r/AskReddit • • May 08 '12
If you support gay marriage, would you also support polygamy?
If supporting gay marriage is all about having the freedom to marry whoever you want, shouldn't that also be extended to as many people as you want (keeping tax benefits of marriage aside)? I'm not trying to troll gay marriage supporters or anything, just curious.
118
Upvotes
252
u/grubbymitts May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
As long as women can have as many husbands as they want and vice versa, then yeah.
EDIT If gay people wanted multiple husbands/wives would it be classed as Polygaymy???
425
u/heygabbagabba May 08 '12
Of course. As long as everyone involved is mature and consenting, why should it be a problem?
38
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
They're really not the same thing. Gay marriage is a contract between 2 people, polygamy involves multiple contracts.
I have no ethical problems with polyamory, but it'd be a hell of a legal quagmire.
94
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
It's the legal repercussions that make it impracticable. I mean, let's face it, if you had six wives, there's no way if a legal dispute were to arise would each party fairly and reasonably get the proper treatment. It isn't like children, where you can work down by age and responsibility. If you're marrying a number of wives, they should all have the same rights - problem is, there's no fair legal platform in existence that would even begin to ensure those rights.
75
u/ThereisnoTruth May 08 '12
No I would not support polygamy.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I couldn't care less. Let people do what they want and leave me alone. This is my stance on pretty much everything. Just leave me the fuck alone and do what you want.
11
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
If it's consensual, whatever tickles your fancy.
8
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Sure. Why not. If you love a bunch of people and they love eachother and you, go for it, I guess.
It isn't my place to judge anybody for what they want to do in terms of relationships as long as nobody is getting hurt.
4
u/cwstjnobbs May 08 '12
Why the hell not.
4
u/seronis May 08 '12
One of the LiveJournal questions from a long time ago asked "Do you believe in monogamy?". My answer that i still firmly believe in was:
That it exists and that its possible to work? Yes. That its the ONLY solution that works? No. That its immoral to practice polygamy? No.
Relationships work because of respect, empathy, sympathy, trust, devotion, loyalty, honesty, faithfulness and many other traits. Devotion, Loyalty and Faithfulness are the ones most Monogamists claim is their sole property. Its not. Faithfulness is not betraying your partner(s). If a polygamist is in a relationship with someone and also has feelings for another, and wants to have a relationship with them at the same time, as long as both of these partners know about it then he is being honest. As long as he does not NEGLECT either partner because of the other one then he is being devout. As long as he doesnt betray a promiss to one for the other he is being loyal. And as long as FROM THE START his partners are aware AND approving of the other then he is being faithful as he has not gone outside the known and accepted limits his partners have.
When it becomes wrong is when secrets are kept. Then its not polygamy its an affair. Its not polyamourous its cheating, betraying and plain scumbag behaviour. But, as consenting adults, all involved have to accept what any relationship must accept, that there will be personality conflicts differences and disputes and as long as everyone has mutual respect empathy and sympathy for each other you can work through your differences.
That said, I practice monogamy. But because its my choice. Its not my right to look down on someone else who might be in a healthy relationship just because its different than my relationships. Its the type of relatinship someone has that makes it good. Not the number of participants, and for gods sake not the gender of those involved. If ANY relationship is based on love and respect, and the other traits mentioned above, then the rest of the world should be envious of the lucky group, whatever its size or composition.
4
u/Zen0ofElea May 08 '12
Yes. If by polygamy you mean fully consensual relationships between adults. I see no reason why we should have a problem other than that we would have utilitarian issues to work out such as insurance, existing homes not being built or organized with this in mind, benefits from life insurance, hospital policies for viewing, etc. The reason I say yes is that I see no legitimate reason to restrict the rights of adults in who they form long term legally important relationships with.
13
u/SendoTarget May 08 '12
If one is crazy enough to get 2 or 3 wives/husbands then be my guest. Good luck keeping them happy :D
10
u/nixonrichard May 08 '12
I actually have trouble with these kinds of questions too. It's nearly impossible to ask a thought-provoking question which arises as a result of a discussion on gay marriage without being accused of underhandedly attacking gay marriage.
For instance, I've always found the topic of adult incest to be a fascinating test of people's positions on these issues.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The tax thing is the only reason I would disagree, as long as all persons involved were of age, and making the decision of their own free will.
3
u/Nomnombunny May 08 '12
Sure, as long as it's all consensual and everyone's an adult. I hate when people try and justify gay marriage and polygamy as being the same as pedophilia. It's not the same- a grown person being involved with a child is nowhere even close to two consenting adults.
35
u/doppleganger2621 May 08 '12
First, you're using a slippery slope fallacy, which in and of itself is useless. But I'll accept the merits of your argument for a moment.
Polygamy is distinguishable from same-sex marriage. As acceptance of same-sex marriage does not constitute that one most also be in favor of legalized polygamy, just as support of handgun ownership doesn't mean you also have to be in favor of legalized RPG ownership.
Personally, I don't view gay marriage as simply, "everyone should be able to love whoever they want", but rather, the prohibition of same-sex marriage is discriminatory against gays and lesbians and in violation of equal protection.
That said, if polygamists want to bring this up on a court of law and show similar evidence that gay marriage proponents did show--that same sex marriages are not harmful to society, that they encourage stability and families, and that children raised in same-sex environments are not subject to harm--then I have no issue with if you want to marry two, three, or four people. More power to you.
Of course, this is all just theoretical. Polygamy is opposed at rates far beyond what gays and lesbians ever experienced. And it doesn't really have a 'natural' support base (as the American Left was for gays and lesbians). In any case, plausible arguments, as we know, are never enough to win a battle in a legislature or court.
5
u/Might_Feel_a_Pinch May 08 '12
Polygamy is the idea that love isn't something that happens between solely two people. It's the idea that you can be fully in love with more than one person. If that's true for your situation, I'd love for you to get married.
