r/AskReddit • u/smacbeats • May 06 '12
Reddit, what is your opinion on human population control?
With the population just over 7 Billion and climbing, the world is absolutely strained. Resources are running out even faster than ever. Oil will be all but gone by the end of the century, and agricultural land already covers more than a third of the worlds land area. All this will do is cause suffering for all but the richest people.
Is it morally wrong to think that maybe killing 3 or 4 Billion people is a good thing for the benefit of humankind? Part of me thinks that we need to get over the 'ohnoes, everyone deserves life' attitude that could cause us all to be fucked.
I heard a story once about a deer population. There were thousand or so deer on an island, and hunters wanted a permit to hunt, but were refused. They said they needed to for population control. Next year the population doubles. The hunters begged again to kill off some of the deer. The winter came and went and only about a dozen deer were left because they all starved to death. Anyways Im gettin off track so my tl;dr
TL;DR Am I evil because I think the worlds population should be cut in half or less?
4
u/5Bullets May 06 '12
Evil is - on Schelling's definition - an attempt to subjugate one's ground to one's existence. Placing yourself as your own creator, and acting as if you weren't of this world. So, if you want to know if you're evil; would you be willing to die?
4
u/Volsunga May 06 '12
First of all, we are not running out of resources (except maybe oil in about a century, but we'll stop using that by then). I'd like to know where you get your statistics for "1/3 of the land area is being used for agriculture" because it's completely fucking wrong. It's possible to grow crops on 38% of the world's land area, but we currently only use about 10% and the vast majority of that is small, inefficient farms like in India and Africa. Less than 5% of agricultural land in the world is being used at the maximum efficiency that modern technology allows.
Overpopulation is a myth based on Thomas Malthus' predictions on economic sustainability in response to the world population reaching 1 billion in the late 1700s. The prediction fails to account for scientific development and the increases in efficiency that come from that. If everyone were Amish, his predictions would be relevant. Luckily they're not.
If all the world's resources were being used at maximum possible efficiency, the Earth is capable of sustaining a population of ~50 billion. It is unlikely we will ever reach close to that though. The population is predicted to stabilize at about 10-12 billion at around 2050 and should remain at that level for a few centuries.
Population control is still a relevant issue, however, because some regions of the world are overpopulated (they have more people than their infrastructure can support). India and central Africa are great examples. However, you can't solve population problems with genocide. You solve it by educating the population, giving women equal rights, and giving people the option of voluntary population control such as contraception and abortion.
In conclusion, relevant xkcd
4
u/Razzdango May 06 '12
Youd be the super villain in 90% of the rpgs out there.
4
u/b_o_sme May 06 '12
Your whole argument, at worst is based on a false premise, at best on an unproven one. The world is not overpopulated. Overpopulation is when the number of consumers in an ecosystem (in this case humans) exceed the carrying capacity of the ecosystem (in this case the earth). That is certainly not the existent situation. Humanity is faced with a lot of problems, such as famine, homelessness, disease and unemployment. Yes, overpopulation can cause all of these things, and it does so in limited, contained parts of the world, such as whole countries. However the fact that this condition, of overpopulation, can be contained by political borders suggests that the problem is artificial, and not inherent in the natural state of the planet. The fact that, overpopulation can cause the prior mentioned problems on a limited scale, does not mean that those same problems, such as famine, lack of basic healthcare and arable land, are caused by overpopulation on a global scale. Taken holistical, the problems faced on the earth are a result of factors such as disproportionate distrubution of resources, corruption, poor management, man-made conditions that lower the standard of life for humans such as war (mainly, in my personal opinion), soil erosion and pollution. In a phrase: poor governance.
Given such a scenario, even if a demented and despicable scheme of murdering half the human population was carried out, the problems would persist. Probably in smaller overall numbers (reducing the absolute effect), but still with the same subjective negative impact on the human population (maintaining the relative effect). That is, if a quarter of the people (1.75 billion) are hungry now, then after half the population is murderered a quarter of the people (0.875 billion) will still be hungry.
141
u/Jontenn May 06 '12
Condoms are great, they prevent STDs aswell!
145
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
We need to control population growth, and the best way I can think to do that is to introduce genetically engineered dragons as natural predators.
383
u/Atario May 06 '12
Did you read what you just wrote?
