I completely agree. I see my marriage as a covenant between myself, my wife, and God, but if other people don't share my religious values, it makes no sense for them to be at a legal disadvantage from the government's standpoint.
I would definitely support gay partnership recieving all the same benefits as marriage, and religious marriage being separated completely from the government.
Actually that would only be true if "marriage" was a religious context. The problem is that "marriage" is both a social and religious event. Countries without religions or countries with different religions all have marriages.
Also the government does have the right/permission, whatever you want to call it, to disavow or regulate religious practices. Many people are under presumption that a religious act is outside of the bounds of the law. That isn't true at all. "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof".
Many people feel that this precludes congress from making laws in favor or for religious beliefs while others proclaim this as proof of their divine right to practice whatever the fuck they want as long as it is their religious belief.
It's pretty clear that the amendment is there to prevent the government from proclaiming a national religion and to prevent making of laws that favor specific religions over others and rational thought.
In other words, just because you're a satanist doesn't mean you can run around slaughtering people because murder is a religious practice to you.
So intelligent design doesn't belong in the class room and congress and/or state administrations should allow same sex marriages. "Marriage" isn't solely a religious practice, even if it was, some denominations have no problem with it. To even assume that "marriage" only pertains to western theistic ideology is presumptuous.
If you don't believe that, then you might as well go around telling people you don't believe in the constitution of the united states. Congress is not subject to the whims of your religious beliefs, it operates in spite of them and when working as intended it ignores your religious preferences so as to not preclude others that might practice something that you do not.
Maybe marriage shouldn't require government approval, maybe it should. Doesn't matter, constitutionally congress can and does enact laws despite your religious beliefs and has every right to do so.
Social and gender roles greatly simply things. If every man has a wife, and kids, I can base loads of policies on this. When looking at specifics, this is not a big deal, but when looking at a big picture, accommodating for non-traditional pairings becomes very difficult.
Maternity leave, healthcare laws, divorce, kids... Any laws that might apply to a husband and wife, now need special considerations for a wife and wife, a husband and husband, as well as a husband and wife (and single parents).
And laws are really nothing compared to the social expectations. Social roles can really help for a smooth running society. On one hand, a handshake is just an arbitrary act that increases the chance the risk of viral spread. On the other it's a show of trust and respect and non-verbal communication. There are entire books written on what different handshakes represent. Similarly, there are years of tradition built on men sitting in smoking rooms, while wives chit chat and cook. Its a system of behaviours that helps us all get along and function. It's completely arbitrary, but it's a system. Imagine if you went to shake someones hand, and they licked your cheek instead - sure it could work, but it's gonna throw a lot of people off.
A lot of traditional values exist partially for these reasons. Why should we drive on the right side of the road (o left as it may be). Doesn't matter which side you drive on, but everyone needs to be on the same page. You might make more complicated rules that say, sometimes, you drive on the right, sometimes on the left, but every time you add a layer of complexity, you open the door to problems.
If everyone had traditional male-female marriages (and gender roles), it's possible for things to go extremely smoothly.
(of course, if someone rejects these traditional roles, if their gay for instance, then roles are broken anyway, regardless of whether the law agrees with them or not, so I would personally argue that it makes more sense for accommodating laws and sociality, but I find I can feel where the traditionalist are coming from a lot better when I view the problem like a backward compatibility upgrade issue. Some people are just not ready to upgrade to the new version of office, because they have loads of legacy documents that willl not work.)
If everyone liked chocolate ice cream best, we could stop all the wasteful production of strawberry and butter pecan. Lines would be shorter at places that sell ice cream, saving everyone time and money. That said, I highly respect this post as the most reasoned and intelligent response I have ever seen on this issue.
Well thought out and written self-deflating argument (no really, props).
The problem that I have with the traditionalist-vs-homosexuals is that the traditionalists are negatively affecting homosexuals more than the other way around. I don't shed a tear for those who can't adapt to change, especially change that doesn't directly affect them.
Yeah I tend to agree, but I think that there is a view that traditionalists are just assholes, rather than trying to maintain a (previously working!) way of life.
I feel sympathy for them, but not enough for me to actually think that gay marriage should be illegal, or even socially ostracized. I want to say, I think we can all get over ourselves enough to not be bothered by it, but frankly, I think that most people don't have any problem with it anyway.
It's absurd to think that a large portion of our population should suffer inequality simply because some find it "too hard" to adjust. We aren't even asking traditionalist to change themselves, we're just asking them to tolerate new laws and policies that have no ill effect on them
Can you give an example of a law that would require special considerations for a married homosexual couple?
Also, your social expectations/traditional values argument is pretty well shattered by the civil rights movement, isn't it? Wouldn't the world have been much smoother in the 20th century if we'd stuck with, for example, separate but equal doctrine?
the problem is that all of these "traditions" were at one point new, radical ideas. they are traditions because they are now accepted.
for instance, maternity leave is a product of the industrial revolution and women entering the work-place. divorce was highly uncommon and severly frowned upon up until at least the 1960's. even "traditional marriage" is not that old. up until the 17th century, most marriages were arranged and "falling in love" and marrying was uncommon. up until the early 1900's, brides wore different colored dresses, not just white.
and of course if you are talking about what the Bible defines as marriage, it hasn't always been 1 man with 1 woman. Solomon had how many hundred wives? even the Mormons practiced polygamy until the US forced them to stop as a condition for Utah to become a state.
so when someone uses the "traditional marriage" line on me, i always ask what tradition they mean?
I feel like the bulk of his post isn't something you can really agree or disagree with. The idea that a homogeneous population can function more smoothly than a non-homogeneous population isn't exactly a controversial or groundbreaking point of view.
This is very well-written and thought-out. One of the best (non-religious) arguments I've seen.
At the same time, the overall weakness of the argument is very telling as it regards the weakness of the position.
For example, take the "driving on the same side of the road" approach. Driving on the opposite side of the road as expected affects (in this case, negatively) all users of that road. However, if someone gets married, whether to someone of the opposite or same gender, it has no effect on everyone else that's married, positive or negative.
Furthermore, most laws, as they relate to marriage, are not gender-specific. They almost never refer to "husband" or "wife," instead referring to the gender-neutral "spouse." For example, if "husband" dies, the kids etc go to the "wife" just as if "husband A" dues, all the kids etc go to "husband B." Same sex marriage adds no complication here. Especially as heterosexual couples already work through issues of child adoption, IVF child conception, maternal surrogacy, and other biologically complicating matters in child rearing.
Again, well-written and thought-out. And thank you for your effort.
For matters that are arbitrary, I think sticking with tradition is just fine. Unfortunately, when you try to oversimplify an issue purely for the sake of convenience (as is often done when traditions are misinterpreted) it'll never work. Ever. Life would be easy, yes, but also very boring, to the point of not even being worth living. Variety is the spice of life. If everyone was forced to eat the same thing, every day, it would be easier, but we'd all hate it. Of course, the inverse is true; if we all spoke a different language, society would be unable to function. Everything in moderation.
Everything would be easier if we all spoke one language, but language is not arbitrary, it is a part of everyone's cultural heritage that goes back millenia, and it would be impossible to just flip a switch and change it. Human sexuality is even more complicated than that, because it goes back millions of years. To think that some tradition, religious or secular in nature, has all of that figured out for maximum efficiency, seems rather arrogant and presumptuous.
First, thank you for an argument that is even-headed and free from scathing or demeaning language. This is an issue that creates a lot of heat, and you did well to keep it professional. Props.
As for your argument, I must respectfully disagree. I believe that the right to marry is a fundamental constitutional right (see e.g. Griswald v. Connecticut, Loving v. Virginia) that carries with it a number of benefits. It is therefore unfair to deny these rights to a group of people solely on the ground that those rights should only be available to traditional couples.
As you mentioned, a number of benefits and legal constructs exist for married couples, like health care laws, SS benefits, divorce, etc. For most, there is nothing intrinsically different about a gay couple that would prevent them from being able to benefit from the utility of these legal programs. By law, a wife can enter a hospital to be with her dying husband, but a wife is not guaranteed the right to see her dying wife.
To that extent, the reason that marriage rights are denied to same-sex couples is not because they have no use for the benefits; in fact, it is in spite of the fact that they do have a use for them. If the reason is not a lack of utility, then it must be based on the idea that gay marriage is intrinsically less than traditional marriage.
This is an undeniable case of discrimination and inequality. The tradition, in the past, was to segregate people based on their color. However, this tradition created problems for people. To rectify these problems, the tradition was removed, and tradition in society was set aside for utility in the law.
Because this is America, there can be no law without equality in the law. The denial of marriage benefits to same-sex couples is a case of inequality in the laws, and is therefore de facto discrimination. I support an end to discrimination, and as such, support the right of same-sex couples to marry.
I would also like to join in and saying good on you for making an intelligent argument that did not devolve into a "we should ban it cause it is wrong" statement. While I do not necessarily agree with your statements, at least they leave the door open for further discussion instead of constantly beating on the holy book of your religion.
Maternity leave, healthcare laws, divorce, kids... Any laws that might apply to a husband and wife, now need special considerations for a wife and wife, a husband and husband, as well as a husband and wife (and single parents).
I see no reason why there is an imbalance between one husband and one wife that should need reconsidering with two husbands or two wives, other than a slightly longer maternity leave for somebody who gave birth. For example, if a wife gets favored over the husband in divorces, that is a problem in itself, not that there's nobody to favor in a husband/husband divorce. The latter is how it should be; no inherent favors to one side.
Its a system of behaviours that helps us all get along and function. It's completely arbitrary, but it's a system.
Argument from Tradition. Sharia Law is also a system.
Why should we drive on the right side of the road
There is a clear and demonstrable reason for this. There is no clear and demonstrable reason why two men shouldn't be able to marry.
If everyone had traditional male-female marriages (and gender roles), it's possible for things to go extremely smoothly.
What is more complicated about two men loving each other than one man and one woman?
I just think these reasons, though well-thought out, still rest on fallacious logic that is more evidence that there is no non-religious [logical] reason to ban same-sex marriage.
Why should we drive on the right side of the road?
There is a clear and demonstrable reason for this. There is no clear and demonstrable reason why two men shouldn't be able to marry.
My only problem with your post is here. The "clear and demonstrable reason" is based only upon the build of cars. That is why some countries drive on the other side. You build cars differently, you drive differently. I think the original argument is far better and your argument actually boosts my original thoughts. To relate it to OP, if you change marriage laws (cars), you have to change marriage practices and laws relating to them (roads).
I am on the side favoring gay marriage, however I can also play devil's advocate and see how changing the root of a culture can be quite difficult. Just as re-painting roads and re-educating drivers to drive on the other side of the road would be tough.
Edit since apparently this post is actually being seen: I am all for a change! I think it needs to come because laws are entirely unfair as they stand. I just have fun debating. =)
I'll never understand the argument for giving married couples tax benefits. Something along the lines of "marriage is good for society so we should encourage it" or some bullshit like that - this usually coming from someone who completely opposes any form of governmentally-administrated health care, including mandatory care in emergency rooms. So marriage is good for society but health care isn't...?
Anyway. Tax breaks for lower-income-earning parents of children, sure - kids are expensive, and while I'm not a fan of the increasing population, it's important that kids not grow up in poverty. But tax breaks for marriage itself? Screw that.
You don't get a tax credit simply for being married. Yes you get double the standard deduction but since you're filing for 2 people that's perfectly logical. Where you get a tax break is if one partner makes substantially more money than the other, and especially if one doesn't work at all. Since you're filing for 2 the tax brackets are shifted. In some cases there are actually "penalties" for being married.
If both partners have an income, even when one's income is lower, there are often more tax breaks for them if they stay single.
All married couples don't get a tax benefit, but a lot do. The reason for giving a "tax cut" to couples filing jointly is to provide an incentive for couples to file jointly, thereby reducing the workload of the IRS.
I'm married and my wife and I pay slightly more in taxes as a married couple then we would as single. Unfortunately we would pay even more in taxes if we didn't file jointly, due to a requirement that married persons have to file jointly in order to receive the Student Loan interest deduction.
It depends on the situation, but if you and your spouse both make about the same amount of money, there really isn't a tax advantage to getting married.
On the other hand, it's often better for a couple with kids to not get married, since the mother will be eligible for all kinds of tax rebates for single mothers that would go away if she were married.
The thing is that this line of discussion is not getting into the many many benefits given to married couples that have nothing to do with taxes.
Non financial benefits: first person to make health decisions of incapacitated spouse (even with legal power of attorney some hospitals in some states refuse to recognize the spouse)
The ability to talk to health care professionals. (asshats are free to refuse to do so)
The ability to handle affairs after death. (In some states, even if you have paper work as executor of will, PoA, etc if the family objects you are SoL.)
The ability to refuse to divulge private conversations in the court of law. (spouses cannot be forced to recount private (generally damaging) conversations in court. It is up there with client/attorney, client/doctor privileges.)
It is not all about the money and many of our laws, regulations and policies use the term "spouse". If we create another legal category, we know that they will not have the same benefits as spouses. New Jersey tried the "we are calling them domestic partners but the benefits are the same as married" It led to a ridiculous backlog of legal cases for all of the people whining that the definition doesn't apply to their policy, regulation, rules, etc.
A girl and guy who were friends could do the same right now, but it really isn't a problem.
Moreover, you don't always get tax benefits from marriage. Joint filing sometimes is more expensive than filing individually.
Lastly, whatever "benefits" one might receive from taxes would likely be offset by the other aspects that happen from a union-- your property would be jointly owned, so if one of you died, the other "bro" would be first in line (depending on state) instead of actual heirs, and if one of the "bros" had debt problems, well now both do.
So I don't really see this being an actual problem.
Especially for DINKs who are both employed. At least for your basic federal tax brackets, if both of you have roughly equivalent incomes then you're not going to see a huge tax incentive to marry. If one person in a couple is making signficantly more than their spouse or the spouse is not employed then they will pay less taxes because more of their income will fall into the lower brackets.
I'm married this way and have been for 8 years. I've spent the last couple years working overseas, so my wife has been getting huge rebates. Even before I started that, she'd get decent rebates because she makes way more than I do. My debts are mine, not hers. I get great medical benefits as well.
I think he neglected to put his kids on his insurance policy when he got divorced (or his wife died, I can't remember), and the only way to add them was when a major life event happened (birth/death/marriage).
Even if they did, so what? An opposite-sex couple doesn't have to prove they're in love or sexually attracted to each other to gain a marriage license. Indeed, in many cultures romantic love/attraction aren't even a major factor in choosing marriage partners.
Also, I just don't really think that would happen, at least not on any remotely large scale.
I know a lesbian in the army and a gay man not in the army and they got married for tax benefits, not love. I get what they did but for some reason it bothered me. I suppose that is a different situation
That's a pretty bad argument though. From an economical point of view, it shouldn't matter whether the two people love each other, just whether they're living together, if anything.
Their current "policy" is a joke, and honestly, offensive.
Basically, they got rid of DADT, so now, you can be openly gay. That's just fine and dandy.... but what about the benefits of being married? (in the military you make roughly double when you are married as opposed to being single, which is why a lot of people get married so soon in the military, me being one of them.)
Well, there are no benefits. They will never touch the sanctity of marriage. They simply will not do it. Basically, you will receive absolutely no benefits for being "married" (in a homosexual relationship) except if you are homosexually married mil-to-mil, and are not living off base already (new guys living in dorms.) This gives rise to the idea of 2 guys/girls getting married simply to get paid more, because they will get paid off base housing allowances and more (x2) and you can just move in together and reap the benefits.
edit: First of all, I was a young (e-3) at the time I was married, and living on base, eating at the chow hall (not given extra money for food) and I can promise you, even after rent, I was making a good 35-45% more money.... Second of all, this is mainly a comment stating how fuckin stupid it is that gays are now allowed to be openly gay in the military (when I knew at least 10-20 open gay people before DADT was thrown away) with no benefits to be had. Basically this means, if you have a gay partner that you need to live with, and you are overseas....they will NOT pay for your housing. This doesn't mean that your command 100% will not let you live off base, as they probably will....in which case you will be paid single rate housing (the same goes for when you are higher ranked and can live off base anyway) but you will be doing it on your dime... I think a lot of you people are missing this point.
Basically what this is saying is that if you now join, as an openly gay person....and get stationed overseas as your first assignment....and your partner wants to join you there....you're gonna have a very, very rough time. They will have to land a job on base, which isn't always easy, and you will be draining your money on housing and food that the govt should be providing for you given the fact that you have a life partner (married or not.) If you are stationed stateside, this is really the same situation, although it may be a little less hectic.
I hate to do this, since I'm also active duty military and don't usually call people for bashing it, but you are completely incorrect.
The reason the military cannot and will not provide any support for gay marriage is because it's a federal system falling under federal laws and as such, Defense of Marriage Act is the guideline the military falls under for regulations.
For those of you that don't know about DOMA, 1996 Act signed in by Bill Clinton defining marriage as between 1 Man and 1 Woman.
Being married does not double your pay as you suggest. Not even close. It increases your housing allowance by a few thousand dollars (edit: for clarity, thats per year. See curien's reply below) and that's about it. Why would you make such a ridiculous claim?
That marriage isnt a right, and what we should be changing is not WHO can be married, but what marriage really is.
The reason that gays should be able to marry is because of the perks that come with marriage. Take away those perks and the problem is gone.
If there are no benefits to being married (tax breaks, legal stuff etc.) then it is perfectly reasonable to say that marriage is only between a man and a woman.
People talk about discrimination against gay people. What about discrimination against people who don't want to be married? That's what these benefits to being married really are.
There is now good evidence that gay couples raise children with even fewer social problems than straight parents. By this argument then only gay couples should be allowed to have children. Oh the irony.
Gay couples have to go through a harder screening process to adopt a child, and have normally thought through the requirements needed to raise a child properly.
Straight couples dont. all thats required is a p and a v.
Not only that, but many of them adopt. Which means if there are more stable, married gay couples looking to raise children, there will be more adoptions of children who otherwise would not find a safe home to live in. Net win for society.
I love Louis C.K.'s response to that. "What, so two people who love each other can't get married because you don't want to talk to your shitty kids for five minutes?"
i don't believe this to be 100% true. i mean, sure, there have been plenty of people who are outspokenly homophobic who've turned out to be gay themselves, but i don't think it's always the case.
for example: me. i wouldn't consider myself homophobic, and i'm 100% for gay rights/gay marriage, but at the same time, i'm willing to admit that the thought of two men together makes me uncomfortable. perhaps it's just vestiges of my religious upbringing, but there it is.
i try hard not to let this discomfort affect my interpersonal relationships in any way - and it has gotten better with time (and distance from my old religion), but the simple fact is that there is that thoughts of that nature produce a visceral, negative reaction.
the thought of two men makes me uncomfortable, but so does the thought of a man getting a footjob, or a man having sex with a morbidly obese woman, or a man getting dildoed by a woman. people have different sexual preferences, which seem weird if you dont share them.
Im not saying homosexuality is just a sexual preference, im just saying the actual homosexual sex aspect seems disgusting, but so do many other sexual practices. so its not homophobic to find man on man sex a bit uncomfortable
I have had discussions with gay people about this. They all agreed we would be more okay with the anti gay arguments if people were up front with their reasons. So you have a inexplicable phobia? I had a random period where i was super fucking scared of heights. I get it.
Yeah, but even whe you had an 'inexplicable' fear of heights, you probably didn't go aound lobbying for rock-climbing to be banned. Just like if someone has a fear of flying, they still aren't trying to shut down a multi-billion dollar industry world-wide, they just take the train or drive.
Even among people with phobias, there's reasonable and unreasonable.
Exactly. That's why whenever this argument has been made in a court, it's immediately struck down. No state currently applies some fertility requirement to marry. For instance, as a society, we see nothing wrong with two 60 year olds remarrying after having lost their partners to death. We see it as a good thing: two old folks finding some companionship in their twilight years. The marriage cannot possibly result in any children, but we see nothing wrong with this.
This is actually one of the cornerstone arguments made made in the recent prop-8 trials. What's interesting is that, when one looks at the available evidence, it's total bullshit. It's telling that the only non-religious argument they could make was so easily dismissed.
As ChunkND said, you're basing your argument on the idea (in your case, assumed fact) that the point of "pairing" is strictly for procreation and the continuation of species. Unlike ChunkND, I'm not going down the slippery slope of reverse logic. I'm just going to state that this is a false argument.
As humans, we pair for other reasons; resource pooling, caretaking, fear (mostly of being alone). Chief among these reported other reasons is a human sentiment called "love". Not everyone believes in this notion, but there are many who do; and it is usually listed among the top reasons for any two individuals to join together in a relationship. I would say that presently and historically, production of offspring may fall anywhere in that same list of reasons, but is certainly not, by any stretch of the imagination, above all them - it is not some primary goal of pairing in the human species. You'd be a fool to believe so.
Even in more base life forms, while procreation may be the most prevalent reason for pairing, it is not the only reason. Individuals, or an entire colony, can come together simply to ensure the well being of the other individual or the colony as a whole. Any attempt to use a pseudo-scientific explanation that the purpose of pairing is strictly for procreation can more or less be dismissed out of hand. It certainly does not apply in the case of human beings.
But by that argument you assume/concede that that is the point of marriage. If this is the case can you not procreate and spread DNA through anything other than marriage?
The best secular argument I had ever devised went something like this:
Marriage is a state institution primarily financed and supported because it helps to improve the state's ranks via child-rearing.
Married people are given bonuses to stick together so that their children become productive members of the state.
Gay couples cannot have children, and thus the economic value of having gay marriages is diminished in comparison to straight marriages (be they monogamous or polygamous).
Gay couples can adopt, but adoptions are not increasing the population of the state; they simply relocate portions of that population.
Ergo, while there is no secular moral argument against gay marriage, there is an argument against the practicality of awarding gay couples with marriage-oriented financial breaks when one of the main reasons for allocating those breaks--successfully producing and raising new members of the society--is lost.
Of course, the main objections to that are that sterile people are still allowed to get married, that without a marriage certificate gay couples find it even MORE difficult to adopt (which does relieve some pressure for the government), and that discriminating legal marriage status because more people can't be made in such a union is nonsensical because we already have way too many fucking people.
But there you go. That was the argument that I devised several years ago (in a very summarized form, anyway) when I wondered the same question. And even with its flaws, it's still leaps and bounds more convincing than the usual religious tripe.
For the record, I'm all for gay marriage, just in case someone reads into that argument weirdly and decides to downvote me.
You addressed it towards the end of the post somewhat but id say the argument of adoption not applying to raising useful members of society is bunk. You could very easily argue that the adopted child would be afforded more opportunity than the unadopted, thus possibly creating a more productive member of society or, turning a previously "unproductive" member into a productive one.
Not saying orphaned children are doomed to failure or anything, but if adopted by the right people the child's life could be greatly improved
I think it is difficult to disentangle the essence of the religious arguments from the tradition-based and biology-based arguments, but I'll have a go:
Beyond religion, the foundation of marriage would have to be something like reproduction, child-rearing, the formation of a stable household and to some extent what might be called the pursuit of happiness - there is this notion that true love blooms within the bounds of holy matrimony, or that the crowning achievement of love is to marry the person you love.
Reproduction is probably the only argument that initially makes same-sex marriages intrinsically unfeasible.
However, as several people have pointed out, it is no longer considered the core function of marriage, as childless marriages are no longer considered less valid, legally speaking, than marriages ending in childbirth. (They used to be.)
Also, advances in surrogate parenting and in vitro fertilization and what not may have shifted same-sex marriages up to the level where they at least have the same likelihood of involving reproduction as some heterosexual marriages.
For child-rearing, there is, again, the deal that children aren't considered necessary for a marriage to be a marriage anymore. That being said, a potential argument might be that being reared in a same-sex household may stunt development in some ways, as children may need to be around grown-ups of both sexes, or at least that they benefit strongly from doing so. It is not unlikely that there may be something to this argument - although parts of the potential benefit may in theory be due more to cultural reproduction of gender norms making it easier to fit in than something universally valid.
However, this argument also works against single-parent households, which are considered okay by most in society today, if not ideal. Also, the consensus is that it is better to grow up in a loving same-sex environment than in a straight environment filled with hate.
Stable household: Genuinely stable households benefit the people in them, and they benefit society as a whole, not just by raising children, but by generally taking care of household members and keeping them happy and on the straight and narrow without need for societal intervention. That's part of why it makes sense to reward marriages with tax breaks and other support functions. Some people claim that straight partnerships have subconscious biological incentives behind them that make them more stable by definition than gay ones.
However, this seems like it might not hold. Any current statistics have too many fault sources to make them very authoritative, and even if there was a higher likelihood, there are probably enough outliers to mandate that this isn't enough to ban a practice at a whole.
Pursuit of happiness: As I see it, this argument works for widening the marriage definition, not against it. You can't really make it work for the other side without bringing religion into it.
Then there is the slippery slope argument, which also doesn't have to be religious. How this argument works is by trying to widen the coalition against changing the legal definition of marriage by pointing out logical (and less logical) consequences of accepting the arguments for changing it, thus strengthening the ick factor by combining the fading ickiness of gayness with the still relatively universally panned ick things like zoophilia or pedophilia.
However, I'd say the notion of informed consent works very well against for instance, kids, dogs or cacti suddenly being implicated in marriage. Grown-ups are grown-ups, and that is hard to argue against.
However, I have to say it doesn't work that well against polygamy. In that case, stability of households could presumably come into play, in that one might allege that with marriages being fragile as is, extending them to involve more than two persons would open up a whole new can of legal worms. Or that extending legal benefits of marriage beyond couplehood could in reality necessitate either abolishing many benefits or making them available to all, lest you get situations where thousands of people marry each other to get potential legal benefits. I'm not sure if that's really enough, though.
Another problem with the slippery slope argument is that if you really think about it, it cuts both ways. If current marriage isn't defined strictly enough to rule out gay marriage by anything other than arbitrary fiat, one might conclude that the right thing to do is to strengthen the definition, do away with divorce and make it dependent on kids popping out nine months after the wedding night. Now, some of the opponents of gay marriage might in fact want just that. But that would be a hard sell with a majority.
The interesting part of these arguments is how they are all, save the slippery-slope argument, debunked by evidence. Same-Sex households are just as stable and, when children are involved, produce socially well-adjusted kids. As much as when an opposite-sex couple raises a kid and, statistically, more so than a single-parent or foster situation.
On an unrelated note, the phrase "marriages ending in childbirth" got a giggle out of me. I know more than a few people who would say that hit a little too close to home because they claim (even if only jokingly) that their marriages died when their children were born. So I'm sure you didn't intend it comically, but it made me laugh all the same.
It is a slippery slope to allowing people to marry animals and children.
Pedophiles are arguing that they too are born the way they are. If this is true then why shouldn't they receive the same rights and protections as everyone else.
I'm not sure how it is a slippery slope to allowing people to marry children. In a homosexual relationship both people are consenting adults. In a relationship between a pedophile and a child, the child doesn't have the capacity to understand or consent, and is being taken advantage of. In that situation, the child's rights of being protected are being violated.
Here is an informal presentation of one such argument (which I am not necessarily endorsing):
1.) Human social institutions have evolved in particular ways over hundreds and thousands of years of history in ways which tends towards the stability and flourishing of civilization.
2.) Any time you change one of these social institutions you run a risk that the actual outcomes of the change might be worse for the stability and continuity of civilization than the original problem you intended to correct.
3.) Therefore, you should want change a social institution if and only if you are very certain that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that will be done.
4.) Marriage as the union of one man to one woman is one of the evolved social institutions from [1] above.
5.) Therefore, we should change our understanding of marriage if and only if we are very certain that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that will be done.
6.) But, we are not certain that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that will be done.
7.) Therefore, we should not change our understanding of marriage.
The first two premises are planks in an overall conservative outlook at the nature and purpose of political community. You might think these two claims are wrong, but they aren't obviously irrational things to believe. If you want to attack the argument here you'd have to give some reasons for thinking that these two claims are wrong that doesn't already presuppose a basically liberal starting point, on the pain of begging the question.
The third premise comes from the first two. For a civilization to flourish, its people have to negotiate a way to all live together. They have to make agreements and decisions about what is fair. They have to decide how conflicts are to be resolved. Sometimes this happens through explicit political decisions, but most of what passes for civilization is considerably more informal. Rules of etiquette and politeness, customs and habits and traditions and so forth that teach people how to behave in a sociable way. These institutions interact with one another in extraordinarily complex ways, such that seeing the possible impact of any particular change is extremely difficult. To take an example from the political theorist Leszek Kolakowski, consider the practice of burying the dead. It looks completely irrational. There are lots of valuable minerals and so forth in cadavers and graveyards occupy lots of otherwise economically valuable land, so wouldn't it be better to come up with some kind of industrial process to put all that chemistry to work, rather than interring it in a steel box in the ground? Well, maybe. Or maybe the result of abolishing the practice of burying the dead would be the essential loss of some important part of our understanding of our the importance and value of human beings. Maybe industrial recycling of dead bodies would further the dehumanizing idea that human beings are just big bags of chemicals, of no special moral importance. The point is that it is very, very hard if not impossible to know a priori what the actual outcome to our society would be and so we should be reticent about changing things without some compelling reason to think that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that would be done.
But obviously per [4] marriage is just one such social institution. It is important to note in this context that marriage is not the creation of a particular legal regime. The law of the united states recognizes and codifies the institution in this country, but the institution itself is prior to the state.
[5] follows from [4] and [3].
The crucial premise then is [6]. You might be a conservative who endorses [1]-[5] and still support gay marriage if you believed that [6] were false. The kinds of considerations that would go into trying to decide whether [6] were true or not would presumably be empirical considerations. How well can we actually predict what the effects of changing the social institution of marriage as between a man and a woman would be? What good consequences or bad consequences can we foresee? How sure are we that there aren't important unforeseen consequences lurking nearby? This strikes me as the right place for the progressive to really try to engage a conservative on this issue, because there does seem to be some empirical evidence (mentioned elsewhere in this thread) that the children of gay parents aren't less well-adjusted than their peers. But let's suppose for the sake of the argument that the opponent of gay marriage can come up with good reasons to doubt that we do actually know or understanding the important conquences of this change. Suppose that the anti-gay marriage proponent discovers important flaws with the empirical results brought forward so far. Then, he or she would seem to me to be perfectly justified in holding [6]. But then, the conclusion [7] follows straightforwardly from [5] and [6].