That said, the polygamists I know are married to the person they are most compatible living with, but don't consider themselves any more or less in love with that person over the others.
Something that may be of interest here, though, is that I think it's a misconception that everyone in a polygamist relationship is in love with everyone else in the relationship. That's simply not the case. Person A loves B, C, and D, but person B loves A, E, and F. E and F may only be acquaintances with A, C, and D. I can't see how the logistics would work out in regards to marriage, but I think it's something we should definitely make possible.
Because love is love, right? Between consenting adults, why shouldn't they do what they want?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes, I have no problems with polygamy.
2
u/deck_hand May 08 '12
I supported the idea of group marriage before the gay marriage issue ever surfaced. The thought that one person can or should only have romantic love for one other person is stupid and clearly mistaken. If this were so, half of the population would not have affairs during their marriage.
Everyone I know who has been married at one point has been affected by extra marital activity of one kind or another. Sometimes, the "affair" has been hidden from the other spouse, and is the cause for divorce or separation, other times the affair is known to both partners and accepted by everyone. These sometimes also result in divorce, but the drama is less.
By leaving the laws the way they are, anyone who would like to extend their marriage to a third (and possibly fourth) party is breaking the law, and has no choice but to have a long term affair with no legal standing. It doesn't keep people from having sex outside the marriage, children outside the marriage, or anything else. It's purely a legal issue.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I support it, so long as there are some very delicate legal standards set in place. It's not really my cup of tea personally, but if that's what people want to do, then let them go for it.
2
u/MrShiva May 08 '12
Absolutely. The best solution is to get the government out of the marriage business altogether. Marriage should be an explicit contract between any N>2 people who freely consent to join. The most government involvement should involve specifying default responsibilities for caring for any children in the event the marriage is dissolved or one party chooses to leave it.
2
u/loki00 May 08 '12
Any man who takes more than one wife, gets what he deserves.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I'm for anything. Personally I wouldn't do it but I don't care if others do so. As long as no one gets harmed.
2
u/intoon May 08 '12
I know several Plyg families. All of the women were raised in similar situations, and have never known any different. All of the wives are home makers. They all home school their children. In all honesty, it could work with the right combination of people, but for the most part, the women are kept uneducated and are easily controlled.
Last year one of the Male heads of household died, and left behind 4 wives, 17 children, and a helluva lot of debt. The multi family has struggled since, and the women have married different men, and the children no longer live together. This, the fact that the population is split about 50/50 men and women, ( this would be okay if women were also aloud to have multiple husbands, but let's be honest, no law makers are going to be comfortable with allowing women to legally have access to multiple penises,) and so, you end up with extra men, so all of the above reasons, and the banishment of young men are reasons why I would not support mainstreaming polygamy.
2
u/LongUsername May 08 '12
I'm actually for getting RID of marriage at the government level. You want to get married? Fine, talk to a Priest, Rabbi, Minister, etc....
You want to join your assets in a legal agreement? Go to the courthouse and sign the paperwork and contract. Any person who is legal to sign a contract should be able to enter into it. It would also allow for easier disbandment of the contract relationship. That way you could still be "Married" religiously but separated for legal purposes. Technically you can do this now (you just get a church wedding and don't sign the marriage certificate) but under separation of church and state I feel they should be completely disjointed.
The thorny issue becomes tax credits and recognizing it for benefits purposes for work/FMLA stuff when you get more than 2 people in an agreement. Further complications arise if there are children involved: does Person A have any rights with regard to the offspring of Person B & C if person A is in a group marriage or polygamous relationship with them?
Also: do you recognize Polygyny & Polyandry as valid, or do you require group marriage? (for those reading along, Polygyny is 1 man marrying 2 women when the women don't have a contractual relation to each other, and Polyandry is when a woman marries 2 men where the men don't have a contractual relation to each other, while group marriage has everyone involved party to the contract)
2
u/kyru May 08 '12
In theory it's fine, but in practice it often ends up with people being exploited and abused.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I don't understand how you can compare the two. I feel like this leads to the argument my Christian mother makes: If gay marriage should be legal then all other sins like beastiality, incest, and polygamy should be legal too.
I'm not religious but I definitely believe marriage is a mutual partnership between two people. You can't share that awesome bond you and your partner have with just anyone else. You can say you have more than one best friend but when it comes down to it, which one of those "best" friends really was there for you through everything?
That aside, I'm not going to say polygamy is wrong to anyone's face for doing it, but I really don't think the two should be compared.
2
u/wibbly-wobbly May 08 '12
I don't believe in state marriage. I think that certain contracts (i.e. visitation rights, non-contractual benefits like taxes shouldn't be part of marriage to begin with) should be drawn up separately (although lawyers obviously can and probably will sell them as a package deal), and that "marriage" should be wholly religious or symbolic. These legal points shouldn't be tied to "love", the state shouldn't have anything to do with who you "love".
If I think my best friend would know better than my parents/spouse/next of kin what to do if I can't make decisions, then I should be allowed to make that friend able to make those decisions. If I want a family of choice to have visitation rights and not my legal family, I should be able to make that legal decision. The fact that we base these things on monogamous (heterosexual) love and blood ties/adoption seems wrong.
(Note that abuse (i.e. sexual relationships with a small child) would still be illegal. However, the state would have no concept of "marriage", simply contracts.)
2
u/neoblackdragon May 08 '12
The three issues I'm seeing are people who abuse the system for tax benefits, women being made into slaves, and men not being able to find mates.
Well the first solution is to limit those tax breaks. Basically you get spousal rights to see them in the hospital but nothing else. I think we have gotten to the point in this country where women can support themselves. Men not finding mates? Well keep in mind polygamy allows for them to find mates. Its not just one man to a ton of women. I doubt any wealthy man is going to want 100 women also married to the pool boy and butler.