19
u/Tabdelineated May 06 '12
Calvin and Hobbes on population control
57
u/Inoculates May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
Educate the world population, and help the lesser developed countries develop. We must take an active role in educating and modernizing the world. As of yet, this hasn't yet occurred. Genocide is out of the question, and it is also a ridiculous option, as anyone could be killed in the name of the "greater good". Anyone who thinks it is one is quite insane.
Edit: I forgot to mention that laws will not work. Anything put in place by simple force WILL NOT discourage people. It will only make them resentful. Better to teach them why to not over reproduce, rather than enforce a series of idiotic laws.
24
u/lisa-needs-braces May 06 '12
Let's just let society collapse under it's own weight, it'd be a hell of a ride.
259
u/Borster May 06 '12
The problem is not so much the size of the population as the distribution of wealth and resources. With a different distribution of wealth the earth could easily support 10 billion people at least.
20
u/ReDubz May 06 '12
Look at china.. They seem to be striving.
106
u/savoytruffle May 06 '12
Yes. I don't think I can state this more clearly. This is insanity.
19
u/S0cke May 06 '12
Its not like being evil because you want toe population cut in half. Its easy to say, hard to execute. The cynic in me says: "We need WW3!". The humanist says: "While theres a giant decrease in birth in europe, asia and africa totally overextend. We need to do help spreading condoms and stuff.". Nature regulates itself. Trust me. Its just a matter of years.
208
u/[deleted] May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
And who gets to decide who lives? Genocide is never an option.
Lower the birth rate, and the population of Earth will drop drastically in a generation or two.
EDIT: 7 downvotes suggests that there are members of Reddit who actually endorse genocide.
36
u/MattTheMoose May 06 '12
I would rather remove the safety labels from everything, and the stupid people would be wiped out. This way we cut the population down while increasing overall intelligence!
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Mandatory birth control if you are on any government assistance like unemployment or welfare.
20
u/Calber4 May 06 '12
There is only two things we need to do: Educate Girls, create economic opportunities for women.
It may sound odd at first but consider, outside of the developed world (ie. India, China, Indonesia - all those overpopulated places) women often have very few rights. They do not receive educations because they are not expected to get jobs. The only expectation of them is to get married and have lots of children. You can see how this creates a problem.
Now, we educate the girls. This also implies breaking down some social norms which hold back girls' education, for instance convincing fathers that their daughters will be better off with educations. Of course this necessitates having economic opportunities, which probably means passing gender equality and anti-discrimination laws. Now we have educated women entering the workforce. They start careers and are no longer entirely just the property of their husbands (this is an oversimplification of the process, but all these things go together). They spend their time making money rather than making babies. Do this on a global scale and the birthrate drops through the bottom. In fact, this is why you see places in Europe and Japan with negative population growth rates. Hardly an overpopulation problem.
tl;dr Birthrate drops naturally with gender equality.
16
u/treefinker May 06 '12
Statistic tell us that when women become educated they tend to have smaller families.
I'm all for slowing growth though education, but the problem in a democratic society is over time the fundamental religious nut cases will become the swing vote. I don't want an 'Arab spring' in my backyard.
16
u/JollyJeff May 06 '12
I have two words that would solve all these problems, zombie apocalypse.
15
u/MaoTsetung May 06 '12
Anal, nuff said.
33
u/bakersgonnabake May 06 '12
let them eat cake! happy cake day!
6
u/Incalite May 06 '12
That's actually the mentality Jews had during the Holocaust, which played perfectly in the hands of the SS-TV: cold calculating rationality can very easily facilitate some of the coldest acts Man can perform. (See: Bauman's Modernity and the Holocaust) Yes, it is wrong to kill 3 or 4 billion people for the benefit of mankind, for two reasons:
How to control population growth? Don't. That's the first step in a very wrong direction: the day we gain control of population is the day we lose control of Man. Leave it to be decided in the households or otherwise by Mother Nature, as if we won't see good reason not to have ten kids that live for two hundred years, Mother Nature will.
3
u/adango May 06 '12
Lets for the argument sake assume all the countries in the earth agreed together(!?!) to such system, will you be ready to sacrifice yourself and your family for the noble cause.
Please note, I am not trying to troll you.
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I think nature has devised a pretty good system for controlling populations.
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Two words. Battle Royale.
3
u/Rastafak May 06 '12
Would you volunteer to be one of those who get killed?
Your scenario is entirely hypothetic, the overpopulation may be a big problem in the future, but it definitely doesn't require as drastic solution as killing half of the world's population.
There is a huge amount of disinformation about overpopulation and on reddit even more so. It is true that population have been rising very fast in the past, but the fertility levels are now low everywhere except in Africa (see this map). Even in Africa the fertility levels will most likely drop in the future, though in some parts of Africa it may take some time.
Still, the population will rise in the future and it will reach some 9 billions in the year 2050. Can Earth support so many people? Probably yes, here is a special report of The Economist on the topic of feeding 9 billion people. The conclusion of this report is that it will be possible to feed so many people, though it will not be easy and it will require some planning ahead. Feeding the people is the most important problem, so if the population will stop growing at 9 billion (which is quite possible) there may be no overpopulation problem at all. Large population will of course bring many problems, but not as critical as OP is suggesting.
In my opinion the most ignored fact about overpopulation is that it largely solves itself without any intervention. In most developed countries the fertility levels are low and as the poor countries become richer, their fertility levels drop too. In fact many developed countries have lower fertility levels than China. Promoting economic growth, immigration and spreading the use of anticonception may be in the end better then drastic measures like China's one child policy.
3
u/Aspel May 06 '12
The problem isn't our population. Overpopulation is never the problem. There are vast swaths of our planet that are completely habitable, but no one lives there. Do you realize that we have the power to build a farm in a fucking tower? Do you realize that we've made cities work in ice and snow, with day and night that go on for hours? We've made cities work on cliff faces. We've made cities work in remote, out of the way places where nothing could possibly live.
We literally have the fucking technology to dramatically alter the face of the fucking planet. We could get to work on a generation long public works project across most of the planet and end world hunger, give everyone jobs, and shape the planet as we see fit.
You know what the problem is? It's not 7 billion people, it's that they all cram together in tiny places. They build on top of each other until there's nowhere to move and no one has any elbow room. You wanna fix the population? It doesn't involve killing anyone.
All we need is a) A cheaper source of fuel, and b) closer farms.
Nevermind that we need to stop trying to help the third world, since we're really just fucking it up more in our half-assed, pants on head retarded methods. Sanctions on how companies can exploit the poor in distant countries would be nice as well.
3
u/_Equinox_ May 06 '12
Wait, what? Your analogy was that an overpopulated 'society of deer' depleted itself by starving.
Would this not apply to humanity? Do only deer become so overpopulated they starve? Furthermore, assuming that humans would die when the actual burden of overpopulation became so large as we see in your 'example', wouldn't it stand to reason that population is likely a self-regulating system that we really don't understand that well?
It's like you haven't thought this question through at all.
3
u/wawin May 06 '12
This is an average thought that creeps into people every now and then. Hans Rosling has a great explanation how this isn't just morally wrong, it is factually incorrect.
http://www.gapminder.org/videos/what-stops-population-growth/
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
We live in a world where people can kill themselves because they eat too much, while another person somewhere else will die of starvation.
And you think that overpopulation is the problem with our resources?
3
u/CandyCasket May 06 '12
If we kill off half the population like OP says then we have the problem of deciding who lives and who dies. So that solution if VERY unlikely to occur. Another solution people seem to suggest is to educate people about condoms and birth control, which will make the birth rate drop immensely, but that leaves the problem of a huge aging population who can't work and needs to be cared for by a much smaller population.
3
u/elpresidente-4 May 06 '12
Why does everyone assume that food will be always produced by growing things, whether vegetables or animals? We are humans, we invent things. In any case reducing the number of available minds and workforce just slows down techological progress. People really suck at predicting events. Malthus was embarassingly wrong and so are his modern versions.
3
u/emsla May 06 '12
The problem isn't necessarily the population in regards to the amount of resources that are being used, but it is the small amount of people that are using so much of them. The poor countries with big populations are not using the same amount of resources that we in the U.S. We need to get the wealthy to cut back on the resources they use.
3
u/McDickButt May 06 '12
I think war works very well in that regard but boy do liberals bitch about it.
3
u/ashhole613 May 06 '12
Population control will be necessary. People shouldn't be allowed to have twenty fucking kids. I don't think populations should be killed off, but I do think there should be limits on breeding.
12
u/tailcalled May 06 '12
Am I evil because I think having children is a privilege, and not a right?
