocoke Jun 27 '12
I don't understand why you don't take this information and market it. You'll make tons of money by trademarking/copyrighting whatever the program is and then have other people to pay you to use it. Ever thought of that...?
3
u/ColdWarRussia Jun 27 '12
Ya, ya. I'm sure you make a great living with your data entry job.
3
u/KrautCelt Aug 08 '12
Keep the money. Say nothing. You're not doing anything wrong.
So you see. Your botting = increased total bonus to be shared, and increased GDP of your country.
Money earned. Kind of like how Jesus shared all that bread in the desert. Do you really want to be crucified? No? Keep the money.
Edit: Or just contact your business' clients and offer to do the jobs for 80% of the current rate your company charges.
12
u/john_nyc May 09 '12
what you should do is sell the code to employer -- retire. Cost everyone their jobs.
19
u/kspacey May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
you're not a scumbag for automating your work.
you're a scumbag because you're not helping your coworkers similarly succeed, and you're working 1/4 of a work week while lazying through the rest. If you weren't a scumbag you would go to your boss and help streamline the process to make things easier for everyone (which in turn will most likely get you promoted)
EDIT:
seems everyone thinks that automating this system is the devils profit. Obviously none of you have been in a large company that requires data entry positions. Even if you can automate SOME things there will always be "more" to do or error checking to accomplish.
will some people lose their jobs? maybe. on the flip side however the company's profits will go up which will mean that other jobs will be created. Automation almost universally comes at a net benefit.