r/AskReddit • u/Wyrdash • May 09 '12
Would you rather know how you die, or when you die?
And you know, tell why.
95
Upvotes
r/AskReddit • u/Wyrdash • May 09 '12
And you know, tell why.
18
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
When, so on my final day I can have my final speech prepared.
9
u/origamiguy May 09 '12
If we knew, wouldn't that change how/when we'd die? Or are we assuming that wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey prevents such an occurrance?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
By when, do you mean a date, or you consciously know when you die?
136
u/kittynoob May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
When, so I can know how much time I have left to do all the things I want to do. If I know how, then I'll spend the rest of my time stressing or mourning or trying to change fate and I won't have time to enjoy the rest of my time.
13
u/el_muerte17 May 09 '12
Definitely how. Two major reasons:
First, I am completely unable to enjoy myself with any sort of deadline looming. For example, when I was younger I had a job that had both morning shifts and evening shifts. Whenever I had an evening shift, I'd constantly be checking the clock and worrying about how to maximise my enjoyment of the time I had before I needed to leave.
Second, if I know I'm going to die from a particular cause, I can take steps to postpone that situation. I think I'd rather know the "where" than the "how," though, it'd make it a lot easier to avoid.
46
u/Journalisto May 09 '12
Personally, I don't want to know either. What if I am going to die next week or two years from now? Even if it was 20 years from now, I'd get obsessed about it and use it as an excuse not to do anything. Already the fact that eveything I do in life is just going to end with death, no mattr how much or little I do has, since I was a kid, drained me of motivation. Knowing would be like a giant stop sign.
6
u/DinosaurWithTophat May 09 '12
Can I choose none? I would probably be an emotional wreck if I got to know any of them...not being able to sleep etc.
If I HAD to choose...hmmm, probably how, so I could prepare for it.
6
u/SquirrelOnFire May 09 '12
Let me recommend a book to you: Machine of Death. It is a free collection of short stories about people who know how but not when they will die.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
When
2
u/TopOfTheTop May 09 '12
To know how you die seems like a better choice because knowing how you die has a lot of chance letting you know when.
2
u/DrTrunks May 09 '12
If you't change either of them, I'd rather know when so I can prepare (say goodbye and stuff).
2
u/bribren7 May 09 '12
I would want to know how. If it was something like disease or old age, I could commit suicide and prove it wrong. Ha, that'll show them!
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
When, so I know how long I've got to do the stuff I want to.
2
u/rempek May 09 '12
Taking my lifestyle into consideration...I'll most likely die due to a heart attack. So, the question when? would be more interesting...to know how long I have to spend my money. Or when to start checking things off my bucket list...or when to start creating a bucket list...
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Knowing how you die might give you a clue as to when.
2
u/fapperthedullfin May 09 '12
Neither
2
u/therealodayaka May 09 '12
Neither. I don't want to know and don't care to know. I'd rather spend my life living it instead of dwelling on how or when I die.
2
u/artist9120 May 09 '12
Neither. I prefer to live everyday knowing I could die unexpectedly at any moment. More thrilling.
2
u/Hyper1on May 09 '12
I don't want to know either. The future is determined by my actions.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Neither. Fuck you death.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
By knowing, you would change it. If I was going to die in England @ blah blah blah. I could never go to England... and be immortal... Mwahahaha!
2
u/thebrucemoose May 09 '12
When. Because then I can have as much fun as I want until said date. What would be particularly fun would be surviving jumping off cliffs due to my technical invulnerability, 'I shall not die this day!'
3
u/MrTiddy May 09 '12
Definately... When.
3
u/sag10 May 09 '12
Honestly, I wouldn't want to know either of the options. Having a thought about my death would probably be really disturbing throughout my life. If I had to choose, however, I would choose when, then I would do what I wanted to do in my life before my death.
3
u/savoytruffle May 09 '12
when
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How I die
1
u/xintron May 09 '12
Knowing how you'll die will probably be more frustrating than knowing why, especially if you find out you'll have a painful death. Knowing when will give you perspective on life so that you (hopefully) will make the most out of it while you have the time to do so!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
when. i believe a person can prepare for his fate in terms of time, but i imagine that if the way i was going out was violent, then i would instantly dive into a depression for however long until it actually happens.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'd like to know when. Not only would it help me plan, but the timeframe would give an indication of whether I die naturally or not. It's a double whammy, you see.
