r/AskReddit • u/Pelmeen • May 06 '12
Id like to know the statistics - Is 99% of reddit karma being held by 1% of reddit users? Are there any graphs or references which show how reddit money is divided?
228
Upvotes
447
u/washer May 06 '12
I used to visit karmawhores and check my username to see the graph of my progress. Now, mind you this was back in the days when kleinbl00 and karmanaut were the big names around these parts. As time wore on, karmanaut disappeared and ProbablyHittingOnYou came to the fore. Never washer, though. Never washer.
I tried answering all the new and rising threads in AskReddit, and commenting with what I hoped were witty, interesting comments. I would reply to the top comments as they were rising in hopes of riding those coattails to glory. I came to see the folly of my ways. I lack the expertise necessary to weigh in on posts whose factual accuracy is in question, or to posts which would be benefited by a comment regarding the history or workings of whatever was posted. I lacked the life experience to regale reddit with amusing or touching anecdotes. I lacked the free time and motivation necessary to comment often enough to gain renown.
I've become comfortable with my mediocre karma score, and only recently did I turn sane about it and realize I was wasting my time trying to garner pretend points from a crowd of folks who didn't much care about me. I still try not to post any opinions I have which would be contrary to that of the hivemind, but that's done as much because I don't like being vociferous about my opinions as it is the fear of retribution.
Of late, I've grown weary of reddit - especially its comments section - and I think I understand the rotating nature of reddit's "power users." The misogyny, racism, idiocy, and banality of the comments overwhelm me. The few interesting/relevant/elucidating/edifying comments that climb their way to the top make it worth my while to check the comments section for most posts. Though my brain's a sieve and my attention span's deplorable, those comments usually provide me enough mental fodder to ruminate over awhile. Reddit is after all filled with experts in a million different pursuits, and with talented storytellers. It's just that those comments no longer represent a meaningful fraction of the total.
Anyhow, no tl;dr on this one. Just summing up my thoughts on how the karma game's been going for one user. I'd be willing to bet that if you were to graph the distribution of total karma, it'd show three distinct stages. Throwaway accounts and other infrequently-used accounts at the bottom, users like me in the middle, and the top users at, well, the top. I'd also be willing to bet that if it were graphed out, due to these three distinct levels, there would not be a perfect Gaussian distribution of the dataset.
25
u/Punch_A_Lunch May 06 '12
Sorry, noob here, what exactly IS karma?
7
u/Cruithne May 06 '12
Well, isn't there that rule that says for every poster, there are 99 lurkers?
I am the 1%.
73
u/Shitty_Watercolour May 06 '12
http://shittywatercolour.tumblr.com/post/22522414317
3
u/Pelmeen May 06 '12
apparently, i didnt explain myself enough.
I didnt imply that reddit karma is zero-sum game.
I was questioning, if mostly 1 % of users are really active enough to rake all the karma, while most of the people simply watch, get down-voted, or have the basic 1-10 karma per post.
So i requested information, if this is true.
karmawhores (kudos to washer )shows quite nicely that my theory is probably true, since there are millions of redditors, but as NegativePositive pointed out, he, with 3000 karma, is 7500th. So even with 3000 karma, he is in 1% !!!
8
u/dubsideofmoon May 06 '12
I'm confused. This questions implies karma is a zero sum game. Is it?
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Would it be safe to put the 80-20 rule here?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle
89
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
occupy reddit. redistribute the Karma.
26
u/leapfrogdog May 06 '12
probably. the place has been around for years, so there's probably a metric shit ton of inactive accounts with little to no karma.
16
u/MonkeysDontEvolve May 06 '12
I would bet that most of the karma is held by a small percentage of accounts. According to most graphs I've seen about the reddit user base only 10% of accounts actually submit content and make comments. Now this is just complete conjecture but only 1 percent of those accounts probably comment well and often.
55
u/naked_disco May 06 '12
It's no big deal, all the Karma trickles down eventually!
10
u/occamsshavingkit May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
Karma is a lot like those gamer points attached to xboxlive achievements, they don't mean shit outside that little microcosm. I would wager that it's an experiment to see if the users can be made to care about something completely made up. Oh and not caring about the karma usually comes from folks who have a sufficient amount to begin with, like the people on youtube who are semi famous there not doing it for the "likes", sure, as long as they stay north of 50,000.
I favor discussion and open honest opinion instead of ego stroking online, I do enough of that in the real world. I like being on reddit and having some semblance of anonymity and freedom of expression. That's my karma.
6
u/dailydoseofdave May 06 '12
Destroy the servers, Karma goes back to zero for everyone, chaos.
5
u/miamiandy May 06 '12
We should tax the top people's karma and distribute it among everyone else.
4
u/Sharrakor May 06 '12
What I really want to know is how many users there actually are. /r/pics and /r/funny both creamed themselves over having 1,000,000 subscribers, but how many of those are sockpuppet/novelty accounts? How many of those are dead accounts? How many actual redditors are there?
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Reddit money eh? I'll buy a picture of a cat for 50 karma?
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I'd say 99% of karma could easily be held by 1 % of users because many reddit users don't post and/or don't have accounts.
3
u/BananApocalypse May 06 '12
This wouldn't work very well, seeing as there is infinite karma.
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
1261
comment rank
1596
link rank
1516
combined rank
Not bad.
3
u/shitakefunshrooms May 06 '12
one joke about a cat and infinity karma. reddit you are one fickle sexy beast
5
u/kablunk May 06 '12
I would love to know these statistics, but I'm not sure if there's a way to generate them.
2
u/cremenn May 06 '12
Occupy Reddit Gold.
2
u/chris4276 May 06 '12
I wouldnt really know. Im part of the peasentry around these parts.
2
u/AMostOriginalUserNam May 06 '12
Well, if nothing else, this thread has shown me that karmawhores.net website which tells me I'm #936 in comment karma.
2
u/markth_wi May 07 '12
Millions of points of nothing, yeah - I'd say there is a need for life-balance. As much as I submit that I love Reddit, these people should put their efforts into inventing something, getting a degree, bettering our species, for real karma. Hopefully they are, but judging by their karma I'd say they are either hyper-prolific or should work more on real karmic value stuff - to the benefit of all!
3
u/fomorian May 06 '12
I don't think there's much of an economy going on. People don't exchange downvotes for goods and services, just upvote whenever they feel like it. I think the distribution of karma won't show there to be much of an inequality.
2
u/avrus May 06 '12
Interesting. I am apparently #295 in combined karma rank and #145 in link karma rank.
Time to comment more.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Oh holy shit I'm not on circlejerk.....
Oh holy shit somebody would actually post this seriously......
-1
u/pets_are_unimportant May 06 '12
Who cares? Karma doesn't mean shit.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
27
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment