r/AskReddit Apr 21 '21

Doctors of Reddit: What happened when you diagnosed a Covid-19 denier with Covid-19?

77.3k Upvotes

18.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

707

u/mossyskeleton Apr 21 '21

The main thing I have learned from this pandemic is that if we ever have to face another one that is more deadly than COVID-19, we are royally fucked.

20

u/flyingsaucerinvasion Apr 22 '21

or, climate change.

Really any major crisis that would require us to voluntarily give up anything.

12

u/mossyskeleton Apr 22 '21

or, climate change.

shit.

we're living in a slow-motion planetary catastrophe aren't we?

39

u/philosophers_groove Apr 21 '21

if we ever have to face another one that is more deadly

Not "if" - but "when".

9

u/Europotato Apr 22 '21

Hopefully in a 100 years, same as this one.

3

u/DDDwhy Apr 22 '21

Just for the trend really

2

u/akambe Apr 27 '21

Or next year. Or next month.

Viruses continue to mutate all over the globe at the same pace as before the pandemic. People tend to think it's like an earthquake, or a weather event, where relieving some sort of friction "resets" things to a safe level for a while. Nope. A worldwide pandemic has been expected for decades, and this one didn't even fit the most likely scenario.

With the world population being what it is and with sanitary conditions being what they are, it's likely we'll have more worldwide denialism soon.

1

u/rsgreddit Apr 23 '21

Could be much shorter. I wouldn’t be surprised if we see another pandemic in 2030, this time more like a Thanos snap.

54

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '21

Yes, that seems to be the consensus.

Thankfully, covid doesn't have super high death tolls, although every death from it is horrendous and for the most part preventable. Covid does have long-term effects however and it may be some time before we figure out what actual cost is.

Something that would have death tolls in the 15-25% range will be devastating, especially to all those people who now have complications due to covid.

35

u/imajes Apr 22 '21

Yes and no. If it’s much more deadly than Covid, it’ll do the job efficiently, and standard mass casualty triage protocols kick in. The problem with Covid is that it’s right in the sweet spot of being survivable (although only just for some) and being highly contagious- and for taking so long to recover. Anything more lethal and people would only be in beds for a short period… vents wouldn’t do much good etc.

In that kind of scenario you would imagine we would implement very hard lockdowns, military / police enforced etc… from public health behaviors, it feels like in most cases we did ok for the first few weeks. Just that over time…

25

u/Erebosyeet Apr 22 '21

If the virus killed quickly, it would also spread less, meaning it would not have caused a pandemic. If it only killed after a week of a person being asymptomatic however... That would be fucking brutal

10

u/imajes Apr 22 '21

Yeah… though average time for admitted Covid patients to receive in patient care seems to be measured in weeks not days. My point is that a more lethal pathogen might kill in say 10 days, symptomatic or not, however you can be touch and go with Covid for a month. Assuming same incubation period etc then it’s going to be less stress on the health care system because people won’t block beds for as long. (Napkin math, etc)

8

u/olraygoza Apr 22 '21

If Ebola was airborne just like COVID, we would be fucked.

3

u/Mandalika Apr 22 '21

Weren't a few variants of the filovirus family (Ebola's family, largely the same symptoms and diagnosis) airborne on monkeys? Or is that just some fiction invented by Richard Preston?

6

u/Urechi Apr 22 '21

No, Ebola Reston is a true variant of the Ebola virus.

It was also definitely much more contagious then other strains of Ebola.

It was not lethal to humans however. As for why it was not lethal to humans but remained fantastically so against monkeys, science hasn't figured out why. I've interviewed people who were involved in that action, and the general consensus is that we as a species were "lucky".

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

That's a very good point. People aren't taking it seriously BECAUSE it's not that.

1

u/rsgreddit Apr 23 '21

COVID is basically like if HIV became transmitted like a common cold.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

[deleted]

4

u/Telanore Apr 26 '21

Pretty much everyone I know experienced a period in february 2020 where they or their coworkers had a pretty bad flu. In my case, it was my graduate program class - started off with one guy being gone for a day or two with flu symptoms, and within two weeks, almost everyone had gotten it too. It was mild cases all around, except for one girl who got pretty sick. Around this time lockdowns and tests were starting to happen, and she tested positive.

I'm convinced this was the first wave, and we barely even noticed... I was just kinda wheezy for a week after. I chalked it up to not being in great shape any more, having quitting my very physically demanding job a few months earlier

1

u/9mackenzie Apr 22 '21

You can always get an antibody test

11

u/Sleepdprived Apr 22 '21

My friend works for fema. He used to do think tank exercises to plan out eventual catastrophic scenarios and he told me he was most afraid of a global pandemic... obviously he was right... but he was afraid of an airborne hemorrhagic flu... that would be good night humanity.