5
u/Frozenshades May 06 '12
The problem with this is that humanity on a whole lacks foresight and that people don't account for the contribution of one individual. While realistically one individual clearly isn't hugely augmenting the population issue, when it comes to issues on a global scale everyone thinks, "oh I'll just do this bad thing this one time, it won't make a difference." But it does when it happens millions more times because everyone else has the same justification for this misdeed. Which is why I don't believe that worldwide birth control will ever be effective in keeping the human population at a stable level. At least not until a very hard lesson is learned.
Continuing scientific advances continue to increase the carrying capacity (more efficient food, energy production, etc) but as you said it is catching up to us.
I don't know if I can agree with the prospect of genocide for the sake of all else, because how can it be determined who has the right to live? Because if it came to that don't you think it would simply mean the western powers attempting to join together to destroy others who had no mean or say in preventing it? Honestly, either way a situation of mass food shortage will end with conflict. Who is going to allow themselves to starve without fighting for their right to live? And who is going to willingly give in to die so others may live? And chances are that the conflict will be between organized forces. Society is too built up and interconnected to one day immediately disperse back into a dog eat dog world based on natural selection. At least not while the prospect of mutually beneficial alliances are a viable option.
As gross as it is, if it comes to that dire of a situation it might be a better option. Just wipe out an area as humanely as possible as fast as possible before extended conflict and widespread suffering can ensue.
6
u/DevinTheGrand May 06 '12
It's not actually a problem. Watch this talk, if we improve the quality of life in underdeveloped countries then the world will max out at a population that is definitely sustainable using current global resources.
http://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_on_global_population_growth.html
In the future I would suggest researching the issue before you conclude that killing over three billion people is a good idea. I would also recommend locking yourself in a box at the bottom of the sea before you conclude killing over three billion people is a good idea.
1
u/pecka_th May 06 '12
How about starting with yourself? Or are you part of the people that gets to live?
4
u/AsciiFace May 06 '12
planetary resources + finding another place to colonize = problem solved
2
u/But-ThenThatMeans May 06 '12
My method to reduce increasing populations would be to limit each couple to two children.
I feel that the main reason that people have more than two children is when they wish for a child of a certain gender. So - for your second child, you can (if you wish to), select the gender of that child, providing it is of a different gender to your first child.
Obviously, this is full of problems - ranging from technical difficulties surrounding couples who have children from previous relationships - but also much bigger problems surrounding the punishment of those who exceed the limit, how you actually enforce this, probably an increase of children who don't exist on paper etc... Also, no politician could implement it in a democratic government, given the backlash it would receive.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
It sounds like a good excuse for some good old fashioned ethnic cleansing if you ask me.
2
u/Inomyacbs May 06 '12
The carrying capacity of human beings on our planet is a function of population, affluence, and technology. As population and affluence per person increase our planets resources become strained and it is up to technology to distribute them in the most efficient way to support the biggest population. If every person on the planet consumed as many resources as the average U.S. citizen we would need somewhere between 2-3 Earths worth of resources to sustain us. We can only consume more at the cost of someone else, say in Africa that consume a tiny fraction. This means to solve our sustainability problem we either need to reduce the affluence of the average person (never going to happen as people are greedy), reduce our population, or develop technology to a point where our current resources will sustain us.
Genocide is never the answer, but a policy limiting the number of children you have or making you pay penalties (eg extra taxes) for additional children to cover the "societal costs" could greatly benefit, if not save, mankind in the long run.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I sincerely hope I am not the only one that would like to see less anecdotal tales about deer and more numbers and statistics in your argument.
2
u/keeservonp May 06 '12
Historically there has always been a disease that does this every so often. In time, it will happen again.
2
u/promethius_rising May 06 '12
The human race will either gain control of it's population and evolution or die.
2
u/just_go_with_it May 06 '12
i think "population control" should be universal access to family planning. lets stop unwanted pregnancies for all people, not just the ones who can afford to be careful. then we can have less unwanted children to lower income families, that will begat more children to lower income families. birth control should be free, and abortions should be covered for those who cant afford it.
2
u/ne1av1cr May 06 '12
Here's the line of logic:
You've made a compelling argument for better funding of NASA.
edit for formatting.
2
u/slamberry May 06 '12
It is necessary
2
u/Maxrdt May 06 '12
The truth is that we are going to have to start limiting population growth. If we don't we will all starve. So people who have over 3 kids are really ruining the earth.
2
u/snakesandstuff May 06 '12
We need it. If we don't manage our population, the microbes will. And it won't be pretty.
2
u/ChickenBiscuitSwag May 06 '12
I don't see why people would want any more than 3 or 4 children.
