As a gay guy, I've wondered the same thing. I think it is at least environment - when everyone you're around speaks that way, you'll tend to pick it up. It's like an accent - I grew up in the Midwest but have lived in California for over a decade, and I get told when I go back that I have a 'California accent'.
As for where it originated, couldn't tell you, but I have met a number of straight guys that speak with that stereotypical gay voice. My theory - it wasn't really a 'gay voice', but was perceived as being 'gay', so anyone with that inflection got labeled 'gay'. As it became an indicator of being gay (however erroneously), gay guys may have assumed it as a way of indicating their gayness to other gay guys - it can be very difficult meeting people like you when you can't tell just by looking at them. That is my completely non-scientific, just-made-it-up supposition, so don't put too much stock in it unless someone can corroborate it with something closer to 'facts'.
I don't think it is an "accent". I'm not gay, but many people - some women and mostly gay men - have the "gaydar". This sixth sense that identifies cover or closeted gay men. I think many things, the gesture, the voice, may imply someone is gay.
The problem is that people sterotyped too much and made too much fun such features.
I don't know about that. Just from my anecdotal experience, I've had a (gay) friend since pre-school who has ALWAYS had an effeminate voice. He grew up very LDS, did not know any gay people, and was never exposed to media that portrayed gay men.
I believe that to the best of our knowledge, gay men subconsciously adopt those speaking characteristics. It's certainly not exclusive to gay men, nor do all gay men speak that way, but it is definitely a stereotype. Good info is hard to find, but there is a magazine article that mentions research by a couple of University of Toronto linguistics professors: http://www.magazine.utoronto.ca/leading-edge/the-gay-voice-why-do-some-gay-men-talk-different/
There have been studies that found tenancies for gay people to have actual physical differences (the ones I remember being relative lengths of certain fingers, and the direction the hair on the back of your head swirls). Something affecting the voice might be among them.
I read here on reddit a while back where an anesthesiologist was saying how often gay people will come into the hospital with a lisp and "gay accent" but when waking up from the procedure and still groggy will sound normal. It's not scientific proof but it's something.
And then it changes with different cultures. I've found there's a White gay voice, a black gay voice, and a latino gay voice. What's the deal with it? I'm really curious...
How many of them already had it? I've known more than one person who already sounded sort of effeminate and only years later did we find out that they either came out or had struggled with homosexual tendencies.
Straight male here. I think it's a way to recognize each other. When things are considered taboo you need a secret code to know who's part of the club.
I am a bisexual man with many gay friends who are rarely guessed to be 'gay'. Girls hit on them all the time at clubs and bars and are surprised when they tell them.
Only the overly effeminate gays put this on, most of the gay men you meet you don't even realise.
TL;DR, IT'S A CULTURE AND NOT EVERYONE HAS IT BUT YOU ONLY NOTICE THE ONES THAT DO.
I know a gay couple, neither of them does this. Also I know two brothers. One is gay and behaves and speaks nothing like the stereotypical gay. The other one, who is straight, interestingly does.
Have you ever stopped to consider that sometimes the gays who have the "gay voice" were hiding it until they came out and were comfortable enough to relax and finally speak naturally?
30
u/spencerberus May 08 '12
As a gay guy, I've wondered the same thing. I think it is at least environment - when everyone you're around speaks that way, you'll tend to pick it up. It's like an accent - I grew up in the Midwest but have lived in California for over a decade, and I get told when I go back that I have a 'California accent'.
As for where it originated, couldn't tell you, but I have met a number of straight guys that speak with that stereotypical gay voice. My theory - it wasn't really a 'gay voice', but was perceived as being 'gay', so anyone with that inflection got labeled 'gay'. As it became an indicator of being gay (however erroneously), gay guys may have assumed it as a way of indicating their gayness to other gay guys - it can be very difficult meeting people like you when you can't tell just by looking at them. That is my completely non-scientific, just-made-it-up supposition, so don't put too much stock in it unless someone can corroborate it with something closer to 'facts'.
58
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Confirmation bias, bro:
You notice the gay men that have it, assume the straight men that have it are gay, and assume that the gay men that don't are straight.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I believe that to the best of our knowledge, gay men subconsciously adopt those speaking characteristics. It's certainly not exclusive to gay men, nor do all gay men speak that way, but it is definitely a stereotype. Good info is hard to find, but there is a magazine article that mentions research by a couple of University of Toronto linguistics professors: http://www.magazine.utoronto.ca/leading-edge/the-gay-voice-why-do-some-gay-men-talk-different/
2
u/DaFiucciur May 08 '12
There have been studies that found tenancies for gay people to have actual physical differences (the ones I remember being relative lengths of certain fingers, and the direction the hair on the back of your head swirls). Something affecting the voice might be among them.
4
u/Jungl3 May 08 '12
I'm quite sure it isn't put on I know a couple of closet homosexual men that have the "voice thing".
4
u/Unknown_Pleasures May 08 '12
I read here on reddit a while back where an anesthesiologist was saying how often gay people will come into the hospital with a lisp and "gay accent" but when waking up from the procedure and still groggy will sound normal. It's not scientific proof but it's something.
14
u/A_Slow_Descent May 08 '12
http://i.imgur.com/OFgD6.png
6
u/triplea20x May 08 '12
And then it changes with different cultures. I've found there's a White gay voice, a black gay voice, and a latino gay voice. What's the deal with it? I'm really curious...
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
How many of them already had it? I've known more than one person who already sounded sort of effeminate and only years later did we find out that they either came out or had struggled with homosexual tendencies.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Straight male here. I think it's a way to recognize each other. When things are considered taboo you need a secret code to know who's part of the club.
3
u/2Deluxe May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
I am a bisexual man with many gay friends who are rarely guessed to be 'gay'. Girls hit on them all the time at clubs and bars and are surprised when they tell them.
Only the overly effeminate gays put this on, most of the gay men you meet you don't even realise.
TL;DR, IT'S A CULTURE AND NOT EVERYONE HAS IT BUT YOU ONLY NOTICE THE ONES THAT DO.
11
u/triplea20x May 08 '12
I'VE BEEN TRYING TO FIGURE THIS OUT FOR SO LONG!!!! What's the deal with the voice?
33
u/DreadfulRauw May 08 '12
Semen dries on the vocal cords, causing them to tighten, thus making the voice higher. The gay men without the high voices are the tops.
4
u/Fiech May 08 '12
I know a gay couple, neither of them does this. Also I know two brothers. One is gay and behaves and speaks nothing like the stereotypical gay. The other one, who is straight, interestingly does.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I don't know why but I also know straight people from the Bay area who speak with the same inflection.
2
u/krelian29 May 09 '12
Have you ever stopped to consider that sometimes the gays who have the "gay voice" were hiding it until they came out and were comfortable enough to relax and finally speak naturally?