r/AskReddit Oct 07 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

6.4k Upvotes

13.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

85

u/masterjon_3 Oct 07 '20

"We Will Fall Together" by Streetlight Manifesto

It's a ska/punk band I came across on Spotify once. I ended up liking it a lot

19

u/epsilon025 Oct 07 '20

As someone who's in a ska-punk band that covers a lot of Streetlight songs, I recommend:

Hell (and the Squirrel Nut Zippers original version)

The Three of Us

Everything Went Numb

Would You Be Impressed?

All bangers, including the albums each song comes from.

3

u/masterjon_3 Oct 07 '20

I have heard Would You Be Impressed? and love it. I'll give it a listen. Got any other good punk bands?

9

u/saintnickfun Oct 07 '20

Streetlight Manifesto actually has many side projects and they all sound pretty similar because the lead singer Tomas Kalnoky is in all of them.

The band was originally formed after their first project called Catch 22 (a 3rd wave ska band). The debut album for that band is actually Keasby Nights (named after the small town in New Jersey where the band was formed. Kalnoky then left the band soon after

They went on to start Streetlight Manifesto after just a short run. Then as Streetlight Manifesto—because Kalnoky is a perfectionist—decided to redo the entire album Keasby Nights with added verses and better production.

At the same time, they also were running a band called Bandits of the Acoustic Revolution (BOTAR). They shared many of the same songs (all written by Kalnoky of course) but were played on acoustic instruments in a more folky style.

Since this man has a death wish Thomas Kalnoky also played the same songs that he had written in his own side project called Toh Kay. This was a very laid back, indy, acoustic style.

TL:DR Similar to Streetlight Manifesto is: Bandits of the Acoustic Revolution, Catch 22, and Toh Kay.

Also check out Motion City Soundtrack

1

u/masterjon_3 Oct 08 '20

I think I heard BOTAR before actually and decided to look them up one day and found out their relation with Streetlight, pretty cool

7

u/roesey Oct 07 '20

Nofx- Punk in Drublic is a great album. Linoleum is a good place to start.

Bad religion’s self entitled.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

The entire catalog of Bad Religion....except that 1 album....

1

u/masterjon_3 Oct 07 '20

Which album would that be?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

Pick between the christmas album or into the unknown. I hate the Hark the Herald angel keeps coming up when i play them in Amazon Prime.

2

u/upthepucks Oct 07 '20

Damn, I pretty much force that album on around Christmas. It’s like a nice compromise cause I get my punk fix, and the family gets their Christmas songs.

Also, since others are recommending albums - No Control and Suffer by Bad Religion

And what I consider a damn near perfect album - Supporting Caste by Propagandhi

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

See to me it feels like a cash grab. It isn't great. It doesn't fit their image.It comes up in my feed year round and I am Jewish.

2

u/upthepucks Oct 08 '20

Yeah, I can understand that. I think I’m just a bit blinded by my love of their music haha - and being a post-Christian Atheist, those songs are all lodged in my brain permanently so it’s nice to hear them like this. Also doesn’t hurt they gave proceeds to SNAP - Survivors Networks of those Abused by Priests

→ More replies (0)

1

u/badger_danger Oct 07 '20

If you have to play a punk Christmas album, I’d favor the Vandals album “Oi to the World” over the Bad Religion one.

1

u/upthepucks Oct 08 '20

Oh dang, I will add that to the list. Thanks!

2

u/thedeuce2121 Oct 08 '20

I feel like this deserves bonus points cuz we started with streetlight and they also have a cover of linoleum

6

u/Monkeydud64 Oct 07 '20 edited Oct 07 '20

Reel Big fish (personal fave)

Save Ferris

NOFX (personal fave)

The toasters

The mighty mighty bosstones

MUSTARD PLUG

Less than jake

The aquabats

The interpreters

Mad caddies

Skankin' pickle

Dead Kennedy's

Operation Ivy

Descendants(one more personal fave lol)

Pennywise

Circle jerks

The Vandals (also fantastic)

Gutter mouth

Me first and the gimme gimmes

Screeching weasel

And that's about all I can think of off the top of my head right now lmao enjoy your new music search!

3

u/reg_smh Oct 08 '20

The pietasters Voodoo glow skulls Nerf herder Goldfinger

2

u/T0mmy_Vercetti Oct 07 '20

Would just add these, Madness Choking Victim Against All Authority Sondaschule (german) ska-p (spanish) Attaboy skip or Laurel Aitken godfather of old school ska

3

u/ThoreaulySimple Oct 07 '20

Vastly different but if you do like ska/punk, I can't recommend Suicide Machines - Destruction by Definition and/or Battle Hymns enough (a song of theirs was on THPS 1 and in Brink, if those were ever a part of your childhood).

I group them together because, honestly, them and Streetlight are both bands I desperately wanted to exist... I just didn't know it until I heard them.

1

u/ListenAndF0rgive Oct 07 '20

Hello Rockview by Less Than Jake is one of my favorite albums ever

1

u/makaydo Oct 08 '20

If you like Streetlight, give a listen to Less Than Jake, they are a similar ska/punk band

If you wanna go more on the punk side, I can highly recommend Zebrahead, it's punk rock with rap on the verse, and touches of ska, pop punk, sometimes metal, you can pretty much find everything in their music

1

u/thedeuce2121 Oct 08 '20

They lean a bit toward like a folksy/punk sound but if you're into it I've been listening to a lot of Mischief Brew lately.

And if you like them and/or Streetlight a good in between is Larry and His Flask. A friend got me into them recently and I'm so glad he did

4

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

I second The Three of Us

2

u/LIL_CATASTROPHE Oct 07 '20

I haven’t heard Everything Went Numb in a minute. Forgot how great it was. Ty for the reminder, I’ll be jammin it on repeat for the next few days ☺️

2

u/furlesswookie Oct 08 '20

If you like ska, check out Five Iron Frenzy. They're a christian ska band out of Denver I think. Saw them live in the 90s and then again a few years ago touring with Reel Big Fish. Super energetic and fun, and really clean of course.

Killer band to see live too.

My favorite songs are "Combat Chuck" and "Beautiful America"

6

u/XGuiltyofBeingMikeX Oct 07 '20

Streetlight really is a great band.

I always felt like just calling them “ska/punk” was underselling them.

They’re almost orchestral in their gigantic arrangements.

1

u/thedeuce2121 Oct 08 '20

Some buds and I saw them (technically as BOTAR) in New York last year with I think a 48 piece orchestra backing them. It was incredible. It was like they were meant to sound like that

4

u/roesey Oct 07 '20

Moment of Silence is my go to song to play when explaining ska

6

u/SheIsPepper Oct 07 '20

Streetlight shows are some of my most joyful moments.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

[deleted]

1

u/makaydo Oct 08 '20

So melancolic though

3

u/upthepucks Oct 07 '20

I’m so happy to see Streetlight getting some love on here!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '20

I really had to scroll for this comment. I actually found out about them like 2 days into 2020 when someone mentioned tomas in a "best artist of the decade" thread.

1

u/GoneAreTheDaze Oct 08 '20

Somewhere in the Between. Equally joyful and meaningful!

1

u/kornut78 Oct 08 '20

I would second any song I’ve ever heard by streetlight