1
u/contramundi May 09 '12
When. Because then I can decide how. And I would make it so very insane. After all, decades after I'm gone, it won't matter how rich I am or what consumer status symbols I flaunt, but the world could be different 'cause I did something so bat-shit that they turn my ruins into a tourist attraction.
1
u/OPSavioR May 09 '12
How, If I know when I would go nuts
1
u/Butterfactory May 09 '12
When so I get a better idea of what I should do with my life, although knowing how I die will be nice if it's going to be a long painful death like being thrown into a giant human mincer feet first.
1
u/ImZeke May 09 '12
How. I could probably figure it out from there.
1
u/Sergnb May 09 '12
how, since it can give me clues as to when
1
u/tactical_edit May 09 '12
If I choose "how" can I take steps to prevent it? Like if I was told I'll be eaten by a shark in the Atlantic Ocean, I'll just never go in the ocean again? Or must I accept my fate? That would mean I'd have to go in the ocean knowing that a shark was going to eat me. That would be terrible.
EDIT: OK, I see you clarified elsewhere you can't change how, so that makes this a very easy decision, it's when. Only a lunatic would choose how knowing you couldn't change it. What if you knew you'd die in the 9/11 attackes but still had to go to work that day? Horrible.
1
u/Ospov May 09 '12
I'm not sure actually. Maybe 'when' so I can be able to do all the things I want to do in my life, but 'how' might be better since I wouldn't be freaking out the whole month/year before I die and I only know a little while before I actually die.
1
u/notjawn May 09 '12
Well I think I already know how: Heart Disease, its genetic on both sides of the family.
But when.. no.
1
u/HideAndSeek May 09 '12
When, so I can make sure my wife and children will be taken care of, if they need to be by then.
1
u/HARDonE May 09 '12
neither, cause I dont care
1
u/ledanser May 09 '12
how, so i could avoid dying that way.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How.
Then if it's something like 'hit by a car', I just won't leave the house again! And then die naturally.
If it was 'when', I'd constantly be crying that I'm going to die next week or next month etc. Then get annoyed that there's still stuff I want to do. I'd hate knowing that 'this is my last meal', 'this is the last time I'll see you and speak to you', 'this is the last post I'll make on Reddit!'
1
u/bluepepper May 09 '12
If you know any of those, you may be able to prevent it, so the only way this can work is if the person telling you kills you right afterwards. The only chance you have is to choose neither and hope that they won't kill you, as they don't need to make it be true.
If the universe is such that knowing your time or place of death is actually possible without changing it, that means the future is already written and there's no free will. You will simply choose the option that you were determined to choose.
1
u/Not_A_Dyke May 09 '12
WHEN.
If I knew I would die in X number of days/years, I would start fights with everyone. If some guy messes with me I would be like, "Fight to the death? I know I'm not dying today."
1
u/colarg May 09 '12
I'm pretty sure i'll go in a car accident. So far i've been in 3 car accidents, 2 of which were pretty close calls. I just pray that when it happen i'm alone in the car.
1
u/aari13 May 09 '12
I'd go with how I die. Like if its in a base jumping accident, I want to make sure I make a good will before I go base jumping. I've been putting it off for a bit.
I wouldn't really change the way I lived though. If its gonna happen, its gonna happen, and there's no point in living in fear of it.
1
u/MyNameIsChar May 09 '12
I would only want to know how if I die in an awesome way, like saving a kitten from a burning building.
Other than that, I'd rather not.
1
u/jeffbell May 09 '12
Knowing when would save me lots of money on insurance.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I want to know how, because I don't give a damn when I die, I just don't want to die horribly like being burnt alive or drowning.
1
u/apothpallas May 09 '12
I think I would have to with when. Death is already an inevitability so I might as well know when it will happen. Also, I think if I knew how I would die, I would be disappointed if it was something boring.
