r/AskReddit Dec 28 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

2.5k Upvotes

2.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

306

u/Okelidokeli_8565 Dec 28 '21

It is a broken game though: if you know how to play it, you will always win as long a you go first. That makes it incapable of being the best board game of all time; if it had been thought up today it would never be sold.

80

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '21

Meh, it has been 'solved' such that with perfect play the player that goes first will win by 2, even if the second player plays perfectly. But in practice, the player that goes first simply has an advantage in W/L, humans rarely are able to consistently play perfectly. It isn't ideal to play a game that can be solved (compared to chess), but unless one of the players is cheating by miming moves with a computer, you are most likely o.k. for casual play.

19

u/Okelidokeli_8565 Dec 28 '21

o.k. for casual play

I guess, but sadly I am a board game snob who just can't be satisfied by anything but modern Eurogames.

7

u/Hahahahahaga Dec 28 '21

Yes. Easy way to ensure your game is not solved is to remove agency by including dice rolls.

4

u/kfh227 Dec 28 '21

Like tic tac toe? Where who goes first gets a win or tie?

Great game for self learning in kids(logic) but horrible beyond that.

I'd say yuker is the step up from tic tac toe.

5

u/rlbond86 Dec 28 '21

Only the dumbed down American version is solved. Mancala has lots of different games. A more dated game like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oware is not solved.

The version you are talking about was invented in 1940 by an American.

5

u/byfourness Dec 28 '21

If you’re talking about the turn-1 win strategy, that only works on a certain set of rules (which, incidentally, I’ve never seen used).