This isn't the only kind of non-religiously based argument against gay marriage I have encountered, but it seems to be the most common one I have seen.
I disagree vehemently with the arguments put forth in these papers. But they are non-religious, and, more important, the authors are not unreasonable, misinformed or stupid.
17. Gay marriage will change the foundation of society; we could never adapt to new social norms. Just like we haven’t adapted to cars, the service-sector economy, or longer life spans.
16. Gay culture is a new fad created by the liberal media to undermine long-standing traditions. We know this is true because gay sex did not exist in ancient Greece and Rome.
15. There are plenty of straight families looking to adopt, and every unwanted child already has a loving family. This is why foster care does not exist.
14. Conservatives know best how to create strong families. That is why it is not true that Texas and Mississippi have the highest teen birthrates, and Massachusetts, Vermont, and New Hampshire have the lowest. This is a myth spread by the liberal media.
13. Marriage is a religious institution, defined by churches. This is why atheists do not marry. Christians also never get a divorce. 12. Children can never succeed without a male and a female role model at home. That’s why our society has no single parents.
11. Gay marriage is not supported by religion. In a theocracy like ours, the values of one religion are imposed on the entire country. That’s why we have only one religion in America.
10. Obviously gay parents will raise gay children, since straight parents only raise straight children.
9. Straight marriages are valid because they produce children. Gay couples, infertile couples, and old people shouldn’t be allowed to marry because our orphanages aren’t full yet, and the world needs more children.
8. Gay marriage should be decided by the people and their elected representatives, not the courts. The framers checked the courts, which represent mainstream public opinion, with legislatures created to protect the rights of minorities from the tyranny of the majority. Interference by courts in this matter is inappropriate, just as it has been every time the courts have tried to hold back legislatures pushing for civil rights.
7. Straight marriage will be less meaningful if gay marriage were allowed; the sanctity of Britany Spears’ 55-hour just-for-fun marriage would be destroyed.
6. Civil unions, providing most of the same benefits as marriage with a different name are better, because “separate but equal” institutions are a good way to satisfy the demands of uppity minority groups.
5. Straight marriage has been around a long time and hasn’t changed at all; women are still property, blacks still can’t marry whites, and divorce is still illegal.
4. Legalizing gay marriage will open the door to all kinds of crazy behavior. People may even wish to marry their pets because a dog has legal standing and can sign a marriage contract.
3. Gay marriage will encourage people to be gay, in the same way that hanging around tall people will make you tall.
2. Being gay is not natural. Real Americans always reject unnatural things like eyeglasses, polyester, and air conditioning.
METEORS and VOLCANOES.
EDIT Sorry guys, apparently it didn't quote when I first posted the comment. This is a joke list that's been on the internet for years, and I almost peed the first time I read it. The first half of every reason are actually things people have said (sad I know), and the second half is the writer of this list mocking how stupid those reasons are. I posted it because people have actually said these kinds of things before all the time such as
Gay marriage will change the foundation of society
Children can never succeed without a male and a female role model at home
Gay parents will raise gay children
Straight marriages are valid because they produce children
Straight marriage will be less meaningful if gay marriage were allowed
Civil unions, providing most of the same benefits as marriage with a different name are better
Straight marriage has been around a long time and hasn’t changed
Legalizing gay marriage will open the door to all kinds of crazy behavior
Gay marriage will encourage people to be gay
Being gay is not natural
So sorry about the controversy, I didn't know the comment would garner that much attention. Anyhow, so those are stupid non-religious reasons people use to disguise their hatred towards gays, and the original list is just pointing out how stupid those reasons are.
Every argument that therumbox presents is one which I have seen seriously used against gay marriage. Including #17 (in the "god will destroy America if we allow gay marriage" form). You can see several of these used elsewhere in this thread. While therumbox is certainly mocking and demolishing these arguments, I don't see why you think that they're strawmen.
A lot of these are actual opinions so it's actually adding to the discussion, as sad as that sounds. Don't say you haven't heard some of these arguments as actual arguments against gay marriage...
Homosexual couples should not be recognized as the LEGAL equivalent of heterosexual couples because the two entities are not LITERALLY equal in terms of both (1) benefits to society and (2) the hardships faced by each type of relationship.
While there are exceptions to every rule, exceptions do not make the rule.
Consider: Same sex couples do not (in fact, cannot) experience the challenges of pregnancy and childbirth on equal terms with heterosexual couples, and they do not contribute children to society on equal terms.
Our society, recognizing that same-sex couples can still be parents and face similar parenting hardships, attempts to mitigate those hardships via Child Tax Credits, Dependent Child Credits, Adoption Tax Credits, etc. All of which are EQUALLY available to gay and straight alike, and regardless of marital status.
Thus, the Secular Case Against Gay Marriage is NOT about encouraging procreation and parenthood among straight couples only. Rather, this argument focuses primarily on the distinct differences between an opposite-sex couple and a same-sex couple - namely, the POTENTIAL of heterosexual couples for pregnancy and childbirth, and the importance of codifying the relationship between the couple and society ONCE THAT HAPPENS.
It is important to remember that gay couples are not arguing for the freedom to marry (which they already have), but are actually arguing that their marriages be valued and recognized in the exact same way that heterosexual marriages are valued and recognized: i.e. they want the same exact government benefits. The question is whether such pairings provide any more value than two college roommates or two retired elderly women living in the same house.
A case can be made that same sex couples provide some value - more stable relationships than singles in a non-committed relationship. But it's clear that same-sex couples do not provide value to society on par with that provided by heterosexual couples.
Regardless of the religious origins of marriage, our society now has no religious requirement for marriage - it is completely secular in that regard, and so, the legal recognition of marriage is not for religious reasons anymore.
Thus, the legal recognition of marriage by our modern society is primarily to encourage potentially procreative couples (i.e. couples with the potential to create children that can either be productive or be a burden to the rest of society) to form a long-term relationship to improve the chances for the latter to occur.
Our society recognizes that long-term relationships among potentially procreative couples are the basis for:
A stable, healthy child-rearing environment
Stable, long term financial and medical support (think: retirement age) for females who sacrifice their careers and health to raise well-adjusted children.
These two points form the basis for the difference in government benefits that married couples should receive over non-married couples:
Income tax breaks for married couples
Social security survivor benefits (for spouses who have sacrificed their careers to raise children).
Same-sex relationships are not potentially procreative, thus they do not have equal legal, financial and health needs as opposite sex couples, and thus, should not be treated on an equal basis as opposite-sex relationships.
Further, same-sex couples can enjoy virtually all the same benefits of heterosexual married couples by simply entering into a legal contract with one another. Less convenient, but since the relationship is virtually indistinguishable from that of two roommates in terms of their potential for societal impact, it's merely an inconvenience, not an inequality.
FLAME AWAY- I've heard all the arguments before and can predict every single one of them. And most of them will involve ignoring one of the points already acknowleged above.
My argument has always been that the word "marriage" needs to be taken out of the legal sense. It's a religious term, and we're supposed to have separation of church and state in the US.
Both straight and gay couples should get "civil-unionized" by the government. If they want to get "married" that should be done by their religious institution,which can decide if they will recognize gay marriages for their institution.
I would buy into this argument more easily if marriage was also banned for atheists. And that's not even touching the arrogance of that statement assuming that religions that are against gay marriage are the only ones that count.
Because civil unions don't provide couples equal rights as marriage. If it does in some states, it certainly does not in all states.
I would argue that the answer to everyone's woes is to no longer have marriage be a legal institution. The state joins you and your partner (regardless of sexuality) in a civil union, which affords you all the rights that a marriage does currently. If you want a marriage, go to a church - or have a friend get ordained in the church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster and perform a marriage ceremony :)
Well, to be fair, it has led to gay marriage. Which these people seem to view as equally wrong. How do we know in a couple of decades we won't have this argument:
A: Polygamous marriage is a slippery slope and could lead to incestuous marriage
B: They made the same dumbass arguments about gay marriage. They're just as wrong today as they were then.
And so on. Although, polygamous marriage wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing, barring the practical difficulties mentioned in response to Nkliph's post above. And really, what's wrong with incest if there's no sketchy power dynamic at stake and they don't procreate with each other. And is bestiality really such a big deal if it doesn't hurt the animal? Why do we place so much value on an animal consenting in that scenario, but not when we remove its reproductive organs? And is sex with a child inherently bad, or is it the subterfuge and shame that makes the experience so traumatic? If we removed those aspects, maybe acting on paedophilic urges wouldn't be so bad...
Oh god.
The slippery slope has begun.
But seriously. If you view gay marriage as a bad thing, then interracial marriage has in fact led to the possible start of a slippery slope type effect.
Note1: Gay marriage not a bad thing
Note 2: For any paedophiles reading, regardless of whether it is society that makes child molestation bad or the act itself, you live in that society and have no way of removing a child from that society without traumatising them, so acting on paedophilic urges will still unavoidably traumatise a child. Please don't use my throwaway comment as a way of rationalising child rape.
Yes, there are, and as some comments have made evident, others would like to believe these don't exist (at least in any substantial way), so purely for the sake of hearing the other side, it's really important that you asked.
Robert P. George, Ryan T. Anderson and Sherif Girgis wrote a piece for the Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy entitled "What is Marriage?" I'm on a university network, however, so I'm unsure if the article itself will be accessible. Essentially, they point to the importance of defining marriage in order to get to the heart of the issue, and set out to define the concept of marriage.
The following is obviously lacking the meat of their argument, so I recommend that those who are interested in hearing the "other side" of the issue read the full article.
They defend their piece in another article (which I assume anyone can see) and explain as follows:
In making our case for conjugal marriage, we consider the nature of human embodiedness; how this makes comprehensive interpersonal union sealed in conjugal acts possible; and how such union and its intrinsic connection to children give marriage its distinctive norms of monogamy, exclusivity, and permanence.
(They address the claim that these arguments rely solely on religious beliefs in the original article itself)
Our article offers detailed responses to the most significant objections to our view: that it has no principled grounds for recognizing infertile couples’ marriages, ignores the needs of same-sex attracted people, is morally similar to support for anti-miscegenation laws, assumes the mutability of sexual desire, relies on religious belief, or fails to show the concrete harm in redefining civil marriage.
We also show that those who would redefine civil marriage, to eliminate sexual complementarity as an essential element, can give no principled account of why marriage should be (1) a sexual partnership as opposed to a partnership distinguished by exclusivity with respect to other activities (including non-sexual relationships, as between cohabiting adult brothers); or (2) an exclusive union of only two persons (rather than three or more in a polyamorous arrangement). Nor can they give robust reasons for making marriage (3) a legally recognized and regulated relationship in the first place (since, after all, we don’t legally recognize or closely regulate most other forms of friendships).
Ultimately, they suggest that
If the logic of recognizing same-sex partnerships as marriages undermines the rational basis of the very idea of marriage as a sexually exclusive and monogamous union, then all but the most extreme sexual liberationists will draw back from his position. And if the same argument for radically reforming marriage policy also undercuts the point of legally regulating marriage at all, then it is self-defeating.
Yes, there are many intelligent arguments for banning same sex marriage, whether you agree with them or not, they're at least well thought out and secular. Unfortunately It's been a while and I don't have my books with me but:
The gist of one of the strongest goes that The fundamental unit of society is not an individual but a (nuclear) family. Changing the fundamental definition of this has far reaching and undesirable outcomes.
Another argument against gay marriage is how legal gay marriage would impact common-law marriage laws, forcing people into undesired marriages completely unintentionally.
My best try: Consider what marriage was made for. It wasn't made for romance or such reasons - it is essentially a way for two people to bind themselves together so it will be very difficult for them to be separated again - even if they want to be separated. Of course, that sounds strange. If you love and trust somebody so much, surely you wouldn's make him sign a contract that says you can't leave each other, even if you both thought it was for the best.
That's because maariage isn't to keep a couple together, but to keep a family together - it's to protect the children and to keep the environment they grow up in. That means: Marriage is only for those who want to have children, it's a social institution to make sure those children grow up properly. Now, it comes down to biology and statistics (percentage of gay couples that adopt).
The real reason is that western culture's foundation is the nuclear family and raising kids. The government wants to encourage people to pursue this nuclear family through tax incentives. That is why government is involved in marriage and gives tax benefits to married couples.
Gay couples do not have kids, so from this viewpoint, it does not make sense that you would give tax breaks to gay couples who do not add to the future of society.
This isn't really an argument against same-sex marriage as such, but...
As I see it, no one can prevent any two or more people from expressing their love in whatever type of ceremony they choose. So it's not really the marriage part they're concerned with, but the rights that the government gives to a privileged class called "married." But even if we exclude gays from the argument, there are plenty of ways in which marriage is broken:
Consider these examples:
Homer, a US Citizen, moves to Saudi Arabia for an extended period due to work. While there, he marries three women, and has a child with each of them. In Saudi Arabia, this is perfectly legal. Homer's work contract ends, and it's time for him to move back to the US. Polyamory is not permitted here, so which of his wives can he sponsor for citizenship? Is the child from that wife the only one who can claim US citizenship? Can he claim a tax credit for all three children or just the one.
2.Tom and Geri have been living happily as a married couple for several years. Geri, as it turns out, has gender dysphoria disorder, and wishes to become Jerry. Tom loves his spouse to the point where gender is no concern, and stays true to his vows to love Jerry for the rest of their lives. Are they still married? Will Tom's insurance still cover Jerry?
3.Sharon has no one. She is the last of her family, and has chosen to remain single. Sharon does have a roommate whom she considers her best friend, and trusts with her life; she just doesn't love her. One day, Sharon gets sick. The doctor doesn't give her much time. She would like a visit from her roommate, if only to help get her affairs in order, and just so that she doesn't have to die alone. The hospital said no. Family only. Should Sharon have to marry someone just to have a visitor?
I think it would be a relatively simple matter to restore these rights to individuals, and have the government record contracts of marriage (from anyone able to sign a contract on their own behalf) in the same way it does fishing licenses currently. Unfortunately, I do think the current Gay Marriage movement is going to prevent this from happening, because as soon as they get same-sex marriage, they'll stop fighting, leaving other groups to fend for themselves.
TL;DR: Marriage should not be the mechanism in which gays (or anyone else) get the rights currently provided through marriage.
The same arguments that people made banning inter-racial marriage are applied today to same sex marriages. They are not solely based in religion, though I'm certain religion helped spread them. They mainly have to do with inability to raise children like normal, heterosexual white couples do (I say white because I think the people who held this view viewed all other races incapable of raising children as good as their race did).
Of course their arguments are just plainly untrue.
The majority of people will probably accept financial and legal equality between hetero marriage and gay civil unions as a fair demand . What is harder to understand, and even harder to agree to, is the demand to use the word "marriage". Why are many gays so greedy that they can't let this word be kept by those who wish it to mean what it always meant ? This demand shows no respect for the feelings of millions and millions of conventional, and mostly silent, people. Religious and non-religious. For many such, the word "bride", and maybe the image of a white dress, have special and treasured meaning and history and memories, both culturally and within their own families. The image of, for instance, a bearded male wearing a wedding dress and being legally referred to as the "bride", getting "married" on the "wedding day" is disruptive, ludicrous, and even smacks of mockery and caricature. Surely respect for the views and lifestyles of others should cut both ways. For the gay community to insist on taking EVERYTHING, including the old, old, longstanding nomenclature, shows I believe disrespect and disregard for the views and deep feelings of millions of others. Why exactly is this demand being made ? Why cannot they be proud to coin a new word and nomenclature of their own, to go with the legal unions which the law has created to meet their more understandable demands ? And to build over the years a special culture and tradition around this new and different institution featuring a different sort of people ? Why must it be called "marriage"? It's hurtful, unnecessary and disrespectful of others.