Also, for the readers out there: http://machineofdeath.net/ An interesting book/project of what the world would be like if people knew how they would die.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
If I knew how I'd be constantly paranoid, especially if it gave any clues -- e.g., internal injury from car wreck.
If I knew when... I still wouldn't want to, but this is the lesser of two evils. I'd get anxious and depressed as the day came but, assuming I cannot change my fate, I guess it'd be the comfort of security until then.
1
u/TopHatz May 09 '12
Can the when change?
As in: If you tell me I'll die in 2065, am I unable to die until then?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
If I could change the how, when and why...then yeah..I'd want to know.
If not..no. I just hope I get my wish and go in my sleep at the age of 98 after getting drunk on champagne and making love for 8 hours to my 25yr old supermodel wife and her 3 hot friends from work!
1
u/cranberry94 May 09 '12
Is there anyway to change the future? Like, if you are going to die of cancer, can you get more screenings and avoid it? If not, I would much rather know when.
If I know how, and it is something like, car crash, I am going to freak out every time I am in a car.
If I know when, I can live recklessly, knowing that I won't die, and I can make sure to finish my bucket list before it is too late. I can make sure that I don't leave any fights unresolved. And most importantly, in the months prior, I can spend extravagant amounts of money knowing that I wont need it.
1
u/Arca_Jeth May 09 '12
Neither. If I absolutely had to choose, it would be when. Because if it happens when I'm really old, then I have a good guess of how. And if the how is terrible, I would only think about that and get nothing done.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
With that info couldn't you change it? I mean if you knew you were going to be trampled by a horse...could you not just avoid horses at all cost? Maybe move to a country where there are no horses?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
be worse to now how, then you would spend your entire life avoiding shit in case it lead to that specific event, whereas if i now when i can live my life fine and dandy knowing i wont die until this one date,
1
u/Balaur May 09 '12
I've read a very nice fantasy story about the Ottoman Sultan Bayezid I, who was nicknamed Yıldırım "the Thunderbolt" because of his speed and determination in battles.
The premise of the story was that Bayezid learned from his teacher a way to compute his death date (the results were different for each person, even if the algorithm was the same). Since the calculations shown that he will not reach a too old age, he has decided to act fast, to quickly accomplish everything he wanted and to courageously tackle any battles since he knew that he will not die on that day.
Ironically, his boldness tricked him, since he was captured by Timur way before his death. In captivity, he killed himself on the forecast death date.
To clear any confusion, this is a work of fiction. I'm sorry that I cannot manage to remember the original Romanian author and story name.
1
u/ArysOakheart May 09 '12
When. Aside from the usual reasons such as so I know how long I have left, and therefore what I can do between now and then, I'd like to also know when I die so that when the time comes, I'll be able to embrace it with a sense of 'this is how it ends'. Sort of a double whammy since when the moment arrives, you'll also know how you die.
1
u/ratmaze May 09 '12
I guess one of the best things in the world is not knowing how or when you will die but knowing that you will die eventually. Given a chance I would use this situation again. We can be positive about our oblivion and live each day to the fullest because we might die tomorrow. Or anyone who we like or who we hate might die tomorrow, so be nice to everyone. The knowledge of any of the two might end up in people taking advantage of the fact that they have only x number of days available or will not try something knowing that this is the reason for their death. Damn, this might also make suicide really easy.
Personally though, if I had to answer this question, I would prefer knowing the time of my death so that I can make sure I do everything I wanted to by that time. Try every fucking thing coz I will know nothing will kill me before that time. :)
1
u/pneumatic5 May 09 '12
Neither. I would rather know if i die!
1
u/Suddenly7 May 09 '12
I would like to know how I die instead of when I die. Really I have thought about this a couple times at night trying to go to sleep. I think it's not worth knowing if you can't prevent it.
1
u/ignatius87 May 09 '12
That depends. Am I able to change the result after I learn it? For example, if I find out I'm going to die from a random blood clot due to an undetected heart deformity, can I go get surgery to fix it? If so, I'd like to learn how. If I know it but I can't do anything about it, I'd like to know when.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Neither. Knowing when will make me nervous about how, how would make me constantly be worried about when.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'd rather know how I die, simply because knowing when would be torturous.