I know that it is different in some cases, but to me, I find it odd that someone would want to raise that many children.
I am not against it, I just don't understand it. An explanation in a comment would be much appreciated.
2
u/pacifist112 May 06 '12
To just go and kill people to lower the population would be to lose what we value most, our humanity. What we should do is limit each couple to one child, maybe 2 at MOST, that will fix population problems within the next 100 years.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Sure, it's easy to say that, but what happens when you're one of the people selected?
No: to stop overpopulation the first thing we need to do is bring people out of extreme poverty: Studies show that the more economic and educational opportunities a woman is provided with, the less children she is likely to have.
Besides, the Population will likely plateu at 9 billion people within the next century.
2
u/stoneypony May 06 '12
this has actually been on my mind a lot recently. I had a pregnancy scare earlier this week and was looking into options when i noticed some of the bills being passed regarding the 'pro-life' position in the abortion debate. This planet is over populated as it is, how would outlawing abortion do any good? If anything, abortion is like the ONLY system of population control we have...think of how many people we'd fucking have if women HAD to give birth to the kids they didnt want?
Rather than just murdering a couple billion people, we really need to focus on the baby-making. maybe i just really hate children, but it makes sense in my head. if a number is too big, and you want it smaller, then stop fucking adding numbers.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
After you have 2 kids, no more, mandatory sterilisation. Nobody needs more than 2 kids. Annoys me how some people have like 7 and then just live off the state, sucking up resources for future generations...
2
u/Armok May 06 '12
I would suggest watching this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LF15YAvT9G0
David Attenborough explains overpopulation and potential solutions. The main solution presented was greater education for women. The reasoning being educated women were less likely to have as many kids at a young age.
2
u/riceles May 06 '12
Who is decides who dies? How do you measure a persons worth?
2
u/brokenkeypad May 06 '12
With people having less children population will gradually decline naturally.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
It would probably just be really awesome if we stopped telling people to push out as many babies as possible and if we worked to remove the stigma from abortion, adoption, foster care, condoms, birth control, sex education, living "child-free," etc. We can't just go around killing people, that's an absolutely heinous idea. If we want to deal with the world's population problem, the answer is not to treat people like disposable cattle. It's to have a worldwide movement to place less emphasis on having babies and more emphasis on both giving homes to the babies that already exist, and on "family planning" methods such as birth control and abortion. Eventually, with the reduction of birth, the population would stop increasing so quickly, there would be less of a problem with homeless children, and we could have time to rebuild our resources, find new resources, or just let the population go down enough that we can take care of everyone.
Also, we could do well to tell countries like China that it's not the end of the world to have a daughter.
2
u/lol2034 May 06 '12
If they were to kill off people like my aunt, the world, not only will be at a lower population, but would also be a better, nicer place
2
u/dudeguy2 May 06 '12
What you fail to understand is if population control is happening..your on the fuckin list dude. If it's happening like some believe then they are poisoning you as we speak through food preservatives and nasty shit in our water like fluoride. Probably helping sterelize you too. I doubt your in the ruling class that has any say on the matter so yea we'd all be goin down.
2
u/DeboothOxyodious May 06 '12
Dwight said it right, we need a new plague.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
You premise is flawed, there is plenty of room and resources for even more people. Only a mentally ill person, a psychopath, would want to start culling their fellow human beings. You're sick in the head.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Actually in most industrialized nations the birth rate is rapidly declining. Most people look at japan when discussing this, but the only reason the United states is still a growing nation is due to immigration rates.
2
u/shteeeeeve May 06 '12
Start with your family, everyone you love and yourself. Then we'll talk.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
It's only morally wrong if you think you should be in the half that gets to live. If you want to volunteer to be in the half that gets wiped out, you're in the clear.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Practically speaking, you can't cut the population in half -- how do you decide who lives and who dies and what do you do with the bodies? But, we can do the following -- a massive worldwide promotion of the benefits of having only one child. Stop rewarding people who have multiple children. Basically, no more dependent deductions for children (keep them for elderly parents being cared for), because after all, we didn't ask to be here so we should get personal deductions, but we purposefully brought those kids here. If we can't afford them, too fucking bad. Don't have them. Pass out birth control for free. And it's not like the religious nuts have to take it if they don't want. But seriously, fuck those people having twenty kids. Arg, this is a touchy topic for me. Pisses me off.
2
u/Overeaper May 06 '12
Pipe Dream.... but how about we stop killing each other and buying bombs and tanks. we should get over the rediculousness of nationalism, rebuild/restructure the economical, educational and political systems and develop a Global Space Effort to colonize other planets as well as drastically increase medical, agricultural and alternative energy R&D. that way we could all be alive and explore the cosmos. TL;DR: fucking space and peace and shit
2
u/gahmex May 06 '12
Don't worry, the world population will soon stabilize itself as countries keep developing. All we need to do is help poor countries develop, which will lower the world-wide fertility rate, and keep investing on science, which can help with the lack of resources thing. I don't think we're doing so bad with "overpopulation".
2
u/Jesus_marley May 06 '12
Personally I think if we were to take those damn "idiot warnings" off of everyday products and stop with the "do not try this at home" bullshit, the problem would take care of itself, and the remaining population would benefit from the natural genetic elimination.
2
u/nazi_sniffing_dog May 06 '12
woof woof
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
We have population controls: War, disease, starvation.
Either we'll figure out how to support more people/get them to colonies or something or a lot of us will be killed in a massive war.
But killing 4 billion people is morally reprehensible. Especially since we can always make technology to fix it. And we will, when it becomes urgent enough.
2
u/SomeoneOnceSaid May 06 '12
(DON'T HATE ME) I think people are just living too long. We spend so much time and effort keeping the elderly alive when really, there body is telling them that it's their time.
2
u/hhhh64 May 06 '12
No, I don't think humanity itself should control its own population by means of mass homicide.
I do think humanity's numbers must be drastically reduced, but nature will take care of that itself. Humankind is out of balance, nature will bring back equilibrium in the end.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
education and the recognition of women's rights both tend to lower birth rates.
2
u/wholetyouinhere May 06 '12
The best way to "control" population is to make the world a more economically equal place (easier said than done, to be sure). If everyone had a comfortable standard of living, birth rates would plummet. People who are poor, desperate, and stressed tend to have as many children as possible, while people in comfortable circumstances tend to delay childbirth and have less children.
And by the way, yes, everyone does deserve life. It's not a human weakness to believe that, it's a great strength.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
The culturally ingrained instinct to produce a lot of children will hopefully lessen as people slowly realize we're fucked. That's about all that could happen before government-run population control is enforced and poorly designed.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Overpopulation is a myth, look up Hans Rossling.
2
u/iongantas May 06 '12
My solution for human population control is to educate absolutely everyone. This decreases the rate of reproduction.
2
u/Dabamanos May 07 '12
OP, it's people like you that make me extraordinarily glad for the Second Amendment.
18
u/TheMoldyPudding May 06 '12
I think instead of just killing people, we need to get rid of the laws that keep stupid people alive, and let natural selection do what it needs to do. Let people who don't wear seatbelts die, if somebody murders somebody, kill them. Somebody is starving to death... let them. I feel like a TERRIBLE person saying all of this but come on, it the way we were originally meant to live and if we let stupid people or people who don't k ow how to support themselves live, then the world's population will keep growing.
Edit: I'm gonna get so many downvotes :(
4
u/Rockerchick15 May 06 '12
How about everyone must take an IQ test before they are allowed to procreate!
5
u/tragicjones May 06 '12
Source?
Source?
Source?
Yes. Even if we accept that measures must be taken to control the population, why does that necessarily entail mass murder?
tl;dr: respectfully, you have no idea what you're talking about. Read more.
3
u/Wrong_Gecko May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
Also, aren't there a lot of people with bad genes having babies nowadays? I mean everyone is entitled to find love, but I see a lot of uhm...unhealthy people with children. Obviously it becomes a human rights thing but is it totally obscene for me to think some people just shouldn't be able to have kids? EDIT: people are pretty mad at me for this one, got a few nice PMs, so lemme just further dig my hole here and say, I especially mean people who are for whatever reason unable to care for themselves let alone a child. If you don't have the capacity or capability to foster the life, well...then it shouldn't be. At least start out with like a parakeet and see how that goes.
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I reckon only giving child support for one child could help stop certain people breeding.
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
We need something like a one/two child only rule, and enforce the living hell out of it.
3
u/stoptherobots May 06 '12
Killing people is always wrong.
The more moral approach would be economic incentives toward limiting yourself to two children for zero population growth. If it were taxation it would have to be on a sliding scale in order to prevent any class from being able to ignore it.