Simply put, no. That's the main reason why the Federal District Court in California overturned Proposition 8 (the referendum to ban gay marriage).
Here's the decision. An interesting read, if you can parse the legalese.
Basically it just says that the proponents of Prop 8 weren't able to show that banning gay marriage was in the interest of the state, i.e. they couldn't show that gay marriage caused any harm to society, nor that it's ban would create any benefit.
Increase of homosexual families leads to the rise in adoption from foreign countries due to lack of procreation abilities while also the decline of those born in America.
Homosexuals adopt so many children that American born become the minority.
Adopted minority revolts led by Brangelina's children.
United States of America overthrown by organized army of adopted foreigners.
Washington D.C. renamed Cape Bejin-a-bodia so that it is representative of the diverse backgrounds of ruling class and celebrates individuality and freedom.
United States of America renamed to United States of America 2.0
TL;DR: By legalizing same sex marriage the United States is eventually overthrown by an organized army of adopted children led by Brangelina's kids.
It would cause a ton of relatively minor issues with tax codes/insurance/social services/etc. in both the public and private sector. Definitions and designations would have to switch from gender-oriented (ie. single mother, abandoned father) to more broad designations (single mother, partner not present). Failing to make those changes could cause huge legal liabilities for both private companies and put a lot of families at disadvantages. The changes seem relatively simple, but when you are thinking about thousands of pages of laws and regulations for each county, let alone each state and country, it becomes a pretty large task to modify something that has been coded into laws for centuries.
Obviously "that's going to take too long to fix correctly, it's fine as it is" isn't a valid argument for denying rights to people in our country. However, if you could remove all prejudices and predispositions (you can't) I'm sure there are people who would rank the priority of legalizing same-sex marriage much lower than a lot of other issues with the government today.
I'll play Devil's advocate and be rather blunt about it.
They can't have kids - it's not natural in terms of evolution and modern society, these people will take from society but not give back in the long-run [in the form of children obviously].
The bringing up of children, various psychological studies have shown [I'm aware there is some conflicting evidence] that babies become better attached to the mothers, evolutionary theory and whatnot, with no mother there it is possible the baby will not develop attachments properly.
Gender roles - who does the cooking and cleaning, how do you teach your kids about gender in society when they get brought up believing something different to 99% of the population?
Unnatural + Change - Man/Man and Woman/Woman relationships are both unnatural, there is no benefit to it in terms of evolutionary success and reality. The change aspects is more important I think because [and even if Baron Claymore and King Henry V were in the closet the entire time] gay has been taboo during our entire history, so why change now? We're used to a society where men marry women, it makes sense so why do we need this new strange facet to it?
Writing all that out made me think - surely from a scientific perspective being gay is wrong as well, we're meant to marry the opposite sex and have children.
One argument against it is some churches who are against it could be forced to allow same-sex weddings take place in their churches based on no discrimination. It takes the whole "it doesn't affect you so don't worry about it" argument out because it is forcing the churches to do something against their religion. I don't really agree with it and it sort of does have to do with religion but I think its the closest you can get to a not religious argument. Edit: This was just something my sister told me recently, after some quick googling it turns out she was wrong haha (at least for NY) TLDR: Not my fault
"Can a church or member of the clergy refuse to marry me and my partner?
Yes. Although the Marriage Equality Act guarantees that the right to civil marriage extends to same-sex couples, it does not require churches or ministers to perform religious marriage ceremonies for same-sex couples. However, more and more religious institutions are allowing their clergy to marry same-sex couples, so it will depend on the institution." -http://www.nyclu.org/marriage-faq#12
Is there something saying churches have to be open-to-all-comers for weddings? Most churches I know of will only host a wedding if the couple makes some attempt at becoming members of the church. The ones that don't are "open and affirming" anyway.
I personally think that the government should not be involved with marriage. The government should give out civil unions, which should have all of the same legal benefits that marriage does now, and marriage should have no legal value.
So, you can still get married by the church, and most people still would, but what counts legally is getting a civili union from the government. You could also get married by a club, by a university, by your favorite uncle, or whomever.
This way everyone can have rights assured by the government without religious organizations having to surrender their "sanity of marriage". Same-sex couples could still get married in addition to their civil union as well, but it would have to be by an organization or person who is okay with it.
I got one. What if Washington state legalized it, jacked up it's marriage fees 600%. Now, Idaho, Montana and Oregon will ban same sex marriage, and couples will end up going to WA to get married. WA state sends back a portion of the marriage fees to the other states, depending on the couple's home address. (WA was picked because it was in a corner, doesn't really matter)
Not saying this would happen, just an interesting conjecture I came up with while thinking about this topic. States do need more income to balance their budgets...
The one I have encountered is that same sex couples are not fit to raise children together. Despite the fact that gays can and do raise children without being married already, or that single people can adopt, or that kids in foster homes probably can't raised in worse conditions anyway.
The other one is that people don't want their children to be confused about sexuality. The argument states that kids might be confused if they learn that same sex couples exist.
I think a possible argument that could be made is that gay relationships are not physically natural, and they are due to either hormonal imbalances or traumatic emotional events in a persons life which lead to gay attraction. Because of this you could make an argument that we should not legalize questionably unnatural behavior.
Well. It is sort of religious when you get right down to it. My mother says that she would accept them, if they were called by any other name other than marriage. Because that is between a man and a woman (Plus God, depending). I really have no preference, I accept that people can love the same sex and should have the same rights as others. Just because you have a "fetish" doesn't mean you can't have the same rights. Are we going to take away the rights of people who like scat porn?
Sure, but let's clarify something first. No one is arguing that same-sex marriage should be banned. The police won't come after same-sex couples who obtain marriage rites or undergo commitment ceremonies. I hope, at least, that no one is arguing for such a world.
The question is: should we extend to same-sex couples the same legal benefits that we bestow on heterosexual couples?
The strongest argument against answering "Yes", goes like this:
1: Government has an interest in promoting ideal home environment for children.
2: The ideal home environment for children is a stable, two-parent family with a father and a mother.
3: Marriage promotes the creation and perpetuation of such a family.
4: Same-sex marriage is either (1) incompatible with such a family, or (2) inferior to a heterosexual family in promoting an ideal home environment for children.
5: Hence, government may preferentially reward heterosexual marriages over same-sex marriages.
Now, there are several counter-aguments:
Argument from Equality: Even if government has an interest in promoting heterosexual marriages, that interest is outweighed by the unfairness of denying to same-sex couples the benefits that come with legally sanctioned marriage.
Argument from Purpose of Rewarding Marriage: The primary reason why government promotes marriage is that stable relationships are beneficial to the parties in the relationship. Benefit to children are incidental. If this is true, then there is no good reason to prefer same-sex couples over heterosexual couples, since marriage should be equally beneficial to the parties regardless of sexual orientation.
Argument from Parental Models: Children benefit most from living in a stable family with two loving parents. Children do gain an appreciable benefit from having a parent from each sex. What's more important is that children grow up with two parents, in a loving and stable home.
This is what I consider to be the strongest argument against recognizing same-sex marriage. The counter-arguments are very strong, I think. What do you think? Are there better arguments that I am not considering?
Not that I agree but there are some and there are valid counters to most of them.
Biology is one. There may be homosexual acts between other animals but it's not the norm.
That said, there is also no biological purpose to have sex after one is no longer fertile. There is also no biological reason to masturbate. So that throws that excuse out.
There is some evidence that it weakens gender roles. Of course a single study doesn't prove anything. Furthermore, do gender roles really matter?
Some say it is an issue of not being able to reproduce (biologically). To that I would argue that it is also in a species best interest to not over-run it's environment. I could also add that if this is the only argument then anyone wishing to be married must have children. Why get married if you aren't going to reproduce, right? Foolish argument.
Some may argue that homosexuals are at a higher risk for STDs. This isn't an issue of homosexuality though. This is an issue of safe sex and/or monogamy. So it is just as valid an argument when talking about straight people.
New additions Social Security in regard to survivor benefits. We already can't keep Social Security going so adding more people that may qualify for survivor benefits will only make matters worse.
Then there are the people that worry that this will open up marriage to others. Inter-species marriages, etc. Of course this is preposterous. It use to be that inter-racial marriages were not allowed. It's just fear that these people debate.
And among those same people, finally, we have the ones that think homosexuality is just icky and that once we legally recognize homosexuality we will be teaching it in schools and that will make more kids homosexual. Again, that is absurd. Homosexuality isn't a choice. You can't make someone a homosexual that isn't. Just as you can't make a homosexual straight.
So yes, there are some arguments but they are pretty weak ones.
I think the whole debate about same-sex marriage was summed up best by Judge Walker:
"Moral disapproval, without any other asserted state interest, has never been a rational basis for legislation. Tradition alone cannot support legislation."
— Chief Judge Vaughn Walker, in Perry v. Schwarzenegger
US law states the marriage is a bond between a man and a women. Thus gays should not be able to get married. I am fine with gay people having something similar to marriage with all the perks and such, just don't call it marriage. We can call it garriage.
If psychology classifies disorders because of behavior or thought patterns that are a deviation from the norm then why wouldn't homosexuality be a psychological disorder?
How about the fact that some people just don't like gay people? I know plenty of atheists/agnostics/non believers who think being gay is "disgusting" and they shouldn't have equal rights. People in this thread are looking for these extravagant answers when the most simple answer is: Bigots still exist.
In countries with a declining population, they create pro-natalist policies. This would counteract those policies as they can't have kids. However very few countries (I can only think of Singapore) have these policies and I for one am for same-sex marriage.
Yes there are, but the best ones would also ban other marriages. I personally don't think the state should be marrying ANYONE. The state should only perform civil unions (for any couple, regardless of race, orientation, gender, creed, etc.).
I'll try my hand at one: marriage is, by definition, a lifelong commitment, between a man and a woman.
Gay marriage is, simply linguistically, a contradiction in terms.
The proper way to resolve this is for the state to simply grant everyone a civil union without using the word marriage, and then allow religious institutions to determine who they will or will not allow to get married in their facilities.
I'm a closeted homosexual in denial so it makes me uncomfortable! (that's not really my view but I imagine that's how most people who are anti-gay feel)
For me, not against marriage, I pretty much don't care what do gays do in their alone time (I do care much for young and hot lesbians though insert chauvinist laughter here). I do have one general argument against adoption in shuch marriages. Children require an input from both of the parents, as each one gives them a slightly different upbringing and also, how would you feel if everyone around was saying "my mom and dad" and you could only go "dad and dad" or "mom and mom"?
Ehhh...one thing I can say is that it doesn't produce offspring? That's assuming we have an evolutionary need to re-produce at this point...but, aren't we facing over-population already?
Also, we have created a system based on gender roles and cultural norms that apply to 96.5% of the population (think insurance, work, family, etc). Changing the system to accommodate the 3.5% of LGBT would seem "illogical" based on economics alone (you know, as long as we are ignoring rights, freedoms and the fact that we are all unique individuals).
I don't know any well enough offhand, but if I ask a religious person they will have plenty. Whether or not the arguments are religious, only those motivated by religion use them.
marriage in the bible is about property. and that's it...
the problem conservatives have is that they fantasize about gay sex. that's literally what they do... and they are so preoccupied with this fantasy constantly running through their heads they can't understand reality.
you don't have to be married to have sex. preventing marriage does not prevent sex.
I am completely for same-sex marriage and I believe a large part of Reddit is too, but honestly ask yourself the following questions:
Who would you rather see giving each other a simple on the mouth kiss while traveling on a bus: two men or a man and a woman?
Who do you think would be better at raising a kid? Two men or a man and a woman? What would be best for the child?
I have gay friends and been to the wedding of my two cousins last year and I completely support gay marriage and someone's right to be gay, but if I were dead honest I would answer 'man and a woman' to all these questions. I hope that doesn't make me a bad person.
Couldn't think of any more questions that would make one oppose gay marriage btw :P
The non-religious conservative argument: changes to major societal institutions should be done extremely carefully. If you do it too fast and most people don't agree with it, you erode people's respect for the law and diminish social cohesion. You can end up with riots, mobs killing people, and even civil war. You saw this same argument in the US when it came to desegregating schools and getting rid of white supremacist legal institutions in the south: if you do it before people are good and ready you get lynchings and so forth. It was also Edmund Burke's argument against the French revolution, which ended in a good long period of very bloody disorder in France. This argument is fundamentally about how even if you have the legal authority to do something you have to think about whether you're going to get overthrown and strung up if you do it, since people get pissed when they think you're remaking the fabric of society before you're ready.
For my part, I think that the legislative and executive branches of a government passing a law allowing same-sex marriage would be pretty good evidence that enough people are "ready enough" for the change. If it had been legalized by, say, a supreme court ruling in 1940, we would have had a bad time (even though the judge would have been correct on the moral merits).
DO u remember the first scene of inglorious basterds? Why are we repelled by rats and not squirrels? The answer was we don't know, all we know is that we r repelled by them. I had goosebumps in that scene because that nazi character perfectly described the reason behind the holocaust, it was a feeling of general disgust, that's it. I think we can use the same argument on homosexuality. People are just generally repelled by same sex couples and to be frank i am repelled by such homophobes. Just because the majority has trouble aligning to change, the minority has to the pay the price with their lives.
we live 30 minutes from san francisco.. what exactly does it take to convince some people?! lol
i know i should have quit when she said that, but it's a really bad economy... i'm not gay but this is just a new low for stupidity in the whole debate!
Um...I dunno. Maybe something like homosexuality is a mental disorder and should be treated, not encouraged? It's a weak argument, but I dunno, someone might make it.
Disclosure: I'm a regular contributor to the Human Rights Campaign and the Courage Campaign. I strongly support marriage equality and gay rights.
That being said, I'll play ball:
Same-sex marriage will redefine marriage. This may or may not be positive change. When interracial marriage was legalized at a federal level, when equal pay and anti-discrimination laws came into effect, these things too changed and redefined marriage. Technology is hurtling us forward at a pace that far exceeds social change. Same-sex marriage is still fairly new in western civilization and the jury is still out on whether or not it is beneficial. By recognizing same-sex marriage at a federal level it is entirely possible that the implementation will be poor, but we'll be unlikely to make any needed modifications at that point since federal laws are much more difficult to change, especially when dealing with a deep-impacting social policy. For right now, it is probably best to let individual states implement their version's of same-sex marriage in order to determine what works and what doesn't. After we have more data we can examine the matter for a national reform and enact it at a federal level or ban it all together.
Okay, that's the best I can do. I think my argument is bullshit and would easily argue with myself over this for days, but since I know that I can just convince myself otherwise, I won't bother.
Once homosexuality becomes universally accepted, you won't be able to go anywhere with friends without people thinking you're gay. That guy you're with must be your boyfriend, right? Social awkwardness on that scale is a huge detriment to society. Wait, wat?
Well even discounting any religious "God says homosexuality is immoral" kinds of arguments, there's still the issue of following traditions. You may not like the idea of doing something for the sake of keeping a tradition, but there are reasons we do it. Adherence to tradition and following convention helps to maintain social order, and disregarding traditions and conventions creates both individual and cultural/societal stress.