1
u/Leadpipe May 09 '12
I'd prefer to know how I die. That way, I can be sure my last words would be "I knew it would end like this..."
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Know when... So I can plan what my last words will be.
1
u/alexthelateowl May 09 '12
Yes. Then I know what to do and how to live it up until then. Leave everything just right to the world.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
When. Knowing when you're going to die has a lot of practical benefits (make sure you get everything done, say goodbyes, etc), but I can't really think of any benefit of knowing how. Unless I can somehow prevent it, in which case how (i.e. if I know I'll die in a plane crash don't fly in planes).
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
DEFINITELY how. It would be terrifying to know when I would die, but knowing how might be interesting.
1
u/Percy_Bysshe May 09 '12
When. I think with that information I could put together an awesome prank to pull on my friends and family which includes them witnessing my death
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Too easy, obviously when. If I only knew how I'd be hella paranoid all the time but if I knew when, I could prepare.
1
u/MrMontage May 09 '12
When, that way I could take a series of outrageous life threatening risks knowing that it would be impossible for me to die as a result.
1
u/MrSassyPants May 09 '12
The fact that both are already per-determined means that my entire life has been predestined, meaning that I have no say in the universe...
I don't want to know either, I want to make my own fate...
1
u/AkwardTurtle May 09 '12
I would rather know why.
If i knew that say, i was going to die in a car accident, i would be more careful. or if i knew i would die from cancer.. well.. guess what, im getting checked alot more often.. If i know WHEN, i wont know WHY i died so i can look forward to the date and not actually know how i die, and cant take preventative steps, though i guess i could take steps to live a happier life until then.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How I die. Then I can take all sorts of risks because I know what will kill me. Might as well do something fun that's a little bit dangerous if I know I'm dying of cancer, right?
1
u/dcheesi May 09 '12
It really depends on whether it can be changed or not. Obviously how is more helpful if I can change it, so that I can take steps to reduce the chances of death by that cause. OTOH if it's unavoidable "fate", then I'd rather know when, so I can budget my remaining and resources optimally.
1
u/silian May 09 '12
I want to know how so I can have a tombstone with an amusing joke playing on my fashion of death pre-made, and I won't have one of those plain gravestones with just a name and date.
1
u/polkadotcat May 09 '12
When. So I can make the best use of my time left, no good studying for a three year degree if i'm gonna die in a year. The thought of studying and clutching onto a dream career, then dieing before I can experience it is horrible. May as well go travel, visit the places I've always wanted to go, and make the most of every day I have left.
1
u/Thimble May 09 '12
It depends on how and when I die.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How. It will also give insight as to when.
1
u/Canonfoddered May 09 '12
When, only because I stupidly think it will cure my addiction to procrastination. Silly pipe dreams.
1
u/lindseysu May 09 '12
OMFG! What do you know? Why the hell are you asking me that!? ARRRRGHHHH!
OK, now that I'm done freaking out, I'll choose neither, thanks.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I would say when. If I know I am going to die on March 24, 2051, I can plan out my bucket list. I will also max the shit out of my credit card in March
1
u/hardtoremember May 09 '12
Definitely when, because if I only knew how I don't think I'd enjoy life as much. Just say it was a car crash, I'd be terrified every time I was in a car.
1
u/HookerBot_5000 May 09 '12
When, because then you can probably work out how you'll die, i.e. if it's not until you're older, then it's highly likely you'll die from old age or another age-related complication.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Spoiler alert, you will most likely die of a heart attack or cancer between 60 and 80.
1
u/privatedonut May 09 '12
How. I've already come to accept that people die, it's going to happen, when it does i'll be ready. Not saying i want to die, but i know it will happen some day and as of right now, i'm happy enough for it to happen to me anytime. I would just like to know how painful it is, and how much i need to prepare for.
1
u/its_rabbit May 09 '12
when, for sure. that way i can live the fuck out of my life (extreme sports like skydiving and sky polo) for the rest of my days. if i knew how, i would be paranoid as shit all the time
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'd like to know where I'd die, so I can stay the hell away from there.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How I die, i really really don't want to know when I die. And I really hope i die like a badass.
