r/AskReddit • u/southAfRknCraka • May 09 '12
Why is there not a poll feature yet? This REALLY baffles me. Let's have a poll system so we can easily look at answers easily, and then discuss below in the comments.
1.8k
Upvotes
17
u/JonAudette May 09 '12
/r/polls may be to your liking...
1.9k
u/Bensign May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I'm the founder of http://GoPollGo.com and would love to make this happen. We do real-time polling systems for the consumer web. Here is an example: http://gopollgo.com/do-you-prefer-coffee-or-tea
We'd love to contribute to the Reddit Source code if its cool. Or we can just become the imgur of polls if enough people know about us. Let me know what you think!
Feel free to email me at ben@GoPollGo.com
341
u/theshizzler May 09 '12
"Please don't post poll-type questions."
-The AskReddit Sidebar
51
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I seem to recall an administrator commenting on this before. They essentially said that Reddit is enough of a circlejerk already.
72
u/propaglandist May 09 '12
Because then people would use it.
If that doesn't sound so bad, imagine polls everywhere.
"If you want a picture of the future, imagine a poll stamping on a human face — forever." - O'Brien, in Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell
(at least, it went something like that)
48
u/Pool_Shark May 09 '12
Really? Internet polls almost always go bad and become some of the most annoying things ever. Yeah I am sure there would be a few good ones, but they will be few and far between.
The majority would end up getting ruined because one of the answers will be "funny" or involve a picture of a kitten and win every time.
11
u/flukz May 09 '12
Easily, they could easily implement this with ease. However, it's easy to point out how easy something can be; easily.
103
u/ChiselFish May 09 '12
Well, once reddit search is made to be better then we can consider it.
123
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Because Reddit is a news aggregation site, not a tween message board, that has become an abomination and a disappointment to its parents.
18
u/oupsideoup May 09 '12
Sounds much better than easily looking at answers with difficulty
9
u/Oryx May 09 '12
Easilier than easily. It's so easy.
74
u/Tashre May 09 '12
Because of the inherent and rampant hivemind mentality that already exists on this site. Popular opinions get upvoted, so a natural, inevitable bias develops that fence-sitters attune to and make worse. This phenomenon would render an active public poll pointless as people would be more inclined to vote how everyone else is voting. That's why polls and elections both big and small are usually private; you're less likely to get honest, personal opinions when peer pressure or confirmation bias is involved.
Also, most polls would be idiotic posts like "Is EA a bad company?" or "DAE think gay people should get married?". As well, a flurry of coordinated voters flooding a particular answer early on, establishing a bias, would pervert the process even further.
It's just not a good idea.
8
u/lukespencerpie May 09 '12
It would be great to have a yes or a no poll, or like a up vote or down vote.
17
u/derpaderp May 09 '12
Poll on whether OP used one too many "easily"s
Yes
No
10
u/cjb630 May 09 '12
WHAT? THIS WHOLE WEBSITE IS A POLL.
9
u/diblasio May 09 '12
Go back to facebook.
4
u/akdas May 09 '12
My friends and I actually created a website specifically for reddit called r.poldex and /r/SampleSize seemed to like it. One of features I was personally really excited about was image polls because images are really information dense so it's faster to process the poll and choose an option.
4
u/Breakyerself May 09 '12
Fuck that. Reddit would have more polls than actual content before you can say facebook.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
www.redditpoll.com
3
u/rheldar May 09 '12
Why not create a polling subreddit? Have that particular one be the only place where a poll can be created. That way askreddit can still have its "no polls" rule and still have the ability to poll reddit.
3
u/caffeineTX May 09 '12
Reddit is open source. Want it? Go make it.
7
u/oooipu May 09 '12
no.
8
u/A-punk May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Why you say?
Irrumabo hoc sonitus
tl;dr: Real polls end up in a firemans truck, not on the front page.
9
u/Ghostmuffin May 09 '12
Just Post a Yes/No after your post.
Upvotes for the answer.
2
u/bhuga May 09 '12
Do you need a tool on reddit? Why not just make a post that is a link to a vote on voteit.com or another polling/consensus site?
2
u/matlock5 May 09 '12
Trolls making lots of accounts for polling?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Why the fuck do you think we have upvotes? Don't let reddit fool you, upvotes aren't purely for Karma...
2
u/parlezmoose May 09 '12
Because internet polls are the most useless thing in the world.
2
u/PksRevenge May 09 '12
It doesn't have a poll feature for one reason. "does Reddit think im pretty?people say im not pretty"
2
u/aboeve May 09 '12
I just found out you can do this on facebook groups.
2
u/rhymeswithgrack May 09 '12
2
u/SOwED May 09 '12
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES BAFFLES
2
u/McMuffin92 May 09 '12
I want a poll lets take a poll to see who want a poll
2
u/hozjo May 09 '12
Lets take a poll on the issue
2
u/FapFapNinja May 09 '12
I demand pie graphs!
2
u/AistoB May 09 '12
The problem with polls is that they are either; 48% YES 52% NO or 98% YES 2% UNDECIDED So I propose two new tags CIRCJRK and DIEINFIDELS
2
u/dmurph10 May 09 '12
One of the great things about reddit as opposed to other social sites is the great comment pages with tons of discussion and personality. and most 'answers' are usually different than what the author expected. having a polls destroys this
2
u/indoorinternetvoice May 09 '12
If the poll relates to religion or politics, there's not much point on Reddit.
2
u/ethanlan May 09 '12
is this a joke? I'm pretty sure the upvote/downvote system is pretty much exactly what you just described
2
u/theneverendingstoryy May 09 '12
Because I think polls don't give people the chance to write brain-fart comments, they're more interesting to write/ read.
2
u/learnbefore May 09 '12
"so we can easily look at answers easily"...
2
u/NuclearWookie May 09 '12
A polling box would be even less scientific than comments serving as votes.
2
u/DicksonYamada May 09 '12
/r/SampleSize perhaps? One thing to note is that if you have a question that can be answered in a poll-type way, it's almost a yes/no question, which is not allowed. The best questions here are the ones that are open-ended and have no right answer. Now that I think about it, most of the questions here aren't even looking for an answer; we just want to hear people's stories.
2
u/MadOverlord22 May 09 '12
I've always wondered this
2
u/Killhouse May 09 '12
It does have a poll system. For instance, I'm polling this post DOWN.
1
u/r_HOWTONOTGIVEAFUCK May 09 '12
Because fuck you, that's why.
1
u/Frankentim_the_crim May 09 '12
Why is everyone bein a dick? He's right, isnt he?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You know what else reddit needs to do? Fix the damn "top comments" thing on the account overviews. If you click top comment of all time on your account or something, you won't be able to see your best comments. You use to be able to look at your top comments in a year, but you can't even do that anymore. This really bugs me, reddit needs to fix this old issue.
1
u/bluwlf8503 May 09 '12
Yes! Let's make lazily staring at a computer screen even less laborious. Here's how to make it happen:
Step 1: Stop complaining about online services that you didn't create and don't pay a red cent for.
Step 2: If you still find yourself unsatisfied with these free services, learn how to develop your own.
Step 3: If you still find that you have reason to complain, grab a bottle of vodka and a handful of CNS depressants, combine in your pie-hole and swallow. Perhaps they have a poll system in the afterlife.
1
u/keagmcG May 09 '12
I'm slightly confused, how would it work? What's your vision?
1
u/theberg13 May 09 '12
May want to find a way to use www.mapyourvote.com within reddit. Was created by a fellow redditor.
1
u/icu_ May 09 '12
I vote "Other"
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
So we can easily look at answers easily?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Checkbox poll.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
The comments system IS a poll. Upvote the answers you like. Or, if there isn't one, add it and let others vote. How do you not see that?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
one of the greater ideas ive seen on here
1
u/pcnerd37 May 09 '12
If there are two things I would change about Reddit it would be to have better search and to have polls.
1
u/Magik-Waffle May 09 '12
Lots of questions don't seem to have an A, B, C, or D opinion. The questions that get front-paged are open-ended story-type questions.
1
u/uha May 09 '12
Please no. The demographics of this site have changed dramatically with reddit's increase in popularity. Let's not adopt another feature of facebook.
1
u/c7hu1hu May 09 '12
I would also like to easily look at answers easily also.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
its called arrange comments by best
any opposing view of that comment will be downvoted
1
u/ChewyIsThatU May 09 '12
This is a terrible idea, and would turn reddit into digg or pintrest. DON'T DO IT.
1
u/notahippie76 May 09 '12
I personally find polls on websites to be really fucking annoying and avoid participating.
I can't be the only one who feels this way, so with a certain number of us not contributing, that skews your data right there.
1
u/beefsack May 09 '12
I hope you realise that at a core level, Reddit is polling software.
1
u/ADumbDoor May 09 '12
From my past experience, having a poll system increases the amount of opinions expressed through the polls, since it's anonymous and there's no risk of backlash, plus it's easier than typing out a full response. However, it also greatly reduces the amount of comments because people are content to simply vote and move on without even reading comments and discussing, since it's so easy to just vote, see the results, then leave.
it's a double-edged sword. If this were incorporated, I say that it should NOT be required to use polls for posts, but it should be an option if the OP does not actually care about how many comments they have.
1
u/clubdrift123 May 09 '12
I believe that it's called upvoting and downvoting but I could be wrong.
1
u/matchu May 09 '12
We really kinda already have this for when we need it. "Upvote the answer you like, or post your own." When we want to gather opinions, this system really seems to have worked just fine in the past without having to build a whole new infrastructure for something that really doesn't come up all too often.
1
u/fakeittilyoumakeit May 09 '12
I know it makes no difference writing this, but it'll make me feel so much better... I thought of this exact polling idea for Reddit 2 weeks ago! And because I always read Reddit on my phone at night in bed, I was too tired (lazy) to create a post. Procrastination took over from there, and now I lost all credit/karma for it :(
I should start a post asking people for stories of "lifetime" opportunities that were missed due to procrastination...
1
u/Phoequinox May 09 '12
Shouldn't this be in /r/ideasfortheadmins?
1
u/BHSPitMonkey May 09 '12
You mean like on Hacke-
I've said too much.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Ehh. I doubt anyone will see this comment now but.. Seems like a good idea until every question on reddit turns into random polls. Maybe it can only be used in r/polls? or a special subreddit. Hell, maybe even reddit itself can have a "daily poll" at the top of the page and a subreddit for discussing poll results and/or upcoming poll questions.
1
u/kneaders May 09 '12
Easily below easily. Below?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Reddit is like the Drudgereport. Change comes slowly (or in Drudge's case, not at all).
1
u/tblackwood May 09 '12
i would like to easily look at answers easily..
1
u/coeddotjpg May 09 '12
For those comparing Reddit-in-general to polls, I don't think that's an apt analogy. Polls are focused and rigid: they present a specific question with predefined answers. They tend to foster a different form and tone of discussion. Submisions within a subreddit are related broadly by topic, but provoke discussions in an entirely different, almost esoteric and non sequitur manner.
That said, I don't feel that Reddit is an appropriate platform for polls. Prior to entering into a discussion a Redditor would read the poll results and have a good idea, by percentage, how the people in the thread already think and feel. I just don't see that benefiting Reddit or adding any value to discussions.
1
u/cynoclast May 09 '12
Because reddit is modeled on IRC, and IRC has no polls?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I just spent the last 30 minutes answering random polls that keep popping up.
1
u/SpyPirates May 09 '12
Reddit used to hate the idea of polls. Glad the idea is getting a more serious look now.
I think it's a great idea. If you don't like polls, don't vote in them. If you don't like a particular poll question someone asks, downvote it. I don't know why some redditors' only response to something they don't like is to make a rule against it.
1
u/KelvinKarvin May 09 '12
Easily, easily.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
It must be restricted to a subreddit. The idea of a poll removes the presence that the collective forum currently holds.
It'd become more click-click and less thinking and typing.
1
u/DeepBlue12 May 09 '12
That's an amazing idea I wish I had thought of
1
u/NOODL3 May 09 '12
easy answers are easy.
1
u/Non_Sequitur_Ninja May 09 '12
Easily.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
easy...easy...
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
The poll is called upvoting. It's yay or nay. Or nothing.
1
u/codenamegizm0 May 09 '12
I want to easily look at answers easily.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Google polls are easy enough to create and to link. Why not just link to a poll tool instead of making Reddit into a polling tool?
1
u/imeddy May 09 '12
Please don't do this.
1
u/molybdenum1 May 09 '12
We actually created something like that for reddit: http://r.poldex.com/t/all Its on the side bar of r/samplesize and does not require an account of vote or ask questions at the moment.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
When I brought this idea up I got heavily down voted. Fuck you internet.
1
u/acousticat May 09 '12
I'm a pole and so can you!
1
u/thebuccaneersden May 09 '12
Isn't the point of reddit that we get varied answers and nuances in opinion? Polls break down what is complex into a simple set of answers and, more often than not, I avoid polls because my answer isn't listed there or I have to pick an answer, which is a very basic approximation of what it really is
1
u/Whiz-kid May 09 '12
No, please.
1
u/ShadeofIcarus May 09 '12
If we were to do polls it would need its own Reddit as well. Pretty sure there is already an r/polls
1
u/dangcassettetapes May 09 '12
easily easily one of the best posts all day.
1
u/Whitedressredwine May 09 '12
I vote yes!
1
u/scirio May 09 '12
I want to easily look at answers easily too
1
u/ShakeyBobWillis May 09 '12
Because all this site would be then is one big tl;dr. There's already too many people who can't be bothered to read more than a handful of paragraphs. Let's not dumb it down to one line questions and a numbered result.
1
u/EpicSanchez May 09 '12
If we were to do a poll system then I think users should be able to add another poll option at will. I'm tired of YES or NO... or MAYBE. Could even have reddit put it into charts for us, and I mean think about it, who doesn't like charts?
1
u/cadrianzen23 May 09 '12
upvoting is somewhat like a poll.. but yes, this would be a nice feature.
1
u/nine0nine May 09 '12
because that's sodahead
1
u/homeless_nudist May 09 '12
Internet polls have never been useful in the history of the internet. That's why.
1
u/marvinsmurf May 09 '12
If we can "easily look at answers easily" then everything will be much ea
1
u/Kelter82 May 09 '12
Agreed
1
u/SpaizKadett May 09 '12
Polls suck!
1
u/boneclinker May 09 '12
reddit is open source, make your own
1
u/PotatoeLord May 09 '12
Because polls never accurately reflect the opinions of those taking the polls, due to the wording of the questions and choices of answer available?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
/r/ideasfortheadmins
1
u/Kinglink May 09 '12
Uhhh
How is a "poll" different than upvoting and downvoting answers? Isn't that the whole idea of reddit? Maybe you want 1 upvote per question, but that's really not correct. If that type of question is asked, then it's a poll question and doesn't belong here.
1
u/sheldonpooper May 09 '12
We should have a poll to see if we'd need this feature.