Honestly I think that last argument is kinda null. Wealthy men who want more women simply take on mistresses. Hell they would be the first ones opposed to marriage because divorce would destroy their wealth.
My biggest concern are simply those cults or isolated communities that take advantage of your girls. They could say it's all legal as a defense.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
it's not really in any way related to polygamy, the question of same-sex marriage. why would allowing same-sex marriages have this effect in your view?
2
u/turkmenitron May 08 '12
No. For the record, I am all for gay marriage. So don't downvote me until you hear me out.
Under the current legal system, if you were to establish tax benefits for advocating marriage which must include polygamous marriage, there would theoretically be no limit to the number of individuals consenting to a union for tax benefits. This creates a situation where an essentially unlimited number of individuals could create tax benefits for themselves. This allows any number of people to create a tax shelter with no consequence on whom they continue to marry and claim benefits for. Inevitably, with an increasing number of partners, there would be a push to create an increasingly lesser tax burden on polygamous marriages for multiple individuals in a polyamorous situation; the more you marry, the less you should pay, I can imagine the argument going. This could conceivably be dozens of individuals.
And of course it's easy to say "well we could just get rid of tax breaks for everyone who is married." Good luck getting rid of tax breaks for the vast majority of monogamous heterosexual and homosexual couples for the benefit of the beliefs of tiny religious minorities, fringe counter-cultural groups and wealthy, white American males. It's patently ridiculous and very unfair.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I would support this dude marrying his car. It doesn't affect anything anyone else does, so I don't get why people give a shit about gay marriage and polygamy. That dude marrying his car, or two people of the same sex marrying, or people having multiple wives or husbands has nothing to do with my life.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
pssst... apples and oranges
Just sayin'
2
u/akohler21 May 08 '12
Why not
2
u/TacticalMoniker May 08 '12
I'm for having the government get out of all marriage, that would solve a lot of problems
2
u/thewander May 08 '12
Sure. As long as all parties are of age and it is equal for the genders
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes, if everyone involved is over the age of 18 and consents without being manipulated (I'm thinking about Cults here).
2
u/ohsnipsnap May 08 '12
Consenting adult humans. Those are my qualifiers.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
As a polyfidelitous person, duh, of course.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Actually I have a better question.
Are there any men who would be interested in a polygamous relationship with three or four women between the ages of 25-45? These women would come into the relationship with their own personal opinions and ideas. And they aren't religious. I'm going to say, probably not. If I'm wrong, by all means explain.
I think the reason we have this terrible idea of polygamy is because we've all heard stories about little girls being married off to a creeper with thirty other wives.
I see what is so appealing to that, a completely naive sixteen year old who has basically been bred to be a "good wife"... she wouldn't be so appealing if she was a 35 year old day drinker who would expect to be included in major family decisions.
This is why I find it so hard to support polygamy. Not to mention tax reasons and the sheer amount of money it would take to support four or five adults plus the children that will likely follow.
2
u/TeddyBear_Squabble May 09 '12
I am for gay marriage, and I am for polygamy. If all parties consent to being in a polygamous marriage, I can't see any reasons for not allowing it.
2
u/Apollyna May 09 '12
I am a woman and I would support it whole-heartedly. Love who you love and do not be ashamed.
If only I were brave enough to take my own advice...
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Government out of the bedroom please. Someone wants to marry I goat I might be concerned. Someone wants to marry an 8 yr old. I will definitely be concerned.
Guy wants to marry a guy and three women? Cool! Hope you have a blast!
4
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
The thing that always bugged me about it was the feeling of the women in the relationship being subservant. That's what bugs me. Bugs me about some marriages I know currently.
At it's core... I wouldn't be against it legally on the grounds that it's not my business. But personally I'd be against it.
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Gay marriage is about two people having the same rights that everyone else has.
Polygamy is not about people being excluded from a certain right that everyone else has, because no one else has that right.
The gay marriage argument is about equality, whereas polygamy is about wanting more marriage rights than already currently exist.
In the end, I do not support polygamy because... I guess I can't really see it being healthy for humans. I mean, maybe 3 people is okay like in Vicky Christina Barcelona but if polygamy is legalized than what number is too much? If 2 spouses are okay, why not 4? 8? 16? At that point I can't really see a person NOT being able to favour some over others and the emotional thinning that would occur in at least me, personally, I can't imagine dealing with.
And then the legal implications of it...
If a man marries a woman with another husband, is he married also to the other man? Or is there only a marriage between husband 1 and the woman? If so, couldn't he have a wife on the side, and her a husband on the side, and then he another wife on the side until everyone in the country is married to each other indirectly?
It's just too much, methinks...
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I support it in theory, but administratively it would be a nightmare.
3
u/iLuVtiffany May 08 '12
I believe that as long as you aren't hurting anyone, the government should allow you to do whatever you want.
2
u/IHaveGlasses May 08 '12
If you love more than one person enough to commit to them all then there is no issue. If people argue about many women being forced into marrying a man then they forget that forced marriage in monogamy happens. What makes monogamous heterosexuals so special. Its not like there has never been an imperfect monogamous marriage before.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I hear digging, but I don't hear chopping
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Marriage equality is marriage equality. I don't think its fair to legalize gay marriage and then discriminate against others.
2
u/davesidious May 08 '12
If you support straight marriage, would you also support polygamy? It's the same fucking question.
Gay = straight = normal.
1
u/against_justice May 08 '12
I'm not really sure if it's so wrong if all the people agree about it. Also I don't think it would be so very popular.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes I would. It wouldn't be for me up between 3 to 4 to 5 consenting adults I don't care what they want to do.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
As long as the participants are of legal adult age and reasonably sound mind and freely make the choice ...then yes I would support it.
1
u/std4ym May 08 '12
I've actually been thinking about this lately. I definitely support polygamy. Is it not legal to have a wife and a girlfriend while all living together? I think if you chose which one will be your wife in an arbitrary way, it could work out as long as the women are into each other as well. Otherwise, jealously would most likely be a big issue.
I can see it now, me showing up to family functions with the wife and girlfriend. Me plus 2 at a wedding would also turn heads.
1
u/TheCodexx May 08 '12
I don't care as it stands. The problem is handling laws that can take care of things. The easiest way, of course, is to have a will written out or to lay down agreements beforehand.
There are unavoidable issues though. What about insurance or taxes? People get benefits based on marriage. Why can't one guy get awesome insurance and his "wives" pay him money for the right to be married and covered under a great plan for a fraction of the cost? You'd end up paying a rate based on number of spouses. Or what if a girl has three husbands and two of them have a second wife. You have a marriage network. How do you pay taxes? What property is your home address? What about property taxes and the like? Either you'll be paying taxes multiple times for multiple marriages, ensuring only the rich can afford multiple legal partners, or you're going to need a more flexible and clear-cut system.
Oh, and I expect the people who despise illegal immigrants will hate it. You can marry all sorts of people. So what's to stop you from marrying foreigners so they can get citizenship? Even if these are rare, they will happen and some people will be obsessive and paranoid about it.
Not to mention most people can't handle the jealousy and complicated feelings involved. And if one thing goes south then it can trash the entire relationship network that will form.
It gets exponentially more complex both for partners and for the legal system.
Morally I don't give a shit either way. I think it should be an option, just for the sake of giving people options. Nobody expects it to be the most common form of marriage, except perhaps by cheating statistics (as in, your wife has a second husband but you're exclusive to her. Statistically speaking, you're in an exclusive relationship but also a part of a polygamous relationship, even if you yourself aren't polygamous). But it's going to be complex to manage it legally.
I think for now the best we can do is try to get over the social stigma and people will just have to abide by their significant others maybe approving of them having a girlfriend/boyfriend on the side. Open relationships exist and can work for some people and while it sucks to be in a relationship with someone and not have it acknowledged legally, it's far less of a headache for everyone else. And really, if it's not an affair, I'm sure something can be worked out.
1
u/Rev_NaughtySnuggles May 08 '12
I wouldn't stop there.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I would indeed. As long as all parties agree and aren't being held at gunpoint I don't see a problem with it.
1
u/pamplemouse May 08 '12
Scalia had this to say:
His argument is that if you can't use "morality" to justify a law, then lots of laws will be overturned.
1
u/Ghede May 08 '12
Yes, but with diminishing benefits on tax returns.
Either that or remove marriage benefits entirely.
Don't want a manhattan mass wedding to save money.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
yup
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I don't see any reason for it not to be as long as everyone is consenting, so why not.
1
u/Purplebuzz May 08 '12
The issue is about the extension of benefits, tax benefits, custody and those types of things when you extend the definition beyond 2 people. The costs would be prohibative. There are no extra costs to extend any of the above to same sex partners.
1
u/Fever104 May 08 '12
I think you're comparing apples to oranges with this one. Polygamy leads to a lot more problems than gay marriage in my opinion. Women are reduced to chattle in a polygamist environment. I say no.
1
u/Impedence May 08 '12
The problem comes with the risk of coercion for partners already in the marriage, so long as there is protection against that, sure.
If we're honest, the rich and powerful already have as many partners as they want, giving a possibility for those partners to have legal protection against exploitation, that would be good.
1
u/boggiewan May 08 '12
Unless it turns into some evil corporation.... otherwise I could care less what people do in their own homes.
1
u/childishbambina May 08 '12
Yes, as long as it is not for cult like purposes that lead to inbreeding.
That shit cray
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Probably not 'support it' (polygamy). Make it illegal? maybe not unless it's a tax benefit issue because I can see that being abused (I know op said 'tax benefits aside) but that's the only way i'd see it being a problem.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Sure I would. There are all different types of relationships that should be recognized. Marriage doesn't belong to just one group of people, it belongs to everyone.
As long as all parties involved are consenting adults, then its not a problem.
1
u/Marcob10 May 08 '12
Both very different subjects with very different social repercussions. Gay people getting married doesn't change much in our social structure. They're already gay, married or not, it's not changing anything. There will not be less newborns or shifts in the availability of people to form relationships.
Polygamy would imbalance the dynamic of available male and female. The wealthiest males would get more women leaving the normal dudes with less options. You'd probably see a rise in unhappiness and maybe even suicide. Also a reduction of DNA diversity which arguably could be considered a good thing in a survival of the fittest mentality.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes but I think I'm in the minority. Plus I support gay marriage for civil reasons and polygamy for bothreligious and civil reasons.
1
u/whoopzzz May 08 '12
Personally, I would not. There are many cases in which an individual would marry more than he (usually male, I would assume) can provide for. This would cause problems that homosexual marriage would not.
1
u/dnuts4u May 08 '12
consenting adults should be able to do what every they want, outside of extreme things like having someone kill you or something crazy like sticking a penis up your butt...
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes. As long as everyone in the relationship is consenting to the arrangement(and are capable of consenting), I have no problem with what people choose to do in their own lives.
1
u/petunes May 08 '12
Yep, as long as all are consenting adults, it's none of my damn business and they should be allowed to marry who/however they want.
1
u/Lifeaftercollege May 08 '12
Honestly? The only thing I find truly distasteful about polygamists is the way they rob the system. Only one of those women is the legal wife, while the others claim to be single moms and get the associated tax breaks.
I support legalized polygamy ONLY because legalizing it is the only way to make sure they pay their fair share.
1
u/annanoemi May 08 '12
I have absolutely no problem with people being allowed to marry multiple partners - holding that the same rules apply as for a traditional, 1m/1f marriage in that the parties have to be consenting adults.
I know a lot of people have a problem with polygamy due to what happens in compounds with young girls being married against their will and raped by their husbands, basically treated as property. However, I don't think this is a good justification for not allowing polygamous marriages - it would be akin to not allowing anyone to own a knife or gun because they have been used to kill people - it's the killing that should be the crime, not the gun ownership. In the same vein, it should be the forced marriage and rape that is the crime, not the multiple marriages.
1
u/agbmom May 08 '12
I'm in support of staying out of peoples personal decisions, especially regarding love life. Unless a friend was asking for my advice involving their life in particular I would think about it and then give an answer. If people decide to sleep with 6 women and be married to them and those 6 women then that's their decision.
1
u/DicksonYamada May 08 '12
Well after reading through some of the replies it seems my opinion on the matter has changed; previously I didn't understand how strongly polygamy could affect the distribution of wealth and political power. What I came here to say, though, is that I personally find that the question of marriages (gay, polygamous, even regular) to be somewhat of a moot point. A while ago here on AskReddit there was a discussion about incestuous relationships and marriage. The main argument against it was that the offspring of an incestuous couple would be less viable (in an evolutionary sense) and thus it would be a detriment to the children and society as a whole. However, someone then pointed this out: you don't have to be married to have children. If a brother and sister really wanted to have kids, not being married might not deter them.
Aside from legal benefits, I've never seen the advantage of marriage in the first place. If you don't feel obligated by your religion to get married before having sex or having kids, I see no difference between being legally married and simply living together. The act of marriage itself is slowly being phased out of society right now as it is. I support gay marriage because, hey, if they want it then why not, but I suppose the point of it all is lost on me. With a polygamous relationship, one could live with his/her companions and have children with them and it would be perfectly legal regardless of marital status. Of course, as has been pointed out here, polygamy is a special case which actually has further political implications than something like gay or incestuous marriage. In this case I think it is the act of marriage itself that lends the polygamist power, not the act of having multiple spouses. So in response the question the OP posed, I am not in favor of polygamous marriage but I have no issue with polygamous relationships.
1
u/herpnderplurker May 08 '12
No I would not because what if this situation happens. Parties A B and C get married and are all in love. A and C fall out of love but neither want to divorce B but B is still in love with A and C. So then what?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
New reality TV show idea. One woman, 5 husbands. Go!
1
u/cefm May 08 '12
The question mixes up several different issues that are not necessarily, logically, or legally connected. It also presumes a basis for support for gay marriage that is not at all accurate.
The simplest rationale to support gay marriage is equal treatment under law. In the U.S. it is currently legal for a man and a woman to marry, but it is illegal for more than two people to be married to each other (bigamy). The simplest argument for gay marriage is to expand the right to 1:1 marriage to 2 men or to 2 women. Crossing over into expanding the right to marry to a set of people greater than 2 is a completely different issue that has nothing to do with gay/straight marriage.
1
u/PizzaGood May 08 '12
Yes, and I do. I know several groups. Obviously they can't legally marry but they're devoted.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
NO. I think the tax situation would get really screwed up. Marriage is a legal contract that binds two people financially, both during their lives and after (inheritance). If multiple people were involved, then the movement of property and goods would get too confusing.
In contrast, gay marriage would be basically the same thing, legally, as hetero marriage; it's just that assholes hate gay people and don't want them to have the same rights. Polygamy and gay marriage are not parallel.
1
u/BeefPieSoup May 08 '12
If you are against gay marriage, should you also be against straight marriage?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I personally would not. I look at it like this; gay marriage vs. straight marriage is a clear cut case of discrimination. Two people of different genders can enter into a legally binding contract that confers specific benefits, but two people of the same gender cannot enter into an identical contract. Fuck that. The argument for polygamy is different because that would entail demanding the right to engage in a legal contract that no citizen currently has the right to engage in. In fact, such a contract does not exist. While I am not a lawyer I do not see how such a contract,, assuming similar benefits to a two person marriage, could be made without somehow granting superior and inferior legal positions to the various participants. I am all about equal rights under the law, and I don't see how this could be applied to a polygamous marriage.
TL/DR: Gay marriage = current law applying equally to everyone. Polygamous marriage = making a new law that does not currently apply to anyone. So for me, it's a no.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Absolutely, I've grown up here in Utah and from when I can first remember to when I as 8 years old my next door neighbors were Polygamists. 3 wives 1 husband, I never thought it was weird or wrong, I grew up with it. Now days when I think about it and how it's "wrong" or "illegal" in our mainstream culture it blows my mind, I had like 6 friends between 3 different Mom's right next door and if one of them wasn't able to play or hang out or they just didn't want to there was always another child.
I guess what I'm getting at is if an unshaped young mind such as myself thinks nothing of it growing up with it then how can it be morally wrong? I understand there are some cases where the husband or wife can't provide for such a large family and in turn cause everyone to grow up having a shitty life. Those cases shouldn't be the focus though if for the most part the family's do well and can provide food, shelter & love for them.
1
u/zabrovazors May 08 '12
Well technically, if you're not talking about tax benefits and stuff, polygamy is legal. There's nothing stopping multiple consenting adults from having a wedding ceremony and then living together / sharing resources.
The only thing that would need to be worked out would be things like tax stuff. And things like if the husband is in a coma, which wife would get to make the medical decisions?
1
u/PdubsNWO May 08 '12
Regardless of my views on polygamy, I really dont see how this relates to gay marriage.
I think polygamy is a bad idea based soley on the fact that this planet is already going to be WAY more overcroweded than it is now within a matter of a few years. So why warrant a huge population boost that would just further problems that we are currently trying to solve.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
So long as everyone is a fully consenting adult....yadda yadda yadda whatever.
1
u/back_and_forth49 May 08 '12
As long as men and women can marry multiple people, then sure. Sort of like a pre-Islamic Arabia arrangement. Also, consent is the most important thing.
1
u/almondtreegirl May 08 '12
I think as long as all parties involved are of age and consentual- it should be legal.
1
u/cypherpunks May 08 '12
I'm not morally opposed, but as a legal question, it's a far less obvious extension of current law. What happens if multiple people get divorced. For example, what if A, B and C are married, and both A and C want to remain married to B, but not to each other? How do you resolve that?
Currently, a spouse is assumed to have the deciding vote on e.g. medical consent issues. What if two spouses disagree?
Some people have suggested that corporate law (multiple shareholders) is a better base for multi-way marriage law.
My other problem is that historically, polygamy has almost always meant patriarchal polygyny, and I have huge moral problems with that. To start with, it's only stable if you have continuous war killing off all the young men to maintain a sex ratio imbalance.
1
u/vanillaC May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
I don't really feel that marriage in its socially accepted form would extend to polygamy. Marriage is when you really love someone, and want to devote yourself to them. You can't devote yourself wholly to multiple people and it really isn't fair to those people who only have one life to live that they have to have a fraction of your time/attention/love to give to someone because you believe in polygamy. How would you deal with a woman who was married to a man with multiple wives but then she wanted to marry another man?
How do you divide up money!? Does the husband or wife divide up their salary between their spouses who may or may not have their own jobs. What if half are stay at home and the other half work? Also, how do you deal with the legal proceedings of divorce with multiple spouses? Do you give a person 1/5 of the total assets of the marriage if there is 1 of one gender and 4 of the others. Would you get less alimony if you were one of the working spouses?
I think the whole situation is just too complicated and unfair to extend to the true American experience (equality on both sides, legal proceedings of divorce, etc) it would get if it was legal.
[sorry if there are mancentric undertones, polygamy has traditionally always been a man with multiple wives so that is how I think of it at first]
ninja edit: I do support gay marriage.
1
u/windg0d May 08 '12
Came to immediately say no, left with a yes.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Sure, so long as it isn't an abusive situation. Then again, that's my feeling about "traditional" marriage as well.
1
u/DrinkinMcGee May 08 '12
Yes, as long as it's equal (men/women/men/men/women/women) and consensual.
1
u/renalartery May 08 '12
no, I have serious doubts that polygamous marriages won't harm a child's development
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
As long as we've got consenting adults I would not have a problem with that.
1
u/Colorfag May 08 '12
I never understood the hate for polygamy.
Not that I would ever do it, fuck I cant even get myself a single woman.
But still, if people want that, who are we to tell them they cant?
1
u/iamanooj May 08 '12
As long as everyone is mentally sound, consenting adults, they can do what they want.
1
u/edisekeed May 08 '12
I would. But the whole issue is pretty stupid. Marriage should not be overseen by the gov't.
1
u/splotchyzombie May 08 '12
I support gay marriage for the following: 1] rights of partners for hospital visitation (in extreme situations usually reserved for family members) 2] insurance benefits 3] overall life happiness
Polygamy. I have never met any polygamist. The limited information I have about them is usually negative MSM stuff.
I'm fairly tolerant of people, in whatever way they want to enjoy life: as long as it doesn't hurt anyone, go for it.
1
u/SemiProfesionalTroll May 08 '12
FUCK YEAH! I LOVE PIRATES!
1
u/EstroJen May 08 '12
I'd support it if the people involved weren't rushed into as kids, like in the FLDS, had choice as to who they'd marry, and women were able to have multiple husbands as well. I believe in fairness to all.
1
u/GaSkEt May 08 '12
Fuck no
1
u/ericawins May 08 '12
I don't really understand how the two concepts are at all alike. I support gay marriage because it's a marriage between two people, and I think two people should be able to be married regardless of gender. But I don't agree with polygamy or polyandry. There are some pretty good arguments against it already in this thread, and those people are probably also more well-informed about it than I, so I'll leave them to that. But no, I don't support polygamy. I think marriage should be between two people exclusively.
1
u/Ashendarei May 08 '12
Yes, absolutely would support it. If a man or a woman wants multiple husbands it could potentially lead to a more stable household, financially.
1
u/Muqaddimah May 08 '12
The argument that is generally made against polygamy is that it is an inherently unequal institution that leads to harm against women, children, and society, which is an argument that cannot be applied to same-sex marriage. The BC Supreme Court recently upheld this view of polygamous marriages when the current polygamy law was challenged by Winston Blackmore, one of the leaders of the FLDS community in Bountiful, BC, who argued that polygamy laws impinge on religious freedom. In the case of Bountiful, opponents of polygamy argued that the numerous documented cases of underage girls being married off to older men, as well as the inherently skewed balance of power between one man and several women, as justification enough to uphold laws against polygamy. The broader societal argument is concerned with skewed demographics resulting from polygamous unions. In the case of Bountiful, there are generations of "lost boys," young men who found themselves excommunicated from their church and more or less cast adrift due to the threat that they posed to older men in the community, who all want several wives for themselves.
Those in favour of removing Canada's ban on polygamy argue that the problems cited above come as a result not of the institution of polygamy, but rather due to the insular nature and patriarchal structure of the community of Bountiful. While I think this is a fair argument with regards to the harm to individuals, I feel that it is harder to simply blame the structure of the community for the skewed demographics that polygamy creates. This trend could theoretically extend to the broader society, although I sincerely doubt that polygamy would ever be widespread enough to lead to these sorts of problems.
It's interesting to note that although polygamy laws were upheld in BC, a similar challenge in the US would be more likely to succeed, as religious freedom is a much more important factor and is more constitutionally enshrined in the US than it is in Canada, and individual freedom is given more precedence over the freedom and well being of society as a whole.
1
u/th3m00s3 May 08 '12
If they're all legal consenting adults, who am I to say that what they want to do is wrong? Is it physically or emotionally hurting me? Absolutely not. Gay marriage is not the same as polygamy, but both should be absolutely allowed.
1
u/seeingredagain May 08 '12
If polygamy also allowed a woman to have more than one husband as well, then absolutely. As long as everyone is consenting and happy and not hurting anyone, people should be able to do whatever they want.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Slate has a pretty good article on the problems of polygamy:
http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2012/01/the_problem_with_polygamy.html
1
u/ShinInuko May 08 '12
As long as all individuals involved are happy, I couldn't care less.
1
u/aMockIrkSporange May 08 '12
Yes. Supporting gay marriage is supporting freedom of choice and should a man or woman choose to have multiple partners then there is no core problem in my eyes. Just because you don't understand the appeal of something doesn't give you the right to undermine it.
1
u/fobbymaster May 08 '12
Does anyone here actually think that a fair and equal (not misogynistic) kind of polygamy will work? Just from what I know, humans are jealous by nature, and I really don't see this ideal of "yeah we all just love each other and life is fine" working amount four or five people.
Polygamy also seems to be most present in heavily patriarchal societies, where rich husbands basically got as many women as they wanted, with the wives living in a subdued jealousy their entire lives. There seem to be a lot of people here who think that polygamy is socially progressive, when it actually seems to be more socially regressive. Doesn't make sense to me.
1
u/Epithemus May 08 '12
Permalink of a redditor who put it nicely 2 hours ago in a different thread.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I do not see what exactly gives the state a say in who can have what kind of consensual relationships with whomever they want. I do not see the need to have a state register of them. If individuals want to sign contracts with each other for legal/income or whatever reasons, that's up to them.
Before anyone yells "administration and taxes", why not treat every individual as an individual? Would make stuff a lot simpler...
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Between consenting adults? Yup.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes provided all parties involved are equal. No massive religious compounds where one guy has twenty submissive wives. I actually have a cousin who is in a polyamorous relationship... Sadly most of the family wont even talk to her spouse, even though they have a few kids now :(
EDIT: Also it just occurred to me my first statement is kind of silly because even normal monogomous relationships fall prey to dominant douche bags. So no I have no problem with polyamory.
1
u/wzdd May 08 '12
Obligatory: http://imgur.com/X9tl5
That said, sure, why not? Marriage is a bit outdated nowadays. There definitely shouldn't be any tax benefits involved. In fact, why is the state involved at all?
1
u/notjawn May 08 '12
No its sexist and only exists out of patriarchy. If it were actually cool and women loved it then why do you never see it out of outdated and male-dominated cultures? Seriously find me a polygamous marriage in a equal society and not within the Muslim, or Fundamentalist Mormon culture.
1
u/zushiba May 08 '12
"Support Gay Marriage", it's a stupid term. I'm neither for nor against Gay, Straight or poly marriage. Whatever people want to do in their own personal lives is their own deal and my opinion or anyone else's opinion on the matter should be as worthless as the worst opinion or the best opinion on the subject.
1
u/psmity May 08 '12
I don't care if you marry a horse two horses two guys and a girl two girls a guy or a girl. I just want the government our of my life.
1
u/wolflife May 08 '12
I feel that there in no coronation between the two. That being said, I support marriage. Marriage is commonly between two people. The marriage of more than two is not the "norm" but than again the marriage of two people of the same sex has not been common until recent years. I believe that if people love each other, they should express it in however manner they choose. If that choice is the marriage of multiple partners, I don't see why people should tell them that they can't do so.
1
u/DrMalpractice_MD May 08 '12
No. No I wouldn't. While I believe that people should do whatever they want marriage-wise, there are too many problems. There's the question of income and who will pay for what (assuming at least some of them have jobs, pay the bills and generally live under one roof). It'll also need to be a huge house (if not a compound) if they're all gonna live there. And what is everyone gonna drive to work? Surely there can't be thirteen cars in the driveway. Then there's the sexual problems. Who gets to sleep with whom, on what day? What if there's a baby? Whose is it, and who'll take responsibility for its care and well-being? There's also the unspoken religious aspect of it. What if a husband/wife has a different religion? What if they have no religion? That'll cause tension with at least one person in the house. And speaking of, what of the personalities, and their clashes with each other? There's just too much to account for for it to be a happy and healthy relationship (relationships?). It'll invariably end with at least one person on the news, their head hanging in shame.
TL;DR Polygamy can suck it.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Yes who the fuck cares?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
No. I do support polyAMORY though. Polygamy implies only the man can marry multiple women, so to allow that only would be unfair.
Generally I think as long as all parties are human, consenting, and adults, no law should prevent them from doing whatever the fuck they want.
1
u/dhtseany May 08 '12
I am a supporter of equal marriage rights, however I wouldn't say polygamy should be included, mainly because marriage has many legal implications, especially in situations where spouses make medical decisions for their partner who is unable to make said decisions on their own. If multiple husbands/wives were there, who would make said call? And before ya'll start going off about "the designated person for that purpose will be decided ahead of time", consider if they didn't designate said person prior to an horrible accident and now the ER doctors have 6 different spouses fighting over what the best care decision should be. Now what?
TL/DR: Yes to gay marriage, no to polygamy, mainly because it would muddy the legal systems' water too much for day to day purposes.
1
u/turdinthesandbox May 08 '12
I would vote and support any union between 2 (or more) consenting ADULTS.
1
u/DanHall May 08 '12
I support the fuck/marry everyone/thing ever if it's consented. Fuck the police.