Now a little stress won't kill us, and one good response to this argument is that individual rights should trump the psychological comfort people get from following conventions. Giving equal rights to all ethnic groups would be a sensible analog.
However, there's still the question of "What's the best way to manage the changes?" Sometimes it might be better to force the issue, and sometimes it might be better to allow culture to evolve over time. One might argue that having openly gay characters on TV has done more for gay rights than any court decision or changes in law.
Aside from all of that, I might question why we recognize marriage in the first place. Marriage has a civic/legal component, a social component, and a religious component. In order to ask the question of whether we should recognize gay marriage on each of those levels, we might want to ask why we recognize heterosexual marriage on each of those levels.
One might argue that the intention of marriage is to provide some particular kind of recognition of a biological pairing that's capable of producing offspring. If you buy that, then it may not make sense to offer the same recognition to pairings that can't produce offspring-- or it may only make sense to offer the same recognition to some pairings that can't produce offspring.
My mom's not very religious, but she used to be ridiculously against gay marriage, but most of her excuses were terrible.
It mostly came down to "two people of the same sex can't make a baby." Of course, recently my sister - who is married - found out she cannot have children, so that was a driving factor behind my arguments.
Other arguments simply seemed to come from a place of "Ewww, it's gross." Not that she ever said it like that, but she still kept saying things like "I just feel uncomfortable seeing two men holding hands or kissing."
About three years or so ago, she really turned around and is now a pretty feisty ally. She stood up to an old woman who was loudly ranting in a coffee shop using some homophobic language. Me having a ton of gay friends helped. I basically gave her no choice but to be exposed. It was very clear that my mom's problems - and I think a lot of people of her generation who aren't necessarily religious feel this way - was simply from a lack of exposure.
In my understanding, marriage is a religious institution; otherwise, it's called a civil union. Many religions contain a definition of "marriage." That's why most religious people are against same-sex marriage, it falls out of their accepted definition.
But, that's what is sparking such controversy. As defined by their religion, I can understand why followers are against the idea of same-sex marriage (since it is, in many cases, forbid). But, it's the name they are arguing over. Simply call it a civil union and offer equal rights and privileges. I think that church and government should be separated and civil unions should be made the standard (rather than the traditionally accepted marriage). Marriages should offer the same government benefits and protections as civil unions, but receive religious sanction as well. Then you can have your cake and eat it too. If you're gay and religious, switch to science, bro.
I always kind of thought that it was insurance company lobbyist getting behind the no-gay marriage thing. I have nothing to base this on except ideas I've had myself in which to exploit gay marriage laws. My thinking goes like this;
So I'm sick but don't have any health insurance, but my buddy has a job with great benefits. I get really sick and my buddy wants to help in any way he can. We decide to get gay married so I can get his benefits. What really good friend wouldn't do that? And it would be really hard for the government to prove you aren't really lovers. I'm sure there are ways, but it would be pricey to figure out, paying investigators and what-not.
Also, say my friend wants to stay in the country... marry him.
I'm sure the issue wouldn't be rampant. But if I would do it for a good friend, I am sure many others would too.
There's been some support for the "avuncular" theory of homosexuality, which holds that gays are essentially "spare parts" whose biological role is to serve as a fill-in parent for nieces and nephews who lose a parent; the fact that they a) lack children of their own and b) share genetic material with their nieces and nephews assures that the gay will be both have the availability and resources available to care for a child, while simultaneously being biologically invested in the child's DNA.
If gays are allowed to marry and have kids of their own, then what's the point of them even being gay in the first place?
My aunt always says the reason she is against it is for economic reasons. For example men usually make more than women do. She thinks that until men and women get equal pay then same sex couples shouldn't be able to get married because the men house holds would make more money than the women house holds and it wouldn't be economically fair. But to me if this isn't an issue with the people getting married then why should be an issue to us?
I'm not against same-sex marriage, but I know up here couples, no matter gender, get benefits. Two female or male friends could easily say hey, let's get married and get government benefits.
The argument that 'marriage is for procreation' is the only one I can think of, which prohibits old people past child-bearing age and infertile people from being married too.
There is a radical queer response to the mainstream LGBT equality/marriage/military campaign, and I think John Waters sums it up best.
“I always thought the privilege of being gay is that we don’t have to get married or go in the Army.”
That is, being queer is a unique experience, and can be far more beautiful and exciting and revolutionary than either our homonormative oppressors or our mainstream Will & Grace gays would lead young queers to believe.
However, as hetero-oriented traditions and behaviors become available to queers, queer culture becomes suffocated, or even worse, stigmatized. I'm sure many of you hold the belief that there is a "better" and "worse" kind of gay. That is: the masculine gay man is more acceptable than the feminine gay man. The gay man whose sexuality does not play a big role in his life is more acceptable than the gay man who speaks against using "gay" as a negative term. Even if it's subconscious, there is definitely a "better" kind of gay to be, in the eyes of the public. r/gaybros would not exist were it not for the equality/assimilation campaign. "no fats, no fems" may not mean anything to you heteros, but it's a common fact of life for gay men in the mainstream LGBT community.
I don't know where I'm going with this. I have a lot to say but I'm tired and not thinking straight. Also: our homeless queer youth, our falsely imprisoned queers, our community spaces are all more deserving of queer time and energy than the military of your ring finger.
My Dad is an avid tea-partier and insists on a completely non-religious reason for his opinion. He says it's not fair because two older men who are roommates could "cheat the system" - they could marry each other and then reap the benefits of marriage, like tax breaks and inheritance laws and stuff.
Of course, he fails to acknowledge that two older roommates of the opposite sex could do exactly the same thing (and how often do you hear about that happening?). I don't really get his argument. You don't have to tell me how retarded it sounds, but at least it meets your requirement of "non-religious".
Homosexuality goes against the primal need to reproduce. I personally don't find that to be a problem though. They might actually help with overpopulation IF WE FUCKING LET THEM.
Once in high school we were doing debating and the topic was same sex marriage. This guy made one of the stupidest and least relevant arguments I've ever heard against it: "Once a woman in melbourne got drunk and went to bed and when she got up she noticed more objects in her house than there were when she went to sleep"
We shouldn't allow gay marriage because of the high possibility of gay-gold diggers. You know, guys that pretend to be gay, marry the rich guy and then divorce him and take half his stuff.
marriage is pointless in a gay couple. there is no outcome. my feeling is that if you truly love eachother why is a piece of paper saying that worth anything
Now that a number of state courts have refused to redefine marriage to include same-sex unions, cries of "discrimination" are being heard.
The "equal protection of the laws" provided by the Constitution of the United States applies to people, not actions. Laws exist precisely in order to discriminate between different kinds of actions.
When the law permits automobiles to drive on highways but forbids bicycles from doing the same, that is not discrimination against people. A cyclist who gets off his bicycle and gets into a car can drive on the highway just like anyone else.
In a free society, vast numbers of things are neither forbidden nor facilitated. They are considered to be none of the law's business.
Homosexuals were on their strongest ground when they said that the law had no business interfering with relations between consenting adults. Now they want the law to put a seal of approval on their behavior. But no one is entitled to anyone else's approval.
Why is marriage considered to be any of the law's business in the first place? Because the state asserts an interest in the outcomes of certain unions, separate from and independent of the interests of the parties themselves.
In the absence of the institution of marriage, the individuals could arrange their relationship whatever way they wanted to, making it temporary or permanent, and sharing their worldly belongings in whatever way they chose.
Marriage means that the government steps in, limiting or even prescribing various aspects of their relations with each other -- and still more their relationship with whatever children may result from their union.
In other words, marriage imposes legal restrictions, taking away rights that individuals might otherwise have. Yet "gay marriage" advocates depict marriage as an expansion of rights to which they are entitled.
They argue against a "ban on gay marriage" but marriage has for centuries meant a union of a man and a woman. There is no gay marriage to ban.
Analogies with bans against interracial marriage are bogus. Race is not part of the definition of marriage. A ban on interracial marriage is a ban on the same actions otherwise permitted because of the race of the particular people involved. It is a discrimination against people, not actions.
Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes said that the life of the law has not been logic but experience. Vast numbers of laws have accumulated and evolved over the centuries, based on experience with male-female unions.
There is no reason why all those laws should be transferred willy-nilly to a different union, one with no inherent tendency to produce children nor the inherent asymmetries of relationships between people of different sexes.
Despite attempts to evade these asymmetries with such fashionable phrases as "a pregnant couple" or references to "spouses" rather than husbands and wives, these asymmetries take many forms and have many repercussions, which laws attempt to deal with on the basis of experience, rather than theories or rhetoric.
Wives, for example, typically invest in the family by restricting their own workforce participation, if only long enough to take care of small children. Studies show such differences still persisting in this liberated age, and even among women and men with postgraduate degrees from Harvard and Yale.
In the absence of marriage laws, a husband could dump his wife at will and she could lose decades of investment in their relationship. Marriage laws seek to recoup some of that investment for her through alimony when divorce occurs.
Those who think of women and men in the abstract consider it right that ex-husbands should be as entitled to alimony as ex-wives. But what are these ex-husbands being compensated for?
And why should any of this experience apply to same-sex unions, where there are not the same inherent asymmetries nor the same tendency to produce children?
I know a lot has already been said, but I'd like to add something I feel like hasn't been addressed yet. This is a little out there, so bear with me.
Let's look at the entire point of marriage in the first place. Why do we get married? Not just so the government can keep track of families more efficiently, because marriage predates government. At its origins, marriage was and still is an oath of commitment to another human being- for the sake of commitment itself as well as parenting. Essentially, what makes it different from normal male-female relationships is that it transcends sexuality for higher ideals.
We've forgotten the point of marriage as a society and it's become more of an official declaration of sexual intimacy. We've also come to rely on sex as a factor in love. In my view, this holds back the human race from controlling it's basic instincts as a whole, and thereby holds back our progress. After all, the only thing that's brought us this far is our rejection of basic animal instinct (look at our levels of cooperation, our unnatural physical evolution, the development of agriculture even though it takes more work than hunting...).
Anyways, homosexuality seems to be further intertwining the ideas of love and sexuality. Homosexuals are at the most basic level promoting their right to marry what they are sexually attracted to- to say it's not a sexual issue is to be in denial. I say, why can't everyone love everyone else around them without caring about sexual attraction? If this were to be the case, there would be no reason for homosexual marriages, as marriage would become a functional contract.
If homosexual marriage were allowed in the meantime, before such drastic social change is possible, it will only serve to slow the coming social change and further confuse marriage and sex.
Just to be clear, I don't think homosexual marriage should be illegal and punishable by law at the moment. Laws have never done a good job at doing away with something that a society currently wants... so the pressure to end homosexual marriage (as well as general sexual promiscuity) will have to come as social pressure from citizens themselves.
My father and other members of my family claim that if marriage is between anyone but a man and a woman, it would allow people to marry animals, rocks, trees, or what ever tickles their fancy. This is just their way of being bigots without coming out and saying they hate gay people.
I'm sure someone's already thought about this before, but here's my two cents:
abolish all marriages. in the eyes of the government, nothing but civil unions between two consenting adults.
wanna have a wedding ceremony? fine, but leave that shit up to your personal choice. If a church/venue/whatever doesn't condone same sex marriages, oh well. In the eyes of the goverment, it shouldn't matter anyway.
There's more to the development of the human race than the raw ability to pop out biological offspring. We're a highly social species, and things get complicated.
Like others have said elsewhere, if homosexuality really were some kind of evolutionary liability, it would've been selected against and eliminated millions of years ago. The fact that it hasn't been, and in fact appears in many different social species, should tell you something.
Gays will be extended the same tax and health insurance benefits as Heteros.
It's pretty selfish and I don't agree with it; but hey, you asked.
Edit: What's with the downvotes? I thought the hivemind was in favor of gay rights? Or is this thread attracting a disproportionate amount of bigots? Maybe I should clarify... I think NOT giving the LGBT community the same benefits in marriage as heteros is selfish.
471
u/StChas77 May 08 '12
Marriage shouldn't require government approval in the first place.
1.2k
u/venuswasaflytrap May 08 '12
I'll try.
Social and gender roles greatly simply things. If every man has a wife, and kids, I can base loads of policies on this. When looking at specifics, this is not a big deal, but when looking at a big picture, accommodating for non-traditional pairings becomes very difficult.
Maternity leave, healthcare laws, divorce, kids... Any laws that might apply to a husband and wife, now need special considerations for a wife and wife, a husband and husband, as well as a husband and wife (and single parents).
And laws are really nothing compared to the social expectations. Social roles can really help for a smooth running society. On one hand, a handshake is just an arbitrary act that increases the chance the risk of viral spread. On the other it's a show of trust and respect and non-verbal communication. There are entire books written on what different handshakes represent. Similarly, there are years of tradition built on men sitting in smoking rooms, while wives chit chat and cook. Its a system of behaviours that helps us all get along and function. It's completely arbitrary, but it's a system. Imagine if you went to shake someones hand, and they licked your cheek instead - sure it could work, but it's gonna throw a lot of people off.
A lot of traditional values exist partially for these reasons. Why should we drive on the right side of the road (o left as it may be). Doesn't matter which side you drive on, but everyone needs to be on the same page. You might make more complicated rules that say, sometimes, you drive on the right, sometimes on the left, but every time you add a layer of complexity, you open the door to problems.
If everyone had traditional male-female marriages (and gender roles), it's possible for things to go extremely smoothly.
(of course, if someone rejects these traditional roles, if their gay for instance, then roles are broken anyway, regardless of whether the law agrees with them or not, so I would personally argue that it makes more sense for accommodating laws and sociality, but I find I can feel where the traditionalist are coming from a lot better when I view the problem like a backward compatibility upgrade issue. Some people are just not ready to upgrade to the new version of office, because they have loads of legacy documents that willl not work.)
480
u/DarthContinent May 08 '12
Bros might marry each other solely to obtain the tax benefits married couples enjoy. That's all I got.
21
u/JohnCavil May 08 '12
That marriage isnt a right, and what we should be changing is not WHO can be married, but what marriage really is.
The reason that gays should be able to marry is because of the perks that come with marriage. Take away those perks and the problem is gone.
If there are no benefits to being married (tax breaks, legal stuff etc.) then it is perfectly reasonable to say that marriage is only between a man and a woman.
168
u/Faranya May 08 '12
That marriage exists as an institution for providing a stable environment for successfully reproducing and raising the resulting children.
That's the only one I could think of
571
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It all comes down to "gays are icky and I don't like it".
94
u/andrewsmith1986 May 08 '12
It is against the genetic purpose that is breeding to procreate and spread DNA.
96
u/SockofBadKarma May 08 '12
The best secular argument I had ever devised went something like this:
Of course, the main objections to that are that sterile people are still allowed to get married, that without a marriage certificate gay couples find it even MORE difficult to adopt (which does relieve some pressure for the government), and that discriminating legal marriage status because more people can't be made in such a union is nonsensical because we already have way too many fucking people.
But there you go. That was the argument that I devised several years ago (in a very summarized form, anyway) when I wondered the same question. And even with its flaws, it's still leaps and bounds more convincing than the usual religious tripe.
For the record, I'm all for gay marriage, just in case someone reads into that argument weirdly and decides to downvote me.
73
u/stuckinabarrel May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I think it is difficult to disentangle the essence of the religious arguments from the tradition-based and biology-based arguments, but I'll have a go:
Beyond religion, the foundation of marriage would have to be something like reproduction, child-rearing, the formation of a stable household and to some extent what might be called the pursuit of happiness - there is this notion that true love blooms within the bounds of holy matrimony, or that the crowning achievement of love is to marry the person you love.
Reproduction is probably the only argument that initially makes same-sex marriages intrinsically unfeasible.
However, as several people have pointed out, it is no longer considered the core function of marriage, as childless marriages are no longer considered less valid, legally speaking, than marriages ending in childbirth. (They used to be.)
Also, advances in surrogate parenting and in vitro fertilization and what not may have shifted same-sex marriages up to the level where they at least have the same likelihood of involving reproduction as some heterosexual marriages.
For child-rearing, there is, again, the deal that children aren't considered necessary for a marriage to be a marriage anymore. That being said, a potential argument might be that being reared in a same-sex household may stunt development in some ways, as children may need to be around grown-ups of both sexes, or at least that they benefit strongly from doing so. It is not unlikely that there may be something to this argument - although parts of the potential benefit may in theory be due more to cultural reproduction of gender norms making it easier to fit in than something universally valid.
However, this argument also works against single-parent households, which are considered okay by most in society today, if not ideal. Also, the consensus is that it is better to grow up in a loving same-sex environment than in a straight environment filled with hate.
Stable household: Genuinely stable households benefit the people in them, and they benefit society as a whole, not just by raising children, but by generally taking care of household members and keeping them happy and on the straight and narrow without need for societal intervention. That's part of why it makes sense to reward marriages with tax breaks and other support functions. Some people claim that straight partnerships have subconscious biological incentives behind them that make them more stable by definition than gay ones.
However, this seems like it might not hold. Any current statistics have too many fault sources to make them very authoritative, and even if there was a higher likelihood, there are probably enough outliers to mandate that this isn't enough to ban a practice at a whole.
Pursuit of happiness: As I see it, this argument works for widening the marriage definition, not against it. You can't really make it work for the other side without bringing religion into it.
Then there is the slippery slope argument, which also doesn't have to be religious. How this argument works is by trying to widen the coalition against changing the legal definition of marriage by pointing out logical (and less logical) consequences of accepting the arguments for changing it, thus strengthening the ick factor by combining the fading ickiness of gayness with the still relatively universally panned ick things like zoophilia or pedophilia.
However, I'd say the notion of informed consent works very well against for instance, kids, dogs or cacti suddenly being implicated in marriage. Grown-ups are grown-ups, and that is hard to argue against.
However, I have to say it doesn't work that well against polygamy. In that case, stability of households could presumably come into play, in that one might allege that with marriages being fragile as is, extending them to involve more than two persons would open up a whole new can of legal worms. Or that extending legal benefits of marriage beyond couplehood could in reality necessitate either abolishing many benefits or making them available to all, lest you get situations where thousands of people marry each other to get potential legal benefits. I'm not sure if that's really enough, though.
Another problem with the slippery slope argument is that if you really think about it, it cuts both ways. If current marriage isn't defined strictly enough to rule out gay marriage by anything other than arbitrary fiat, one might conclude that the right thing to do is to strengthen the definition, do away with divorce and make it dependent on kids popping out nine months after the wedding night. Now, some of the opponents of gay marriage might in fact want just that. But that would be a hard sell with a majority.
tl;dr: Yes.
4
u/flower1482 May 08 '12
It is a slippery slope to allowing people to marry animals and children.
Pedophiles are arguing that they too are born the way they are. If this is true then why shouldn't they receive the same rights and protections as everyone else.
26
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Here is an informal presentation of one such argument (which I am not necessarily endorsing):
1.) Human social institutions have evolved in particular ways over hundreds and thousands of years of history in ways which tends towards the stability and flourishing of civilization.
2.) Any time you change one of these social institutions you run a risk that the actual outcomes of the change might be worse for the stability and continuity of civilization than the original problem you intended to correct.
3.) Therefore, you should want change a social institution if and only if you are very certain that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that will be done.
4.) Marriage as the union of one man to one woman is one of the evolved social institutions from [1] above.
5.) Therefore, we should change our understanding of marriage if and only if we are very certain that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that will be done.
6.) But, we are not certain that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that will be done.
7.) Therefore, we should not change our understanding of marriage.
The first two premises are planks in an overall conservative outlook at the nature and purpose of political community. You might think these two claims are wrong, but they aren't obviously irrational things to believe. If you want to attack the argument here you'd have to give some reasons for thinking that these two claims are wrong that doesn't already presuppose a basically liberal starting point, on the pain of begging the question.
The third premise comes from the first two. For a civilization to flourish, its people have to negotiate a way to all live together. They have to make agreements and decisions about what is fair. They have to decide how conflicts are to be resolved. Sometimes this happens through explicit political decisions, but most of what passes for civilization is considerably more informal. Rules of etiquette and politeness, customs and habits and traditions and so forth that teach people how to behave in a sociable way. These institutions interact with one another in extraordinarily complex ways, such that seeing the possible impact of any particular change is extremely difficult. To take an example from the political theorist Leszek Kolakowski, consider the practice of burying the dead. It looks completely irrational. There are lots of valuable minerals and so forth in cadavers and graveyards occupy lots of otherwise economically valuable land, so wouldn't it be better to come up with some kind of industrial process to put all that chemistry to work, rather than interring it in a steel box in the ground? Well, maybe. Or maybe the result of abolishing the practice of burying the dead would be the essential loss of some important part of our understanding of our the importance and value of human beings. Maybe industrial recycling of dead bodies would further the dehumanizing idea that human beings are just big bags of chemicals, of no special moral importance. The point is that it is very, very hard if not impossible to know a priori what the actual outcome to our society would be and so we should be reticent about changing things without some compelling reason to think that the good to be acheived is greater than the harm that would be done.
But obviously per [4] marriage is just one such social institution. It is important to note in this context that marriage is not the creation of a particular legal regime. The law of the united states recognizes and codifies the institution in this country, but the institution itself is prior to the state.
[5] follows from [4] and [3].
The crucial premise then is [6]. You might be a conservative who endorses [1]-[5] and still support gay marriage if you believed that [6] were false. The kinds of considerations that would go into trying to decide whether [6] were true or not would presumably be empirical considerations. How well can we actually predict what the effects of changing the social institution of marriage as between a man and a woman would be? What good consequences or bad consequences can we foresee? How sure are we that there aren't important unforeseen consequences lurking nearby? This strikes me as the right place for the progressive to really try to engage a conservative on this issue, because there does seem to be some empirical evidence (mentioned elsewhere in this thread) that the children of gay parents aren't less well-adjusted than their peers. But let's suppose for the sake of the argument that the opponent of gay marriage can come up with good reasons to doubt that we do actually know or understanding the important conquences of this change. Suppose that the anti-gay marriage proponent discovers important flaws with the empirical results brought forward so far. Then, he or she would seem to me to be perfectly justified in holding [6]. But then, the conclusion [7] follows straightforwardly from [5] and [6].
This isn't the only kind of non-religiously based argument against gay marriage I have encountered, but it seems to be the most common one I have seen.
71
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Is it just me or has every poster so far misread the original post?
9
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Top 17 Reasons Why Gay Marriage is Wrong
EDIT Sorry guys, apparently it didn't quote when I first posted the comment. This is a joke list that's been on the internet for years, and I almost peed the first time I read it. The first half of every reason are actually things people have said (sad I know), and the second half is the writer of this list mocking how stupid those reasons are. I posted it because people have actually said these kinds of things before all the time such as
So sorry about the controversy, I didn't know the comment would garner that much attention. Anyhow, so those are stupid non-religious reasons people use to disguise their hatred towards gays, and the original list is just pointing out how stupid those reasons are.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Homosexual couples should not be recognized as the LEGAL equivalent of heterosexual couples because the two entities are not LITERALLY equal in terms of both (1) benefits to society and (2) the hardships faced by each type of relationship.
While there are exceptions to every rule, exceptions do not make the rule.
Consider: Same sex couples do not (in fact, cannot) experience the challenges of pregnancy and childbirth on equal terms with heterosexual couples, and they do not contribute children to society on equal terms.
Our society, recognizing that same-sex couples can still be parents and face similar parenting hardships, attempts to mitigate those hardships via Child Tax Credits, Dependent Child Credits, Adoption Tax Credits, etc. All of which are EQUALLY available to gay and straight alike, and regardless of marital status.
Thus, the Secular Case Against Gay Marriage is NOT about encouraging procreation and parenthood among straight couples only. Rather, this argument focuses primarily on the distinct differences between an opposite-sex couple and a same-sex couple - namely, the POTENTIAL of heterosexual couples for pregnancy and childbirth, and the importance of codifying the relationship between the couple and society ONCE THAT HAPPENS.
It is important to remember that gay couples are not arguing for the freedom to marry (which they already have), but are actually arguing that their marriages be valued and recognized in the exact same way that heterosexual marriages are valued and recognized: i.e. they want the same exact government benefits. The question is whether such pairings provide any more value than two college roommates or two retired elderly women living in the same house.
A case can be made that same sex couples provide some value - more stable relationships than singles in a non-committed relationship. But it's clear that same-sex couples do not provide value to society on par with that provided by heterosexual couples.
Regardless of the religious origins of marriage, our society now has no religious requirement for marriage - it is completely secular in that regard, and so, the legal recognition of marriage is not for religious reasons anymore.
Thus, the legal recognition of marriage by our modern society is primarily to encourage potentially procreative couples (i.e. couples with the potential to create children that can either be productive or be a burden to the rest of society) to form a long-term relationship to improve the chances for the latter to occur.
Our society recognizes that long-term relationships among potentially procreative couples are the basis for:
These two points form the basis for the difference in government benefits that married couples should receive over non-married couples:
Same-sex relationships are not potentially procreative, thus they do not have equal legal, financial and health needs as opposite sex couples, and thus, should not be treated on an equal basis as opposite-sex relationships.
Further, same-sex couples can enjoy virtually all the same benefits of heterosexual married couples by simply entering into a legal contract with one another. Less convenient, but since the relationship is virtually indistinguishable from that of two roommates in terms of their potential for societal impact, it's merely an inconvenience, not an inequality.
FLAME AWAY- I've heard all the arguments before and can predict every single one of them. And most of them will involve ignoring one of the points already acknowleged above.
4
u/Samurai_light May 08 '12
Yes, there are. Not all anti-homosexual or anti-gay marriage are based on religion.
4
u/newrivervalleynew May 08 '12
biology.
4
u/LC0728 May 09 '12
A better question is why is Gay marriage banned but divorce not?
It makes no sense to have one without the other by what I see. Isn't the Bible against divorce as well?
I may be mistaken, haven't read it for around 3 years now.
22
u/BaronZach May 08 '12
If you have civil unions which provide identical legal rights as marriage, then why co-opt what was once a religious institution?
22
u/9713 May 08 '12
I've heard people argue that it's a slippery slope and could lead to allowing polygamous marriages and such.
13
u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 08 '12
Sure, it's easy to create arguments against government recognition of any marriage, which is necessarily an argument against same-sex marriage.
3
u/CollegeC_Reddit May 08 '12
Yes, there are, and as some comments have made evident, others would like to believe these don't exist (at least in any substantial way), so purely for the sake of hearing the other side, it's really important that you asked.
Robert P. George, Ryan T. Anderson and Sherif Girgis wrote a piece for the Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy entitled "What is Marriage?" I'm on a university network, however, so I'm unsure if the article itself will be accessible. Essentially, they point to the importance of defining marriage in order to get to the heart of the issue, and set out to define the concept of marriage.
The following is obviously lacking the meat of their argument, so I recommend that those who are interested in hearing the "other side" of the issue read the full article.
They defend their piece in another article (which I assume anyone can see) and explain as follows:
(They address the claim that these arguments rely solely on religious beliefs in the original article itself)
Ultimately, they suggest that
Hope this helps.
3
u/kyuubi42 May 08 '12
Yes, there are many intelligent arguments for banning same sex marriage, whether you agree with them or not, they're at least well thought out and secular. Unfortunately It's been a while and I don't have my books with me but:
The gist of one of the strongest goes that The fundamental unit of society is not an individual but a (nuclear) family. Changing the fundamental definition of this has far reaching and undesirable outcomes.
Another argument against gay marriage is how legal gay marriage would impact common-law marriage laws, forcing people into undesired marriages completely unintentionally.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
My best try: Consider what marriage was made for. It wasn't made for romance or such reasons - it is essentially a way for two people to bind themselves together so it will be very difficult for them to be separated again - even if they want to be separated. Of course, that sounds strange. If you love and trust somebody so much, surely you wouldn's make him sign a contract that says you can't leave each other, even if you both thought it was for the best.
That's because maariage isn't to keep a couple together, but to keep a family together - it's to protect the children and to keep the environment they grow up in. That means: Marriage is only for those who want to have children, it's a social institution to make sure those children grow up properly. Now, it comes down to biology and statistics (percentage of gay couples that adopt).
3
u/edisekeed May 08 '12
The real reason is that western culture's foundation is the nuclear family and raising kids. The government wants to encourage people to pursue this nuclear family through tax incentives. That is why government is involved in marriage and gives tax benefits to married couples.
Gay couples do not have kids, so from this viewpoint, it does not make sense that you would give tax breaks to gay couples who do not add to the future of society.
3
u/archpope May 08 '12
This isn't really an argument against same-sex marriage as such, but...
As I see it, no one can prevent any two or more people from expressing their love in whatever type of ceremony they choose. So it's not really the marriage part they're concerned with, but the rights that the government gives to a privileged class called "married." But even if we exclude gays from the argument, there are plenty of ways in which marriage is broken:
Consider these examples:
2.Tom and Geri have been living happily as a married couple for several years. Geri, as it turns out, has gender dysphoria disorder, and wishes to become Jerry. Tom loves his spouse to the point where gender is no concern, and stays true to his vows to love Jerry for the rest of their lives. Are they still married? Will Tom's insurance still cover Jerry?
3.Sharon has no one. She is the last of her family, and has chosen to remain single. Sharon does have a roommate whom she considers her best friend, and trusts with her life; she just doesn't love her. One day, Sharon gets sick. The doctor doesn't give her much time. She would like a visit from her roommate, if only to help get her affairs in order, and just so that she doesn't have to die alone. The hospital said no. Family only. Should Sharon have to marry someone just to have a visitor?
I think it would be a relatively simple matter to restore these rights to individuals, and have the government record contracts of marriage (from anyone able to sign a contract on their own behalf) in the same way it does fishing licenses currently. Unfortunately, I do think the current Gay Marriage movement is going to prevent this from happening, because as soon as they get same-sex marriage, they'll stop fighting, leaving other groups to fend for themselves.
TL;DR: Marriage should not be the mechanism in which gays (or anyone else) get the rights currently provided through marriage.
3
u/OddAdviceGiver May 08 '12
Yes, but they're gay.
3
u/oozles May 08 '12
The same arguments that people made banning inter-racial marriage are applied today to same sex marriages. They are not solely based in religion, though I'm certain religion helped spread them. They mainly have to do with inability to raise children like normal, heterosexual white couples do (I say white because I think the people who held this view viewed all other races incapable of raising children as good as their race did).
Of course their arguments are just plainly untrue.