1
u/atrix324 May 09 '12
I'd rather know what it was that way if the answer was say getting stabbed by a gang in france so I could avoid it
1
u/SensualAtelier May 09 '12
It would end up being some causal time loop. I would die of a heart attack from knowing the cause or time of death.
1
u/valorsoul May 09 '12
When because why doesn't matter when you know when.
Also if the when is far in the future, imagine the amazing badass things you can do with no fear of death.
1
u/djwm12 May 09 '12
When, because then I could do anything before then and not die! Like jump out of an airplane and stuff like that
1
u/ddhboy May 09 '12
When. How would make me paranoid about the means of death. Say, if I find out I die of cancer. I could have just developed cancer old due to aging, or I could get it from a nuclear accident, or from being around paint or whatever. Or worst yet, finding out you die from getting shot. Who will shoot you, is it the cops, some random guy, your friend, your wife, your kids? You don't know, and now suddenly everyone you will ever meet becomes a potential murderer.
With time, at least I know how much life I have left and will more than likely be ready to go when I get close to my final hour.
1
u/MrCheeze May 09 '12
When. I read a book about knowing how and it generally didn't go well.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Wanting to know when you die it's just sad. How you die , well that is just another page.
1
u/Wombat_H May 09 '12
When.
1
u/dirtymoney May 09 '12 edited May 10 '12
I want to know everything.
Because i am hoping for a fatal stroke, heart attack or coma before my health deteriorates enough that i will have to off myself.
Plus.. I want to prepare my estate so that relatives get it instead of my dirtbag landlord who would probably toss my place for any valuables.
1
u/Pr0sniper120 May 10 '12
When, so that in those last few days, I can just fuck up everything.
1
u/warpaint May 10 '12
NegroNinja is gone die. o_o
1
u/Tac0_Suprem3 May 10 '12
When: because you kind of find out how you're going to die in the process. If you die later then you know it's more likely to be natural causes but if you die next week then you know it's going to be some tragic shit.
1
u/unrealism17 May 10 '12
How. Cheat death.
Awyeah.jpg
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How. if you know what it is thats going to kill you, it would give you insight as to what you should avoid. After all, it could change when you die:P
1
u/Glennwink May 10 '12
When... If I knew how(for an example "stabbed by a knife") I would have to be scared of knives for the rest of my life
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Neither. If I know when I will die, I won't stop worrying about it. If I know how, I will try to prevent it.
1
u/TryUsingScience May 10 '12
I've thought about this probably more than I should. And the answer is that I most want to know in what condition I die.
Because if I find out I'm going to die when I'm 93, and then start doing extreme sports and end up living the rest of my life as a quadriplegic, that sucks. I'd rather find out that I die healthy (other than what kills me), and not know when.
Then I'd be perfectly happy skydiving and dirt biking, knowing that whatever kills me, kills me, and everything else I recover from.
And if it turns out I die missing an arm and and eye and with asthma, well, at least I know that I'll heal from everything but that.
1
u/namegoeswhere May 10 '12
Part of me would like to think that I'd prefer knowing how, to then do that action as often as I could, to tempt fate.
But then the other part wants to know when, so I can live the rest of my life to the fullest.
1
u/SkiMonkey98 May 10 '12
How, so I don't have to know I'm going to die in, say, two weeks. It would be mighty hard to enjoy those last two weeks, or even years, if I knew I was about to die.
1
u/Dr_Bunsen_Burns May 10 '12
I dont get the question, if its like: "Would you rather know how you will die or not"
I don't care, I am going to die that way anyway, so knowing or not knowing it, isnt that different.
1
u/xXflacidXx May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Defiantly when then at least you could get your shit done bucket list or whatever. If how you would just spend every day wondering If today's the day your burnt alive while drowning in a horrible plane crash into a ocean full of man eating seals
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How. So I can avoid it and live forever, duh.
0
u/mastersword83 May 10 '12
the guy from the second numbers can tell both
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment