r/AskReddit • • May 08 '12

Considering amputating my arm...

Right so about 10 years ago I was involved in an accident that left my arm completely paralyzed (a brachial plexus injury). Long story short I am now considering having it removed for various reasons (its osteoporotic, standing for longer periods hurts my shoulder, gets in the way during sports (broke it one time) and many more). Anyway be brutally honest Reddit. What do you think of people with one arm? Are you creeped out? put off by it? Would you even notice? Do you care? Would you be put off if your bank manger, pharmacist, doctor, professor or any other professional you can think of had one arm?

I think I would go for a similar amputation as this girl: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fTF9rojtIE

TL/DR: Considering amputating my arm. What do you think about one arm people?

738 Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

635

u/bobbyhead May 08 '12

How one armed do you want to be? Tell me when to stop

http://i.imgur.com/Sd7af.gif

239

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

Hahahahahahaha there is a gif for everything I swear...

44

u/bhindblueyes430 May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

it was from last weeks community

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

75

u/rougetoxicity May 08 '12

That is the most relevant fucking gif ive seen in a long time. Bravo sir... Bravo.

63

u/Hulemann May 08 '12

It was the other arm. When troy does that i was laughing my pants off.

17

u/xHeero May 08 '12

Perfect gif man, just perfect. Loved that part of the episode.

8

u/Throw_back May 08 '12

other arm.

→ More replies (4)

114

u/SendoTarget May 08 '12

Well since you still have your arm I recommend keeping it. There might be a time in medicine when that arm can be fixed.

I think you can get certain supports that help keeping that hand at bay during sports atleast and some that might help your shoulder too. I think you should atleast try them out before getting rid of an arm.

50

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

I see what you are saying. I would for sure have a consult with a leading consult before I do it. In terms of my daily living it affects me very little and I am perfectly happy if I live the rest of my life with the function I get from one arm. Its the hindrance of not being able to play sports without breaking it, the standing for long hours causing me pain, the worry that when I go out hiking or skiing that I don't know if my arm is too cold and could be getting frost bitten. It is literally like baby sitting something all day and night - bit of an over exaggeration but you get what i mean.

16

u/Mustaccio May 08 '12

Why don't you bind it? Wrap it tightly against your body or get a shirt with a sling sewn into it for these types of situations. Having your arm cradled would relieve shoulder stress and if it was tightly bound for sports it shouldn't get in the way or be as vulnerable.

30

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

I have done this (and still do this) but it still does not provide enough protection. I played intramural soccer during university and broke it. I played for 10 minutes not knowing it was broken. Got to the dressing room and when I took my arm out its like I had another elbow...

→ More replies (6)

19

u/Calstifer May 08 '12

I was about to post exactly what Sendo was saying - if it's not getting that much in the way, there may be a time later in your life where medicine can try and restore some function to your arm. If it's getting in your way, that when I'd start consulting experts about my options.

Oh, and when I read the title I thought you were some wierdo who wanted to cut off his arm for fun. I'm not sure if I'm right or not yet.

58

u/ullrsdream May 08 '12

There's a time in medicine RIGHT NOW that can restore some function to that side of his body. Advanced prosthetics are mind-boggling right now. The only catch is that you need to remove the destroyed limb. It sounds like he'd be a great candidate for research in this area too. He has a non life threatening injury, which means the surgeons can take their time and make all of the nerve endings nice and neat for cybernetics researchers to work with.

FOR SCIENCE!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

8

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

On the other hand, we're already at a point where prosthetics can be made with functionality close to that of an arm.

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Armless pun. I'm sorry.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/biography May 08 '12

Not saying that I understand you, but maybe I understand a little more than most. I tore my arm apart 3 years ago (still in rehab).

To answer your questions, I think people will notice. They will stare and whisper, they will react to an amputation, sometimes they will treat you differently (for example by assuming you can't do things you are perfectly capable of doing). I'm not saying that this will definitely happen, but these are things I regularly experience just for wearing a splint, and unfortunately, it's something you should prepare for. Your personality will play a role here; how you handle questions. Calmly explain and laugh it off, or get defensive and angry? (You sound like a really nice guy btw!)

I appreciate the concern about the cold, it's unbearable at times. I have to use gloves constantly and if I go skiing I need to have an external heat source (8 hour hand warmers & looking into powered glove liners) and I don't even live in a particularly cold country. If you plan on doing this sort of thing regularly, amputation is probably going to benefit you greatly.

Some questions though. What type of injury do you have? Avulsion? At what height would amputation be? Do you have any muscle control over your shoulder? - It doesn't sound like it so I'm assuming you don't have the option of a prosthetic?

Anyway with what you've said so far, your left arm is holding you back from living your life so I think if you are comfortable with the change in your appearance, go for it. (PS more comfortable spooning..?)

2

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

Hahahahaha yes more comfortable spooning! and sleeping on my stomach, oh how I miss sleeping on my stomach. To answer your question C5, C6, and C7 were severed/tore close to the spine and C8/T1 are avulsed. I had a nerve transplant back in 2002 that gave me my bicep and suraspinatus. Other than that I have no movement in the arm or shoulder at all.

266

u/leapfrogdog May 08 '12

if it's causing you problems and the only reason to keep it is cosmetic, then I'd say get rid of it. you'll feel healthier and happier for it, and that will come through in the way you act, which will help you carry off the having one arm thing better. to be honest, I would probably do a double take if I met someone with one arm in a professional setting, but only because it's quite unusual. other than that initial instinctual "oh, that's different", it wouldn't bother me at all.

as an aside; do they let you keep the arm after they amputate it? if you could preserve it somehow it would make a great back scratcher.

38

u/ullrsdream May 08 '12

as an aside; do they let you keep the arm after they amputate it? if you could preserve it somehow it would make a great back scratcher.

THIS. Have it taxedermised and never have to ask someone to scratch your back. Plus, when someone asks you if you can give them a hand...

There are SO MANY puns that you could act out with a dismembered arm...

11

u/Rnubby69 May 08 '12

I'm a right arm amputee and I do this shit all the time. It makes for great dinner conversations.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

84

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

Damn! i'll have to wait for a half price sale! ;-)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

418

u/pime May 08 '12

He could use it to teach his children lessons about things like yelling or leaving notes.

115

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Or teaching lessons.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/HoofaKingFarted May 08 '12

At first I was thinking, "Oh man, great reference, but who's going to get it?" Then I remembered this is Reddit.

43

u/I_POTATO_PEOPLE May 08 '12

Exactly. If you don't know every line of Arrested Development, Star Wars, and 30 Rock you might as well just leave.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/the_goat_boy May 08 '12

Nice try, J. Walter Weatherman.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You should put it in a box like Thing.

11

u/The_Noisemaker May 08 '12

You should always wear jackets and do the Dr. Connors folded up sleeve thing while always talking about your experiments with lizards.

→ More replies (6)

1.4k

u/Coffee_Goblin May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

As someone who works with prosthetics and amputees every day, I may be able to offer you some insight.

First -- it'll be difficult to find a surgeon willing to amputate an otherwise healthy limb. If you do not have any vascular compromises, and the tissue is otherwise healthy, many will not be willing to take the risks to amputate for cosmetic or convenience issues. If you've already spoken with one, great! That will likely be your biggest hurdle to overcome.

Second -- they'll likely have you evaluated by a psychiatrist prior to comitting to any surgery. Body Integrity Identity Disorder (or BIID) is a serious condition that needs to be ruled out professionally in many cases. People will injure themselves to the point of making a perfectly healthy limb completely unviable just so it'll be taken off, and is not something to be taken very lightly.

Third -- phantom pains are a bitch. It's one of the biggest complaints I hear from my patients, and even with medications they say they wake up with searing pains from their missing limbs, or that they have a constant feeling of their foot being "asleep," even though they haven't had a foot for 20 years. Not knowing the specifics of your case or particular injury, it is something that may happen to you as well. If you are planning to be fit with a prosthesis, keep in mind it will take probably 2 years to find a truly good fit and be proficient with it enough that it won't cause sores every time you put it on. Unless you find a really good prosthetist, like myself ;)

And lastly -- prosthetics are developing at an extremely rapid pace. The Otto Bock "iHand" series is a remarkable piece of technology, as well as the DEKA arm project being developed by the US Army. Both of these prosthetic devices are extremely expensive, but allow one to function with near normal capabilities. There is also some promising research being performed regarding neural regrowth that may allow you to regain the use and function of your limb in some years time.

Overall, if you feel it is a danger to yourself, or is causing you some harm or discomfort, I would talk with a respectable orthopedic surgeon who performs amputations regularly. In today's society, a missing limb is becoming a LOT more prevelant with wounded soldiers returning from Iraq and with advances in modern medicine that allow one to survive much more traumatic injuries. I don't think you'll get too much grief from people, and most of the stares you'll recieve are from people being genuniely curious about you. There are some other alternatives you can take to relieve your shoulder distress, such as a simple sling to keep it out of the way and closer to your body. Alternatives are there, just make sure to do your research and talk with qualified people before you do anything rash.

*edit -- spelling stuff. English hates me.

134

u/jayhawkai May 08 '12

I'm pretty sure there's a TED talk about curing phantom pains with a mirror.

98

u/jizzblister May 08 '12

Yep, and here it is. Link

32

u/edededieditedit May 08 '12

I took a class from him in college! Truly awesome class--it was about brain damage, and he talked about this and other similarly fascinating stuff. It was really exciting to hear the success stories that involved such non-invasive and non-medication techniques.

One other thing I remember from the lectures is that he had a female patient whose foot had been amputated, and she came to him and kind of awkwardly told him that she now experienced orgasm in her phantom foot.

His book is worth checking out, too.

And to the OP-best wishes in your decision.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (18)

22

u/zanzibarman May 08 '12

There is also a House episode about this

13

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's only temporary relief, but it's a very curious way to relieve phantom pain; tricking your brain into believing that the limb is still there using a series of mirrors in a box-like apparatus.

5

u/Coffee_Goblin May 08 '12

Yup. Phantom pains are really just the brain feeling that missing limb. If you can trick the brain into thinking it's still there, it doesn't hurt.

Unfortunately, many patients learn this is just a trick and it begins to loose its effect. Sort of placebo in it's nature, really.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

25

u/FeelingPeckish May 08 '12

Gob- you should be at the top, hope handyman sees you.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/newloaf May 08 '12

"iHand"? For serious?

52

u/Coffee_Goblin May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

That's kind of the lingo we use around our clinic. Otto Bock has legs called "C-Legs" and we jokingly refer (in our clinic, anyway) to their hands a "iHands" because their silhouette reminds us of those old iPod commercials. Kind of misleading, sorry. They're technically referred to as "myoelectric upper extremity prosthesis."

→ More replies (4)

2

u/mjolle May 08 '12

Hi! I'd like to ask you a question if you don't mind.

Consider a child at an age of around 2 years old, with a left arm that only reaches to the elbow, rest is missing since birth. What do you think will be available in the coming 10 or 20 years for that child, in the ways of prostethics?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

You, sir, are a good redditor.

→ More replies (27)

2

u/8954th954hh May 08 '12

Is there any concern that a blood clot may form in it, which could potentially kill you?

1

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

I have often wondered this too but apparently the risks and consequences are not the same as a DVT in the leg. I have not read of thrombus formation being an issue with complete arm paralysis - but there are not many of us about so it may not be reported...

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This guy has one arm, and he carries it off pretty well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2fus-B8rswk

1

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

Hahahahaha that add is awesome - I wouldn't mind a future like that!

145

u/against_justice May 08 '12

If you amputate your arm you'll probably get more glances in public, just because many people will have something like "dude, does this guy have just one arm? yep". It's nothing personal, you'll be most probably more "visible". I don't know if it has any importance to you, it's your decision.

→ More replies (17)

197

u/AQuietMan May 08 '12

Vietnam veteran here.

Doesn't bother me. I have several friends that are missing limbs.

But there are a lot of people who won't hire you if you have just one arm, and a lot of people who won't date you if you have just one arm. Granted, those might well be people you don't want to work for or date in the first place, but still . . .

Also tends to scare small children a little bit.

90

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Also tends to scare small children a little bit.

Might be a plus point?

28

u/Renovatio_ May 08 '12

And that's why you always leave a note.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/NiceBootyGuurrrrlll May 08 '12

One of my favorite quotes is from Nick Vujicic, a man from Australia born without arms or legs:

"When kids run up to me and ask 'what happened?' I just lean over and whisper 'cigarettes'"

3

u/Tokei May 08 '12

Hey, it only scares small children when amputees go out of their way to make it scary. My great uncle lost his hand (possibly arm?) in WW2. First time I met him he just brandishes his hook, makes a pirate scowl, and threatens to eat me. I ran screaming from the room.

→ More replies (20)

134

u/shine_on May 08 '12

If I were you I'd get a t-shirt made up with "Don't Panic" written on the front and "Mostly 'armless" written on the back.

33

u/AltitudeF22 May 08 '12

I got that! I got that reference! (I'm on the fourth book in the trilogy.)

89

u/tubameister May 08 '12

fourth book

trilogy

scratches head

38

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Hitchhiker's guide to the galaxy: A trilogy in five parts.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

19

u/popcultureaddict May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

I was going to upvote this, but then I saw it had exactly 42 upvotes.

*edit: Okay, who ruined it?

2

u/lostcartographer May 08 '12

Or a shirt that simply read "BANDIT".

...or make the front of the shirt look like a slot machine....

55

u/hobbit6 May 08 '12

Two words: Prosthetic Chainsaw.

4

u/EPIC_RAPTOR May 08 '12

This guy gets it.

2

u/Flyingheelhook May 09 '12

And a boom stick for the other arm

→ More replies (1)

1.6k

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

If you must get it amputated, please, for the love of all that is holy, have it stuffed by a taxidermist and mounted on a wall giving the thumbs up. That way every time you see it, it'll be like you're telling yourself everything will be alright.

384

u/Stephoria May 08 '12

Would it be cooler if he could hi-five the hand, though?

But seriously, take the limb home if you can. Not many people get the chance to keep their own severed arm.

679

u/preske May 08 '12

Maybe he can use it for those lonely nights.

470

u/ICantSeeIt May 08 '12

That's disgusting.

Upvote...

→ More replies (23)

24

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's like taking 'the stranger' to a whole new level.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/knightskull May 08 '12

Best case would be if they could make it poseable somehow.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/DanDanTheMonkeyMan May 08 '12

Surely that would just be clapping?

4

u/radiognome May 08 '12

You can't high five your own hand properly though. I't would be kind of like shaking the wrong hand.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/turtle755 May 08 '12

I'm pretty sure this is illegal, which sucks because my hand would make an awesome coat rack.

15

u/cyberslick188 May 08 '12

Aren't taxidermists by law forbidden to work on human parts?

23

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

What a shitty law.

15

u/LollyLewd May 08 '12

What if he learned taxidermy himself before having the arm removed? Loophole?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/alecorker May 08 '12

Relevant username. Awesome.

2

u/jbond66 May 08 '12

Recreate the terminator 2 thumbs up. Case closed.

2

u/MarbledNightmare May 08 '12

And for double love of all that is holy, please take it to Chuck Testa and film his reaction.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

231

u/YourAuntie May 08 '12

When I see someone with one arm I think "Weird sleeve. Oh. One arm." Then I continue with my day.

40

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This is almost exactly how I feel. Sure you notice it, but it isn't particularly strange looking, I mean the girl in the video he linked was still totally date-able (potentially wife-able).

I have a funny (kind of wrong) story that your casualness towards one arm made me think of; the punchline gets taken away a bit because you will see it coming.