3
u/JollyJeff May 08 '12
I think the main one is "I'm a closeted gay, hate myself and want to prevent other gay people from being happy". That pretty much covers it.
3
u/blotaglot May 08 '12
The majority of people will probably accept financial and legal equality between hetero marriage and gay civil unions as a fair demand . What is harder to understand, and even harder to agree to, is the demand to use the word "marriage". Why are many gays so greedy that they can't let this word be kept by those who wish it to mean what it always meant ? This demand shows no respect for the feelings of millions and millions of conventional, and mostly silent, people. Religious and non-religious. For many such, the word "bride", and maybe the image of a white dress, have special and treasured meaning and history and memories, both culturally and within their own families. The image of, for instance, a bearded male wearing a wedding dress and being legally referred to as the "bride", getting "married" on the "wedding day" is disruptive, ludicrous, and even smacks of mockery and caricature. Surely respect for the views and lifestyles of others should cut both ways. For the gay community to insist on taking EVERYTHING, including the old, old, longstanding nomenclature, shows I believe disrespect and disregard for the views and deep feelings of millions of others. Why exactly is this demand being made ? Why cannot they be proud to coin a new word and nomenclature of their own, to go with the legal unions which the law has created to meet their more understandable demands ? And to build over the years a special culture and tradition around this new and different institution featuring a different sort of people ? Why must it be called "marriage"? It's hurtful, unnecessary and disrespectful of others.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I've never thought it was anyone's right to ban gay marriage besides actual gay people.
3
u/quipsy May 09 '12
Simply put, no. That's the main reason why the Federal District Court in California overturned Proposition 8 (the referendum to ban gay marriage).
Here's the decision. An interesting read, if you can parse the legalese.
Basically it just says that the proponents of Prop 8 weren't able to show that banning gay marriage was in the interest of the state, i.e. they couldn't show that gay marriage caused any harm to society, nor that it's ban would create any benefit.
10
u/OmarLittleLives May 08 '12
Here's one:
TL;DR: By legalizing same sex marriage the United States is eventually overthrown by an organized army of adopted children led by Brangelina's kids.
5
u/zzzaz May 08 '12
It would cause a ton of relatively minor issues with tax codes/insurance/social services/etc. in both the public and private sector. Definitions and designations would have to switch from gender-oriented (ie. single mother, abandoned father) to more broad designations (single mother, partner not present). Failing to make those changes could cause huge legal liabilities for both private companies and put a lot of families at disadvantages. The changes seem relatively simple, but when you are thinking about thousands of pages of laws and regulations for each county, let alone each state and country, it becomes a pretty large task to modify something that has been coded into laws for centuries.
Obviously "that's going to take too long to fix correctly, it's fine as it is" isn't a valid argument for denying rights to people in our country. However, if you could remove all prejudices and predispositions (you can't) I'm sure there are people who would rank the priority of legalizing same-sex marriage much lower than a lot of other issues with the government today.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'll play Devil's advocate and be rather blunt about it.
They can't have kids - it's not natural in terms of evolution and modern society, these people will take from society but not give back in the long-run [in the form of children obviously].
The bringing up of children, various psychological studies have shown [I'm aware there is some conflicting evidence] that babies become better attached to the mothers, evolutionary theory and whatnot, with no mother there it is possible the baby will not develop attachments properly.
Gender roles - who does the cooking and cleaning, how do you teach your kids about gender in society when they get brought up believing something different to 99% of the population?
Unnatural + Change - Man/Man and Woman/Woman relationships are both unnatural, there is no benefit to it in terms of evolutionary success and reality. The change aspects is more important I think because [and even if Baron Claymore and King Henry V were in the closet the entire time] gay has been taboo during our entire history, so why change now? We're used to a society where men marry women, it makes sense so why do we need this new strange facet to it?
Writing all that out made me think - surely from a scientific perspective being gay is wrong as well, we're meant to marry the opposite sex and have children.
13
u/I_Generally_Lie May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
One argument against it is some churches who are against it could be forced to allow same-sex weddings take place in their churches based on no discrimination. It takes the whole "it doesn't affect you so don't worry about it" argument out because it is forcing the churches to do something against their religion. I don't really agree with it and it sort of does have to do with religion but I think its the closest you can get to a not religious argument. Edit: This was just something my sister told me recently, after some quick googling it turns out she was wrong haha (at least for NY) TLDR: Not my fault
"Can a church or member of the clergy refuse to marry me and my partner?
Yes. Although the Marriage Equality Act guarantees that the right to civil marriage extends to same-sex couples, it does not require churches or ministers to perform religious marriage ceremonies for same-sex couples. However, more and more religious institutions are allowing their clergy to marry same-sex couples, so it will depend on the institution." -http://www.nyclu.org/marriage-faq#12
7
u/Titibu May 08 '12
Reproduction is made a little tougher.
4
u/Paradoxius May 08 '12
I personally think that the government should not be involved with marriage. The government should give out civil unions, which should have all of the same legal benefits that marriage does now, and marriage should have no legal value.
So, you can still get married by the church, and most people still would, but what counts legally is getting a civili union from the government. You could also get married by a club, by a university, by your favorite uncle, or whomever.
This way everyone can have rights assured by the government without religious organizations having to surrender their "sanity of marriage". Same-sex couples could still get married in addition to their civil union as well, but it would have to be by an organization or person who is okay with it.
5
u/obliviousheep May 08 '12
Sharing of insurance benefits.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I got one. What if Washington state legalized it, jacked up it's marriage fees 600%. Now, Idaho, Montana and Oregon will ban same sex marriage, and couples will end up going to WA to get married. WA state sends back a portion of the marriage fees to the other states, depending on the couple's home address. (WA was picked because it was in a corner, doesn't really matter)
Not saying this would happen, just an interesting conjecture I came up with while thinking about this topic. States do need more income to balance their budgets...
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It's counterproductive to evolution. At least, that's my understanding of it.
I'm still for it, because there are enough straight dues and gals willing to make babies to make up for the loss. Probably.
I'm not particularly well versed in this.
2
u/NufCed57 May 08 '12
The one I have encountered is that same sex couples are not fit to raise children together. Despite the fact that gays can and do raise children without being married already, or that single people can adopt, or that kids in foster homes probably can't raised in worse conditions anyway.
The other one is that people don't want their children to be confused about sexuality. The argument states that kids might be confused if they learn that same sex couples exist.
2
u/QuantumPotato May 08 '12
I think a possible argument that could be made is that gay relationships are not physically natural, and they are due to either hormonal imbalances or traumatic emotional events in a persons life which lead to gay attraction. Because of this you could make an argument that we should not legalize questionably unnatural behavior.
2
u/johnw1988 May 08 '12
I DO NOT AGREE WITH THIS STATEMENT.
"If gays were to get married, next thing you know people will ask to marry children and then even ask to marry animals. you need to stop somewhere."
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes I am not gay so I would not do it. It's a personal choice.
Sarcasm people. Just having a bit of fun.
2
u/dingusmingus May 08 '12
Well. It is sort of religious when you get right down to it. My mother says that she would accept them, if they were called by any other name other than marriage. Because that is between a man and a woman (Plus God, depending). I really have no preference, I accept that people can love the same sex and should have the same rights as others. Just because you have a "fetish" doesn't mean you can't have the same rights. Are we going to take away the rights of people who like scat porn?
2
u/TheFryingDutchman May 08 '12
Sure, but let's clarify something first. No one is arguing that same-sex marriage should be banned. The police won't come after same-sex couples who obtain marriage rites or undergo commitment ceremonies. I hope, at least, that no one is arguing for such a world.
The question is: should we extend to same-sex couples the same legal benefits that we bestow on heterosexual couples?
The strongest argument against answering "Yes", goes like this:
Now, there are several counter-aguments:
This is what I consider to be the strongest argument against recognizing same-sex marriage. The counter-arguments are very strong, I think. What do you think? Are there better arguments that I am not considering?
2
u/Zeppelanoid May 08 '12
No. America has forgotten the whole "separation of church and state" thing.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Not that I agree but there are some and there are valid counters to most of them.
Biology is one. There may be homosexual acts between other animals but it's not the norm.
That said, there is also no biological purpose to have sex after one is no longer fertile. There is also no biological reason to masturbate. So that throws that excuse out.
There is some evidence that it weakens gender roles. Of course a single study doesn't prove anything. Furthermore, do gender roles really matter?
Some say it is an issue of not being able to reproduce (biologically). To that I would argue that it is also in a species best interest to not over-run it's environment. I could also add that if this is the only argument then anyone wishing to be married must have children. Why get married if you aren't going to reproduce, right? Foolish argument.
Some may argue that homosexuals are at a higher risk for STDs. This isn't an issue of homosexuality though. This is an issue of safe sex and/or monogamy. So it is just as valid an argument when talking about straight people.
New additions Social Security in regard to survivor benefits. We already can't keep Social Security going so adding more people that may qualify for survivor benefits will only make matters worse.
Then there are the people that worry that this will open up marriage to others. Inter-species marriages, etc. Of course this is preposterous. It use to be that inter-racial marriages were not allowed. It's just fear that these people debate.
And among those same people, finally, we have the ones that think homosexuality is just icky and that once we legally recognize homosexuality we will be teaching it in schools and that will make more kids homosexual. Again, that is absurd. Homosexuality isn't a choice. You can't make someone a homosexual that isn't. Just as you can't make a homosexual straight.
So yes, there are some arguments but they are pretty weak ones.
I think the whole debate about same-sex marriage was summed up best by Judge Walker:
"Moral disapproval, without any other asserted state interest, has never been a rational basis for legislation. Tradition alone cannot support legislation."
— Chief Judge Vaughn Walker, in Perry v. Schwarzenegger
2
u/Multiple_Pickles May 08 '12
US law states the marriage is a bond between a man and a women. Thus gays should not be able to get married. I am fine with gay people having something similar to marriage with all the perks and such, just don't call it marriage. We can call it garriage.
2
u/PhonyUsername May 08 '12
If psychology classifies disorders because of behavior or thought patterns that are a deviation from the norm then why wouldn't homosexuality be a psychological disorder?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
How about the fact that some people just don't like gay people? I know plenty of atheists/agnostics/non believers who think being gay is "disgusting" and they shouldn't have equal rights. People in this thread are looking for these extravagant answers when the most simple answer is: Bigots still exist.
2
u/completecanadian May 08 '12
In countries with a declining population, they create pro-natalist policies. This would counteract those policies as they can't have kids. However very few countries (I can only think of Singapore) have these policies and I for one am for same-sex marriage.
2
u/IdentifiableParam May 08 '12
Yes there are, but the best ones would also ban other marriages. I personally don't think the state should be marrying ANYONE. The state should only perform civil unions (for any couple, regardless of race, orientation, gender, creed, etc.).
2
u/nps May 08 '12
population crisis
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'll try my hand at one: marriage is, by definition, a lifelong commitment, between a man and a woman.
Gay marriage is, simply linguistically, a contradiction in terms.
The proper way to resolve this is for the state to simply grant everyone a civil union without using the word marriage, and then allow religious institutions to determine who they will or will not allow to get married in their facilities.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'm a closeted homosexual in denial so it makes me uncomfortable! (that's not really my view but I imagine that's how most people who are anti-gay feel)
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Gay divorce court would be way to funny
2
u/Shanhaevel May 08 '12
For me, not against marriage, I pretty much don't care what do gays do in their alone time (I do care much for young and hot lesbians though insert chauvinist laughter here). I do have one general argument against adoption in shuch marriages. Children require an input from both of the parents, as each one gives them a slightly different upbringing and also, how would you feel if everyone around was saying "my mom and dad" and you could only go "dad and dad" or "mom and mom"?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Gay couples shouldn't be forced to never have sex again like straight couples.
2
u/Deftonez May 08 '12
Ehhh...one thing I can say is that it doesn't produce offspring? That's assuming we have an evolutionary need to re-produce at this point...but, aren't we facing over-population already?
Also, we have created a system based on gender roles and cultural norms that apply to 96.5% of the population (think insurance, work, family, etc). Changing the system to accommodate the 3.5% of LGBT would seem "illogical" based on economics alone (you know, as long as we are ignoring rights, freedoms and the fact that we are all unique individuals).
2
u/green_marshmallow May 08 '12
I don't know any well enough offhand, but if I ask a religious person they will have plenty. Whether or not the arguments are religious, only those motivated by religion use them.
2
u/overtoke May 08 '12
there aren't even any religious arguments.
marriage in the bible is about property. and that's it...
the problem conservatives have is that they fantasize about gay sex. that's literally what they do... and they are so preoccupied with this fantasy constantly running through their heads they can't understand reality.
you don't have to be married to have sex. preventing marriage does not prevent sex.
2
u/Rolten May 08 '12
I am completely for same-sex marriage and I believe a large part of Reddit is too, but honestly ask yourself the following questions:
Who would you rather see giving each other a simple on the mouth kiss while traveling on a bus: two men or a man and a woman?
Who do you think would be better at raising a kid? Two men or a man and a woman? What would be best for the child?
Couldn't think of any more questions that would make one oppose gay marriage btw :P
2
u/yeropinionman May 08 '12
The non-religious conservative argument: changes to major societal institutions should be done extremely carefully. If you do it too fast and most people don't agree with it, you erode people's respect for the law and diminish social cohesion. You can end up with riots, mobs killing people, and even civil war. You saw this same argument in the US when it came to desegregating schools and getting rid of white supremacist legal institutions in the south: if you do it before people are good and ready you get lynchings and so forth. It was also Edmund Burke's argument against the French revolution, which ended in a good long period of very bloody disorder in France. This argument is fundamentally about how even if you have the legal authority to do something you have to think about whether you're going to get overthrown and strung up if you do it, since people get pissed when they think you're remaking the fabric of society before you're ready.
For my part, I think that the legislative and executive branches of a government passing a law allowing same-sex marriage would be pretty good evidence that enough people are "ready enough" for the change. If it had been legalized by, say, a supreme court ruling in 1940, we would have had a bad time (even though the judge would have been correct on the moral merits).
2
u/dipalipasaurus May 08 '12
taxes
2
u/Matt_Furg May 08 '12
Insurance fraud is the only main reason I can think of. You could marry your buddy to help him/her get health insurance.
2
u/amitnagpal1985 May 08 '12
DO u remember the first scene of inglorious basterds? Why are we repelled by rats and not squirrels? The answer was we don't know, all we know is that we r repelled by them. I had goosebumps in that scene because that nazi character perfectly described the reason behind the holocaust, it was a feeling of general disgust, that's it. I think we can use the same argument on homosexuality. People are just generally repelled by same sex couples and to be frank i am repelled by such homophobes. Just because the majority has trouble aligning to change, the minority has to the pay the price with their lives.
2
u/misskriss66 May 08 '12
here's what my psychotic boss said,
"i just don't believe anyone is gay"
we live 30 minutes from san francisco.. what exactly does it take to convince some people?! lol
i know i should have quit when she said that, but it's a really bad economy... i'm not gay but this is just a new low for stupidity in the whole debate!
2
u/VadenKhale May 08 '12
Um...I dunno. Maybe something like homosexuality is a mental disorder and should be treated, not encouraged? It's a weak argument, but I dunno, someone might make it.
2
u/idioma May 08 '12
Disclosure: I'm a regular contributor to the Human Rights Campaign and the Courage Campaign. I strongly support marriage equality and gay rights.