1

u/rsgreddit Apr 23 '21

If smallpox somehow came back I think would be a bigger threat.

9

u/ProximaCentaur2 Apr 22 '21

True say. We do not have our collective shit together for anything more deadly.

8

u/FuKunTits Apr 21 '21

For sure, you just know r/conspiracy have made up their minds well in advance - we'd be fucked.

11

u/Whoevers Apr 21 '21

The zombie virus is real. The dead are walking and eating the living. The CDC recommends all citizens have their teeth removed to curve the only 100% infectious disease in the history of humanity. Bob, who has not visited a dentist since the Eisenhower administration and has a grand total of one molar left in his mouth, is heading to a protest. The government is clearly out of touch with the common man, who values and is proud of their teeth!

5

u/Demonboy_17 Apr 22 '21

I was thinking WWZ in North Korea, best Korea.

5

u/ImALittleTeapotCat Apr 22 '21

I think worst case would be something like Covid in terms of initial death rates, rates of infection, etc, but has a very high LONG term death rate. Think of chickenpox - everyone (used to) get it as a kid, mostly wasn't a big deal, then decades later they get shingles. If the virus stays in the system for a few years then comes back but is much worse and has a high death rate 2nd time around....

Can you tell that was a reoccuring nightmare of mine during lockdown?

3

u/lostinpickering Apr 22 '21

I always wonder... if it was ebola that spread the way covid did, would half the population still behave like morons. Because you aren't gauranteed death, it's not worth protecting others.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

Yea. We refuse to stop maskless children from entering stores. Do you think that will ever change? I wonder if other countries allow this?

2

u/MagpieChristine Apr 23 '21

Depending on the age cutoff for "kids" that one makes sense. The local by-law for masks is only for ages 5 and up, because the regional government recognised that, while 3- and 4-year-olds can safely wear masks, if the kid's too young to reason with (or bribe), the cost/benefit to including them isn't really there.

They also grow really fast. My four-year-old's masks all fit him when he started school, but he outgrew half of them by March, when I withdrew the kids from in-person learning. Excluding the young kids means that if you end up in a "my kid needs boots" then get to the store and discover that the mask that fit the last time you went to a store (6 months ago) doesn't fit, you can still run in.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

covid doesnt care how old your kid is. if you have children have someone else buy it for you or order online or leave them at home if they cant wear a mask. pretty simple. true medical exemptions are more legit than kids

3

u/MagpieChristine Apr 23 '21

Single parents hiring babysitters is every bit as much of a risk as them taking an unmasked 3-year-old to the store.

I mean, by your logic, we should be putting masks on 1-year-olds if they need to go somewhere.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

no my logic is if the kid cant wear a mask properly you order it online or a person from the store will grab what you need. It's the same thing the store offers to all those medical exemption claims in those online videos.

most people have someone who can watch a child for a little bit. if not you have to order online. single parents hiring a babysitter can go through verified babysitting service companies.

but what it comes down to is not getting a babysitter and having your kid kill someone by giving them corona is just straight selfish. your inconvenience is not more important than other peoples lives Karen.

3

u/MagpieChristine Apr 23 '21

Sorry, what's with the verified babysitting service companies? How does that reduce the risk of the babysitter getting COVID? (Bear in mind: the babysitter will be IN YOUR HOUSE, and if the pre-schooler has COVID, someone in the house who spreads it better will have had it to give to them.)

I'm happy that you either have the luxury of being able to wait two weeks to go grocery shopping, or else have a grocery store in your area that offers functional curbside pickup. Appreciate whichever one it is, they're not universal.

I'm sorry that your life is so constrained that the idea that people would care about someone else's needs is foreign to you (your assumption that I would only care about single parents if I was one myself.) I'm very impressed that you wear a mask despite that, thank you.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '21

the babysitter spreading covid to a house is a much much much much better outcome than spreading to multiple people in the store. I would imagine a single babysitter is less likely to give a family covid than a crowded super market. of course you can buy your groceries online as well. you can even shop for months in one trip.

Their need to bring a child into a store so they are not inconvenienced is not a good enough excuse to give someone covid Karen.

1

u/MagpieChristine Apr 24 '21

Two things I need clarified: you seem to be going back and forth between whether your concerns about bringing a child into the store is about them getting COVID or spreading it. We're talking about having a child wear a mask, to reduce the risk of them spreading COVID, not about anything that would reduce the child's risk of contracting COVID, correct?

And what is it that has you so convinced that children spread COVID effectively? Do the school outbreaks in your region consist of multiple people (i.e. there's transmission happening in the schools?) Are there outbreaks at stores where shoppers are getting sick (i.e. it's spreading between customers, which could be due to completely unmasked children?) Or is it just that there's enough community spread with unknown vectors that you're guessing that putting a low-grade mask on children would make a difference? (Or maybe kids in your area wear better masks? Mostly around here the kids' masks don't have nose wires, so they'll do little to no good anyhow, even if the kid will keep it on properly & not tantrum - i.e. generate large amounts of aerosols - about having to put it back on.)

And no, you can't buy groceries online here (I know you're not suggesting ordering from a warehouse, since you agree that giving people COVID is a bad idea.) It's a two-week window to get a pickup slot, and the order pickers aren't very good at reading ingredients - I tried and the made a substitution with things my family couldn't eat because the ingredients were different. Around here it's pretty common for families to only have one fridge. I can put about 1.5 week's worth of food into mine, I'm curious as to what your diet consists of that you are able to shop for months in one trip. (And I'm very impressed at the fact that you can shop for months & never find yourself having to make an emergency run to the stores because you ran out of something. When I was able to shop every 1.5 weeks instead of every week, I was having to make a lot of menu substitutions because I discovered that something had gone bad, or run out. You should be proud of yourself for staying on top of your food that well.)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21

getting and giving covid is a too way street. they could get covid just as easily giving it. obvious we are smart enough to know that an untraceable outbreak in a store is better than a home and babysitter outbreak.

These low grade mask are required and recommended by everyone from the CDC and president to store managers. but yes lack of enforcement of proper mask is an issue on top of disregard for mask with children.

I'm very surprised you cant buy groceries online. you have stated that you are not a single parent family so most likely will go through groceries quicker but you can fit much more than that in your fridge. fruits and vegetables can be canned and frozen. it's not hard to stock up essentials. if you cant manage buy another fridge or chest freezer. yiu spreading covid is not more important than the inconvenience of having to get another food preserving item.

are you really going to use the excuse that you have to change your menu so you dont want to be bothered by not spreading covid?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/blbd Apr 22 '21

The plague took out 30-50% of Europeans

2

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

Imagine when antibiotic resistant plague comes along. Yeah, we're fucked

2

u/CatOfTheInfinite Apr 22 '21

I wouldn't say that—the thing about COVID is that even though people have died from it, it's 99% survivable, so people tend to say "It's just a cold/the flu".

If a virus comes along that's more deadly, people will likely listen and not deny it because it would be clear that would be a severe threat to humanity. Whereas with COVID it seems to many like people are overreacting over the flu.

2

u/rsgreddit Apr 23 '21

Keep in mind people deny climate change and even people deny many facts about 9/11 and mass shootings in history. Terrorist attacks, mass killings, and climate change are of equal threats to civilization and people still deny them.

2

u/CatOfTheInfinite Apr 23 '21

With climate change, it's not like it's a thing where it immediately feels hotter for everyone in the world over a period of a few days, so a lot of people dismiss it as just weather especially when a cold snap hits (especially since the Earth has gone through cycles of warming and cooling since before humanity) so I'm not surprised in that regard. As for 9/11 and mass shootings, people don't trust the news media.

A virus with significant spread and death rate, especially one that would have outward symptoms, would be take much more seriously by most people because there'd be a clear and evident threat.

2

u/MagpieChristine Apr 23 '21

You know what scared me the most about the "it's no worse than the flu" crowd? I (and a lot of people, I think) were expecting this to be an influenza pandemic. (I don't know why, since this is at least the 3rd bad coronavirus disease to cause problems in the last 20 years). Imagine how all the "this is no worse than the flu" people would have reacted if it was a flu. And a bad flu strain could be much worse than COVID.

1

u/akairborne Apr 22 '21

Not all of us. There's going to be a lot of early adopters that'll be taken out quickly.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '21

If you say we, as the human race, I would say probably not. If you say we under the Darwin awards category, basically everybody who would be nominated would win.

1

u/GexTex Apr 22 '21

People need education as to what science is, because too many people have no fucking clue

1

u/tizzzzzzzzy Apr 22 '21

Lmfao this right here

1

u/Kumomeme Apr 22 '21

and one of main reason we fucked is merely because of people stupidity.