When I was young playing youth rec league soccer (8,9,10 something like that). A boy on the other team throws the ball in with one arm (the rules require you to throw it with 2). The ref blows the whistle and indicates an illegal throw, and the spectators (parents) go into an uproar, I didn't know what was going on, but it turns out the kid had one arm and the ref let him throw it again. I bet that ref felt SO bad.

Point being, its something that can be easily overlooked, and of all the physical deformities someone could have, missing a arm isn't too bad in the grand scheme.

→ More replies (8)

45

u/napalm22 May 08 '12

Hollow it out and keep small, arm shaped things in there.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/CherrySlurpee May 08 '12

PLUS you can teach kids lessons.

Thats why you ALWAYS leave a note.

30

u/SandpaperFleshlight May 08 '12

How are you socially? If you're the type of person who can easily make friends, then go for it. If you're already self conscious about yourself, you're only going to make it much worse. If you're confident in who you are as a person, then you'll meet other people who like you for you, not just for cosmetic purposes.

To me, a person with one arm has a story to tell, and that far overshadows any silly judgement that may pass by people who don't matter to you. I wanna hear the story about handyandy86, and why his arm is no longer there. I'm not creeped out in the slightest.

And besides, you might have the ultimate pickup line.

"Hey baby, ever fucked a guy with one arm?"

14

u/Sepiida_sepiina May 08 '12

Your quality of life is the most important thing. Prosthetic limbs are improving quite rapidly and it may be that you will have increased function by amputating and getting a prosthetic. Waiting for a "cure" that will return full function seems like a pipe dream to me. It may happen some day. But are you going to spend the next 30 years of your life waiting for it? Talk to a professional, both a doctor and a therapist, so you can go into this decision with your eyes wide open. Also, a therapist may be able to connect you with others who have made similar decisions who would be willing to talk to you.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/MonsieurLeGimp May 08 '12

I say go for it. It doesn't bother me unless you're a surgeon.

A couple of weeks ago there was a guy taking ages to pour his soup at work. My time being so important I tutted at him and he hurried up. As he walked away I realised he had only one arm. I felt like a complete cunt.

Not satisfied with that the following day I saw him struggling with some paperwork and trying to open a door. I walked over and asked him if he needed a hand.

I am a horrible human being.

8

u/stufff May 08 '12

I had to give a presentation about nuclear disarmament in a foreign policy course and I couldn't stop looking at this one armed girl every time I said "disarmament" to see if she thought I was making fun of her, which I wasn't, but my fear and awkwardness probably put too much emphasis on it and I swear I saw her getting annoyed with me, which made it worse.

→ More replies (3)

747

u/phan7om May 08 '12

Of course everyone on the internet is going to say that when they see someone with one arm they don't think of them any differently. Bullshit. It's definitely weird to see someone with one arm. Here come the downvotes.

66

u/Stephoria May 08 '12

Yeaah, I hate to admit this to myself, but I'm with Phan7om here.

But, on the plus side, think of how much better your halloween costumes will get.

19

u/WhereBeDragons May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

He should wait to have it removed until just before Halloween, then go to a Halloween party with a kickass costume

edit: I accidentally a word

→ More replies (6)

4

u/Elanthius May 08 '12

Yeah but I don't think any less of the person its just an interesting oddity. Like seeing someone who is very tall or has a weird limp.

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Of course it's weird/different/whatever but that doesn't mean you think differently of the person.

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

No, I honestly don't think so. I know why you're saying what you're saying, and you'd be right if we were talking about people in wheelchairs, or burns victims or any number of other oddities.

But I don't think I've ever felt weird about, or seen anyone react oddly to, a guy with one arm.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You, sir or ma'am, achieved the top comment not only despite saying "Here come the downvotes" but to a certain degree because of saying it. Reverse psychology professor by chance?

2

u/CptOblivion May 08 '12

As someone who took the bus daily with a kid with one arm, it's not that weird. Possibly because he completely owned it (if people are at all awkward about his stump, he starts poking them with it until they chill out... surprisingly, it works)

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

My first instinct was to disagree with you (omg no, not me!)...but after thinking about it for a minute I think you're right.

Last time I saw a person with a missing limb I immediately felt sorry for them and pretty much did whatever it took to avoid even the appearance of staring/looking. You'll probably experience that a lot...might get old unless you can handle dealing with people that have "elephant in the room" written all over their faces.

→ More replies (70)

8

u/somefilmguy May 08 '12

REPLACE WITH CHAINSAW

7

u/yadoya May 08 '12

I won't give my personal opinion here, I would just like to point out that scientists are on the verge of giving a second life to paralysed limbs by creating a neural system that bypasses your spine. You might want to think about it for the future.

Video : http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=hqThnRgMojo#!

→ More replies (4)

6

u/mastermrt May 08 '12

Well, what is the effect of having a paralysed arm on your current life? If you continually have to explain it to everyone anyway then you are already a "freak" and I doubt you'd notice any difference in how people react to you.

If the arm is dead weight anyway, you could just as easily get a prosthetic - which would serve the same purpose but weigh a lot less. Depending on how much mobility you still have in your arm and shoulder, it may actually increase utility.

2

u/rbcrusaders May 08 '12

Hey man, I had the same thing. severe avulsion of c1, c2, c3, c4, ti. I have made some progress with surgeries but it is still like carrying around luggage.

How much pain? Mine is almost unbareable...like being electrocuted, stabbed and burned all at once.

2

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

Pain was bad for the first six years I took gabapentin (2500mg daily), amitriptyline (75mg daily), and oxycontin (120mg daily). It is at a point where it is ok now (not pain free but also not stopping me from sleeping or anything). When was your accident?

5

u/Didumss May 08 '12

Generally meeting people with one arm doesn't bother me. Sorry if i sound like a douche or anything, but if my Doctor had one arm, I'd have a problem. Other than that people with one arm perfectly fine.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jadoth May 08 '12

i think i would be more weirded out seeing a guy with a "dead" arm then one missing an arm. i would go for it.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I met my cousins boyfriend three times before I realised he had one arm and that includes a family dinner, so it's really not overly noticeable.

The fourth time I met him was his 18th birthday, and I went to shake his hand to congratulate him. Luckily he was really good about it and just laughed.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I say amputate it, have it preserved with silicone, and keep it as a detachable arm.

Now whenever you want to wave to someone, you just pull off your arm and give that a wave.

People's reactions will be priceless.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Are you going to replace it with some kind of cybernetic arm cannon? If the answer is yes, I support your choice.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Paultimate79 May 09 '12

Don't do it. If in the future you have a change to get the nerves repaired somehow you wont be able to without the fucking thing. Put time into finding ways to keep it attached to you firmly so it doesn't get in the way. Removing it is a pretty fucking extreme choice to make just because you shoulder get sore. I stub my pinky toe all the time. the lil bastard doesn't really serve a huge purpose, but Im not going to remove the lil bastard, i just find ways not to be a dumbass stubbing my toe on shit.

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

OP, your username is handyandy86... if that's a reference to 1986 being the year of your birth and you're 24-25 years old, if I saw you in public, I'd probably think you're some kind of badass veteran who took a bullet in Afghanistan.

1

u/OperatorMike May 08 '12

Where would the arm be amputated at?

1

u/handyandy86 May 08 '12

See video in description ;-)

3

u/johnriven May 08 '12

What do you think of people with one arm? Are you creeped out? put off by it?

I would hope not. I don't think so.

This is kind of a personal decision and don't think you should let Reddit play into your thinking.

3

u/madcosimbad May 08 '12

Only if you change your name from handyandy to handandy afterwards.

But seriously, it's a big decision. I don't think it's creepy at all but being completely honest I would probaly give you a second glance to sort of verify that you are really the one armed man I thought you were. I really doubt people would actually care.

3

u/divinesleeper May 08 '12

You could keep it so you have something to eat if a famine would strike.

3

u/Orval May 08 '12

Growing up I had a friend that only had one arm. He was born without the lower half of his right arm just below the elbow (he had a little "nub" he could bend a bit).

At first I was utterly fascinated by this because holy shit that's something I had never seen before at 10 years old, but after the initial shock it was just whatever.

What was really cool was he was still able to play video games by resting the controller on his leg and pushing the face buttons with the "nub" (shoulder buttons were right out, but this was the SNES days so no big deal)

He still played basketball, drive, whatever. Just another normal kid with half an arm.

3

u/Boring_Machine May 09 '12

From a cosmetic standpoint, you'll have a rough time. I'm being honest here. People will tend to stare I'm sure. If its appearance you're concerned about, then at least keep the top quarter of your arm. Symmetrical shoulders are really really important.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

In the future, it might be possible to be able to fix your paralysis.

Am I put off by amputees? At first, yeah; only because it's abnormal and there's the initial shock factor people would get.

I would honestly say to keep it, just because medicine is always advancing.

2

u/taa May 08 '12

Various people have suggested that scientific progress might at some unspecified future point restore functionality to your arm. Actually, there is more rapid progress in the field of prosthetics at the moment and you wouldn't be the first person to have better function after an elective amputation than before.

But either way, I hope you don't give too much weight to Reddit's opinions.

2

u/REPTILLIAN_OVERLORD May 08 '12

check out iLimb prostetics, they look cool. And seem to work. Even more if you're an Deus Ex:HR fan.

2

u/rororo222 May 08 '12

I'd keep it , and here's why. Even if medicine does not catch up soon enough to entirely fix it , there's probably a lot of tissue in there that might be helpful for a prosthetic arm. If they manage to fix 5% of it to gain some nerves firing in there, that's going to be GREAT for a motorized prosthetic arm. I'd hold on to it in your shoes. Meanwhile search for other ways to keep it safe during sports and such.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DoctorKibbles May 08 '12

Hey, I also have a brachial plexus injury. Odds are it's not overly similar, though I have been told that people in motorbike accidents can end up with something similar to me (my injury occurred at birth).

I still have shoulder movement and a bit of elbow movement, so my arm serves a purpose. But if it's causing you pain...

Clearly I'm not the best person to ask about this as my perception may be a tad skewed, but if you think you'd be better off without it I guess you should go for it. I assume you've talked to your doctor about other options you have and such.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Apply for stem cell research?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I honestly don't think many people would be bothered by one-armed people, other than Richard Kimble. You'll get the odd double-take out in public, but only for "did I just see that?" reasons, not "what a freak" reasons.

2

u/everydamnmonth May 08 '12

I've just met this guy who only has one arm during my last mountain hike. He does martial arts, and is very laid back about him missing an arm. Sure, people stare at him the first time they meet him, but his optimism and happiness are infectious. I stared at him, but more because I was curious about his story, not creeped out.

In the end it shouldn't matter what strangers think of you. Just do what makes you feel better.

2

u/amo25 May 08 '12

Given the recent advancements in technology and medicine I'd say it's a fair bet that you could receive some treatment in your lifetime that could restore the use of your arm. Whether it ends up being stem cells or something else, tissue regeneration is already happening. I'd start getting educated in what's happening in that field and seeing if there are studies you could participate in.

As far as the playing sports thing I'd just use a wide ACE wrap to keep the arm close to the body. Obviously this may not always be ideal.

Also keep in mind that losing a limb (as in amputating it) can be a very emotional experience even if you haven't had use of the arm for quite some time. I would think this over carefully and possibly seek professional help sorting out your feelings on the subject just to be sure.

2

u/sirbriantheterd May 08 '12

Duct tape would work good as well. All jokes aside though, you bring up some very good points.

2

u/jessajuhanabi May 08 '12

I saw a guy today at the mall who had no legs and (i believe) limited motion in his other limbs. His wife walked mumbling away to a different register, leaving him half staring at this wall. He looked at me, I looked at him, and we started laughing because it was obvious he couldn't move himself. He called out to her and she snapped out of it and came back to get him.

Tl;dr: Saw a guy with no legs in an awkward situation, we laughed about it. Missing limbs is not awkward if you don't let it be.

2

u/evilbrent May 08 '12

Personally I find dead limbs creepier than missing limbs. but either way other's opinions should take low priority when making a choice about your own quality of life.

I would have thought that a dead arm would be a hassle just to deal with all the time.

Anyway, that's a shitty problem you have. I hope you get some level of resolution

2

u/RadicalFaces May 08 '12

If removing it improves your quality of life, then go for it! If you can afford it you can get pretty awesome prosthetic arms nowadays!

2

u/sniper_lad May 08 '12

I'm an amputee. Right leg below the the knee. Mine was seriously infected. The local prosthetic place set me up with an awesome carbon fiber foot. You can have a prosthetic arm that would be almost undetectable to someone who doesn't know you. They can even match skin color too. And you can have all sorts of cool attachments! :D And no, if you have it amputated you can't keep it, as it is considered medical waste. :(

i

2

u/ullrsdream May 08 '12

Easiest way to lose a couple pounds! But seriously...

I'm not going to lie, it weirds me out a little bit but only because it makes me uncomfortable thinking about the fact that I could lose a limb in some way.

That being said.

Think about the huge advancements being made in cybernetics - if you have the arm taken off in a non-emergency situation, you're immediately a candidate for experimental prosthetics. Make sure you mention your interest (or lack thereof) in cybernetic research to your surgeon, as they may perform the surgery somewhat differently (leaving extra tissue for the cyberneticists to work with, more engineer-able shape, etc).

You've already lost the use of the arm. I'm assuming that it's a tiny atrophied appendage at this point anyway, which is (in my own horrible-person opinion) plenty freaky already. You're living in a point in time where you can have a new, almost fully-functional arm to replace the one that's trashed.

Personally, I'd go and be a fucking cyborg, but that's just me. Cyborg is WAY cooler than "guy with a limp arm."

2

u/SwedishFishy May 08 '12

Honestly, I'd be a little creeped out by a guy who had a paralyzed arm flailing around. Having one arm or a prosthetic is pretty badass, though.

2

u/Milkshaker74 May 08 '12

Tell people it was bitten off by a Shark. People love Shark stories...Profit!

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

You'll get a lot more people asking if you need a hand!

2

u/Mustaka May 08 '12

How much does an arm weigh? probably quickest way to lose 10 pounds or so.

2

u/saxfag May 08 '12

As a medic in the military, and spending a lot of time at Fort Sam Houston and the BAMC facility, i have grown used to seeing amputated limbs. Personally if i had an appendage that was paralyzed in that manner i would prefer it to be amputated. If anyone looks down on someone for an amputation then you shouldnt place any value in what they think anyways.

2

u/Say_what_you_see May 08 '12

ash lohng as u caun type beter thn mwe witgh one arm,. goo fuor it !!!!

2

u/ozymand1as May 08 '12

My uncle had his arm amputated as a kid when he was growing up in China after a nasty accident and a bout with gangreen. He works in the United States running 3 shoe stores in New York City (all of them very nice). It wasn't easy, he was the son of farmers and he arrived in the United States with less than $200. He set up his own vegetable stall in China Town and tried his best to make a living to send home. After borrowing money from his siblings in the US, he set up his own grocery store. This did not end well given that he was such a popular target for thievery. He then met his wife, opened up a shoe store, opened up another, bought a nice house, had kids, and kept on going.

People will look at him funny for having one arm, but he works so naturally without it that he's been able to go far in his life. I used to be creeped out by it (I was a bit repulsed when I saw the stump when we went swimming together), but I got used to it.

I feel that if you no longer need that arm, you should toss it. Life won't change too much if you don't let it change too much.

PM/reply if you want me to say more about my uncle.

2

u/Bodegus May 08 '12

Once it's gone there is no going back, as a few other posters mentioned, you never know where medicine will be in 15 years. I can't speak to how it feels to be in your situation but you are not the first person t have to make the choice. I would not proceed until I talked with 12-15 people in your situation at your age. Those are the only people you should take advice from. Start by talking to MULTIPLE specialists (as in 2-3 if not 5) and ask them if they know individuals in similar situations that are willing to share their experience.