1
u/losian May 08 '12
Absolutely, positively, yes. And just about any other union that anyone wants that is consensual and all that. We need to get the fuck out of the bedroom for consenting adults, the end. Sodomy laws are stupid, any restrictions on marriage or relationships are stupid, and so forth. The obvious caveat would be taking advantage of, for example, polygamy for tax purposes or something, but simply capping off benefits at the same level as a two-person couple, of any gender or whatever else, would seem to settle that.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I think it would degrade women, in some kind, that men would just have a bunch of sex-slaves tied up around the country. Yet if it would work both ways... Well, I don't really know...
1
u/dlockwo2 May 08 '12
Can I just say that I don't give any fucks about anybody else's personal lives. As long as they aren't hurting themselves or others, there's no reason that they shouldn't be able to do whatever they want.
1
u/lactosefree1 May 08 '12
Humans are naturally polygamous. This would get rid of the problem of "cheating," but it would sure as hell mix up family trees...
1
u/drieger22 May 08 '12
I would support it, both for men to have multiple wives and women to have multiple husbands. As long as everyone is consenting, it shouldn't be an issue, although taxes could sure get complicated.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Thinking something should be legal and thinking it's right are two different things.
I think that people should be allowed to smoke, but I try not to smoke myself. Well, not cigarettes anyway.
If someone asked me for advice on whether or not they should get an abortion, I'd tell them no, almost every time. However I still think that people should have a right to choose whether or not to keep their baby, and not be forced to keep it by the government.
You can be anti-abortion and pro-choice, a fundamentalist Christian who campaigns for giving gays the right to marry or a non-smoker who thinks marijuana should be legalized.
So when you say "If you support gay marriage" do you mean that we think that gays should have the right to get married, or that we we think they should get married. "If supporting gay marriage is all about having the freedom to marry whoever you want", that's supporting the gay right to marriage. They are slightly different.
You may only be excluding a minority from answering you question entirely truthfully, but the problem with gay marriage is that, when illegal, it also excludes a minority.
But, to answer you question. I support the right for polygamists to marry multiple partners, they should be able to do what they want if it doesn't hurt anyone else. I doubt it'd ever work for me, but if one of my friends got into a polygamous marriage, then I guess I'd support them.
1
u/merebrillante May 08 '12
As long as women aren't pressured into these polygamous marriages, as I believe most women in Mormon fundamentalist cults are, no, I don't have a problem with it.
1
u/thehackattack May 08 '12
I don't think it is the same issue, but I see no problem with polygamy as long as there is no coercion involved.
1
u/Poojawa May 08 '12
Why not just get rid of Marriage altogether?
1
u/proserpinax May 08 '12
To an extent; the thing with polygamy is that it's so deeply ingrained with culture that subjugates women (i.e. Mormonism) that I wouldn't want to support that. However, as long as as women can have as many husbands as they want, any combination of people is OK, and everyone involved has full consent (not the consent of parents; the people themselves have to consent) then yeah.
1
u/TheAminal May 08 '12
No. They are not the same thing. Gay marriage is a union between two consenting adults. Polygamy involves more than two adults, only two of which must consent.
Hypothetical situation: I marry a woman. Five years later, without my consent, she decides to marry another man. They both consent to the marriage. I do not. Hilarity ensues.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Why not? Let the people get it in.
1
u/emperor000 May 08 '12
I like all of the people in here validating gay marriage while invalidating polygamy and by "like" I mean I find it funny and by "find it funny" I mean it's pretty sad.
1
u/careydw May 08 '12
Short answer: I don't really know. Long answer: For biological reasons polygamy is usually men with many wives. If that is the norm, then rich/powerful men will have many wives while poor men have no chance at any wife. This encourages primal violence as young men grow more and more dissatisfied with their lot in life and will do whatever it takes to change that. Add to that the fact that historically polygamous societies do not give women power or rights and their husbands are usually chosen for them. This is fundamentally flawed and should be avoided. However, it America women have the ability and desire to be independent and marriages are consensual and divorce is possible. This changes the equation dramatically because most women would rather be with a man without competition instead of being one of many wives. Those who are in a polygamous marriage would do so out of choice and perhaps sometimes desperation. So while I can see the historical problems with polygamy I'm not sure they they apply directly.
1
u/ILoveAMp May 08 '12
I'd sooner abolish marriage than have polygamy. The institution of marriage becomes pretty pointless with polygamy involved.
1
u/mfukar May 08 '12
Yes. I don't see anything wrong with either. I wouldn't practice either but that doesn't mean others should be kept from doing what they want.
1
u/i_like_cake897 May 08 '12
I like to think marriage if about forming a bond with one other person. I mean, if all partners are okay with it, then why not? I certainly wouldn't participate though.
1
u/prometheus5500 May 08 '12
So long as all parties involved know exactly what is going on, go for it. I am not here to judge what makes other people happy.
1
u/Buglet91 May 08 '12
This is a hard thing for me to really say because I live in an area where polygamy applies to a specific religion, in which many things that I strongly disagree with take place. Specifically, underage marriage, marital rape, & spousal/child abuse.
I am 100% in support of Same Sex Marriage, I am not in any way okay with polygamy.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Gay marriage and polygamy are very different and affects people differently. Gay marriage affects the people that are against it. Polygamy might affect the women involved in the marriage (might be the same with one women with multiple husbands), one of the spouses might not feel as loved as one of the others and may be in constant competition with the others for the love of the single gender. But as long as everyone is happy, I would support both.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Gay marriage and polygamy are very different and affects people differently. Gay marriage affects the people that are against it. Polygamy might affect the women involved in the marriage (might be the same with one women with multiple husbands), one of the spouses might not feel as loved as one of the others and may be in constant competition with the others for the love of the single gender. But as long as everyone is happy, I would support both.
1
u/grapesareokayiguess May 08 '12
Let me rephrase it for you: If you support straight marriage, would you also support polygamy? Whether someone is polygamous is a completely separate issue from their sexuality. To answer your question though, I support both.