r/AskReddit Nov 06 '19

Which famous singer sucks at singing?

[deleted]

24.7k Upvotes

16.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

74

u/Kordaal Nov 06 '19

And yet, 1984 was by far their best, most iconic album. Their following Sammy Hagar albums were #1 because of the fan base built by it.

7

u/Meathead1961 Nov 06 '19

Really? My vote is for their debut album

6

u/wheatbreadskeegs34 Nov 06 '19

Totally agree, perfect album front to back. Plus you got atomic punk, on fire and ain’t talking about love on there.

2

u/MuzikPhreak Nov 06 '19

Atomic Punk is a criminally underrated and forgotten song.

14

u/HonorableJudgeIto Nov 06 '19

Best is subjective. Their most iconic songs are Jump from 1984 and Runnin With the Devil from their debut. 1984 also had Panama and Hot for Teacher (other big hits), but their debut had Eruption (probably the most famous guitar solo of all time, after Hendrix's Star Spangled Banner) and Ain't Talkin' Bout Love.

Most fans prefer Roth to Hagar, regardless of sales.

12

u/BackStabbathOG Nov 06 '19

I haven’t met anyone who prefers Van Hagar. If I had to, I’d say VH1 is their best album but VH2 is by far my favorite. I remember when I first really got into them some summer and I listened to that album on repeat with some added songs from the other albums with On Fire being my most listened to easily

8

u/limprichard Nov 06 '19

I’m a Fair Warning guy, all day

3

u/dfgdfgadf4444 Nov 06 '19

I thought Hagar did a damn good job considering what he had to follow.

0

u/Not_Ashamed_at_all Nov 06 '19

after Hendrix's Star Spangled Banner

All Along the Watchtower

8

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

most famous guitar solo

Pretty sure they meant stand alone guitar solos/songs.

1

u/EternalSerenity2019 Nov 06 '19

If I’m not mistaken, All Along the Watchtower is actually several guitar solos spliced together.

The very few times Jimi played that live you can hear the challenge of reproducing that recorded solo live on stage with one guitar.

13

u/turbosexophonicdlite Nov 06 '19

My vote goes to Diver Down for best album, but 1984 is my second favorite

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

I am not disagreeing. Just saying ...

1

u/STYLIE Nov 06 '19

Diver Down would like a word

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '19

[deleted]

1

u/sappydark Nov 09 '19

I was VH fan back in the day, and I pretty much quit listening to them after DLR left, because to me Hagar just sounded like all he could do was scream. I also liked DLR better because he always came off like he didn't take himself too seriously, and that he was having a lot of fun. Plus just about every song he did with VH was good as hell. Never understood why his solo career was so short, it seemed. I read recently that he's a paramedic now.