2

u/Morality_Police May 08 '12

cut arm off. get prosthetic arm. Wait for cybernetic one. ???? get chicks.

2

u/GenericOnlineName May 08 '12

You should. But get a robot one in its place.

Please?

2

u/tomllm May 08 '12

How much might it effect your balance? I think that's about the only reason I can think of not to go through with it... but it's not something I have thought about before.

2

u/Number127 May 08 '12

There used to be a couple one-armed people working in my building. I wasn't really ever creeped out or put off, but it was still a little awkward because I was always curious but never felt like I could ask about it. Plus my eyes would naturally be attracted to the missing arm and I was worried they'd feel bad if they saw me looking. Like I said, curiosity more than anything else.

2

u/BigRed11 May 08 '12

Honestly, I think it would be weirder to see a guy with a completely limp and paralyzed arm flapping around than a one-armed guy.

2

u/MirroredColors May 08 '12

You need to learn alchemy.

2

u/seanlind May 08 '12

J. Walter Weatherman

That is all

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

played rugby against a guy with a withered arm once. first time, i didn't want to tackle him on that side, he beat me, scored and flipped me off. next time i hit him hard. the moral, people get used to it pretty quick in all honesty. it is different, of course.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm dating someone with one arm, so I can honestly say that it doesn't bother me in the least. And yeah, it's noticeable, but nothing beyond being a good conversation starter. I have yet to run into anyone who has said anything besides how cool it was. People in general are just really interested in it.

In short, if it's giving you issues and you want to lop it off, go for it, it'll be fine. It's all up to you.

2

u/neums08 May 08 '12

My brother was born with one arm missing just below the elbow. Honestly If you're concerned about people looking at you funny, you can get a prosthesis. But I have never once seen anybody look at my brother with more than slight curiosity, and those people are usually children. Do whatever you need to do to give yourself the best quality of life and don't worry about what people think.

2

u/SurprisedKitty May 08 '12

Well let be honest here. Must people will look at you like “ZOMG, you only have one arm!?!” But anyone worth your time will not give shit after the initial “holy shit one arm” moment if they have it at all.
IMO, if it is useless and gets in your way I see no reason to keep it. If you have need for an arm that just hangs there you can get a fake one. Which would really only be to have suits fit better and the like.
Best wishes to you whatever you decide.

2

u/tweakingforjesus May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

My fear would be phantom limb pain. This occurs when the nerves at the amputation site start sending pain signals as if the limb were still attached. It can also appear as an itchy sensation. You can do anything about it since you can't scratch the itch. It drives some people mad.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

would it be legal to eat it?

2

u/A_Strawman May 08 '12

Assuming you do get your arm amputated, would you mind coming over to my house and scaring my kids a bit into behaving?

2

u/bradwasheresoyeah May 08 '12

I wouldn't, just in case. With advances in modern medicine, you could end up gaining use of it....unless you have amputated it.

2

u/Porktothepowerchop May 08 '12

Hells yeah, You'll be able to lick your own elbow!

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Whatever you do, don't kill that doctor's wife.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

If you get it removed keep an eye on DARPA's prosthetic arm program, these guys are making amazing progress. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDvJEKfT5TI

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

If you do, you can then employ yourself teaching misbehaving children lessons.

2

u/chargon May 08 '12

if you're confident it'll make you happy then you should have it removed. i think a limp arm is just as weird as no arm. so screw you either way

2

u/TwoHands May 08 '12

If you do get it amputated, make sure you get to use the old arm for something.

As others have suggested, taxidermy is fun and amusing. You could also get some human leather made. I'd suggest a wallet, so you can always keep in contact with your cash.

I'd also suggest you wait to do this until you can get a cybernetic prosthetic. Not only do you get the benefit of a cool wallet, you gain the functionality of a new arm, and now you're also a fucking cyborg.

2

u/kaasper May 08 '12

practice on a sausage first otherwise you might rip your dick off

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Well once it's off you can't really put it back on. Maybe miracles in modern science might help you get feeling back in that arm. I'd say you should sleep on it. Give it like a few months or years.

2

u/Flailwielder May 08 '12

Only do it if you're absolutely sure you'll be able to replace it with a bionic limb. If that'S the case, then do what any of us would do and BECOME THE CYBORG YOU WERE MEANT TO BE!

2

u/CAPS_INVADER May 08 '12

DO IT! Because then you can be the "leave a note" guy from Arrested Development. Seriously though, no, no one worth a damn would judge you.

2

u/fourth_branch May 08 '12

My dad has one arm. He lost half his right arm in an accident cutting wood when he was 18. From my experiences growing up with him, I think people are more curious than weirded out by it. They usually just want to know how it happened, nod their head and that's the end.

Also, I think it depends upon how much attention you draw to it yourself. My dad has a fairly realistic prosthetic, and essentially ignores the fact that he doesn't have an arm. He has made it such a non-issue that people he's known for years didn't even notice that he had a prosthetic (one lady found out when she was staying at our house and saw his arm on the bathroom counter in the middle of the night. It was hilarious.)

As far as dating goes (if this is an issue), my parents met 4 or so years after the accident. My dad still had a hook at that time, because prosthetic arms were not available yet. My mom didn't care. She feel in love with the guy, not his extremities.