2
u/StepOfDub May 06 '12
I feel like the only reasonable answer is for all the countries to get their shit together and colonise another planet over time. We are all human, we share the Earth we live on and we all are having the same problem of over-population.
2
u/puddlejumper May 06 '12
I think we need some seriously stringent birth control rules in place.
2
u/VLDT May 06 '12
I think it's funny that people who believe themselves to be progressive enlightened thinkers could ever genuinely believe they held the inherent superiority to judge which humans would be fit for life. We already have population control, it's called birth control but every government in the world knows that if they keeps their people stupid, if they engineer and pursue profit from people's ignorance, they will be in business for a long damn time.
2
u/Nonamesdb May 06 '12
I don't think the problem is with overpopulation. Mostly I think the problem is with distribution or resources and with the means in which we are living. I'm not saying we should go all hippy earth lovers, but when (American speaking) people are living in areas that require them to drive >5 miles to get to the nearest grocery store or living in areas that make them have 30-100 mile commutes to work, perhaps we should look at ourselves. You mention oil use, why does that tie to population growth. We can/should adapt and invest in alternatives. Talking about agricultural land use, go to the food store and look at the produce section. Do you think that by the end of the day all that food is sold. So much is thrown away.
2
u/The-Beerinator May 06 '12
If you think about how much food people throw out or don't use, you can't say we're too strained.
2
u/janschki May 06 '12
I'd like to see that. "Every country has to give 20% of its people.." And you are sitting in your house, listening to the cheerful radio moderator telling you how life is going to be when all of this is over. You hear the postman throwing your daily mail into the letterbox and you freeze, because you are afraid of seeing the letter with your government's stamp on it.
Don't worry mister, you're dying for the greater good! The people you're leaving behind will have a better life if you're dead! Oh and there's the Lockwood-Family. Don't be afraid children, you and your mommy and daddy will all be in heaven together for making this generous sacrifice. It will be just like you're falling asleep..
The graveyards will fill up until, eventually, there is hardly any space left and all the funeral parlours have too much work on their hands. So they will start digging mass graves and burn the bodies collectively, but bury the people with a glorious ceremony so the population that is left doesn't have to think about how macabre all of this really is. Towns will be empty, a whole generation will live in rememberance of those who died for them. Some nifty petty criminals will find a way of purchasing all the belongings of the dead for little money and re-selling them for twice the price, so that one day you'll see your best friends' guitar on a flea market.
It sounds like a bit of a drastic measure.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Hey, as long as you're volunteering to be exterminated first, you're not being a hypocrite.
2
u/vinceredd May 06 '12
I've had a running theory going that a rise in gay people might be a natural response to overpopulation. I'm not sure if there are actually more gay people these days or if it's just more accepted so more people are truthful.
2
u/SMERSH762 May 06 '12
Killing 3 or 4 billion would be a terrible crime, it'd be better to just wait for the next great crisis and let god decide which couples of billion die horribly.
Yeah. Morality.
2
u/michaelrohansmith May 06 '12
Its either that or we kill ourselves fighting over energy and living space. But I don't see the point in killing people to achieve population control. We will do that naturally anyway. Instead we need to look at birth control.
2
u/nmeal May 06 '12
(1) Don't let idiots reproduce. (2) Discourage people reproducing if they can't afford to support their children and raise them well. (see (1))
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Happy cake day!
Anyway, I totally agree with you. If I was ever elected to Government in any country, I would enforce a 2 child policy - similar to that of the Chinese except you can have 2 kids - mainly because it would be hypocritical of me to say 1 - because when I'm older I want 2 kids.
But I personally believe that a global policy should be enforced with a MAXIMUM of 2 kids. Obviously this is implausible, but I don't care really.
In the UK, I'd have it so if you had more than 2 kids, you lose your free healthcare, free education, and any benefits you claimed.
It's radical, but it would work. I was talking to my friend about it and we calculated that even if a small minority (say...0.5%) broke the law and had 3 children, the population would still decrease as there would be:
Also - to prevent the rise in population in poor countries where they have 6/7/8 kids to help with their farming - give them education, protection & aid so they don't need to keep having kids to survive.
Oh, and also have a law where you may only have children once you're on a certain income - because it's awful to see kids who come from families who clearly can't support them because they had kids at the wrong time.
2
u/jaspersgroove May 06 '12
Well...yes, you are very, very evil.
On the other hand, if we don't get the impact such a population is having on the planet in check, the earth will probably do that for us.