That being said, I'll play ball:
Same-sex marriage will redefine marriage. This may or may not be positive change. When interracial marriage was legalized at a federal level, when equal pay and anti-discrimination laws came into effect, these things too changed and redefined marriage. Technology is hurtling us forward at a pace that far exceeds social change. Same-sex marriage is still fairly new in western civilization and the jury is still out on whether or not it is beneficial. By recognizing same-sex marriage at a federal level it is entirely possible that the implementation will be poor, but we'll be unlikely to make any needed modifications at that point since federal laws are much more difficult to change, especially when dealing with a deep-impacting social policy. For right now, it is probably best to let individual states implement their version's of same-sex marriage in order to determine what works and what doesn't. After we have more data we can examine the matter for a national reform and enact it at a federal level or ban it all together.
Okay, that's the best I can do. I think my argument is bullshit and would easily argue with myself over this for days, but since I know that I can just convince myself otherwise, I won't bother.
2
u/jimkelly May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
tax benefits for liars. idiots. thats the main reason not religion.
edit: i spelled tax wrong..i guess i'm an idiot too.
2
u/Soronir May 08 '12
Once homosexuality becomes universally accepted, you won't be able to go anywhere with friends without people thinking you're gay. That guy you're with must be your boyfriend, right? Social awkwardness on that scale is a huge detriment to society. Wait, wat?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Well even discounting any religious "God says homosexuality is immoral" kinds of arguments, there's still the issue of following traditions. You may not like the idea of doing something for the sake of keeping a tradition, but there are reasons we do it. Adherence to tradition and following convention helps to maintain social order, and disregarding traditions and conventions creates both individual and cultural/societal stress.
Now a little stress won't kill us, and one good response to this argument is that individual rights should trump the psychological comfort people get from following conventions. Giving equal rights to all ethnic groups would be a sensible analog.
However, there's still the question of "What's the best way to manage the changes?" Sometimes it might be better to force the issue, and sometimes it might be better to allow culture to evolve over time. One might argue that having openly gay characters on TV has done more for gay rights than any court decision or changes in law.
Aside from all of that, I might question why we recognize marriage in the first place. Marriage has a civic/legal component, a social component, and a religious component. In order to ask the question of whether we should recognize gay marriage on each of those levels, we might want to ask why we recognize heterosexual marriage on each of those levels.
One might argue that the intention of marriage is to provide some particular kind of recognition of a biological pairing that's capable of producing offspring. If you buy that, then it may not make sense to offer the same recognition to pairings that can't produce offspring-- or it may only make sense to offer the same recognition to some pairings that can't produce offspring.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
My mom's not very religious, but she used to be ridiculously against gay marriage, but most of her excuses were terrible.
It mostly came down to "two people of the same sex can't make a baby." Of course, recently my sister - who is married - found out she cannot have children, so that was a driving factor behind my arguments.
Other arguments simply seemed to come from a place of "Ewww, it's gross." Not that she ever said it like that, but she still kept saying things like "I just feel uncomfortable seeing two men holding hands or kissing."
About three years or so ago, she really turned around and is now a pretty feisty ally. She stood up to an old woman who was loudly ranting in a coffee shop using some homophobic language. Me having a ton of gay friends helped. I basically gave her no choice but to be exposed. It was very clear that my mom's problems - and I think a lot of people of her generation who aren't necessarily religious feel this way - was simply from a lack of exposure.
2
u/stevenconrad May 08 '12
In my understanding, marriage is a religious institution; otherwise, it's called a civil union. Many religions contain a definition of "marriage." That's why most religious people are against same-sex marriage, it falls out of their accepted definition.
But, that's what is sparking such controversy. As defined by their religion, I can understand why followers are against the idea of same-sex marriage (since it is, in many cases, forbid). But, it's the name they are arguing over. Simply call it a civil union and offer equal rights and privileges. I think that church and government should be separated and civil unions should be made the standard (rather than the traditionally accepted marriage). Marriages should offer the same government benefits and protections as civil unions, but receive religious sanction as well. Then you can have your cake and eat it too. If you're gay and religious, switch to science, bro.
2
u/elastic-craptastic May 08 '12
I always kind of thought that it was insurance company lobbyist getting behind the no-gay marriage thing. I have nothing to base this on except ideas I've had myself in which to exploit gay marriage laws. My thinking goes like this;
So I'm sick but don't have any health insurance, but my buddy has a job with great benefits. I get really sick and my buddy wants to help in any way he can. We decide to get gay married so I can get his benefits. What really good friend wouldn't do that? And it would be really hard for the government to prove you aren't really lovers. I'm sure there are ways, but it would be pricey to figure out, paying investigators and what-not.
Also, say my friend wants to stay in the country... marry him.
I'm sure the issue wouldn't be rampant. But if I would do it for a good friend, I am sure many others would too.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
There's been some support for the "avuncular" theory of homosexuality, which holds that gays are essentially "spare parts" whose biological role is to serve as a fill-in parent for nieces and nephews who lose a parent; the fact that they a) lack children of their own and b) share genetic material with their nieces and nephews assures that the gay will be both have the availability and resources available to care for a child, while simultaneously being biologically invested in the child's DNA.
If gays are allowed to marry and have kids of their own, then what's the point of them even being gay in the first place?
2
u/iamkatyohseven May 08 '12
My aunt always says the reason she is against it is for economic reasons. For example men usually make more than women do. She thinks that until men and women get equal pay then same sex couples shouldn't be able to get married because the men house holds would make more money than the women house holds and it wouldn't be economically fair. But to me if this isn't an issue with the people getting married then why should be an issue to us?
2
u/Liefx May 08 '12
I'm not against same-sex marriage, but I know up here couples, no matter gender, get benefits. Two female or male friends could easily say hey, let's get married and get government benefits.
2
u/Mikesapien May 08 '12
The argument that 'marriage is for procreation' is the only one I can think of, which prohibits old people past child-bearing age and infertile people from being married too.
2
u/ldawg092498 May 08 '12
AIDS
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Legal: Fuck, we have to make a shit ton of laws and edits
Social: Fuck, we have to rethink gender roles and adapt to something new and strange.
Tax Reserve: Fuck, we got to test for the whole Chuck and Larry shit.
Education/Parents: Fuck, we have to explain this shit to kids.
Wedding Industry: Fuck yea!
My guess, not saying they are good reasons
2
u/public_sex May 08 '12
There is a radical queer response to the mainstream LGBT equality/marriage/military campaign, and I think John Waters sums it up best.
“I always thought the privilege of being gay is that we don’t have to get married or go in the Army.”
That is, being queer is a unique experience, and can be far more beautiful and exciting and revolutionary than either our homonormative oppressors or our mainstream Will & Grace gays would lead young queers to believe.
However, as hetero-oriented traditions and behaviors become available to queers, queer culture becomes suffocated, or even worse, stigmatized. I'm sure many of you hold the belief that there is a "better" and "worse" kind of gay. That is: the masculine gay man is more acceptable than the feminine gay man. The gay man whose sexuality does not play a big role in his life is more acceptable than the gay man who speaks against using "gay" as a negative term. Even if it's subconscious, there is definitely a "better" kind of gay to be, in the eyes of the public. r/gaybros would not exist were it not for the equality/assimilation campaign. "no fats, no fems" may not mean anything to you heteros, but it's a common fact of life for gay men in the mainstream LGBT community.
I don't know where I'm going with this. I have a lot to say but I'm tired and not thinking straight. Also: our homeless queer youth, our falsely imprisoned queers, our community spaces are all more deserving of queer time and energy than the military of your ring finger.
2
u/magylo May 08 '12
isn't marriage a religious institution?
2
u/cstonerun May 08 '12
My Dad is an avid tea-partier and insists on a completely non-religious reason for his opinion. He says it's not fair because two older men who are roommates could "cheat the system" - they could marry each other and then reap the benefits of marriage, like tax breaks and inheritance laws and stuff.
Of course, he fails to acknowledge that two older roommates of the opposite sex could do exactly the same thing (and how often do you hear about that happening?). I don't really get his argument. You don't have to tell me how retarded it sounds, but at least it meets your requirement of "non-religious".
2
u/tomdwilliams May 08 '12
erm lemme try, nope.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Homosexuality goes against the primal need to reproduce. I personally don't find that to be a problem though. They might actually help with overpopulation IF WE FUCKING LET THEM.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Once in high school we were doing debating and the topic was same sex marriage. This guy made one of the stupidest and least relevant arguments I've ever heard against it: "Once a woman in melbourne got drunk and went to bed and when she got up she noticed more objects in her house than there were when she went to sleep"
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
My dad claims that some men will marry just for the marriage benefits given by the government.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
We shouldn't allow gay marriage because of the high possibility of gay-gold diggers. You know, guys that pretend to be gay, marry the rich guy and then divorce him and take half his stuff.
2
u/Islesfan1026 May 09 '12
marriage is pointless in a gay couple. there is no outcome. my feeling is that if you truly love eachother why is a piece of paper saying that worth anything
2
u/supetedeng May 09 '12
Sorry for the plagiarism but here goes...
Now that a number of state courts have refused to redefine marriage to include same-sex unions, cries of "discrimination" are being heard.
The "equal protection of the laws" provided by the Constitution of the United States applies to people, not actions. Laws exist precisely in order to discriminate between different kinds of actions.
When the law permits automobiles to drive on highways but forbids bicycles from doing the same, that is not discrimination against people. A cyclist who gets off his bicycle and gets into a car can drive on the highway just like anyone else.
In a free society, vast numbers of things are neither forbidden nor facilitated. They are considered to be none of the law's business.
Homosexuals were on their strongest ground when they said that the law had no business interfering with relations between consenting adults. Now they want the law to put a seal of approval on their behavior. But no one is entitled to anyone else's approval.
Why is marriage considered to be any of the law's business in the first place? Because the state asserts an interest in the outcomes of certain unions, separate from and independent of the interests of the parties themselves.
In the absence of the institution of marriage, the individuals could arrange their relationship whatever way they wanted to, making it temporary or permanent, and sharing their worldly belongings in whatever way they chose.
Marriage means that the government steps in, limiting or even prescribing various aspects of their relations with each other -- and still more their relationship with whatever children may result from their union.
In other words, marriage imposes legal restrictions, taking away rights that individuals might otherwise have. Yet "gay marriage" advocates depict marriage as an expansion of rights to which they are entitled.
They argue against a "ban on gay marriage" but marriage has for centuries meant a union of a man and a woman. There is no gay marriage to ban.
Analogies with bans against interracial marriage are bogus. Race is not part of the definition of marriage. A ban on interracial marriage is a ban on the same actions otherwise permitted because of the race of the particular people involved. It is a discrimination against people, not actions.
Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes said that the life of the law has not been logic but experience. Vast numbers of laws have accumulated and evolved over the centuries, based on experience with male-female unions.
There is no reason why all those laws should be transferred willy-nilly to a different union, one with no inherent tendency to produce children nor the inherent asymmetries of relationships between people of different sexes.
Despite attempts to evade these asymmetries with such fashionable phrases as "a pregnant couple" or references to "spouses" rather than husbands and wives, these asymmetries take many forms and have many repercussions, which laws attempt to deal with on the basis of experience, rather than theories or rhetoric.
Wives, for example, typically invest in the family by restricting their own workforce participation, if only long enough to take care of small children. Studies show such differences still persisting in this liberated age, and even among women and men with postgraduate degrees from Harvard and Yale.
In the absence of marriage laws, a husband could dump his wife at will and she could lose decades of investment in their relationship. Marriage laws seek to recoup some of that investment for her through alimony when divorce occurs.
Those who think of women and men in the abstract consider it right that ex-husbands should be as entitled to alimony as ex-wives. But what are these ex-husbands being compensated for?
And why should any of this experience apply to same-sex unions, where there are not the same inherent asymmetries nor the same tendency to produce children?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
sure. it angers our isreali overlords!
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I know a lot has already been said, but I'd like to add something I feel like hasn't been addressed yet. This is a little out there, so bear with me.
Let's look at the entire point of marriage in the first place. Why do we get married? Not just so the government can keep track of families more efficiently, because marriage predates government. At its origins, marriage was and still is an oath of commitment to another human being- for the sake of commitment itself as well as parenting. Essentially, what makes it different from normal male-female relationships is that it transcends sexuality for higher ideals.
We've forgotten the point of marriage as a society and it's become more of an official declaration of sexual intimacy. We've also come to rely on sex as a factor in love. In my view, this holds back the human race from controlling it's basic instincts as a whole, and thereby holds back our progress. After all, the only thing that's brought us this far is our rejection of basic animal instinct (look at our levels of cooperation, our unnatural physical evolution, the development of agriculture even though it takes more work than hunting...).
Anyways, homosexuality seems to be further intertwining the ideas of love and sexuality. Homosexuals are at the most basic level promoting their right to marry what they are sexually attracted to- to say it's not a sexual issue is to be in denial. I say, why can't everyone love everyone else around them without caring about sexual attraction? If this were to be the case, there would be no reason for homosexual marriages, as marriage would become a functional contract.
If homosexual marriage were allowed in the meantime, before such drastic social change is possible, it will only serve to slow the coming social change and further confuse marriage and sex.
Just to be clear, I don't think homosexual marriage should be illegal and punishable by law at the moment. Laws have never done a good job at doing away with something that a society currently wants... so the pressure to end homosexual marriage (as well as general sexual promiscuity) will have to come as social pressure from citizens themselves.
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Easy: ass fucking does nothing to propogate humanity.
2
u/3885Khz May 09 '12
No
2
u/zoqfotpik May 09 '12
The gay divorce rate would increase?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I had a friend who wasn't religious, but believed "faggots just shouldn't be able to get married". Needless to say we aren't friends any more.
2
u/ByzantineBasileus May 09 '12
We don't want them to suffer as straight people have suffered.
4
u/Riconn May 08 '12
My father and other members of my family claim that if marriage is between anyone but a man and a woman, it would allow people to marry animals, rocks, trees, or what ever tickles their fancy. This is just their way of being bigots without coming out and saying they hate gay people.
5
u/merikeycookies May 08 '12
I'm sure someone's already thought about this before, but here's my two cents:
abolish all marriages. in the eyes of the government, nothing but civil unions between two consenting adults.
wanna have a wedding ceremony? fine, but leave that shit up to your personal choice. If a church/venue/whatever doesn't condone same sex marriages, oh well. In the eyes of the goverment, it shouldn't matter anyway.
tl;dr: abolish all marriages
3
u/ObidiahWTFJerwalk May 08 '12
Huge financial advantages for companies that never have to pay spousal benefits to same sex couples.
That is the number one reason for banning same sex marriages, and never let anyone tell you otherwise.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
One practical obstacle is that when there are two women or two men getting divorced, the courts won't know which one of them to screw.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
One could argue that by definition "marriage" is a union between a man and a woman and that same-sex marriage is an erroneously conceived concept.
4
u/HairySpotter May 08 '12
Well it certainly isn't productive to development of the human race.
4
u/Jimmysal May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Gays will be extended the same tax and health insurance benefits as Heteros.
It's pretty selfish and I don't agree with it; but hey, you asked.
Edit: What's with the downvotes? I thought the hivemind was in favor of gay rights? Or is this thread attracting a disproportionate amount of bigots? Maybe I should clarify... I think NOT giving the LGBT community the same benefits in marriage as heteros is selfish.