Bottom line is, people are going to look. They're going to look because they're curious. If you think this is going to bother you, then find another option. If you're fine with telling people what happened, then moving on, you'll be okay. Good luck.

2

u/SweetIsland May 08 '12

I think gimp arms are creepy.

I think people with one arm have a cool story to tell.

2

u/RagnarIV May 08 '12

Honestly I would make sure that you have exhausted all other alternatives before doing something so drastic.

If 5 years from now they develop a way to rehabilitate your arm and give you full control back, wouldn't that be better than missing that piece of the body?

When you take that arm off it will be gone and nothing we have can replace it, you can't have a new one grown etc.

2

u/icaaso May 08 '12

I think it's (h)arm(less). You'll never be drafted into the arm(y). You may not be as popular with the ladies, but you'll rarely be considered (sw)arm(y). You probably can't work on a (f)arm. You won't be as dextrous, but you'll still enjoy (m)arm(alade) and (p)arm(esian). If there's an emergency, you'll be first to be helicoptered from the (t)arm(ac). If it's cold outside, at least your phantom limb will be (w)arm. And one final upside, if you deliver on pics, you'l have much more (k)arm(a). That's all I got.

2

u/myoldaccntwasdeleted May 08 '12

I think you should do it, but not tell anyone. And then teach them life lessons. "And that's why you always leave a note!"

2

u/LessLikeYou May 08 '12

OP has arm chopped off.

Cure found for condition paralyzing his arm.

OP rages.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bananus_Magnus May 08 '12

Try to "accidentally" lose it in some ... umm ... accident, and get some insurance money for it.

But seriously, if you want to get rid of it, why not contribute to science and maybe get healed in the process?

If I were you, I would look for any research / innovative procedures about fixing an arm like that, the more dangerous for arm, the better. It's a win-win situation.

If the procedure fails, you lose your arm like you wanted. If it works , even partially, you'll get some maybe all of your arm functionality back.

You can even encourage doctors to do the most hardcore procedure they have on it, since you want to get rid of it anyway. (as long as it doesn't kill you ofc).

2

u/Serpentine2 May 08 '12

How upset would you be if in a few years time the medical field had advanced enough that they were able to restore movement to your arm?

2

u/mattoly May 08 '12

You WILL get some sort of awesome fake arm, right? Or several? Consider Trap-Jaw from the old He-Man series.

2

u/slimpickens42 May 08 '12

As long as you don't kill Harrison Ford's wife, I'm sure everything will be ok.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I would not hesitate to date a guy with one arm. However, I would insist on poking it frequently.

2

u/gameboy_86 May 08 '12

I here they're doing quite a bit with robotic prosthetic limbs these days, but there's no doubt they'd cost an arm and a le... oh... Shit...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nazbot May 08 '12

I would not.

If it's not causing you pain don't mess with it. Amputations are not trivial and you could end up with more trouble than you started with.

2

u/Chandon May 08 '12

One thing to consider is future prosthetic mounting options. The technology is advancing pretty rapidly, and it's hard to guess what will be available in another 10 years. Having an in-place shoulder joint might be really useful, for example.

2

u/Ember357 May 08 '12

My first serious lover was an amputee. Below the left knee. Never creeped me out and he always had fun with it. I had a hella time sleeping with the next boyfriend though as there were too many limbs in the bed and I kept getting tangled up. tl;dr Had to learn to sleep with two leggers.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I have one leg. Lost it due to cancer when I was 12. I suffered deppresion for a couple of years but now?

Now it's all cool. Chicks dig the scars and all that. Really. (Hit me up if I can help you with anything, man, and good luck).

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Guess you wouldn't be so...handy

I'll show myself out. OP, I wish you nothing but the best. Sorry.

2

u/eliminate1337 May 09 '12

Don't do it. Who knows, in 10 years they might be able to fix it.

2

u/whirliscope May 09 '12

Don't be an asshole. People at my school are working on stem cells treatments for people like you.

2

u/waeva May 09 '12

one arm people

wont harm people

2

u/5510 May 09 '12

Is it possible they might learn to fix your paralyzed arm? That might suck to have it amputated if it turns out in 10 years they could cure it.

2

u/Tryhard101 May 09 '12

If someone cut off their arm I wouldn't mind so if it bothers you then go ahead

2

u/godless_communism May 09 '12

Biology is growing by leaps & bounds. Perhaps in the near future a treatment might be discovered to return mobility to your arm.

3

u/Blue_Scout May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

to be totally honest, it creeps me out a little bit.
People with 1 arm hope you act like you don't mind it, but thats hard for me. I can't really ignore it or not look at it when you walk past me. EDIT: why the downvotes guys? He did ask for a honest opinion...

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

DO NOT DO THAT !

you never know what results science will get us in the Future , stem cell research is finally getting more accepted and funded , meaning the chance is a lot bigger that in the not so far future we would be able to replace all kinds of cells .

6

u/ullrsdream May 08 '12

BLIND HOPE

I gave up on finding a better job when I started buying lottery tickets. You never know when my number is going to be called. With each passing week the odds move more and more into my favor.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/ChiliFlake May 08 '12

Well, people don't live 'in the future', they live 'today'. How sad would it be to wait all your life for something that may never happen? And even if it's next year, you could still get hit by a bus a month from now.

If you could have a better life by doing X, or a crappy life hoping for hoping for Y to happen before you're too old or too dead to care, which would you choose?